Showing posts with label communist party usa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label communist party usa. Show all posts

Thursday, August 24, 2017

The right builds its bogeyman of "violent leftists"

The discussion on political violence in the US has been particularly cramped for a long time. Not that it was ever as clear as one might have wished.

Ordinary statecraft involves the application of violence, particularly through the police, the national security agencies and the prison system. This is considered legitimate violence when done in accordance with established law. This is the "state monopoly on violence" that is used to mark the difference between functioning national governments and "failed states." André Munro calls it "the concept that the state alone has the right to use or authorize the use of physical force. It is widely regarded as a defining characteristic of the modern state." (State monopoly on violence Britannica Online; accessed 08/23/2017)

Use of the police power is a general attribute of modern states and is usually not seen as political violence. But since political decisions involving class and other group conflicts set the legal parameters of legitimacy, there is something political even about legitimate state violence. Black activists in the United States have often argued that many if not all black prisoners were in a real sense political prisoners because of the ways in which the political system has excluded them from substantive contribution to political decision-making and because of racially biased policing. But since not only Democrats or Republicans but presumably nearly all splinter parties in the US would be in favor of banning armed robbery, police coercion in arresting an armed robber is not commonly regarded as political violence.

Political violence in the usual sense of using violence of some kind to achieve partisan or policy goals has been some part of American life since the beginning. The American Revolution was certainly an act of political violence, as were the Whiskey Rebellion, slave revolts, the localized civil war in "Bleeding Kansas, John Brown's raid on Harper's Ferry, the Confederate rebellion. The resistance to Reconstruction democracy in the South commonly involved violence as did the post-Reconstruction segregationist Jim Crow regimes. Sometimes the violence was superficially legitimate in that it enforced discriminatory laws aimed at African-American citizens. Sometimes it was law enforcement acting with de facto approval from their superiors in taking illegal action. Organized terrorist groups like the Ku Klux Klan were certainly part of the violence, as were mobs incited by public officials like the one in the Ole Miss (University of Mississippi) riot over integration in 1963.

There was also plenty of violence applied against labor organizers over the years, certainly not all of it "legitimate." (FYI, that's meant to be an obvious understatement!)

Political Violence After the Second World War

Unofficial political violence in the US - violence not undertaken by organs of the state - has been largely a monopoly of the Radical Right for decades. Not entirely, of course. Urban riots in the 1960s, political in at least a general sense, were widely perceived as acts by black people on the left. Unlike the largest urban riot in American history, the New York Draft Riot of 1863 which manifested overt pro-slavery, pro-Confederate and anti-black racist aims.

And some organized lelft groups undertook violent actions with political motivations in the 1960s and 1970s, of which the Weather Underground, the Black Guerrilla Army and the bizarre Symbionese Liberation Army are some of the best know. The Black Panthers advocated "armed struggle," though in theory and largely in practice they emphasized their right to exercise defensive violence against abusive authorities. The Black Panther Party's 10-point program of 1966 included, "We believe we can end police brutality in our Black community by organizing Black self-defense groups that are dedicated to defending our Black community from racist police oppression and brutality. The Second Amendment to the Constitution of the United States gives a right to bear arms. We therefore believe that all Black people should arm themselves for self-defense."

Given the success of the firearms lobby in loosening gun laws in recent years and in enacting "stand-your-ground" laws that make it easier for people to legally get away with murder, and the way in which gun proliferation advocates emphatically argue that people in the US in the present day need to keep firearms to defend themselves against tyrannical government, it may seem weird that during the 1940s and 1950s, people associated with the American Communist Party were arrested, prosecuted, deported and imprisoned for advocating the overthrow of the US government by "force and violence."

Actually, the US Communist Party of that period, like the German Social Democratic Party supported by Karl Marx and Frederick Engels during their lifetimes, advocated taking power via electoral means with the determination to use legitimate government police power to suppress any attempt at a violent revolution against any such duly elected left government. A series of Supreme Court decisions related to such cases drew clear distinctions between talking about the violent overthrow of the government in the abstract and advocating and preparing for immediate action toward that end, including Schneiderman v. United States (1943), Yates v. United States (1957), and Noto v. United States (1961).

Do I even need to mention that the evidence against the defendants in those cases was far less serious than what the Bundy Ranch crowd did in 2014? (Julie Turkenwitz, No Guilty Verdicts in Bundy Ranch Standoff Trial New York Times 08/22/2017)

The question of political violence and "armed struggle" was heavily influenced in the 1960s by the dispute between the Soviet Union and China over the national liberation movements of the time. The Second World War was followed not only by the victory of Mao Zedong's Communists in China but massive decolonization in Asia and Africa. The independence movement in India and the successful violent revolt in Algeria against French control made a huge impression on European publics. The USSR and China had a major division in the late 1950s over various issues, not the least of them Mao's seeming indifference to the idea of a nuclear third world war. The two powers vied for influence among the emerging independent nations and among insurgent movements, with Vietnam being the most significant because of the US military intervention there.

