Showing posts with label catfood commission. Show all posts
Showing posts with label catfood commission. Show all posts

Sunday, April 17, 2011

What happens when the deficit deal gets done? How much of Social Security will be left?


Simpson-Bowles policy for seniors: Let them eat catfood!
I've come across several good items warning that we need to watch out for the next budget deals that Obama actually strikes with the Republicans, the one that is probably coming over raising the debt ceiling next month.

The notion that Obama has to negotiate budget deals with the Republicans over the debt ceiling is bogus. It's pure political theater. As Digby has been saying for months, if he negotiates over that it's because he wants to, not because he has to. Republican leaders know there's no choice but to raise the debt ceiling. Lots of the wealthiest Americans, the only constituency they truly care about, would lose serious money if the debt ceiling isn't extended on time. Obama does not have to deal with them over it.

But he's almost certainly going to. Gene Lyons uses sports analogies to discuss the debt limit fight in It's Time to Play Ball Cagle Post 04/14/2011. Gene thinks that Obama's budget deal from last week was a reasonable one for him to make, "the tactical equivalent of an intentional walk in baseball." In his reading, Obama preferred to stage a political confrontation with the Republicans' Ryan plan, proposed by "the Wisconsin Republican with the funeral director's demeanor and the zeal of an Ayn Rand enthusiast." He gives a great short summary of the Ryan proposal: "Reduced to a slogan, Ryan's ballyhooed plan is 'Back to the 19th Century': $4.5 trillion in tax cuts for millionaires and corporations, huge cuts in Social Security, Medicaid and food stamps, while privatizing Medicare."

But Gene is worried about what kind of ugly deals Obama will strike with the Ryan Republicans. He describes it on the explicit assumption that Obama is committed to the Democrats' own platform and campaign themes:

To the degree that it endorses Ryan's schemes, in a sane political climate the GOP would be risking political obsolescence. This was the same party that only a year ago pitched a fit over Sarah Palin’s imaginary "death panels." Now its leading thinker wants to control costs by asking grandma to bargain for cheaper heart surgery?

Standards, however, are anything but rational. The president faces a defining challenge. I often wonder whether Obama has mistaken the U.S. government for the Harvard Law Review, where the emollient balm of his personality persuaded rival factions to reason together.

Ivy League intellectual that he is, I’m afraid he definitely underestimates public ignorance on everything relating to the budget: where the money comes from, where it goes, and what’s at stake in the coming showdown over the U.S. government debt limit. It’s hard for somebody as obsessed with public policy as Obama to grasp how little his countrymen know.
Noting that trying to put the federal government into default is a non-starter even for the Teapartyized Republicans, he worries about Obama's willingness to act on that understanding:

Congress can repeal Medicare and Social Security, but it can't renounce their lawful debts. Ordinarily, an establishment Republican like John Boehner would refrain from even bluffing about the idea, which he dare not follow through.

Obama's seeming passivity, however, has made the GOP reckless.

Batter up. [my emphasis]
Robert Borosage of the Institute for America's Future observes in Obama's Deficits: Progressive Priorities, Conservative Context Huffington Post 04/13/2011 that Obama's Wednesday speech included some excellent statements of Democratic principles and vision of government. But he articulated them in a context in which he accepts the Republican framing and the economically destructive idea that cutting public spending is a good idea when the economy is in a weak recovery and is also in what economists call a "liquidity trap" - big corporate savings but domestic demand to weak to induce them to invest:

But it is worth understanding just how conservative this debate has become -- and how far the president has retreated. The most progressive president since Johnson has now embraced a center-right agenda -- even before entering negotiations with the Republicans.

The president effectively announced the demise of a reborn Keynesian era that has expired before the economy revived. 25 million Americans are in need of full-time work. Home values are still sinking; gas prices are at $4 a gallon and rising. Consumer confidence is plummeting. Europe's growth is slowing. But the federal government will join the states and cities in immediately cutting spending and laying off workers.

With this premature embrace of austerity, mass unemployment may become the new normal. Wages will remain stagnant. The concentration of wealth will grow and the middle class will continue to decline.

