Showing posts with label bill ayers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bill ayers. Show all posts

Thursday, November 13, 2008

They can't let it go, the Bill Ayers thing


They, in this case being Wolf Blitzer and Sarah Palin, as reported by Rachel Weiner in Palin Attacks Obama Over Ayers Yet Again On CNN Huffington Post 11/12/08. At the risk of sounding like I'm partially defending that rightwing fanatic neo-Confederate theocrat Palin, it's Blitzer who brings it up in the passage Weiner quotes:

BLITZER: Because, you know, during a campaign, every presidential campaign, things are said, it's tough, as you well know, it gets sometimes pretty fierce out there. And during the campaign, you said this, you said: "This is not a man who sees America as you see it and how I see America."

And then you went on to say: "Someone who sees America, it seems, as being so imperfect that he is palling around with terrorists who would target their own country."

PALIN: Well, I still am concerned about that association with Bill Ayers. And if anybody still wants to talk about it, I will, because this is an unrepentant domestic terrorist who had campaigned to blow up, to destroy our Pentagon and our U.S. Capitol. That's an association that still bothers me.

And I think it's still fair to talk about it. However the campaign is over. That chapter is closed. Now is the time to move on and to, again, make sure that all of us are doing all that we can to progress this nation.

Keep us secure, get the economy back on the right track, and many of us do have some ideas on how to do that and hopefully we'll be able to put all of that wisdom and experience to good use together.

BLITZER: So looking back, you don't regret that tough language during the campaign?

PALIN: No, and I do not think that it is off-base nor mean-spirited, nor negative campaigning to call someone out on their associations and on their record. And that's why I did it. [my emphasis]
Right now, the media pod people are trashing Palin, although a competing narrative is already peeking its way through the cloud of scorn, saying that everybody is underestimating the White Princess' political talents.

It's important for Democrats not to let our unavoidable shadenfreude over seeing Palin ridiculed by the Pod Pundits who normally put most of their energy into trashing Democrats.

But it shouldn't distract us from the fact that our national political press is flat-on-its-face dysfunctional. The full transcript is available at CNN-The Situation Room Transcripts. But it's Wolf Blitzer who bring up Bill Ayers in the question.

She was happy to pick up the cue, because for the hard right, they love talking about Obama the Terrorists' Pal. But at least in the section quoted by Weiner, Palin shows her usual level of concern for facts.

But before getting into that, not only does Blitzer not challenge her on easily identifiable misstatements in response to his question. He and his Establishment cohorts generally have been unwilling to do the kind of serious investigations they needed to be doing into her association with radical, theocratic religious groups that encourage they supporters to deep their more theocratic beliefs secret in order to win power in secular institutions like the Republican Party. Nor did they provide the kind of focus needed on Palin's close public association right up into 2008 with the far-right, neo-Confederate, explicitly anti-American Alaskan Independence Party, an affiliate of the radical-Christianist Constitution Party. And, as Palin told Wolf, it isn't "off-base nor mean-spirited, nor negative campaigning to call someone out on their associations and on their record".

But the press has focused a lot of attention on her clothes. Maureen Dowd has so far devoted significant portions of three of her high-profile New York Times columns to that pressing topic.

For those who are interested, In These Times has published a post-election column by Bill Ayers himself addressing the controversy over his loose association with the President-elect, What a Long, Strange Trip It’s Been 11/07/08. He states an obvious fact when he writes, "I became a prop, a cartoon character created to be pummeled." Most of his comments about the state of politics are pretty vague. Understandably so, since the Republicans, the Democrats and the press made him a national pariah this year. He probably doesn't want to embarrass anyone by too closely associating himself publicly with them. (By the way, he has his own blog. Doesn't everybody?)

It could also be he's just saying what he thinks. But he does mention someone, though not by name, that he has been "pallin' around with", as Palin put it:

My voicemail filled up with hate messages. They were mostly from men, all venting and sweating and breathing heavily. A few threats: "Watch out!” and “You deserve to be shot.” And some e-mails, like this one I got from satan@hell.com: “I’m coming to get you and when I do, I’ll water-board you.”

