Showing posts with label israel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label israel. Show all posts

Friday, August 10, 2018

Cory Booker displays his political identity

Cory Booker just reinforced my underwhelming impression of him as a politician and potential Presidential candidatee. Cenk Uygur and Ana Kasparian of The Young Terms explain in Cory Booker Has Media Debacle 08/09/2018. I was surprised to see him with that sign in the first place.



Cory Booker is a ConservaDem.

Tuesday, May 15, 2018

Bernie Sanders panel on the Iran deal and the danger of an Iran War

Bernie Sanders held a town hall on Monday, Breaking the Deal: A Town Hall on Trump's Iran Decision 05/14/2018:



The panel includes featuring Joe Cirincione, President of the Ploughshares Fund; Lara Friedman of Peace Now; Rob Malley, head of the Crisis Group; and, Suzanne Dimaggio of New America.

With the Trump Administration doing its version of the 2002 buildup to war, everyone concenred about it needs to be aware of major events in the Middle East that affect the environment in which Trump would launch a war against Iran.

This is one of them: David Halbfinger, Killings in Gaza, New Embassy in Jerusalem, and Peace as Distant as Ever New York Times 05/14/2018; Declan Walsh, Waves of Gazans vs. Israeli Tear Gas and Bullets: Deadliest Mayhem in Years New York Times 05/14/2018; Amnesty International, Israel/OPT: Use of excessive force in Gaza an abhorrent violation of international law 05/14/2018.

Halbfinger reports, "At least 60 were killed and thousands injured, local officials said — the worst day of carnage there since Israel invaded Gaza in 2014." Despite apparently all 60 deaths being Palestinians killed by the Israeli Army, both Israel and the Trump Administration said it was all the fault of Hamas.

Sen. Sanders tweeted yesterday:



Bernie's fellow progressive Senator, Elizabeth Warren, tweeted the following on the Gaza killings:

[sound of crickets]

Chuck Schumer, leader of the Democratic "Resistance" in the Senate, tweeted on Gaza:

[crickets]

Nancy Pelosi, head of the the Democratic "Resistance" in the Senate, tweeted on Gaza:

[crickets]

Corporate Democratic Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, tweeted on Gaza:

[crickets]

Corporate Democratic Sen. Cory Booker, tweeted on Gaza:

[crickets]

Who-knows-what-kind-of Democratic Sen. Kamala Harris, tweeted on Gaza:

[crickets]

Friday, May 11, 2018

Israel, Russia, and the Iran deal

American commentators and news junkies these days are too often trying to squeeze every bit of news about Russia into their preferred model of the Trump-Russia scandal.

But things to happen outside of America's borders. Russia has become a more important player in the Middle East in the last 10 years, something that in itself doesn't bother me. Given the disasters the US role in the Middle East has created over the past 20 years or so, Russian involvement there is about as bad a move as Russia's worst critics would wish on it.

Mark Katz explains the current balance of interests between Russia and Israel in Putin And Netanyahu: Converging Interests? LobeLog 05/11/2018. He sums it up this way:
Although Putin’s and Netanyahu’s interests with regard to Syria may be convergent, they are not identical. Putin wants Iran to remain in Syria as a junior partner in propping up the Assad regime but not acting provocatively otherwise. Netanyahu not only wants Iran out of Syria, but may even join U.S. National Security Advisor John Bolton and other hawks in seeking regime change in Tehran. If so, the Putin-Netanyahu tactical alliance will not last.
He describes the conflicting interests between Iran and Russia this way:
Israeli strikes on Iranian targets in Syria have the advantage of weakening Iran vis-à-vis Russia inside Syria without Moscow having to confront Tehran directly. And Tehran does have ambitions in Syria that Moscow does not share. For Tehran, preserving the Assad regime is not just an end in itself, but a means for Iran to better support Hezbollah in Lebanon in its conflict with Israel. Russia, by contrast, has strong economic and security ties to Israel that it wants to continue and expand. Moscow does not want Iran to disturb this, or create sufficient problems for Israel that the U.S. gets back into the Syrian conflict in Israel’s defense.
Unlike our President's imagination of the world, foreign policy is much more shades of gray and messy compromises than it is about win/lose situations or conflicts between Good and Evil.

Sunday, November 13, 2016

Trump, ISIS and Israel

Aljazeera's Inside Story takes a look at How will President Trump deal with ISIL, Syria & Iran? 11/12/2016:



The Real News interviews Gareth Porter on the neocons in Trump's entourage and those angling for influence on the Trump Administration, Discredited Neocons From The Bush Era Floated as US Foreign Policy Advisors to Trump 11/12/2016:



Gareth expects that the neoconservatives will dominate foreign policy in Trump's Administration, even more so than in the Cheney-Bush government.

Tuesday, March 29, 2016

Bernie opposes "interventionist, regime change, unnecessary wars" - what an Unserious Guy!

Imagine that! A Democratic campaign add supporting peace! It seems like it's been forever since I've seen such a thing. But Bernie is doing it (The Cost of War 03/24/2016):



Robert Parry discusses the ad in Bernie Sanders as Commander-in-Chief 03/28/2016:
Apparently having learned no lessons from the Iraq War, Clinton consistently took hawkish and interventionist positions as President Barack Obama’s first Secretary of State.

In 2009, Clinton backed a coup in Honduras that removed democratically elected (and progressive) President Manuel Zelaya) and reaffirmed control by the Central American country’s oligarchy. Since then, Honduras’s human rights situation has worsened, driving thousands of children to flee northward seeking safety and leaving environmental and political activists at the mercy of death squads.

Also, in 2009, Clinton joined with Bush-holdover Defense Secretary Robert Gates and neocon-favorite Gen. David Petraeus in pushing Obama into a major escalation of the Afghan War, a counter-insurgency “surge” that sent another 1,000 American troops to their deaths – and many more Afghans – but has since been abandoned as a failure.

In 2011, Clinton joined with “liberal interventionists” in again pushing Obama into a “regime change” war in Libya that led to the overthrow and torture-murder of Muammar Gaddafi – which she gleefully welcomed with the quip, “We came, we saw, he died” – but has since turned the once relatively prosperous North African country into a failed state with the Islamic State gaining another foothold.

Both as Secretary of State and since her departure in 2013, Clinton has pressed to escalate the “regime change” war in Syria, seeking a “no-fly zone” that would require the U.S. military to destroy the Syrian government’s air force and air defenses, apparently without regard to the risk that the U.S. intervention could pave the way for Al Qaeda’s Nusra Front and/or the Islamic State to march into Damascus.

Though the Syrian “regime change” strategy that Clinton has advocated has failed to oust President Bashar al-Assad, it has transformed another reasonably functional Mideast state into a bloody killing field and driven millions of refugees into what is now a destabilized Europe.
Is Clinton making a course change? Well, she was saying last year that wants to change Obama's course so far, as Jessica Schulberg reports in Hillary Clinton Promises A More Muscular Foreign Policy As President 09/09/2015:

Obama was hesitant to condemn the Iranian crackdown on protesters during the 2009 Green Revolution. The unrest erupted just as the Obama administration was quietly mulling outreach to the Iranians on the nuclear issue, and the president was mindful of the way a condemnation would sound in a country that views the U.S. as an arrogant superpower intent on regime change. The administration’s failure to take a more proactive role on behalf of the protesters was a mistake Clinton regrets, as she wrote in her memoirs and repeated in her speech Wednesday. “That won’t happen again,” she vowed.
She's moderated her tone a bit. But this is a report from last week (y Alex Seitz-Wald, Clinton Takes on Trumpism in Foreign Policy Speech NBC News 03/23/2016):

With one eye on an ascendent Donald Trump and the other on Europe, still reeling from this week's terror attack, Hillary Clinton offered a firm defense of internationalism and American leadership Wednesday. The Democratic front-runner said the U.S. is the only country that can rally the world to defeat ISIS and stand up to Russia and China.

At a hastily arranged speech on the campus of Stanford University, Clinton leaned on her personal experience as secretary of state and a senator from New York during September 11, to reject Trumpism while projecting her own vision of strength. ...

One name almost entirely absent from Clinton's speech was Obama. While she's generally called for continuing the president's legacy, foreign policy is the issue are where they've diverged the most, and Clinton seems to favor a more muscular U.S. on the world stage.
Then there was the recent AIPAC meeting. Paul Pillar writes (Ben Norton, “Took pandering to a new level”: Progressives, Palestinians criticize Hillary Clinton for “Israeli PR” AIPAC speech Salon 03/21/2016):

Democratic front-runner Hillary Clinton headlined the annual policy conference of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or AIPAC, on Monday.

She aggressively voiced support for Israel and hard-line right-wing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and made no mention of the Israeli military’s almost five-decade-long illegal occupation of the Palestinian territories.

Clinton also blasted her opponent Bernie Sanders, the only presidential candidate to turn down the invitation to speak at the AIPAC conference, for promising to be neutral on Israel-Palestine. Sanders said he would pursue a “level playing field” in negotiations, something Clinton insisted she would never imagine of doing.

Many progressives, young Americans and Jewish Americans are distancing themselves from Israel, which is increasingly far-right. The current administration is the most right-wing government ever in Israel, and Netanyahu will soon be the longest serving prime minister in the nation’s history — acting as head of state for even longer than Israeli founding father David Ben-Gurion.
And this despite the fact that Netanyahu has aligned more explicitly with the Republicans in domestic US policy than any Isreali government has even aligned itself with either major US party in US domestic party politics before.

