Showing posts with label iran-contra. Show all posts
Showing posts with label iran-contra. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

The 1968 election, Iran-Contra and the trail of Presidential crime

While I'm on a roll of quoting from Robert Perry's Consortium News, I should mention the current piece by Perry, Rethinking Watergate/Iran-Contra 03/09/2013. Charlie Pierce giveswhigh praise to Perry in reference to this article and the great work he's done on its topic in History Comes to Call Esquire Politics Blog 03/15/2013. Pierce writes:

Bob Parry is one of the unknown heroes of this business of mine. Almost alone, he stood against the Reagan era foreign policy at the height of Saint Ronnie's popularity, bringing the truth about the savagery that administration and its clients were bringing down on the people of Central America. He is still dogging the general scandal of Iran-Contra to this day and, since I think the non-prosecution of that episode, and the successful stonewalling by both Reagan and George H.W. Bush, was a decisive turning point in getting us to where we were when we launched the Iraq fiasco, I applaud him for that. He stayed true to his calling, never wrote a bad book about John Belushi, and didn't get scared even when he actually was threatened by White House operatives. [my emphasis]
The deadly thread that runs through Perry's work on Nixon's undermining of Vietnam War peace talks in 1968 to the Watergate scandal to the "October Surprise" scheme by the Reagan campaing in 1980 to Iran-Contra is the corrupt practice of holding Presidents and other high officials harmless when they violate the law in serious ways.

Republican Presidents, at least. Congress impeached Bill Clinton over blowjobs.

Tags: , ,

Friday, February 04, 2011

St. Reagan and the Iran-Contra affair

The Iran-Contra scandal was the event that detracted the most from Ronald Reagan's image during his Presidency, though his hardcore admirers enthusiastically supported the controversial operations involved. This report from the National Security Archives has a good general summary and many links to more recently available documents, The Iran-Contra Affair 20 Years On 11/24/2006:

On November 25, 1986, the biggest political and constitutional scandal since Watergate exploded in Washington when President Ronald Reagan told a packed White House news conference that funds derived from covert arms deals with the Islamic Republic of Iran had been diverted to buy weapons for the U.S.-backed Contra rebels in Nicaragua.

In the weeks leading up to this shocking admission, news reports had exposed the U.S. role in both the Iran deals and the secret support for the Contras, but Reagan's announcement, in which he named two subordinates -- National Security Advisor John M. Poindexter and NSC staffer Oliver L. North -- as the responsible parties, was the first to link the two operations.

The scandal was almost the undoing of the Teflon President. Of all the revelations that emerged, the most galling for the American public was the president's abandonment of the long-standing policy against dealing with terrorists, which Reagan repeatedly denied doing in spite of overwhelming evidence that made it appear he was simply lying to cover up the story.

Despite the damage to his image, the president arguably got off easy, escaping the ultimate political sanction of impeachment. From what is now known from documents and testimony -- but perhaps not widely appreciated -- while Reagan may not have known about the diversion or certain other details of the operations being carried out in his name, he directed that both support for the Contras (whom he ordered to be kept together "body and soul") and the arms-for-hostages deals go forward, and was at least privy to other actions that were no less significant. [my emphasis]
From St. Reagan's address to the nation in which he admits having "traded arms for hostages":



The Federation of American Scientists, a great resource for a lot of things like this, has a copy of The "Walsh Report", the final report from Iran-Contra special prosecutor Lawrence Walsh. It's formal title is Final Report of the Independent Counsel for Iran/Contra Matters 08/04/1993.

Congress investigated the matter, as well. Their findings are an important part of the historical record on Iran-Contra. See Report of the Congressional Committees Investigating the Iran/Contra Affair by Lee H. Hamilton, Daniel K. Inouye. Excerpts are also provided by the American Presidency Project at UC-Santa Barbara.

Wyoming Congressman Dick Cheney's Iran-Contra defense would provide to be a significant step onto the road that took the United States into invading Iran and directly employing sadistic torture as a terror measure in foreign policy.

