Showing posts with label elaine pagels. Show all posts
Showing posts with label elaine pagels. Show all posts

Monday, July 30, 2012

Elaine Pagels' book on the Book of Revelation

Biblical scholar Elaine Pagels has done a popular book on the Apocalypse of John, aka, the Book of Revelation, called Revelations: Visions, Prophecy, & Politics in the Book of Revelation (2012).


By "popular", I mean it's not a scholarly book as such. She doesn't lead the reader through discussion of Greek participles.

But it is written from a scholar's viewpoint. She's analyzing the history of the book and the story of how it came to be included in the New Testament canon during the fourth century CE. As she explains, the first list of the enduring New Testament canon of which we know is from a letter from the Bishop Athanasius in 367 CE.

A specialist in the Gnostic texts found at Nag Hammadi in 1945, Pagels uses some of those esoteric works to recreate some of the religious and historical context in which the Book of Revelation was written and understood until it became part of the established Christian canon of Scripture.

She doesn't walk us through the history of the book through the following 15 centuries. But she does make some informed observations about the persistence of its popularity, for better or worse:

We need not rehearse the history of religious violence-from crusaders fighting "infidels" and inquisitors torturing and killing Jews to save their immortal souls, to Catholics and Protestants fighting religious wars from the sixteenth century on, or Christian groups engaged in vigilante violence to the present time, or the wartime rhetoric of world leaders - to realize how often those who wield power and see themselves standing' on God's side against Satan's have sought to force "God's enemies" to submit or be killed. Such apocalyptic fervor, whether engaged in by Christians or Muslims, allows no neutral ground between God's kingdom and the lake of fire, and no room for compromise, much less for human-or humane-interaction. [my emphasis]
She notes that the notion of justice in history, or maybe it should be History, is one of the ideas that people have taken from Revelation.

Yet John's Book of Revelation appeals not only to fear but also to hope. As John tells how the chaotic events of the world are finally set right by divine judgment, those who engage his visions often see them offering meaning-moral meaning - in times of suffering or apparently random catastrophe. Many poets, artists, and preachers who engage these prophecies claim to have found in them the promise, famously repeated by Martin Luther King Jr., that "the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice."
That saying is also a favorite of President Barack Obama's.

And it is also important to remember that John's Apocalypse promises a bright ultimate future for the elect:

Finally, too, this worst of all nightmares ends not in terror but in a glorious new world, radiant with the light of God's presence, flowing with the water of life, abounding in joy and delight. Whether one sees in John's visions the destruction of the whole world or the dark tunnel that propels each of us toward our own death, his final vision suggests that even after the worst we can imagine has happened, we may find the astonishing gift of new life. Whether one shares that conviction, few readers miss seeing how these visions offer consolation and that most necessary of divine gifts - hope.
The philosopher Karl Löwith argued that the concept of meaning in history was based on Jewish and Christian thought: "it is only within a preestablished horizon of ultimate meaning, however hidden it may be, that actual history seems to be meaningless. This horizon has been established by history, for it is Jewish and Christian thinking that brought this colossal question into existence." (my emphasis) (Löwith, "The Theological Background of The Philosophy of History" Social Research 13:1/4; 1946)

Revelation originally spoke to a world in which Christians were persecuted by the secular power of Rome in "actual history". But it promised that this "actual history" was, if not exactly meaningless, insignificant seen against the ultimate victory of the Lord over the forces of evil. "The very existence of a philosophy of history and its quest for a meaning is due to the history of salvation; it emerged from the faith in an ultimate purpose," writes Löwith. He argues that it is in the Jewish and Christian apocalyptic literature in particular that we find the roots of Western theories of meaning in history, even the distinctly secular ones:

The Greek historians wrote pragmatic history centered around a great political event; the fathers of the church developed from Jewish prophecy a theology of history focused on the supra-historical events of creation, incarnation and consummation; the moderns elaborate a philosophy of history by secularizing theological principles and applying them to an ever increasing number of empirical facts.
One of the issues around the Book of Revelation is to what degree it was a specifically Christian document. As Pagels explains, the author was likely a Jewish Christian follower of Jesus who does not specifically refer to himself as "Christian". The initial followers of Jesus were Jews like himself, of course. But the Jesus movement among Jews fast developed distinctive features and Gentile converts started coming in significant numbers soon after Jesus' death. The conflicts between Jewish Christians and Gentile Christians are evidenced in Paul's letters and in the Acts of the Apostles. Over time, Christians defined themselves in more hostile terms toward Judaism. But Jewish Christian groups survived in the Middle East for centuries; the Prophet Muhammad almost certainly had contact with them and was likely significantly influenced by them.

G.W. Bowersock in a review of Pagels' book (Apocalypse Then New York Review of Books 04/05/2012; behind subscription) notes that John Marshall (2001) and Daniel Boyarin (2011) have made a strong case for the Jewish nature of Revelation. As Bowersock delicately puts it, this "raises the deeply complex issue of the Jewishness of the first Christians," an issue which Pagels discusses in her book.

