The UCtelevision (UCTV, from the University of California) channel from You Tube. is a good resource. They present a number of videos of an hour or so length, such as this one, Obama Afghanistan and Vietnam with George Packer of the New Yorker:
This is a talk Packer gave at UC-Santa Barbara, and it's formal title is "An American Dilemma: Obama, Afghanistan and Vietnam". Oddly, it's undated, but it appears to be this event of 05/18/2010.
Tags: afghanistan war, george packer
Showing posts with label george packer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label george packer. Show all posts
Monday, January 03, 2011
Saturday, July 12, 2008
Is the Iraq War just making everybody goofy?
George Packer was a liberal hawk before the war but has written very critically about it over the years, not least in his 2005 book, The Assassins' Gate: America in Iraq.
Now, I've thought some of Packer's writing was a bit odd before. But in this piece, Obama’s Iraq Problem New Yorker 07/07/08, he makes two arguments that combine to be remarkable weird.
One is that The Surge (aka, the McCain escalation) has succeeded wonderfully. The other is that because The Surge has succeeded wonderfully, that removes the need to get American troops out of Iraq on the timetable Obama has proposed.
Only with a press corps so dysfunctional as ours in the US could such Bizarro logic take hold. The Surge is succeeding, so we have to leave the troops in Iraq. The Surge hasn't succeeded and there's still lots of violence and instability, so we have to leave the troops in Iraq. And Great American McCain has a magic plan to end all attacks on Americans in Iraq so that we can then leave the troops in Iraq for 100, years, or 1,000, or whatever.
For the sake at least of clearing my own head, the notion that The Surge has succeeded in creating an acceptable military or political solution is just wishful thinking. The US is not going to be able to leave American troops in Iraq indefinitely. And the polls are showing no evidence that the alleged success of The Surge has diminished the public's opposition to the Iraq War, even though Packer has somehow persuaded himself by one of those marvels of thought which only Big Pundits and major journalists seem capable of producing that Obama opposition to the Iraq War is somehow going to hurt him in the general election.
Doesn't it bother any of our Establishment journalists that their conventional wisdom is so often wrong? Apparently not. One hint of the problem in this thinking about the Iraq War as a campaign issue is that McCain's campaign has been trying to say that Obama's position on the war is pretty much the same as McCain's now. That's not because McCain's 100-years-in-Iraq position is wildly popular. It's because he wants people to think his own position is closer to Obama's antiwar stance.
Tags: george packer, iraq war
Now, I've thought some of Packer's writing was a bit odd before. But in this piece, Obama’s Iraq Problem New Yorker 07/07/08, he makes two arguments that combine to be remarkable weird.
One is that The Surge (aka, the McCain escalation) has succeeded wonderfully. The other is that because The Surge has succeeded wonderfully, that removes the need to get American troops out of Iraq on the timetable Obama has proposed.
Only with a press corps so dysfunctional as ours in the US could such Bizarro logic take hold. The Surge is succeeding, so we have to leave the troops in Iraq. The Surge hasn't succeeded and there's still lots of violence and instability, so we have to leave the troops in Iraq. And Great American McCain has a magic plan to end all attacks on Americans in Iraq so that we can then leave the troops in Iraq for 100, years, or 1,000, or whatever.
For the sake at least of clearing my own head, the notion that The Surge has succeeded in creating an acceptable military or political solution is just wishful thinking. The US is not going to be able to leave American troops in Iraq indefinitely. And the polls are showing no evidence that the alleged success of The Surge has diminished the public's opposition to the Iraq War, even though Packer has somehow persuaded himself by one of those marvels of thought which only Big Pundits and major journalists seem capable of producing that Obama opposition to the Iraq War is somehow going to hurt him in the general election.
Doesn't it bother any of our Establishment journalists that their conventional wisdom is so often wrong? Apparently not. One hint of the problem in this thinking about the Iraq War as a campaign issue is that McCain's campaign has been trying to say that Obama's position on the war is pretty much the same as McCain's now. That's not because McCain's 100-years-in-Iraq position is wildly popular. It's because he wants people to think his own position is closer to Obama's antiwar stance.
Tags: george packer, iraq war
Sunday, January 20, 2008
Hope never dies for the advocates of the press conventional wisdom (no matter how braindead it may be)
George Packer at his Interesting Times blog gives us a couple of examples in Scenes from a Primary 01/08/08, about the New Hampshire primary. This sentence is very telling: "Dinner with two dozen Dartmouth students last night. They wanted to talk Iraq; I wanted to talk politics."