Tags: , ,

Saturday, June 19, 2010

Reagan, Iran and Republican impunity


Robert Parry reminds us of the long-term consequences of St. Ronald Reagan's shady deals with Iran in The Tricky October Surprise Report Consortium News 06/17/2010:

The significance of Reagan’s victory on modern American history can hardly be overstated. For instance, while Carter wanted to use his second term to press for U.S. energy independence and to secure a lasting Middle East peace, Reagan had little use for such policies and instead pushed through an anti-government agenda of tax cuts for the wealthy and deregulation of corporations.

Three decades later, the United States remains addicted to oil, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict continues to bedevil U.S. policy-makers, Reagan’s (and later George W. Bush’s) tax cuts have contributed to massive federal deficits, and the concept of corporate self-regulation has led to financial and environmental disasters.

Today, as Republicans anticipate major congressional gains in November, Reagan’s anti-government mantra has become a Tea Party and GOP rallying cry again.

Perhaps even more important, the notion of Republican impunity – to get away with pretty much whatever audacious action they undertake – pervades national politics.

Since the 1970s, Democrats have shied away from holding Republicans accountable for a string of national security scandals, with the failed investigation into the 1980 October Surprise case serving as a kind of template, not dissimilar from President Barack Obama’s refusal to investigate President George W. Bush’s complicity in torture and other war crimes.

The Democrats seem to believe that if they "look forward, not backward" regarding Republican crimes that they can secure some measure of bipartisanship, even if there is little evidence of that.
As Perry explains, the famous bipartisanship Democrat, former Congressman Lee Hamilton, played an important role in constructing that dubious record of achievement. The kind of "bipartisanship" that allows Republican officials to break the law with impunity is a very bad thing.

Tags: ,

Monday, June 29, 2009

Gary Webb's "Dark Alliance" series from 1996


Gary Webb (1955-2004)

Reporter Gary Webb did a series for the San Jose Mercury-News in 1996 on the role of cocaine traffic in financing the Contra war in Nicaragua during the 1980s. As he opening of the initial article in the series put it:

For the better part of a decade, a San Francisco Bay Area drug ring sold tons of cocaine to the Crips and Bloods street gangs of Los Angeles and funneled millions in drug profits to a Latin American guerrilla army run by the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency, a Mercury News investigation has found.

This drug network opened the first pipeline between Colombia's cocaine cartels and the black neighborhoods of Los Angeles, a city now known as the "crack" capital of the world. The cocaine that flooded in helped spark a crack explosion in urban America - and provided the cash and connections needed for L.A.'s gangs to buy automatic weapons.

It is one of the most bizarre alliances in modern history: the union of a U.S.-backed army attempting to overthrow a revolutionary socialist government and the Uzi-toting "gangstas" of Compton and South-Central Los Angeles.
The series is available at the Dark Alliance Web page maintained by NarcoNews, a news service focusing on Latin America in general and the problems of the "war on drugs" in particular. Apparently, the site was down for some time but is now restored.

Webb's story was not well received among the Establishment press, not to mention parties with more urgent interests at stake. Robert Perry, who had written about the cocaine-contra connection earlier, tells the story that led to Webb's suicide in We All Failed Gary Webb ConsortiumNews.com 12/10/08. He writes of Webb's last years:

Though a number of factors contributed to Webb’s suicide, it was his inability to find meaningful work in his profession that pushed him into a deep depression. Eight years earlier, he had been forced out of his job at the San Jose Mercury News as a result of the ugly controversy that followed publication of his story about contra-cocaine trafficking.

That story prompted a fierce counterattack from major U.S. newspapers, including the New York Times, the Washington Post and the Los Angeles Times which had all downplayed or dismissed the contra-cocaine scandal when it first arose in the mid-1980s. Unwilling to admit their earlier error, the big papers simply trashed Gary Webb.

With Webb and his story under fierce attack, the executives at the San Jose Mercury News found betraying their reporter a better course for their own careers. Webb was reassigned to a humiliating job and resigned in disgrace.