The president allowed that he was "sympathetic" to the view that we shouldn't cut spending until the economy is fully recovered. But he embraced the conservative argument that "doing nothing on the deficit is just not an option," because we could do "real damage to the economy" if we don't "begin a process now."

But mass unemployment and stagnant wages represent "real damage to the economy" that is here and now, not speculative. There's no sign of the potential harm that might be caused by deficits in the sometime future. Interest rates are low; America has no trouble financing its debt. The president started down this path prematurely in 2009; now he has forced the pace. [my emphasis]
Focusing on cutting deficits now is just Herbert Hoover economics. No better result can reasonably be expected from it in 2011 than in 1932.

And, from the Center on Budget and Priorities, Robert Greenstein on President Obama's Deficit-Reduction Plan 04/13/2011, another warning on the likely results of Obama-style budget negotiations:

Another significant concern stems from the President’s proposal to limit the annual growth in Medicare costs per beneficiary to the per capita rate of growth in the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) plus only 0.5 percentage points and to require automatic cuts in Medicare if this target would otherwise be exceeded. This goal is laudable. But it may be unrealistic. Historically, Medicare costs per beneficiary have risen about 2 percentage points per year faster than GDP growth per capita. The health reform law will launch a series of demonstrations, pilots, and research projects to find effective ways to slow health care cost growth without reducing the quality of care or access to care. But we don’t know yet how much or how quickly we can lower health care cost growth, especially since the principal driver in cost growth is medical advances that improve health and save and prolong lives but add significant costs.

Finally, the President’s plan calls for a mechanism to trigger automatic reductions in programs and tax expenditures if the debt would exceed certain benchmarks (measured as a share of GDP). The goal of stabilizing the debt as a share of GDP is precisely the right one. But all triggers like this that have been designed in the past have suffered from a fatal flaw — they required the deepest budget cuts when the economy was weakest and the smallest cuts when it was strongest — the opposite of what sound economic policy entails. The President’s plan calls for the trigger to "include a mechanism to ensure that it does not exacerbate an economic downturn." No one has succeeded until now in producing a mechanism that meets this test, and it remains unclear whether it can be done. This new proposal bears some similarities to the trigger in the 1985 Gramm-Rudman-Hollings law, which was not successful and which Congress ultimately repealed.

To be sure, the President's plan represents an important step forward in the debate. But it should be recognized that this plan is a rather conservative one, significantly to the right of the Rivlin-Domenici plan. While we worry about some particular elements of the President’s plan, we worry much more that the deficit-reduction process that’s now starting could produce an outcome that is well to the right of the already centrist-to-moderately-conservative Obama proposal, by reducing its relatively modest revenue increases and cutting more deeply into effective programs that are vital to millions of Americans. [my emphasis]
Then there's this: Alexander Bolton, Some Senate Dems willing to consider Social Security reforms The Hill 04/13/11:

Sens. Tom Carper (D-Del.) and Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) and Sen.Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.), who caucuses with the Democrats, are all openly calling for reform, and making it plain that the party is disunited on the issue when a titanic debate over debt is gathering momentum.
The good news is that Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid continues to be a hardliner on the issue, at least in public:

But Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) refuses to give an inch on benefit cuts, arguing that the program has not contributed “one penny” to the debt.
There is currently a "Gang of Six" Senators working on a bipartisan budget proposal: Democrats Dick Durbin, Kent Conrad and Mark Warner, along with Republicans Saxby Chambliss, Tom Coburn and Mike Crapo. According to this report by Richard Wolf, 'Gang of Six' hopes to spur bipartisan action on deficit USA Today 04/11/2011.

