Showing posts with label occupy wall street. Show all posts
Showing posts with label occupy wall street. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 28, 2011

2011 retrospective: Occupy Wall Street and press corps disconnect

I'm trying to avoid the ever-popular year-end lists or retrospectives. But what the heck, here's one of my favorites from 2011, Occupy Wall Street and the cluelessness of the mainstream media in evaluating it, much less recognizing its potency. Here The Young Turks memorialize what may be the most emblematic moment on US mainstream TV news for 2011, Occupy Wall Street Attacked by Erin Burnett YouTube date 10/05/2011:



And this brilliant Halloween spoof by The Alyona Show's Alyona Minkovski 10/31/2011, Halloween:'Seriously, Protesters?!':



Tags: , ,

Thursday, November 17, 2011

What does Obama think about this week's nationwide Occupy crackdown?

Lynn Parramore has 6 Burning Questions About the Violent Crackdowns on Occupations Around the Country Alternet 11/15/2011. The one I find most interesting is this one (emphasis in original):

What, if any, was the role of the White House? Who was in charge of following the nationwide Occupy crackdown at the White House? What does President Obama, the man who celebrated the uprisings in Egypt (and who is currently out of the US, in Asia), think about the raids and the encroachments on the civil liberties of peacefully protesting Americans? As a constitutional scholar, what is his view of the restrictions of the press and the arrests of journalists?
Politics is politics, as Joe Stalin said when he was on the verge of making a Non-Aggression Pact with Hitler Germany. And we know that foreign relations produces even more routine hypocrisy than day-to-day domestic politics.

And in fairness to President Obama, he was late in expressing enthusiasm for the activism of the Arab Awakening.

Yet we have had months this year in which the Arab Awakening was celebrated by the media and our politicians, normally in the self-congratulating triumphalism that approved of how the primitive Arabs were copying us enlightened Americans.

Now we have a brutal crackdown on a nationwide protest movement that raises real questions about the practical limits of freedom of speech today and about the willingness of the urban police to enforce the law, rather than to uphold the authority and protect the convenience of the 1%.

I would certainly like to hear the Democratic President express himself clearly on this subject.

Tags: ,

Occupy Wall Street is a protest movement

Public Policy Polling just published a study showing that Occupy Wall Street is dropping significantly in the public's regard: Occupy Wall Street Favor Fading 11/16/2011:

The Occupy Wall Street movement is not wearing well with voters across the country. Only 33% now say that they are supportive of its goals, compared to 45% who say they oppose them. That represents an 11 point shift in the wrong direction for the movement's support compared to a month ago when 35% of voters said they supported it and 36% were opposed. Most notably independents have gone from supporting Occupy Wall Street's goals 39/34, to opposing them 34/42.
Digby comments on the report in Old fault lines Hullabaloo 11/16/2011 and Oh. Homeland security AND the FBI 11/15/2011.

Charles Pierce weighs in on it in The Manufactured Narrative (and Delicate Future) of Occupy Esquire Politics Blog 11/16/2011.

This development doesn't especially surprise me for the reasons that Digby and Pierce describe. At this point, it's even a measure of the effectiveness of the Occupy movement.

This movement is a protest movement. It's not a mobilization effort for a political party. It's not a campaign for a candidate running for office. It's not a membership group offering policy solutions for a broad range of problems. It's a protest movement.

Protests aren't needed around issues that aren't problematic. Protests are needed around things that aren't going right, around problems that aren't being adequately recognized or addressed. Protests are meant to break the routine order of daily business. They are meant to disturb established habits of thinking. They are meant to change priorities. They are meant to shake people out of complacency and apathy, to raise issues others aren't bothering to raise, to make people uncomfortable with the current situation in hopes they will see it needs to be changed in a positive way.

The Democratic and Republican Parties have both competed for decades now primarily over which can more effectively comfort the comfortable. That was the theme of Kenneth Galbraith's The Culture of Contentment (1992), and that process has continued the last two decades. So it's not at all unusual that a massive protest movement like Occupy would generate doubt and opposition, not only among the most comfortable one percent, but also among the large portions of the 99% who feel comfortable enough with current social arrangement that they resent or fear anyone who tries to rock the boat.

The Occupy movement has created one of what Jerry Brown has called a "democratic moment", in which ordinary people bypassed failing party and governmental channels to inject themselves directly into the political process. And they have generated widespread sympathy and activism across the country and the world, feeding into the already existing anti-austerity protests like those of the indignados in Spain and Greece.

The fact that they don't have polls showing a majority agreeing with them doesn't change the nature or significance of what the movement has accomplished. They have exposed the capture of both major political parties and the Supreme Court by the Money Power (to use a Jacksonian terms) in a new and immediate way. They have exposed the corruption and militarization of police departments and their blatant hostility to dissent, including in several major cities (Chicago, Oakland, Portland, Seattle) with Democratic mayors.

The movement has given the maldistribution of wealth and income new prominence in the public discussions and media coverage, even in the mainstream media, while the Democrats and Republicans blithely chug along in the ridiculous Congressional "super-committee" proposing to slash vital civilian programs and to cut Social Security and Medicare benefits while cutting tax rates for the wealthiest. It shows the extent of the practical corruption of the Democratic and Republican parties. But the pressure created by the Occupy movement also contributes to the pressure to force this ludicrous super-committee scheme to end in a meaningless deadlock, the best outcome that can be expected at this moment.

This edition of the Brooks and Shields Clown Show from last Friday's PBS Newshour (11/11/2011) illustrates the effect the movement is having on political conversation (Shields and Brooks on GOP Race After Perry Flub, 'Occupy' Movement):



Sleepy Mark Shields was downright alert in talking about the Occupy movement.