Monday, November 09, 2015

Netanyahu in Washington

Robert Hunter gives a rundown on what he expects to be the concerns on each side of the US/Israel governmental meeting today between President Obama and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (Bibi Comes Calling: What President Obama Needs to Say LobeLog Foreign Policy; accessed 11/09/2015):

When Benjamin Netanyahu, prime minister of Israel, visits the Oval Office on Monday, both he and President Barack Obama have a domestic political interest in “making nice” with one another. Netanyahu has to show Israelis back home that his efforts to derail the conclusion of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) with Iran, following his outrageous speech to a joint session of Congress last spring, have not seriously damaged his country’s relations with the United States, Israel’s only firm supporter in the world. Obama also wants to show the American Jewish community that he bears no grudge, as he seeks its support for other elements of his foreign and domestic policies and as he paves the way for his successor in January 2017.
He notes that there won't be pretense of near-term progress on the endless peace process, as it is still politely called:

The ghost at the banquet on Monday will be the Israeli-Palestinian peace process. Both Netanyahu and Obama will pay lip service, but that is about it. Although US interests and efforts in the Middle East as a whole would be immensely aided by serious progress on this front—a proposition that no serious observer rejects—nothing will happen for the balance of this administration and well into the next. Obama made this clear last week, presumably to keep it off the agenda with Netanyahu.
Despite the distinctly unfriendly, even hostile attitude that Netanyahu's government has taken toward Obama, Netanyahu is pressing for a substantial increase in US military aid to Israel, which is easily the strongest military power in the Middle East and the only one with nuclear weapons:

Israel will also want to complete work on a 10-year extension of its security agreement with the US, which runs out in 2017. This will certainly be agreed to, at least in principle. At about $3 billion a year in military aid, Israel wants this figure to be bounced up to $5 billion. Obama may not be willing to go that far. And Israel will want to intensify the agreements, some tacit, some explicit, under which the US is supposed to “coordinate” its overall Middle East approaches with Jerusalem.
Hunter also suggests that Obama wants Netanyahu to intervene with AIPAC, the largest group in the Israel lobby in the US, to tell them to moderate their criticism:

Obama also has items on his agenda. Beyond a shared interest in presenting a calm and mutually supportive relationship, he wants to get Netanyahu to “call off the dogs” in the continuing US debate about the JCPOA and its implementation. Groups like the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), which is a politically potent and reliable reflection of Israeli government thinking, continue to try limiting the pacing of the agreement, especially in terms of sanctions relief. These groups also have consistently portrayed Iranian behavior, both under the agreement and in general, in the worst light possible. Netanyahu could have a good deal of influence in Washington, but whether he will be responsive is another matter (Obama is unlikely to raise this sensitive issue, himself, but rather to relegate it to subordinates).
It is indeed a "sensitive" issue. For the President to ask a foreign leader to intervene on his behalf with a domestic political group like AIPAC would be a high-level admission of what is actually common knowledge about the lobbying power of AIPAC and its arguably uncomfortable closeness to the Israeli government.

Hunter also points out that the US needs to be more clear generally in Middle East policy that we are pursuing a sensible policy for American interests and less to satisfy the preferences of client states that may have divergent interests from the US on important issues:

In the final analysis, in the Obama-Netanyahu meetings and in other US diplomacy regarding the Middle East, the United States needs to make clear a general policy that applies to Saudi Arabia and other Sunni states as much as to Israel: America’s strategic partnerships with friends in the region must become a genuine two-way street not just a one-way provision by Washington of military goods and services and security commitments. If Obama adopts this position and gives it teeth, he will greatly improve the chances that the United States can succeed with its overall objectives in the Middle East, which would also benefit Israel and other regional states. In any event, “American interests first” is always a good approach.

Thursday, August 13, 2015

Jimmy Carter and his legacy

Jimmy Carter continues to promote Middle East peace, however distant it may seem at the moment (Bronwen Maddox, Jimmy Carter: there is zero chance for the two-state solution Prospect 08/13/2015 ):

“At this moment, there is zero chance of the two-state solution,” said Jimmy Carter, giving his bleakest pronouncement yet on the Israeli-Palestinian deadlock to which he devoted much effort while President of the United States, and even more time since then.

“These are the worst prospects for peace between Israel and the Palestinians for years,” he said, adding that he didn’t think that Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel’s Prime Minister, “has any intention” of making progress towards the goal, the thrust of international efforts for decades, of the creation of a separate state for the Palestinians alongside Israel. After John Kerry’s efforts as Secretary of State to broker a deal, which collapsed in the spring last year, the “US has withdrawn” from the problem, he reckoned.
This is the state of affairs about which he warned in his book Peace Not Apartheid:

Among other observations in his interview with Maddox:

About Obama he is more forthright. “There are 22 people in my family and they all voted for Obama over Hillary [Clinton]” in 2008, he said. “In some ways he has been successful,” he says; “I particularly approve” of his action to restore relations between the US and Cuba—which Carter had also tried when President. But apart from that, the Iran deal, and healthcare “I don’t think he has had notably historic successes.” This might seem harsh, in that even Carter’s warmest fans have had to pick carefully among the storms of his presidency to find clear wins.

His praise is warmer, though, than for Hillary. He has said on US television that she is not “proven” as a politician, and has complimented John Kerry as Secretary of State for making efforts for Middle East peace that she, as Kerry’s predecessor, neglected to do. “She’s still got to get the nomination,” he points out, adding uncontroversially that he expects that she will indeed be the Democrat contender for the White House. If she is, however, he and his family will vote for her, he adds. On that point, at least, he appears prepared to compromise, for the sake of his lifelong loyalty to the Democratic cause.
Of course, he announced this week he has been diagnosed with cancer at age 90. We don't know how serious it is. I hope he survives to be still making important observations on world affairs at 100.

Observations like these:

Carter is now eloquent on the limits on US power which have so shaped Obama’s presidency. The 2003 Iraq invasion “was a clear mistake — a horrible mistake,” he said. “It has destroyed Iraq as a nation and opened up Iranian influence.” The US’s presence in Afghanistan, even if less controversial at its start, has been running for 13 years. US presidents no longer set out to “tell the truth and keep the peace,” he said. And its politics are deteriorating. “The massive quantities of dollars pouring into the political process have lost the essence of what made American democracy admirable.” “You need to raise $200-$300m” to run for Governor, Senator, never mind President, he said, and then the funders want their return on that afterwards. “When I ran we didn’t raise a nickel from outside.” The 2010 and 2014 rulings of the Supreme Court opening the gates to campaign donations from individual and corporate donors are “one of its biggest mistakes,” he said.
Charlie Pierce assesses Carter's public role to date this way (The Overlooked History of Jimmy Carter, Who Fights for His Life Esquire Politics Blog 08/12/2015):

This is a man who has lived a good, long, rich and decent life, and who has been slandered in history by people not morally fit to tie his shoes. I admit, my first exposure to him was in the frustrating stern chase in the 1976 Democratic primaries on behalf of Mo Udall. (Don't ever mention the 1976 Wisconsin primary to me. I will nail your head to the floor.) But watching what was done to him during the 1980 campaign – including what I believe was the international ratfcking involving the Reagan campaign and the Iranian hostages – and subsequently during the following eight-year national amyloid cascade got me on his side. I don't believe he was a good president, and it can be argued that the stick up his ass was the size of a Louisville slugger and that his talking about "ethnic purity" in our neighborhoods presaged what was coming with DLC politics. Nevertheless, this was a tough man, despite what you may have heard. He was tough enough to win a very hard primary season and then whip a sitting president in the general election. He was tough enough to hand a Kennedy the worst electoral drubbing anybody in that family ever suffered. And, more relevant to our current situation, he was a lot tougher on Iran than Ronald Reagan ever was.
It's sometimes a bit difficult to recall how controversial Carter was within the Democratic Party, and not primarily from Southern conservatives. George McGovern and his immediate family voted for Gerald Ford in 1976, worried that Carter was too hawkish - though McGovern certainly did not campaign for Ford! In 1980, not only Ted Kennedy but Jerry Brown made serious primary challenges to Carter when he was the sitting Democratic President.

Monday, March 23, 2015

Gideon Levy says Netanyahu told the truth about no two-state solution

Israeli peace advocate gives re-elected Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu backhanded praise for his pre-election statement flatly rejecting a two-state solution (Netanyahu will be remembered for speaking Israel's truth Haaretz 03/22/2015):

I would like to say thank you to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Thank you for telling the truth. Last week you were revealed as the first Israeli prime minister to tell the truth. For at least 25 years most Israeli statesmen have been lying, misleading the world, the Israelis and themselves, until Netanyahu arose – he of all statesmen – and told the truth. If only this truth had been told by an Israeli prime minister 25 years ago, maybe even 50 years ago, when the occupation was born. Still, better late than never. The public rewarded him for this truth, and Netanyahu was elected for a fourth term.

Netanyahu said last week that if he were to be reelected, a Palestinian state would not be established on his watch. Plain and simple, loud and clear. This simple, pure truth was the case for all his predecessors as well – all the prime ministers, peace lovers and justice seekers from the center and the left, who gave false promises. ...

After all, one had to deceive the Americans, bluff the Europeans and cheat the Palestinians, fudge things for the Mideast Quartet and lie to some Israelis. One also had to play for time, to build settlements and get rid of every possible Palestinian partner – Yasser Arafat, who was too strong; President Mahmoud Abbas, who is too weak; and Hamas, which is too extreme. One has to play for time, so the Palestinians become more extreme and everyone understands that there’s no one to talk to. [my emphasis]
This is why I'm leery of the strategy that the Obama Administration is sending up trial balloons on, of the US using the two-state solution to put diplomatic pressure on Israel.