The Gang of Six approach is based on Obama's commission, which called for a mix of spending cuts and tax increases. Obama never endorsed the plan, and his proposed 2012 budget called for only $1.1 trillion in deficit reduction over 10 years. But White House press secretary Jay Carney said the president knows much more is required.
That would be the Simpson-Bowles Catfood Commission, whose main focus was how to start the phaseout of Social Security. Wolf follows the now-standard journalistic convention of referring to the "plan" of the Catfood Commission, the actions which it "called for," etc. The Catfood Commission never issued a formal report, because not enough of the members could agree that old people should have to live on catfood. But apparently, since Obama appointed it stacked with Social Security opponents to provide those recommendations, our press corps has just decided to play along and pretend they did. Co-chairs and social Security opponents Alan Simpson and Erskine Bowles did issue a plan, which is typically what is referred to by the Commission's plan or report. I guess this just illustrates how phony the whole bipartisan Kabuki with the Catfood Commission really was. It's purpose was to recommend Social Security Phaseout, so it's now Beltway consensus that they recommended that. Even though formally, the Commission didn't recommend anything at all.

Joan McCarter writes in disgust (Durbin, Lieberman, willing to 'take action' on Social Security Daily Kos 04/13/2011):

It's hard to imagine why any Democrat ... finds they are in agreement with Joe Lieberman, whose sole purpose in political life is now to piss on anything remotely progressive or important to the Democratic base, particularly on something as important as Social Security.
She relates "Gang of Six" member Dick Durbin's expressed willingness to include discussions on Social Security in deficit-reduction consideration, even though Social Security doesn't contribute to the federal deficit. In Harry Reid 2010 Netroots Nation convention appearance in Las Vegas, he said that he got Dick Durbin appointed to the Catfood Commission to defend Social Security! But Democratic activists have been particularly skeptical of Durbin since he made this statement, as reported by Obama Tells Debt Commission 'Everything Has to Be on the Table' New York Times 04/27/2010:

Representative Dave Camp of Michigan took pre-emptive aim at a value-added tax, saying, "Washington has borrowed enough from the American people."

But Senator Richard J. Durbin of Illinois, the second-ranking Senate Democratic leader, denounced suggestions of an administration VAT plan as the "musings of right-wing cable shows."

He also admonished "bleeding heart liberals" to be open to program reductions to restore fiscal balance. An hour after the commission’s meeting, however, several liberal activists held a conference call with reporters to press for additional spending to create jobs, lower military spending, higher taxes for the wealthy and no cuts in Medicare or Social Security. [my emphasis]
That was Obama a year ago this month, when he still had a solid majority of Democrats in the House. That article is a good reminder of how the Obama White House has always seen the deficit issue and the work of the Catfood Commission. It even contained a hint that if the Commission didn't agree on a report, the White House would pretend they had anyway. In ObamaSpeak, "everything has to be on the table" means Social Security Phaseout:

President Obama told his bipartisan debt commission on Tuesday that "everything has to be on the table," while the Federal Reserve chairman, Ben S. Bernanke, suggested overhauling the nation’s tax code to raise more revenue. ...

Former Senator Alan K. Simpson of Wyoming, the panel's Republican co-chairman, warned the panel, "The extreme right and the extreme left will savage our final product."

That assumes, however, that the commission will agree to one before its Dec. 1 deadline. Expectations are low given the party polarization, especially in an election year.

Still, administration officials have suggested that should the commission reach a deadlock, Mr. Obama could adopt proposals left on the table.

While Fed chairmen typically stick to monetary policy and shy away from advising elected officials about budget policy, Mr. Bernanke's remarks were the latest in his recent string of calls for elected officials to make "hard choices" soon, before debt threatens the economy’s recovery and growth.

"Choices regarding Medicare, Social Security and other spending programs cannot be made in a vacuum but must be combined with decisions about how much revenue the government will raise and how it will raise it," he said. [my emphasis]
Dean Baker's analysis of the Simpson's and Bowles' recommendations remains relevant, unfortunately: The Deficit Commission’s Parallel Universe Boston Review 11/11/2010:

The country in which most people live is experiencing an economic disaster. More than 25 million people are unemployed, underemployed, or have given up looking for work altogether. Tens of millions are now underwater on their mortgages, with millions facing the imminent loss of their homes. Furthermore, there is little prospect that the situation will improve anytime soon.

