Paul Krugman effectively takes Hillary Clinton's side against Bernie Sanders over health care in Health Reform Realities New York Times 01/18/2016. He advises against a new Democratic President pushing for single-payer health care, though he frames it as a priority issue rather than echoing the misleading claims of the Clinton campaign. Still, Krugman notes, "If we could start from scratch, many, perhaps most, health economists would recommend single-payer, a Medicare-type program covering everyone."
Krugman's argument here strikes me as playing into one of the most serious weaknesses of the Democratic Party in framing issues. If the Republicans get only part of what they want on an issue, they keep going back to the well to get more. They've been trying to ban abortion since 1978 or so. And they've come a long way toward that goal. They have succeeded in seriously restricting access to abortion. And the number of "coathanger" style abortions are rising again. But the Republicans aren't saying, "Hey, we've already got some of these sinful wimmin going for coathanger abortions. So let's move on to making someone else's life miserable." No, they want to continue on this issue (while simultaneously making others miserable) until *only* back-alley abortions are available.
The Democrats, on the other hand, tend to do what Krugman seems to be advising on health care and say, "Well, we got something accomplished, so let's just move on to the next thing." The Dems need to learn the virtues of defending their own accomplishments while demanding improvements. They are often strangely weak on both counts.
They also need to take into full account the Republicans' incremental approach to undoing programs they don't like. The Affordable Care Act (ACA, Obamacare) is particularly vulnerable to this approach. As Krugman accurately observes, "Obamacare is, however, what engineers would call a kludge: a somewhat awkward, clumsy device with lots of moving parts," problems which he expects "will probably always cause a significant number of people to fall through the cracks."
The Republicans are pursuing a very visible strategy of trying to sabotage the ACA by knocking off one part after another. The rightwing Supreme Court put the Medicaid expansion, which was one of those "awkward, clumsy" features Krugman references, partly at the mercy of ideological Republican Govenors completely opposed to the ACA. The Congressional Republicans are now pushing a scheme to remove a critical aspect of the law, the mandatory coverage provision. Removing that would make the private plans more expensive and thus serve to discredit the ACA further.
The best way for the Democrats to hold the line against these tactics, even if that's all they really want to do, would be to push for improvements. And if they want improvements, it would be better to push for what they really want, or even more than they really want. Adding a public option is the obvious next step, as Krugman indicates. But if the Dems want that, they are more likely to get it by pushing for single payer and accepting a public option as a fallback position.
Krugman repeatedly and rightly criticized Obama for his pre-compromise approach to the financial bailout in 2009. That is, he proposed about half of what was really needed, and then compromised it down from there. Supposedly, he started out from a position he thought a significant number of Republicans in Congress would accepted. Hence, pre-compromised. But even in 2009, those bipartisan-minded Republicans mainly existed in Obama's imagination. Now, we're in the Age of Trump, when Sarah Palin will soon count as a sober political analyst at the rate we're going.
It's time for the Democrats to jam their message home to the voters. Note to sit back and play defense while the Republicans keep pecking away at their accomplishments when they are not in the position to rapidly roll back the wheel of progress.
On his blog, though, Krugman takes a more bluntly pro-Clinton position in Weakened at Bernie’s 01/19/2016. He argues that Sanders' health-care plan promises too much and that his financial-reform plan doesn't adequately address the problem of shadow banking.
Still, there's an undertone of advising the Democrats to be more timid than Sanders wants to be.
Showing posts with label aca. Show all posts
Showing posts with label aca. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 19, 2016
Wednesday, November 20, 2013
Reality- based commentaries on the ACA/Obamacare
I've seen a couple of non-hysterical pieces today about the state of Obamacare, one from Gene Lyons (Fix The Website, And The Political Problem Solves Itself National Memo 11/20/2013), the other from Paul Krugman at his blog (11/20/2013).
