Showing posts with label edward snowden. Show all posts
Showing posts with label edward snowden. Show all posts

Monday, June 08, 2015

Snowden, Democrats and the corporate press

"[Edward] Snowden's whistleblowing has led to many extraordinary revelations. None is more significant or more revealing than what it highlighted about the function many American journalists actually perform, and how far away that is – universes away – from the way they market their function." - Glenn Greenwald, Media Lessons From Snowden Reporting: LA Times Editors Advocate Prosecution of Sources The Intercept 06/07/2015

One of the particular features of the wave of protest and reform movements that we still remember as The Sixties is that in some ways, the corporate media were not primary targets of the protests.

Generalizations are tricky because they're, well, generalizations.

The "alternative" or "underground" press was a feature of the US in the 1960s. Radical America, Ramparts, Socialist Revolution (later renamed Socialist Review) and The Great Speckled Bird were some of the better known and more influential samples of that phenomenon in the United States. And various political groups like the Black Panthers had their own papers and magazines. (Radical America's first issues billed themselves as a journal of the Students for a Democratic Society.)

And the left/populist/socialist press since the 19th century has made criticisms of the established press. So such criticism from the left is scarcely unknown in the pre-blogosphere days in the US.

But the big protests of the 1960s were directed against the corporate press in the way that, for example, the conservative Springer press (Bild, Die Welt) was a target of militant left protests in Germany in the 1960s and 1970s. Latin American popular movements like Peronism in Argentina have targeted the misconduct of the oligarchic press for a long time.

In mainstream politics in the US, it's the Republican Party that has made "the liberal press" a major target of criticism for decades now. The current form of such criticism owes much to Southern segregationist attacks on the "Northern" and "liberal" press during the fight in the 1950s and 1960s to preserve the Segregation 1.0 system. The Nixon Administration, especially Vice President Spiro Agnew before he resigned in disgrace, railed against the Liberal Press - largely a fantasy image even then - and its criticism of Nixon's Vietnam War policies.

The civil rights movement certainly had occasion to challenge the role of the press. Any decent history of the civil rights movement in Mississippi, for instance, would have occasion to mention the role of "the Hederman press." (See: Kathy Lally, A journey from racism to reason Newspaper: The Clarion-Ledger of Jackson, Miss., was once the most racist paper in the United States, until an offspring of the publishing family decided to make the paper -- and his family name -- respectable. Baltimore Sun 01/05/1999.)

Dennis Mitchell in A New History of Mississippi (2014) writes about the press in Mississippi during the 1950s and 1960s:

Deprived of leadership from the state's spiritual leaders and intellectuals, Mississippians looked to newspapers and television for their news and ideas. Unfortunately, as a whole, Mississippi's newspapers proved to be the weakest in the nation in their coverage of the civil rights movement, according to the Columbia Journalism Review. The arch segregationist Hederman family owned the papers with the highest circulation in Jackson and Hattiesburg. Their headlines and locally written news stories dehumanized the "mixers;' as they called integrationists, referring to them as human freaks and abnormal mammals. Readers who got past the headlines into the text of wire service reports got more balanced information because the editors did not rewrite wire reports. [my emphasis in bold] (p. 422)

The major media in the US did play a significant role in challenging the official narrative of the Vietnam War. Daniel Ellsberg's leak of the Pentagon Papers which were printed by various major papers starting with the New York Times was a prime example of this. And with Nixon and Agnew trying to browbeat the press into conformity on Vietnam, liberals and Democrats were understandably inclined to defend the press in that situation.

And the major role papers like the Washington Post and the New York Times played in exposed the Watergate scandals which led to Nixon's resignation further reinforced the image for liberals of the major media as effectively playing the role of an independent Fifth Estate.

Glenn Greenwald quotes an op-ed by Daniel Ellsberg (NSA leaker Snowden made the right call Washington Post 07/07/2013) in which Ellsberg defends Edward Snowden's decision to leave the US to avoid prosecution over his leaks: "Many people compare Edward Snowden to me unfavorably for leaving the country and seeking asylum, rather than facing trial as I did. I don’t agree. The country I stayed in was a different America, a long time ago."

And a large part of that difference is a drastic shift toward conformity and lack of critical reporting on the part of major media.

Democrats and progressives have been forced - at a speed that seems all too painfully slow - to recognize the ways in which the national press as a larger institutions and so many of the individual institutions that make it up are often much more of a barrier to progress than a facilitator. The Clinton pseudoscandals were a big factor, the stolen election of 2000 another, and the Iraq War even more so. At least now there is a strong progressive narrative associated with the netroots and the Democratic base that views the national media with a strongly critical eye. The Young Turks online network of sites and online programs is a notable positive element in that regard.

Digby Parton is oe of the most perceptive observers of this issue. As she point out in Hillary Clinton’s toughest adversary: The world-historic narcissism of the political press Salon 06/02/2015, Democratic politicians are much behind the Democratic base on this.

James Vega in Democrats: the mainstream media gang is whining with operatic self-pity ... Democratic Strategist 05/27/2015 points to the reality that, particularly with Hillary Clinton as the leading Presidential candidate, the pro-Republican bias of the "mainstream" media is more pronounced than ever. And he warns that Democrats need to be fully cognizant of that situation:

In the first place, it means that Hillary is entirely right in refusing to play by the traditional rules. The mainstream political press has itself rendered these rules obsolete by failing to report on the most important political story of recent years - the extremist conquest of the GOP. Reporters and commentators who refuse to report this reality as an objective fact about modern American politics cannot possibly also play the role of impartial arbitrators or objective journalists when covering a Democratic political candidate.

Second, Hillary's decision to act in accordance with this insight presents a profound challenge and threat to the GOP crypto-partisans among the press corps, one which will inevitably engender a deep and profound hostility and desire to cut her down to size. ...

As a result, Democrats should prepare themselves for the uncomfortable fact that in the coming months the mainstream press will become increasingly and stridently anti-Clinton. So long as she does not play by their rules they will describe her as "remote," "fake," "robotic", "inauthentic" "scripted", "cynical" "manipulative", "dishonest" and "insincere". Her Republican opponent, whether it is Bush, Walker, Rubio, or any of the other contenders will then be described in contrast as much more "real" "down to earth" "authentic" "open" "honest" and "sincere." Fueled by their wounded vanity and the very real threat to their influence, the mainstream commentators will create a narrative that continually frames the 2016 election in precisely this way.

Democrats must be prepared to fight back. The necessary rebuttal must be to insist that - although the press may genuinely be in denial about their own motives - their failure to tell the truth about GOP extremism makes it impossible for honest Americans to treat them as objective or honest. The Democratic response must be the following:

Until you are willing to tell your readers the truth about GOP extremism, for all practical purposes you are promoting an ideologically partisan, pro-Republican point of view. As a result you cannot simultaneously claim to also be neutral or objective or that you are acting as the unbiased representatives of the public or as guardians of American democracy. Either tell your readers the truth about GOP extremism or accept the fact that honest Americans have the right to view you as partisan advocates for the GOP.
This is important because the Washington press has always been entirely untroubled by criticisms that they are sensationalistic, superficial or cynical. Part of their vanity, in fact, is based on their self-image as the grizzled veterans who have "seen it all." What does get under their skin, on the other hand, is the accusation that behind their protestations of independence they are basically carrying water for the GOP. It gets under their skin because, deep down, they know that it's true. [my emphasis in bold]

Sunday, August 11, 2013

Obama defends the surveillance state

Conservative columnist Dave Weigel does a decent takedown of President Obama's comments Friday about domestic spying and Edward Snowden in Scoffer in Chief Slate 08/09/2013:

The president’s mission, as set out on Friday, is to take credit for all the reforms that sound the best, and to re-establish the government as a trusted actor without doing much that's new. In that May speech at the National Defense University, Obama committed to "a strong Privacy and Civil Liberties Board to review those issues where our counterterrorism efforts and our values may come into tension." On Friday, he said that he’d "asked the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board to review where our counterterrorism efforts and our values come into tension." Created in 2004, on the recommendations of the 9/11 Commission, the board was effectively powerless until three months ago, when it finally got a chairman, and the president’s still bland when it comes to its goals.