The police lieutenant who came to copy down those threats deadpanned that he hoped the guy who was going to shoot me got there before the guy who was going to water-board me, since it would be most foul to be tortured and then shot. (We have been pals ever since he was first assigned to investigate threats made against me in 1987, after I was hired as an assistant professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago.) [my emphasis]
Which brings us to Palin's ongoing accusation that Blitzer solicited from her. So far as I'm aware, Bill Ayers has been a law-abiding citizen for at least the last 25 years or more. (See Thomas Frank, My Friend Bill Ayers Wall Street Journal 10/15/08.) I'm not certain whether Ayers' much-alluded-to comment about doing more refers to wishing he had done more bombing with the Weather Underground (WU). I have seen him say in a documentary that he wishes they had done more to stop the Vietnam War.

So maybe it's technically correct for Palin to call him an "unrepentant ... terrorist", though I don't really think it's fair.

But it's simply not true what Republicans - and at on at least one occasion, Hillary Clinton - said about him and the WU, that they killed Americans. Or what Palin says to Blitzer above, that they sought to "blow up, to destroy our Pentagon and our U.S. Capitol". They never attempted to blow up the entire Capitol or Pentagon, which is the literal meaning of Palin's claim to Blitzer. And it's not right, at least from my point of few, of falsely accusing someone of killing people.

You can think Ayers and the other members of the WU were ten kinds of scumbags when their group was active. And they did plant bombs in the Capitol building, the Pentagon, the State Department and other public buildings. But they were not trying to randomly kill people in those buildings, which is what the word "terrorism" most likely conjures to most Americans these days. On the contrary, they went out of their way to avoid injuring or killing anyone, setting their bombs to go off at night and issuing warnings before the blasts were timed to occur.

Could they have killed people? Sure. It was risky and in the eyes of virtually everyone in the US at the time, it was irresponsible and reckless. But the only people that were ever killed in the course of the WU's actions were two three of their own members who died when a bomb they were constructed unexpectedly detonated.

Ayers in his column also makes a pretty straightforward Jeffersonian observation about the kind of "culture war" pariah image they hung on him and tried to hang on Obama:

Obama has continually been asked to defend something that ought to be at democracy’s heart: the importance of talking to as many people as possible in this complicated and wildly diverse society, of listening with the possibility of learning something new, and of speaking with the possibility of persuading or influencing others.

The McCain-Palin attacks not only involved guilt by association, they also assumed that one must apply a political litmus test to begin a conversation. ...

In a robust and sophisticated democracy, political leaders - and all of us - ought to seek ways to talk with many people who hold dissenting, or even radical, ideas. Lacking that simple and yet essential capacity to question authority, we might still be burning witches and enslaving our fellow human beings today. [my emphasis]
Which gets back to the point of why real journalism could have been valuable in reporting on the accusation involved Ayers. Reports that elaborated their actions accurately and described their political theory would have highlighted the fact that Obama has never involved himself with such an approach to politics. And I would be astonished if they could have found footage of even one Democratic member of Congress at the time expressing even remote sympathy for Weather Underground bombings.

Decent reports would have also described the fact that the Weather Underground, for all the attention they attracted, were a small group with minimal support even among those who were passionate antiwar activists. In fact, if the interviews in the documentary The Weather Underground (2003) convey an accurate picture, the group members themselves came to some kind of consensus in the mid-to-late 1970s that they had been mistaken in their approach of symbolic bombings. And that they had badly misread the political climate in America.

And, again assuming a fantasy world of competent professional journalism by our leading press outlets, such an approach to the story might have taught people something about terrorism. It would actually be interesting to hear what some of the former WU members have to say about the murderous Islamic terrorism of today. Who knows? They might actually have useful insights! And it would actually surprise me if they haven't had terrorism experts from government agencies attempt to talk to them about that very subject.

But our Wolf Blitzers think they have fulfilled their journalistic mission if they report what one side says and then what the other side says. And the "two sides" - more than that are very difficult for our reporters to manage - in this matter were Republicans and Democrats. Republicans had the incentive to make Bill Ayers sound as sinister as possible. While Democrats had an incentive to distance Obama from Ayers, not to encourage a fact-based discussion of the actual history involved. Because the latter could easily have been spun during the election as "defending" the WU's actions in the 1970s.