Both of them are agreed on a basic point: get the Obamacare website functioning reasonably well, and lots of people will be able to sign up for a better health insurance policy than they had before, often at lower cost. Gene Lyons, referring to comparison's to Katrina or other epic disasters on the Presidential watch of Georege W. Bush:
Democrats have legitimate reason to criticize Obama for a clumsy rollout of the ACA. Krugman puts it this way:
Obamacare Repeal Motive Behind 'Keep Your Plan' Bill 11/15/2013:
Obamacare Unraveling? 11/15/2013:
An actual conservative who doesn't sound insane in his public statements is Norm Ornstein of AEI (aka, Neocon Central) in Republicans Have No Interest in Fixing — or Even Understanding — Obamacare The Atlantic Online 11/14/2013 accurately emphasizes the essentially conservative nature of the ACA:
On that point, I disagree with Orstein's comment about "the president’s false comments about Americans remaining free to keep their coverage." As I said in an earlier post, Obama's basic statement on the topic was fair. Even junk insurance plans that were in effect at the time the ACA was passed in 2010 were grandfathered in. But Obama never promised your insurance company would never raise rates. On the contrary, it was a selling point for the ACA that it was based on private insurance. He didn't claim the federal government would dictate rates. The exchanges were designed to make the health insurance market function more efficiently and in a way that benefited more people. And, if Obama doesn't keep conceding to the Republicans on key parts of the plan, the ACA looks capable of going far toward achieving that goal.
Antoher conservative, David Weigel, also thinks the story about political disaster for Democrats over Obamacare is way overblown (Democratic Panic: Still All About Healthcare.gov Slate 11/18/2013):
Both of them are agreed on a basic point: get the Obamacare website functioning reasonably well, and lots of people will be able to sign up for a better health insurance policy than they had before, often at lower cost. Gene Lyons, referring to comparison's to Katrina or other epic disasters on the Presidential watch of Georege W. Bush:
Possibly feeling sorry for the ex-rancher-turned-dog-portrait-painter [Bush], Fox News even went so far as to dub this president's [Obama's] mealy-mouthed apology "Obama’s Watergate." Meanwhile, a bunch of ostensibly liberal Washington courtiers/pundits proved their independence by joining the excited throng declaring Obama's presidency finished.He uses CLNN to stand for CNN, which he has re-dubbed "the Chicken Little News Network."
Except wait a minute. Didn’t many of the same savants declare the GOP defunct after the government shutdown a few weeks back? Well, that was melodramatic nonsense too. While much of their intended audience dozes, headline-hungry, ratings-driven, click-soliciting news organizations act increasingly like a litter of kittens in a room full of balloons — excitedly chasing the next big political scandal or a glimpse of Miley Cyrus’s nipple.
Whichever comes first.
That's life at CLNN, "Where the Sky Is Always Falling."
Comparing a health insurance fib to a botched natural disaster or a catastrophic war is morally grotesque to begin with. Goodness, nobody died. If this the worst falsehood President Obama emits, he’ll go down as one of the least mendacious pols in living memory. [my emphasis]
Democrats have legitimate reason to criticize Obama for a clumsy rollout of the ACA. Krugman puts it this way:
What's going on isn’t a policy question: we know from the states with working exchanges (including California) that the underlying structure of the law is workable. Instead, it’s about an implementation botch, which is an incredible mess, and reflects very badly on Obama. But the future of the reform depends not on policy per se but on whether the IT issues can be fixed well enough soon enough, a subject on which I have zero expertise.I've written here before about what I thought was an excessively apologetic and defensive response on the White House's part to criticism of the website problems. These two videos from The Young Turks spell out the risks he unnecessarily took on by responding that way, especially by agreed to postpone the implementation of the minimum standards for new health care insurance.
Of course, that hasn’t stopped other people from breathlessly commenting on every twist and turn in the polls, every meaningless vote in the House, and so on. Hey, it's a living.
But at this point there’s enough information coming in to make semi-educated guesses — and it looks to me as if this thing is probably going to stumble through to the finish line. State-run enrollments are mostly going pretty well; Medicaid expansion is going very well (and it’s expanding even in states that have rejected the expansion, because more people are learning they're eligible.) And healthcare.gov, while still pretty bad, is starting to look as if it will be good enough in a few weeks for large numbers of people to sign up, either through the exchanges or directly with insurers.