One upshot of this was that Mao and his partisans insisted that "armed struggle" was always necessary to establish the goal of socialism, while the Soviets stressed that a "peaceful transition to socialism" was possible and desirable in many places. In Latin America, the example of Cuba and the advocacy by Che Guevara for "one, two, many Vietnams" had a great deal of influence. Juan Perón encouraged a broad-based political resistance in Argentina, which included but was by no means limited to sabotage and guerrilla resistance. On the radical left in Western countries, that larger world environment heavily influenced the way in which political conflict was discussed. So a lot of elaborate arguments over the role of violence in politics were elaborated on the left. And while Western conservatives tried to use law-and-order rhetoric and policies in response to domestic unrest and guerrilla violence in other countries, the center-left walked a line between supporting reform and decolonization, on the one hand, and opposing social violence, on the other. In the United States, the Democratic Party was particularly split over the American Cold War policy of active counterrevolution in Vietnam and elsewhere (Brazil, Chile, Argentina, the Dominican Republic, Indonesia, etc.)

The violent Radical Right in the US in Recent Decades

The Patriot Militia movement of the 1990s was a significant development on the violent right. The Oklahoma City bombing of 1995 dramatically demonstrated how deadly the Radical Right could be in the United States. Bill Clinton's speech commemorating the dead in that attack is widely considered one of his finest moments as President. He delivered a message that aimed at comforting the victims and their families but also sought to deligitimize the far right cause as destructive and godless and something that should be taken seriously (Remarks at a Memorial Service for the Bombing Victims in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 04/23/1995):

To all my fellow Americans beyond this hall, I say, one thing we owe those who have sacrificed is the duty to purge ourselves of the dark forces which gave rise to this evil. They are forces that threaten our common peace, our freedom, our way of life. Let us teach our children that the God of comfort is also the God of righteousness: Those who trouble their own house will inherit the wind. Justice will prevail.

Let us let our own children know that we will stand against the forces of fear. When there is talk of hatred, let us stand up and talk against it. When there is talk of violence, let us stand up and talk against it. In the face of death, let us honor life. As St. Paul admonished us, Let us "not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good."

Yesterday, Hillary and I had the privilege of speaking with some children of other federal employees -- children like those who were lost here. And one little girl said something we will never forget. She said, "We should all plant a tree in memory of the children." So this morning before we got on the plane to come here, at the White House, we planted that tree in honor of the children of Oklahoma. It was a dogwood with its wonderful spring flower and its deep, enduring roots. It embodies the lesson of the Psalms -- that the life of a good person is like a tree whose leaf does not wither.
Deborah Lauter and Mark Pitcavage recall the federal response in the following years in a 2015 retrospective (Homegrown extremist threat remains 20 years after Oklahoma City bombing CNN 04/19/2015):

The attack's aftermath saw a storm of media coverage with themes such as "attack on the heartland" and America's "lost innocence." In fact, the bombing took the country by surprise. It wasn't simply the scale of the tragedy that drew attention, but the fact that the bombing exposed something new: American citizens targeting their own government with a deadliness hitherto unseen.

The public became aware of the true danger of the extreme right. Reports connected McVeigh and his accomplice Terry Nichols to anti-government ideology movements, such as the militia movement, as well as to white supremacist causes.

Law enforcement also played catchup. The Federal Bureau of Investigation's 1994 annual report on terrorism had given short shrift to the extreme right. Its coverage of domestic terrorism focused on the activities of Puerto Rican radicals and animal rights and environmental extremists.

In contrast, the report spent only a paragraph describing the threat from right-wing extremists. It ignored the rapidly growing militia and sovereign citizen movements ...
When it comes to domestic terrorism, federal officials have too often been blind in the right eye.

After Oklahoma City, everything changed. The FBI shifted its priorities, hiring new agents and reassigning staff to work on domestic terrorism cases. It significantly expanded the number of Joint Terrorism Task Forces and went to Congress with a lengthy "want" list.

The effort actually paid off. Increased scrutiny of right-wing extremists resulted in a flurry of arrests for everything from terrorist plots to hate crimes. Though it had paid a high price to do so, it seemed that the United States had recognized the dangers that right-wing extremists posed.
Since the 9/11 attacks in 2001 and with the wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria, and Yemen, Muslim terrorism has become a bigger concern compared more secular ideological ones. But in the US, domestic far-right terrorists have been more responsible for more terror attacks than Muslim extremists since 2001. We should be careful about the distinctions we're making, though. Muslim extremist terrorist are generally hard right theocrats in their politics. And many American far-right groups are heavily influenced by radical right Christian ideas, often stemming in some way from the Christian Identity movement.

Daryl Johnson was with the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) when Obama became President. He was warning then about the growing danger of far-right terrorism, as he describes in I warned of right-wing violence in 2009. Republicans objected. I was right. Washington Post 08/21/2017:

Eight years ago, I warned of a singular threat — the resurgence of right-wing extremist activity and associated violence in the United States as a result of the 2008 presidential election, the financial crisis and the stock market crash. My intelligence report, meant only for law enforcement, was leaked by conservative media.