Even when the CIA inspector general issued his 1998 report, which confirmed much of what Webb had alleged and more, the Establishment newspapers refused to significantly revisit the issue. That would have been far too embarrassing for them, and they faced no powerful interests demanding that they correct their earlier flawed reporting. [my emphasis]
Sen. John Kerry pressed for an investigation of the cocaine-contra story, as Perry reports in some detail in How John Kerry exposed the Contra-cocaine scandal Salon 10/25/04:

In December 1985, when Brian Barger and I wrote a groundbreaking story for the Associated Press about Nicaraguan Contra rebels smuggling cocaine into the United States, one U.S. senator put his political career on the line to follow up on our disturbing findings. His name was John Kerry.

Yet, over the past year, even as Kerry's heroism as a young Navy officer in Vietnam has become a point of controversy, this act of political courage by a freshman senator has gone virtually unmentioned, even though -- or perhaps because -- it marked Kerry's first challenge to the Bush family.
As the national press was sliding toward the cliff it went over with the Whitewater story, Kerry's investigation failed to catch the imagination of the corporate press, who were reluctant to challenge the noble image of St. Reagan:

The Reagan administration's tolerance and protection of this dark underbelly of the Contra war represented one of the most sordid scandals in the history of U.S. foreign policy. Yet when Kerry's bombshell findings were released in 1989, they were greeted by the mainstream press with disdain and disinterest. The New York Times, which had long denigrated the Contra-drug allegations, buried the story of Kerry's report on its inside pages, as did the Washington Post and the Los Angeles Times. For his tireless efforts, Kerry earned a reputation as a reckless investigator. Newsweek's Conventional Wisdom Watch dubbed Kerry a "randy conspiracy buff."

But almost a decade later, in 1998, Kerry's trailblazing investigation was vindicated by the CIA's own inspector general, who found that scores of Contra operatives were implicated in the cocaine trade and that U.S. agencies had looked the other way rather than reveal information that could have embarrassed the Reagan-Bush administration.

Even after the CIA's admissions, the national press corps never fully corrected its earlier dismissive treatment. That would have meant the New York Times and other leading publications admitting they had bungled their coverage of one of the worst scandals of the Reagan-Bush era. [my emphasis]
Official investigations in 1998 confirmed much of what Kerry had found and what Perry, Barger and Webb had reported:

While the major newspapers gloated when reporter Gary Webb was forced to resign from the Mercury News, the internal government investigations, which Webb's series had sparked, moved forward. The government's decade-long Contra cocaine cover-up began to crumble when CIA inspector general Frederick Hitz published the first of two volumes of his Contra cocaine investigation on Jan. 29, 1998, followed by a Justice Department report and Hitz's second volume in October 1998.

The CIA inspector general and Justice Department reports confirmed that the Reagan administration knew from almost the outset of the Contra war that cocaine traffickers permeated the CIA-backed army but the administration did next to nothing to expose or stop these criminals. The reports revealed example after example of leads not followed, witnesses disparaged and official law-enforcement investigations sabotaged. The evidence indicated that Contra-connected smugglers included the Medellin cartel, the Panamanian government of Manuel Noriega, the Honduran military, the Honduran-Mexican smuggling ring of Ramon Matta Ballesteros, and Miami-based anti-Castro Cubans.

Reviewing evidence that existed in the 1980s, CIA inspector general Hitz found that some Contra-connected drug traffickers worked directly for Reagan's National Security Council staff and the CIA. In 1987, Cuban-American Bay of Pigs veteran Moises Nunez told CIA investigators that "it was difficult to answer questions relating to his involvement in narcotics trafficking because of the specific tasks he had performed at the direction of the NSC."

CIA task force chief Fiers said the Nunez-NSC drug lead was not pursued then "because of the NSC connection and the possibility that this could be somehow connected to the Private Benefactor program [Oliver North's fundraising]. A decision was made not to pursue this matter."
Perhaps the most revealing press reaction that Perry describes in Salon was this one:

The Los Angeles Times actually used Kerry's report to dismiss the Mercury News series as old news because the Contra cocaine trafficking "has been well documented for years."
This is actually a standard technique of our dysfunctional press corps: ignore or downplay the story when it breaks, then dismiss later revelations as old news. Stories like George W. Bush's drunk driving and his dubious National Guard record were dismissed by conventional press wisdom in 2004 because they had been surfaced but not seriously explored in the national press in 2000. (Dan Rather's famous report on the latter was an exception, but that didn't work out too well for him.)