Obamacare Repeal Motive Behind 'Keep Your Plan' Bill 11/15/2013:
Obamacare Unraveling? 11/15/2013:
An actual conservative who doesn't sound insane in his public statements is Norm Ornstein of AEI (aka, Neocon Central) in Republicans Have No Interest in Fixing — or Even Understanding — Obamacare The Atlantic Online 11/14/2013 accurately emphasizes the essentially conservative nature of the ACA:
There is no excuse, period, for the president’s false comments about Americans remaining free to keep their coverage. And there is plenty wrong with Obamacare, partly because it was jerry-built to get around the early and implacable opposition of all Republicans in both houses to passing any health care bill, or to offer a single vote for the plan in return for adding constructive amendments. But the structure, built around expanding the risk pools, creating a fair marketplace of private insurers to enable competition to work, and premium support for those who can't afford coverage, is precisely the one Republicans advocated in the 1990s and right up until 2009. In the supreme irony, it is the same structure Rep. Paul Ryan offers in his proposal for Medicare — call it Obamacare for seniors.Obama's reaction seems politically counterproductive in the situation. He should have responded by more aggressively sticking up for the program, explaining it, and going on the offensive against Republicans and against insurance companies trying to rip off customers with junk policies.
If you think about it, it would be in the interest of conservatives who believe in the magic of markets to make this system work. If it can be demonstrated that real competition in a real marketplace offers good services at lower overall costs, that adds powerful ammunition to the case for free markets. Let’s face it: The unrelenting opposition to all parts of the law, as reflected not just in critiques like Krauthammer’s but also in the more vapid and confused attacks by Sarah Palin and others, is far more about Barack Obama than it is about the structure and nature of the Affordable Care Act. [my emphasis]
On that point, I disagree with Orstein's comment about "the president’s false comments about Americans remaining free to keep their coverage." As I said in an earlier post, Obama's basic statement on the topic was fair. Even junk insurance plans that were in effect at the time the ACA was passed in 2010 were grandfathered in. But Obama never promised your insurance company would never raise rates. On the contrary, it was a selling point for the ACA that it was based on private insurance. He didn't claim the federal government would dictate rates. The exchanges were designed to make the health insurance market function more efficiently and in a way that benefited more people. And, if Obama doesn't keep conceding to the Republicans on key parts of the plan, the ACA looks capable of going far toward achieving that goal.
Antoher conservative, David Weigel, also thinks the story about political disaster for Democrats over Obamacare is way overblown (Democratic Panic: Still All About Healthcare.gov Slate 11/18/2013):
You can find anonymous Democrats to panic about anything, and you can find plenty of Democrats willing to trash implementation so far, on the record. But recently, when I was talking to one of the Democrats assigned to win House seats in 2014, I got the impression that the panic is tied largely to the crisis of healthcare.gov. If the website sucked wind through Thanksgiving, said the Democrat, it was dreadful but, for Democrats, survivable. If it failed into 2014? That would blow open doors for Republican-led delay bills, and the party's vulnerable members would start to endorse those bills, because what choice would they have?Tags: aca, obamacare
Day to day, it's very easy to write a "collapse of liberalism" story. Talk to Democrats, though, and you learn that to a staggering degree they think a fixed website would end the general crisis. One month of increased signups—that's all they want. Ask them how they feel in mid-December.
Monday, November 18, 2013
Obama and the Obamacare rollout
I found myself liking this column by Bob Kuttner and being annoyed by it at the same time: Obama's Gift to the Republicans Huffington Post 11/17/2013. I'm not quite sure what annoyed me. Part of it may have been the pop psychology. And there seems to be a sour-grapes edge to his criticism, suggesting that the whole problem goes back to trying to do anything more complex than what he calls "Medicare for All," a single-payer system.
But this observation is accurate as far as it goes: "The Affordable Care Act, as a government mandate for people to purchase private insurance with an array of possible subsidies, had too many moving parts. It was an accident waiting to happen."
However, there were particular features about this law that made it more politically accident-prone than a system structured this way had to be. Just including a public option would have made a dramatic difference, although it would have ramped up Republican fury even higher, if that's possible. The ACA delayed the main implementation until 2014, which would have given a Republican President elected in 2012 plenty of time to abolish it before the most popular features took effect.