Blandness serves a purpose. The White House’s plans for a website that will "serve as the hub for further transparency" are obviously silly, and the most concrete plan denoted in the press conference may not have a real impact. "One of the concerns that people raise is that a judge reviewing a request from the government to conduct programmatic surveillance only hears one side of the story," Obama said. "We can take steps to make sure civil liberties concerns have an independent voice, in appropriate cases, by ensuring that the government's position is challenged by an adversary." He was referring obliquely to a Democratic bill that would create a "public advocate" in the FISA court. Civil libertarians wonder if that would truly add more accountability to the process, or whether it would become yet another surveillance rubber stamp.
He also makes a good point about Obama's style. On the one hand, Obama makes considerable effort to come across as the proverbial regular guy. "But when the topic of Edward Snowden comes up, President Obama talks like he’s at the summit of Olympus, uninterested in mortals. It’s not a very convincing act."

Obama's own authoritarian leanings have come out most clearly around the issue of government secrecy and his War on Whistleblowers. He's also exhibited a downright cruel streak in relation to it, as Juan Cole recalls in Informed Comment 08/10/2013:

Mr. Obama at one point in his press conference called on Edward Snowden to come back to the United States and argue his case. I mean, really. This kind of disinformation and grandstanding can't possibly be necessary, even given the constraints mentioned at the beginning of this essay. Mr. Obama knows very well that if Snowden returned to the US, we would never ever hear from him ever again. He’d go straight to a maximum security prison for the rest of his days on earth and die there.

Bradley Manning was held at a brig by the Marines and was falsely declared a suicide risk so that he could be tortured by being chained naked to his bed for a year and woken up several times a night (sleep deprivation is a torture tactic, as is humiliation via making a prisoner nude. These same techniques were used by the US military on Iraqi prisoners at Abu Ghraib). There is no reason to believe that Snowden would be treated better. Note that Obama’s own spokesman, P. J. Crowley, publicly criticized Manning’s treatment and was fired for it. Obama had been in a position to stop the torture but did not.

If Mr. Obama were serious about wanting Snowden voluntarily to return and participate in a national debate, he would take the espionage charges off the table. Despite cynical presuppositions by Snowden’s critics, there is no evidence whatsoever that he has shared sensitive intelligence with either China or Russia. [my emphasis]
The dedicated Obama critic David Bromwich writes of the surveillance state (Diary London Review of Books 06/21/2013):

Fear must have been among the strongest emotions that penetrated Snowden when he grasped the total meaning of the maps of the security state to which he was afforded a unique access. In one sort of mind, and it characterises the majority of those in power, the fear turns adaptive and changes slowly to compliance and even attachment. In a mind of a different sort, the fear leads to indignation and finally resistance. But we should not underestimate the element of physical fear that accompanies such a moral upheaval. Since the prosecutions of whistleblowers, the abusive treatment of Manning and the drone assassinations of American citizens have been justified by the president and his advisers, a dissident in the US may now think of his country the way the dissidents in East Germany under the Stasi thought of theirs. ‘The gloves are off.’ Nor should we doubt that a kindred fear is known even to the persons who control the apparatus.
It's certainly created a dangerous situation for preserving the rule of law - in the national security arena, maybe we should talk about a revival of the rule of law - when the only way a person like Snowden who seeks to expose what he has good reason to believe are not only anti-democratic but illegal spying by the government and private companies to which it was outsourced the job is to be willing to go into permanent exile and risk the fate back home that Juan Cole describes.

Tags: , ,

Monday, August 05, 2013

Justifying the NSA

I'm not the least surprised at this: US embassy closures used to bolster case for NSA surveillance programs by Spencer Ackerman and Dan Roberts Guardian 08/05/2013.

No one can brush off this kind of warning. But after the intelligence abuses of the Cheney-Bush and Obama Administration, after the extreme secrecy and dishonest representations of their massive surveillance programs by Obama's intelligence officials, my confidence in the intelligence agencies to be honest with the American public about these dangers is very low.

I do wish the government and the press would stop using "Al Qaeda" as a blanket term for The Terrorists. But that usage is well established and shows little sign of going away.

As Charlie Pierce puts it in his distinctive style (What Are the Gobshites Saying These Days Esquire Politics Blog 08/05/2013):

Those of you keeping score at home will note that, for the last two or three months, the NSA has been under some criticism for its Hoovering up of our personal data. If I were running an secret surveillance state, and I found that secret surveillance state nearly defunded by the Congress only a week earlier, I might think to myself, hmm, what I could use right now, along with a cold beer and a plate of gherkins, would be a worldwide terror alert of a kind we've rarely seen before, but of sufficient vagueness that I couldn't be accused of ginning up fear for my own bureaucratic purposes. I might not even be inclined to wait until serendipity dropped this opportunity in my lap.
Juan Cole is especially impressed with the embassy-closing gesture, as he explains in How the GOP Libya Witch Hunt Made us Close our Mideast Embassies and Crippled US Diplomacy Informed Comment 08/05/2013:

... the GOP is inadvertently pushing the US into a posture of dangerous diplomatic weakness. This weakness is clear in the unprecedented closing of 21 US embassies in the Middle East this weekend because of a vague terrorist threat apparently emanating from “al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula,” based in Yemen.

The Obama administration most likely took this weird step to insulate itself from any further witch hunts of the sort the Republicans launched over the tragic attack on a CIA safe house doubling as a US consulate in Benghazi, Libya, on Sept. 11, 2011. That a radical extremist cell should have attacked in this way was a surprise, since the radicals had been persecuted by Muammar Gaddafi, and the US had helped overthrow the dictator. I was in Benghazi in summer of 2011 and was told that personal security was not so bad (you wouldn’t be mugged as an individual), but that militias might steal from, e.g., a company. The existence of a set of terrorist cells that would and could kill ambassador Chris Stevens and three others was not clear. When the surprise attack was launched, the Libyan government organized a special forces unit to extract the remaining dozens of Americans and get them to Tripoli, with it did without further loss of life. There is no reason to think that the Obama administration behaved inappropriately through the crisis. ...

So at a time when Tunisia and Libya facing the greatest popular turmoil since 2011, you have American embassies barely functioning and not able effectively to engage in diplomacy, suggest compromises, push for moderation. The GOP produced this sad situation by forcing the administration to protect themselves from further invidious inquisitions.

Now the Benghazi Disease has spread from Tunisia and Libya to the whole Middle East. Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula is a few hundred guys out in the boondocks of Yemen (and that is really the boondocks). They have a pathological fascination with the non-metallic explosive PETN, which is why we all have to get naked at the airport while scanners look for pouches of it, since it wouldn’t set off the metal detectors. They did try to attack the US Embassy in Sanaa in 2008 and killed 6 of their own guys. As far as I can tell they have a dearth of successful operations.

It is inappropriate to give AQAP the idea that they can push around a superpower this way.
He thinks this is more of the story on the embassy closings than an attempt to justify the NSA domestic surveillance programs.

Tags: , ,

NSA spying and the transformation of the Internet (Updated)

A lot of people have responded to Snowden's revelations with a shrug, saying, "I have nothing to hide." But that misses the point. It's bad enough that private companies track our movements, tastes, habits, health and networks, all to sell us more stuff. But when governments do the same thing, creating a domestic spying industry 171 with hundreds of thousands of contractors, the potential for abuse is frightening.

That digital dragnet is what Snowden has been trying to bring into the open and reform: the Internet, once one of our greatest tools, can be turned against us.

History has shown that he is correct. The 20th century's targets of totalitarian states had almost nowhere to run. The enemies of Egypt's military coup, like them or not, are not so secretly being rounded up and arrested. And Snowden, the messenger in a global Internet-based spying scandal, is now a man without a country.

The Internet is not dead or dying. But it's not our best friend forever. And as America's spymasters and its global companies keep defending their digital dragnet, Snowden's revelations remind us what the Internet has become.
So writes Steve Rosenfeld in The Internet As We Know It Is On Its Deathbed Alternet 07/30/2013.

He's getting at an important aspect and likely consequence of the NSA spying program and the public revelations of it through the whistleblower Edward Snowden. That being, who wants to go through this? Who wants to become a whistleblower even against what look like serious crimes if you have to become a permanent fugitive sheltering in a foreign country, worrying that every change of government there may mean you have to run again? No doubt, it's quite a deterrent.

Snowden's revelations didn't themselves create some new era for the Internet. But they certainly seem to show that we've entered one.

Because of massive secrecy, we don't have a clear picture of everything the federal government is collecting and storing. But there are good reasons to assume that they are collecting and storing all electronic communications, all phone calls including recordings of the content, and maybe even all Web searches.