I should note here that one of the claims of the original series and of Webb's subsequent book based on it, Dark Alliance (1998), was, as quoted above, that the CIA's Contra financing activities "helped spark a crack explosion in urban America". Though that claim, at least as quoted there, was pretty modest, it was one of the aspects on which his critics hung the "conspiracy theory" epithet. And his analysis did lend itself easily to already-extant theories about how the spread of hard drugs among African-American urban communities was somehow a deliberate plan by the government/ruling class/white elite to control the black population. That notion long predated Gary Webb's series in 1996. Here was his version in the opening article:

While the [Nicaraguan Contra's] war is barely a memory today, black America is still dealing with its poisonous side effects. Urban neighborhoods are grappling with legions of homeless crack addicts. Thousands of young black men are serving long prison sentences for selling cocaine -- a drug that was virtually unobtainable in black neighborhoods before members of the CIA's army started bringing it into South-Central in the 1980s at bargain-basement prices.

And the L.A. gangs, which used their enormous cocaine profits to arm themselves and spread crack across the country, are still thriving, turning entire blocks of major cities into occasional war zones.
But however dramatic that speculation was, the real factual meat of the story was the CIA's collaboration with drug trafficers, which was largely substantiated by the subsequent official investigations.

This story not only involves an important piece of more-or-less contemporary history. It also is an important chapter in the collapse in quality in much of the American press, particularly the national political press corps.

And it's a reminder that guerrilla groups, of all persuasions, can degenerate partly or wholly into basically criminal operations with no meaningful practical political goals. When an insurrectionary process continues as long as the one in Colombia, for instance, the need to finance themselves through extra-legal channels - no government looks cheerfully on fundraising for groups waging armed warfare against it - can lead them to settle into patterns of behavior in which the financing method starts to take precedents over the political goals.

See also:

It's Time for Realism by Michael Massing The Nation 09/02/1999 (09/20/1999 edition)

Life of a Scandal by Peter Kornbluh The Nation 09/02/1999 (09/20/1999 edition)

Tags: , ,

Friday, December 28, 2007

Craig Unger's The Fall of the House of Bush


Craig Unger's new book on the Bush dynasty could probably be more accurately titled, The Iraq War and the Twilight on the Bush II Presidency. It's largely an account of how the influence of the neoconservatives and the Christian Right converged in the Republican Party to produce the Iraq War after the 9/11 attacks, using the latter as a justification for a far-reaching, radical foreign policy.

Unger has done his own extensive interviews with many of the key players in his story, as well as using the many available secondary sources to construct his narrative. He does a good job of telling the story, including the disgraceful role of the Establishment press, although he does seem a bit too wedded to conventional political wisdom on some points. He also gives credit to the liberal blogosphere for keeping questions and issues in play that the mainstream press was ignoring or underplaying, like the serious questions about the necons' claims about the now-infamous aluminum tubes.

These contemporary histories are important because they preserve a lot of current perspectives, including their limitations, in a way that will become a challenge to reconstruct some day. Especially since the Iraq War is such an historic disaster and everyone is already trying to distance themselves from the many failures involved. We can see already in Unger's account that the material that has so far leaked through Dick Cheney's thick wall of official secrecy makes the story of the Iraq War look much uglier than it did as it was unfolding. And to those who were really paying attention, it looked very ugly at the time.

Unger's narrative gives a good idea of the various factors that went into the Iraq War: neoconservative grand strategies of forcibly remaking Middle Eastern nations to be more congenial to the West and to Israel; access to oil supplies; the scams run by Ahmad Chalabi and other Iraqi emigrants; the lobbying efforts for Likud Party-oriented pro-Israel groups, especially AIPAC; and, Christianist notions about bringing on the end of the world and the return of Christ by escalating tensions in the Middle East. More subjectively, there were psychological factors including Bush's desire to outshine his father as a military conqueror; neocon group dynamics that led to shared assumptions not being adequately questioned; and, Dick Cheney's authoritarianism.