And Kuttner's right about the complexity. It involves a sliding-scale subsidy option, online insurance exchanges, a range of new choices, new rules on health insurance, and it does rely on private insurance companies without the competition of a public option. The insurance companies get a definite benefit from the required coverage. But they don't have a profit incentive to make the Obama Administration or the federal government look good in the process of implementing them. The extension Obama is giving them on meeting minimum standards is potentially a sweet deal financially: the companies can still sell overpriced policies (at least renewals) that are junk insurance, or close to junk status, constructed in a way that they are unlikely to ever have to pay for any significant amount of medical care, e.g., policies that don't cover hospitalization costs.
And I agree with Kuttner that, "The president has lost control of both the narrative and the politics."
But he also seems to some extent to be buying into the position that the ACA is just an unworkable thing: "The Republicans, who were unable to destroy Obamacare by holding the budget hostage, are now enjoying watching it fall of its own weight."
I'm not sure what the falling-of-its-own-weight metaphor means there. The website is having some problems. And I tend to think Kuttner is probably right in saying:
A public option would have made a huge difference. But Democratic critics who feel they need to distance themselves from "Obamacare" should be proposing that as a fix, not undermining the ACA system even more. Mark Shields in Friday night's Political Wrap on the PBS Newshour had reverted back to his now-customary half-asleep state after several weeks of being energized and focused. But even though he carelessly overstates it, he also has a point when he says (Shields and Brooks on waning ACA confidence and its impact on liberal government 11/15/2013):
Shields at least sees the urgency in defending the ACA. But he went along with the crowd in piling in on Obama over the keep-your-own-health-insurance thing - understandably, I guess, since Obama himself isn't defending himself on it:
But the basic statement was fair. Even junk insurance plans that were in effect at the time the ACA was passed in 2010 were grandfathered in. But Obama never promised your insurance company would never raise rates. On the contrary, it was a selling point for the ACA that it was based on private insurance. Rates were going to be subject to private competition, facilitated by the new exchanges. The point of the particular approach in the ACA was to create a functioning competitive market in insurance that would make it accessible to everyone. Obama tried at one point to defend himself from the criticism by responding along those lines. But then his seeming compulsion to accept Republicans framing kicked in to the point of effectively accepting the harshest Republican criticism on the keeping-your-insurance issue. So now he has commentators like Shields, who is obviously inclined to defend him on the ACA, not only saying it was false but joining Republicans in trashing Obama's "record of integrity" over the issue.
Digby has a helpful discussion of the problems of the Obamacare website in The Contractor State Hullabaloo 11/14/2013. She links to this piece by David Auerbach, Quixotic Queries Question Quality! Slate 10/12/2013, which shows something about the complexity of the project management involved. It's not an excuse. But it provides real-world context.
Tags: aca, obamacare
But this observation is accurate as far as it goes: "The Affordable Care Act, as a government mandate for people to purchase private insurance with an array of possible subsidies, had too many moving parts. It was an accident waiting to happen."
However, there were particular features about this law that made it more politically accident-prone than a system structured this way had to be. Just including a public option would have made a dramatic difference, although it would have ramped up Republican fury even higher, if that's possible. The ACA delayed the main implementation until 2014, which would have given a Republican President elected in 2012 plenty of time to abolish it before the most popular features took effect.
And Kuttner's right about the complexity. It involves a sliding-scale subsidy option, online insurance exchanges, a range of new choices, new rules on health insurance, and it does rely on private insurance companies without the competition of a public option. The insurance companies get a definite benefit from the required coverage. But they don't have a profit incentive to make the Obama Administration or the federal government look good in the process of implementing them. The extension Obama is giving them on meeting minimum standards is potentially a sweet deal financially: the companies can still sell overpriced policies (at least renewals) that are junk insurance, or close to junk status, constructed in a way that they are unlikely to ever have to pay for any significant amount of medical care, e.g., policies that don't cover hospitalization costs.
And I agree with Kuttner that, "The president has lost control of both the narrative and the politics."
