Showing posts with label jesus freaks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label jesus freaks. Show all posts

Monday, August 12, 2013

The "Jesus movement" of the 1960s and 1970s

I've posted before about the "Jesus movement" of young evangelical Christians in the late 1960s and 1970s, e.g., Hippies to the right of me, hippies to the left, here I'm stuck in the middle with Evan Bayh 02/23/2010.

Randall Stephens at Religion in American Life has an interview with Larry Eskridge, who has done a new book about that phenomenon, A History of the Jesus People: An Interview with Larry Eskridge (n.d., accessed 08/12/2013), Eskridge's book is God's Forever Family: The Jesus People Movement in America (2013). In the interview, Eskridge says:

In terms of the particular historical moment, the Jesus movement's biggest bottom line was in generational terms: it played a major role in keeping evangelicalism together by providing a much easier path for a lot of people — particularly evangelical kids raised in the church—to navigate the massive changes that buffeted American society and culture during that period. The Jesus People had a degree of "with-it-ness" and a cultural cache that the larger movement certainly didn’t possess going into the late '60s. I think it’s fair to say that if the Jesus People hadn’t come along when they did the evangelical church would have been nowhere near as formidable a force throughout American culture come the 1980s and beyond.
He also mentions the innovative impulses in religious music of that time:

Music was such an important element in what held youth culture together by the 1960s that it would have been truly surprising if any sort of popular movement could have had any grass roots traction without a musical component. The Jesus movement was certainly obsessed by music just like the larger youth culture — "Jesus Music" seemed to naturally pour forth in the form of halting, homemade folk songs and bluesy, rock tunes from the earliest manifestations of the movement all across the country. A whole network of musical groups and venues grew up within the space of a few short years along with the infrastructure to distribute the music to Jesus Music fans. Of course this was all surprising in that the music of the Jesus People was an obvious departure from the norms of the larger evangelical subculture. Certainly there was no shortage of resistance among older, more traditional church people to the new forms of music. But the combination of cultural crisis, earnest Jesus People fervor, and the sheer size of the generational cohort eventually served to lessen most older evangelicals' opposition. I think most adults in the churches saw that it would be a better alternative to cultivate their kids’ enthusiasm for Jesus by indulging their new worship choruses on Sundays and letting them listen to Jesus Rock in their spare time.
The hippie subculture had a definite religious element involved, more the vague sort that today is called "spirituality" as semi-distinct from "religion." I still like the broad classification used by John Robert Howard that I posted about in The sixties: those famous hippies 06/14/2008. His two categories "visionaries" and "freaks and heads" included people who had some kind of spiritual perspective on life, though in mostly cases it wasn't necessarily terribly theologically sophisticated; but the same is true of most church-goers. You don't have to be a professor of theology to have a serious religious/spiritual orientation or important insights along those lines. See, e.g., Jesus of Nazareth.

And while many of the "freaks and heads" were using pot and psychedelics for entertainment (or self-medication), certainly the early advocates of LSD had quasi-religious and mystical ideas that they connected with LSD usage. The early issues of Psychedelic Review included articles along those lines, such as Herman Hesse: Poet of the Interior Journey by Tomothy Leary and Ralph Metzner (1:2 Fall 1963):

Few writers have chronicled with such dispassionate lucidity and fearless honesty the progress of the soul through the stages of life. Peter Camenzind (1904), Demian (1919), Siddhartha (1922), Steppenwolf (1927), Narziss und Goldmund (1930), Journey to the East {1932), Magister Ludi (1943) -different versions of spiritual autobiography, different maps of the interior path. Each new step revises the picture of all the previous steps, each experience opens up new worlds of discovery in a constant effort to communicate the vision.
The "Jesus movement" of the 60s and 70s was a diffuse movement that led into many directions, including cult groups like the Children of God.

But the relationship of the "Jesus freaks" to the hippie counterculture was fated to be superficial and imitative. Within the confines of conservative evangelical Christianity, i.e., fundamentalism, there wasn't much room for the kinds of social unconventionalism distinguishing the hippie movement. Quoting my earlier description of Howard's other two categories of hippies from 1967:

Howard's categories of "midnight" and "plastic" hippies provide a way of talking about the cultural diffusion of some hippie styles, practices and attitudes. The business system always seeks ways to make money. And the hippie movement made love beads and leather shirts commodities with decent profit margins. Despite the exaggerated reactions from many of their elders, hippie styles could be adapted by people who had no ambition or desire to "tune in, turn on, drop out", as a popular saying had it. Thus, the "plastic" hippies.