And according to the Obama Administration and the defenders of the surveillance state in Congress, this is all being collected legally. (I won't drive myself crazy with this, but in our current SpySpeak, "collection" doesn't mean tracking, recording and storing all this stuff, but only reading or listening to the contents. I'm going to stick to regular English in this post.)

So why should that data all just set there in the gigantic new storage facility that the feds are building and may already be in operation? Certainly, people have some ideas to put it to work: Eric Lichtblau and Michael Schmidt, Other Agencies Clamor for Data N.S.A. Compiles New York Times 08/03/2013; Marcy Wheeler, U.S. Justice: A Rotting Tree of Poisonous Fruit? Emptywheel 08/05/2013. Marcy's title refers to the judicial doctrine known as "fruit of the poisonous tree." If the cops come search your house without a proper warrant or some other accepted legal justification, any evidence they find there cannot be used against you in court. Nor can any other evidence secured based on information found in the illegal search; that's where the "fruit of the poisonous tree" concept comes in. (As fans of police procedural TV dramas know, if the state can make a plausible case that the police would inevitably have found the "fruit" anyway.)

Marcy also points to this story: Stewart Powell, NSA handing over non-terror intelligence San Francisco Chronicle 08/04/2013.

This is another version of the dilemma that Cheney and Bush created with their gulag system of "black sites" and Guantánamo. When you create a parallel "justice" system, you not only do a lot of unnecessary harm and injustices to people. But you wind up having to recreate the wheel. After detaining and torturing people for years, the government had to eventually come up with a procedure to judge the guilt of the detainees. But for any halfway honest justice system, evidence collected via torture can't be allowed. So we've wound up with the bizarre situation that it's near-impossible to try detainees the government thinks are guilty. But we're also holding detainees indefinitely that the government no longer even claims to think are guilty of anything.

The same thing is happening with the massive surveillance state. It's justified as protecting us against The Terrorists. But such massive surveillance, justified under a secret law and governed by a secret court whose decisions are secret and whose judges are appointed by authoritarian-segregationist Chief Justice John Roberts, is incompatible with democratic governance and a fair justice system. And those conflicts will only grow if the surveillance Kraken isn't reigned in. The defense has to be able to contest the source of the information and the chain of evidence-collection in a meaningful way in order to provide a fair trial.

The Kraken

In theory, this could be used to benefit defendants, as well. Apparently, the NSA is sweeping so much information that they must have evidence relating to just about every criminal case in the US. If they are providing some of it to the prosecution, why shouldn't they have to provide it to the defense? For that matter, shouldn't there be an obligation to turn exculpatory evidence over to the defense? If that were done systematically, local cops might have to start behaving a lot better!

So, just as with the Bush Gulag (as Al Gore called it), the Cheney-Bush-Obama surveillance state is now having to recreate the wheel by building a parallel justice system, one that is increasingly starting to collide with the main justice system.

Oh, the DEA is in the act, too: John Shiffman and Kristina Cooke, Exclusive: U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investigate Americans Reuters 08/05/2013. Speaking of poisonous trees, the War on Drugs is a tree that is the source of a lot of the poisonous fruits in violations of privacy and civil rights, the militarization of police and the overcrowding of prisons. This news prompted this mini-rant from Ana Kasparian at her Facebook page today:

So the NSA is now taking the info they collect by spying on us, and sending it to the DEA so they can prosecute us for drug use. On top if all that, the DEA lies about where the information originated from, which destroys our right to a fair trial. America is NOT the land of the free. Our rights are being destroyed right in front of our eyes. THIS is why Snowden is an American hero. He revealed the tip of the iceberg, and it's up to us to respond accordingly.
(Update: Bmaz at Emptywheel provides some background on this news in About the Reuters DEA Special Operations Division Story 08/05/2013)

There is reason to think that the government is being just plain dumb and needlessly abusive in some of its searches. Like this case that recently drew some attention: Natasha Lennard, NSA at work? Writer says house raided after online browsing Salon 08/01/2013; Michele Catalano, pressure cookers, backpacks and quinoa, oh my! Writing Out Loud 08/01/2013; Watertown Redux? Cops, not Feds, Raid House in New York Somewhere BagNewsNotes 08/03/2013.

This is how repression works. Not primarily by busting everybody that steps out of line. But by creating a consciousness that if you step out of line, you might get in trouble, even really serious trouble. So, for instance, if you read about the Boston Marathon bombers using pressure cookers to make explosives and were curious about how that could be, you might have wanted to google something like "pressure cooker explosives" or "pressure cooker bombs." But normal curiosity might get you a visit from a Counter Terrorism Task Force, which most people presumably prefer not to have.

Okay, so most people who aren't terminal news junkies may not bother. But what does it do to the liberating potential of the Internet that has been so much discussed the last two decades? It doesn't end it. But the popular notion that the Internet provides an inherently democratic platform that can't be stifled by governments has to be revised.

Joshua Yaffa reports on how Putin's government in Russia is asserting greater control over speech over the Internet in Is Pavel Durov, Russia's Zuckerberg, a Kremlin Target? (print title: "The Flight of the Russian Zuckerberg") Bloomberg Businessweek 08/01/2013 talks about the Putin government's attempts to bring VKontakte, the leading social networking site in Russia, more under state control. The online version omits the following paragraph, which is fifth from the end in the print version:

The change in VKontakte's ownership occurred at the same time the Duma was extending the state's ability to monitor and filter Internet content. Last summer it created a so-called blacklist law that requires providers to block access to sites deemed to contain child pornography, material on drug use, or calls to suicide. On May 24, VKontakte was entirely blocked for several hours when it was placed on the blacklist. The state agency responsible for maintaining the register of banned sites said it was a "mistake," but some inside the company took it as a warning.
Both versions contain these paragraphs which follow the one just quoted in the print edition:

The Duma passed another law calling for the blocking of sites with pirated content. Given VKontakte's trove of free music and video, this legislation could be an even more immediate threat to the company. In mid-June, perhaps to get out in front of the pending regulations, it began a massive campaign to delete unlicensed songs on user pages at the request of a law firm representing Universal Music (VIVHY), Sony Music (SNE), and Warner Music.

The crackdown may be the first step toward what Sergei Zheleznyak, the deputy speaker of the Duma, has called "digital sovereignty." That would mean even foreign Internet companies such as Facebook would be forced to place their servers in Russia, making such sites more liable to monitoring or blocking. Such a move would resemble the Chinese setup, in which the state simultaneously pushes users toward homegrown versions of social networks over which it has more sway — such as Baidu (BIDU) in China, or perhaps VKontakte in Russia — while demanding greater access and compliance from foreign companies operating in Russian territory. Before, says Soldatov, the Russian authorities would "ask to remove content, not to be given a back door." That may be changing. [my emphasis]
This doesn't mean that the political-liberating potential of the Internet is shot. Size matters, or in this case volume. The NSA is vacuuming up and storing such staggering amounts of information that the monitoring potential is inherently self-limiting. Because most of what they're getting is irrelevant to either actual crimes or political dissent. They are creating many haystacks of information in which they hope to locate needles. It certainly could lead to needless annoyance for people who trade recipes via e-mail, Facebook or telephone that involve a "pressure cooker." But who knows what dangerous and subversive ideas people might pick up from reading John Locke or Benjamin Franklin online?

But it does mean that governments of overtly authoritarian and more ostensibly democratic casts have been able to go much further in controlling and monitoring the Internet than some of the more enthusiastic digital libertarians may have hoped.

Finally, there's the question of how this will affect online business. With social networking sites such as Facebook suffer as more people decide that they would prefer to share hardcopy photos of the family picnics instead of posting them on a social networking site? I would be amazed if in the wake of the Snowden revelations and other related reporting if foreign corporations aren't looking for ways to avoid exposing their information to American Internet companies. Most of them presumably don't want to have the NSA sweep up their trade secrets and give them to American competitors. And, for that matter, American companies have a legitimate worry that the NSA will take their information and share it with some business that has better crony-capitalist connections to whatever Administration is in power at the moment.

This gives me a chance to roll out one of my favorite history quotes: "When philosophy paints its gray on gray, then has a form of life grown old, and with gray on gray it cannot be rejuvenated, but only known; the Owl of Minerva first takes flight with twilight closing in. - G. W. F. Hegel, "Preface," Philosophy of Right. That was his dramatic way of saying that we can't really understand an era until it is ending. And it looks like some important phase of the Internet phenomenon may be coming to an end. Globalization meets "digital sovereignty"?