Whatever its short-term advantages of highlighting the irresponsible warmongering of Netanyahu and his Republican allies, it also means that the Obama Administration is pretending the current reality is something other than the fact that Israel now faces the basic choice of being a democratic state that is no longer Jewish either officially or by majority, or being a Jewish apartheid state that is undemocratic.

At this point, it's hard to see how pursuing the phantom of a two-state solution that is no longer feasible actually advances the resolution of the long-standing failure to achieve a lasting peace settlement in Israel-Palestine.

Thursday, March 19, 2015

Obama Administration sketches a new posture on the Israeli occupation - or does it?

The White House chose Peter Beinart to write their press release in the form of a news story on US policy toward Israel, Enraged by Netanyahu's rhetoric, White House officials believe Israeli-U.S. relations fundamentally changed Haaretz 03/19/2015. Via Beinart, the Obama Administration frames things this way. They complain about Netanyahu's comment about the Arabs voting and about his campaign comments about settlement policy in the occupied territories and his explicit rejection of a two-state solution.

This is a little much to swallow:

There is little President Obama considers more loathsome, administration officials note, than stoking racism to win votes. “Given our own history we have a unique perspective on the idea that minorities’ voting is not something to be condemned or feared,” said one administration official. The analogy is significant because the civil rights movement is Obama’s moral compass. For an administration official to compare Netanyahu to George Wallace or Bull Connor, even obliquely, says a lot about which side of history they believe he’s on. [my emphasis]
Does the "moral compass" that Martin Luther King, Jr. was following in this speech resonate with the President: Martin Luther King's Speech Against the Vietnam War, column by David Bromwich Antiwar.com 03/16/2008?

I'm guessing not.

Ironically, Antiwar.com calls itself "one project of our parent foundation, the Randolph Bourne Institute." But the link leads directly to the segregationist/"libertarian" Mises Institute.

The White House via Beinart floats the following policy options. First one:

... let the Palestinian Authority collapse and let Bibi deal with the calamity that follows. Early this year, Israel began withholding more than $100 million in tax revenue to punish Palestinians for trying to join the International Criminal Court. Since then, the Obama administration has been going around, cup in hand, trying to get European and Persian Gulf countries to give the Palestinian Authority the money to stay afloat.
Number two:

A second option is to allow the United Nations Security Council to pass a resolution condemning settlements. In other words, to withdraw America’s veto. Administration officials insist that they will never cut military aid, since that would harm Israeli security. And they say Obama will go on meeting Netanyahu, as unpleasant as that may be. They also won’t support Palestinian efforts at the International Criminal Court, since that feeds Israel’s “delegitimization.”
Beinart doesn't mention it, but both the Cheney-Bush and Obama Administrations have been distinctly hostile to the notion of the ICC having jurisdiction over Americans. We're Exceptional, after all.

Not vetoing UN resolutions that Israel doesn't like, though, would be a notable change in the US diplomatic stance. Realistically, though, as long as "Administration officials insist that they will never cut military aid," Israel is unlikely to take such diplomatic slights that seriously as pressure.

And number three:

The third, and most dramatic, move would be for America to support a UN resolution outlining the parameters of final two state deal. Administration officials expect the French to push such an effort on the theory that UN parameters would attain the iconic status enjoyed by UN resolutions 242 and 388, and, eventually, become the basis for serious talks. The Obama administration would not sign a European-crafted resolution, which they suspect would make specific demands on Israel about territorial withdrawal and the division of Jerusalem while offering only vague language about Palestinian obligations on refugees and recognition of Israel as a Jewish state.

But there is a serious effort, which began last year, and has already involved extensive negotiations by people close to the administration, to Americanize a final status resolution. Such a resolution would endorse an Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank and making Jerusalem the shared capital of two states. It would acknowledge that the 1967 lines could be modified by land swaps, but to satisfy the Palestinians, perhaps declare that those land swaps be equal in size. To make the resolution more palatable to Israel, however, the US would insert clear language recognizing Israel as a Jewish state, essentially ruling out a large-scale right of refuge return and making Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank contingent on the performance of Palestinian security forces. [my emphasis]
Here's where I start to suspect that chronic Democratic stumbling may take over.

This stance assumes that the Democrats and the Obama Administration would put their two-state position up against the de facto Republican-Likud position of Greater Israel.

But can we really assume that a two-state solution, even with the best imaginable will on all sides, is a realistic option any more? I very seriously doubt it, though if it could be pulled off in a comprehensive settlement, I would be happy to see it. But it doesn't look very feasible. Robert Perry writes in Netanyahu Unmasks Israel Consortium News 03/18/2015:

The truth is that the two-state solution has been a fiction for at least the past two decades, dying in 1995 with the assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin. But the two-state illusion still served important political purposes both for Israelis, who would pay it lip service while continuing their steady encroachment on Palestinian lands, and for U.S. politicians who could point to the mirage as an excuse not to pressure Israel too hard on its human rights violations.

Yet, whenever any U.S. official actually tried to reach that shimmering oasis of a two-state solution, it would recede into the distance. Then, the Israelis would rely on their friends and allies in the news media and politics to blame the Palestinians. Now, however, the illusion of Israel seeking such an outcome in good faith has been lost in Netanyahu’s anything-goes determination to keep his office – a case of political expediency trumping strategic expediency.
Assuming the two-state solution is dead, what we're looking at is basically the choice that Jimmy Carter and others have described: (1) A predominately Jewish Israel with Palestinians in Israel and the occupied territories as the subjected population in an apartheid state; or, (2) constructing some version of Greater Israel that would make the occupied territories part of Israel and make the Palestinians there full citizens, which would mean a non-Jewish majority in the not-too-distant future.

And choice, in other words, between a Jewish state that practices apartheid or a democratic state that is not Jewish-majority.

So what would it mean for the Obama Administration or a future one to "insert clear language recognizing Israel as a Jewish state" in a UN decision that would take on the force of international law? That would put the United States more on the apartheid side of that choice.

And if absorbing the occupied territories makes them part of Israel, what would it mean to make "Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank contingent on the performance of Palestinian security forces"?

That resolution only makes sense in terms of a two-state solution, where "Israeli" and "Palestinian" were still two separate things.

But without a final settlement on the nature of the state, doesn't recognizing Israel de jure as a "Jewish state," and giving them the right to have their army in the occupied territories until Israel determines that there is no remaining terrorist threat, mean locking the status quo into place in all essential aspects?

That one is a puzzler to me.

Wednesday, March 18, 2015

Israel and the US post-Israeli election

After Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu's win in the Israeli election Tuesday, foreign policy observers and analysts are speculating on what changes in US-Israeli relations may follow.

Netanyahu took the unusual step of publicly announcing his rejection of any possible two-state solution for Israel and Palestine. That has been the longtime official goal of the United States and theoretically of Israel, too. How possible it was and how seriously either country took it has been in question for some time. It was in 2006 that Jimmy Carter's book Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid was published, warning that the time for a two-state solution was in danger of passing permanently.

Roberta Rampton and Patricia Zengerle report in U.S. rebukes Israel's victorious Netanyahu on Mideast policy Reuters 03/18/2015:

White House spokesman Josh Earnest reaffirmed Obama’s commitment to a two-state solution to the Middle East conflict and said that based on Netanyahu’s comments, "the United States will evaluate our approach to this situation moving forward."

Netanyahu’s insistence that there will be no Palestinian state while he holds office, seen as a maneuver to mobilize his right-wing base, angered the Palestinians and drew criticism from the United Nations and European governments. Chances for restarting long-stalled peace moves already had been low.

U.S. lawmakers were divided on Netanyahu's hardened stance.

"It was remarkable to back-track so significantly on a two-state solution," said Democratic U.S. Senator Chris Murphy, adding it could make Washington's effort to mediate more difficult.

Republican Senator Lindsey Graham said he hoped the United States and Israel would see the election as "an opportunity to start over." But he said: "A two-state solution is impossible as long as Hamas exists and runs Gaza."
Yes, you could say that "lawmakers were divided" over Netanyahu's public policy shift.

He has put himself clearly on the side of the Republican Party against the Democratic Party and the Democratic President. The Republicans are happy about that development, as Cenk Uygur explains in Who Are Netanyahu's GOP Supporters? The Young Turks 03/18/2015:



Paul Pillar writes on Netanyahu's Latest Challenge to Obama The National Interest 03/18/2015:

After all the alarming and scaring that this prime minister has done, one of his final scares was to warn that Arab citizens of Israel would actually—you'd better sit down before you read this—vote. This was an even more blatant, and openly racist, approach to the subject of voter turnout among opposing parts of the electorate than the enactment of voter suppression laws in the United States. ...

For the United States, the most significant of Netanyahu's statements in his appealing to the intractable Right of the Israeli electorate was to declare clearly and unequivocally his opposition to a Palestinian state. In so doing, and in affirming his determination to hold on to occupied territory, he offered no honorable alternative way to deal with the trilemma of how Israel cannot hold onto all that land and be a Jewish state and be democratic. Evidently he sees things the same way as his billionaire backer Sheldon Adelson, who said, “Israel isn't going to be a democratic state—so what?”

