Showing posts with label ben carson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ben carson. Show all posts

Thursday, November 19, 2015

Not-so-smart Dr. Ben

You don't often see a definition of the word "smart." At least I don't. But this one from "neuroguy" (Dr. Ben Carson Is Not Smart Alternet 11/10/2015) strikes me as a good one (italics in original):

“Smart” is a multifaceted cognitive feature composed of excellent analytical skills, possession of an extensive knowledge base that is easily and frequently augmented, possession of a good memory, and being readily curious about the world and willing, even eager, to reject previously accepted notions in the face of new data. Being smart includes having the ability to analyze new data for validity and, thinking creatively, draw new insights from existing common knowledge.
As the title indicates, it's about Dr. Ben, who seems to be dropping in some recent polls. (Sophia Tesfaye, Ben Carson is cratering: New polls show controversies taking a toll on the wingnut favorite Salon 11/19/2015) The actual caucuses and primaries will be here soon enough, so I'm not putting a lot of faith in the opinion polls at this point.

But he does have some big hurdles to get past as a Presidential candidate. (Adele Stan, Is Ben Carson's Campaign About to Implode? The American Prospect 11/18/2015)

As Adele Stan points out, he may not pass some of the ideological litmus tests that the Christian Right applies.

Even more serious, though, is that he's a black candidate running in the Republican Party, aka, the Christian Republican White People's Party. The Republican Party since 1968 has been working hard to establish and maintain itself as the anti-black party. It's very difficult to imagine them nominating Dr. Ben as their Presidential candidate. Chauncey DeVega describes that reality this way (The Paris Terror Attacks and the Right-wing Media's War on Reality, Indomitable 11/17/2015; bolding in original)

In the post civil-rights era, conservatism and racism is now the same thing. The Republican Party is the United States’ largest white identity organization. As a matter of policy, it uses overt and subtle racism to win votes from racially resentful white people. To point, almost immediately, overt and open white supremacist websites began to feature content from more “mainstream” right-wing websites in response to my essay on the Paris terror attacks. Their “analysis” and “commentary” were almost identical: violent threats, racism, lies and disinformation.
DeVega sees Dr. Ben's candidacy this way (Is He a Genius? A Fool? Or Both? Ben Carson Now Has a "Rap Music" Political Ad 11/05/2015):

Ben Carson now has a rap video that is designed to appeal to "black voters". Although hip hop as an art form has fallen so far below the artistic and musical creativity and majesty of even ten years ago (never mind 20 years when Biggie, Nas, Tribe, Outcast, and Wu-Tang released seminal albums) Carson's rap video will of course have no appeal to "black" voters. The only folks who will be moved by it are Carson's racially resentful and bigoted white conservative supporters. Why? Because it lets them feel "cool" and "hip" as they groove to the negro race record croonings of Carson's emcee and the jungle rhythms of the synthesized drum. ...

He is fleecing dumb white conservatives of their money, getting rich off of campaign donations, and engaging in a type of post modern performance art and spectacular politics that mocks the stupidity of the American public.
But, even if Dr. Ben remains a major contender for the nomination, the ascendancy of spectacle over reality in politics proceeds.

Guy Debord wrote in Society of the Spectacle (1968; Black & Red translation, 1970) :

The spectacle is not a collection of images but a social relation among people mediated by images.

The spectacle cannot be understood as the abuse of a world of vision, as the product of the techniques of mass dissemination of images. It is, rather, a Weltanschauung which has become actual, materially translated. It is a vision of the world which has become objectified.

Monday, November 09, 2015

More on Dr. Ben and troublesome reality

Roy Edroso adds some valuable perspective to the Dr. Ben tale-tales meme in With Ben Carson's Truthiness in Question, Rightbloggers Rage Against 'Liberal Media' Village Voice 11/09/2015:

The rest of you may be thinking: Who cares? Reagan thought he was in Germany in World War II, and it didn’t hurt him. Understand, though: Carson has over the years made all kinds of controversial statements about Nazi Germany, slavery, and their relationship to Democratic policy. Reporters haven’t made much of these because they conform with mainstream conservatives thought — see Liberal Fascism, et alia — so any cavils would be counted as politically motivated attacks by Liberal Media.

But fudged biographical details in a book — that’s something the Fourth Estate can work with, as James Frey and many others can tell you. So reporters began to dig.