A political backlash ensued because of an objection to the label “right-wing extremism.” The report also rightly pointed out that returning military veterans may be targeted for recruitment by extremists. Republican lawmakers demanded then-Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano rescind my report. The American Legion formally requested an apology to veterans. Some in Congress called for me to be fired. Amid the turmoil, my warning went unheeded by Republicans and Democrats. Unfortunately, the Department of Homeland Security caved to the political pressure: Work related to violent right-wing extremism was halted. Law enforcement training also stopped. My unit was disbanded. And, one-by-one, my team of analysts left for other employment. By 2010, there were no intelligence analysts at DHS working domestic terrorism threats. [internal links from original not included]
Johnson also appeared in a Netroots Nation panel earlier this month which Dave Neiwert organized: The White Face of Domestic Terrorism: How Islamophobia Distorts the Reality of Terrorist Violence in America 08/12/2017 (scroll down to locate at the link). He expands on the subject and recent developments in that talk. As it happened, this panel started a few minutes after the news broke about the fatal attack that killed Heather Heyer in Charlottesville.

Both Sides Do It?

With Trump and his loyal followers now holding up the "antifa" protesters as justification for far right violence, it was inevitable that we would start to see more media coverage of them. "Antifa" is a word taken from German, a short form of "anti-fascist." German and Austrian protesters against the far right have been known by that name for years. The name is used as a generic term. It's not a reference to any party or any particular political program or ideology other than activist opposition to the far right. Though Trump in his Phoenix campaign speech Tuesday used it in a way that may soon become another Republican cuss word for Mean Libruls. Cenk Uygur notes just after 3:20 that Trump used "An-TI-fa" as a carnival barker type call (Trumpamania Running Wild In Phoenix, Brotherrr! The Young Turks 08/23/2017):



Michael Shure and Nomiki Konst in that segment also note that Trump's supporters listening to the speech were probably not familiar with the term "antifa" yet. Which is why it could now morph into another Republican version of Mean Libruls.

Before we get into Republican and liberal-concern-troll versions, it's worth taking a look at Dahlia Lithwick's column in which she quotes participants in the pro-democracy counter-protests in Charlottesville describing how some protesters defended others from attacks by the white supremacist/KKK/Nazi goons, Yes, What About the “Alt-Left”? Slate 08/16/2017. One Charlottesville resident relates:

I stood with a group of interfaith clergy and other people of faith in a nonviolent direct action meant to keep the white nationalists from entering the park to their hate rally. We had far fewer people holding the line than we had hoped for, and frankly, it wasn’t enough. No police officers in sight (that I could see from where I stood), and we were prepared to be beaten to a bloody pulp to show that while the state permitted white nationalists to rally in hate, in the many names of God, we did not. But we didn’t have to because the anarchists and anti-fascists got to them before they could get to us. I’ve never felt more grateful and more ashamed at the same time. The antifa were like angels to me in that moment.
A minister gives this description:

Out of my faith calling, I feel led to pursue disciplined, nonviolent direct action and witness. I helped lead a group of clergy who were trained and committed to the same work: to hold space on the frontline of the park where the rally was to be held. And then some of us tried to take the steps to one of the entrances. God is not OK with white supremacy, and God is on the side of all those it tries to dehumanize. We feel a responsibility to visibly, bodily show our solidarity with the oppressed and marginalized.

A phalanx of neo-Nazis shoved right through our human wall with 3-foot-wide wooden shields, screaming and spitting homophobic slurs and obscenities at us. It was then that antifa stepped in to thwart them. They have their tools to achieve their purposes, and they are not ones I will personally use, but let me stress that our purposes were the same: block this violent tide and do not let it take the pedestal.

The white supremacists did not blink at violently plowing right through clergy, all of us dressed in full clerical garb. White supremacy is violence. I didn’t see any racial justice protesters with weapons; as for antifa, anything they brought I would only categorize as community defense tools and nothing more. Pretty much everyone I talk to agrees—including most clergy. My strong stance is that the weapon is and was white supremacy, and the white supremacists intentionally brought weapons to instigate violence.
It's helpful to look at accounts like these of the particulars in the protest events. They involve specific decisions about risks and assessments of danger in a given moment. Organizers have a responsibility to be clear with participants about known risks, especially in cases like those the minister describes in which violence against the participants is anticipated. The same is true of "antifa" groups who plan to defend other protesters against violence from armed militants. That risks includes the reality that police and prosecutors often are "blind in the right eye" in such situations and may accuse them of crimes for even purely defensive actions.

It's important to remember that there's nothing wrong with protecting someone against acts of violence. And there's nothing wrong with defending oneself from a violent attack. The kind of Ghandian militant pacifist resistance described by the minister is a particular kind of strategy in given situations. Taking such an approach may not involve a purely pacifist outlook. And even the few people who are genuine pacifists would generally not consider personal self-defense in the face of a violent attack to be wrong in all circumstances.