It would be inaccurate to reduce a political event as important as the Iraq War to psychological causes. But I was particularly intrigued by Unger's description of neocon group dynamics, which he describes as reaching a cultlike intensity. Because of their shared friendships and interlocking front groups (Unger uses the term), they created a kind of extended groupthink in which the fantastic and foolish notion was validated and revalidated that conquering Iraq and installing a subservient government would be quick and easy, and this would set the stage for a rapid series of regime changes in Iran, Syria and beyond.

Unger at one point seems to be saying that it was the grand neocon strategy of serial regime change that was the real reason for the Iraq War. But I don't think its meaningful to exclude those other factors. The role of oil has never given me the kind of contortions that it seem to induce in some people. It's pretty obvious to me that all American policies in the Middle East need to take oil supplies into account. It would be irresponsible not to do so. The fact that some oil companies may have colluded with Cheney to arrange oil deals for themselves is something that deserves detailed official investigation than it has so far received. But even if there are some players who turn out to be stereotypical cynical manipulators concerned only with oil riches, that doesn't eliminate the other factors as important.

Unger gives a good blow-by-blow description of how the measures the neocons and Cheney's office set up to "stovepipe" raw intelligence to policymakers while bypassing the elaborate vetting process of the official intelligence agencies. This process meant that the various neocons in the Pentagon and the Office of the Vice President could cherry-pick data bits which fit their own narrow and unrealistic preconceptions and ignore others. No President should simply set policy based on intelligence recommendations. It's the President's job to make decisions based on a wide variety of considerations. But the "stovepiping" process is a real reminder how important it is to have raw intelligence information carefully vetted by people who are looking for factual information more than for bits of useful propaganda.

In dealing with present-day issues of transnational terrorism and nuclear proliferation, having accurate intelligence is especially important. The recklessness and destructiveness of Cheney and Bush in this regard is staggering, just based on what we already know. I shudder to think what the picture will look like when considerably more key information becomes public.

Unger also does a good job of highlighting the dubious role of longtime neocon player Michael Ledeen, another of the Iran-Contra veterans who have played destructive roles during this administration. Unger also weaves the story of the Joe Wilson mission to Niger and the subsequent Valerie Plame exposure into his narrative, which is one of the key things that reminds us how much uglier the story looks with the then-behind-the-scenes material included.

The particular idiocy and recklessness of neocon bigwig Richard "Prince of Darkness" Perle also comes out clearly in Unger's narrative. For instance, Perle wrote an editorial that appeared in USA Today on 05/01/03, the same day as Bush's "Mission Accomplished" extravaganza on the USS Abraham Lincoln. It was entitled Relax, Celebrate Victory. The great strategic thinker wrote of the Iraq War, "From start to finish, President Bush has led the United States and its coalition partners to the most important military victory since World War II." To repeat, this was May of 2003.

Unger gives what's probably my favorite Perle quote, too, from just before the start of the Iraq War: "If we just let our vision of the world go forth and we embrace it entirely and we don't try to piece together clever diplomacy but just wage a total war, our children will sing great songs about us years from now." (my emphasis) What.A.Fool.

But let's give the Prince of Darkness credit. People are already singing songs about the Iraq War. The best-known ones and the ones that are likely to endure are those about what a horrible decision it was.

If I had to make just one criticism of Unger's book, it would be that in his very useful and informative sketch of the history of the Christian Right, he fails to make clear what a central role the politics of segregation and racism played in its formulation and the extent to which the neosegregationist outlook is identified with the Christian Right/Christian fundamentalist/Christian dominionist supporters.

This leads him astray, for example, when he repeats the press corps conventional wisdom about the 2004 election that it was primarily decided by "values" voters. He fails to ask how many of those who identified "values" as their key concern would ever have considered voting for a Democrat in any case, or how many of those were Southern and/or rural/small town whites. Because to a considerable part of the Christian Right base, "values" means "keeping us white folks safe from scary black people". Gays and immigrants may irritate them, too. But there is a heavy continuity between the old segregationist vote and today's Christianist vote. This is something the late Steve Gilliard was very good about reminding us. And he was right. You can't understand the Christian Right voting phenomenon without understanding its connection with segregationist and now what I call neosegregationist sentiments.