Buzzfeed announced that Carson had told a commencement audience in 1998 that the biblical Joseph built the Egyptian pyramids to store grain. (“Now all the archeologists think that they were made for the pharaohs’ graves. But…”) Since his statement had nothing to do with the fascist Obama Administration, it was fair game and the story spread.
And he turns his appreciative eye for rightwing kookiness on Carson's defenders: "An 'E' for effort also went to National Review’s Jim Geraghty, who gamely asked, 'How likely is it that Carson’s theory on the pyramids’ use or builder is likely to influence any of his decisions as president? What, is it going to ruin our relationship with Egypt?' This suggests a new slogan for the Carson campaign: 'Crazy but Harmless.'"

As Rick Perlstein has pointed out recently, the long-running relationship between movement conservative politics and con jobs is turning more and more into a fusion the longer it goes on.

Friday, November 06, 2015

Dr. Ben and militant ignorance

I don't know if I've used it here, but I've long thought that "militant ignorance" was a good phrase to describe the dogmatic attitudes of a lot of rightwing Republicans.

Josh Marshall today (Ignorance and Arrogance TPM 11/06/2015) uses that concept to describe the combination of blithe confidence in which Presidential candidate Dr. Ben Carson declares the kookiest beliefs:

When you watch Carson navigating the public square you see someone who is remarkably ignorant about huge swathes of human knowledge and particularly information about US government and public policy. But you also see someone who's quite confident he's very knowledgable. So he's both remarkably ignorant and either stunningly unaware of his ignorance or totally indifferent to it. You might even say he is militantly ignorant. In all aspects of life, that is a dangerous combination. And the combination is almost always rooted in arrogance. None of us know everything. And in a complex world, we don't need to. The key is having some realistic grasp of what you do know and what you don't know. [italics in original]
Josh's use of "the public square" is a nice touch. About the only place I ever see that used in a contemporary context is Christian Rightists whining about how the Mean Libruls don't want them to "participate in the public square."

The conservative Christian Post is running this column which defends Carson's crackpot theory, though in a mealy-mouthed way: Leonardo Blair, Ben Carson's Theory That Egyptian Pyramids Were Built by Joseph Is 600 Years Old 11/05/2015. I should stress that this article should not be taken as a serious analysis. It's not. The most obvious sign is this portion, which for a reasonably careful reader would immediately trigger caution:

Veteran alternative archaeology reporter Scott Creighton as well as a 2011 report in the Smithsonian magazine note that there is no consensus as to why the pyramids were built.

"The idea that these structures were conceived and built as tombs is all pervasive to our modern mindset, so much so that many have come to accept the idea as being not so much a theory but as actual fact," wrote Creighton in an essay published online.

"So why then should it be deemed necessary to question what many regard as fact? The first thing to say is that the evidence in support of the tomb theory is only circumstantial; there is no direct primary evidence to support the pyramid tomb theory. Neither are there any ancient Egyptian texts that state why the ancient Egyptians conceived and built their pyramids. Indeed, there are a number of ancient texts that state the pyramids were not used as tombs," he said.
There is a Smithsonian article at the link included. Normally the reader would expect the immediately following quote to come from that piece. It says after the first part of the quote that it comes from "an essay published online."

But digging into this a bit, I found what you so often find with middle-brow attempts to argue for a crackpot position. The article referenced is highly misleading, though not technically false. When I read it, I thought, well, this Creighton guy must have something on the ball if he's getting published in Smithsonian. Because that's a serious publication a reputation to protect. In fact, I read the whole article before realizing that the author is Mike Dash.

This is typical of the work of hacks, fakes and propagandists to try to associate highly dubious claims with respectable or respectable-seeming sources. Also, in this case, there is also a fairly obvious fact that the pyramids had, you know, people buried in them. That's a pretty good reason to think they were built as tombs, since they very obviously functioned as tombs. Arguing for an alternative claim would require some pretty strong arguments for an alternative or pointing out a basic problem in the assumption. I'm not an archaeologist or an "alternative archaeology reporter." (I wonder if some news organization has a position with that job description!) But I don't find the arguments he makes there to call the theory in question very persuasive. For instance, he claims that some earlier graves are rectangular, but the base of a pyramid is square? That might be a question of some importance as to why that change took place. But is that a reason to question whether structures that functioned as tombs and have no known major alternative usage were intended to be tombs? You don't need to be an Egyptologist to see the answer is no.