I think the message, which is, people say, unclear is a lot stronger than the messenger.
Sleepy Mark wouldn't stray far enough from Beltway Village conventional wisdom to not gripe a little bit about the hippies.

But after making his ritual pledge of allegiance to Beltway conventional wisdom, he actually had something to say worth listening to:

Not -- certainly not Mayor Adams of Portland, but I think some of the critics and opponents of the movement itself have tried to discredit the movement by focusing attention on the exotic, eccentric, erratic behavior of some of the Occupiers.

But it hit home to me this past week when this question was put. The current economic structure of the country is out of balance and favors a small proportion of the rich over the rest of the country; America needs to reduce the power of major banks and corporations -- 76 percent of Americans, Wall Street Journal poll, agree with that; 60 percent strongly agree with that.

It cuts across partisan, religious, racial, age divisions. So I think that is a direct consequence of the movement. I think the movement's message has been very effective in getting across. I doubt if it would have been that strong three months ago. [my emphasis]
David "Bobo" Brooks became a caricature of himself. Bobo's specialty is explaining why Republican attitudes and Party positions of the day are entirely sensible and do so in a soft, restrained tone. Usually, when he adopts the most exaggeratedly calm tone is when he's spewing the most undiluted hogwash. Here he says - with a straight face - that the Koch-brothers-front-group-funded Tea Party rightwing protesters were raising the same issues as the Occupy movement! Following directly on Shields' comments just quoted, Bobo declares:

That's exactly what the Tea Party movement has been saying.
Yes, and it's the stork that brings babies into the world, too! Bobo might as well have been doing a comedy routine mocking himself at this point. He continues:

My problem with that movement and the Tea Party movement, both of them, is they have no leaders. They have no institutions. And you can celebrate democracy if you think it's useful to have a movement with no leaders. But if have no leaders and no institutions, you have no direction, you have, I think, no lasting power. But you have nobody to be serious and be rigorous and say, here are the problems we all agree on. Here is what we are offering.

And if you have no leaders, you're not going to have any structure for a set of solutions. And, politically, you're not going to be defined by your best people. You're going to be defined by your worst, who are going to be the most disruptive. And that's, I think, what has happened to the Occupy movement.

So I just think a movement needs leaders and institutions to have staying power, as the civil rights movement did.

JIM LEHRER: What about Mark's point, though, that all of that aside, it has raised the consciousness about this very issue that Mark...

DAVID BROOKS: Yes, I think it has.

The Tea Party movement really was talking about financial concentration. This was their core message, the concentration of finance in Washington, and which is the core message of the Occupy movement, obviously, from a different perspective.

But -- so, that issue is something that a lot of us agree with. A lot of us -- I'm no Occupy type, but I think the banks should be broken up, as they do. And, nonetheless, it's not enough just to raise the issue. And I give them credit for that. You have got to have some solutions. And that involves studying the issue.

Things are complicated. And so -- and then the final point -- and this is what the mayors are facing all around the country -- is you have a right to raise issues. You have a right to protest. You don't have a right to occupy parts of your city.

And so there is a balance mayors are dealing with. And I think they have been very lenient with the Occupy movement. But as these efforts mount, I think they're right to try to restore some order, while giving them the right to protest. [my emphasis]
You have a right to protest, says Bobo. It just should be somewhere like a caged-in "free speech zone", safely out of sight and out of mind of Very Serious People like Bobo and other Beltway star pundits.

Bobo is continuing the Establishment media trend mocked so effectively by RT America's Alyona Minkovski in this clip sending up CNN's Erin Burnett's famously clueless coverage of the Occupy Wall Steet protest (Halloween:'Seriously, Protesters?!' 10/31/2011):



Tags:

Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Occupying the 1st Amendment

Cenk Uygur of Current TV's The Young Turks reports on the current state of freedom of speech and assembly in American plutocracy, with particular reference to New York City's billionaire Mayor Michael Bloomberg and Occupy Wall Street (Why Bloomberg Fights Occupy Wall Street YouTube date 11/15/2011):



Robert Reich characterizes the situation this way (Occupiers Occupied: The Hijacking of the First Amendment 11/15/2011)

A funny thing happened to the First Amendment on its way to the public forum. According to the Supreme Court, money is now speech and corporations are now people. But when real people without money assemble to express their dissatisfaction with the political consequences of this, they’re treated as public nuisances and evicted.
There appears to have been nationwide coordination in Monday's clearing of various Occupy sites across the country. Enough of the peasants grumbling about the 1%. RJ Eskow asks, State of Siege USA: Why Would They Want to Shut the #OWS Movement Down NOW? C&L 11/16/2011. He looks at how both Democrats and Republicans, despite being shaken by the success of Occupy's democratic moment, continue on the same march to austerity economics and immunity for the 1% from all responsibility for their deeds and misdeeds.

Tags:

Occupy Oakland

RT America's The Alyona Show has had a reporter on the scene at Occupy Oakland; they had the following report from Monday 11/14/2011, Occupy Oakland Evicted:



Dan Siegel talks about Occupy Oakland in an appearance with Keith Olbermann on Current TV's Countdown 11/15/2011, Occupy Oakland: Dan Siegel, why he resigned as advisor to Mayor Quan:



Salon's Joan Walsh has been trying to be analytical and fair, though it's also clear that she's worried about backlash from Sarah Palin's Real Americans. She has what seems like a solid report in On the eve of destruction 11/14/2011.

Both reports talk about the discussion over tactics, including the use of violence against property.

Jonathan Simon at his Governing Through Crime blog, Governing the Occupy Movement through Crime 11/15/2011 makes an important point about how a shooting incident was used by Oakland officials as a main justification for clearing the primary Occupy Oakland encampment downtown. Although those involved in the shooting were hanging around the encampment and may have been staying there, it's not clear whether they were actively involved in the protest. Simon writes:

The gist of the argument behind this blog, and the book, Governing through Crime: How the War on Crime Transformed American Democracy and Created a Culture of Fear,is that political leaders facing a chronic legitimacy deficit since the late 1960s have frequently used protecting citizens from crime as the least problematic way of justifying the exercise of power.