So to me, the real story here is not that rightwing fanatic Palin is still repeating her rightwing fanatic trash talk from the campaign. That's strictly "dog bites man" kind of news. The real story to which Democrats should be paying attention is the continuing dysfunction of the national press corps. A dysfunction that rarely helps the interests of Democrats more than those of Republicans.

Tags: , , , ,

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

The Demeanor of Da Meaner Guy by Robert S. McElvaine

There has been a lot of discussion of John McCain's demeanor during the presidential debates. More important, though, has been the demeanor of his campaign as a whole.

Demeanor refers to the way in which someone behaves toward other people. In comparison with Barack Obama, John McCain's behavior toward his opponent and toward the voters has shown repeatedly that he is "da meaner" candidate.

During the final presidential debate on Wednesday evening, Sen. McCain said, "I don't care about an old washed-up terrorist" and "I have repudiated every time someone's been out of line, whether they've been part of my campaign or not, and I will continue to do that."

Yet his campaign had just released a commercial claiming that Sen. Obama and "domestic terrorist Bill Ayers" are friends who have been closely associated for years. Republican parties in battleground states distributed pamphlets saying "Obama Has Close Ties to Domestic Terrorist" and showing a photo of Obama next to a quotation from Ayers, "I don't regret setting bombs. I feel we didn't do enough," to lead voters to think that the words are Obama's.

And the day after McCain said he would continue to repudiate anyone in his campaign who got out of line, his campaign got on the lines with a massive nationwide robocall effort that begins with: "Hello. I'm calling for John McCain and the RNC." The automated calls tell those who pick up their phones that they "need to know that Barack Obama has worked closely with domestic terrorist, Bill Ayers, whose organization bombed the U.S. Capitol, the Pentagon, a judge's home, and killed Americans."

We are all familiar with tag lines at the end of a political campaign commercial that say something like, "The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee is responsible for the content of this advertising."

McCain's "terrorist" ads, pamphlets, and calls should have a tagline saying, "John McCain and the Republican National Committee are Irresponsible for the totally misleading content of this advertising."

Or: "I'm John McCain, and I approve this lying message, which tells you all you need to know about me."

[Historian Robert S. McElvaine is Elizabeth Chisholm Professor of Arts & Letters at Millsaps College. His latest book is Grand Theft Jesus: The Hijacking of Religion in America (Crown). He is currently at work on a book on America in the 1960s, Oh, Freedom! (Norton).]

Tags: , ,

Monday, October 20, 2008

Contemporary 1975 account of a Weather Underground bombing

The McCain campaign has made Bill Ayers into the "Willie Horton" of the 2008 Presidential campaign.

Here is part of the text of a robocall being used by the McCain campaign. Chris Wallace confronted McCain with it on FOX News and McCain not only affirmed it was his campaign's material but defended its use with McCarthyist guilt-by-association insinuations against Obama.


I looked up a 1975 hearing of the Internal Security Subcommittee of the Senate Judiciary Committee dated 01/31/1975, titled "State Department Bombing by Weatherman Underground". It concerned a bombing at the State Department for which the Weather Underground (WU) organization took responsibility. The Internal Security Subcommittee investigator that Sen. Strom Thurmond had there to testify, Robert James Short, was already convinced that the WU were responsible. They had delivered a 12-page communiqué about the action and they already had an established modus operandi by this point. So their responsibility was not in question.

When I first saw this hearing transcript, I thought I should probably wait until after Nov. 4 to post anything about it so that the focus would be more clearly on the actual historical events rather than election-related. But it only took a few seconds' reflection to recall that the loons are going to believe what they want to believe, especially since McCain has made this a central argument in his campaign.

So I decided I would proceed with a reality-based post (or maybe more than one) about the WU. I've posted historical material about the group before, including Terrorism, the old-fashioned kind 06/04/07 and Was the antiwar movement against the Vietnam War counterproductive? 08/04/07, both of which preceded John McCain adopting Bill Ayers as his campaign mascot. But the latter post in particular dealt with how "the Sixties" figures in the Republican/Christianist "culture war" narrative.