Of course, there is no surprise in the substance of Netanyahu's statement. It has long been abundantly clear from the conduct of himself and his government that he has had no intention of acceding to creation of a Palestinian state, and that past remarks suggesting that he did were only window dressing. But to move from window dressing and polite fiction to open declaration nonetheless has consequences, not only for the one making the declaration but also for others who have to deal with him. [my emphasis]
As Israel goes even more in the direction of creating an apartheid state, we can expect to hear from Republicans how Israel can serve as a model on how to handle not just "terrorists" but minority populations who are theoretically full citizens of their own country.

Juan Cole describes the implications of Netanyahu's stance in Apartheid Forever: Israel’s Netanyahu rules out Palestinian Citizenship Rights Informed Comment 03/17/2015:

Netanyahu and the Israeli right-of-center say they want to keep Palestinians homeless and without citizenship rights in a state because they fear a Palestinian state will make claims on Israel and present a security challenge. Netanyahu said Sunday that if Israel relinquished the West Bank it would become a bastion of Muslim radicalism (but West Bankers are substantially more secular than the Jewish population of West Jerusalem).

But in fact, Netanyahu and the right are dedicated to Greater Israel, to annexing the West Bank territory and finding a way to expel the Palestinians from it. The Palestinians are not a security challenge– they are like the guard at a bank getting in the way of bank robbers. The bank robbers feel a need to knock him out or kill him, remove him from the scene.

But it is shameful to have Israel preside over 4 million stateless people forever. This is Apartheid. And Netanyahu has just made Apartheid the official policy of Israel, just as South African leader P.W. Botha dedicated himself to making black South Africans stateless and without the rights of citizenship. The only fig leaf Israel had for its Apartheid was the farce of the “peace process” and a pro forma ritual invocation of a “future Palestinian state.” Now Netanyahu has ripped off the fig leaf and stands naked before the world. Botha was called by his victims the “Great Crocodile.” It would be better epithet for Netanyahu than “Bibi.”

Monday, November 24, 2014

The pending "Jewish nation-state law" in Israel

There is a law pending in the Israeli parliament (Knesset) that's known as the "Jewish nation-state law." If passed, it would seemingly be a significant step toward creating a formal apartheid-like type of government.

The Israeli paper Haaretz provides a summary of the pending law in Israel's Jewish nation-state bill: a primer 11/25/2014:

The legislation, which was originally drafted by right-wing MK Ze'ev Elkin (Likud), is an attempt to resolve the tension between the country's dual Jewish and democratic character, as enshrined in the Declaration of Independence.

It does that by defining Jewishness as the default nature of the state in any instance, legal or legislative, in which the state's Jewishness and its democratic aspirations clash.

The bill defines the State of Israel’s identity as "the nation-state of the Jewish people.” That not only means that the country's national holidays are Jewish religious holidays or that the flag is the Magen David; it also means that Jewish law will be the inspiration for Israel's legal system and it enshrines the automatic citizenship granted by the Law of Return.

Crucially, while the bill affirms “the personal rights of all [Israel's] citizens according to law,” it reserves communal rights for Jews only. In other words, individual Arabs are equal in the eyes of the law, but their communal rights are not recognized.
It isn't law yet. It's apparently not any kind of done deal. Haaretz notes, "both Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Justice Minister Tzipi Livni have proposed watered-down versions of the bill. At this stage, it's not clear which version will be brought to vote in the Knesset plenum."

Euronews reports on the proposed law in Israeli cabinet backs bill which critics describe as 'undemocratic' 11/23/2014:


Friday, October 31, 2014

Israel, the US, Palestinians and Iran

Mitchell Plitnick grumbles about the focus on an anonymous American official's "chickens**t" comment about Israel's Bibi Netanyahu. (Netanyahu and Obama: Name-Calling and its Discontents LobeLog Foreign Policy 10/31/2014) He then proceeds to use it repeatedly himself in his article.

Plitnick isn't just tossing around insults, though. He's making an informed evaluation of the leadership style of Obama and Netanyahu. And he emphasizes that the real problem between the US and Israel is not the personalities of their leaders, but rather real differences in interests and policies. He also makes this useful observation about how that affects the options for American leaders:

[Obama] is a president with a non-confrontational style trying to govern with what is, arguably, the most defiant and combative Congress any president has ever had to deal with. And he is dealing with an Israeli government that is pursuing a very different strategy than its predecessors. The Israel of today no longer cares about the majority of the Jewish community in the United States. This Israel, correctly, determined that its ultimate desire to completely thwart a two-state solution and maintain an apartheid system over the Palestinians would never be acceptable to most American Jews. But most US Jews weren’t the ones providing the political power and, more importantly, the funding for congressional campaigns and for settlements in the West Bank.

The Jews that do provide these things, as well as the Christians, are right-wingers, either in their general politics or at least on Middle East policy (including policy toward the entire Arab world, Iran and Turkey). They are now the only ones Israel cares about. More liberal-minded devotees are not, at this stage, providing that much support for Israel, either economically or financially. Those of them who do provide this support will continue to check their otherwise liberal values at the Israeli door. The rest are not, in the estimate of the Netanyahu government, worth the compromises that must be made to garner their support. [my emphasis]
Plitnick cites this news report by Ron Ben-Yishai, Easing Gaza restrictions is the new two-state solution Ynet 10/11/2014 about current Israeli-Egyptian plans for keeping a lid on the Palestinians. He doesn't think it's like to succeed. But he emphasizes that the Obama Administration is supporting that effort:

This seems like another doomed plan, one that harkens back to old Israeli beliefs that Palestinian nationalism will eventually just go away. But we must recognize that this is happening with the silent approval of the United States. Egypt, in particular, would not work with Israel on such a plan if it believed that the United States would object. More to the point, the plan is also intended to provide the US with what it wants most: Palestinian silence. What American policy has always represented is the complete lack of importance placed on the welfare of the Palestinians, or anyone else (including ordinary Israelis) in the region, for that matter. The entire issue is only relevant insofar as it affects more “important” US concerns.

So, the Obama administration will likely allow Israel to proceed with its plans, even if it doesn’t believe those plans are likely to succeed. This is evident in the lack of material response to Israel’s direct challenge to the international consensus on a two-state solution. [my emphasis]
Even if he's overstating the case on American indifference to the fate of the Palestinians, his argument that the immediate point of greatest tension between the two countries is Iran is plausible:

If Congress persists in pressuring the administration on its Iran policy, a pressure which most understand as directed by Jerusalem, Obama may well respond through the Palestinian issue. In that case, we might see a more direct counter to Israeli policies, such as a Security Council resolution condemning the settlements or even an “Obama Plan” basing a two-state solution on the 1967 borders and sharing Jerusalem. That would be a turn of events not seen in decades, but Israel has also never worked so hard to undermine US goals on foreign policy matters as it has on Iran. [my emphasis]

Thursday, October 30, 2014

Israel and the US 2014

Jeffrey's Goldberg's article, The Crisis in U.S.-Israel Relations Is Officially Here The Atlantic 10/28/2014, has touched off a number of responses that review the state of relations between the United States and Israel.

Paul Pillar in U.S.-Israeli Relations: Don't Call It a Crisis The National Interest 10/29/2014 makes this observation in connection with the tensions that Goldberg describes:

One can legitimately question some of the particular accusations by the U.S. officials that Goldberg reports, not to mention the scatological and indecorous terminology employed. But to concentrate on this is to overlook the larger and far more important contours of the relationship. The most fundamental truth about the relationship is that, notwithstanding routine references to Israel as an “ally,” it is not an ally of the United States beyond being the recipient of all that U.S. material and political largesse. An ally is someone who offers something comparably significant and useful in return, particularly on security matters. That this is not true of Israel's relationship with the United States is underscored by the priority that the United States has placed, during some of its own past conflicts in the Middle East such as Operation Desert Storm, on Israel not getting involved because such involvement would be a liability, not an asset. [my emphasis in bold]
Chemi Shalev places much of the blame for the current tensions on Bibi Netanyahu (The 'chickenshit' relationship between Obama and Netanyahu Haaretz 10/29/2014):

Netanyahu earned the White House’s ire not for “standing up for Israel’s interests” behind closed doors, as he claims, but for wagging his finger, thumbing his nose and spitting in Obama’s eye while doing so, for the entire world to see. Despite the steady stream of righteous indignation emanating from Netanyahu and his defenders in both Israel and the U.S.in the past 24 hours, there are very few red lines that the prime minister has not crossed in recent years in his contentious relationship with the American president. ...

Netanyahu has gleefully dissed Obama and his policies, on and off the record, often sounding no different than any rank and file member of the Republican caucus in Congress and regularly flaunting his intimate ties with their mutual benefactor and Obama nemesis, Sheldon Adelson. [my emphasis]
Israeli dove Gideon Levy (Who's the real chickenshit? Haaretz 10/29/2014) places more of the blame on Obama for letting Bibi push him around up until now, writing, "After six years of supporting the Netanyahu government’s moves with money and backing, support in the UN and weapons deliveries, there’s something pathetic and even aggravating about the insults now being hurled at Netanyahu. They seem more like ego games than policy."

Levy also seems to think the possibility of a two-state solution is gone: "Obama let Netanyahu continue building in the settlements, striking the fatal blow to the two-state solution dead."