He also seems to be hanging on to the notion that Colin Powell is somehow a tragic but sympathetic figure who was victimized by the neocons. I have no sympathy for Powell's role in the Iraq War catastrophe. He knew that Cheney's people were trying to scam the country into war. And his presentation at the United Nations in February 2002 was key to enabling the war. He had every reason to know what he was going was irresponsible, and that he was facilitating an unnecessary and illegal war. But he did it anyway. To Unger's credit, despite his seeming sympathy for Powell, he describes how Powell's ignored his own State Department's intelligence specialists in the preparation of that infamous UN presentation.

Unger's acceptance of the misleading "values" version of the 2004 election leads him astray into accepting a flawed Culture War framework of American politics, with particular reference to 2004:

By 2005, for tens of millions of Americans, it was increasingly impossible to ignore the realities of what was happening in Iraq - the absence of WMDs, the escalating sectarian violence, the vast expenditures of blood and treasure in pursuit of a mission that was unclear at best, constantly changing, and had never been accomplished at all. Polarizing the nation more profoundly than at any time since the Vietnam era, the war had become a litmus test issue that defined and linked whole sets of belief systems — red state America versus blue, evangelical Christians, antiabortion activists, NASCAR dads, and other denizens of the Bible Belt versus the secular, post-Enlightenment America that has long been on the cutting edge of science and the embodiment of modernism. Those who questioned U.S. policies in the Middle East, as their foes saw it, were cut-and-run traitors who aided and abetted the enemy. On the other side were Neanderthals waging a holy war in the Middle East, shredding the Constitution, destroying civil liberties, rolling back not just the New Deal but the Enlightenment, all in the name of God.
This is an example of the journalistic habit of providing "balance" by making both sides of a controversy sound equally to blame or equally deserving of consideration. But the impression this view leaves is very misleading. For Christianist "culture warriors", the Iraq War does indeed serve as a litmus test for their rejection of the dirty hippies and rampaging evil black people of their fantasies. This is why what support their is left for the Cheney-Bush Iraq policy is restricted to conservative white Republicans, and even some of those have faltered.

Most Americans, though, have a far more pragmatic view of the Iraq War. You hardly need to approve of hippie communes with mass orgies on the weekends to see it doesn't make any sense to keep 160,000 American troops fighting in a conflict where the protracted conflict itself has become more of a problem than leaving could cause. There are "both sides" to culture war issues like gay marriage. But when it comes to the Iraq War, there's basically only one side that sees it as organically tied to abstinence-only education and literal interpretation of the Christian Bible.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Friday, October 26, 2007

The Iran-Contra affair


More blogging on The American Age: United States Foreign Policy at Home and Abroad since 1750 (1989) by Walter LaFeber. This is his summary of the Iran-Contra affair during the Reagan-Bush administration. I think the Iran-Contra affair is pretty much a template for the entire foreign policy of the Cheney-Bush administration:

During the summer of 1987, joint Senate and House special committees conducted nationally televised hearings on the schemes. As they organized, a special commission headed by former Texas Republican senator John Tower, which Reagan had asked to investigate the role of the White House in the Iran-Contra affair, made its report. The Tower commission concluded that the NSC staff was responsible for the chaotic policy and that the president was out of touch with the foreign policies of his own White House. The House-Senate investigation confirmed much of the Tower commission's report. North testified that he had largely worked under Casey's direction, but he had also kept the new NSC director, Admiral John Poindexter, informed of the plan. Poindexter testified that he never told the president about the diversion plan. Casey never testified at all. He had died of a brain tumor months earlier and took to the grave whatever he had told his close friend Ronald Reagan about the plan.

North became a hero to much of the television audience for his defense of the Reagan Doctrine, even if the defense meant breaking the law. His attractiveness wore off, however, as second thoughts appeared. North, after all, admitted that he destroyed government documents that might have contained damning evidence. He also admitted that he had made statements to Congress that were "false," "evasive and wrong." The Army Times condemned North for having "paraded a travesty of military values before a credulous national television audience." Retired Colonel Harry Summers damned North and the others for selling weapons to Iran that might well be used against U.S. soldiers, and for itarting down the "slippery slope" by placing their wishes above those of Congress or the president - "for at the bottom of that slope is military dictatorship" in the United States. (my emphasis)
The enthusiasm for North at the time in the Republican Party is a sign of the authoritarian streak among much of the Party base. It also worth noting that Harry Summers is one of the most important advocates of the stab-in-the-back theory of the US loss in the Vietnam War. So it's not like he's "anti-military", even in the goofy, ideological sense conservatives often use the term.