The Establishment press has decided the Iraq War is no longer an important issue, even though it consistently shows as such in the public opinion polls. That's a perfect illustration. Since our "press corps" has defined the Iraq War as unimportant in the Presidential campaign - however they came to that truly weird conclusion - by definition talking about the Iraq War is not something you do when you "talk politics." Amazing. (George Packer did a book on the Iraq War, so it's not really surprising that students would bring it up to him.)
Like the rest of the press crew, Packer just loo-ooves St. John McCain, that bold Maverick:
Tom Edsall, who for some reason beyond my feeble imagination manages to be regarded as a "liberal" writer, decribed those Republican fault lines in "The Political Impasse" New York Review of Books 03/26/1987:
Russert did read a quotation from Michael Gerson (who wasn't there) in which the word "Iraq" appeared. Godwin, whose son has served in Iraq, did mention the word a couple of time, though mainly to repeat the current press script that no one cares about the Iraq War in the election any more, e.g., "If foreign policy comes back or Iraq comes back in a bigger positive or negative way, that could change this whole thing." This is a truly amazing phenomenon. The pundits decide through whatever mystical process occurs in such things that nobody cares any more about the war and they just start talking about the election as if that's the case. It's an awe-inspiring case of groupthink.
They talked a lot of drivel about how the Republicans are trying to find the "soul" of their Party. If there is such a thing as a Party's "soul", the Republicans' soul is the idea that the wealthiest Americans should be liberated of the terrible burden of paying taxes to support their country.
Godwin did manage to say something sensible on this notion that the Wall Street/Main Street coalition in the Republican Party is shattering:
Then there was this exchange:
How might they run against Obama? From the start of The Rush Limbaugh Show 01/14/08:
This, by the way, is typical segregationist humor. And it was followed by typical segregationist comma-dancing, in which Rush managed to use the word "spade" many more times and claim there's nothing wrong with it, as reported by Media Matters, Limbaugh twice used word "spade" during discussion of Obama 01/15/08.
Yes, I think the Christian Republican White People's Party will have some ideas about how they will campaign against Barack Obama. And heal that alleged split between "populist" theocrats and wealthy people who prefer not to pay taxes.
Tags: george packer, racism, rush limbaugh, thomas edsall
The Establishment press has decided the Iraq War is no longer an important issue, even though it consistently shows as such in the public opinion polls. That's a perfect illustration. Since our "press corps" has defined the Iraq War as unimportant in the Presidential campaign - however they came to that truly weird conclusion - by definition talking about the Iraq War is not something you do when you "talk politics." Amazing. (George Packer did a book on the Iraq War, so it's not really surprising that students would bring it up to him.)
Like the rest of the press crew, Packer just loo-ooves St. John McCain, that bold Maverick:
Eight years ago, McCain took on the Republican establishment and began to pry open cracks that are now gaping holes. This year, he’s brought the same appealing manner, but he’s made his peace with the Party: an independent in style, a Republican in substance. Back from the dead, he’s now talked about in New Hampshire as the likeliest Republican nominee. He’s also the only one with a good chance of winning in November.But about those "gaping holes" that Packer detects in the facade of the authoritarian Republican Party, he writes about a conversation he had with a nurse in Salem, New Hampshire:
In conversations like these you can feel the old Republican coalition splitting at its seams. Whatever was the matter with Kansas no longer is. The nurse is a Christian populist—angry about the wages nurses make, resentful of Romney pouring his millions into an election. She has almost nothing in common with the party’s Wall Street establishment (other than their mutual suspicion of what she calls "social medicine"). The coalition that Reagan built outlasted its natural life by a generation—just like the New Deal coalition of urban ethnics, blacks, and Southerners did. It's hard to see how the Republicans will avoid the fate of the post-1968 Democratic Party: a decade or two of interest-group politics, litmus tests, infighting, and nostalgic appeals to dead Presidents and defunct movements. Pat Robertson will go the way of Lane Kirkland; Mike Huckabee and Mitt Romney will follow in the footsteps of George McGovern and Walter Mondale.Conventional political observers have been speculating since the Christian Right emerged in its current form during the Carter administration that there were unbearable tensions between the Wall Street and Main Street wings of the Party. But, funny thing, they always seem to coalesce around the Republican Presidential candidate.