Tags: , ,

Wednesday, July 31, 2013

Government stenography on the Snowden leaks

Michael Riley does a piece of stenography for the national security establishment in Snowden's Access to NSA's Deepest Secrets Disputed (Print title: What Snowden Doesn't Know) Bloomberg Businessweek 07/18/2013.

The feds have made two broad arguments about Snowden's revelations. One is that he's a traitor and criminal who damaged the national interest so that there's more chance now that The Terrorists will kill us all in our beds. The other is that his revelations are no big deal, nothing to see here, move along.

Riley's stenography promotes the second version. His cited sources include:

  • "current and former intelligence officials familiar with his role within the agency"
  • "a former senior official at the Department of Defense who, like other current and former intelligence employees cited in this article, asked not to be named talking about NSA operations"
  • "every intelligence official interviewed for this story"
  • "A former U.S. intelligence employee"
  • "A former senior intelligence official"
  • "a former NSA official"
  • "current and former intelligence officials"
  • "A person familiar with the TAO unit in Hawaii"

Riley does cite one from by name, from a conservative-leaning security think-tank, apparently speculating along the lines of Riley's various anonymous sources: "'I think he was overbilling by telling people he had access to the dark inner secrets,' says James Lewis, a fellow in cybersecurity at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. 'He did what contractors do — he padded his résumé.'"

The core of this argument comes at the end:

The most secretive of the NSA’s programs is Tailored Access Operations, or TAO, an elite group of 200 hackers who break into foreign computer networks. They train for two years to qualify for the program, and their work generates some of the U.S. government's most valuable intelligence. Contractors don't get those jobs, current and former intelligence officials say.

Snowden has hinted he has more damaging information in his possession that he hasn’t released. His leaks gave foreign governments an idea of the breadth of the NSA’s data sweeps but didn’t reveal which networks it has tapped. TAO's activities were apparently among Snowden’s targets. He told the Guardian that he took the job in Hawaii so he could gain access to lists of computers the agency had hacked. There's no indication he got near that information. A person familiar with the TAO unit in Hawaii says no one within the tight-knit group of hackers had met or even heard of Snowden—until they saw his face on the news.
Apparently, according to Riley's parade of anonymous sources, those 200 hackers are the only ones in the NSA who knows anything worth knowing. Why all that other unimportant information is so highly classified is not a question Riley or his anonymous sources address.

But since there were all these people apparently talking about classified information without formal authorization, I'm sure the Pentagon and the Justice Department are eagerly seeking those sources so they can also be sent to prison for years or life. And, yes, I mean that ironically. Leakers who leak information on behalf of their agencies propaganda operations are normally not targeted for such actions. (It would be interesting to know if the government had ever officially disclosed that 200 hackers have all the good stuff in the world of NSA spying.)

I'm sure Riley's anonymous Administration sources would deny that it rises to the importance of the Good Stuff From The 200 Hackers, Glenn Greenwald and the Guardian just published new revelations about the massive NSA spying, XKeyscore: NSA tool collects 'nearly everything a user does on the internet' 07/31/2013:

A top secret National Security Agency program allows analysts to search with no prior authorization through vast databases containing emails, online chats and the browsing histories of millions of individuals, according to documents provided by whistleblower Edward Snowden. ...

US officials vehemently denied this specific claim. Mike Rogers, the Republican chairman of the House intelligence committee, said of Snowden's assertion: "He's lying. It's impossible for him to do what he was saying he could do."

But training materials for XKeyscore detail how analysts can use it and other systems to mine enormous agency databases by filling in a simple on-screen form giving only a broad justification for the search. The request is not reviewed by a court or any NSA personnel before it is processed.

XKeyscore, the documents boast, is the NSA's "widest reaching" system developing intelligence from computer networks – what the agency calls Digital Network Intelligence (DNI). One presentation claims the program covers "nearly everything a typical user does on the internet", including the content of emails, websites visited and searches, as well as their metadata. ...

Under US law, the NSA is required to obtain an individualized Fisa warrant only if the target of their surveillance is a 'US person', though no such warrant is required for intercepting the communications of Americans with foreign targets. But XKeyscore provides the technological capability, if not the legal authority, to target even US persons for extensive electronic surveillance without a warrant provided that some identifying information, such as their email or IP address, is known to the analyst.
But if it wasn't signed by every member of the League Of 200 Hackers, it can't be very important!

Tags: , ,

Friday, July 05, 2013

US vs. Europe vs. Latin America Over Edward Snowden

The Edward Snowden case acquired an extra touch of melodrama the last couple of days as Anna Chapman, the Russian spy expelled from the US in 2010 ...


... supposedly proposed to him via Twitter ...


... then followed up with this message to the NSA:


Die Welt seemed to accept that as her real Twitter account, Ex-Spionin fragt: "Snowden, willst Du mich heiraten?" 04.07.13.

Yes, Edward Snowden, this could be you (well, maybe!)

Honey trap? Publicity stunt by Chapman? A great opportunity for Snowden? I mean, shoot, if you have to spend the rest of your life at the Moscow Airport, you can see why he might want some company!

Then again, this DPA story "Chapman" liebt "Snowden": Twitter-Romanze amüsiert Moskau Salzburger Nachrichten 05.07.2013 was more cautious on whether it is really her Twitter account.

The Chapman story is entertaining. Especially with The Americans on hiatus for the summer. Speaking of which, Chapman and her fellow spies busted in 2010 were the inspiration for the series: Olivia B. Waxman - Q&A: The CIA Officer Behind the New Spy Drama The Americans Time 01/30/2013

But the diplomatic flaps that the Snowden affair and what seems to be hamhanded handling of it by the Obama Administration are more series that Anna Chapman publicity stunts. The revelations of NSA spying on the EU nations has caused some upset. And it seems to be more than just leaders doing the required posturing for domestic political reasons to show they maintain some national pride. Stephen Walt writes in News Flash: States Spy on Each Other Foreign Policy 07/03/2013:

The National Security Agency has done us all a service by reminding the world that international politics is still a) inherently competitive and b) primarily conducted by nation-states. I refer, of course, to the recent revelations that in addition to spying on U.S. citizens, the National Security Agency (NSA) has also been spying on America's European allies. You know: our closest strategic partners!
But he also notes that there may be some substantive consequences to this:

Which is not to say this aspect of the Snowden affair won't have significant consequences. Exposure of the NSA's efforts is bound to complicate efforts to negotiate a transatlantic trade and investment agreement [TTIP], an initiative that faced plenty of obstacles already. It is also going to give ammunition to all those people who are worried about the globalization of information and who would like to see governments do more to protect privacy and limit both corporate and governmental data-collection. And that makes me wonder whether we are now at the high-water mark of loosely regulated global connectivity, and that all these revelations will eventually lead both democracies and authoritarian societies to place much stricter limits on how information flows between societies (and individuals).

If so, then you should probably enjoy the Wild West of Internet freedom while you can, before the firewalls go up.
As I've said before, I won't be crying if EU upset over the spying disrupts the progress of the TTIP negotiations, because it's already looking to be a bad deal for most people in the countries affected. And speaking of which, I see indications that the real upset by EU government was over the extent of what is still called "industrial espionage." In other words, the EU One Percent is especially worried that the NSA is tapping into private trade and proprietary information and passing it on to American corporations. But that's not to minimize fears on the part of the majority that the US is tapping into their private conversations with no good reason. Spain's former Foreign Minister Ana Palacio from the conservative party (PP) also highlights the connection between uproar over NSA spying in Europe with the TTIP negotiations (The Snowden Effect Project Syndicate 07/04/2013):

... Europeans have raised serious questions about US intelligence practices. These range from the lack of professionalism implied by allowing contractors to conduct such sensitive work to America's hands-off approach toward certain allies, like the United Kingdom and New Zealand, while relegating many of its other allies – including most of the European Union – to surveillance-worthy status.