It's also a well-established tradition on the center-left to take any and all opportunities to distinguish themselves from the dirty hippies who actually organize and demonstrate for progressive causes and against reactionary ones. Good liberals are supposed to be polite and not ruffle too many feathers. It was such liberals that Martin Luther King, Jr. addressed in his Letter From Birmingham Jail.

Which brings us to Peter Beinart's The Rise of the Violent Left The Atlantic Sept 2017; accessed 08/23/2017:

Those responses sometimes spill blood. Since antifa is heavily composed of anarchists, its activists place little faith in the state, which they consider complicit in fascism and racism. They prefer direct action: They pressure venues to deny white supremacists space to meet. They pressure employers to fire them and landlords to evict them. And when people they deem racists and fascists manage to assemble, antifa’s partisans try to break up their gatherings, including by force.

Such tactics have elicited substantial support from the mainstream left. When the masked antifa activist was filmed assaulting Spencer on Inauguration Day, another piece in The Nation described his punch as an act of “kinetic beauty.” Slate ran an approving article about a humorous piano ballad that glorified the assault. Twitter was inundated with viral versions of the video set to different songs, prompting the former Obama speechwriter Jon Favreau to tweet, “I don’t care how many different songs you set Richard Spencer being punched to, I’ll laugh at every one.”

The violence is not directed only at avowed racists like Spencer: In June of last year, demonstrators—at least some of whom were associated with antifa—punched and threw eggs at people exiting a Trump rally in San Jose, California. An article in It’s Going Down celebrated the “righteous beatings.”
Yes, even-the-liberal Peter Beinart agrees with Trump that "antifa" is a danger to good Christian white folks!

Anarchists are know for being an unruly bunch, though stereotyping them as particularly inclined to violence would be unrealistic and unfair. And the press is known for carelessly labeling people "anarchists" who may not identify themselves that way at all. That said, I've never had a particularly high regard for the group (or groups) of anarchists who show up in the San Francisco Bay Area to protests wearing black masks and displaying a penchant for fighting, throwing rocks through windows and minor arson. As I recall, I first noticed them in Oakland during some protest during the oughts. They didn't seem to have any distinct or coherent message. And one of my first thoughts was, masked people who show up out of nowhere to commit vandalism during protests: a perfect vehicle for official and unofficial provocateurs. A group like that strikes me an extremely likely target for police or homeland security agents seeking to entrap people in "terrorist" plots.

But nothing is safer for pundits and liberal concern-trolls than "both sides do it!" And Beinart happily goes there:

A similar cycle has played out at UC Berkeley. In February, masked antifascists broke store windows and hurled Molotov cocktails and rocks at police during a rally against the planned speech by Yiannopoulos. After the university canceled the speech out of what it called “concern for public safety,” white nationalists announced a “March on Berkeley” in support of “free speech.” At that rally, a 41-year-old man named Kyle Chapman, who was wearing a baseball helmet, ski goggles, shin guards, and a mask, smashed an antifa activist over the head with a wooden post. Suddenly, Trump supporters had a viral video of their own. A far-right crowdfunding site soon raised more than $80,000 for Chapman’s legal defense. (In January, the same site had offered a substantial reward for the identity of the antifascist who had punched Spencer.) A politicized fight culture is emerging, fueled by cheerleaders on both sides. [my emphasis]
Yes, who can argue with that? On one side, we have white supremacist militants being actively encouraged and incited by the President of the United States. On the other, there are some masked anarchists with zero actual political influence. Both Sides Do It!

I won't try to fact-check all the claims in Beinart's piece. I'll just note here that he doesn't always make it clear just who is doing the violence in incidents for which he blames antifa.

I don't want to encourage people to break windows just for the heck of it. But it's probably time to recall the discussion in "the Sixties" in the US and Germany and presumably other places as well about the difference between "violence against things" and "violence against people." Yes, it's very rude, against the law and probably unnecessary in nearly all cases to toss a rock through the window of a Walgreens. But neither the law nor any sane system of values considers breaking a store window as morally or practically equivalent to deliberately ramming a group of people with a car. The latter, we should note, being a practice that Republicans in several state legislatures are attempting to decriminalize.

The editorial board of the Wall Street Journal got into the act earlier in August with A Berkeley ‘Escape Hatch’ 08/09/2017 with a snotty editorial about UC-Berkeley not taking a more law-and-order approach toward protesters. That was one of St. Reagan's favorite themes in his successful first campaign for California Governor in 1966.

Michelle Goldberg takes a more sober approach to reporting on what the antifa movement is all about The Public Face of Antifa Slate 08/22/2017:

After the riot in Charlottesville ... antifa is suddenly making headlines. The term antifa refers to a loose network of militant left-wing activists who physically square off against the far right, and often try to prevent those they deem fascists from speaking publicly. Antifa is sometimes used as a synonym for black bloc anarchists — the scruffy kids in black bandanas or balaclavas known for smashing Starbucks windows — but while the movements overlap, they’re not identical. ... The movement appears to be growing rapidly under Trump, though it’s impossible to put hard numbers to it; there are no membership rolls.
Michelle's article is a good overview that tries to deal seriously with the practical situation presented by aggressive white supremacist demonstrations. I'm impressed that she avoids any kind of simplistic "both sides do it" false equivalence. She's not doing the kind of liberal concern-troll criticism that Peter Beinart presents.