Below is the full text of a contemporary news report of the State Dept. bombing, "Weather Underground Strikes - Bomb Set Off At State Department" by Lance Gay and Brad Holt Washington Star-News 01/29/1975, as it appears in the official subcommittee report.

Several items stand out in looking at this news report now:

  • No one has ever seen Barack Obama engaging in, encouraging or in any way supporting a violent political action of this type. Just reading the article makes that clear to anyone whose brain hasn't been pickled in OxyContin.
  • The WU were technically good at the terrorist tactic they used. As Gay and Holt report of the State Department bombing, "The building is one of the most closely guarded government buildings in the Nation's Capital."
  • No one was injured in the bombing. And it was clear that the WU did not intend to injure anyone. They phoned in a bomb warning before the blast was set to explode.
  • The WU had engaged in a series of bombings of the same type, all aimed at facilities they took to be symbols of bad acts of American imperialism.
  • The State Department bombing was specifically described as a protest against continuing aid to the governments of South Vietnam and Cambodia, which the WU claimed were violations of the Paris Peace Accords.
  • The WU's ideology was secular and political, not religious.
  • The active members of the WU were a small number, at most a few dozen. Gay and Holt report at the time that FBI "estimates that it consists of 20 to 30 persons".
After the fall of Saigon and Phnom Phen later in 1975, the WU rapidly dissolved into internal factional fights. Despite their sweeping revolutionary rhetoric, the Vietnam War was always their primary focus. As former WU member Brian Flanagan said in a 2003 documentary on the group, "I think that the Vietnam War made us all a little crazy." In that same documentary, the now-newly-infamous Bill Ayers says, "I think the war was what unified us. And when the war ended, it was hard to go on."

Weather Underground terrorist attack on State Dept. men's room, Jan. 1975

As I've said before, even though the Obama campaign understandably wants to avoid saying anything that could be "spun" as defending the WU and their actions, that doesn't get the media off the hook for failing to do elementary fact-checking. And I do think that it's wrong to falsely accuse people of killings, as the McCain robocall depicted above does. As Andrew O'Hehir writes in When terrorism was cool Salon 06/07/03, the only deaths caused by the WU were two of their own members, killed accidentally while assembling a bomb:

As misguided and counterproductive as the Weather Underground's activities may have been, after the townhouse bombing [1970] the group never again planned attacks against human beings. Their post-1970 bombings were symbolic in nature and happened at night when the buildings were empty. For all the vitriol heaped on the Weather Underground by other leftists - and especially by ex-leftist neocons like David Horowitz and Ronald Radosh - it never killed or injured anyone except its own members. (In this regard, it's striking that right-wingers routinely employ the excesses of Weatherman to paint the entire left as anti-American terrorist sympathizers, while the left is either too civil or too cowardly to use the hateful acts of Timothy McVeigh, Eric Rudolph and James Kopp to attack conservatives in general.) [my emphasis]
In 1975, Lance Gay and Brad Holt reported very straightforwardly that the WU at that point had claimed responsibility for seven bombings. "None of the previous explosions - one of which was in a washroom at the Capitol, and another in a restroom at the Pentagon - resulted in any injuries." Why can't the press today handle such basic fact-checking and background reporting?

Below is the text of the Gay/Holt article as it appears in the Subcommittee report, except that I've emphasized some passages in bold:

[From the Washington Star-News, Jan. 29, 1975]

WEATHER UNDERGROUND STRIKES—BOMB SET OFF AT STATE DEPARTMENT
(By Lance Gay and Brad Holt)

An explosion ripped through a third floor men's restroom at the State Department early today moments after callers here and in San Francisco claiming to represent the anti-war Weather Underground group said they had set bombs in government buildings to protest continued U.S. involvement in Indochina.

No one in the heavily guarded building was injured in the blast, which came at 12:56 a.m. today in a restroom next to the Sahelian Drought Emergency desk - the State Department office coordinating American relief aid to drought-stricken areas of the Sahara Desert.

The explosion tore through two adjoining bathrooms and ripped out parts of the ceiling, breaking water pipes and causing both heavy structural and water damage to the third floor and the two floors below which include the State Department's security offices.