The bitter irony is that, at this suddenly inauspicious moment, Europe and the US are launching their most significant joint project since the creation of NATO – a transatlantic free-trade agreement. For the sake of its success, is it really too much to ask of the US that it play its part internationally with a bit more skill and professionalism, and that it treat its partners with respect?
Andrea Böhm argues in Purer Selbstverrat Zeit Online 05.07.2013 that the famous "soft power" of the US comes not just from the cultural industry ("Hollywood") and technological innovation ("Silicon Valley") but also from the country's continuing struggle to realize its own ideals. Joschka Fischer, for instance, the former Green Party leader and former German Foreign Minister, admire the democratic self-renewal that the US has repeatedly displayed in our history. But, Böhm notes, that struggle to realize democratic ideals looks like it is tapped out at the moment. "Amerika hat derzeit nicht die Kraft zu Selbstkorrektur. Die muss jetzt anders entstehen." ("At this time, America doesn't have the power for self-correction. It must comes from somewhere else now.") The NSA surveillance revelations have highlighted the similarities between the Obama and Cheney-Bush Administrations on extreme domestic spying practices.

And Böhm rightly points to the key problem in that regard of the state of Permanent War, of which the War on Terrorism has become a continuation of the Cold War. "Er [Obama] kann das amerikanische Militär von den Kriegsschauplätzen in Afghanistan und im Irak abziehen, nicht aber sein Land aus dem geistigen Kriegszustand lösen – und vielleicht will er es auch gar nicht." ("He [Obama] can pull the American military out of the battlefields in Afghanistan and Iraq, but not release his country out of the mental state of war - and maybe he also just doesn't want to.")

That attitude helps explain how the diplomatic hostilities over Snowden have spread to South America with the retaining of Bolivian President Evo Morales plane in Vienna this week for over 13 hours because France, Italy, Portugal and Spain withdrew overflight rights after his plane departed from Moscow. The Real News reports in Bolivians Indignant at European Treatment of President Morales 07/04/2013:



The Young Turks also report on the story in Why Is Obama Bullying the President of Bolivia? 07/04/2013:



Martín Granovsky in Lo que hay detrás Página/12 05.07.2013 notes that although the formal complaints are being directed against the European countries that played games with overflight, the main actor in this drama is clearly the United States. Bolivia is protesting, apparently with good reason, that withdrawing the overflight rights was a serious violation of diplomatic protocol and international law. They even used the word "kidnapped," to describe Evo's stopover in Vienna.

But Bolivia doesn't seem to be complaining about Austria's conduct. Austrian President Heinz Fischer posted this photo of him greeting Evo at the airport ("Boliviens Präsident Evo Morales kann Heimreise fortsetzen": Statement von Bundespräsident Heinz Fischer 03.07.2013):

Bolivian Presisdent Evo Morales and Austrian President Heinz Fischer

Less obviously plausible is Bolivia's argument that Evo's life was endangered by the overflight problem. I suppose this argument is based on the pilot's message, heard in The Young Turks report, that they had to land because their were running out of fuel.

The South American alliance UNASUR have issued a formal protest against France, Italy, Portugal and Spain in solidarity with Bolivia, Declaración de la UNASUR frente al agravio sufrido por el Presidente Evo Morales 04.07.2013, calling their action a continuation of "colonial practices." (Technically, the declaration in the name of "Las Jefas y Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de países de la Unión de Naciones Sudamericanas (UNASUR), reunidos en Cochabamba" (the chiefs of state and government of countries of the Union of South American Nations {UNASUR} meeting in Cochabamba", Bolivia under the auspices of UNASUR. This Reuters headline spins it as South American leftist leaders rally for Bolivia in Snowden saga 07/05/2013. The actual "chiefs of state and government" were Evo Morales himself, Argentina's Cristina Fernández, Venezuela's Nicolás Maduro, Peru's Rafael Correa, Uruguay's José Mujica and Surinam's Dési Boutarese. As Reuters reports:

At the end of the summit ... a statement was issued demanding answers from France, Portugal, Italy and Spain. The United States was not mentioned in the statement.

"Europe broke all the rules of the game," Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro said shortly after arriving at the Cochabamba airport. "We're here to tell President Evo Morales that he can count on us. Whoever picks a fight with Bolivia, picks a fight with Venezuela."

Maduro said an unnamed European government minister had told Venezuela that the CIA, the U.S. spy agency, was behind the incident.

"We are not colonies any more," Uruguayan President Jose Mujica said. "We deserve respect, and when one of our governments is insulted we feel the insult throughout Latin America." ...

Noticeably absent from the Cochabamba gathering was the president of regional heavyweight Brazil, Dilma Rousseff, who sent her international affairs adviser and a deputy foreign minister to the meeting.

The presidents and foreign ministers of Chile, Peru and Colombia, which have good relations with the United States, also stayed away. In a written statement, Colombia's foreign ministry called on Bolivia and the European governments involved to find a diplomatic solution.

Bolivia and Venezuela were also irked at receiving provisional arrest requests for Snowden from Washington, a move Bolivia called "illegal and unfounded".
The UNASUR statement (or UNASUR Six?), aka, Declaration of Cochabamba, called the overflight denials violations of international law and says that Evo was "virtually taken hostage" ("convirtiéndolo virtualmente en un rehén").

In this kind of diplomatic situation, it's important to keep in mind that politically operative assumptions are not the same as journalistically or legally documented facts. So far as I'm aware as of this writing, Washington has not admitted to pushing France, Italy, Portugal or Spain to withdraw overflight rights from Evo's plane. But it's a very plausible assumption, almost an inevitable one. Cenk Uygur in The Young Turks report does a decent job of framing that. He also addresses the uncertainty as to whether the plane was actually searched while it was on the ground in Vienna. Marcy Wheeler writes in Europe again stuck saying, "They told us they were sure" Emptywheel 07/05/2013:

In point of fact, it’s not yet clear Snowden wasn't on the plane. While Austrian authorities checked the passports of the known passengers on the plane, they apparently did not conduct a thorough search. And 3 Spaniards who showed up to conduct a search were denied entry (though Morales did stop in the Canary Islands, which would have provided another opportunity to conduct a search on Spanish territory, but by that point Morales was already making a literal international incident about his treatment).
Granovsky quotes Argentine human rights attorney Leandro Despouy, one of the authors of the 2009 UN special report that charged prisoners were being tortured in the Guantánamo gulag station, points out that some of the countries denying overflight rights to Evo's plane did grant overflight to American planes they knew to be carrying prisoners kidnapped by the United States.

Diana Cariboni and Jared Metzker comment on the Latin American angle to the story in Snowden Is No Trifling Matter IPS News 07/04/2013:

Morales' aircraft was rerouted and forced to land in Austria, where it was stuck on the tarmac for 14 hours. The governments implicated in the incident brandished technical explanations, and after hours of heated negotiations, the presidential jet was allowed to take off again.

While it was grounded, the plane and its passengers were apparently subjected to some kind of inspection, the scope of which is not yet clear. But afterwards, Austria's foreign minister, Michael Spindelegger, stated that there were only Bolivian citizens in the aircraft.

The incident violates international law, because aircraft carrying national leaders have diplomatic immunity. Bolivian diplomats complained at the United Nations that Morales had been "kidnapped" during the time he was grounded in Austria. And the indignation spread to other South American governments.
They also report on the diplomatic pressures the US is bringing against offers of asylum to Snowden. The highly unusual action against Evo Morales is part of this pressure:

Michael Shifter, president of the Washington-based Inter-American Dialogue think tank, said "It seems either the U.S. had something to do (with the decision to deny the airspace) or it was done out of a sense of solidarity with the U.S.

It is possible they made the decision alone based on a recognition of how serious this issue is to the U.S."

Shifter said that normally such a drastic step would indicate a state of war. He described it as "An extreme overreaction ... Whatever one thinks about Snowden or Morales, it seems like this was disrespectful of international law."

He also said the incident "looks terrible in political terms.“It was out of proportion. It reflects a patronising, paternalistic mindset that stronger countries can bully weaker ones."

But he disagreed with Younger that it would facilitate a Latin American refuge for Snowden. "What this ultimately underscores is how seriously the U.S. regards this case," he said.

"It may be tempting to take Snowden in in order to needle the U.S., but the consequences of that will have to be taken into consideration. The U.S., for all its weaknesses, is still the U.S.," he said. [my emphasis]
Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

Monday, July 01, 2013

More surveillance stories

Here a couple of quick takes on the US dragnet surveillance story.