Pillar makes some objection to the use of "crisis" about the current situation:

... in this context the word crisis is a misnomer. The term usually indicates a potential for a big turn for the worse, especially the outbreak of a war between whatever two parties are experiencing a crisis. That's not what's involved here. The only reason the term crisis comes up regarding U.S.-Israeli relations is the fictional, deliberately inflated view of the relationship as something qualitatively different that ought to defy any of the usual rules that apply to any patron and client or to any bilateral relationship. Sweep aside the politically-driven fiction about two countries that supposedly have everything in common and nothing in conflict and instead deal with reality, and the concept of crisis does not arise at all. What you have instead is a bilateral relationship that is like many others the United States has, with some parallel interests and objectives along with other objectives that diverge - sometimes sharply - and with honest recognition of the latter being a normal part of business.

Monday, September 08, 2014

The politics of the 2014 Gaza War

Sarah Posner has a long post at Religion Dispatches on differences within the American Jewish community over the recent Gaza War, The Collapse of the American Jewish Center 08/12/2014.

She cites this report by J.J. Goldberg in The Jewish Daily Forward, How Politics and Lies Triggered an Unintended War in Gaza 07/10/2014, which explains how the Netanyahu government manipulated information about the kidnapping and murder of three Israeli Jewish boys:

The frustration had numerous causes. Once the boys’ disappearance was known, troops began a massive, 18-day search-and-rescue operation, entering thousands of homes, arresting and interrogating hundreds of individuals, racing against the clock. Only on July 1, after the boys’ bodies were found, did the truth come out: The government had known almost from the beginning that the boys were dead. It maintained the fiction that it hoped to find them alive as a pretext to dismantle Hamas’ West Bank operations.

The initial evidence was the recording of victim Gilad Shaer’s desperate cellphone call to Moked 100, Israel’s 911. When the tape reached the security services the next morning — neglected for hours by Moked 100 staff — the teen was heard whispering “They’ve kidnapped me” (“hatfu oti”) followed by shouts of “Heads down,” then gunfire, two groans, more shots, then singing in Arabic. That evening searchers found the kidnappers’ abandoned, torched Hyundai, with eight bullet holes and the boys’ DNA. There was no doubt.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu immediately placed a gag order on the deaths. Journalists who heard rumors were told the Shin Bet wanted the gag order to aid the search. For public consumption, the official word was that Israel was “acting on the assumption that they’re alive.” It was, simply put, a lie. ...

Nor was that the only fib. It was clear from the beginning that the kidnappers weren’t acting on orders from Hamas leadership in Gaza or Damascus. Hamas’ Hebron branch — more a crime family than a clandestine organization — had a history of acting without the leaders’ knowledge, sometimes against their interests. Yet Netanyahu repeatedly insisted Hamas was responsible for the crime and would pay for it. [my emphasis]
It doesn't help the United States in the rest of the world to be seen as backing a war by Israel on Gaza that was understandably widely viewed as unjustified and excessively destructive.

Tags: ,

Sunday, August 10, 2014

Implications for Israel of Obama's new Iraq War

Amos Harel reports on some of the practical benefits and drawbacks to Israel's current government from the Obama Administration decision to resume direct combat in the Iraq War (Islamic State draws heat from Israel - but not for long Haaretz 08/11/2014):

From the Israeli perspective, there’s some public diplomacy benefit here. The world is being somewhat distracted from what’s going on in Gaza, and now Israel is not the only country bombing Islamic extremists. But these are small comforts at best. Europe, in particular, seems to have gotten fed up with the IDF’s operations in Gaza, even as it declares its understanding for Israel’s right to defend itself. And despite the renewal of rocket fire, even the United States is expecting Israel to come to some long-term agreement with Hamas.

The Islamic State's progress has no direct or immediate ramifications for Israeli security, but one can't ignore the indirect effects. Jordan, one of Israel's closest allies in the region, is in a panic – not just because the Islamic State's rampages are liable to bring even more refugees banging on its gates, but because they pose a real threat to its borders. To a great extent, Israel sees the border between Jordan and Iraq as its strategic eastern border. In recent months, the world media has reported extensively on the intelligence and military assistance Israel is providing Jordan, so the latter can cope with threats along its borders with Syria and Iraq.

Another indirect effect relates to the situation in Lebanon. Along with its operations in Iraq and Syria, the Islamic State recently seized control of the village of Arsal along the Syrian-Lebanese border. The presence of Sunni extremists there forced the Lebanese Army to deploy units along the border to block their progress, and Hezbollah was also forced to make changes in its military positions. [my emphasis]
Tags: , ,

Wednesday, August 06, 2014

The latest Gaza war

The whole field of US policy toward Israel is frustrating for me to think about.

Because fundamentally the US has a real interest in a peaceful and permanent resolution of the problem of the occupied territories. Israel's perceived interest appears to be the opposite.

So we end up with the kind of bipartisan ship in which every time Israel goes to war, Congress immediately leaps in with a unanimous or near-unanimous and one-sided vote of support for Israel. This constricts the range of discussion of options in the US at the start, because our lazy national media can't present "both sides" if the political consensus is in agreement on everything but which side is more militant in its support of the Israeli government making war. And this in support of a country with which the US does not have a mutual defense treaty. The US has offered to make one but Israel has refused, because such a treaty would require a legal definition of the border to be defended.

Like in earlier wars, Israel's spokespeople repeat the refrain that Israel has the right to defend itself. Not that any American politician is questioning that, or anyone else I know of. I assume jihadist groups would deny that right but presumably they expect restraint from Israel less than anyone.

What that endlessly repeated declaration means is that Israel presents all of its actions in the Gaza war, targeting of UN schools and refugee centers included, as legitimate defense. What's playing out in that war right now certainly looks like neither side, Hamas or Israel, has any principled objection to deliberately killing civilians to terrorize the other side. But Israel has immensely greater ability to do so, and is in fact doing so in the current phase of this conflict.

The Young Turks did a long commentary on the Gaza War that takes up the first half hour or so of this video, The Young Turks - 08.04.14: Gaza, Israel, John Kerry, Police Brutality & What's In A Name?:



One of the constructive aspects of the Obama Administration so far is that, ironically, Obama has to some extent opposed the bad bipartisanship in Congress over Israel policy by withdrawing from Iraq and pursuing negotiations with Iran over their nuclear program. The latter in particular is something Israel opposes and it's been an annual ritual for years for Israel to threaten to go to war with Iran if the US doesn't. (Rupert Murdoch's Times of London is famous for every year or so printing a story about Israel's impending attack on Iran.)

And this is a toxic bipartisanship over Israel policy, because the Republican side of it is driven by a fanatical Christian fundamentalist ideology that wants escalating war in the Middle East so Jesus can hurry up and return to Earth - and do away with all the Jews in the process. There is also a subtext (not so "sub" actually) that the fundis see Israelis as white people fighting against dark-skinned Muslims. Even though a considerable number of Palestinians are Christians, and I'm sure American fundi tour groups are often surprised at the complexion of many non-Arab Israelis. I saw some poll recently that showed during the current Gaza war, the only group in which general approval of Israel had increased during the war was Christian fundis.

The Arab governments in reason are pretty cynical about the whole business. But even monarchies and dictatorships have to take account of public opinion in some way. It's certainly believable that those governments are happy to Israel as a permanent enemy to show their zeal for Islam in the form of publicly criticizing Israel.

Now that we're not directly making war in Iraq and are finally wrapping it up (hopefully!) in Afghanistan, that removes some of the urgency for the United States from the old "winning hearts and minds" in the Muslim world effort. Not that we were ever good at it. The fact that supposedly serious commentators adopted without irony the "winning hearts and minds" phrase that became a bad joke of the Vietnam War is a symptom of how poor the effort was.

But it's hard to imagine that resolving the Palestinian statehood issue and also reaching a permanent settlement over Kashmir between India and Pakistan wouldn't at least remove some of the potential for anti-American politics in the Muslim world. The latter is virtually unknown in the United States, but supposedly well known in Muslim countries; it has been a major factor in Pakistan's relations to the Afghan government, which Pakistan perceives as pro-India.

Andrés Cala, whose foreign policy writing I only recently discovered, has a good commentary on Israel, Israel’s Bloody but Hollow ‘Victory’ Consortium News 08/05/2014:

Like in the past, Israel has more than enough geopolitical support – or silent complicity – from Western governments, even if the rest of the world condemns Tel Aviv for its disproportionate use of force and the terrible civilian death toll, now approaching 2,000 Gazans killed, including many children.

During the four-week-long onslaught, Israel has found that it’s getting harder to justify its overwhelming assault on the narrow Gaza Strip, especially attacks on United Nations-designated buildings shielding civilian refugees. But Israel apparently is willing to ignore the global outrage as long as its vital Western allies – chiefly the United States – continue to insist Israel has “a right to defend itself.”

But European public opinion – with discreet and isolated political consequences so far – is turning decisively against Israel’s use of force against the 1.7 million Gazans who are blockaded on all sides by Israel and Egypt’s military regime. Though most European governments continue to mute their criticism of Israel, popular disgust with these periodic attacks — called "mowing the grass" in Israel — could tilt the geopolitical balance in favor of the Palestinians.
The US has developed an unhealthy relationship with Israel which amounts in practice to one-sided support of Israel, even when they are doing things that conflict with US interests, at least as conceived in a reasonably realistic way.

Until the US can change the domestic political context of our support for Israel to the point where we can have a normal set of trade-offs, our ability to influence Israel's policy in a constructive way will be minimal. For instance, the US needs to be able to credible condition its level of aid on the status of settlement activity in the West Bank. But until that happens, we'll be stuck in the position of providing large amounts of aid to Israel and providing effectively uncritical support even to Israel's most reckless military actions, while having little direct effect over Israel's actual policies. Thereby having the rest of the world, not implausibly, see the US as directly complicit even in the worst Israel does.