Tom Edsall, who for some reason beyond my feeble imagination manages to be regarded as a "liberal" writer, decribed those Republican fault lines in "The Political Impasse" New York Review of Books 03/26/1987:
In 1980 and 1981 the ideological and economic conflicts within the Republican coalition had not yet emerged. Instead, the main forces behind that coalition—a unified business community, a nascent Christian right, a well-financed conservative movement that has been gathering political and intellectual momentum for a decade, and a growing number of white voters who no longer supported Democratic welfare policies—provided Reagan with a strong base of support. His administration could therefore have its way, particularly in lowering taxes, raising military spending, and cutting benefits for the poor. Three main factors created a favorable climate for Reagan's budget and tax cut legislation. The steeply graduated income tax rates that inflation was pushing onto working- and middle-class incomes; rising regressive Social Security taxes; and increasingly heavy state and local tax burdens.And he didn't ignore the Christianists' differences with the plutocrats, either:
In 1980 and 1981, then, it seemed that the combined economic, class, and social interests supporting Reagan could become the core of a new majority party. During the last few years, however, these elements have lost their cohesion, and the Republican drive to expand its base has, in fact, had the effect of dividing its supporters. The Administration's 1986 tax reform proposal, for example, clearly had an implicit political purpose: by lowering all tax rates, eliminating many tax breaks, and shifting a significant share of the tax burden from individuals to corporations, the tax plan was intended by party strategists to give a populist boost to Republican hopes of realigning the parties. Instead of being perceived as the instrument of the rich and of corporate America, the GOP would appear as the defender of the common man.
Another Republican alliance coming under strain is that between the country-club Republicans who have controlled the party organizations in most states, and the increasingly restless conservative Christian political community. This alliance has been of prime importance to the GOP: between 1976 and 1984, white fundamentalist Christians accounted for a shift of at least eight million votes to Republican candidates, according to The New York Times–CBS polls. No other single group in those years did more to create a strong Republican coalition.Today's Meet the Press was a festival of press hackery featuring Tim Russert hosting Doris Kearns Goodwin, Newsweek's Jon Meacham, Peggy Noonan of the Wall Street Journal, Tom Brokaw of NBC and Michele Norris from NPR. Do I even need to say that they were all gaga over the bold Maverick McCain's brilliant success with his straight-shooting campaign?
Conservative Christian political leaders, including Pat Robertson, have, however, become increasingly intent on gaining direct political power. They are sponsoring campaigns to take over numerous state and local Republican party organizations, and running their own candidates in GOP primaries. For example, in Indiana in 1986, fundamentalist Christian candidates defeated candidates backed by the party for Republican nominations in two congressional districts, severely embarrassing one of the strongest state Republican parties in the country. Similarly, fights between Christian groups and party regulars occurred in Republican congressional contests in South Carolina and Tennessee. In three out of four of these districts, the Republican would normally have been favored to win. In fact, Democrats won all four districts. Republican party regulars, dismayed by such activities, are having increasing difficulty maintaining control over nominations. (my emphasis)
Russert did read a quotation from Michael Gerson (who wasn't there) in which the word "Iraq" appeared. Godwin, whose son has served in Iraq, did mention the word a couple of time, though mainly to repeat the current press script that no one cares about the Iraq War in the election any more, e.g., "If foreign policy comes back or Iraq comes back in a bigger positive or negative way, that could change this whole thing." This is a truly amazing phenomenon. The pundits decide through whatever mystical process occurs in such things that nobody cares any more about the war and they just start talking about the election as if that's the case. It's an awe-inspiring case of groupthink.
They talked a lot of drivel about how the Republicans are trying to find the "soul" of their Party. If there is such a thing as a Party's "soul", the Republicans' soul is the idea that the wealthiest Americans should be liberated of the terrible burden of paying taxes to support their country.
Godwin did manage to say something sensible on this notion that the Wall Street/Main Street coalition in the Republican Party is shattering:
But I think for the Republican Party, the prospect of victory eventually may solve some of these divisions. I mean, clearly, each one of these primary candidates represents a particular piece of the Reagan coalition. Nobody has it all. My sense is, however, when we get closer to having a Democrat - suppose Hillary wins February 5, and they know who that opponent is, that that desire to win may somehow heal, if not the soul, the desire to look like the soul is healed.Russert was desperately trying to find a racial angle to the Democratic contest. The guy is fixated on it.
Then there was this exchange:
MS. NORRIS: I mean, they [the Republicans] actually will talk openly about bringing Barack Obama down a few notches because they want to run against Hillary.The Republicans won't know how to run against Obama? Say what? They've been running against black people since 1964! Good grief, what planet do these reporters live on?