About 19 minutes before the explosion, the Washington office of the Associated Press said it received a call telling the news agency that a "communique" had been left in a telephone booth near the AP office "Tonight we attack the AID (Agency for International Development) in the State Dept. Headquarters in Washington D.C. and the Defense Department in Oakland, California," the 12-page typed letter said. The AID offices are located on the third floor of the State Department complex at 23rd and C Streets NW.

The Washington Post said it also received a call about 12:35 a.m. from a female caller who claimed to be from the Weather Underground and who told the newspaper that a bomb had been placed in the west wing of the State Department. The newspaper contacted D.C. police, who then notified the State Department.

A guard assigned to the building said a District policeman came to the building about 12:50 a.m. "He told me there was a bomb and I picked up the phone to call my office and the bomb went off just then," said the officer, who asked not to be identified. The officer noted the exact time of the blast 12:56 a.m.

There were only a few employees of the department in the tightly secured building at the time and those in the operations division on the 7th floor of the structure said they did not know of the blast until they were told by guards. The building was not evacuated.

"We only heard reports of it, we didn't hear a thing up here," said an employee in the operations division shortly after D.C. police and firemen rushed to the building following the explosion.

"The floor of the third floor looks like a river," said one guard. "Some of the ceiling is down but none of the walls was blown down. The damage is pretty extensive in three rooms." Among the rooms damaged were the offices of AID's African Affairs Division.

District police cordoned off the building and brought in dogs to search for more explosives, but found none. Police also searched buildings at 1901 Pennsylvania Avenue NW and 1875 Connecticut Ave., NW, based on a tip they received, but found no explosives.

Early today, the FBI brought in sifting equipment and were combing through the wreckage to try to determine what kind of explosive device had been used. District bomb squad officers said today that they believe the explosion was caused by a dynamite bomb of perhaps as many as 10 sticks.

In San Francisco, another bomb threat telephoned to the AP prompted officials to cordon off the Armed Forces Induction Center in Oakland, but a search of the sprawling facility failed to turn up any explosive device.

The 12-page letter the AP picked up in a telephone booth near its downtown offices here linked the bombing at the State Department to President Ford's request yesterday for a total of $522 million in arms aid for Cambodia and South Vietnam. Insurgents in both countries have recently achieved a number of military victories and administration officials have warned Congress that South Vietnam will go under unless it is given additional aid.

The Weathermen's statement said the Ford request is a "deliberate and outright sabotage of the Paris Peace agreement" that was signed two years ago. "The U.S. government continues to wage war against Vietnam and Cambodia," the communique continued. "Unable to resolve the deepening economic crisis at home, the imperialists mobilize for further war."

State Department officials said they don't know how anyone could get into the building to plant such a device. The building is one of the most closely guarded government buildings in the Nation's Capital and visitors must have a building pass at all times to get by a guard located in the front lobby. The building was being guarded at three open entrances at the time of the blast.

The early morning bombing marked the seventh time in four years that someone claiming to be from the Weather Underground has claimed responsibility for a bomb blast. None of the previous explosions - one of which was in a washroom at the Capitol, and another in a restroom at the Pentagon - resulted in any injuries.

On March 1, 1971, a time bomb of between 15 and 20 pounds of dynamite, was detonated in a ground floor lavatory at the Capitol, causing minor damage. The Weather Underground claimed responsibility for that explosion and said the act was in retaliation for U.S. foreign policies.

The bomb in the Pentagon was set off May 19, 1972 in a fourth-floor women's restroom of the sprawling complex and again the Weather Underground claimed credit, saying the act was in response to continued U.S. bombing and mining of North Vietnam.

The other bombings the group has claimed credit for were:

  • The June 14, 1974 explosion at Gulf Oil's international headquarters in Pittsburgh, Pa., which damaged two floors of the 38-story building.
  • The Sept. 28, 1973 explosion that demolished four rooms at the International Telephone and Telegraph Corp.'s Latin American division offices in New York City.
  • The May 31, 1974 explosion in the California attorney general's office in Los
    Angeles that ripped off doors and tore holes in the office ceiling.
  • The August 1971 explosion and fire that gutted two California prison system
    offices.
The Weather Underground originally called itself the Weathermen and had its origins in a left-wing splinter group of the radical, but generally non-violent Students for a Democratic Society in the late 1960's. The Weathermen took their name from a 1965 Bob Dylan song "Subterranean Homesick Blues." which includes the verse "You don't need a weatherman to tell which way the wind blows."