The Smithsonian article by Mike Dash, not the "alternative archaeology reporter"- the one that would have to pass through editing to be posted - is titled Inside the Great Pyramid 11/01/2011. As the title suggests, it deals mainly with "the question of who first entered the Great Pyramid after it was sealed in about 2566 B.C. and what they found inside it." (Dash) It does not deal with the broader question of the purpose of the pyramids.

But there's worse. Repeating part of the quote above from the Christian Post article: "Veteran alternative archaeology reporter Scott Creighton as well as a 2011 report in the Smithsonian magazine note that there is no consensus as to why the pyramids were built."

Mike Dash's article does not claim that "there is no consensus as to why the pyramids were built"!

Dash's references to mysteries and purpose are the kind of thing you expect to see in a well-edited publication:

Few would be so bold as to suggest that, even today, we know why Khufu ordered the construction of what is by far the most elaborate system of passages and chambers concealed within any pyramid. His is the only one of the 35 such tombs constructed between 2630 and 1750 B.C. to contain tunnels and vaults well above ground level. (Its immediate predecessors, the Bent Pyramid and the North Pyramid at Dahshur, have vaults built at ground level; all the others are solid structures whose burial chambers lie well underground.) For years, the commonly accepted theory was that the Great Pyramid's elaborate features were the product of a succession of changes in plan, perhaps to accommodate Pharaoh's increasingly divine stature as his reign went on, but the American Egyptologist Mark Lehner has marshaled evidence suggesting that the design was fixed before construction began. If so, the pyramid's internal layout becomes even more mysterious, and that's before we bear in mind the findings of the Quarterly Review, which reported in 1818, after careful computation, that the structure's known passages and vaults occupy a mere 1/7,400th of its volume, so that "after leaving the contents of every second chamber solid by way of separation, there might be three thousand seven hundred chambers, each equal in size to the sarcophagus chamber, [hidden] within."
Dash's takes the obvious assumption that the pyramids are tombs for granted, as we see in that quote. The rest of Dash's article is an interesting and entertaining historical detective story about when the Great Pyramid was first breached and some discussion of the actual historical sources relevant to that question.

But this is one example of the conservative Christian world of thought and reporting in which Dr. Ben is popular and from which he apparently derives a great deal of his more controversial beliefs about historical fact. This particular one isn't directly defending Carson's kooky pyramid claim. It's instead leaving the false impression that serious secular archaeology isn't generally agreed that this structures in which Pharoahs and various members of their entourage were buried were actually intended to be tombs. In other words, it stakes out the position that it wasn't kooky and exceptionally ill-informed for Dr. Ben to dismiss the idea that the pyramids were intended to be tombs.

Tuesday, October 06, 2015

A crackpot ghost helping to run the Republican asylum

David Corn last week takes a look at how much Republican Presidential candidate Ben Carson admires a deceased Mormon fundamentalist crackpot who is also one of Glenn Beck's main gurus, maybe the main one. (Ben Carson's Love Affair With a "Nutjob" Conspiracy Theorist Mother Jones 08/29/2015

That would be the late authoritarian kook, Willard Cleon Skousen (1913-2006). I wrote about him on this blog in Glenn Beck's political guru 09/21/2009:

Skousen was a Morman rightwinger who taught at two Mormon universities and served for four years as the Salt Lake City chief of police, until the ultra-conservative mayor of the time fired him for being too hardline. "He operated the police department like a Gestapo," the mayor said.

Skousen in the early 1960s after being canned as police chief was involved with far-right groups like the Birchers' American Opinion Speakers Bureau, the Christian Anti-Communism Crusade, the All-American Society and the American Security Council. Zaitchik writes that Skousen in the early 1960s became "the nation's most prominent Birch defender." The Birchers were angry at Barry Goldwater's movement because the 1964 Republican Convention that selected Goldwater as its Presidential nominee also condemned the Birch Society which viewed former President Dwight Eisenhower as having been a Communist. The pique of the Birchers against Goldwater, despite his endorsement of many views to their liking, was probably not irrelevant to the fact that Goldwater's parents had been Jewish, though they had converted to Christianity.