The "midnight" hippies, on the other hand, are those who don't adopt hippie styles but do share some aspects of the more thoughtful hippie criticisms of the broader society.
Within Howard's classification scheme, the Jesus Freaks fit more into the "plastic" category. That is, they adopted some of the clothing and hair styles of the hippies and some of the more tolerant peace-and-love postures of the hippies, which distinguished them from judgmental, fire-and-brimstone fundamentalists. You can see how the styles might be attractive:


But experimenting with drugs and even using alcohol were pretty much as taboo for the "Jesus movement" as for any straitlaced fundamentalist devotee. For them as for their more conventional elders, "exploring" things like "Eastern religions," i.e., Buddhism and Hinduism, was only legitimate in the context of proselytizing people away from those views to conservative Christianity. In general, proselytizing was as much or more of an emphasis for the "Jesus movement" adherents as for their more conventional fundamentalists friends of their own age as well as older ones. Christianity has always had a significant element of syncretism to it, although Christians have often highly selective about it. We could understand the "Jesus movement" of that time as a sort of cultural syncretism. Or, to put it another way, a branch of traditional Protestant proselytizing that also gave its adherents a way to feel "cool" and in touch with their less socially inhibited friends and acquaintances in their age group.

Also, anything that sounded like "free love," which would be pretty much cover most sexual activity outside of marriage was also off-limits to the "Jesus movement." Hippies were more demonstrative at least about their claimed lack of inhibitions ("hang-ups") about sex than most people, except for maybe frat boys. As I wrote in the 2008 post:

The hippies also helped challenge public hypocrisy about heterosexual sex and love practices. And Howard notes how the hippies may have contributed to the gay rights movement. The openly-gay libertarian-anarchist writer Paul Goodman was popular among the alternative-lifestyle hippies. Howard notes that in the Haight-Asbury neighborhood in San Francisco, Ground Zero for the Summer of Love in 1967, even before 1967 the Haight had become home to a community including blacks, white beatniks and "a small homosexual colony".
The "Jesus movement" was not noted from producing any greater openness or even healthy adult attitudes about sex than the larger fundamentalist subculture of which they were a part.

One aspect of their history that is surprising and disappointing is the limited contribution of their "Jesus music." Maybe I'm being too narrow in that evaluation. Some of the songs used in "folk masses" at the Catholic Church are actually good, with memorable melodies and lyrics that show some insight and reflection. And the "Jesus movement" music presumably had some effect on that style of music.

It's hard to say that for the marketing genre known as "Christian contemporary" music. An awful lot of it is just plain dull, with simple melodies, unimaginative instrumentation and superficial, repetitive lyrics. My sister-in-law mildly mocks it as "7-Eleven music": seven words repeated 11 times.

It didn't have to be that way. Kate Campbell's 2001 album Wandering Strange is an example of what Christian contemporary music could have been. But then, most of the songs there are new arrangements of older songs from the Baptist Hymnal. Someone more knowledgeable than I about the early Jesus Rock songs might be able to make a plausible case that there was a "co-optation" of the genre to become at least less annoying to fans of more traditional styles. And maybe the commercial genre of Christian Contemporary is too narrowly defined. If it regularly included songs performed by Johnny Cash or Kate Campbell with Christian religious themes, it would be expanded for the better from my perspective.

I've more than once heard this song used in Catholic confirmation ceremonies in Austria (in English), K.D. Lang sings Leonard Cohen's Hallelujah:



Works for me. Why could Christian Contemporary do this kind of thing? It's even a "hallelujah" song! Okay, the lyrics aren't strictly Christian, it's by a Jewish songwriter and it's sung here by a lesbian performer, but still ...

Pentecostals and fundamentalists are often distinguished from one another. But that's mainly due to differences over rituals like speaking in tongues, Pentecostal "prophecy" and exorcism. The general approach to the Bible and to social attitudes and sexual habits are generally compatible. But I wonder how much of the "Jesus movement's" energy and activists eventually wound up channeled into Pentecostal ("charismatic") movements. Because the Pentecostals in some ways already practiced rituals that were both regarded as weird by other fundamentalists and were most mystical. In those ways, they were better positioned to take advantage of the "Jesus movement" impulse than other established denominational traditions.

It occurs to me that corporate Democrat Cory Booker is a modern example of something like the "Jesus movement" of the Sixties and Seventies, a public figure who manages to come off as open and tolerant but also looks to be closely tied to Christian Dominionists. (Susie Madrak, Anybody But Cory Booker C&L 08/12/2013.