Greg Miller, Misinformation on classified NSA programs includes statements by senior U.S. officials Washington Post 06/30/2013; see commentary by Digby, Whose interests are the secrets serving? Hullabaloo 07/01/2013, Miller's article addresses one point of interpretation in the early Glenn Greenwald reporting on Edward Snowden's revelations, "News accounts of the NSA programs have also contained inaccuracies, in some cases because of the source materials. Classified NSA slides that were published by The Post indicated that the NSA was able to tap directly into the servers of Google, Microsoft, Apple and other technology companies. The companies denied that they allowed direct access to their equipment, although they did not dispute that they cooperated with the NSA."

Rick Perlstein made much of that distinction in his dispute with Greenwald over the story. See Glenn Greenwald's 'Epic Botch'? The Nation 06/13/2013 and subsequent posts in Rick's Nation blog. Perlstein relies heavily in his criticism on the arguments of Karl Fogel, which he elaborates in Epic botch of the PRISM story Rants.org 06/11/2013 and further posts on that blog.

But it has always sounded to me like a distinction without much of a difference.

Ludwig Greven, Merkel muss den USA jetzt drohen Zeit Online 01.07.2013 applauds the idea of the EU threatening the US over the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) to get them to back off the current level of, uh, friendly espionage they the Obama Administration conducting against our EU and NATO (supposed) friends and partners.

Barrett Brown holds forth on The cyber-intelligence complex and its useful idiots Guardian 07/01/2013:

Summing up the position of those who worry less over secret government powers than they do over the whistleblowers who reveal such things, we have New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman, who argues that we can trust small cadres of unaccountable spies with broad powers over our communications. We must all wish Friedman luck with this prediction. Other proclamations of his – including that Vladimir Putin would bring transparency and liberal democracy to Russia, and that the Chinese regime would not seek to limit its citizens' free access to the internet – have not aged especially well.

An unkind person might dismiss Friedman as the incompetent harbinger of a dying republic. Being polite, I will merely suggest that Friedman's faith in government is as misplaced as faith in the just and benevolent God that we know not to exist – Friedman having been the winner of several of the world's most-coveted Pulitzer Prizes.
Tags: , , , , , ,

Sunday, June 30, 2013

Massive NSA spying and the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Pact (TTIP)



Video report from Euronews, New NSA spy claims hit Germany as EU calls on Washington for explanations 06/30/2013


This could be one very good effect of the NSA spying revelations, to make it harder to get a deal closed on the US-EU Transatlantic Trade and Investment Pact (TTIP), a treaty currently being negotiated that is basically aimed at undercutting regulations on banks and other corporations, lowering incomes for most people and overriding existing consumer protection laws. (Claus Hecking and Stefan Schultz, Spying 'Out of Control': EU Official Questions Trade Negotiations Spiegel International 06/30/2013)

Maybe if corporations start realizing that the massive domestic surveillance programs could really start costing them money by torpedoing a treaty they want, some of them will start pushing politicians they, uh, sponsor, to put some functional privancy limits in place. Not that the TTIP would be any better because of that!

Of course, the Obama Administration and other supporters of the spectacularly wide-ranging might say this is more evidence of how Edward Snowden and news outlets that printed his and other revelations about the NSA spying program have hurt the national interests of the US.

Part of what is going on here, I say as someone who hasn't followed the news about "cyberwar" and cyber espionage in great detail, seems to be that the world is hashing out new standards for what is acceptable and unacceptable spying. Of course, all countries outlaw espionage, even for friendly countries. And all countries engage in it, including against friendly countries.

So alongside the laws that are often honored in the breach, there is an elaborate set of diplomatic protocols and side agreements about just how far one country will go in retaliating against another for routine espionage. And part of what we're seeing now is surely a shaking out of what those new informal practices and protocols will be in international law and foreign relations will be.

But as the EU's reaction shows, some European countries that are on very friendly terms with the United States think that the US stepped over that informal line. When it comes to dragnet spying, the formal, legal restrictions don't seem to concern the Obama Administration excessively.

Chris Strohm reports for Bloomberg Businessweek in A Privacy Board Was Supposed to Protect Americans From NSA Spies 06/27/2013 that the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board that is one of the "transparency" and oversight safeguards against the program being abused is about as useless as the Congress and the courts have been in exercising any oversight or imposing any limits on whatever domestic spying the President decides he wants to do.

So, we know the NSA and other federal and local agencies are conducted what collectively amounts to a gigantic domestic surveillance dragnet. The federal programs have what is apparently no effective oversight on what the Executive Branch is doing with the program. There is a secret court, the FISA court, that approves broad Executive requests and issues secret warrants but it's all secret. Citizens can't get any relief from the regular federal court system because the Administration argues no one has standing to take action unless they can prove they're being spied on and they can't prove that unless the Administration provides information on the programs and they don't because they're secret. There is nominal Congressional oversight, but none of them can talk publicly and explicitly about programs going on that they see are dangerous or illegal because the programs are secret. Even when Members of Congress think Administration officials are committing the federal felony of lying to Congress about the programs, they can't say publicly why they think a crime is being committed because it's all secret.

Supposedly these programs are helping the Administration catch terrorists all over the place. But they can't tell us anything convincing on who or how because it's secret. And the revelations about the program from Snowden's leaks are damaging the anti-terrorism effort badly. But they can't say how, either, because it's all secret. Except for the leaks of apparently classified information that say it's having some bad effects, leaks which aren't prosecuted by the Administration. Or officially verified. Because it's all secret.

The mainstream media, to the extent they don't try to ignore the programs altogether, are generally uninterested in serious investigative reporting on them - fortunately with a few exceptions. Since everything's secret, the public's information on what their government is doing with these vast surveillance programs, even on the broad outlines of the programs, is largely coming from whistleblowers who risk espionage charges, life in prison or indefinite exile abroad to make the information public. Even when the actions revealed may be illegal actions against American citizens. And the conventional wisdom among the Beltway Village reporters is more inclined to criticize the government for not having caught the leakers sooner than to push for more responsible reporting on the massive domestic spying programs.

I suppose if you think that Obama, and all of the folks at the Pentagon, the CIA, the FBI, and all of the 1.4 million holders of security clearances, many of them working at private contractors like Edward Snowden was, will always be honest and responsible in their acquisition and use of the information, then it's all great. Even though anonymous pro-Administration sources are telling the press that it will take the government months yet to figure out what all Snowden may have taken.

I'm certainly not convinced.

Tags: , , , , , ,

Friday, June 28, 2013

Obama, a President who has seriously failed the rule of law

"It is not ... war crimes and torture that upsets the Nobel Peace Prize winner in the White House, but rather those that manage to make these crimes public," writes Ralph Sina in George W. Obama: Das Ende einer Hoffnung Blätter für deutsche und internationale Politik 7/2013 (July 2013) ("Es sind somit nicht Kriegsverbrechen und Folter, die den Friedensnobelpreisträger im Weißen Haus empören, sondern jene, die es wagen, diese Verbrechen publik zu machen.")

Sina's article focuses on Obama's massive domestic and international spying programs and his harsh war on whistleblowers including Bradley Manning and Edward Snowden. The article could have used some closer editing. In the first paragraph, for instance he says that George W. Bush retired to his "farm", apparently unaware that Bush dumped his famous ranch for a place in Dallas as soon as he no longer saw the need for the ranch as a showplace where he could imitate Ronald Reagan playing a cowboy.

But he does make some important points. One that I don't see made often enough about Obama treatment of Bradley Manning was his openly declaring that Manning was guilty of a crime. As Commander-in-Chief of the armed forces, this creates tremendous and illegitimate pressure on the military court martial to find him guilty and hand out the most severe sentence. Some of the "torture-like" conditions to which Manning was subjected were modified when a reporter finally confronted Obama with a question about it in public. But it went on unconscionably for a long time. And there was no indication that Obama ordered any disciplinary measures for those who ordered Manning's disgraceful treatment.

Obama, after all, had already publicly declared Manning a criminal and (effectively) a traitor. And he adopted an indefensible Look Forward Not Backward policy toward prosecuting torture crimes and war crimes under the Cheney-Bush Administration.

He points also to the shameless situation, which Obama as President owns, that at least 56 inmates at the Guantánamo torture gulag that even the authoritarian Obama Administration acknowledge to be innocent of any crime are still indefinitely imprisoned there. Obama, who has no scruples launched drone "signature strike" assassination against completely unknown persons, has the power to have fixed that situation for those innocent men. He also has the power and the solemn obligation to prosecute those who falsely imprisoned men like that them and tortured so many, brutally murdering some of them in the process. But he won't prosecute the torturers. And I fully expect he will leave office with those innocent prisoners at Guantánamo still there with no foreseeable prospect of resolving their situation.