Speaking of which, Adam Johnson has a report on how Centrist Pundits Paved Way for Trump’s ‘Alt-Left’ False Equivalence FAIR 08/16/2017

In a pre-Charlottesville piece, Cecilia Saixue Watt reports on a small armed left group without getting mired in both-sides-do-it cliches, The Redneck Revolt: the armed leftwing group that wants to stamp out fascism Guardian 07/11/2017.

Tuesday, July 18, 2017

The drama of documentary evidence, Trump-Russia edition

The stories of the Trump campaign's apparently myriad contacts with Russians has me thinking more about what kind of contacts cross the line of propriety.

One good guideline in thinking about it is that if it's illegal, that means it's officially improper.

Most contact between Americans and non-Americans are perfectly legal. From business deals to personal contacts to hearing presentations made by foreign officials to sports competitions to attending shows by foreign celebrities to being a tourist in another country, most of it is far from being illegal or improper in any meaningful sense. Fiona Hill, the top Russia adviser on the National Security Council, who I've quoted here recently, has dual UK-US citizenship. It's legal for her to associate with herself. And it doesn't prevent her from getting a security clearance.

There are American laws regulating American business dealings with foreign firms. That's why companies have lawyers.

And there are laws about foreigners contributing financially to American political campaigns. There are also laws and regulations about governments directly influencing political campaigns. And laws against hacking other people's computers. And working with foreign intelligence agencies. The Washington Post has a column by a former CIA officer, Trump Jr.’s Russia meeting sure sounds like a Russian intelligence operation 07/14/2017, that explains why the now-notorious Don Jr./Veselnitskaya meeting looks so much like dirty business. Although that's already pretty obvious to everyone but partisan Republicans who will defend anything Trump does.

Obviously, political ideas don't stop at national borders. Nor should they. And there is a broad spectrum of things that facilitate those. There are books and movies and TV reporting and commentary, for instance. At the other end of the continuum we would have paid agents promoting political subversion or, say, hacking the computers of one party or campaign to give an advantage to another. Hacking into election systems is also illegal, even if they don't do it to manipulate the vote.

It's impossible to not thing about precedents in this situation. There were Nazi Fifth Column operations to deal with in the 1930s and 1940s. And there the Red Scares after both world wars, the one after the Second World War being largely remembered as McCarthyism.

There were several sensational cases of espionage in the postwar era involving Communists. In the United States, the conviction and exection of Julius and Ethel Rosenberg for passing atomic secrets to the Soviet Union was easily the most serious. Klaus Fuchs was a german-born British Communist who also passed atomic secrets to the USSR. He was imprisoned for several years in Britain, but later was released to East Germany, where he became deputy director of the East German Central Institute for Nuclear Research. Marian Smith Holmes has an article about atomic espionage figures, Spies Who Spilled Atomic Bomb Secrets Smithsonian 04/19/2009.

Alger Hiss became (in)famous as a target of investigation by California Congressman Richard Nixon and the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC). He was convicted not of espionage but of perjuring himself before Congress by denying he had been a Soviet agent. There are respectable historians who believe that Hiss was guilty, and that seems to be the leading opinion. Hiss himself denied to the end of his life that he had been a Soviet agent. And there is still no clear historical consensus on Hiss' guilt. The loathsome nature of Hiss' main accuser, Whittaker Chambers, and the role of the perennially unsavory Tricky Dicky in his case are more than sufficient cause to be reserved about the conclusiveness of the case.

Robert Oppenheimer, civilian head of the Los Alamos laboratory in the Manhattan Project, had his security clearance removed and was accused of espionage for the Soviets, as well. Hardcore rightwingers still like to make that claim. But it remains a far-fetched one.

But if an American political party wants to take a foreign government or movement as in some way a model to which to aspire, there's nothing illegal about that in itself. In the case of the US Communist Party, they explicitly took the Soviet Union as a model to emulate. There's some argument to be made that this association helped them win support after the Great Depression struck capitalist country but not the USSR. And, of course, the Soviets were American allies in the war, which also helped the US party's image somewhat. That didn't mean that the armed services didn't look askance at known or suspected Communists in the armed forces. Oppenheimer's admitted association with Communists, though he always claimed he was never actually a party member, caused him problems after the war. But the Army was willing to put enough confidence in him that he had a key role in developing the atomic bomb.

But the Communist Party's close identification with the Soviet Union was probably more of a turnoff to potential supporters most of the time than a net benefit. Because taking a dim view of Russia has been more the norm than the exception for Americans during the last century or more. The Czar wasn't that popular for Americans, either, though Russia was also an American ally in the First World War.