Many fewer live in the other America, the world of Wall Street and Washington lobbyists. This is where you’ll find former Wyoming Republican Senator Alan Simpson and investment banker-turned-Clinton Chief of Staff Erskine Bowles, the co-chairs of President Obama’s deficit commission, which on Wednesday outlined its plans for what it calls “fiscal responsibility.” In their world the key fact is that, today, corporate profits are back to their pre-recession peaks. As long as the bonuses on Wall Street are again hitting record highs, the economy must be just fine, so what else is there to do but worry about deficits?
Tags: , , , , , ,

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Waiting for Wednesday's deficit speech

The White House has been putting out two distinctly different story lines on what to expect from Obama's deficit speech Wednesday. Sunday and Monday, the story was that Obama would go for cuts in Medicare and Medicaid and maybe Social Security. Tuesday a competing story line was pushed to friendly journalists that the President would come out in strong defense of those programs.

A story by Tim Fernholz from Tuesday evening (10:00 PM EDT) in The National Journal, Bowled Over: Why is Obama Embracing Simpson-Bowles Now? 04/12/2011 goes with a version that says that Obama will embrace the approach of the Simpson-Bowles Catfood Commission, whose main notable recommendation was (blather aside) the phaseout of the Social Security program:

The White House's studied distance from the Bowles-Simpson report, named after the commission's cochairmen, led Republicans and some Democrats to complain that the president wasn't leading on fiscal reform.
In a side of the sloppy reporting so sadly common in respectable publications these days, journalists commonly refer to a report from the Catfood Commission. It didn't actually issue a formal report. They couldn't get the required votes. So the co-chairs released their own recommendations, which is what is normally referred to when sloppy reporters talk about the Catfood Commission's report. Fernholz technically get it right in that quote. But he also refers to when the Catfood Commission "released its long-term plan last December"; and in the immediately continuing paragraph he refers to "the commission's proposals":

That will change on Wednesday, when Obama is expected to endorse some version of the commission's proposals as a template for a grand fiscal bargain.

Coming just two months after the release of his fiscal 2012 budget, which included none of his commission's proposals, the move is jarring. But White House aides say it makes sense: If Obama had introduced an ambitious plan, Republicans would have immediately tarred it as partisan and dismissed it as a legislative nonstarter.

But Democrats say House Republicans gave them a new opportunity to stake out the fiscal high ground when Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan, R-Wis., unveiled a sweeping plan that would drastically cut spending and overhaul the social safety net—yet would not significantly reduce the deficit over the next decade.

Obama administration officials say the Republican plan allows Democrats to establish themselves as fiscally responsible by embracing a bipartisan plan and characterizing the GOP approach as extreme. ...

... By contrast, Democrats hope their embrace of Bowles-Simpson — while then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif. deemed it “simply unacceptable” when first released, now-House Minority Leader Pelosi said it contains “many good suggestions” — will give them credibility as the party more interested in solving problems than fighting. [my emphasis]
This would be the scenario that Digby has been warning about for a while: setting up the Catfood Commission's (unofficial) Social Security Phaseout recommendation as the "moderate" approach.

I don't know why Democratic voters should accept the Party being "more interested in solving problems than fighting," when the chosen solutions are bad ones.

The Democrats' main political message right now, especially from Obama, is: At least we're not as bad as the Republicans!

When a Democratic President is unwilling to go to the wall fighting for Social Security and Medicare - that message has definitely ceased being a political program and has become a partisan racket. Democratic voters are not mainly concerned with whether Obama and the Congressional Republicans get praised by Beltway pundits. They are interested in seeing them deliver on their own professed programs. And they certainly expect the Democrats to defend Social Security.

Tags: , , ,

Thursday, December 02, 2010

The Villagers are convinced that Social Security Phaseout is a great thing

Michael Hirsh in his analysis 'An Adult Conversation' about Budgets National Journal 12/01/2010 put on display the Beltway Village's completely fatuous obsession with phasing out Social Security via bipartisan harmony, aka, Democrats caving to the Republicans. The Catfood Commission issued a report that hasn't gotten a majority vote, even though its membership was stacked by President Obama so that it leaned heavily to those who support Social Security Phaseout.