My own favorite chapter of Revelation is Chapter 12, with its cosmic story of the woman in the heavens and the dragon after her. It apparently intrigues Pagels, as well, because she has some interesting suggestions about it. Her caution in a footnote that the symbolism of that chapter may be "multivalent", I tend to think she's right to note identify the woman with Mary but I would question the identification of the child with the Messiah.

Friday, November 16, 2007

The Gospel of Judas

If you're intrigued by the reports and articles on the recently-published Gospel of Judas, a good place to start would be Reading Judas: The Gospel of Judas and the Shaping of Christianity (2007) by Elaine Pagels and Karen King. Pagels and King are two of the leading authorities on the forms of early Christianity than are generally called Gnosticism. They comment in passing that "Gnosticism" may no longer an entirely useful term. But the Gospel of Judas clearly has similarities to other forms of what we called Gnosticism.

The book includes a text by Pagels and King analyzing Judas and its historical context, and a translation of the work by King, with extensive notes on the translation. The available text of the book is in Coptic, a form of the Egyptian language using Greek letters; the original is believed to have been in Greek. Pagels' and King's book is a popular work, not one of technical scholarship. That means its accessible to a wide audience, but backed by solid scholarship.

National Geographic's Web site has some background information on the book and how it came to be published in 2006.

Pagels and King argue that a key concern of the author of the Gospel of Judas, which dates to the mid-2nd century, was how Christians should respond to Roman persecution. The Christian trend that became the orthodox tradition held that Christians captured by the Romans and faced with torture and brutal execution should nevertheless refuse to publicly disavow the faith. Some leaders even argued that Christians knowing that authorities were actively seeking them out should not even flee.

St. Iranaeus (died 200-203)

The author was outraged at this position. The community of which he was part (by inference from the text) knew that they also faced persecution. But they felt that the attitude of leaders like Irenaeus were being reckless and misrepresenting the theological meaning of sacrifice in the Christian religion. Pagels and King write:

How does such teaching impel people to act? - some Christians, like Irenaeus, when faced with the reality of persecution and death, advocated that people should be martyred, arguing that God wills all this suffering for people's own good. For Irenaeus, suffering and even death are meant to teach people about the greatness and goodness of God in granting eternal life to a sinful humanity. But the author of the Gospel of Judas not only denies that God desires such sacrifice, he also suggests that the practical effect of such views is hideous: It makes people complicit in murder. By teaching that Jesus died in agony "for the sins of the world" and encouraging his followers to die as he did, certain leaders send them on a path toward destruction - while encouraging them with the false promise that they will be resurrected from death to eternal life in the flesh.
They go on to explain that this attitude toward how Christians should respond to Roman persecution was also part of a larger theological difference with other Christians over the meaning of Jesus' sacrifice.

For the author of Judas, they argue, the real message of Jesus was the knowledge that there is a higher realm of spirit in additional to the material world that we know. Unlike some Gnostics, though, the Judas community did not see the material world as evil. This whole question of the relation of spirit and body, spirit and the material world, was a major theological issue in early Christianity.

Pagels and King write:

Thus the "good news" of the Gospel of Judas is that, as Paul wrote, "the sufferings of this present time are not worth comparing with the glory about to be revealed in us" (Romans 8:18). For although what happens to Jesus, so far as anyone in the world can see, ends in the hideous anguish of crucifixion, and what happens to Judas ends in his murder, each has hope. Those who hear this message recognize that rather than being simply physical bodies with complex psychological components, we are fundamentally spiritual beings who need to discover what, in us, belongs to the spirit. This gospel suggests that our lives consist of more than what biology or psychology can explore - that our real life begins when the spirit of God transforms the soul.
The also explain some of the complex Gnostic cosmology assumed by the Judas community, which may seem bizarre to those not much exposed to it. I won't try to describe it here. But in the notes to the translation, King (I assume the notes to her translation are hers) says that the particular cosmology of Judas is similar to what scholars called Sethian Gnosticism or Sethianism.

She also makes clear in the notes, as they do in the text, that the Gospel of Judas has a strongly anti-Jewish emphasis:

When the I was first published, newspapers and other media announced that it would undermine Christian anti-Judaism by rehabilitating Judas (whose name is related to the word Jew). No longer the betrayers of Christ, Jews would be free from that slander at last. But while the Gospel of Judas does give a positive face to Judas s act of handing Jesus over, it also portrays the Jewish chief priests and scribes as the ones who are waiting to catch Jesus. No hint appears that the Romans - who actually put Jesus to death—played any role at all. All blame is placed squarely on the Jews - those scribes who pay Judas to hand Jesus over and even Jesus's own disciples, who are portrayed as killers and sinners standing at the altar of the Jerusalem Temple. This ending offers no redemption for Jewish-Christian relations, but it does call us to reconsider how the (largely unhistorical) portrait of Judas in the gospels and many other unhistorical features of the gospel story need to be corrected. Whether people accept or reject what the Gospel of Judas says, it should be approached in terms of what we can learn about the historical situation of the Christians who wrote and read it: their anger, their prejudices, their fears - and their hopes.
Tags: , ,