But he also seems to some extent to be buying into the position that the ACA is just an unworkable thing: "The Republicans, who were unable to destroy Obamacare by holding the budget hostage, are now enjoying watching it fall of its own weight."
I'm not sure what the falling-of-its-own-weight metaphor means there. The website is having some problems. And I tend to think Kuttner is probably right in saying:
This law, after all, is Obama's signature initiative. It has been on the books since March 2010, with a full implementation date of 2014. An engaged chief executive would have been demanding frequent and detailed progress reports from his team. He would have gotten early warnings about possible glitches. But this president is tragically and inexcusably hands-off.Obama really did need to have a good rollout. And when the rollout hit some problems, he needed needed to double-down on defending the program, not scramble to find ways to apologize and re-apologize and compromise with the critics on minimum insurance standards.
A public option would have made a huge difference. But Democratic critics who feel they need to distance themselves from "Obamacare" should be proposing that as a fix, not undermining the ACA system even more. Mark Shields in Friday night's Political Wrap on the PBS Newshour had reverted back to his now-customary half-asleep state after several weeks of being energized and focused. But even though he carelessly overstates it, he also has a point when he says (Shields and Brooks on waning ACA confidence and its impact on liberal government 11/15/2013):
Judy, this is beyond the Obama administration. If this goes down, if the Obama -- if health care, the Affordable Care Act is deemed a failure, this is the end -- I really mean it -- of liberal government, in the sense of any sense that government as an instrument of social justice, an engine of economic progress, which is what divides Democrats from Republicans -- that's what Democrats believe.It won't be the end. But it will be a huge setback. And, as we saw last week, the Democrats still have a tendency to react to setbacks by trying to look more "centrist" instead of articulating a liberal alternative like a public option that would let them both defend the basic idea of the ACA and also show they are responding to public criticism. In this case, a public criticism massively magnified by the mainstream press.
And that's what Democrats believe. Time and again, social programs have made the difference in this country. The public confidence in that will be so depleted, so diminished, that I really think the change -- the equation of American politics changes.
Shields at least sees the urgency in defending the ACA. But he went along with the crowd in piling in on Obama over the keep-your-own-health-insurance thing - understandably, I guess, since Obama himself isn't defending himself on it:
The other thing is, let's be very blunt about it. The president said time and again that nobody is going to lose his insurance or her insurance if they like it. And so, driven to one of two conclusions, that is -- wasn't a true statement. And you're driven to one of two conclusions.In retrospect, Obama should have tacked on some qualifier to that statement, like "but this is a private-insurance based plan, so every consumer will have choices to make. If my insurance company starts charging me more for the same or less services, do I stick with them or do I make a more suitable selection from the insurance exchanges?" That would have combined the reassurance about keeping your own insurance with a qualification and bit of explanation about how the new system would work.
Either the president was almost -- almost negligently uncurious in not asking about what the answer was, or he made the choice to trade his considerable reputation and record of integrity for short-term political gain. That's why they had to come and that's why there was such consternation in the ranks.
But the basic statement was fair. Even junk insurance plans that were in effect at the time the ACA was passed in 2010 were grandfathered in. But Obama never promised your insurance company would never raise rates. On the contrary, it was a selling point for the ACA that it was based on private insurance. Rates were going to be subject to private competition, facilitated by the new exchanges. The point of the particular approach in the ACA was to create a functioning competitive market in insurance that would make it accessible to everyone. Obama tried at one point to defend himself from the criticism by responding along those lines. But then his seeming compulsion to accept Republicans framing kicked in to the point of effectively accepting the harshest Republican criticism on the keeping-your-insurance issue. So now he has commentators like Shields, who is obviously inclined to defend him on the ACA, not only saying it was false but joining Republicans in trashing Obama's "record of integrity" over the issue.
Digby has a helpful discussion of the problems of the Obamacare website in The Contractor State Hullabaloo 11/14/2013. She links to this piece by David Auerbach, Quixotic Queries Question Quality! Slate 10/12/2013, which shows something about the complexity of the project management involved. It's not an excuse. But it provides real-world context.
Tags: aca, obamacare
Thursday, November 14, 2013
Obamacare and keep-your-junk-health-insurance: a left-right alliance?