Obama's success so far in keeping the Iranian nuclear negotiations going and pressuring leading Democrats in Congress not to sabotage them is an example of how policy can begin to change.

It's also a reminder that when Obama wants to use the Presidency to implement policies that support peace and progress, he's able to get substantial things done in that direction.

Tags: ,

Friday, March 07, 2014

Ukraine, Russia and domestic polemics

Timothy Snyder has a three-part article on the Ukraine situation at the New York Review of Books:

Fascism, Russia, and Ukraine 02/19/2014

Ukraine: The Haze of Propaganda 03/01/2014

Crimea: Putin vs. Reality 03/07/2014

The first one is a bit confusing in that it reads a bit like "fascists, fascists, which one's the fascist"? But he does provide some helpful summaries of the repressive measures taken by Viktor Yanukovych's government after the crisis heated up. And he describes the concept behind Putin's Eurasian Union goal, which Snyder takes to be a version of "National Bolshevism."

He marvels that some people on "the Western left" are sympathetic to false pro-Putin claims, without describing who he's including in "the Western left." Apparently the LaRouchies are kinda-sorta supporting Putin's positions. Maybe that's who he means by "the Western left." (?!) I've seen more drooling over Putin's manly manliness from American conservatives like Victor Davis Hanson than from anyone I would identify as "left."

In the second piece, he gets more specific, though it's still not clear where he places the LaRouchies:

Interestingly, the message from authoritarian regimes in Moscow and Kiev was not so different from some of what was written during the uprising in the English-speaking world, especially in publications of the far left and the far right. From Lyndon LaRouche’s Executive Intelligence Review through Ron Paul’s newsletter through The Nation and The Guardian, the story was essentially the same: little of the factual history of the protests, but instead a play on the idea of a nationalist, fascist, or even Nazi coup d’état.
Snyder makes an insistent case that the overthrow of Yanukovych was "a classic popular revolution" - whatever he counts as "classic" - against "an unmistakably reactionary regime." But after berating the Russian/Yanukovych framing of the overthrown as a fascist/Nazi coup or something along those lines, Synder writes:

The Ukrainian far right did play an important part in the revolution. What it did, in going to the barricades, was to liberate itself from the regime of which it had been one of the bulwarks. One of the moral atrocities of the Yanukovych regime was to crush opposition from the center-right, and support opposition from the far right. By imprisoning his major opponents from the legal political parties, most famously Yulia Tymoshenko, Yanukovych was able to make of democracy a game in which he and the far right were the only players.

The far right, a party called Svoboda, grew larger in these conditions, but never remotely large enough to pose a real challenge to the Yanukovych regime in democratic elections. In this arrangement Yanukovych could then tell gullible westerners that he was the alternative to the far right. In fact, Svoboda was a house opposition that, during the revolution, rebelled against its own leadership. Against the wishes of their leaders, the radical youth of Svoboda fought in considerable numbers, alongside of course people of completely different views. They fought and they took risks and they died, sometimes while trying to save others. In the post-revolutionary situation these young men will likely seek new leadership. The leader of Svoboda, according to opinion polls, has little popular support; if he chooses to run for president, which is unlikely, he will lose.

The radical alternative to Svoboda is Right Sector, a group of far-right organizations whose frankly admitted goal was not a European future but a national revolution against all foreign influences. In the long run, Right Sector is the group to watch. For the time being, its leaders have been very careful, in conversations with both Jews and Russians, to stress that their goal is political and not ethnic or racial.
After seeing how the Western powers picked allies in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya and Syria, I think it's a very sensible caution for citizens of those Western countries to wonder just who Our Side is in this particular crisis.

In the third part he writes, "The Russian invasion and occupation of Ukraine’s Crimean peninsula is a disaster for the European peacetime order." It certainly is a major disruption with far-reaching consequences for people in Ukraine, including the Crimea. But I don't see how in current circumstances it's going to be a "disaster" for the EU countries unless some wild escalation of sanctions and counter-sanctions starts taking place.

And he writes, "After the regime tried and failed to put down the protests by shooting protestors from rooftops on February 20, EU negotiators arranged a deal whereby Yanukovych would cede power to parliament. Rather than signing the corresponding legislation, as he had committed to do, Yanukovych fled to Russia." He seems to mean this as an indictment of Yanukovych's conduct, and that may be justified. But it also emphasizes how actively the EU was involved in backing the opposition in some form or another in seeking regime change. And that's also a legitimate matter for public concern, in the US and in Europe. I don't recall the German Bundestag authorizing Chancellor Angela Merkel to undertake regime change in Ukraine.

And there's the seemingly unavoidable Hitler analogy - unavoidable in the sense that the US only ever faces "Hitler" as a threat in foreign policy, at least in the eyes of analogy-makers:

Putin and others blur the category of citizenship by speaking of Russian “compatriots,” a category that has no legal status. By compatriots Putin means people the Russian government claims as Russians—or who, according to the Kremlin, self-identify as Russians—and who therefore need its protection. This sort of argument, the need to protect the Volksgenossen, was used to significant effect by Adolf Hitler in 1938 in enunciating German claims to Austria and then to the Sudetenland in Czechoslovakia. Hitler’s substitution of ethnicity for state borders led then to the Munich conference, appeasement, and World War II. Russian historian Andrei Zubov has developed the comparison with Nazi aggression further, likening Putin’s action to the Anschluss, and recalling that the Anschluss led to a war that turned against its authors. The parallel has also been noted by the chief rabbi of Ukraine.
Snyder also seems to think the Russian propagandists have super powers:

An excellent propaganda apparatus, such as the Russian one, can find ways to repeat its message over and over again in slightly different ways and formats. Plenty of people in the West now spread Russian propaganda, sometimes for money, sometimes from ignorance, and sometimes for reasons best known to themselves. Those who repeat the Russian propaganda conceits do not need to convince everyone, only to set the terms of debate. If people in free societies have their discussions framed for them by rulers of unfree societies, then they will not notice the history unfolding around them (a revolution just happened in Europe!) or sense the urgency of formulating policy in a desperate situation (a European country has just invaded another!). Propaganda can serve this technical purpose no matter how absurd it is.
I guess if you want to frame this as a New Cold War, then "Russian" propaganda is just as sinister as "Communist" propaganda. Although who all these people "in the West" are who so eagerly "spread Russian propaganda" are, I really don't know. Unless it's those publications he named in Part 2, and even that was a broad assertion.

Snyder seems to really want to pump up the role anti-Semitism in Russia. I was struck by this passage: "In the years before Stalin's death Israel became part of an international plot that was directed by fascists in the capitalist West." And the so-called "Doctor Plot" incident does seem to have been the start of some kind of anti-Semitic campaign in the USSR at that time.

But that was scarcely the whole story. I quoted an article on the founding of Israel over five years ago, Israel's founding and the Soviet Union 01/19/2009: "Establishment of the state of Israel on 14 May [1948] was internationally an important achievement for the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union and its satellites supported the Jews in every way throughout the war in Palestine." (Rami Ginat, "Soviet Policy towards the Arab World, 1945-48," Middle Eastern Studies Oct 1996) And I also wrote there:

But Britain and France weren't ready to recognize Israel at that time. Both nations were trying hard to hang on to their worldwide empires and didn't want to give the Jewish-Zionist national liberation movement in Palestine that much of a victory.

The Soviet Union did. And the Truman administration decided to support the creation of Israel, not because it was particularly popular, on the contrary. Truman was persuaded it was the right thing to do for a number of reasons.

But it's important to note here that aligning diplomatically with the USSR on this issue, when Britain and France were taking a different position, showed that Truman wasn't simply dogmatically committed to opposing the Soviet Union above all other considerations. Although, as Neff points out in the quotation above, Truman's administration put trying to limit Soviet influence in the Middle East as a higher priority than arming Israel in the face of the Arab War with Gamal Abdel Nasser's infamous threat to drive the Jews into the sea. The Soviet Union, not the US, was their most important international ally at the time. Czechoslovakia was their most important arms supplier.
There's more to understanding these situations that taking sides on the crisis of the moment.

Tags: , ,

Sunday, January 19, 2014

Diane Feinstein takes a sensible position on Congressional war powers - at least for the moment

I'm not in the habit of particularly praising my California Sen. Diane Feinstein. She's a liberal Democrat and has a decent voting record on many domestic issues.

But as Chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee, she's had a terrible record on oversight of the intelligence agencies. She's been more of an advocate for expansive powers for intelligence agencies at the expense of democratic and Constitutional rights.

This is one of the major problems in the US right now. One of the major democratic deficits right now, to borrow a term rightly applied the EU in its current form. Congress has virtually ceded its war powers to the Executive. Elizabeth Beavers of the Friends Committee on National Legislation writes in Bring the War on Terror to an End 01/10/2014, a piece appearing on the website of US News and World Report (!), focuses on the expansive authority claimed by the Executive Branch - and so far largely unchallenged by Congress - under the open-ended 2001 Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF):

How can the National Security Agency maintain its sweeping, invasive spying program? The only justification is the AUMF. Where did the president get the authority to indefinitely detain people for over a decade without charge or explanation? The AUMF provides that power, of course. Can U.S. citizens be targeted by drones for assassination without due process? Sure, says the AUMF.