MR. MEACHAM: Because it's a known known, to give Secretary - former Secretary Rumsfeld his due. Hillary Clinton, they know what to do. Barack Obama, how do you run against the first African American nominee? It explodes all conventional campaign dogma in ways that completely will surprise and pleasantly and unpleasantly perhaps as they go forward. And I that that that's the - one of the things that's so scary about Obama to Republicans is they don't how to run against him. (my emphasis)
How might they run against Obama? From the start of The Rush Limbaugh Show 01/14/08:
It is funny to watch -- and, ladies and gentlemen, a final observation here. Bill Clinton and Hillary Clinton -- have you noticed, it's Obama versus the Clintons? Two against one. Obama campaigning against both of the Clintons. I wonder how well Mrs. Clinton would hold up if the shoe was on the other foot. That is, if she had to run against an ex-president and a senator. I think she'd cry and complain about the unfairness. For all of her BS about being a victim and piling on, Obama is holding his own against both of them, doing more than his share of the "spadework," maybe even gaining ground at the moment, using not only the spade, ladies and gentlemen. But when he finishes with the spade in the garden of corruption planted by the Clintons, he turns to the hoe. And so the spadework and his expertise, using a hoe. He's faring well. (my emphasis)Short version: "Spade, yuh git it! Spade and ho! Yuck, yuck, makin' fun of black people is funny, ain't it?"
This, by the way, is typical segregationist humor. And it was followed by typical segregationist comma-dancing, in which Rush managed to use the word "spade" many more times and claim there's nothing wrong with it, as reported by Media Matters, Limbaugh twice used word "spade" during discussion of Obama 01/15/08.
Yes, I think the Christian Republican White People's Party will have some ideas about how they will campaign against Barack Obama. And heal that alleged split between "populist" theocrats and wealthy people who prefer not to pay taxes.
Tags: george packer, racism, rush limbaugh, thomas edsall
Labels:
george packer,
racism,
rush limbaugh,
thomas edsall
Friday, July 27, 2007
George Packer saying, something-or-other about the civil-military relationship
Dave Dilegge at SmallWarsJournal.com links to this post by journalist George Packer, Guns and Brains Interesting Times blog 07/20/07:
But how crude is his "crude generalization". Pretty much, I would say.
Now, I suppose we'll have to take Packer's criticism on the autobiographical details that he felt "a visceral dislike of the military". If that's even what he meant to say; technically, he says that he belongs to "a generation of educated liberals" who felt that way.
But the picture he paints is more a conservative "culture war" concoction that a description of sentiment against the military on campuses during the later Vietnam War period. It's also important to distinguish between management, e.g., generals, and employees, e.g., private and sargeants. Packer specifically mentions Ivy League schools, saying that it was "almost a reflex on Ivy League university campuses, where officer training was sometimes banned, to regard anyone in uniform as funny, if not sinister".
I don't know what the Bush kids and their peers at Ivy League schools may have thought in that regard. But antiwar activists interacted with soldiers and veterans, and veterans like John Kerry were always active in the antiwar movement, and became more and more its leaders as the Vietnam War dragged on. In other words, those who were actively opposing the Vietnam War didn't show much evidence of regarding "anyone in uniform as funny, if not sinister".
It's also worth noting that there were then and still are substantial questions about the nature of the relationships between universities and other institutions, including corporations and the military. I certainly think it makes a lot of sense to restrict the ways the military can recruit on college campuses, especially around final exam time, which can be particularly stressful for many students.
And those questions continue. At Stanford University during the Vietnam War, for instance, student protesters objected to the university's organizational connection with the Stanford Research Institute (SRI), which had military contracts for practical tasks. Those kinds of questions are still coming up. I posted recently about a Tom Hayden blog post that challenged the particular way that Harvard's Carr Center on Human Rights interacted with the military, although his argument on that particular case didn't convince me.
But that's something very different than the "visceral dislike of the military" Packer describes, which supposed led Ivy League students (and presumably professor) well into the 1970s and 1980s "to regard anyone in uniform as funny, if not sinister."
It widely recognized that since the Vietnam War, there has been more of a pronounced separation between the active-duty military and society in general. I've posted numerous times about what people like Wesley Clark and Andrew Bacevich have had to say about this phenomenon. And it was apparently common during the Vietnam War for officers to tell their soldiers that the dirty hippie war critics back home hated them.