I was struck by this post on the left-leaning Firedoglake blog from Jon Walker, Obamacare Can Handle the "Keep Your Health Plan" Bill FDL dated 11/14/2013; accessed 11/13/2013. He's endorsing Michigan Republican Congressman Fred Upton's so-called Keep Your Health Plan Act to allow insurance companies to peddle substandard, junk insurance policies. "It lasts for only one year," Walker assures us. Just like other the postponements that Republicans have been demanding as part of their all-out efforts to sabotage the implementation of the ADA any way they can. Why the junk insurance policies are desirable for 2014 but not for 2015 is not clear. Gee, I wonder if some Republicans will propose another year-long extension this time next year?
I was almost done with the post when I got the news that the White House is now on board with the idea of extending the private junk insurance policies for a year. So I'm changing the tenses below to reflect that this was a political preliminary to the White House capitulation, which could in practice turn out to be fatal for the ACA as a whole. This is a delay that matters, a lot. Republicans are sure to read this as a "blood in the water" sign from the White House on the ACA.
Bill Clinton jumped on board with this idea earlier this week. This was a surprise to me. I would have thought his partisan devotion to what is, after all, a private-insurance based ACA would have held him back from doing this. And, as Sam Stein reports in Obamacare Angst Among Democrats Approaches A Tipping Point Huffington Post 11/13/2013:
Otherwise, it's not so encouraging for a labor-progressive point of view.
The Firedoglake bloggers were generally critical, as most of the Democratic wing of the Democratic Party were, of the failure to include a public option in the ACA. I was also of a mind in 2010, looking at the specific situation as of that moment, that I wanted to see the Progressive Caucus be willing to go down to the bitter end to deep-six the plan if it didn't include a public option.
Whether that would have wound up with Obama capitulating and including the public option or not is not just another of the endless what-if questions of history. The fabled dustbin of history has a lot of those. But I do believe that the failure to take a more determined stand taught the Obama White House that the Congressional progressive could be safely ignored when push came to shove. The weight of corporate money means that no matter how small, the Blue Dog faction among the Democrats will have weight in policy fights disproportionate to their numbers. But the more specific practical lesson that the White House undoubtedly drew from the public option controversy was that if they disappointed the Progressive Caucus on even a self-described red-line issue like the public option, it wouldn't matter. The progressives would go along with the watered-down version.
The Obama White House didn't have to be afraid of the Progressive Caucus, in other words. But the smaller Blue Dog faction was willing to threaten to kill legislation that didn't meet Blue Dog minimum requirements. This is no the situation I want to see Congressional progressive be in.
But now we have the ACA, with all the flaws inherent in its private-insurance basis and the various ways in which the structure of the legislation gives the Republicans in Congress and the state level to do a great deal of mischief. If the ACA breaks down in the current environment, the Republicans and Blue Dogs will push to gut the law of all its most constructive features. But I predict they would try to leave in place the individual mandate, because that is something the insurance companies love but a lot of consumers will hate, especially if the insurance companies can go back to providing only junk insurance.
Changes to the law at this point have to go in one of two broad directions: toward removing the constructive parts, or toward fixing the problems by better regulations of the insurance companies and by expanding the opportunities for public-option features. And I think Digby is right in pointing the Medicaid expansion as a type of increased public option, even in the ACA framework. (Single payer under Obamacare? You betcha! Hullabaloo 11/11/2013) Finding away around the crassly partisan Supreme Court's ruling allowing individual states to refuse to adopt the Medicaid expansion would be a good step in the constructive direction.
So the rush of both Blue Dogs and some progressives, as well as Bill Clinton (who presumably has Hillary's political positioning also in mind), to join with Republicans on the keep-the-junk-health-insurance cause is disturbing.
Robert Reich is harsh on the latest round of corporate Dem folding in the face of criticism from rightwinger (Having the Backbone to Set Minimum Standards for Health Insurance 11/13/2013):
Charlie Pierce was disturbed by Clinton's announcement (The Beginning of What May Be the End Esquire Politics Blog 11/13/2013):
As Reich puts it:
This, of course, is meant to "head off" a general stampede by the Democratic chickenshit caucus. It is also meant to show that the president is conscious of the concerns of a Republican opposition that will now proceed to demand a delay in the individual mandate, tort reform, and the removal of one of the A's in the president's surname.