Obama's most important Constitutional responsibility as President was and still is restoring the rule of law after the Cheney-Bush Administration's tortures and war crimes. He has completely rejected that responsibility.

Toward the end of the piece, Sina points out that Obama's extreme policies on electronic surveillance mean that the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP), the neoliberal trade treaty now being negotiated between the US and the EU, would carry real dangers for EU laws and constitutional principles of privacy and individual rights. These treaties are a favorite instrument in the neoliberal framework of economic policy to undermine protections for workers and consumers and, in the case of telecommunications, individual rights for the financial benefit of the corporations involved and for the governments dominated by them.

Sina concludes of Obama, "Nicht nur Amerika hat einen großen Hoffnungsträger verloren, sondern auch Europa." ("Not only America but also Europe has lost a great focus for hope.")

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, June 26, 2013

More reassurances on the secret spying program that can't provide reassurances because it's secret

Rebecca Greenfield reports for The Atlantic Wire, Al Qaeda Has Changed How It Talks Since the NSA Leaks, but How Much? 06/26/2013. she explains in the last paragraph:

Since the leaks began three weeks ago today, intelligence officials have demonized Snowden by claiming that his leaks affected national security efforts by tipping off terror organizations. Really, that's the whole defense of the program: "[Snowden] has basically alerted people who are enemies of this country ... (like) al-Qaida, about what techniques we have been using to monitor their activities and foil plots, and compromised those efforts, and it's very conceivable that people will die as a result," said U.S. Senator Angus King earlier this week. So far, though, it's unclear how much spying on U.S. citizens has helped anti-terror efforts. [my emphasis]
That's the Administration's defense - and that of its Republican and Democratic supporters in Congress: the domestic spying is helping lots and lots. But we can't tell you how because it's all secret. Trust us.

And, oh by the way, it will take us months to figure out what information this one employee of a private contractor, Edward Snowden, took from our super-duper domestic spying records that are keeping you safe though we can't tell you how and we're not really even supposed to be saying the program exists.

As Marcy Wheeler points out in Shorter WaPo: It Would Take Months to Know about Spying Misconduct Emptywheel 06/25/2013, this is an odd argument for the Obama Administration to be making through anonymous sources:

Funny thing is, if all that were true — if the government is still struggling to figure out what Snowden took a month after he left NSA — it indicates that the government would not know if a Sysadmin at the NSA had spied on Americans, if ever, until months after someone did so.

But, promise, this giant dragnet is secure.
Trust us.

From Aljazeera English, Snowden 'is in Moscow airport transit zone' 06/25/2013:



Greenfield passes along an Administration claim about how Snowden's leaks helped "Al Qaeda", with appropriate caution:

Following the Edward Snowden leaks that detailed a large part of the process by which the U.S. government's largest intelligence agency spies on terrorists — and American citizens — Al Qaeda has reportedly (and predictably) started tweaking the way it communicates, but in a way the doesn't necessarily make it harder for the National Security Agency to track them. "[A] lawmaker briefed on the matter said al-Qaida's Yemeni offshoot, al-Qaida in the Arabian Peninsula, has been among the first to alter how it reaches out to its operatives," reports the Associated Press's Kimberly Dozier, referring to what is thought of as the most active group of the network. The AP sources, of course, cited secrecy in declining to elaborate on how Al Qaeda has shifted its digital tactics: "The officials wouldn't go into details on how they know this, whether it's terrorists switching email accounts or cellphone providers or adopting new encryption techniques," she continues. [my emphasis]
But, you know, trust us. We're keeping you safe. Though we can't tell you how. And anybody who does tell you how is committing espionage. Unless it's an anonymous Administration sources of some kind, in which case it's okay.

I wish the media and the Democrats would start being more critical about this Secret Superpower that is known by the name "Al Qaeda". As far as I can tell based on what I've seen in the public record and from my perspective as a non-security-clearance citizen, the group headed by Osama bin Laden that was called "Al Qaeda" no longer exists in recognizable form, though presumably few of its members are still at large. The groups that call themselves "Al Qaeda in xxxxx" seem to be using the label as a generic name, sort of like "kleenex" became a generic name for hand tissues, even ones that aren't sold by Kleenex.

But Members of Congress, government officials including the President, and the press keep talking about the Secret Superpower "Al Qaeda" as though its an ongoing entity from the time of the 9/11 attacks.

Tags: , ,

Monday, June 24, 2013

Snowden's asylum-seeking

Marcy Wheeler analyzes some of the implications of the Obama Administration overreach in its charges against Edward Snowden in Obama’s Stubbornness and the Risk of Snowden Emptywheel 06/24/2013:

The most likely approach to lead to further damage, however, is to charge him with Espionage. This not only raises the specter of the treatment we’ve given Bradley Manning — giving Snowden Denise Lind’s judgement that Manning’s rights were violated to include in any asylum application — but also easily falls under what states can call political crimes, which permits them to ignore extradition requests. That is, we appear to be pursuing the approach that could lead to greater damage.

By contrast, letting Snowden get someplace safe is perfectly equivalent to letting the CIA off for torture (or, for that matter, James Clapper off for lying to Congress). It’s a violation of rule of law, but it also serves to minimize the tremendous damage the spooks might do to retaliate. Obama has chosen this path already when the criminals were his criminals; he clearly doesn’t have the least bit of compunction of setting aside rule of law for pragmatic reasons. But in Snowden’s case, he seems to be pursuing a strategy that not only might increase the likelihood of damage, but also lets China and Russia retaliate for perceived slights along the way.

All this is just an observation. I believe Obama’s relentless attacks on whistleblowers and his ruthless enforcement of information asymmetry have actually raised the risk of something like this. And he seems to be prioritizing proving the power of the US (which has, thus far, only proved our diminishing influence) over limiting damage Snowden might do. [my emphasis]

CNN interviews Glenn Greenwald on the Snowden case, Greenwald defends NSA leaker Snowden 06/23/2013:



Kevin Gosztola discusses Snowden's asylum request to Ecuador in Snowden's Asylum Request: 'Unlikely I Would Receive Fair Trial or Proper Treatment Prior to Trial' FDL 06/24/2013:

Earlier this morning, I published a post titled, "Leaving the US Doesn't Make Snowden Any Less of a Whistleblower." I highlighted this reality the United States government faces where leakers are now fleeing because they believe they will be punished unlawfully and subjected to harsh conditions, as Manning was during his confinement at Quantico.

This and the fact that people like Secretary of State John Kerry are talking about Snowden being a traitor, who committed acts of espionage, is not going to help persuade any country to return Snowden.

Moreover, there is a lot of huffing and puffing going on about the "rule of law" and how Russia must follow it and arrest Snowden and send him back to the US. However, Snowden has submitted an application for asylum and, as long as that is pending, Russia is supposed to respect that application and not override it by having him extradited.
I was never much impressed by the argument that Snowden's leaking would have somehow been more virtuous or honorable if he had stayed around in the US to be arrested. Since the Obama Administration is pursuing a de facto policy that any leaking of even non-classified and non-harmful information about national security is aiding enemies of the US, Snowden would have been foolish not to take Obama's draconian policy against leakers and whistleblowers into full account.

David Sirota in Why shouldn't David Gregory be charged with a crime? Salon 06/24/2013 addresses that issue:

Snowden’s decision to flee the United States has often been depicted as an act of treason unto itself. The idea is that whereas Daniel Ellsberg was a hero for blowing the whistle and remaining in the United States, Snowden is a coward for blowing the whistle and fleeing. Left largely unmentioned is the big change between the time of Ellsberg’s disclosures and today: This White House is waging an unprecedented campaign to criminalize whistle-blowing; it sometimes tortures whistle-blowers; and it claims the right to extra-judicially assassinate American citizens who criticize the government but haven't even been formally charged for a single crime. In light of this, why have most media outlets not bothered to even ask whether Snowden's location outside the United States is, unto itself, a response to these troubling changes in U.S. government policy?
These are real concerns. Federal whistleblowers on national security issues cannot expect to be treated fairly or even legally by the US Government under the Obama Administration. It's bad policy. And whistleblowers would be foolish to ignore its reality.