Another aspect worth noticing in particular is that LaFeber describes North's supposed popularity among the public wearing off very quickly. Eric Alterman has pointed out that the mainstream media at the time tended to talk about North's great popularity among the public, even though he wasn't terribly popular with the general public.

And speaking of Eric Alterman, he wrote last year about now-Defence Secretary Robert Gates and the Iran-Contra affair in Contra Gates American Prospect Online 11/08/06.

Tags: ,

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Reagan's 1987 military clashes with Iran

Continuing with my blogging on The American Age: United States Foreign Policy at Home and Abroad since 1750 (1989) by Walter LaFeber, here is a reminder that the United States engaged in active, overt military hostilities with Iran in 1987.

Saddam Hussein's Iraq had attaked Iran in 1980, thinking it would be a quick and decisive war. Instead, it dragged on for years in what was little more than a bloody stalemate that took many lives on both sides. The Reagan-Bush administration was officially neutral in the war but was actively supporting Iraq, including allowing materials to be sent from the United States to facilitate Saddam's chemical and biological weapons program. In 1987, the US actually became a belligerent on Iraq's side for a brief period of time.

As LaFeber summarizes it:

In early 1987, [the Reagan-Bush] administration concluded that Iran threatened the oil exports of Kuwait (which was pro-Iraq in the Iran-Iraq war). The Kuwaiti exporters depended on free movement of their tankers through the Persian Gulf. The president put Kuwaiti tankers under the American flag and used a U.S. fleet to protect them against attacks by Iranian gunboats. Behind that decision lay Reagan's and Shultz's determination to reassert their power in the region as well as to try to intimidate [Ayatollah] Khomeini [leader of the Iranian Revolution and the top person in the Shi'a theocratic government at that time]. Reagan had been told that the nine U.S. warships in the area were sufficient for the job. Within two months, however, he had to send forty-one combat vessels to the region and spend $10 million to $20 million each day on the operation. Even then, the Iranians disabled a number of U.S. and non-U.S. flagships. Americans and Iranians were virtually at war with each other. In 1987, an Iraqi missile killed 37 sailors on a U.S. ship. In mid-1988, a U.S. naval commander mistook an Iranian airliner for an attack jet and shot it down, killing 290 innocent civilians. The passageway was kept open, and the U.S. Navy, with the help of a few allies, continued to carry off a difficult and dangerous task. Critics believed that, given Iranian policy and naval strength, the passage would have remained open without such a U.S. commitment. (my emphasis)
One of the key players in the Cheney-Bush administration's Middle East policy has been Elliot Abrams, who was also around in the Reagan years. LaFeber writes of his notorious role in the Iran-Contra scandal, for which Abrams was convicted of a felony but was pardoned by Old Man Bush when he was President:

The State Department's point man on Central America, Assistant Secretary of State Elliott Abrams, had also lied to Congress when he told it, in November 1986, that no third-party funds were going to the [Nicaraguan] Contras [a rightwing anti-government terrorist group supported by the Reagan-Bush administration], even though he personally had begged for some of those funds from the sultan of Brunei. Abrams became an outcast on Capitol Hill (Minnesota Republican senator David Durenberger said that he would trust Abrams no further "than I can throw Oliver North"), but Reagan and Shultz kept him in the State Department. Democratic congressman Lee Hamilton from Indiana, chairman of the House investigation committee, summarized the affair by declaring that the "policy was driven by a series of lies - ... lies to our friends and allies, lies to the Congress, and lies to the American people." Hamilton concluded that "the policy achieved none of the goals it sought. The Ayatollah got his arms, more Americans are held hostage today [and] subversion of U.S. interests throughout the region by Iran continues." Reagan's confusion throughout the three-year affair was exemplified when reporters asked him if the late William Casey had engaged in secret CIA activities without the president's knowledge. Reagan replied, "Not that I know of." (my emphasis)
That Lee Hamilton has more recently been known as the second half of the name of the Baker-Hamilton Commission.