But does this mean that "on military bases, anti-intellectualism became a badge of honor" and that "liberal" became a dirty word? It's true that over time, up to 90% of the officer corps became Republican. But educational standards for recruits went up over time until the Iraq War forced some relaxation of them. And for officers, education was respected and encouraged. The service war colleges have maintained solid academic standards. I often quote studies from the service colleges because they are some of the best material available on military issues, edited according to demanding standards.
The whole framing that Packer uses on this seems odd to me. Maybe he's writing with reference to particular experiences of his own. But as a generalization, it hardly makes sense. It sounds like some kind of warmed-over conservative culture-war script to me.
Tags: george packer
I grew up during the Vietnam era and belong to a generation of educated liberals who came of age with a visceral dislike of the military. In the seventies and eighties, it was almost a reflex on Ivy League university campuses, where officer training was sometimes banned, to regard anyone in uniform as funny, if not sinister. At the same time, on military bases, anti-intellectualism became a badge of honor, a subscription to The New Yorker the mark of an oddball, and the words “liberal” and “academic” terms of abuse.I'll bleep over any discussion of how exactly Packer considers himself a liberal. He's the author of one of the best books about the Iraq War so far, The Assassins' Gate: America in Iraq, and he's done some very good reporting. His continued faith in the Iraq War enterprise does puzzle me, though.
Here’s a crude generalization: after the sixties, intellect and patriotism went separate ways, to the detriment of both. This mutual hostility made intellectuals less responsible and soldiers less thoughtful. We’ve come to think of this antagonism as natural and inevitable, as it is between cats and dogs, but in fact it was a product of recent political and cultural changes in American life. The estrangement was compounded by professionalization on both sides and the adoption of inward-looking and jargon-ridden specializations: the all-volunteer military and the social-theory crowd became equally isolated American subcultures.
The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have begun to close the divide. (my emphasis)
But how crude is his "crude generalization". Pretty much, I would say.
Now, I suppose we'll have to take Packer's criticism on the autobiographical details that he felt "a visceral dislike of the military". If that's even what he meant to say; technically, he says that he belongs to "a generation of educated liberals" who felt that way.
But the picture he paints is more a conservative "culture war" concoction that a description of sentiment against the military on campuses during the later Vietnam War period. It's also important to distinguish between management, e.g., generals, and employees, e.g., private and sargeants. Packer specifically mentions Ivy League schools, saying that it was "almost a reflex on Ivy League university campuses, where officer training was sometimes banned, to regard anyone in uniform as funny, if not sinister".
I don't know what the Bush kids and their peers at Ivy League schools may have thought in that regard. But antiwar activists interacted with soldiers and veterans, and veterans like John Kerry were always active in the antiwar movement, and became more and more its leaders as the Vietnam War dragged on. In other words, those who were actively opposing the Vietnam War didn't show much evidence of regarding "anyone in uniform as funny, if not sinister".
It's also worth noting that there were then and still are substantial questions about the nature of the relationships between universities and other institutions, including corporations and the military. I certainly think it makes a lot of sense to restrict the ways the military can recruit on college campuses, especially around final exam time, which can be particularly stressful for many students.
And those questions continue. At Stanford University during the Vietnam War, for instance, student protesters objected to the university's organizational connection with the Stanford Research Institute (SRI), which had military contracts for practical tasks. Those kinds of questions are still coming up. I posted recently about a Tom Hayden blog post that challenged the particular way that Harvard's Carr Center on Human Rights interacted with the military, although his argument on that particular case didn't convince me.
But that's something very different than the "visceral dislike of the military" Packer describes, which supposed led Ivy League students (and presumably professor) well into the 1970s and 1980s "to regard anyone in uniform as funny, if not sinister."
It widely recognized that since the Vietnam War, there has been more of a pronounced separation between the active-duty military and society in general. I've posted numerous times about what people like Wesley Clark and Andrew Bacevich have had to say about this phenomenon. And it was apparently common during the Vietnam War for officers to tell their soldiers that the dirty hippie war critics back home hated them.
But does this mean that "on military bases, anti-intellectualism became a badge of honor" and that "liberal" became a dirty word? It's true that over time, up to 90% of the officer corps became Republican. But educational standards for recruits went up over time until the Iraq War forced some relaxation of them. And for officers, education was respected and encouraged. The service war colleges have maintained solid academic standards. I often quote studies from the service colleges because they are some of the best material available on military issues, edited according to demanding standards.
The whole framing that Packer uses on this seems odd to me. Maybe he's writing with reference to particular experiences of his own. But as a generalization, it hardly makes sense. It sounds like some kind of warmed-over conservative culture-war script to me.
Tags: george packer
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)