I'll add here that I'm glad Snowden made the leaks that broke this story out of the shadows. I'm withholding judgment on his motivations, partly because I don't actually care about them at the moment. But I'm also giving him the benefit of the doubt on that count.

Tags: , ,

Priorities and the Snowden leaks

The Edward Snowden case is obviously a big deal. Secretary of State John Kerry is rattling the diplomatic sabres with Russia and China over it, as Spiegel Online reports in Affäre um Whistleblower Snowden: Kerry droht China und Russland 24.06.2013.

I was glad that Nancy Pelosi caught some static at Netroots Nation this weekend over Edward Snowden and the domestic spying programs.

And I take it for granted that Snowden broke the classification laws. And presumably even his most passionate admirers recognize that he did so. Snowden himself certainly seems to believe he did.

I would qualify that only to say that in our post-9/11 secrecy state, the scope of the classification laws haven't been adequately tested in the court system.

Daniel Ellsberg isn't a fan of the current domestic espionage program. And in Ellsberg: A Coup Against the Constitution 06/15/2013 he also addresses some of the real Constitutional issues involved:



But what Snowden disclosed was a confirmation of a massive domestic surveillance program unsuited to a democratic society and ultimately incompatible with it. Some of those who have regarded Snowden and his revelations with a jaundiced eye argue that we all knew that something like this was going on anyway. Gene Lyons, for instance, who has been paying close attention to this story, writes in Cyber Warfare Beats The Other Kind 06/19/2013:

Privacy in the 18th century sense vanished with the Internet, and it’s never coming back. It’s childish to think otherwise.

Yesterday my wife dropped my binoculars, knocking them out of whack. Before I figured out how to fix them I priced a new pair on Amazon. This morning, Facebook sent me an advert for Chinese-made Bushnells costing far less than the originals. By tomorrow, they’ll be back to selling me patent medicines somehow involving pretty women with preposterously large breasts. They don’t know that I suffer from maladies their "weird secrets" purport to cure, but they definitely know my age and gender.

MasterCard recently shut me down because their computer algorithm correctly deduced that a guy who spends most of his money buying cattle feed in Arkansas probably wasn’t buying a huge HDTV in Mexico City. Amazon knows that I've read all the Henning Mankell "Kurt Wallender" novels and thinks I may have a thing for Scandinavian murder mysteries.
But Amazon is following your purchases to sell you more stuff. Amazon can't put you in jail, or hold you in an isolation cell for months or years as an "enemy combatant."

If Amazon slips up and lets it slip publicly that you're ordering a lot of novels that fans of Fifty Shades of Gray are also ordering, that might be embarrassing. If you work for, say, Chick-Fil-A, it might even get you fired. But if you get fingered by the government as a Terrorist, that's a whole different set of problems. Does our whiz-bang national security bureaucracy sometimes make serious mistakes on these things? You can ask Steven Hatfill about that. (David Willman, Anthrax subject receives payout Los Angeles Times 06/28/2013)

The fact that computer technology allows a bloated, heavily privatized national security state to collect and store vast amounts of data on everybody means that privacy concerns and the need for privacy protection are more urgent, not less. There is an enormous difference Amazon annoying you with pop-up ads and the FBI or NSA trying to turn you into the next Steven Hatfill based on some flawed algorithm based on your patterns of phone calls and e-mails. One of those things has far more serious consequences for the person on the receiving end than the other.

Nor am I persuaded by the argument Pelosi and other Obama defenders are making of the massive domestic surveillance program, that it was bad under Cheney and Bush because they were doing it illegally, but Congress legalized what they doing and Obama is getting a vague warrant from a secret court and so now it's all good.


No, it's not. And whether it's legal or not also hasn't been tested adequately in court, because the Obama Administration has used the secrecy of the programs themselves to block court challenges to their legality and constitutionality.

Digby is dead right on this point (Let's open this thing up already Hullabaloo 06/21/2013):

One of the most laughable comments the NSA program supporters have been making is the one insisting that the FISA court is "transparent." It's rulings are secret as are the government's interpretations of the law and those rulings. If that's what we call due process these days, we might as well just officially institute a Star Chamber and call it a day.
After the Cheney-Bush Administration, the most urgent Constitutional task Obama had was to restore the rule of law and prosecute torture perpetrators. Instead, he's practiced a Look Forward Not Backward non-prosecution policy for high government officials who break the law on the pretense they are doing so for National Security Of The Homeland and for wealthy bankers who crashed the world financial system and rip off millions of people. He hasn't restored the rule of law, he's reinforced the trend toward blatant class justice.

And it's clear that the Obama Administration has been more aggressive than any before on pursuing whistleblowers and leakers. Marisa Taylor and Jonathan Landay give us a glimpse of how extreme it has become in Obama's crackdown views leaks as aiding enemies of U.S. McClatchy 06/20/2013:

President Barack Obama's unprecedented initiative, known as the Insider Threat Program, is sweeping in its reach. It has received scant public attention even though it extends beyond the U.S. national security bureaucracies to most federal departments and agencies nationwide, including the Peace Corps, the Social Security Administration and the Education and Agriculture departments. It emphasizes leaks of classified material, but catchall definitions of "insider threat" give agencies latitude to pursue and penalize a range of other conduct.

Government documents reviewed by McClatchy illustrate how some agencies are using that latitude to pursue unauthorized disclosures of any information, not just classified material. They also show how millions of federal employees and contractors must watch for "high-risk persons or behaviors" among co-workers and could face penalties, including criminal charges, for failing to report them. Leaks to the media are equated with espionage.

"Hammer this fact home ... leaking is tantamount to aiding the enemies of the United States," says a June 1, 2012, Defense Department strategy for the program that was obtained by McClatchy.
And far from rethinking their draconian approach, Taylor and Landay report that the Administration takes the latest revelations as evidence they need to double-down in their drive against leakers: "The Obama administration is expected to hasten the program's implementation as the government grapples with the fallout from the leaks of top secret documents by Edward Snowden."

Charlie Pierce explains some of the obvious problems with this kind of official paranoia in The Snowden Effect, Special Sunday Edition Esquire Politics Blog 06/23/2013:

You want "Nixonian"? This, right here, this is Nixonian, if Nixon had grown up in East Germany. You've got the entire federal bureaucracy looking for signs of "high-risk persons or behaviors" the way Nixon sent Fred Malek out to count the Jews. You've got created within the entire federal bureaucracy a culture of spies and informers, which will inevitably breed fear and deceit and countless acts of interoffice treachery. (Don't like your boss at the Bureau Of Land Management? Hmm, he looks like a high-risk person. Tell someone.)
Then there is problem of officially-directed but still illegal leaks of classified information for purpose of making the Administration look good.

Which brings me back to Secretary of State Kerry's huffing and puffing at Russia and China. If enforcing the rule of law on Edward Snowden is important enough to add a significant new grievance to our relations with those two countries, then the torture crimes of the Cheney-Bush Administration are important enough to prosecute. Not only are they far more significant in terms of the rule of law. The Torture Convention Treaty signed by St. Reagan and approved by the Senate thereby becoming the law of the land requires it. So do other American laws. And if a leak like Snowden's that brings accountability to a massive domestic surveillance program that is a real threat to democratic government - and to sane law-enforcement and defense priorities - is serious enough to prosecute, so are leaks by Administration officials designed to make it look good.

Like, for instance, the one reported on by Mark Hosenball in Exclusive: Did White House "spin" tip a covert op? Reuters 05/18/2012.

See also David Sirota's Why shouldn't David Gregory be charged with a crime? Salon for some relevant discussion of this question. Put another way, if someone violates the classification laws and regulations, that would pretty obviously be grounds for discipline or dismissal from their positions and revocation or adjustment of their classification clearances.

But unless there is clear venal motive, i.e, selling information for money, or identifiable damage to security beyond a vague classification-is-sacred assumption, it's a matter of legitimate discretion whether they should be prosecuted for a crime. But since the Obama Administration is making a practice of going after high-profile leakers like Snowden for espionage, then the wink-and-a-nod attitude toward links of classified information that support the White House's PR efforts are all the more egregious.

Also, as much as we might like to think so, the world does not revolve around American Exceptionalism. Arrogance and overreach can produce blowback, which could be part of what is going on with Russia in the Snowden case: Marcy Wheeler, Remember How Angry Russia Is about Viktor Bout Emptywheel 06/24/2013.

Tags: , , ,