Good quote from Hamilton: Reagan's policies on Nicaragua and Iran were "driven by a series of lies - ... lies to our friends and allies, lies to the Congress, and lies to the American people." That pretty much describes the entire Cheney-Bush administration, doesn't it?

Tags: , , , , ,

Friday, February 02, 2007

Moyers documentary on the Iran-Contra affair

Via Jonathan Schwarz at Tom Tomorrow's This Modern World blog, I came across this remarkable documentary by Bill Moyers from 20 years ago (1987) about the Iran-Contra affair called "The Secret Government ... The Constitution in Crisis" at Google Video. (Darn if I can make the embed work.)

Apparently this is the first time the full 1hr. 26 min. version has been publicly available, with only a 22-min. version previously available. (For some reason, my Norton Security software decided to warn me about 30 minutes into the film that it was a "suspicious" Web site that might be used for "phishing". But it doesn't require any user input to view the film.)

The Iran-Contra operation in many ways was the template for the entire foreign policy of the Cheney-Bush administration. That is the way Dick Cheney thinks the government ought to be run - under a Republican Executive, of course.

This is an excellent summary of the Iran-Contra affair, its Constitutional implications and its relationship to Cold War espionage practices. He covers the overthrow of Mossadegh's government in Iran in 1953; the overthrow of the Jacobo Arbenz government in Guatamala in 1954; the Bay of Pigs fiasco in 1961; the assasination plots against Fidel Castro, some in league with the Mafia; covert war in Indochina; the Gulf of Tonkin incident of 1964; Operation Phoenix; the subversion of the Allende government in Chile; domestic spying; "the White House crimes known as Watergate" (Moyers).

Moyers says in the documentary (after 18:45), "The secret government has no constitution. The rules it follows are the rules it makes up". That's a good, brief statement of the Dick Cheney philosophy of government.

After 41:40, he says "once we dicide that anything goes, anything can come home to haunt us".

One valuable thing that Moyers' documentary does is to show the particular connection between Watergate and the Iran-Contra affair. Both have come back to bite us again through officials like Dick Cheney and Rummy and the Iran-Contra miscreants like Elliot Abrams who have played significant roles in the Cheney-Bush administration.

While Watergate is remembered as a big scandal. But Edwin Firmage argues in the documentary (1:03) that the Constitutional violations and dangers were signficantly greater in the Iran-Contra affair.

Seymour Hersh has said elsewhere that he believes that the Iran-Contra affair has still never been adequately investigated and explained.

This sequence is a grim, grim sign for the future. Watergate degenerated to Iran-Contra, and Iran-Contra became in large part a mode of operation for the entire Cheney-Bush administration.

And unless the public, the Congress and the Republican Party in particular is not alert to the danger and actually concerned to avoid it, the liklihood is that veterans of the Cheney-Bush administration and some of today's true believers influenced by the Cheney method of government will come to power again. And, like Cheney and Rummy intended to restore the Watergate/Iran-Contra mode of operation, those future zealots will try to make the Cheney method work to an even greater degree than in has during the first six years of the current administration.

It's sad to hear people talk in the 1987 documentary about how anti-Communist zealotry led people to do foolish, reckless, immoral and illegal things. And to realize how very, very similar it sounds to today's Republican warnings about the threat of The Terrorists.

"Just salute and follow orders" (1:08) is how Moyers characterizes the mentality of the Iran-Contra conspirators. And that's been the general mentality of hardline Bush followers since 9/11.

It's not a democratic attitude. Democracy cannot survive too much of it.

This set of quotations from Dick Cheney gives a good picture of how Cheney viewed the Iran-Contra affair in the context of his theory of unlimited Executive power.

Cheney was responsible for shaping the minority report of the Congressional committee investigating the Iran-Contra affair. According to Lou Dubose and and Jake Bernstein in Vice: Dick Cheney and the Hijacking of the American Presidency (2006), Cheney's current chief of staff David Addington was the primary author of the text on Executive power in that report.

Tags: ,