There's not a word in Hirsh's analysis about the devastation that Social Security Phaseout would cause. For that matter, he doesn't both to say that Social Security Phaseout is the whole point of the cynical exercise. Hirsh gets all tingly at the bipartisanship:

You could almost forget, sitting there, that those whom Alan Simpson called "the workers of the dark arts" -- the lobbyists, the interest groups, the ideologues -- were waiting to pounce just outside the hearing room, to end this bipartisan "adult conversation." It was all so civil and positive, as if two years of bitter ideological battles over the size and nature of government had never taken place. Even Rep. John Spratt, D-S.C., sat somewhat startled as Reps. Paul Ryan of Wisconsin and Jeb Hensarling of Texas, two leading [rightwing] House Republicans serving on the president's National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform -- better known as the deficit commission -- saluted Spratt as an honorable colleague who had moved the budget debate forward. "I wish you'd said it before," said Spratt, the soon-to-depart chairman of the budget committee, to laughter in the room. "We never did sit down and ... search for common ground."
The self-styled "adults" in the Village - who regard Little Tommy Friedman, Age 6, as a wise commentator - all know that God meant for old people to be sick and hungry and get by eating catfood and die early. So for them, gutting Social Security, the highly successful social insurance program without which most of the elderly in the US would be below the poverty level, is an indispensable sign of Seriousness (Village version).

Actually, that last quote from Spratt doesn't indicate a lot of bipartisanship went on. And the Catfood Commission member have failed to come up with anything close to a consensus. That in itself is a victory for Social Security supporters. But they've energized the zombie of Social Security Phaseout even in their failure. The next big test for the Obama Administration will be his State of the Union (SOTU) address in January. The Villagers expect him to be "adult" and offer those nice Republicans Social Security Phaseout in the SOTU in exchange for, well, none of the Republicans yelling out "You lie!" during the speech, or something equally substantial.

Hirsh spins out the Village fantasy on the issue:

Interviewed after unveiling of the commission’s final report – which called for $3.9 trillion in deficit cuts over ten years -- both liberal and conservative members described arriving at a couple of common realizations after eight months of study: one, of just how deep America's fiscal hole was; and two, just how central the issue had become to the concerns of average Americans worried about their children’s futures. "One thing we all learned on this commission is that the problem is much bigger than we thought," said Bruce Reed, the executive director. "Americans went through budget crises of their own over the past two years, and they want us to deal with ours." [my emphasis]
If our star pundits could read an opinion poll, they would know that the deficit is low on the list of public concerns. And that what concern is expressed is shallow.

Gene Lyons described the silliness of the analogy that Bruce Reed uses that - and why it's foolish for Obama and the Democrats to use such talk (Sure, the government is just like your family Salon 11/24/2010):

Democrats have been using this dreadfully misleading metaphor to showcase their "seriousness" to Washington media courtiers for years. Conservatives, of course, always use recessions to try to frighten people into cutting Scrooge McDuck's taxes. (Good times, too: The official rationale for the Bush tax cuts was it'd be imprudent to pay down the debt too fast.)

Remarkably, the public doesn't appear to be buying.

A week or so before Erskine and Simpson volunteered themselves to speak for a commission that hasn't yet voted, CBS News released a poll. What do Americans want the new Congress to focus upon next January? Fifty-six percent cited "economy/jobs." Second was "healthcare" at 14 percent. "Budget deficit/national debt" polled at 6 percent. If my e-mails are any indication, many of those are people who can't distinguish one from the other. [my emphasis]
Michael Hirsh, on the other hand, pats pro-Phaseout Democrats for caving to the Republicans in an "adult" manner on "entitlement reform", the Republicans term for Social Security Phaseout:

Accordingly, some political courage was in evidence. Some Democrats began to gingerly talk about touching their "third rail" -- entitlement reform -- while some Republicans talked about raising more tax revenues by reforming the tax code. "Every member of this commission gets it: This debt is like a cancer," co-chairman Erskine Bowles said afterwards. "There’s no turning back. ... Together I think we have started an adult conversation."
Maybe these "adult" Democrats can strike an "adult" compromise with the nice Republicans: we give you Social Security Phaseout, and you Republicans agree to eliminate the home mortgage interest deduction! Yeah, that will play well for the Democrats in 2012.