It is doubtful that members of Congress envisioned the future they were creating when they voted "yes" for the AUMF in 2001. But now that future is the present world we live in, and it is time to re-examine it. Is it safer? Is it more secure? As Americans, do we have more liberty? As global citizens, are we leading by example to bring about justice and the rule of law? There is a strong case to be made that the answer to each of those questions is a resounding no, and it is directly because of the AUMF.

It is impossible to discuss the issues of warrantless wiretapping, the war in Afghanistan, the detention facility at Guantanamo or targeted drone strikes without discussing the AUMF. These troubling practices are only possible because they are considered "incidents of war" that are covered by the sweep of the AUMF's authority.
So it's a surprise to see Feinstein's speech, Feinstein on Iran: Give Diplomacy a Chance, Oppose Additional Sanctions 01/15/2014. In it, she's taking her usual stance of defending the Obama Administration's foreign policy, in this case the current negotiations with Iran over nuclear capabilities. And she's opposing a Congressional resolution backed by the Israel lobby that would likely make those negotiations impossible.

Thanks to Administration pressure, the public popularity of the negotiation efforts and backing from Congressional supporters of the negotiations like Feinstein, the effort to pass the anti-negotiation bill seems to be stymied for the moment, as Jim Lobe reports in Israel Lobby Thwarted in Iran Sanctions Bid For Now Inter Press Service 01/15/2014.

Feinstein's speech is interesting as part of a debate on how the Congress should assert its power in foreign policy. No one is questioning that Congress has the power to restrict the Executive's options in a negotiation; they clearly do. But they exercise it so infrequently in opposition to the Executive Branch and have lately been more interested in promoting a warlike foreign policy and especially to cover up, validate and even legalize dangerous practices by intelligence agencies that in restraining the already heavy temptation for the Executive to be reckless in foreign policy.

What's particularly notable about the dispute in which Feinstein is participating is that the anti-negotiations legislation (the Nuclear Weapon Free Iran Act of 2013) shows an appalling willingness of its sponsors - 59 Senators are co-sponsors - to waive their own Constitutional responsibility under their Constitutional war powers. The proposed legislation includes this provision:

if the Government of Israel is compelled to take military action in legitimate self-defense against Iran’s nuclear weapon program, the United States Government should stand with Israel and provide, in accordance with the law of the United States and the constitutional responsibility of Congress to authorize the use of military force, diplomatic, military, and economic support to the Government of Israel in its defense of its territory, people, and existence
Since Israel has repeatedly threaten to launch a preventive military attack on Iran over the nuclear weapons issue, the Congressional sponsors surely must realize this is a green light from Congress to encourage Israel to launch such an attack.

Which is pretty much what Feinstein says in her speech near the end says:

Let me acknowledge Israel's real, well-founded concerns that a nuclear-armed Iran would threaten its very existence. I don't disagree with that. I agree with it, but they are not there yet.

While I recognize and share Israel's concern, we cannot let Israel determine when and where the United States goes to war. By stating that the United States should provide military support to Israel in a formal resolution should it attack Iran, I fear that is how this bill is going to be interpreted.

Let me conclude. The interim agreement with Iran is strong, it is tough, and it is realistic. It represents the first significant opportunity to change a three-decade course in Iran and an opening to improve one of our most poisonous bilateral relationships. It could open the door to a new future which not only considers Israel's national security, but protects our own. [my emphasis]
We'll be hearing quite a bit of commentary this year about the beginning of the First World War. We can at least hope most of it will be less frivolous than that of Bill Kristol, which is after all a very low bar to meet.

But one major factor in the immediate chain of decision-making that led to the all-out war in 1914 was Germany's assurance to the Austro-Hungarian Emperor Franz Joseph II's government that Germany would back them in a war against Serbia. It wasn't a German Archduke that Gavrilo Princip assassinated in Sarajevo. And a less reckless government than Kaiser Bill's might have reasoned that giving a green light to the Habsburg Empire for a war on Serbia might not be something to agree to without more careful consideration.

Just as a more responsible Congress in 2002 could have and should have been less willing to give President Cheney an authorization to launch a preventive war on Iraq based on false claims. More importantly, a more responsible Congress would have tried to impeach a President and Vice President who violated the Congressional resolution they did pass in October 2002 when they did invade Iraq.

The problem is not that Congress isn't willing to exercise its authority in foreign affairs. The problem is that in doing so, they are far too deferential to the Executive Branch in general and, even more importantly, lacking in a sense of responsibly exercising their Congressional duties in foreign affairs and especially in the use and enforcement of their war powers.

Diane Feinstein has been a textbook case for that lack in a sense of responsibility on intelligence oversight. But in telling the Senate it would be irresponsible for give Israel a green light for a war that would not be in America's interests, she asserted a sensible approach toward Congressional war powers and responsibilities.

Tags: , , , ,

Sunday, February 03, 2013

Chuck Hagel and the Israel lobby

Last week's quarrelsome Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing on former Republican Sen. Chuck Hagel's nomination as Secretary of Defense highlighted the real existing effect of the Israel lobby and its outsize effects on American politics and foreign policy. I've listed below several pieces discussing this issue.

I'm still bothered by the fact that President Obama picked another Republican for his third Secretary of Defense, following Bill Clinton's example with Bill Cohen, his third Defense Secretary. Obama kept George W. Bush's Secretary of Defense, Bill Gates, on as his first SecDef. This works against the success that Obama has had in diminishing the Republicans' perceived advantage on national defense in public opinion polls. It's another symptom of Obama's near-compulsive pursuit of an illusory bipartisan harmony.

But for this nomination, that ship has sailed. And now the Republican nominee for SecDef has become a partisan flashpoint, with his own Party for whom he served in the Senate bitterly opposing him and the Democrats supporting him. And so the game has to be evaluated for what it is. But Israel and the closely related issue of Iran got the most attention.

Here are two video news reports on the hearings, which ran for eight hours.

The Hagel Hearings The Real News 02/01/2013, with commentary by Jim Lobe:



Chuck Hagel Defends Record at Confirmation Hearing PBS Newshour 01/31/2013:



The main issue in whether Chuck Hagel is qualified to be the US Secretary of Defense has become whether he's rabid enough in his support for anything and everything the government of Israel might want to do themselves or might want the United States to do. Obviously in the reports above, John McCain's seemingly theological concept of the value of The Surge in Iraq, also made a newsworthy moment in the hearing.

As Gideon Levy writes in Israel does as it pleases Haaretz 02/03/2013, Israel's foreign and military policies are increasingly heedless of their extreme unpopularity and even their blowback potential for Israel. Their policies are often reckless, and their allies, including the United States, need to take full account of that fact.

The public discussion of US-Israeli policies still largely proceeds on the polite assumption that a two-state solution with the Palestinians is still a viable option. In reality, Israel has succeeded in closing it down as a realistic possibility. Stephen Walt in Some inconvenient truths Foreign Policy 01/28/2013 listed this as one of the practical realities he wishes that the Washington foreign policy establishment would openly acknowledge:

#3: "There's not going to be a two-state solution." For official Washington insiders, the politically-correct answer to any question about the Israel-Palestine conflict is that we favor a two-state solution based on negotiations between the two parties, preferably done under U.S. auspices. Never mind that there's not much support for creating a viable Palestinian state in Israel (surveys in Israel sometimes show slim majorities in favor of a 2SS, but support drops sharply when you spell out the details of what a viable state would mean). Never mind that the Palestinians are too weak and divided to negotiate properly, and the failure of the long Oslo process has diminished Fatah's legitimacy and strengthened the more hardline Hamas. Never mind that the latest Israeli election, while it weakened Netanyahu, did not strengthen the peace camp at all. And never mind that the United States has had twenty-plus years to pull of the deal and has blown it every time, mostly because it never acted like a genuine mediator. But nobody in official-dom is going to say this out loud, because they have no idea what U.S. policy would be once the 2SS was kaput.
But, as Levy notes:

Even more troublesome are the questions about the settlements. Again, Israel's conduct is based on the assumption that, as far as West Bank settlements are concerned, anything is allowed. A committee set up by the UN − by the power of whose decision the State of Israel was established and won world recognition − published a document on Thursday castigating Israel's policy. The committee ruled that the settlements are a violation of international law − or, in other words, a war crime.

Israel, the report's composers established, will be susceptible to lawsuits in the International Criminal Court in The Hague and sanctions. So what? The Foreign Ministry has already called it a one-sided report. A commentator in Israel Hayom, like all Israel's commentators, has already consigned it to "the garbage heap of history." ...

I appeared before this investigation committee’s members − impressive, well-known jurists − at their request. Their committee was set up by the same council that wrote the Goldstone Report into Operation Cast Lead in Gaza − which penetrated so deeply into Israeli consciousness that the Israel Defense Forces acted differently in last November’s Operation Pillar of Defense. That report was not thrown into the garbage heap, but went into history. This settlement report, too, will resonate − at least in the outside world.
See also:

Phyllis Bennis, Will Chuck Hagel's Appointment Actually Help the Anti-War Left? The Nation 01/08/2013

Juan Cole, Why the Senate should Confirm Chuck Hagel as SecDef Informed Comment 01/31/2013

Juan Cole, Chuck Hagel Mauled in Bizarro World of US Senate Informed Comment 02/01/2013

Robert Dreyfuss, The Hagel Disaster The Nation 02/01/2103

Howie Klein, Will The GOP Slap Down Obama By Torpedoing Chuck Hagel? Down With Tyranny 02/02/2013

Jim Lobe, It’s All About Israel Inter Press Service 02/01/2013

Jim Rutenberg, Secret Donors Finance Fight Against Hagel New York Times 01/26/2013

Stephen Walt, I'd like to thank the Senate Armed Services Committee Foreign Policy 02/01/2013

Tags: , , ,

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Some lessons so far from the latest Gaza mini-war

The last I looked at the news, there was a cease-fire in the latest Gaza war. Who knows whether it will last? It's another violent and depressing chapter in the long transition from the now-seemingly-dead possibility of a two-state solution to an Israel that includes the West Bank and Gaza and will face a choice between remaining a democracy and remaining a majority Jewish state.