The Weathermen officially split off from the SDS in 1969 after a sometimes bitter dispute within SDS over tactics. The group then went underground and the FBI - which has been unable to penetrate the group - estimates that it consists of 20 to 30 persons. One of the group's leaders is Bernardine Dohrn, a fugitive since 1970 who remains on the FBI's "10 Most Wanted" lists.

Meanwhile, in an unrelated incident, more than 1,100 employees of the New Executive Office building near the White House, yesterday were evacuated from the building following a bomb threat. The 10-story building was evacuated for an hour yesterday afternoon while officials searched it and failed to discover anything unusual.
Tags: , , ,

Friday, October 17, 2008

Four things that annoy me

Some things are such familiar parts of our political landscape these days that it's easy to forget how bad some of them are.

The Republican Party has internalized a cult-like definition of "patriotism" that means nothing more or less than "supports the Republican Party". Exhibit A, the White Princess:

Palin also made a point of mentioning that she loved to visit the "pro-America" areas of the country, of which North Carolina is one. No word on which states she views as unpatriotic. (To Avoid Being 'Depressed,' Palin Skimps on Campaign News by Juliet Eilperin, Washington Post The Trail blog 10/17/08)
I think all civilians should stop referring to the President as "Commander-in-Chief" unless they are specifically talking about the Constitutional role of the Executive: "The President shall be Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States, and of the Militia of the several States, when called into the actual Service of the United States", as the document itself says. As Glenn Greenwald spells it out, "under our Constitution and basic government design, people who aren't in the military don't have a 'Commander-in-Chief'."

How did we ever get to the point that we have to rely on comedians like David Letterman, John Stewart and Stephen Colbert to ask the tough, direct questions to candidates and political leaders on national TV? As Juan Cole puts it, "For laughs, you have to go to the candidates themselves." Could our national press be any more broken?

Speaking of the broken media, can reporters not do any fact-checking any more? I posted once before on Weather Underground veteran Bill Ayers and why I thought it was important to look at terrorism as realistically and unsentimentally as possible. And that goes for ideological sentiments that distort reality. Again, Juan Cole points out that in the recent discussions of Ayers, facts don't seem to have mattered to much of anyone:

There is reason to be skeptical about McCain's depiction of Ayers nowadays. Despite McCain's misquotation, did not say after 9/11 that he wished he had bombed more. He said he wished that the underground had done more to stop the Vietnam War, and he avers that he meant political action, not bombings. Ayers never was involved in killing anyone, contrary to the impression given by calling him a 'terrorist,' and erasing from the record all the regrets he has expressed about his involvement in violence. McCain also does not mention that charges were dropped against Ayers because the government itself engaged in misconduct with the COINTELPRO program. Ayers is now a respected professor of education who has been honored by and served on committees with prominent Republicans. [my emphasis]
If our "press corps" had the energy, incentive and ability to do a little work on these things, their readers might actually learn something. The COINTELPRO program conducted covert operations to disrupt radical groups, some but not all of which were engaging in violence. Like Abu Gonzales and Dick Cheney, the COINTELPRO people were known at times to regard the law as "quaint" and even acted as instigators of violence (provocateurs). It was a program of the kind that warms the hearts of the authoritarian-minded. But its disregard of the law wound up limiting its effectiveness in actually catching and prosecuting law-breakers.

I should add that some individual members of the Weather Underground did get involved with the Black Liberation Army (BLA) group that did kill people. One former WU member is serving a life sentence for being involved in a robbery with the BLA in which people were killed.

But Ayers was not one of them. As I said in the earlier post about him, It's bad enough that the guy, who has apparently lived as a perfectly law-abiding citizen for the last nearly three decades (however distasteful some of his current views may be to many) is being held up as a poster boy for Evil. The McCain-Palin campaign is also falsely accusing him of being an attempted murderer. The later was not just a matter of calling him a "terrorist" as Cole mentions. Palin has referred to him as "a domestic terrorist who tried to kill his own people" and linking that caricature of Ayers to Obama. Our "culture warriors" have long since stopped caring whether what they say is actually true. But the press ought to be a little more informative.