Even though the Catfood Commission hasn't even been able to issue a stock bipartisan report to be quickly forgotten, Hirsh sees hope that we can all come together to phase out Social Security. He declares that the Commission report that the Commission itself didn't even endorse passes the all-important Goldilocks test - both "the right" and "the left" criticize it!

Indeed, within hours of the meeting, the attacks began from both sides. Tamara Draut of Demos, a liberal think tank, called the commission members "out of touch" and said their plan "ignores the need for immediate public investments to spur job creation, relies too heavily on discretionary spending cuts, and slashes Social Security at a time when fewer Americans can count on a secure retirement." On the right, Anton Davies of George Mason University called the spending cuts "window dressings," arguing that the commission has proposed only "one-tenth of what we need to balance the budget."

Yet even outside the hearing room one does feel the slow gathering of a consensus, like wisps of humid air before a storm. Among the bellwethers in determining if that consensus ever gathers force will be Paul Ryan and Jeb Hensarling, both of whom withheld their final votes on the plan but made positive noises that clearly delighted Bowles and Simpson. "I believe this commission has been a success," said Ryan, echoing Bowles' sentiment that "it has helped us move this conversation more to the adult level." Hensarling actually suggested that he’d "like to see this plan come to the floor," albeit likely without his vote. [my emphasis]
In the Bizarro world of the Beltway Village, being criticized by "both sides" is a virtue in itself. here how it works:

Liberal: The sky is blue.

Conservative: No, the sky is yellow.

Pod Pundit: The great Maverick John McCain says the sky is green, and he's being attacked "from both sides." This shows the Maverick's greatness and seriousness, being willing to reach across the aisle and deal with both sides. And he's proposed a reasonable compromise to have Congress officially declare the color of the sky an open question but to condemn calling the sky blue as dishonoring our troops. What a Maverick!

Tags: ,

Tuesday, November 02, 2010

News from the Catfood Commission

David Dayen in Cat Food Commission Will Get Busy After Elections FDL News Desk 11/02/2010 interprets the tea leaves offered in this article about the work of the President's Catfood Commission (officially named the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform), which is heavily stacked with let-Grandma-eat-catfood advocates who want to phase out Jacki Calmes, Social Security: Debt Panel Pauses Until After Elections New York Times 11/01/2010.

Despite the hype about the alleged vital need to reduce the deficit - something Republicans care absolutely nothing about and neither should the Democrats at this point - the Catfood Commission has always been about Social Security Phaseout. And Calmes' article confirms this is still its main focus:

While Mr. Bowles and Mr. Simpson will propose health policy changes for the commission’s deliberations, Social Security is getting more of the members’ attention. Republicans are more inclined to scale back future retirees’ benefits than are Democrats, especially since liberal groups have mobilized in opposition. Especially controversial is the idea of raising the retirement age for full benefits; currently it is being increased gradually to 67 under a 1983 law.

Other options include less generous formulas for both initial benefits and annual cost-of-living increases for retirees in future decades. Democrats say any compromise to assure Social Security’s solvency for the next 75 years would have to include increased payroll tax revenues as well as changes in benefits. The likeliest revenue option would raise the cap on wages subject to payroll taxes, now $106,800.

Both sides agree that they cannot make enough cuts in all other federal spending — the “discretionary” spending that Congress decides annually — to make a big dent in projected deficits. That category is smaller than entitlement programs as a share of the federal budget, is growing more slowly and yet covers the full range of government operations from education to warfare.
This is about phasing out Social Security. A bad, bad, extremely bad policy idea. And won that is virtually certain to be a disaster for the Democratic Party if President Obama embraces Social Security Phaseout. And it's his commission, his appointees. Congress declined to set it up, but Obama proceeded to do so by Presidential action.