In Oakland this played out in almost comic precision. Hemmoraging legitimacy after first clearing the plaza in a violent police sweep and then letting the Occupy encampment be reestablished Mayor Jean Quan seemed paralyzed with indecision about what to do about the camp until a murder on the periphery of the encampment last week gave her a crime cover. Having supported the goals of the occupation and accepted encampment as a protest tactic the Mayor now found an imperative requiring the preventive clearing of the site (read the full story in the SFChron here):

"The encampment became a place where we had repeated violence and, this week, a murder. We had to bring the camp to an end before more people were hurt."
I'll add here that I went down to the Occupy Oakland site on Saturday morning of Nov. 5. Downtown Oakland, like most big city downtowns, is a mixture of people on a normal day. There are a lot of office workers and medical people in the area. There's a large Kaiser Permanente facility there and a lot of offices, restaurants and shops in the vicinity of City Hall, where Occupy Oakland camped. There are some buildings that have been recently built or renovated and others that are more run-down. There are also a fair amount of homeless or transients in the area. On a normal day, it's not a particularly unsafe place to be, though in any city you have to always be aware of the surroundings, especially after dark.

When I walked around the Occupy Oakland encampment, it was midmorning, and a lot of people seemed to be waking up and getting something for breakfast and starting the day. There was a spirited protest mini-rally at a Wells Fargo bank branch a block or so away. There were a few people who I guessed may have been homeless or beggars or both hanging around the camp, which didn't surprise me, but not a lot. It wasn't like a camping site at a state park. But it didn't strike me as especially grungy.

Digby tweeted on Tuesday, "Many readers like posts that focus on defecation of #OWS protesters 2 exclusion of all else/#bizarrerightwingfetish". When I was at the Occupy Oakland camp, there seemed to be plenty of Porta-Potties available. And I didn't see or smell nasty stuff. Sorry to disappoint FOX News fans.

My general impression of downtown Oakland is consistent with what Simon observes here:

While the details of the murder investigation are unknown to me, there is little reason to believe from what we know thus far that the encampment created a context that made such a killing more likely. Far from it. As media attention to the encampment has disclosed to many casual observers, Oakland has loads of homeless men, many of them battling symptoms of mental illness, life long drug abuse, and the soul destroying impact of mass incarceration. The city also has lots of young men punished and pushed out of schools and toward jail (read Victor Rios' superb book Punished for more on that) whose search for dignity takes them into deadly games of gang competition and related honor violence. These troubled populations, frequently churned by law enforcement, prison, and parole, has been a source of crime and insecurity in Oakland for decades; Occupy Oakland didn't bring it there, and based on published reports did not make it worst.
Joan Walsh's article gives a good sense, I think, of how a disparate protest movement would inevitably encounter problems with homeless people and drug dealers and various marginal urban dwellers, especially in a setting like downtown Oakland. The occupying of this Occupy movement doesn't seem likely to turn into anything like the squatter movement in Germany in the 1970s. So there would be some kind of natural limit on this phase of it, even in the absence of police misconduct.

But the Occupy movement became a genuinely "democratic moment". It changed the national political dialogue on the depression and exposed some rotting and rotten parts of our political system in an important way.

One of the things the Occupy movement has highlighted is the increasing militarization of the police. Digby writes about that in Militarizing the Police: How the Drug War and 9/11 Led to Battle-Dressed Cops Cracking Down on Peaceful Protests Alternet 11/14/2011. So does Glenn Greenwald in A police raid suffused with symbolism Salon 11/15/2011.

Tags: ,

Thursday, November 03, 2011

Occupy Oakland and its general strike

With the eyes of the world on Oakland yesterday, the violent clashes of the night of 11/02 and the early morning of 11/03 will get disproportionate attention: Kristin Bender et al, Occupy Oakland demonstrators clash with police, block Port Oakland Tribune 11/03/2011.

That shouldn't detract from the real accomplishment of Occupy Oakland on Wednesday the 2nd (although it will). Diane Sweet gives a brief report on the day's events in Occupy Oakland Shuts Down City C&L 11/03/2011. Pulling off a one-day general strike really is quite an accomplishment. The members of the ILWU (International Longshoremen's and Warehouse Union) did an informal walkout, though it's a safe guess that the union leadership wasn't bothered by that though technically they didn't endorse the action, probably for legal and contractual reasons.

Cenk Uygur reports on the port shutdown in Occupy Oakland Organizer on Blocking the Oakland Port The Young Turks YouTube date 10/03/2011:



This is a report on the port shutdown from Aljazeera English, Protesters shut down huge Oakland port in US 11/02/2011:



Here is a PBS Newshour report from during the day of 11/02/2011, Occupy Oakland Movement Tries to Flex Muscle With General Strike:



This comment from PBS reporter Spencer Michels is an appropriate observation:

An observation: As controversial as the activities of Occupy Oakland are, very few people, organizations or politicians have spoken out against the principles of this demonstration.

The strike and the encampment have attracted a mixed group of protesters and denizens of the community. Although the group claims it has no leaders, participants gather often for planning meetings, where they work out the logistics of a city hall camp-in.
Local news report video from KTVU TV: OAKLAND: Occupy Oakland protests erupts into violence

This is a segment related to Occupy Oakland from Keith Olbermann's Countdown (apparently from 10/02/2011; YouTube date 11/03/2011), OWS: Joshua Shepherd links vets' issues with larger movement:



C&L has set up a section of their blog devoted to Occupy America.