Richard Falk, the UN Special Rapporteur on Palestinian human rights, makes the following useful observations about the beginning of this round of conflict last week (The latest Gaza catastrophe Aljazeera English 11/18/2012)

The assassination of Jabari came a few days after an informal truce that had been negotiated through the good offices of Egypt, and quite ironically agreed to by none other than Jabari acting on behalf of Hamas. Killing him was clearly intended as a major provocation, disrupting a carefully negotiated effort to avoid another tit-for-tat sequence of violence of the sort that has periodically taken place during the last several years.

An assassination of such a high profile Palestinian political figure as Jabari is not a spontaneous act. It is based on elaborate surveillance over a long period, and is obviously planned well in advance partly with the hope of avoiding collateral damage, and thus limiting unfavourable publicity. Such an extra-judicial killing, although also part and parcel of the new American ethos of drone warfare, remains an unlawful tactic of conflict, denying adversary political leaders separated from combat any opportunity to defend themselves against accusations, and implies a rejection of any disposition to seek a peaceful resolution of a political conflict. It amounts to the imposition of capital punishment without due process, a denial of elementary rights to confront an accuser.

Putting aside the niceties of law, the Israeli leadership knew exactly what it was doing when it broke the truce and assassinated such a prominent Hamas leader, someone generally thought to be second only to the Gaza prime minister, Ismail Haniya. There have been rumours, and veiled threats, for months that the Netanyahu government plans a major assault of Gaza, and the timing of the ongoing attacks seems to coincide with the dynamics of Israeli internal politics, especially the traditional Israeli practice of shoring up the image of toughness of the existing leadership in Tel Aviv as a way of inducing Israeli citizens to feel fearful, yet protected, before casting their ballots. [my emphasis]
As Falk points out, Israel is legally an occupying power in Gaza bound by the laws governing such occupations. But:

It is truly alarming that now even the holiest of cities, Jerusalem, is threatened with attacks, but the continuation of oppressive conditions for the people of Gaza, inevitably leads to increasing levels of frustration, in effect, cries of help that world has ignored at its peril for decades. These are survival screams! To realise this is not to exaggerate! To gain perspective, it is only necessary to read a recent UN Report that concludes that the deterioration of services and conditions will make Gaza uninhabitable by 2020.
That UN report (p. 16), Gaza in 2020: A liveable place? (2012) finds:

In the absence of sustained and effective remedial action and an enabling political environment, .... the daily lives of Gazans in 2020 will be worse than they are now. There will be virtually no reliable access to sources of safe drinking water, standards of healthcare and education will have continued to decline, and the vision of affordable and reliable electricity for all will have become a distant memory for most. The already high number of poor, marginalized and food-insecure people depending on assistance will not have changed, and in all likelihood will have increased.

To ensure that Gaza in 2020 will be "a liveable place", on-going herculean efforts by Palestinians and partners in such sectors a energy, education, health, water and sanitation, need to be accelerated and intensified in the face of all difficulties.
Robert Fisk in We are all Israelis now: its brutality, unlike Syria's, is fought in the name of the West's war on terror The Independent 11/20/2012 suggests that Hamas fell into a trap that the Israeli government set for them:

It’s odd, the way they all get away with it. Lord Blair, whose 92 Business Class trips to the Holy Land have produced a peace beyond all peace, is now talking about how it’s in everybody’s interest to have a truce – is his face getting a bit skeletal, or is that my imagination? – and a truce, I suppose, we shall have, well over 100 Palestinian and three Israeli dead too late. But is it all worth it? Was the murder by Israel of Hamas’s military leader Ahmed al-Jabari in fact not staged to provide an excuse to bomb all those new missiles that Hamas has acquired?

That wise old Israeli owl Uri Avneri – he is 89 years old – thinks this is just the trap that Hamas fell into by launching its preposterous "Gates of Hell" rocket attacks in revenge for Jabari’s death. The whole Operation "Pillar of Defence" was about destroying Hamas’s weapons – not about the largely ineffective missiles themselves. ...

One of the new Israeli lines on the war runs like this. Israel kills "terrorists" by the score along with a handful of “collateral damage” innocents – and the world rages against Israel. Yet isn't the Syrian regime killing Syrian innocents by the thousand every month? Where are the mass protests, the venting of wrath at Bashar al-Assad? What hypocrisy! But of course, this is in itself a hypocrisy. We know the old "Hama rules" of Syria; no one asks us to support them. And comparing Israel’s brutality to that of the Assad regime is playing the old Lord Blair game: we weren't perfect in Iraq – but we weren't as bad as Saddam.

No. Israel claims to hold the same values as the supposedly moral West. It says that it is fighting "terrorism" in our name as well as its own. It says it is fighting like us. It is playing by our Western rules. We are all Israelis now; that is what we are meant to say.
Helena Cobban in Obama admin wilfully blind on Gaza crisis? Just World News 11/21/2012 reminds us that the US position has become more and more uncritical toward Israel over time:

Time was, back in the old days, when there were people in the White House and in positions of influence in the State Department who understood the broad dynamics of Middle Eastern politics and who had a well-grounded sense of what, broadly speaking, the American people's interests in the region were. Back in the day, "even-handed" used to be a term of praise for U.S. officials involved in the sometimes complex work of negotiating issues between Arabs and Israelis.

Oh boy, how that has changed. With the rise of AIPAC's influence over all relevant branches of the U.S. administration (except for some remaining small pockets of resistance in some portions of the Defense Department), kowtowing to Israel became the order of the day. "Even-handed" even came to be understood as a slur expressed against those who were insufficiently zealous in the cause. Too deep and granular an understanding of the dynamics of a region that is host to some 300 million Muslims and just 6.5 million Jewish Israelis came to be seen by everyone in the self-referential bubble that is Washington as a clear career-ender. (Exhibit A: Amb. Chas Freeman, and the humiliation meted out to him in March 2009. But there are numerous other examples, too..)

A self-imposed blindness became the order of the day in Washington.

And today, that blindness matters.
Because, as she notes, the Arab Awakening has significantly shifted the political perspective of countries like Egypt on Israeli-Palestinian issues.

And she takes a dim view, a little too dim perhaps, of past American peace efforts. But at this point, it does seem pretty clear that official Washington has given up any hope or real effort toward a lasting peace settlement, two-state or otherwise:

For 39 years now, ever since the Geneva Conference of December 1973, Washington has successfully maintained its monopoly over all Arab-Israeli peace diplomacy. The record of this tenure has been especially poor regarding the crucial Palestinian strand of the effort. Over the past 39 years, the Israelis have implanted 500,000 settlers into the occupied Palestinian territories. They have maintained total control over all of the West Bank (including East Jerusalem) and Gaza. They have killed several tens of thousands of Palestinians-- between Lebanon, Gaza, and the West Bank-- and have displaced hundreds of thousands more from their ancestral homeland. They have completely transformed the human geography of Jerusalem. They have refused any attempts by the eight million or so Palestinians living in exile to return to their homeland. Palestinian acts of violence over that period have killed some hundreds of Israelis.

Every so often throughout the past 39 years-- and especially in the aftermath of a flare-up of tensions-- Washington would trot out some version or another of a new "peace initiative", or even (heaven forbid!) a peace "process", involving the Palestinians. All of it was flim-flam, smoke and mirrors whose main effect (and in some cases, also the intention) was to give the Israelis more time to continue their colonial taking of the Palestinians' land and resources. [my emphasis in bold]
Juan Cole also points to the new role of Egypt in Morsi Emerges as Key Power Broker in Gaza Conflict Informed Comment 11/21/2012:

Egypt’s President Muhammad Morsi, a member of the same Muslim Brotherhood that gave birth to Palestine’s Hamas movement, has emerged as a key broker in the Gaza crisis. President Obama is said to have called him for the third time in 24 hours on Tuesday!

Morsi sympathizes with the stateless Palestinians, who are being kept without a state and without basic human rights by the right wing Israeli government. But more, he sympathizes with Hamas itself, which the US and Israel have branded a terrorist organization. Because the US has put Hamas on the terrorist list, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton cannot talk to the government of Gaza (which seems rather stupid), and Morsi is therefore a key interlocutor. ...

... Morsi as president makes part of the big difference between Israel’s attack on Gaza in 2008-09 and today’s assault. In 08-09, the Palestinians had no real support from Egypt and of course the Israeli government and the Bush administration had it in for them. Hosni Mubarak and his right hand man Omar Sulaiman hated Hamas. When Israel attacked Gaza, they quickly closed the Rafah crossing and Egyptian troops actually shot dead two Palestinians trying to flee into Egypt from the bombing.

Egypt, at some 82 million (nearly the size of Germany), is the most populous Arab country, and it is still something of a thought leader for the Arab world. It has the biggest and best army in the Middle East, though there are virtually no Egyptians who would welcome war.
Tags: , ,