Showing posts with label brics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label brics. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 22, 2014

The new BRICS development bank: new challenge to the IMF/Washington Consensus

The BRICS countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) last week announced they were setting up a new development bank that would provide an alternative source to the IMF for development loans.

Joe Stiglitz discusses it in this Democracy Now! report, Nobel Economist Joseph Stiglitz Hails New BRICS Bank Challenging U.S.-Dominated World Bank & IMF 07/17/2014. Stiglitz says this "reflects a fundamental change in global economic and political power."



The YouTube summary of this reports says:

A group of five countries have launched their own development bank to challenge the U.S.-dominated World Bank and International Monetary Fund. Leaders from the so-called BRICS countries -- Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa -- unveiled the New Development Bank at a summit in the Brazilian city of Fortaleza. The bank will be headquartered in Shanghai. Together, BRICS countries account for 25 percent of global GDP and 40 percent of the world's population. To discuss this development, we are joined by Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz, a professor at Columbia University and the World Bank's former chief economist. "It's very important in many ways," Stiglitz says of the New Development Bank's founding. "This is adding to the flow of money that will go to finance infrastructure, adaptation to climate change -- all the needs that are so evident in the poorest countries. It [also] reflects a fundamental change in global economic and political power. The BRICS countries today are richer than the advanced countries were when the World Bank and the IMF were founded. We're in a different world -- but the old institutions haven't kept up."
Here are a couple of reports from The Real News.

Is the New BRICS Bank a Challenge to US Global Financial Power? 07/18/2014 features a debate between a heterodox economist and a more-or-less dogmatic left thinker:



Leo Panitch in that interview argues that the new BRICS efforts are just another variation on neoliberal economics. He cites the example of the Bank of the South, which in his description was made ineffective by Brazil's insistence on it being "a very conventional development bank."

Michael Hudson of the University of Missouri-Kansas City considers it far more significant. I didn't find Panitch's criticism convincing just because it isn't so clear to me. Hudson stresses the significance of the aspect of independence from US financial hegemony in the new BRICS effort. Panitch seems to be saying that because the BRICS isn't an anti-capitalist bloc of nations, it's not that significant. Hudson's stress on the independence aspect seems to me to be the better measure of the significance of this development.

Panitch even says demands at around 14:40 that Hudson not "try to turn Putin and his cronies into the vanguard of a new socialist society," which is not something Hudson or anyone else I know of is arguing about the BRICS and the new development bank. (See Stiglitz' discussion above.) I'm fond of utopian criticism when it's done right. But Panitch really seems to be arguing that if this is not some explicit and pure vision of whatever brand of socialism he favors, it has no real importance.

Actually, a break from the neoliberal international system on things like capital controls can be vital in enabling a country to pursue Keynesian, pro-labor policies, as we see in Argentina. And that is extremely important. That would presumably be especially so for anyone who wants to see a society that fits into the classical socialist vision, as Panitch seems to. But the truth is that some leftwing intellectuals have carved out niches for themselves as more-or-less permanent cranks to the point they can be entertaining but often falls into a lazy and sterile this-isn't-perfect-so-why-should-I-care type of analysis.

At just after 12:30, Hudson brings the conflict between Argentina and the Nixon-appointed zombie judge Thomas Griega into the conversation.

Here's another Real News video emphasizing the neoliberal practices that can be found among the BRICS, BRICS: Progressive Rhetoric, Neoliberal Practice 07/19/2014:



Mario Osava reports for Inter Press Service on the disappointment of some activists over the new bank in International Reform Activists Dissatisfied by BRICS Bank 07/22/2014:

The creation of BRICS' (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) own financial institutions was "a disappointment" for activists from the five countries, meeting in this northeastern Brazilian city after the group’s leaders concluded their sixth annual summit here.

The New Development Bank (NDB) and the Contingent Reserve Arrangement (CRA), launched Tuesday Jul. 15 at the summit in the northeastern Brazilian city of Fortaleza, represent progress "from United States unilateralism to multilateralism," said Graciela Rodriguez, of the Brazilian Network for the Integration of Peoples (REBRIP).
I'm more inclined initially to see this as a hopeful, progressive development in the world.

Time will tell. Time and the actual performance of the NDB and CRA.

Tags: ,

Monday, July 21, 2014

Argentina and the BRICS

Argentina was invited to the recent BRICS meeting that announced a new development bank, which is actually called the New Development Bank (NDB). As Fabiana Frayssinet notes in Argentina Once More on the Map, Invited by BRICS Inter Press Service 06/18/2014, this could mean that the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa) might have to be changed to "BRICSA, ABRICS or BRICAS, if Argentina is admitted."

The Buenos Aires Herald reports that Argentine President Cristina Fernández used the opportunity of the BRICS meetings to state her position in defiance of Nixon-appointed zombie judge Thomas Griesa that is trying to push Argentina into bankruptcy at the end of this month (Default by default 07/21/2014):

There her tone was not so much that Argentina would not pay as that Argentina had already paid (remitting the corresponding deposit to New York at the end of last month, which was immediately frozen by Manhattan judge Thomas Griesa) — she further argued that the existing 2005 and 2010 bond swaps favoured holdout creditors because even a starting 70 percent haircut would later permit them profits trebling the outlay on debt bought at junk bond levels of 10 percent. CFK also seemed to assume that there could be no default without one being declared by the government in question and she herself had no intention of taking such a step herself, ergo no chance of default. The substance of this speech hardly differed from her Flag Day declaration of a willingness to "pay 100 percent of bondholders," a pledge prompting the market optimism until recently, but the change of tone has prompted uncertainty.
There is another hearing before the Nixon zombie judge on July 22.

A Mexican economist uses the Argentine conflict with the Nixon zombie judge to illustrate the need for institutions like the NDB (reported by Mario Osava, International Reform Activists Dissatisfied by BRICS Bank Inter Press Service 07/22/2014):

“We want an international system that serves the majority, not just the seven most powerful countries (the Group of Seven),” that does not depend on the dollar and that has an international arbitration tribunal for financial controversies, said Oscar Ugarteche, an economics researcher at the National Autonomous University of Mexico.

"It is unacceptable that a district court judge in New York should put a country at risk," he told IPS, referring to the June ruling of the U.S. justice system in favour of holdouts ("vulture funds") in their dispute with Argentina, which could force another suspension of payments.

"We need international financial law," similar to existing trade law, and an end to the dominance of the dollar in exchange transactions, which enables serious injustice against nations and persons, like embargoes on payments and income in the United States, he said.

"Existing international institutions do not work," and the proof of this is that they have still not overcome the effects of the 2008 financial crisis, said the Mexican researcher.

Major powers like the United States and Japan have unsustainable debt and fiscal deficits, yet are not harassed by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), in contrast to the treatment meted out to less powerful nations, particularly in the developing South.
Tags: , , ,