Tags: , , , ,

Wednesday, October 08, 2008

Bill Ayers

Bob Somerby on Tuesday took up the accusation that Obama once or twice talked to Bill Ayers, former Weather Underground (WU) member in his Daily Howler column of 10/07/08.

He makes the point that even if you think the Weather Underground were demons from Hail, Bill Ayers has long since become an active figure in establishment Chicago politcs. Somerby cites the following passages from Scott Shane's Obama and ’60s Bomber: A Look Into Crossed Paths New York Times 10/03/08:

Since earning a doctorate in education at Columbia in 1987, Mr. Ayers has been a professor of education at the University of Illinois at Chicago, the author or editor of 15 books, and an advocate of school reform.

“He’s done a lot of good in this city and nationally,” Mayor Richard M. Daley said in an interview this week, explaining that he has long consulted Mr. Ayers on school issues. Mr. Daley, whose father was Chicago’s mayor during the street violence accompanying the 1968 Democratic National Convention and the so-called Days of Rage the following year, said he saw the bombings of that time in the context of a polarized and turbulent era.

"This is 2008," Mr. Daley said. "People make mistakes. You judge a person by his whole life."
Joan Welch took up the issue in Ugly time Salon 10/06/08:

The McCain campaign may be going off a cliff. Sarah Palin hit a new low -- and that's hard for her -- when she smeared Barack Obama with his association with '60s radical Bill Ayers, by claiming that Obama sees America "as imperfect enough to work with a domestic terrorist who tried to kill his own people" -- as though Obama's concerns about American society led him to ally himself with terrorism. Break it down, folks, and that's what she's saying. Palin's got some syntax problems when she talks, so maybe she didn't mean it that way -- but I think she did. She's found slightly different ways to say the same thing two days in a row, even after multiple news organizations criticized her take on the Obama-Ayers connection.
Among other things, she points out that Obama was a child when the Weather Underground was bombing buildings. "Is Palin saying the Democratic nominee was a member of WeatherKids?" she asks.

But seeing the current film about the German Red Army Faction (RAF) and researching a bit about them for my post on the film, I'm reminded that the RAF's level of violence was really in a whole different league than the Weather Underground. The WU carried out some spectacular bombings, including one inside the Pentagon and one in the Capitol building. Plus they sprung LSD guru Timothy Leary from a low-security prison with no violence. They did not carry out kidnappings or assassinations, much less set of bombs in public places to deliberately kill and injure civilians, as the car bombers and suicide bombers so frequently do these days in the Middle East.

The only case in which a death may have been connected to the WU's actions was a bombing of the mathematics building at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, which has sometimes been linked to the WU, with what degree of credibility I don't know. A graduate student working at night in the building was killed.

So - not that any Democratic Party spokesman is going to make the point for fear of having it turned into a "gotcha" soundbite - Palin's statement calling Ayers "a domestic terrorist who tried to kill his own people" is also not true. It's bad enough that the guy, who has apparently lived as a perfectly respectable, law-abiding citizen for the last nearly three decades (however distasteful some of his current views may be to many) is being held up as a poster boy for Evil. The White Princess is also falsly accusing him of being an attempted murderer.

At the end of the film Der Baader-Meinhof Komplex, the Brigitte Mohnhaupt characters explains to her fellow RAF members in relation to their leaders who committed suicide in prison that they really had committed suicide, they weren't murdered as the RAF claimed, and tells them, you should look at them as something that they weren't. Which could also be the coda to the film.

It's a good guideline for the reality-based ín looking at terrorism. Let's look at the phenomenon and its practitioners for what they are, not just make up anything we find it comforable to think about them.

Previous related posts:

Terrorism, the old-fashioned kind 06/04/07

Was the antiwar movement against the Vietnam War counterproductive? 08/14/07

Remembering 1968: Ralf Fücks gives a Green view 05/14/08

"Der Baader-Meinhof Komplex" film 10/05/08

Tags: , , , , , ,