Speaking of tradition, the way some commentators and politicians talk about the Trump-Russia scandal has notable echoes of the way anti-Communists talked about Communists and the Soviet Union. And conservatives like Nixon and hardcore rightwingers like Joe McCarthy were more than happy to identify liberals and Democrats with Communists and the USSR.

I was reminded of one comparison to today's situation reading this, "Nothing so effectively shores up the American predilection for moral certainty as a good batch of incriminating documents." (Maurice Isserman and Ellen Schrecker, "'Papers of a Dangerous Tendency': From Major Andre's Boot to the VENONA Files"; Cold War Triumphalism: The Misuse of History After the Fall of Communism, E. Schrecker, ed.; 2004)

Whittaker Chambers' Pumpkin Papers stunt is a good example of using "incriminating documents" to good effect.

But the (digital) papers that Don Jr. released about his Veselnitskaya meeting are more damning than anything in the Pumpkin Papers were for Alger Hiss!

Isserman and Schrecker have some other worthwhile observations based on information including a number of Soviet documents release after the fall of the USSR:

Of the approximately 50,000 party members in World War II, 49,700 were uninvolved in espionage, even taking the highest estimate of communist participation in the KGB's network. The average Communist in 1944 was far more likely tobe a fur worker or a public school teacher than a policy maker in the Treasury Department, and thus an unlikely candidate for a Soviet operative to approach for workplace gossip. And even among the tiny minority of Communists and their fellow travelers who did occupy sensitive posts, not all were necessarily approached or agreed to spy on behalf of the Soviet Union.
After the Second World War, the Soviets tended to recruit agents in more conventional ways rather than on an ideological basis. Aldrich Ames, arrested in 1994 on espionage charges, was a CIA employee. The Senate Select Committee on Intelligence reported in 1994 (An Assessment of the Aldrich H. Ames Espionage Case and Its Implications for U.S. Intelligence 11/01/1994):

While the precise extent of Ames's espionage activities was unclear at the time of his arrest, Justice Department officials confirmed that Ames was believed to have caused the death or imprisonment of a number of Soviets who had been sources of the CIA and FBI. ...

The affidavit made public at the time of the arrests also confirmed that Ames had received substantial payments for the information he had provided -- money that he had used years earlier to purchase a new Jaguar automobile and a $540,000 home, with cash, in Arlington. Apparently, these seemingly large expenditures by an employee making less than $70,000 a year had not raised questions at the CIA.

On April 28, 1994, Ames and his wife, Rosario, pled guilty to charges stemming from their espionage activities. Entered into the record at the time the pleas were made was an agreed-upon "Statement of Facts" which provided new details regarding the Ames's espionage activities. Meetings with the Soviets in Washington, D.C., Vienna, Bogota, and Caracas were acknowledged for the first time. Ames also acknowledged that as of May 1, 1989, he had been paid over $1.8 million by the KGB and that $900,000 more had been set aside for him.
The blowhard alcoholic Joe McCarthy who claimed he had a list of Communist employees of the State Department never uncovered a single Communist in federal employment, much less a Russian spy. Not even with the help of his lieutenant, the future mob lawyer and political mentor to Donald Trump, Roy Cohn. Isserman and Schrecker write that McCarthy "was not simply 'exaggerating' a problem - he was making it up."

They also note, "We also now know that by 1953, the year of the Rosenbergs' execution, the FBI had quietly written off the American Communist Party as a serious espionage threat." Go figure. It's a reminder to everyone to keep their critical thinking skills working in the Trump-Russia scandal.

They also quote Richard Hofstadter, "[T]here are conspiratorial acts in history "and there is nothing paranoid in taking note of them."

Monday, September 26, 2011

Blackslisting in the 1950s and a couple of thoughts from it today

Erik Tarloff, the son of Frank Tarloff, a screenwriter blacklisted in the 1950s for Communist affiliations, writes about his father in a piece for The Atlantic melodramatically titled, My Father Was a Communist 09/21/2011. (One early Cold War paranoia film was called I Married a Communist.) The writers known as the Hollywood Ten were the most famous targets of the blacklist, though Tarloff was not among the ten.

This is an interesting topic in itself. But it also relates directly to a couple of current concerns.

The Encyclopædia Britannica's current article on the Hollywood Ten describes the ten and the era succinctly:

... 10 motion-picture producers, directors, and screenwriters who appeared before the House Un-American Activities Committee in October 1947, refused to answer questions regarding their possible communist affiliations, and, after spending time in prison for contempt of Congress, were mostly blacklisted by the Hollywood studios. The 10 were Alvah Bessie, Herbert Biberman, Lester Cole, Edward Dmytryk, Ring Lardner, Jr., John Howard Lawson, Albert Maltz, Samuel Ornitz, Adrian Scott, and Dalton Trumbo.