Tags: ,

Monday, September 27, 2010

Obama, deficits and Social Security Phaseout

Digby gives a concise explanation on why it's politically useless for Democrats to try to posture around their deficit-reduction cred in It Will Always Be On The Table Hullabaloo 09/27/2010. (Policy-wise it's also very bad, and that is a related though not identical question.)

There's no doubt that he's correct. But I would caution that if he thinks he will be rewarded for being serious about balancing the budget he needs to think again. The Democrats thought they had banished the "big spender" label for all time when Clinton not only balanced the budget but created a surplus. The thinking was that nobody could ever say again that the Democrats were irresponsible stewards of the economy and they could finally "take that off the table."

I think it's fairly clear that didn't work out the way they planned it. The Republicans have a neat trick of running up huge debt and creating economic crises when they are in office and then vilifying the Democrats for what they have to do to clean up the mess.Once it's done they come back into power and pass out all the goodies to their rich friends. It's a clear pattern. There's no "taking it off the table."

As long as this pattern holds, Democrats will always be on the defensive, stuck with the dirty work and never being able to reap the electoral rewards for doing it. So they should probably just forget trying to earnestly prove to America that they really are the "responsible" party and concentrate on delivering peace and prosperity. I have a sneaking suspicion that's what people really care about. [my emphasis]
One of the reasons that Obama has been beating the deficit drum is that he stacked his Fiscal Catfood Commission to recommend cuts in Social Security. Those are entirely unnecessary, so to justify those, he will have to pretend that not only is the deficit a huge problem (which it isn't) and that Social Security is a major contributor to the deficit (which it isn't).

If Obama and the Congressional Democrats embrace the Catfood Commission recommendations - it's hard to imagine those won't include major cuts in Social Security - they won't call it Social Security Phaseout, of course. They will give it an Orwellian name like Social Security Salvation and Expansion Initiative. But a phase-out is what it will be.

In roughly 10 years, we've seen Social Security Phaseout go from being a subject both Republicans and Democrats tiptoed around carefully, to the point where the Republicans are eager to embrace it (with an Orwellian branding label) and a Democratic President has appointed a Catfood Commission stacked to recommend it.

In 2005, the Democrats actually managed to take an all-too-infrequent stand in straight-up defense of their own platform and their base in opposing Bush's Social Security Phaseout. And because no significant number of Dems in Congress would drink the Kool-Aid, the Republicans in Congress decided it was the better part of discretion to refrain from doing so themselves.

Once a Democratic President openly embraces Social Security Phaseout, the political firewall that has protected it from goofy ideologues and greedy Wall Street scamsters will be breached in a major way. And an actual phaseout of the program will be relatively quick to come.

And even some loyal Democratic voters may decide that Social Security would be safer under a Republican President because the Democrats in Congress would at least have to oppose phaseout like they did in 2005, out of sheer opportunism. If that is a legacy President Obama, leaves to the people and the Democratic Party, it will be a truly pitiful one.

Tags: , ,

Thursday, August 26, 2010

Catfood Commission for killing Social Security


Catfood Commission co-chairs Alan Simpson and Erskine Bowles: On a jihad against Social Security

The most consequential political event this year is likely to be, not the election or the enactment of health care reform, but the report of the President's Deficit Commission and how Congress responds to it. Liberal bloggers have appropriately labeled it the Catfood Commission, as in "let Grandma eat catfood."

Jane Hamsher describes how President Obama stacked the Commission for a heavy bias in favor of Social Security cuts in President Obama, It’s Time to Can the Catfood Commission Firedoglake 08/26/2010.

In January of 2010, a bill sponsored by committed Social Security slashers Judd Gregg and Kent Conrad which would have created an official Catfood Commission to make recommendations about the nation’s deficit was defeated by the Senate on a bipartisan vote — 22 Democrats and 24 Republicans voted no.

Undeterred, on February 18, President Obama issued an executive order creating a Catfood Commission anyway.