Tags: aca, obamacare
I was almost done with the post when I got the news that the White House is now on board with the idea of extending the private junk insurance policies for a year. So I'm changing the tenses below to reflect that this was a political preliminary to the White House capitulation, which could in practice turn out to be fatal for the ACA as a whole. This is a delay that matters, a lot. Republicans are sure to read this as a "blood in the water" sign from the White House on the ACA.
Bill Clinton jumped on board with this idea earlier this week. This was a surprise to me. I would have thought his partisan devotion to what is, after all, a private-insurance based ACA would have held him back from doing this. And, as Sam Stein reports in Obamacare Angst Among Democrats Approaches A Tipping Point Huffington Post 11/13/2013:
On Wednesday morning, Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.) announced that he was co-sponsoring a bill to allow individuals who buy their own insurance to stay on their current health care plans indefinitely rather than be forced into better regulated plans through the newly created exchanges.I suppose if you value Bipartisanship as valuable in itself, this might be an encouraging sign.
Coming from one of the Senate's most notably progressive voices, the Oregon Democrat's announcement was a particularly vivid demonstration of how nervous party members are over the state of the Affordable Care Act. The flawed website, combined with the steady stream of news of insurers forcing people to adopt more comprehensive and at times expensive plans in response to new regulations, had already persuaded five other Democrats to support the Keeping the Affordable Care Act Promise Act, introduced by Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-La.).
Otherwise, it's not so encouraging for a labor-progressive point of view.
The Firedoglake bloggers were generally critical, as most of the Democratic wing of the Democratic Party were, of the failure to include a public option in the ACA. I was also of a mind in 2010, looking at the specific situation as of that moment, that I wanted to see the Progressive Caucus be willing to go down to the bitter end to deep-six the plan if it didn't include a public option.
Whether that would have wound up with Obama capitulating and including the public option or not is not just another of the endless what-if questions of history. The fabled dustbin of history has a lot of those. But I do believe that the failure to take a more determined stand taught the Obama White House that the Congressional progressive could be safely ignored when push came to shove. The weight of corporate money means that no matter how small, the Blue Dog faction among the Democrats will have weight in policy fights disproportionate to their numbers. But the more specific practical lesson that the White House undoubtedly drew from the public option controversy was that if they disappointed the Progressive Caucus on even a self-described red-line issue like the public option, it wouldn't matter. The progressives would go along with the watered-down version.
The Obama White House didn't have to be afraid of the Progressive Caucus, in other words. But the smaller Blue Dog faction was willing to threaten to kill legislation that didn't meet Blue Dog minimum requirements. This is no the situation I want to see Congressional progressive be in.
But now we have the ACA, with all the flaws inherent in its private-insurance basis and the various ways in which the structure of the legislation gives the Republicans in Congress and the state level to do a great deal of mischief. If the ACA breaks down in the current environment, the Republicans and Blue Dogs will push to gut the law of all its most constructive features. But I predict they would try to leave in place the individual mandate, because that is something the insurance companies love but a lot of consumers will hate, especially if the insurance companies can go back to providing only junk insurance.
Changes to the law at this point have to go in one of two broad directions: toward removing the constructive parts, or toward fixing the problems by better regulations of the insurance companies and by expanding the opportunities for public-option features. And I think Digby is right in pointing the Medicaid expansion as a type of increased public option, even in the ACA framework. (Single payer under Obamacare? You betcha! Hullabaloo 11/11/2013) Finding away around the crassly partisan Supreme Court's ruling allowing individual states to refuse to adopt the Medicaid expansion would be a good step in the constructive direction.
So the rush of both Blue Dogs and some progressives, as well as Bill Clinton (who presumably has Hillary's political positioning also in mind), to join with Republicans on the keep-the-junk-health-insurance cause is disturbing.
Robert Reich is harsh on the latest round of corporate Dem folding in the face of criticism from rightwinger (Having the Backbone to Set Minimum Standards for Health Insurance 11/13/2013):
Democrats are showing once again they have the backbones of banana slugs.