The group originally included the German writer Bertolt Brecht, but Brecht fled the country on the day following his inquest, and the remaining 10 were voted in contempt of Congress on Nov. 24, 1947. Convicted in federal court the following year, they were given sentences of six months to one year in prison. (While in prison, Dmytryk broke with the rest and agreed to cooperate, admitting being a communist and giving the names of 26 others.)
Ten years ago, it might have been more of a challenge to try to describe the Red Scare atmosphere of 1948-54, in particular. But if you've spent some time listening to FOX News, or Glenn Beck, or the Tea Party types, you pretty much get the idea.

In the case of Hollywood, rightwingers got it into their heads that Commie conspirators were sneaking Red messages into movies. ("Red" referred to Communists in those days, not Republicans.) Since there were few if any obvious examples, it was kind of like the fear of backwards messages on rock songs that were supposedly going to convert listeners into Satanists or something, a rightwing fad of the 1970s.

This obituary of the Tarloff, Obituary: Frank Tarloff by Dick Vosburgh The Independent 09/29/1999, includes the following story:

One of Tarloff's favourite anecdotes concerned the day he warned his landlord that he'd soon be called before HUAC: "I'll be refusing to give the names of Communists," he told him. "So if you don't approve of that, I'll understand if you ask us to leave." The landlord was a member of the Los Angeles underworld, and, although not a political animal, had no sympathy with squealers. "Don't worry," he told Tarloff. "As long as you don't rat on nobody you're welcome here."
HUAC was the House Un-American Affairs Committee, which before the Second World War had investigated both Nazi and Communist activities but achieved its greatest prominence during the postwar Red Scare and various investigations, notably the investigation of Alger Hiss which made Congressman Richard Nixon a national figure.

It wasn't illegal to be a Communist or a member of the Communist Party (CP, or CPUSA as the FBI preferred) in 1953 when Frank Tarloff was blacklisted. But the Truman Administration in 1948 had successfully prosecuted the top leaders of the CP under the Smith Act for being unregistered agents of a foreign power and for having conspired to advocate the overthrow of the US government. In 1954, the Communist Control Act outlawed the CP itself in all but name.

When actual CP members were called before an investigating committee at that time, the Party line was that they should refuse to testify on First Amendment grounds of freedom of speech. The political-legal argument was that it was unconstitutional for the government to investigate the personal political beliefs of individuals. But the courts at the time recognized only the 5th Amendment right against self-incrimination as legally justifying a refusal to testify. The CP, it appears, was happy to have individual members in that situation become martyrs to the cause and go to prison.

The younger Tarloff's explanation of this in a footnote is confusing:

The earliest uncooperative witnesses invoked their First Amendment right to free speech as the basis for their non-cooperation, and subsequently were convicted of contempt of Congress and sent to prison. Later witnesses who, on the advice of counsel, relied on their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, escaped criminal prosecution, although they still sacrificed their careers. Of course, to any rational person, this distinction makes no sense: Since witnesses were not being accused of a crime, self-incrimination should have been an irrelevant consideration, whereas they had been exercising their right to free speech. But such were the times, and such are the vagaries of the justice system.
I think Erik Tarloff here is trying to argue in favor of the First Amendment option, though he might have mentioned that at least one later Supreme Court decision seemed to validate it. But arguing that the Fifth Amendment shouldn't have been appropriate doesn't take full account of the real risk of being prosecuted in connection with CP membership at the time, not unlike the way in 2011 members or even contributors to organizations officially labelled "terrorist" by the federal government risk prosecution and serious jail time.

Soviet espionage of later decades in the US tended not to rely on CP members or the ideologically committed, but instead used less romantic methods of bribery and blackmail. But that had not been the case in the 1940s, and revelations about atomic espionage, above all the convictions of Julius and Ethel Rosenberg in connection with it in 1951, meant that there were real legal risks involved with admitting CP membership.

Erik Tarloff raises an important civil-liberties point:

The interviewer began the dialogue by asking if my father would feel equal outrage had the blacklist targeted Nazis rather than Communists. Wrong-footed, Frank fumfered some sort of response. After the interview, both my parents emerged from the studio in high dudgeon. "How dare he?" was the gravamen of their scandalized indignation. And when they told me about the interview later that day, I made matters worse by suggesting the interviewer had posed a legitimate question. There was a distinct chill in the parental household for some time thereafter.

But it is a legitimate question. Unless one is prepared to defend Communism on its merits, or, alternatively, is merely defending one's comrades out of a kind of tribal loyalty, then one is, I think, obliged to consider whether punishing people for their political beliefs is always wrong, or wrong only when it's one's own side that is being persecuted.
He goes on to point out (in a footnote) that his father supported the right of Nazis to march in the famous case in Skokie, Illinois.

Erik has framed it as a fairly straightforward civil-liberties question. But if we ask about Congress or other government bodies investigating private groups constituted as political or religious entities, it's a complex question, in practice. And it relates to two current concerns.

One is the designation of groups as terrorist groups and the drastic laws penalties a person can incur for giving "material assistance" to a group officially so designated. Laws apply to political and religious groups. Political parties can't just send money to the party leaders' Swiss bank accounts. A group organized as a tax-exempt religious institutions can't carry on partisan electioneering in its own name.