Unlike Bill Clinton’s Danforth Commission, which ended in deadlock, Obama set this commission up in such a way that it was stacked with deficit hawks who largely agreed on what needed to be done: 12 of the 18 members were to be appointed by Senate and House leaders in each party, and 6 would be appointed by the President. This virtually guaranteed that Social Security privatization fetishist Paul Ryan would be on the commission, as would Gregg and Conrad. [my emphasis]
No one should be fooled about what further raising the retirement age would mean. As Jane puts it, "raising the retirement age to 70 — resulting in a 20% benefit cut to Social Security recipients."

And if the deficit hawks win this round, they'll be going for even further cuts very soon. It won't be 27 years this time, the length of time since Reagan signed into law the changes raising the retirement age to 67.

Obama appointed the disgraceful Alan Simpson, a stereotypical mean old man, to be co-chairman of the Catfood Commission along with Erskine Bowles, another Social Security opponent. Brian Beutler at TPM gives us some background on Simpson's history of trying to destroy Social Security in Tit's A Big Deal: Alan Simpson's Long History Of Advocating Social Security Cuts 08/26/2010. This is what the miserable old Republican punk Simpson that Obama appointed to co-chair the Catfood Commission caught some criticism for saying about his fellow Americans:

Yes, I've made some plenty smart cracks about people on Social Security who milk it to the last degree. You know 'em too. It's the same with any system in America. We've reached a point now where it's like a milk cow with 310 million tits!
The Catfood Commission's report is due in early December, safely after the election. (Safely for politicians, not for most citizens.) And both Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi have agreed to give their recommendations an up-or-down vote during the lame-duck portion of this Congressional session after the November elections.

This is taking on all the looks of a massive system FAIL! The Beltway Village elite have adopted it as an article of faith that Social Security needs to be cut. It's a successful program that is vital to the country. But billionaires like Pete Peterson, a main leader of the jihad against Social Security, hate it. Before Social Security, being old for most people meant being poor. If Obama and the Democratic Congress - I can barely believe I've writing this - if Obama and the Democratic Congress succeed in cutting Social Security and opening the way to its near-term complete abolition, being old in the US will once again mean being poor.

The Village all thinks its necessary. Obama from all appearances thinks its necessary. Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi both signed off on a procedure to maximize the chances of this destructive idea being enacted into law this year.

I'm guessing that part of the calculation of trying to do this in a lame-duck session relates to the Progressive Caucus in the House. They took a firm stand on keeping the public option as part of the health care reform. It was their "red line," they claimed, without which they would oppose the bill. But when it came down to it, the Blue Dogs were more willing to remove that critical aspect of the reform. And enough House members who had pledged to never ever vote for the bill without the public option went along. The White House came down hard on the Progressive Caucus, not on the Blue Dogs, and the enough of the Caucus caved for Obama's deal with the insurance companies to win the day.

In other words, the White House knows that the Progressive Caucus in this Congress can be rolled. And I imagine that's part of the calculation of scheduling the Social Security phase-out vote during the lame-duck session. The Progressive Caucus in the next Congress may be less willing to cave on critical issues.

The vast majority of the public doesn't want Social Security cut. Poll numbers may change some when the Catfood Commission rolls out its recommendation and the White House and the Peterson Foundation put on an advertising and publicity blitz in favoring of the Social Security phase-out. They won't call it a "phase-out", of course. But this is an issue where the conventional wisdom of the political class and the CEOs and the tame pundits and kept reporters are advocating a policy that will drastically impact the lives of a majority of the country and in a bad way.

If the Democratic Party enacts this, the chances for progressive reforms on any front will be badly set back. Our system isn't amenable to third party solutions. But any Democratic Senator or Representative that votes to cut Social Security deserves to be voted out in their next primary in favor of candidates who will fight to roll back the Catfood Commission's destructive recommendations.

If Obama endorses a Social Security phase-out, not matter what the marketing brand-name, that will be his main legacy for the future. And it will be a sorry one.

Tags: ,