The Affordable Care Act was meant to hold insurers to a higher standards. So it stands to reason that some insurers will have to cancel their lousy sub-standard policies.
But spineless Democrats (including my old boss Bill Clinton) are caving in to the Republican-fueled outrage that the President “misled” Americans into thinking they could keep their old lousy policies — and are now urging the White House to forget the new standards and let people keep what they had before.
Charlie Pierce was disturbed by Clinton's announcement (The Beginning of What May Be the End Esquire Politics Blog 11/13/2013):
If the Democratic party, through its elected leaders, bails on the health-care law even so far as go out of its way to let people keep their lousy insurance plans that do not come up to the Affordable Care Act's specifications, that's pretty much the ballgame. There will be barbering and compromising until hell won't have it and, eventually, the only thing left will be the Medicaid expansion, and we all know the vast influence that poor and lower middle class people have over the political process. (And, as Steve M shrewdly notes, the Democrats will get blamed for the deleterious effects of any changes now anyway.) There is far less of a downside right now to being stubborn, regardless of what the courtier press is telling nervous Democrats. Otherwise, the tracks already are cleared and you can hear the the train a-comin'.He's right. Democrats are really losing sight of the basics of health care reform if they fold on this.
As Reich puts it:
Can we please get a grip? Whenever industry standards are lifted — a higher minimum wage, safer workplaces, non-toxic foods and drugs, safer cars — people no longer have the “freedom” to contract for the sub-standard goods and services.In The Surrender Is Not Abject, So There's That 11/14/2013 after the White House announced it's capitulation, Pierce writes:
But that freedom is usually a mirage because big businesses have most of the power and average people don’t have much of a choice. This has been especially the case with health insurance, which is why minimum standards here are essential.
This, of course, is meant to "head off" a general stampede by the Democratic chickenshit caucus. It is also meant to show that the president is conscious of the concerns of a Republican opposition that will now proceed to demand a delay in the individual mandate, tort reform, and the removal of one of the A's in the president's surname.
Tags: aca, obamacare
Monday, August 19, 2013
I hope Krugman's right on Obamacare
Paul Krugman thinks President Obama will hang tough on the essential elements of his Affordable Care Act (ACA), aka, Obamacare.
And he thinks the program will win substantial support (One Reform, Indivisible New York Times 08/18/2013):
Time and the quality of implementation and the kind of defense the Democrats make for the program will eventually tell whether the ACA was adequate to move health insurance in the right direction or too flawed to survive politically.
Tags: aca, affordable care act, obamacare
And he thinks the program will win substantial support (One Reform, Indivisible New York Times 08/18/2013):
I guess that after all the years of vilification it was predictable that Republican leaders would still fail to understand the principles behind health reform and that this would hamper their ability to craft an effective political response as the reform’s implementation draws near. But their rudest shock is yet to come. You see, this thing isn’t going to be the often-predicted “train wreck.” On the contrary, it’s going to work.I hope he's right. It was a risky approach. But hopefully as the most popular features kick in and millions of people realize that they and/or their children other relatives and acquaintances can now get good health health insurance where they couldn't before, they will lean toward demanding fixing the parts that are deficient rather than abolishing the whole thing.
Oh, there will be problems, especially in states where Republican governors and legislators are doing all they can to sabotage the implementation. But the basic thrust of Obamacare is, as I’ve just explained, coherent and even fairly simple. Moreover, all the early indications are that the law will, in fact, give millions of Americans who currently lack access to health insurance the coverage they need, while giving millions more a big break in their health care costs. And because so many people will see clear benefits, health reform will prove irreversible.
This achievement will represent a huge defeat for the conservative agenda of weakening the safety net. And Republicans who deluded their supporters into believing that none of this would happen will probably pay a large personal price. But as I said, they have nobody but themselves to blame.
Time and the quality of implementation and the kind of defense the Democrats make for the program will eventually tell whether the ACA was adequate to move health insurance in the right direction or too flawed to survive politically.
Tags: aca, affordable care act, obamacare
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)