The Skousen book that Beck so loves is The 5,000 Year Leap (1981). But he also made ripples in the sphere of far-right influence with other volumes like The Naked Communist, The Communist Attack on the John Birch Society, The Naked Capitalist (1970) and The Making of America (1982), the latter of which claimed that slaveowners had been the "worst victims" of the slavery system in the Old South.

As [Alexander] Zaitchik explains, the Mormon journal Dialogue: The Journal of Mormon Thought in its Autumn-Winter 1971 issue published a symposium on The Naked Capitalist, which was receiving notable attention from conservative Mormon intellectuals. Dialogue has made the symposium available on its Web site, including a pitch by an admirer of Skousen's book and a response by Skousen himself. You can get a first-hand look there at the ideology on which Beck is operating and recommending to his followers as it looked during the first Nixon administration, long before the "teaparty" movement became a favorite media entertainment item.
This is a picture of Ben Carson's and Glenn Beck's intellectual mentor:


It's fascinating to see in Corn's article that just last year, Carson referred to Skousen's book The Naked Communist this way: "It was written in 1958. Cleon Skousen lays out the whole agenda, including the importance of getting people into important positions in the mainstream media so they can help drive the agenda. Well, that's what's going on now."

A paranoid conspiracy theory that worked for the Birchers and similar rightwinger fringers in 1958 still can work for them today in only slightly modified form. Only today it works for mainstream Republicans like Ben Carson.

Victor Ferkiss wrote in 1962 ("Political and Intellectual Origins of American Radicalism, Right and Left" Annals 344; Nov 1962):

The single most important tenet of right-wing radicalism is the absoluteness of the menace of communism and the struggle against it. It is not only an important or the most important thing in the world, it is the only thing. Everything that happens is a function of it - a nationalist revolution in Africa, government medical care for the aged, or less homework in schools - just as for Marx everything was epiphenomenal to the control of the means of production. The Communists are winning because they recognize the absoluteness of the struggle; the United States is losing because, save for the radical right, it does not. [my emphasis]
It sounds this is true today for Skousen disciple Ben Carson, as well.

Frekiss also noted how the Radical Right then turned their paranoid against the all-threatening external Communist menace against domestic political figures that had nothing to do with Communism:

Today, ... the radical right ... holds that the Communists are basically weak and that what makes them strong is our failure to use the strength we possess-a concomitant of our failure to recognize the absoluteness of the struggle. Get rid of the traitors, spies, and do-gooders in our midst, and we will triumph over communism with a minimum of effort and expense.
What he said in the ellipse was, "the radical right de-emphasizes
military as well as foreign-aid expenditures." They still gripe about foreign aid, that's a perennially favorite grievance. But today they love, love, love military expenditure. Frekiss there was talking about the isolationist right of the John Birch Society type, which espoused the kind of segregationist "libertarianism" that the Paul family professes now. It always had a militaristic core. And Rand Paul's political evolution over the last few years shows a lot of that side of this type of "isolationist" radicalism.

But, amazingly, Frekiss also wrote about the Radical Right of 1962, "One noteworthy element is missing: racialism." He just went right of the tracks on that one!

Another article in the same number of the Annals, "Conservatism" by Jasper Shannon, shows how anti-Communism made for fluid distinctions between conservatives and reactionaries:

The frenzied frustration of the Cold War made Marxian communism the symbol of every kind of wickedness. Unable to destroy the enemy abroad, many conservatives turned to a real or fancied enemy within. Not content with warning against the diminishing number of official members of the American Communist party, baffled conservatives broadened the definition of communism to include anyone whose views they regarded as dangerous. Liberals and even moderate conservatives fell under the sweeping charges of what one may call the emotional conservatives. Some of these radical-right persons clung to General Douglas MacArthur as a forlorn hope for the presidency in 1952. Embittered by MacArthur's failure to win a considerable following, they supported Robert A. Taft. When Taft was defeated by Eisenhower, the wrath of these inflamed rightists turned against Taft for not throwing his delegates to MacArthur. No language was too strong to be applied to either Taft or Eisenhower in this moment of agonized disappointment.
That reference to Ohio Senator Robert Taft is relevant to discussion then and now about the split between conservatives and reactionaries. In practice, the boundaries between conservatives and Radical Right were often hard to detect.

And in the US today, finding those boundaries is practically an impossible effort.