I'll say several things here, all of which can be true at the same time: the more violent (starting fires) aspect of the protest was not the result or the goal of the main Occupy Oakland protest group - in fact, the latter tried to discourage such actions; the violence does reflect in part the frustration and anger many people feel not only against Wall Street but specifically against the misconduct of Oakland police last week; critics will use the violent aspects to try to discredit the protests more generally; the Bay Area has some actual anarchist types around who look for opportunities to stage dramatic scenes; the authorities at all levels are using spies and provocateurs at a level not seen since the COINTELPRO program and probably on a much greater scale than even that; some of the more violent individuals in Oakland Wednesday night were almost certainly police provocateurs of some kind.

Pure protest movements exist only in the minds of their critics. People who want to understand what they are really about have to look at the whole picture. Grownups can look at the main thrust of the 99% protest of the Occupy movement and see that Ron Paul crackpots and general sleazebags try to glom onto it for one reason or the other. The Occupy movement has to deal with those as part of the efforts of those acting on behalf of the 1% to discredit their movement. Since the Occupy movement is challenging the power of organized money, they can't count on the favorable press or the Koch brothers-type financing that the Tea Party could.

Given all those factors, I'm frankly not worrying personally about the occasional paint-ball splattering a public building or people pounding on ATMs during a large demonstration. The main crowd in the Occupy Oakland protest apparently opposed those actions on Wednesday and that's good thinking on their part. But if you're an outside observer who's too pure to support anything about any movement that has anything like that happening at its demonstrations, then forget about protesting anything substantive. Get yourself a funny Colonial costume and join the Tea Party.

Or, if you really like sounding "left", you can join up with some Trotskyist sect. They are the people who support revolution everywhere except where one is going on. The perfect environment for someone who want to be "left" but doesn't want to do anything that might actually discomfort the most comfortable.

There is an Occupy Oakland website.

Tags: ,

Monday, October 31, 2011

A strange interview with philosopher Slavoj Žižek

I've had occasion a couple of times recently to post on Slavoj Žižek, a Marxist and critical theorist, in connection with Occupy Wall Street. OWS may be a big boost to the Slavoj Žižek, because he's getting a level of public attention that he probably never has before. This Aljazeera English interview is an example. I'm getting the impression that Žižek may be better at diagnosing fundamental social problems than he is about grasping real existing political movements.

Žižek saw in the London riots of this summer some like feral violence. He discusses it a bit at the start of this interview. He wrote about it more extensively in Shoplifters of the World Unite London Review of Books 08/19/2011.

Talk to Al Jazeera - Slavoj Zizek YouTube date 10/29/2011:



Žižek says beginning around 2:00 that he considers Communism to be a bigger "ethical catastrophe" than fascism, in which he presumably includes Nazi Germany. (In poli sci and history, there's substantive disagreement whether German National Socialism/Nazism represents a variant of fascism or was its own distinct form of far-right dictatorship.) Here's his reasoning:

Let's face it, 20th century Communism was, precisely because it started with such hopes and ended in a nightmare, was maybe the greatest catastrophe, ethical catastrophe, I'm almost tempted to say, in the history of humanity. More than fascism.

You know why? Because, let's be very simple. In fascism, we have bad guys who said, our program is to do this and this bad things, no?, And - what a surprise - they took power, they did bad things, no?. In Communism, you have authentic tragedy. Which is why you have dissidents, you have always inner struggles. So, but nonetheless, it is over.
Now, one could argue that this comes from the perspective of a person who grew up and formed his perspective in a then-Communist country (Yugoslavia) and is trying to argue that the official ideologies of those countries contained important elements that were true, but not realized in "real existing socialism", as those regimes were known to refer to themselves.

Still, Nazi Germany was oriented toward war from the time Hitler took power until V-E Day. It plunged Europe into the most destructive, deadliest war in all history. The Communist governments did not do that. Nor did any Communist governments undertake the physical extermination of an entire ethnic group as we saw with Nazi Germany and the Jews, in Rwanda, and arguably with the dying Ottoman Empire and the Armenians.

Nazi ideology was explicitly bad in the sense that Žižek argues. But I wouldn't endorse his view that somehow a betrayal of the stated ideals of noble ideals of some sort is ethically more catastrophic than the fact of Nazi Germany having launched the deadliest war in all of history, of which the Holocaust was very much a part. It may suit Žižek's stance of being part of a grand historical tragedy from the side of the East European Communist regimes. But as an ethical argument, it just doesn't wash.

Beginning around 3:40, he approvingly quotes (gulp!), Ayn Rand. No, I'm not kidding. And it gets even more problematic from there. For me, this whole interview was like nails on a blackboard. At the end, he even seems to think that the American Tea Party movement is a progressive workers' movement. (?!)

Žižek is a respected philosopher in the field of critical theory, an area on which I've posted many times. For reasons I discuss more below, critical theory is generally focused on diagnosing large problems, which is one reason it played an important role in sociology, notably with the 1940s studies on authoritarianism of which The Authoritarian Personality is the most famous. It has not focused so much on describing the shape of a fundamental alternative to capitalism and the "modernity" associated with it. Most of them have understood themselves as socialists. But the defining experience for critical theory - which originally meant the people associated with the Social Social Research, aka the Frankfurt School in the 1930s - was European fascism, especially the experience of Nazi Germany. That left them with a partisan appreciation of civil liberties and the fundamentals of representative democracy, which expressed itself in a radical-democratic outlook that didn't approve the forms of government in the Communist world but also didn't reject Marxist perspectives wholesale. It would be fair to say as a generalization that they built on the radical-democratic element in historical Marxism, which made them not partisans of the Communist movements but also highly critical of the post-First World War course of Social Democracy.

Žižek in this interview discusses violence in the sense of the Sorelian utopian general strike. For history buffs or philosophy geeks who happen to be familiar with that concept, it makes some sense. But for the average news consumers, even very well-informed ones, are likely to be left scratching their heads over the way he puts it.

Critical theory continues the analysis of the problems and opportunities of modernity that emerged from the classical German philosophy of the late 18th and early 19th century, of which Kant and Hegel are the most significant. Broadly speaking, critical theory draws from that tradition as well as Nietzsche, Kierkegaard, Freudian psychoanalysis, Husserl's phenomenology, and existentialism. Max Horkheimer and Herbert Marcuse actually defined the term "critical theory" to describe their general approach, though the term was also used earlier to refer to Kantian thought.

Žižek in this interview shows the pitfalls of this viewpoint when processing contemporary political events. He brings up some interesting empirical observations that alerted me to some things to look for, e.g., describing a mass demonstration in Istanbul for gay rights that, he says, did not attract any attempts at violence by onlookers. But he seems almost sensationalist at times in trying to make people think with provocative statements. But in terms of giving us a sense of social and political dynamics, it's pretty deficient.

The catchiest phrase I noticed in the interview comes just after 2:50: "The marriage between democracy and capitalism is over."

He makes it specifically in reference to China. But there is a conflict between capitalism and democracy in that capitalist economies, left to their preferred course, will tend to concentrate wealth and power in a small number of people, as we see now in the 1% society that OWS is highlighting. Democracy gives the public the power to offset, mitigate and potentially end the disproportionate power of the 1% over the rest of society. Capitalism will always produce types like the Koch brother billionaires who want to buy out the political system and have it serve solely the perceived self-interests of the 1%. A healthy democracy has to be able to counteract that disproportionate economic power.

Tags: , , , ,

Occupy Wall Street and the Money Power

Matt Stoller has a perceptive take on Occupy Wall Street and its political significance at the moment in Occupy Wall Street: The Primary the President Never Had? Alternet 10/24/2011: "What the occupiers have done, perhaps unwittingly, is force political elites to choose, at least publicly, between their funding stream and their popular legitimacy." And he writes:

The gravitational pull of the occupiers is remarkable to behold. Tea Partiers are angry at the stolen thunder. Wall Street tycoon Larry Fink (who is on the investor, not the banks side) offered praise for the protests. Liberal Democratic groups like Moveon and Democracy for America have a new language and group to organize around, instead of defending the White House. Labor now has another horse to back, a motley energetic group calling itself the 99 percent, rather than a mild center-right Democratic elite class. Big-dollar liberal donors are excited to find a way to tap into this "energy." The occupiers are considered a new pole in the political system, "Krugman's army," perhaps.
Glenn Greenwald has a perceptive take in The importance of protests Salon 10/30/2011:

Ever since I began writing about politics, the most frequently asked question I’ve encountered has been: but what can we do about all of this? The reason I find the Occupy movement to be one of the most important, exciting and inspiring political developments of the last decade is that it provides the definitive answer to that question. Though still in what I hope is its incipient stage, this protest movement proves that citizens of all different backgrounds and even ideologies (though sharing common interests) possess the ability to unite, pose a threat to seemingly invulnerable power factions, and demand change beyond the mere act of voting once every two years — and that they can endure and even grow in the face of abusive police force. Though it has already accomplished substantial good, the protest movement hasn’t yet achieved all of that, but it has provided the template and made manifest the possibility.

... oligarchs in a corrupted society will be free from any meaningful checks from the government they own and control, and will continue to pilfer from the rest of the society until resulting social unrest on the part of ordinary citizens becomes too disruptive and threatening to their interests. Put another way, an oligarchical class that operates without any fear in its collective heart of the citizenry will continue to assemble and protect its ill-gotten gains without limits. That is why this protest movement is so vital — so indispensable — because it is precisely that fear in the hearts and minds of the elite classes that has been so destructively lacking. [my emphasis in bold]
I'm happy to see that a group of progressive media figures has decided to put more of a focus on the anti-democracy Citizens United Supreme Court decision. (Paul Blumenthal, Campaign Finance Reformers Launch Progressive Effort To Remove Money From Politics Huffington Post 10/26/2011)

The current crooked Supreme Court is not only corrupt but more and more crassly partisan. Just as in the New Deal when the "nine old men" on the Supreme Court did all they could to torpedo the New Deal programs, today's Roberts Court is using their position to more permanently entrench the power of money to control the political institutions that are supposed to be representative democratic institutions but are failing to play that role at this moment in some very serious ways, Greece possibly being the most painful example right now.

Tags: ,

Saturday, October 29, 2011

Occupy Wall Street and the basics of US income inequality

Occupy Wall Street and the European movement of indignados are both very much related to the great increase of inequality in Europe and the US during the last 30 years.

The Congressional Budget Office just released a very helpful study on Trends in the Distribution of Household Income Between 1979 and 2007 (Oct 2011). One thing about these comparisons that can make it easy for polemicists to create sound-bites that fog the water is that there is a lot of room to select data, e.g., which income cohorts to compare, which dates to choose, etc. But this CBO set of bullet-points is one good overview of the basics, dealing with the period 1979-2007:

The share of income going to higher-income households rose, while the share going to lower-income households fell.
  • The top fifth of the population saw a 10-percentage-point increase in their share of after-tax income.
  • Most of that growth went to the top 1 percent of the population.
  • All other groups saw their shares decline by 2 to 3 percentage points.
This concentration of wealth has major implications for democracy. You can have a democracy with significant disparities of wealth and income. But the more extreme the concentration at the top becomes, the more disproportionate the power of the wealthiest to control political outcomes through the direct and indirect power of money becomes.

Conservatives for a long time have attacked any increase for taxes on the wealthy as "income redistribution" and therefore bad. Democrats - do I even need to say it? - have rolled over and played dead in front of such propaganda.

The truth is that every tax is a redistribution of income of some kind. The real question is whether redistribution of fair, just and conducive to the health of democracy. What we have now is none of those three.

As the CBO report points out, tax policies have shaped how the distribution of income has changed since 1977, and shaped it in the direction of increasing concentration of power for the wealthiest:

Government transfers and federal taxes both help to even out the income distribution. Transfers boost income the most for lower-income households, while taxes claim a larger share of income as people's income rises.

In 2007, federal taxes and transfers reduced the dispersion of income by 20 percent, but that equalizing effect was larger in 1979.

  • The share of transfer payments to the lowest-income households declined.
  • The overall average federal tax rate fell.
Distribution of wealth and distribution of income are closely related phenomena but not identical. The distribution of income alone doesn't fully measure the economic clout of the largest 1% or 10%. But because they are heavily correlated, it certainly gives a vivid picture.

Ryan Chittum recently busted the rightwing AEI for a study purporting to show that there had been no increase in income inequality in The Myth of Income Equality, Courtesy of AEI CJR The Audit 10/26/2011. The following takes five whole sentences for him to say, which probably makes it 4 1/2 sentences more than the average Rush Limbaugh fan would even attempt to listen to:

The poorest 20 percent of households made an average $11,034 last year, $179 less than they did in 1979. The median income rose to $49,445 last year from $46,074 in 1979, while the top 20 percent made an average $169,633, or $48,536 more than in 1979.

But the real blowout hasn't been between the 80th and 99th percentiles. It’s been in the top 1 percent and top 0.1 percent, which is why that "We Are the 99 percent" slogan has struck such a chord. The poorest member of the top 1 percent made $347,000 in 2007 (the latest year I can find), more than double the $165,049 they made in 1979.
Paul Krugman in Denial In Depth 10/29/2011 takes off from Chittum's post to point out common patterns in rightwing counterfactual argumentation:

What I found myself thinking about, however, is the way the inequality debate illustrates some typical features of many debates these days: the way the right has a sort of multi-layer defense in depth, which involves not only denying facts but then, in a pinch, denying the fact that you denied those facts.

Think about climate change. You have various right-wingers simultaneously (a) denying that global warming is happening (b) denying that anyone denies that global warming is happening, but denying that humans are responsible (c) denying that anyone denies that humans are causing global warming, insisting that the real argument is about the appropriate response.

I’m not sure there are three levels (yet) on inequality, but we definitely have (a) right-wingers denying that inequality is rising and (b) denying that anyone is denying the rise in inequality, but attacking any proposal to limit that rise.

You might ask, how is it possible to take such mutually contradictory positions? And the answer is, it's very easy if confusing the debate is your job.
Tags: , ,

What does a famous actual Marxist think of the OWS protests?

A couple of weeks ago, I was quoting some pearl-clutching editorial at even-the-liberal New Republic that was shocked! shocked! I tell you, shocked! that Marxist academic and former Yugoslav democratic dissident Slavoj Žižek had made spoken to the Occupy Wall Street crowd in New York and suggested they try to "imagine the end of capitalism". The New Republic editorialist was horrified.

Žižek did a commentary on the European version of Occupy Wall Street, the indignados of Greece and Spain, Shoplifters of the World Unite London Review of Books 08/19/2011. The immediate topic was this past summer's London riots, which is different the organized protests of the indignados/OWS. But he does discuss the latter. To be fair, his take was more specifically on the anti-austerity protests in Greece and Spain, and this was before the OWS protests as such had started. Here is his comment, which leans toward academicese:

But one should also avoid the temptation of the narcissism of the lost cause: it’s too easy to admire the sublime beauty of uprisings doomed to fail. Today’s left faces the problem of ‘determinate negation’: what new order should replace the old one after the uprising, when the sublime enthusiasm of the first moment is over? In this context, the manifesto of the Spanish indignados, issued after their demonstrations in May, is revealing. The first thing that meets the eye is the pointedly apolitical tone: ‘Some of us consider ourselves progressive, others conservative. Some of us are believers, some not. Some of us have clearly defined ideologies, others are apolitical, but we are all concerned and angry about the political, economic and social outlook that we see around us: corruption among politicians, businessmen, bankers, leaving us helpless, without a voice.’ They make their protest on behalf of the ‘inalienable truths that we should abide by in our society: the right to housing, employment, culture, health, education, political participation, free personal development and consumer rights for a healthy and happy life.’ Rejecting violence, they call for an ‘ethical revolution. Instead of placing money above human beings, we shall put it back to our service. We are people, not products. I am not a product of what I buy, why I buy and who I buy from.’ Who will be the agents of this revolution? The indignados dismiss the entire political class, right and left, as corrupt and controlled by a lust for power, yet the manifesto nevertheless consists of a series of demands addressed at – whom? Not the people themselves: the indignados do not (yet) claim that no one else will do it for them, that they themselves have to be the change they want to see. And this is the fatal weakness of recent protests: they express an authentic rage which is not able to transform itself into a positive programme of sociopolitical change. They express a spirit of revolt without revolution.
In other words, they don't have a clear message! Exactly one of the criticisms that FOX News, Republicans and CNN airhead Erin Burnett made of OWS!

I'm not familiar enough with Žižek to have an idea of which of the million varieties of Marxism most influence him. But that part of his commentary reminds me of a definition I once heard of Trotskyists: they're the people who support revolution everywhere except where there's one going on.

Now, I wouldn't quarrel in this case with the literal meaning of Žižek's judgment, "They express a spirit of revolt without revolution". And the fact that he did show up to speak to OWS presumably indicates he thinks the movement is significant.

But it also illustrates how an elaborate revolutionary ideology can serve an above-the-fray attitude that discourages rather than invites engagement. Gee, they don't have a full-blown political party with long position papers on how they will solve all problems immediately upon taking power! How can a self-respecting, a very self-respecting, important Marxist intellectual take them seriously?

I admit my reaction to that essay is colored by having read this account of a conference where Professor Žižek appeared: Michael Sayeau, The Fifth International: n+1 covers the London Conference, "On the Idea of Communism" n+1 04/22/2009. But here is how he concludes his London Review essay:

The situation in Greece looks more promising, probably owing to the recent tradition of progressive self-organisation (which disappeared in Spain after the fall of the Franco regime). But even in Greece, the protest movement displays the limits of self-organisation: protesters sustain a space of egalitarian freedom with no central authority to regulate it, a public space where all are allotted the same amount of time to speak and so on. When the protesters started to debate what to do next, how to move beyond mere protest, the majority consensus was that what was needed was not a new party or a direct attempt to take state power, but a movement whose aim is to exert pressure on political parties. This is clearly not enough to impose a reorganisation of social life. To do that, one needs a strong body able to reach quick decisions and to implement them with all necessary harshness. [my emphasis]
It's true that the Spanish indignados and the larger indignado movement that OWS represents aren't the same as a set of Leninist parties ready to seize power and expropriate the expropriators. But apart from the non-insignificant matters of the desirability and the feasibility of such a seizure of power, in this context it becomes a doctrinaire way of dismissing a protest movement that has changed the political dialogue in the Western democracies, at a moment in time when the mass political parties of left and right  proved incapable of defending the interests of the working majority against the plutocrats.

If OWS and the democratic movement generally can block destructive actions by parties left and right, such as cutting Social Security and Medicare benefits in the United States, that will be a substantial progressive achievement.

It is obvious that to have a government that can represent the majority interest effectively against the Money Power, as the Jacksonians called it, the majority would have to have a political party or party coalition working effectively on their behalf.

But that doesn't mean there's no role for protest movements outside the political party structures proper. As dogmatic as today's Republican Party is, wealthy factions like that of the Koch brothers do represent a kind of inside-outside strategy; if they decide that the Party establishment is insufficiently subservient to their interests, they have various organizations, think tanks, donation channels, etc., that can bring pressure on recalcitrant members. (Even in the most rigid authoritarian party, a Marxist intellectual like Žižek would presumably be the first to recognize that there would still be contradictions among the supporting factions.)

What the United States and the European democracies need right now is a progressive movement that is substantially independent of the left parties but which can bring effective pressure to bear on them in the form of lobbying, mass mobilizations like OWS, and primary challenges to Blue Dogs such as the challenges Blue America promotes.

Žižek's August comments are a reminder that even people with a worldview that emphasizes the inevitability of social and political changes can be taken by surprise by the ones that actually occur. Some are more disappointed than others when that occurs. Some are actually glad to see it!

Tags: , ,

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Oakland police honor (?!) Iraq War veteran at Occupy Wall Street confrontation

The Twitter feed for In These Times names the injured man in this video as "Two time Iraq War Veteran, Scott Olsen".



The YouTube information gives the date of the event as 10/25/2011 and links to http://www.ktvu.com/video/29587714/index.html as the original. We don't see in the video what blooded Olsen's face and evidently left him unable to get up and walk away. We do see the police very obviously prevent other protesters from coming to the aid of the wounded man, although other demonstrators eventually do carry him away.

Tags:

Tuesday, October 25, 2011

Krugman on the Republicans' all-over-the-map attacks on Occupy Wall Street

Paul Krugman, looking at the strange assortment of attacks the Republicans are directing at the Occupy Wall Street movement, explains it this way (Say Anything 10/25/2011)

The key to understanding this, I’d suggest, is that movement conservatism has become a closed, inward-looking universe in which you get points not by sounding reasonable to uncommitted outsiders — although there are a few designated pundits who play that role professionally — but by outdoing your fellow movement members in zeal.

It’s sort of reminiscent of Stalinists going after Trotskyites in the old days: the Trotskyites were left deviationists, and also saboteurs working for the Nazis. Didn’t propagandists feel silly saying all that? Not at all: in their universe, extremism in defense of the larger truth was no vice, and you literally couldn’t go too far.

Many members of the commentariat don’t want to face up to the fact that this is what American politics has become; they cling to the notion that there are gentlemanly elder statesmen on the right who would come to the fore if only Obama said the right words. But the fact is that nobody on that side of the political spectrum wants to or can make deals with the Islamic atheist anti-military warmonger in the White House.

Strap yourself in; this is not going to be fun.
Tags: , ,

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Steve Walt on Occupy Walt Street and the democratic moment of 2011

Steve Walt seems to think we're experiencing a very significant manifestation of what Jerry Brown calls a "democratic moment". In Riding the wave of discontent Foreign Policy 10/18/2011, he's ready to declare this something like a world-historical moment, though he doesn't use that exact term. And this from a guy who is so cautious he doubted the Tunisia protests that kicked off the Arab Awakening would spread outside Tunisia's borders! (Unlike a lot of other foreign policy honchos, he quickly acknowledge his mistake.)

Speaking of the current state of information technology, he writes that it:

... allows events and ideas to spread much more quickly. As a result, demonstrators in Cairo can watch what's happening in Tunis and imitate it, and then other people in other countries get the idea that protest can be effective, even if their particular grievances are somewhat different. And so it spreads, as the radical idea of ordinary people taking action against the seemingly impregnable becomes increasingly contagious. Plus, each group can learn from each other and feed off the sense of being part of a larger process, instead of feeling like isolated and powerless individuals with scant hope of success. This sort of thing has happened before in world history (e.g., in 1789, 1848, 1919, 1989, etc.), but never in so many far-flung and widely different contexts.
He's a tad inconsistent on his historical comparisons, earlier including 1968 among them: " This wave of political contagion is more widespread than the "velvet revolutions" of 1989 (though not yet as significant), and perhaps the nearest analogue would be wave of youth-revolutions and upheavals that occurred back in 1968."