Tags: ,

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Hippies to the right of me, hippies to the left, here I'm stuck in the middle with Evan Bayh


There was an episode of Law and Order (that would be Law and Order Prime, the one with Sam Waterston) in which Waterston's Jack McCoy prosecutes a case of a 1970s terrorist would gets busted years later after having transformed herself into a respectable Republican lady under an assumed identity. There is a lot of conversation about the meaning of "the Sixties" in connection with the case. In the end, she's sent to prison to get out, as I recall, sometime in the early 2000s. McCoy says wearily at the end (quoting from memory), "Maybe by then the Sixties will finally be over."

The fictional Jack McCoy was too optimistic. For a lot of Republicans, it will always be 1969, Dick Nixon and Spiro Agnew will always be bravely defending white civilization and hippies and antiwar protesters and scary rioting black people, and the Commies will always be poised to come ashore in San Francisco and begin their conquest of America. There are even young conservatives who parents hadn't hit puberty yet in 1969 who are stuck in 1969!

So is recovering conservative Michael Lind. Lind is one of the best in analyzing the pathologies of the American right, which he has being doing for years now. His takedown of Pat Robertson's paranoid conspiracy-theory classic The New World Order is one of the best of that sort of thing I've seen. But, Lordy, that fellow Lind is as haunted by the Sixties as he former fellow conservatives are. In Glenn Beck is the new Abbie Hoffman Salon 02/23/10, he argues - I'm not sure if it's even partially tongue-in-cheek - that Glenn Back and the Tea Party movement are the dirty freaking hippies of today.

In doing so, he uses some compulsive Centrism to set up a just-like-the-hippies comparison to today far-right activists and loons. For example:

Just as the New Left claimed that the New Deal era wasn't really liberal, so the countercultural right claims that the Republican Party from Nixon to George W. Bush wasn't really conservative. '60s radicals like Carl Oglesby denounced John F. Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson as sinister "corporate liberals" in the same way that the radicals of the right claim that the two Bushes, if not the sainted Reagan, were inauthentic "big government conservatives." The radical left had Ralph Nader. The radical right has Ron Paul.
It's not quite nails-on-the-blackboard bad. But here are a few obvious problems with this approach.

You would be hard put to find anyone reasonably identified with the "New Left" of the 1960s saying that the New Deal "wasn't really liberal". If you were going to research this in some detail, some obvious American sources among the more intellectual ones would be the publications Monthly Review, Radical America, Socialist Revolution (later Socialist Review) and New Left Notes.

The New Left is a term that covered a broad range of people, from some (but not all) civil rights activists, the more militant Democratic Party reformers, the Students for a Democratic Society (SDS) and other student activists, anti-Vietnam War protest groups, and an assortment of critical intellectuals, Maoists, and a variety of leftwing political sects. Basically, they rejected what they called "Cold War liberalism", though I'm not sure how often they used "corporate liberal" as a pejorative. "Establishment liberal" was probably more common. (All three are useful descriptive terms, although the outlook known as "Cold War liberalism" or "Scoop Jackson liberalism" back in the day would now be called "neoconservative".) The New Left also rejected Soviet-line Communism. The Communist Party (and the Socialist Party) were the Old Left.

The term New Left I believe originated in Britain, although it wasn't not such a drastic neologism. It was the more-or-less Trotskyist British journal New Left Review, which is still published, that popularized the term. The New Left in the United States is conventionally dated from the 1964 Democratic convention, specifically the establishment of the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party (MFDP) in opposition to the desires of the Democratic leadership at the time.

But the general perspective of the New Left was that they wanted either radical reforms or revolution, the latter term various and imaginatively defined. Except for maybe the more dogmatic (or maybe hack) Marxists, they hardly accused the New Deal of not being "liberal". They might criticize the New Deal for being a too-limited set of reforms designed to preserve the capitalist system, which the New Left generally preferred to see replaced by some form of socialism. Liberals wouldn't argue with that analysis. On the contrary, they would have bragged that the New Deal saved capitalism by curbing its worst abuses. And that Franklin Roosevelt had no intention of setting up socialism, the paranoia of the Glenn Becks of the 1930s notwithstanding.

If the New Left particularly emphasized one negative aspect of the New Deal, it would be that it didn't directly address the problems of white racism and Southern segregation, in particular. That aspect of the New Deal was not liberal, although a 1960s New Leftist might say that it was all too characteristic of Democratic and Republican Party liberalism (yes, there once was such a thing as Republican liberals!) that it failed to address both structural and subjective white racism. And who would step up today to argue against the accuracy of that criticism? Even Republicans are happy for any opportunity to label liberals racists, no matter the contortions in which they may have to indulge to get there.

You can always make superficial comparisons that are plausible at a high level. You could say, for instance, that in 1965 the Democratic Party, the Republic Party and the US Communist Party were all political parties and so they were basically the same. It wouldn't tell you anything meaningful about American politics. It might tell you something meaningful if you were looking at laws applying to political parties in 1965.

So, yeah, Glenn Beck criticizes Republicans as well as Democrats. And New Left activists in the Sixties criticized Democrats as well as Republicans. So what?

Lind's article also blurs the difference between hippies and New Left activists. Yes, there was considerable crossover influence. But the actual hippie counterculture tended to be nonpolitical, and was a distinct phenomenon from the New Left. Hippies for the most part didn't spend their time organizing antiwar rallies or writing historical articles analyzing the history of white racism. And while some members of the Black Panthers may have used drugs, their activity had more to do with things like going out armed with their own shotguns and confronting abusive cops than with getting stoned and teasing out the deeper meanings in Herman Hesse stories.

In the nightmares and daymares on which so many of today's Republican conservatives feed their fears, those hippies are still out there all mushed together with black people with leather jackets and shotguns and unkempt Vietnam veterans demonstrating against the war and Bill Ayers plotting with ACORN to bomb bathrooms in government buildings. I'd prefer to see liberals and progressives de-mystify those fears and distorted images rather than clumsily try to turn the composite bogeyman against the Tea Partiers.

In any case, Lind's article gets the wrong counterculture for the Tea Partiers. Since the 1920s, Christian fundamentalists have nurtured a kind of religious counterculture that heavily overlapped with what is sometimes politely called the "folkways" of white Southerners. And there has been a subculture of fanatical, conspiracist rightwingers with clear continuities back into the 1930s. It today's Tea Partiers are part of a counterculture, those are the sources of it, not the mushed-up scare image of "the Sixties".

In fact, the Christian fundamentalist subculture actually had a small overlap with the hippie movement - not so much with other Republican bogeymen of the Sixties. Those were the "Jesus Freaks" or "Jesus people" or "Jesus movement" of the late 1960s and early 1970s. Billy Graham even cranked out one of his many proselytizing books under the title, The Jesus Generation (1971). It left one clear cultural heritage, "Christian contemporary" or "praise" music. Also known as 7-11 music, i.e., seven words repeated 11 times.

I recently came across a 2007 book by Preston Shires, a history done from a conservative Protestant viewpoint, called Hippies of the Religious Right : From the Counterculture of Jerry Garcia to the Subculture of Jerry Falwell (2007), published by Baylor University Press. Baylor is a private Baptist liberal arts school that in recent years expressed high academic ambitions. But they recently selected former special prosecutor Kenneth Starr as their president; see Marv Knox, Kenneth Starr named Baylor president Associated Baptist Press 02/15/10. From the parts I've read, the book itself seems remarkably superficial and credulous, but it does give an account of the phenomenon of that time.

However, he also absurdly asserts that violence in the anti-abortion movement is the fault of the hippies of the Sixties and Seventies! Here is his typical rightwing justification for that polemic:

This violent aspect of the Christian Right was beholden to the darker side of the counterculture. In the same way that certain sixties’ youth could justify violence against those who advocated and practiced war or who denied civil rights to nonwhites, some Christian Right activists justified violence against those who advocated and practiced, in their mind, murder.
It's all those damn fucking hippies' fault!

Git over it, people! A rightwing fanatic walking into a church in the Midwest and shooting an "abortion doctor" in the head is not the fault of some hippie smoking pot in Golden Gate Park in San Francisco in 1967! This is just the typical projection strategy that so many Christian Rightists commonly employ to avoid taking responsibility for their "bad choices", as they like to say of other sinners. Anybody even remotely familiar with the history of lynching in the US knows that rightwing fanatics and sadists didn't need the Sixties Flower Children to teach them about murdering people for their own bigoted ends.

Here is also the conflation of the conservatives' images of the enemy from 1969 that Lind's article plays into: hippies, antiwar activists, uppity black people, and those dadgum loose wimmin screwin' around and gittin' theirselves pregnant.

Wake up and smell the global warming, folks. Log on to the Internet, this new thing all the kids are talking about. You might even be able to dig up some reality-based information on the alternative movements of the Sixties there. This sitting around yelling, "You hippies git off my lawn!" is getting a little old.

Tags: , , ,