And the laws don't allow political parties, lobbyists or churches to run criminal enterprises, whether it's money-laundering, gambling, prostitution, drug trafficking or stockpiling arms to murder public officials. Although thanks to the NRA and the Republican Party's fetish for guns, the lst item probably has more legal latitude than the others. A criminal enterprise can't legalize itself by declaring itself a church or political group. Still, this is why we need to cops and prosecutors and justice officials who are scrupulous about following the law in making these investigations and determinations. The same goes for Congressional or legislative investigators.

Another way it relates to current concerns is the matter of how to research political groups, fringe or otherwise, and who should be doing it. Erik Tarloff mentions the publications like Red Currents that listed alleged Communists and sympathizers. This kind of thing is kind of a small-town conformity approach. "That ole boy ain't acting right. So nobody better give him no job until he straightens up." The fact that Hollywood media moguls were willing to play along with that is pitiful. So is the fact that too many slezy members of Congress and legislative bodies were willing to feed the fires. And there was a whole tawdry crew of paid informers, stool pigeons and fanatics who got into the act of red-hunting in those days.

All that said, if you're going to find out what a political group and individuals who identify with it stand for, you would obviously need to research what those groups say in their meetings, media appearances and publications. "Guilt by association" was all-too-common in the McCarthy era. But guilt-by-assocation refers to guilt by irrelevant association, e.g., you signed a Communist petition so you must be a Communist; this guy was a member of the CP so he must be spying for the Russians, etc. But it's not guilt-by-association to associate people with positions that they've taken in public. The two main CP leaders in this period, Eugene Dennis and William Foster, were official officers of the Party, spoke on the Party's behalf, and published articles under their own names in Party publications. It would hardly be irrational for people to associate themselves with actions and ideas with which they had publicly associated themselves.

So it's a perfectly legitimate and even necessary thing for reporters and scholars and political activists to investigate political groups and draw conclusions from their findings. That's no excuse for sleazebags like Andrew Breitbart or his disciple James O'Keefe to use tapes edited to create a totally misleading impression. This has come up recently in the press with whining from Christian Right leaders over writers from sites like Talk to Action and Religion Dispatches who have investigated the public activities of Rich Perry backers who have associated themselves with the extremist New Apostolic Restoration. Dave Neiwert has done excellent work over the last two decades or so conducting professional journalistic investigations of far-right groups.

Even public figures have a right to complain about unethical or illegal actions by investigators. But any of us who take public political or religious positions can't really object if people associate us with positions we take in public. If I publicly identify myself with the Democratic Party and publicly say I support Social Security and Medicare, all of which I've done here multiple times, I would look pretty silly whining that someone else was associating me with the Democratic Party or saying that I support Social Security and Medicare. But something like that is just what some of the mealy-mouthed leaders of the New Apostolic Restoration are doing in response to careful research by people like Rachel Tabachnick.

Tags: , ,

Monday, March 19, 2007

What will the hardcore paranoids make of this?

Earl Browder, Communist Party leader circa 1938 (he went on to become a flaming rightwinger in his later career)

Communist Party USA Gives Its History to N.Y.U. New York Times by Patricia Cohen 03/20/07. The story says pretty much what the headline implies:

The cache [of donated documents] contains decades of party history including founding documents, secret code words, stacks of personal letters, smuggled directives from Moscow, Lenin buttons, photographs and stern commands about how good party members should behave (no charity work, for instance, to distract them from their revolutionary duties).

By offering such an inside view, the archives have the potential to revise assumptions on both the left and the right about one of the most contentious subjects in American history, in addition to filling out the story of progressive politics, the labor movement and the civil rights struggles.
Cohen notes that many of the documents have been available already at the Library of Congress:

The primary source of American party documents available to the public has been the Library of Congress, which microfilmed a batch of Communist Party USA records in Soviet archives that had been shipped there 50 years earlier for safekeeping. John Earl Haynes, a historian at the Library of Congress who was the first American to examine the Soviet files, said that since N.Y.U. has a copy of the Library of Congress material, “This will give Tamiment [the NYU library] the enviable position of being able to offer researchers access to what is in Moscow as well as the new C.P.U.S.A. collection.”

When the collection opened in 2000, the Library of Congress said, "the C.P.U.S.A. has always been a secretive organization," and “the previous paucity of the archival record has been a major obstacle to scholarship on the history of the American Communist movement,” and a reason for "highly contentious" debates.
Yes, it's safe to say the Communist Party generated "highly contentious" debates.

The article also quotes Ronald Radosh, an historian, "Red diaper baby" (from the days when red was the Party color of the Communists, not the Republicans) and general rightwing twit complaining that the NYU library wasn't condemning the Commies enough. Or something. Even after the Party is history, people that have spent decades emotionally committed to fighting the Nefarious Communist Conspiracy can't quite give it up yet.

Tags: