Keith Olbermann has a good comment segment on the Libya War.
For a rosy view, check out Juan Cole's Top Ten Accomplishments of the UN No-Fly Zone 03/24/2011 Informed Comment 03/24/2011. Cole is consistently good at gathering and reporting information from Arab-language sources and at reporting them to his readers. Given his critical stance toward the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars, and given the fact that his criticisms have all too often turned out to be well-placed, I'm surprised that he's initially so optimistic on the Libya intervention. I think he may be taken an optimistic evaluation of the Kosovo War as a major reference point for this one. He doesn't seem to be giving full weight to the limitations on air power that a closer look at the Kosovo War exposes. He also doesn't seem to be looking at the potential for insurgency in Libya, whether Muammar Qaddafi is ousted or not. (On that point, see Steven Metz, Libya’s Coming InsurgencyThe New Republic 03/20/2011.)
Neil Purcell pointed out this antiwar piece by David Rieff, The Road to HellThe New Republic 03/23/2011, who writes:
So much for the hope that Iraq and Afghanistan might actually have taught the West anything lasting about trying to impose democracy at the point of a gun. Instead, it is as if Iraq, which, in the United States, was initially welcomed by most liberal internationalists and neoconservatives alike as a war of liberation, had never happened, and, instead, we have traveled backward in time. Remember those halcyon days of the late 1990s when Tony Blair was promising the world that in the future the West would fight wars in the name of its values, not just of its interests, in effect promising that the wars of the twenty-first century would be noble wars of altruism? If you don’t, well, don’t worry: If the war in Libya is any indication, you’ll have the chance to live them all over again. Of course, the catastrophe in Iraq was supposed to have sobered us, and made even the most ardent liberal interventionists realize that Pascal’s great phrase, “He who would act the angel, acts the beast,” expresses the stark truth about what we self-flatteringly call humanitarian interventions. But instead, here we go again. [my emphasis]
I just heard Keith Olbermann’s Special Comment on Racism and the Tea Party MovementFiredoglake 02/16/10. Olbermann in this presentation, which he at least managed to do in a non-ranting style, tries to stigmatize the Tea Party movement as racist. It a proposition that has a lot of evidence in its favor. But he does so in such a dumb, clumsy way that it will make it more difficult for people to make the legitimate point about the racist element among the Tea Party activists.
His framework is cringe-inducing silly. He starts off saying that racism is present in part within every white man [sic]. Then he proceeds to say that if you say that you're opposed to the President because he's black: "say that, and in all but the lifeless fringes of our society, you are an outcast." (4:30 ff on video) This just makes no sense. If white racism is universal among whites (or just white men?), as he plainly says, then how is it that only in "the lifeless fringes of our society" is it acceptable to openly express white racism?
His framework sounds like some stiff Southern white guy circa 1970 having to say something about racial issues to a mixed-race audience and trying not to piss anyone off too much. But the problem is that if you are trying to condemn white racism among a particular group of activists, you can't do that with sappy boilerplate about how every white man is a bit of a racist, and then say (as Olbermann does) that, gee, there's probably a lot of racial prejudice among blacks and Hispanics, too.
Olbermann's video essay makes him sound blissfully unaware that conservatives for decades have been making an everyone-should-be-colorblind argument against anti-discrimination laws and their enforcement. If the law is unable to take any account of race, even when people are targets for discrimination based on socially-constructed categories of race, then it would be impossible to enforce anti-discrimination laws. "What do you mean this company discriminates because it hires only whites and turns down all applicants of color? You're looking at people by race to say that! That's not right. We're completely colorblind here."
If you're going to do a ten-minute-or-so presentation like that about the general issue of white racism in America, to be meaningful it would have to present the problem of institutional racism in some way. Since patterns of discrimination by race have been copiously documented for decades in hiring, promotion, income, housing, health, education and on and on, that shouldn't be too much of a challenge for MSNBC to pull together. And then within that context, you could talk about different perceptions of issues by race, which has also been copiously documented in opinion polling over the years.
Stigmatizing racist groups as racist is absolutely necessary and legitimate. But while Olbermann's presentation of the fact was clumsy at best, the reality is that overt racism as such is officially and unofficially discouraged in our society and generally condemned with varying degrees of seriousness. So if you are going to stigmatize someone as racist, you need to have good grounds for it and state them clearly.
Olbermann could have pointed to Jimmy Carter's informed judgment that white racism motivated much of the anger among the Tea Party protesters. Carter had to deal up-close-and-personal with the admirers of Lester Maddox and George Wallace in the 1950s and 1960s. He has dealt with conflict situations all over the world both as President and through the Carter Center for decades afterwards. He actually has real authority to speak about racism and ethnic hostility.
Olbermann could also have pointed to research by people like Dave Neiwert, who actually knows something about far-right groups and their methods and rhetoric and has been chronicling their role in the Tea Party groups. He could have cited specific examples of Tea Party leaders or featured speakers promoting neo-Confederate and state-secessionist ideas. He could have given quotes from Glenn Beck, the Bircher-minded conspiracy theorist who was the chief media organizer of the Tea Party movement. He could have cited crassly racist caricatrues of Obama that have appeared at Tea Party events. Instead, he cited several quotes anonymously from various rightwingers, one of which I recognized as coming from Bill O'Reilly (who I don't associate with the Tea Partiers in a distinct way) but the others I didn't even recognize.
The result was a mess. A mess that plays right into the current Republican standard election-year whine that them thar fancy libruls are lookin' down their noses at all the reglur white folks.
Olbermann's presentation also effectively gave credibility to the Tea Party movement's pretensions of being a grassroots insurgency when it's mainly well-financed Republican astroturf. That doesn't mean that it's not energizing new activists to get into the political fight at some levels on behalf of Republicans. On the contrary, it seems to be doing just that.
Olbermann's video essay leaves the impression that white racism and only white racism is behind Tea Party activism. That is an oversimplification of both the Tea Party movement and of white racism. White racism hasn't been an effective instrument of conservative and reactionary politics because it stands alone as a motivator to political action. It has played such a role because politicians have effectively combined it other issues, such as resentment of government handouts to wealthy investment bankers and concern over unemployment.
I don't put any stock in notion of a "left-right alliance" with the Tea Partiers. That's "sucker populism". There may be crossover agreement on particular issues between progressives and the more militant rightwingers. But their political perspectives are dramatically different. But I also want to be realistic about the sources of both white racism and rightwing extremism - overlapping but not identical phenomena.
A sloppy, scolding lecture like the one Keith Olbermann just provided makes that goal harder to achieve.
Cynthia Boaz makes some important points in Why Torturing to Prove Torturing is Wrong is Never Okay: A Note to Keith Olbermann CommonDreams.org 06/08/09. She's criticizing Keith Olbermann for taunting Sean Hannity over waterboarding, daring him to get waterboarded himself. I heard Olbermann Monday night making a similar point about the accused terrorist killer of Dr. George Tiller:
And the man who allegedly killed Dr. George Tiller says there are more attacks planned on abortion targets. Shouldn‘t we be subjecting that man to enhanced interrogation techniques? ...
The alleged terrorist charged with assassinating Dr. George Tiller says more violence is planned. If Mr. Bush were still president, wouldn‘t we be water boarding Scott Roeder to find out what and where? ...
an act which seems to define the term terrorism, an act committed for political and religious reasons, the alleged perpetrator has now threatened more violence. The Number one story in the COUNTDOWN, as the man accused of killing Dr. George Till in the vestibule of his church warns of potential acts of terrorism against abortion providers, why, with a domestic terrorist in our grasp, why are we not treating him as such?
Why is the far right not calling for him to be water boarded to tell against whom the next gun or bomb will be directed?
Uh, because the liberal Keith Olbermann is already doing so?
Olbermann promoted this line all through the show, introducing Denise O'Donnell of the New York Department of Public Safety to talk briefly about the case at the end of his Monday program:
OLBERMANN: Nevertheless, in terms of public understanding of what happened, and what he has said, and what he has done, the semantics as we obviously saw during the last administration, hugely important, given its handling of detainees who were soon to be involved in violence that was, you know, based on religious and political grounds, and which, we were told, were attempts to circumscribe American freedoms.
If Scott Roeder had an Islamic name and was promising to attack more Americans or knew of attacks planned against more Americans, wouldn‘t people at one end of the political spectrum now be saying, in that sort of hyperbolic example, we should use enhanced interrogation techniques to find out what he has planned or what he knows about?
O‘DONNELL: Well, I don‘t think this is really an issue about torture. This individual has been charged. He‘s not being interrogated by the police. But what is important is that the law enforcement community is taking this very, very seriously.
She didn't really need to add "... as opposed to you, Keith, who are using this case to make frivolous 'gotcha' points". She made the point more gently.
This is my concern about the snarky, infotainment style news programs that Olbermann and now Rachel Maddow do. (Maddow seems to be more substantial than Olbermann so far.) Both have done some decent reporting on the torture issue. But the market study that was reported recently showing that some large percentage of conservative think Stephen Colbert is being serious when he spoofs rightwing ranters in his onscreen persona is a telling fact about our current press environment. We've reached a point where some of the best news reporting is being done by comedians. If some significant portion of the viewers of Colbert's comedy show on the Comedy Central channel think he's being serious, I can't help but wonder how many viewers of Olbermann's ostensibly hard-news program take his suggestions about torturing people seriously.
Cynthia Boaz makes several points about Olbermann's clowning around about torture:
By calling-pushing, even-for the water boarding of his rival talk-show host Sean Hannity (who, in a moment of exceptional foolishness volunteered to be water boarded in order to demonstrate that it's "not that bad"), Olbermann gave away the moral high ground on this issue, undermined his otherwise unassailable argument against torture, and trivialized the very thing he wants us all to take so seriously. I would go so far as to say he's "normalized" it, if the ability of Olbermann supporters to twist themselves into logical and moral knots in defense of his campaign is any indication.
And she reminds us in a mild way, that for all his stylistic imitation of the legendary Edward R. Murrow, that Olbermann is really no Edward Murrow:
... I would simply ask Mr. Olbermann to ponder this question: You have been compared- justly in my view- to Edward R. Murrow. Can you honestly imagine that Mr. Murrow would have condoned - much less engaged in - a campaign like the one you've run against Mr. Hannity? Murrow went up against the vilest of the vile, Senator Joe McCarthy, and never once did he reduce his tactics to those of his opponent. He found a way to reveal the logical weaknesses in McCarthy's views and the pathetic and desperate political motives behind it without sacrificing his own integrity. He simply gave McCarthy the rope with which to hang himself.
Trust me, Mr. Olbermann, that is all you need to do. The American people - your audience - want our public figures to help us access the better angels of our natures, not to continue exploiting what mystics call "the lower vibrating emotions"- anger, fear, judgment, envy, and in this case - a voyeuristic sadism wrapped in crude humor. You have apparently called off your campaign against Hannity, but it would be helpful to explain why (beyond noting that Hannity is a coward), and acknowledge that perhaps you were a little too human. That's what Murrow would have done, and it's what the Keith Olbermann I've come to respect would do as well. [my emphasis]
Comedy is a challenging art form. And there are ways to use comedy to criticize torture. But that's the problem with Olbermann's approach - his brand of infotainment is presented as serious news laced with liberal snark, which may or may not be humorous. Boaz has a legitimate point when she writes that Olbermann's approach actually functions to legitimize torture.
I see no reason to believe that is his intent. But he's let snark get the best of his message on this one.
Keith Olbermann responded to Glenn Greenwald's post criticizing his flip on the FISA revision and telecom amnesty at DailyKos in Well, You Stumped Me 06/26/08. He did introduce an angle I hadn't heard before, which is that John Dean reads the language in the current bill under consideration as leaving open the possibility of criminal prosecution of the telecoms while ending civil lawsuits against them. But Olbermann's argument is unconvincing. And he doesn't deal with the probably much more serious aspect of the FISA bill, which would effectively allow arbitrary surveillance at the President's discretion.
Olbermann goes on to praise John Dean's brilliance - not something I would argue with but he puts an unusual emphasis on the credibility of his source on this and even works a baseball story into it - and declares, "I think John Dean is worth 25 Glenn Greenwalds (maybe 26 Keith Olbermanns)."
I'll have to go find something on Dean's position. He's one of my favorite authorities on things like this, as well. But Olbermann's position still strikes me as silly in light of his emphatic opposition to telecom amnesty back in January as being a "shameless, breathless, literally textbook example of Fascism - the merged efforts of government and corporations that answer to no government."
Even if Dean is right about criminal liability, stripping away civil liability is a very bad thing. A McCain Justice Department would be extremely unlikely to attempt such prosecutions, since McCain is wholly in favor of the FISA bill and the warrantless spying program, telecom amnesty and all. Obama would be under tremendous pressure not to do so. And the very fact the Dems caved on this bill weakens their hand in insisting on such prosecutions.
Then there's the problemita of Bush's pardon power. He can and almost certainly will issue blanket pardons to telecom execs for all criminal acts involved with the warrantless spying program. Since a major part of the illegal spying was conducted by private telecom companies, shutting down civil remedies will largely eliminate our chances to find out the extent of the program in any near term time frame, maybe ever. Congress could investigate it in detail. But if the Dems are afraid to filibuster an unpopular and blatantly bad bill like the FISA revision, it's unlikely they will do such an investigation absent revelations forced by civil lawsuits.
Olbermann's post doesn't even discuss the provisions in the FISA bill that could very well allow arbitrary surveillance of pretty much anyone in the US, citizen or not, without showing probable cause. There's a fig leaf of court review included. But it's a small and thin one.
This argument of Olbermann's is also less than impressive:
Thus, as I phrased it on the air tonight, obviously Obama kicked the left in the teeth by supporting the bill. But anybody who got as hot about this as I did would prefer to see a President Obama prosecuting the telecoms criminally, instead of seeing a Senator Obama engender more "soft on terror" crap by casting a token vote in favor of civil litigation that isn't going to pass since so many other Democrats caved anyway.
When Markos was on (Monday? Again, blurs) he made the simple but essential point that if this is Obama's rationale for this, maybe he should explain it. I think it can be argued that if he's caught the same hole in the bill that Dean has, his best course is actually to shut up and take the criticism and hope the Republicans don't see the loophole.
Assuming John Dean's reading of the bill's language is correct, why should Congressional Republicans worry about the loophole? The administration that orchestrated the criminal warrantless surveillance is almost certainly going to issue pardons so the perpetrators don't have to worry about it.
Coming from one of the few Big Pundits that attempts to be more-or-less consistently liberal, this was to me the most disturbing part of Olbermann's post: "I don't know much about Mr. Greenwald and I didn't read his full piece ..." (my emphasis). But that doesn't stop him from accusing Greenwald of being "simplistic and childish" in that same piece. He's responding to Greenwald's post criticizing him, and he didn't even bother to skim through the whole thing? We're not talking about a 50-page law journal article. Greenwald's post was kind of long for the average blog post - given the length of many of mine, that's certainly no criticism! - but it wasn't that long. Since I was basing my earlier post on Greenwald's piece, I at least felt obligated to read the whole thing to make sure I got the full context before posting on it.
And in any case, Olbermann's attitude as expressed here is the very outlook that has let Cheney, Bush and the lockstep Republican Party in Congress roll over the Democrats on major issues again and again. (Digby gives several examples from this sad record in Getting Things Done Hullabaloo blog 06/26/08.) Well, other Democrats are caving in, so what's the big deal if the leader of the Party does it? The difference, in this case, is between passing a bad bill and blocking it. And surely Olbermann can't imagine that the Republicans are going to refrain from calling Obama "soft on terror" and much worse because he surrendered to the Republican position on this bill, can he?
Olbermann also scolds those of us who were such rude hippie malcontents as to talk about the Great Journalist Tim Russert's manifest problems in his role as a Great Journalist while Olbermann and his fellow members of the journalistic clan were eulogizing him with virtually no critical comment whatsoever:
On a personal level, a thanks to all who expressed sympathies on our two great losses. I will confess, as suggested in another diary, to continuing surprise that there was even a little callousness expressed at Tim Russert's passing. I think the political hats were taken off briefly in respect of the loss of a good man, even on the Right (except for the disgusting New York Post). I was startled to see so many here [presumably he means Daily Kos] unable to hold their fire until at least after he was interred.
This is one of the most prominent of the rare liberal voices about the punditocracy. He's fine with Obama backing the complete cave-in on the FISA bill. He doesn't mind telling us that he didn't even read the full blog post he's brushing off with contempt, a disturbing indication that he shares some of the most dubious habits of his peers.
I am glad to see him note that Rupert Murdoch's New York Post can be "disgusting". I wish he had had that in mind when he did his 10-minute rant against Hillary Clinton over her comment about RFK, basing his report on the New York Post's reporting of it that was so bad even the Post itself later withdrew the language.
And he tut-tuts those who discussed the legacy of Tim Russert as a journalist. Most of us did not know Russert "on a personal level". We did know about his often-damaging legacy as one of the leading figures in the TV news business. And it's a perfectly valid criticism of the news judgment of Olbermann and others who praised Russert to the high heavens on air without providing more than the tiniest hint of the negative aspects of his effect on news. And consequently on the state of our politics and on our involvement in the completely unnecessary Iraq War. Instead, they turned their endless praise for Russert into a massive exercise in media self-congratulation.
He was against it before he was for it. Glenn Greenwald explains how Olbermann eloquently opposed the Cheney-Bush FISA bill which was essentially the same as the one the House recently passed and is now pending in the Senate, in Keith Olbermann: Then and nowSalon 06/26/08.
Since Olbermann was an Obama partisan during the primaries, it's plausible as Greenwald argues, that he's now praising Obama's support of the same bill is a continuation of that partisanship. But that's no reason to pretend the bill is something that it isn't, or to avoid discussing the dangerous provisions of the bill, which he previously attacked. Just this past January, Olbermann was saying that telecom immunity was a "shameless, breathless, literally textbook example of Fascism". Telecom immunity is still in the bill. And though Obama says he'll seek to have it removed in the Senate, he also said ahead of time that he would support the bill with the telecom immunity provisions included.
Greenwald also writes that Olbermann's guest Jonathan Alter of Newsweek was "desperate to defend Obama", though he presumably meant defending him on the FISA capitulation to Cheney and Bush. But it's important to remember that praising Obama's support of the Cheney-Bush FISA bill is entirely consistent with the Establishment press' GOP-friendly scripts. They praise Democrats for being good boys and girls when they show "bipartisanship" by capitulating to the authoritarian Republicans on important issues of the Constitution and the rule of law.
And Greenwald poses an important question, after discussing Alter's goofy description of the FISA capitulation on Olbermann's show:
What's much more notable is Olbermann's full-scale reversal on how he talks about these measures now that Obama - rather than George Bush - supports them. On an almost nightly basis, Olbermann mocks Congressional Democrats as being weak and complicit for failing to stand up to Bush lawbreaking; now that Obama does it, it's proof that Obama won't "cower." Grave warning on Olbermann's show that telecom amnesty and FISA revisions were hallmarks of Bush Fascism instantaneously transformed into a celebration that Obama, by supporting the same things, was leading a courageous, centrist crusade in defense of our Constitution.
Is that really what anyone wants - transferring blind devotion from George Bush to Barack Obama? Are we hoping for a Fox News for Obama, that glorifies everything he says and whitewashes everything he does? (my emphasis)
That depends on who "we" are. But the main liberal criticism of the Establishment press the last few years has demanded that the press do their jobs, including reporting the news accurately, exercising some decent judgment about news priorities and providing some meaningful professionals news analysis instead of relying on ditzy guild scripts.
I don't see any real possibility of the mainstream press becoming a "FOX for Obama" operation, or any major part of it. The real problem is one that we see in Olbermann's flip over telecom amnesty and the FISA changes. The Republicans praise the Democrats for capitulating on an important issue, and pundits perceived as "liberal" like Olbermann or Mark Shields praise the Democrats for capitulating. When the Democrats don't do what the Republicans want, the Republicans attack them for that and the press corps far more often than not adopts a GOP-friendly script on the topic, while the TV "liberals" like Olbermann, Shields or Chris Matthews may or may not defend the Dems refusing to capitulate. Shields and his PBS Newshour counterpart David Brooks were in perfect solidarity last week in approving the Republican attacks on Obama for declining public funding for his general election campaign.
Plenty of liberal Democrats voted for the October 2002 Iraq War resolution, one of the most consequentially bad votes in the history of Congress. If "liberal" pundits want to cheer the Dems for such capitulations, that's one thing. (And bad enough!) But if they use the sloppy methods that have become characteristic of their trade in doing so, i.e., distorting or ignoring problems or just making stuff up, the public will not be well served.
And for the Democratic base generally, it would be hard for me to argue with Greenwald's observation, "The real danger is that those who defend Obama the Candidate no matter what he does are likely to defend Obama the President no matter what he does, too." To end the Iraq War and get a decent health-insurance plan passed, a President Obama will need a Democratic base that's ready to make him do it. Otherwise both efforts will be steamrolled by the Republicans and industry lobbies. If the base just salutes and cheers every time he caves to Republican pressure, he'll be doing a lot of caving.
The Obama-Clinton contest has become a war of nerves, it seems, even though the outcome is virtually certain.
I'm concerned about the problems in the press coverage of Clinton's campaign for the same reason I'm concerned about the problems in how the press treated the Jeremiah Wright story, the silly flag pin flap, etc. We need a responsible press that gets their facts right, that provides some substantive news analysis beyond "Side A said, Side B said", and has some sane priorities in news judgment. We don't have such a press corps today.
There are real problems with American democracy today: the Iraq War, the torture policy, the partisan-politicization of federal prosecutors, the reactionary court system, the one-sided predominance of Republicans in the military officers corps, the massive illegal surveillance, the extreme secrecy in the Executive branch, the systematic anti-science attitude across the government, the staggering levels of crony-capitalist style corruption, and the covert operations of which we only have hints at this point (e.g., Somalia). By the standards of contemporary democracies, the US has some serious democratic deficits.
And without a decent press, we'll never to be able to fix them. One of the most important things a new administration could do would be to reinstate some version of the Fairness Doctrine for broadcast and cable news and to put serious restrictions on corporate ownership and policies for newspapers, magazine and TV news. A change to accounting laws restricting the internal profit margin a TV news division could be required to generate would go a long way to improving coverage. Or at least giving it a reasonable chance to improve. In a more fundamental long-term sense, the collapse of TV journalism in particular may be the most destructive weakness of our democratic culture today.
In a previous post, I discussed how Tim Russert (who is considered a icon of the "liberal media" by conservatives) and his fellow travelers dealt with the Clinton RFK remark this past Sunday. Unfortunately, MSNBC's actual liberal Keith Olbermann also went seriously overboard on the story, as well. One of the problems of today's Establishment is that it has very few liberals voices and does a bad job of presenting liberal perspectives. But in the case of the press conventional wisdom about Vile Hillary, the press dysfunction also has its liberal components, as well.
Here's the video of Olbermann giving his righteously indignant denunciation of Vile Hillary.
This is an unpleasant rant. It seems especially weird coming from the guy who wound up having to apologize on the air for talking about Clinton's persistence in the Presidential race, saying that someone needs to take her into a room and only he comes out. In his rant about the RFK remark, he even trashes Clinton for saying falsely that people are pressing her to drop out - even though that was the point of his take-her-into-a-room statement.
It was a nasty and tasteless remark. But no one I know of thought Olbermann was actually advocating that someone murder Hillary Clinton. Even though his comment could more easily have been taken to conjure up that image than what Clinton said about Robert Kennedy's death after the California primary in 1968. I don't recall anyone saying of his remark that it provided "an X-ray of a very dark soul" and was evidence that he had "murder on [his] mind", or that he "has more lethal fantasies than that nutty skater" Tanya Harding, as columnist Michael Goodwin did of Clinton.
The Daily Howler in his 05/27/08 post recalls that back in March, Clinton said the following in an interview published in Time magazine:
STENGEL (3/6/08): Can you envision a point at which—if the race stays this close—Democratic Party elders would step in and say, "This is now hurting the party and whoever will be the nominee in the fall"?
CLINTON: No, I really can't. I think people have short memories. Primary contests used to last a lot longer. We all remember the great tragedy of Bobby Kennedy being assassinated in June in L.A. My husband didn't wrap up the nomination in 1992 until June. Having a primary contest go through June is nothing particularly unusual.
Yep! Last Friday, all the mimis screamed and yelled at Clinton’s deeply vile statement. But Clinton had said the same thing in March! And to show you how fake this week’s outrage was: Not one damn thing happened back then!
There was no madness back in March. Before considering Robinson, Olbermann, Herbert and Dowd, let’s make sure we understand the chronology of Clinton’s March statement:
Clinton’s interview with Stengel was held on March 5. The full transcript was posted on-line, on March 6.
As you can clearly see from the transcript, Stengel said nothing—nothing at all—when Clinton made her statement about Robert Kennedy. This was no sign—no sign at all—that he was troubled, in any way, by what the vile person had said.
On March 10 or thereabouts, Time’s hard-copy edition hit the street (dated March 17). The cover stories—about Obama and Clinton—included two Q-and-A’s from the Stengel interview. And yes: This did include the Q-and-A in which Clinton cited Kennedy’s death. But even then, after several days had passed, there was no reference to Clinton’s statement in Time’s cover-story reporting. There was still no sign that anyone at Time was troubled by what Clinton had said.
In its next edition (dated March 24), Time published several letters about the Obama/Clinton cover stories. None of the letters mentioned Clinton’s reference to Kennedy’s assassination - and no such letters appeared in subsequent editions. In short, there was still no sign that anyone had found a problem with Clinton’s remark.
That brings us around to our hounds from hell - to Olbermann, Robinson, Herbert and Dowd. Olbermann, Robinson, Herbert and Dowd wrote many columns - appeared on many cable programs - during the first few weeks in March. And guess what? Not one of them said the first f*cking thing about the outrage Clinton committed. Olbermann and Robinson kept their traps shut. Joe Klein didn’t say one word either.
In fact, no mainstream pundit (no one; nobody) said a word about Clinton’s statement in March - a statement which was published in Time, and on-line at the magazine’s web site. No one at Time said a word; no one in the wider press corps. And yet, this past weekend, everyone keened and wailed and tore their hair when Clinton so vilely said the same thing!
At the very least, the fact that she had made the same point in March, worded a bit more artfully then, and that no one took it as showing the darkness of her soul filled with thoughts of murder, should at the very least be reason to think she simply phrased it poorly in the now-infamous version. Olbermann even quotes that March statement of hers. But rather than point out that this at least suggests that she had other than homicidal intentions in her more recent statement, Olbermann said, "In retrospect, we failed her when we did not call her out, for that remark, dry and only disturbing, inside the pages of a magazine."
I've been impressed with some of Olbermann's forcefully worded editorials about the Bush administration and about the Iraq War. But in the future, I'm going to listen much more carefully to his editorials even when he's taking a position I like.
Because while such journalistic malpractice might occasionally work to the benefit of the Democrats, on the whole we've seen for the last 16 years since the Whitewater pseudo-scandal appeared on the front page of the New York Times, this kind of loose-cannon journalism overwhelming works against the interests of the Democrats and, more importantly, greatly disadvantages the public.
The substance (or lack thereof) of the controversy notwithstanding—big sister blog Swampland weighs in here and here and here and here and here - Olbermann is edging ever-closer to self-parody, or, worse, predictability. (As soon as the Clinton gaffe broke, blog commenters were wondering how ballistic he would go, and he obliged, and how.) Even if we concede his argument - that Clinton was at best callously and at worst intentionally suggesting she should stay in the race because Obama might be killed - every time he turns up the volume to 11 like this lately, he sounds like just another of the cable gasbags he used to be a corrective to.
Fair enough, as I see it. But then Poniewozik goes on to talk about what it shows about the narrow-mindedness of Obama and Clinton supporters, turning away (as the unwritten laws of the Establishment media require him to) from what it says about the massive dysfunction of the national press.
There is a distinct liberal critique of the mass media that has become widespread since 2002 and the media's collapse in the buildup to war in Iraq. The decades-long conservative whine about the Liberal Press! Liberal Press! Liberal Press! has mostly been a fact-free form of "working the ref". And, for various reasons, it's been depressingly successful.
Democratic candidates should try to "work the ref" as well, since Republican campaigns do it so effectively.
But the thrust of the liberal critique of the Establishment press is that it's failing to do it's job. Instead of getting their facts right, providing substantive news analysis", and applying sane priorities in news judgment, they run with often mindless scripts, allow the Drudge Report and other gossip-mongers to set their news agendas, and often can't get the most basic factual reporting right. We don't need a press that flacks more often for Democrats. We need a press that does the job that the press has to do for democracy to function.
The mass media script of the incorrigible vileness and malice of the Clintons is currently working to Obama's favor. But we've already got some heavy doses about how the same bad habits that are currently driving their journalistic jihad against Clinton can quickly be turned on Obama. And given the press' general adoration of St. McCain, it will be again during this year, almost certainly in much uglier ways than we've seen directed against Obama before. And the result could be McCain elected in 2008, and war with Iran in 2009.
But the press has had 16 years since they went off the Whitewater cliff to refine their hatred for the Clintons. It will take them another year or two at least to develop such a poisonous script about Vile Obama.
Burtseva goes further than I would in generalizing from Olbermann's celebrity reporting, particularly in relation to Britney. She seems to think that almost any kind of satirical or insulting shots about a celebrity's personal image is wrong, even when that image is essential to the reason they are a celebrity in the first place.
But she makes some valid points about the subject. Last year, Olbermann reported on Paris Hilton getting slugged in the face by some guy, saying "she's had worse things happen to her face". His report was also captioned, "A Slut and Battery". Though Paris Hilton is perhaps unique in that her only claim to celebrity status seems to be that she is a celebrity, she hasn't promoted herself as someone who goes around seeking to be slugged in the face. Among other criticisms of that report, Burtseva writes of Olbermann, "He thinks women who make particular sexual choices are to be taken less seriously when they claim to have been assaulted." Again, that's perhaps a bit too much of a generalization to hang on that one report of his. But as a criticism of that particular report, it's perfectly sensible.
Burtseva notes that on his Feb. 19 broadcast, he chose as his first topic to discuss "that most important of word events: Britney Spears' hairstyle choice". He had Village Voice columnist Michael Musto on to discuss it. Burtseva asks parenthetically:
Pause for a moment to consider this scenario: The man who has been called the Arthur R. Murrow of our time has a gossip columnist on his show to discuss a pop singer's hairstyle.
Good point.
She quotes the following dialogue between Olbermann and his guest:
OLBERMANN: The hair dresser, Miss Tognozzi, also asked if Britney Spears appeared to be under the influence. She said no, but she did use the word trance to describe her. A trance.
MUSTO: No, she actually said the tramp dropped her pants, and it got reported as trance, but it works anyway.
Burtseva comments sourly (and appropriately), "Olbermann elected not to take issue with the crude commentary of his guest. I'm not shocked."
Her general judgment of Olbermann's Britney-hair segment:
In the eyes of Olbermann and his sexist ilk, Spears made two mistakes: She dared to be overtly sexual and she dared to shed one of the defining markers of her femininity. I neither know nor care how much sex Spears has and with whom, or why she shaved her head, but I have this radical proposition: In spite of the fact that she's made sexy music videos, Spears' body is her own and should not be subjected to Olbermann's disgusting views.
That short paragraph is an example of a good idea sandwiched into bad framing. For one thing, it's not at all clear from her article who she wants us to picture as part of Obermann's "sexist ilk". Liberal reporters? Democrats? Guys named Keith?
And for someone like me who reads her blog post but didn't see the segment in question, she gives us four examples of Olbermann's "disgusting" views. One is the fact that he didn't object to Musto's comment, a comment that was kind of disgusting. The others are: Olbermann called Britney a "pop tart"; he wondered about "what she was on", i.e., whether she was on drugs or drunk; and, someone at the "cast and crew" blog of the Olbermann show referred to her in a post as "sweetheart".
Dumb or trivial, maybe. But I don't see those as "disgusting". None of them comes close to the "A Slut and Battery" caption in bad taste. And her conclusion in the end that Olbermann is "a petty, disrespectful misogynist" don't obviously follow from the information she provides in the article. I mean, if I'm going to join in trashing one of the leading liberal TV commentators - one of the only ones actually - I'd like to know I'm doing it for good reasons. Rightwingers could use her blog post to say, "Even the a liberal feminist like Sandi Burtseva says that Keith Olbermann is a woman-hater with disgusting, degrading views of women who even mocks domestic violence victims." Maybe there's more justice in her view than I'm seeing, but I'm withholding judgment on some of her general criticisms.
Having made all those reservations about Burtseva's post, she has a legitimate point about the Britney's-shaved-head story. As quoted above, "She dared to be overtly sexual and she dared to shed one of the defining markers of her femininity", i.e., her hair. It's a good point. Her sexy image is a big reason many of her fellow Southern Baptists have criticized her from the beginning of her national fame. And regardless of whatever particular issues she may have been having when she changed hairstyles drastically, would it be international news for days running if a male star of similar status shaved his head? Like Boo's ex Justin Timberlake, for instance?
I'm also not one to draw broad social conclusions from media coverage of some pop culture event or personality. But Brutseva has hit on something important, in that people project their ideas about sex and gender roles onto Britney's celebrity image. And then draw judgments based on how close she comes to fulfilling the expectations they project onto the image.
When Johnny Cash passed away, his daughter Rosanne said that there would always be a "Johnny Cash" - the public persona of the star - but there would never be another Daddy, the private father and man she knew. More than most famous people, Britney has to co-exist with "Britney", the celebrity character of which people have such intense and contradictory expectations.