Showing posts with label chapo guzmán. Show all posts
Showing posts with label chapo guzmán. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 19, 2016

Sean Penn, El Chapo and the "war on drugs"

Eric Vance at The Last Word On Nothing harshes on Sean Penn for his article on El Chapo (No, Mr. Penn, That Is Not Why We Hate You 01/19/2016:

I am a journalist working in Mexico and I can guarantee you I’m not jealous that I didn’t get to interview Mexico’s most notorious criminal while hiding out in the mountains of Sinaloa. I wouldn’t want that interview. Put another way, There’s no way in hell, heaven, purgatory or anything in between that I would take that interview, even if it was offered.

It’s not that I’m scared – sitting next to Chapo Guzman is probably the safest place in the whole country. It’s that I’m not qualified and I know it. I’m a science writer – I write about fish and jungles and ancient temples. I wouldn’t want to interview the country’s most well-known druglord because I don’t have the perspective to do it right. Journalism requires a combination of experience and research being brought to bear on issues that affect society.

And when you go into an interview unprepared, especially with someone bringing their own agenda, you run the risk of getting “snowed.” Completely covered up under spin and misdirection and allowing the subject to control the interview because you don’t know the ways they can confuse the conversation. I’d get chewed up and spit out. Totally humiliated.

Which is exactly what happened to Mr. Penn. In fact, from interview to execution, his “article” was a lesson in how not to do journalism that should be taught in every j-school in the country. Reading his tome of self-indulgence, all I could feel for him was pity because he did such a bad job. And sadness at the loss of an opportunity.
He also criticizes Penn's article for devoting very little attention to what Penn says was his main goal, to highlight the disastrous nature of the "war on drugs."

In his report (El Chapo Speaks Rolling Stone 01/09/2016), Penn does write this:

What I didn't know, and what was not yet being reported, was that from the time the weather cleared, a military siege on Sinaloa was imminent. Evidently, El Chapo and his men, after leaving us the night before, had skirted through the jungle back to a ranch property. According to media reports that didn't come until days later, a cellphone among his crew had been tracked. From the time the military and the DEA moved in on them, the reports of what happened are conflicted. A source familiar with the cartel informed me on October 3rd that the initial siege had begun. That source and another on the ground in Sinaloa reported that over the next several days, two military helicopters were shot down and Mexican marine ground troops laid siege to several ranch properties. There were additional reports that 13 Sinaloa communities had been ravaged with gunfire during simultaneous raids. La Comision Nacional de los Derechos Humanos (the National Commission for Human Rights) struggled to enter the area but were prohibited. Villagers protested their treatment by the military. By the time news agencies broadcast the story in the United States, the mayhem throughout Sinaloa in those days had been essentially reduced to a nearly successful raid that had surgically targeted only Chapo and his men, and claimed he had been injured in flight with face and leg wounds. [my emphasis]
This figures mainly as a dramatic postscript to Penn's recently-completed visit with Chapo Guzmán. In such a long article, that doesn't amount to that much about the drug war. Even with this early paragraph sketches out a fairly vague questioning of the whole effort:

There is little dispute that the War on Drugs has failed: as many as 27,000 drug-related homicides in Mexico alone in a single year, and opiate addiction on the rise in the U.S. Working in the emergency and development field in Haiti, I have countless times been proposed theoretical solutions to that country's ailments by bureaucratic agencies unfamiliar with the culture and incongruities on the ground. Perhaps in the tunnel vision of our puritanical and prosecutorial culture that has designed the War on Drugs, we have similarly lost sight of practice, and given over our souls to theory. At an American taxpayer cost of $25 billion per year, this war's policies have significantly served to kill our children, drain our economies, overwhelm our cops and courts, pick our pockets, crowd our prisons and punch the clock. Another day's fight is lost. And lost with it, any possible vision of reform, or recognition of the proven benefits in so many other countries achieved through the regulated legalization of recreational drugs. [my emphasis]

Sunday, January 10, 2016

Chapo captured, the campaigning fugitives in Argentina

Sean Penn of all people did an interview with Sinaloan drug cartel boss "El Chapo" Guzmán before he was recaptured: El Chapo Speaks Rolling Stone 01/09/2016. It's an interesting read. But Senn makes it very clear that the conditions imposed by Guzmán meant that he was largely presenting his own version of his story with little if any probing questioning.

The interview was a joint project of Sean Penn's with the famous Mexican actress and producer Kate de Castillo. Kate starred in the film Under the Same Moon. She also played a drug "lordess" (I don't remember seeing that word before the Penn article) in the telenovelas La Reina del Sur and Dueños del Paraíso.

The three fugitives in Argentina that escaped from a high-security prison in Buenos Aires Province were briefly reported captured on Saturday. But the news turned out to be 2/3 premature (A victory turns into an embarrassing failure: two fugitives remain at large Buenos Aires Herald 01/10/2016):

The nearly two-week manhunt appeared to have finally come to an end in the afternoon, when several police and top politicians said authorities had arrested Víctor Schillaci and brothers Martín and Cristian Lanatta. The men escaped from the General Alvear prison in Buenos Aires province on December 27.

A couple of hours later, Security Minister Patricia Bullrich, confirmed that Martín Lanatta was the only one arrested and that he was on his way to Buenos Aires City.
The two brothers Lanatta had claimed that the Peronist candidate for BA Province Governor, Aníbal Fernández, had ordered the murders they had been convicted of committing. There was no proof offered other than their claim, which had never come up at trial. But the brothers appeared on television making the claim last year, which became a significant issue in the campaign.

This Guardian article gives background, although it was written based on the reports that all three fugitives had been captured, Fugitive killers recaptured after 13-day manhunt that gripped Argentina 01/09/2016:

The trio were convicted over the 2008 killing of three businessmen in the pharmaceutical industry who were allegedly linked to an ephedrine trafficking gang, in a high-profile case dubbed “the triple murder”. Ephedrine is used for the production of methamphetamine.

Their escape came two weeks after President Mauricio Macri took office. The daring prison break raised suspicions of outside help and a blame game erupted between Macri and officials in the government of the former president Cristina Fernández de Kirchner.

“Drug-trafficking has grown in the last decade like never before in our country because of the inaction or complicity of the last government,” Macri said this week, vowing to take on the traffickers.

In August, two months before the presidential election, Martín Lanatta alleged Fernández’s cabinet chief, Aníbal Fernández, was involved in the ephedrine trade and ordered the triple murder.

Aníbal Fernández has rigorously denied the accusation and prosecutors have not investigated the claim. The then ruling party said the allegation was designed to hurt its presidential candidates and derail Aníbal Fernández’s bid to become governor of Buenos Aires province.
Fernández posted this article on his Facebook page: Gabriela Cerruti, Las conexiones entre los prófugos, Cambiemos y Lanata-Wiñazki
10.01.2016; also in Conexiones entre prófugos, Lanata, Macri y Wiñazki Taringa! 10.01.2016 without the writer attributed. It reports that the one escapee really captured, Martín Lanatta, has apprehended at a property whose "dueña es Viviana Agusti, secretaria de gobierno de la Comuna de Cayastá, amiga de Nicolás Wiñazki, el periodista de Canal 13 que entrevistó a los hemanos Lanatta en el programa Periodismo Para todos" ("owner is Viviana Agusti, secretary of the government of the community of Cayastá, friend of Nicolás Wiñazki, the reporter from Canal 13 who interviewed the brothers Lanatta in the program Periodismo Para [T]odos"). ParaCiudad.com reports that part of the story in Martín Lanatta fue detenido en el campo de una amiga de Nicolás Wiñazki09.01.2016.

As Raúl Kollmann reports in Huyó, volcó y lo pescaron Página/12 10.01.2016, the latest cock-up in the case where the authorities reported all three captured but later only one was a continuing embarrassment for the national government of President Mauricio Macri:

El presidente Mauricio Macri y los más altos funcionarios del país y la provincia de Buenos Aires se felicitaron entre ellos por la captura de los tres prófugos, mientras el Ministerio de Seguridad le informaba al juez Sergio Torres de las tres capturas. Sin embargo, horas más tarde el jefe de la policía de Santa Fe y luego el de la Federal, Román Di Santo, tuvieron que rectificarse: “Hay un solo detenido”. El estupor recorrió la tarde y los funcionarios empezaron a mirarse entre ellos y a cruzar acusaciones.

[President Mauricio Macri and the highest functionaries of the country and the Province of Buenos Aires congratulated each other for the capture of the three fugitives, while the Miniter of Security informed the judge Sergio Torres of the three captures. Nevertheless, hours later the chief of police of Santa Fe and later that of the federal government, Román Di Santo, had to correct themselves: "The is only one person arrested." The astonishment recurred in the afternoon and the functionaires start point fingers at each other and exchange accusations.]
Kollmann also observes that the resources on which the three fugitives have drawn so far, while sufficient to keep them all three at large for 13 days, were not of a quantity and sophistication that might be expected of a narcotics operation like that of which they were alleged to be a part.