One of the historical problems/issues around the worldwide protests in 1968 is what was it that made them such a global phenomenon, affected so many different countries. Norbert Frei in 1968.Jugendrevolte und globaler Protest (2008) gives this question quite a bit of attention, without coming to a firm conclusion. I hope I'll be around in 40 years to look back and wonder why things happened the way they are happening in 2011. Hegel's famous metaphor for his view that we could only understand the real significance of historical periods only when they were passing from the scene is a reminder of our limitations of fully appreciating what's happening before our eyes: "When philosophy paints its gray on gray, then has a form of life grown old, and with gray on gray it cannot be rejuvenated, but only known; the Owl of Minerva first takes flight with twilight closing in."

So I don't know if the Owl of Minerva has taken wing yet on whatever this is that's happening. But Steve Walt is pretty impressed:

There is, of course, a deeper taproot to all this. As my colleague Jenny Mansbridge reminded me in a superb talk I attended last week, (and which will be published next month in PS), the present combination of economic inequality and political gridlock is fatal to the proper functioning of democratic orders. In a capitalist democracy, corporate interests tend to be wealthier than the rest of society, and the state is the only actor powerful enough to intervene to prevent corporate interests from going too far and exploiting their position. This is what happened in the Gilded Age and again in the Roaring 20s, which eventually led to the Progressive Era and later the New Deal.

But if the political system is gridlocked, then the state cannot act quickly or decisively to retard corporate power. Even worse, as corporate interests grow stronger they tend to acquire greater political power (and especially when a tame Supreme Court helps them, as it did in the Citizens United decision). Instead of just hamstringing the state, corporate interests can get it to enact laws that favor them even more. The result will be rising economic inequality and precisely the sort of irresponsible and unregulated behavior that led to the Great Recession of 2007.

Put these three things together, and you have a recipe for global protests in very different countries. Despite the many differences between conditions in the United States, in Greece, in Egypt, in Syria, in Israel, or elsewhere, what unites the 2011 wave of global protest is the shared belief that the People in Charge do not know what they are doing, care more about their own wealth and well-being than they do about the common weal, or are simply too spineless and shallow to do what at least a few of them secretly know to be right.
That Citizen's United decision, one of the worst and most irresponsible in the history of the Supreme Court (right up there with Dred Scott and Bush v. Gore), really may turn out to be a legal decision that contributes greatly to a major political turning point, just as Bush v. Gore should have been.

I don't remember the last time I saw anything about our Democratic President Barack Obama mentioning the Citizen's United. But if he thought it was the menace to democracy that this guy did, he would be raising hell about it constantly:



Wow! He really calls the seriousness of this ruling out:

This ruling strikes at our democracy itself.

I can’t think of anything more devastating to the public interest.

Wouldn't it be great to have a guy like that for President?

Tags: , ,

Monday, October 17, 2011

Why do conservatives bash Aljazeera? Here's an AJ report on Occupy Wall Street featuring two conservative bobbleheads

Aljazeera English in this report demonstrates that they can do a 24-minute news report that rivals FOX News for bad reporting. This is Mike Hannah anchoring an episode of Inside Story dated 10/17/2011 at YouTube, "Demanding 'economic justice'":



The first few minutes are a half-decent news summary on the worldwide solidarity demonstrations with Occupy Wall Street this past weekend. It does seem to give undue attention to rowdiness in Rome.

The groaner lines start quickly. At about 3:35, the AJE reporter makes the rather remarkable statement that the purpose of the Glass-Steagal act was to give the Federal Reserve the right to regulate interest charged by banks. Whether or not Glass-Steagal affected that, the key regulatory component of it was the separation of investment banking from commercial banking. You can make pretty theoretical cases out of the air on whether regulation of probelms arising from their combination is possible without that. But the experience of both the US and Europe these last 10 years tells me that allowing them to be combined is as bad as an idea as it was when Glass-Steagal was first enacted.

Then they bring on two (and only two) commentators to discuss the protests and their significance, both of whom parrot standard bobblehead Republican economic talk. Bobblehead 1 is Charlie Wolf of the Daily Mail. Bobblehead Charlie looks like the kind of chronically constipated sort who wears his jackboots to bed.

Bobblehead 2 is Sam Bowman, who looks to be about 19 years olf from something called the Adam Smith Institute. I'm guessing he was severely traumatized by reading an Any Rand novel just as he hit puberty; this is known to have severely retarding effects on adolescent mental development.

Both the bobbleheads seem to be particularly disturbed that some of the protesters use mobile phones and post on Twitter. Somehow this is supposed to make the protesters contemptible hypocrites. Would the two Bobblehead Brothers really give them more respect if they were all people who lived "off the grid" like the Unabomber? ROTFLOA, as they say on the Internet.

Bobblehead Charlie at about 5:50 begins working himself up for an orgasm with this:

I think for the majority of them, and I don't say this disparagingly towards them, but they are useful idiots. [A reference to Lenin's description for liberals - meant to be disparaging] I, I understand and I empathize there are people out of work and times are tough. But I think they are being used and, as Sam Bowman said, it is a rather inchoate, diverse, uh, protest. It really makes no sense. It, ruh, you can't get anywhere politically as to what they want.

However, the masses aside, the quote-unquote useful idiots, [Bobblehead Charlie really likes that one] are being controlled by a bunch of people who have some very nefarious means and desires, as you just listed, on wanting to change the Constitution of the United States. That's an anathema to the thinking of the United States. They want to turn it into some kind of Communist, or socialist, Marxist, uh, uh, entity. That's not going to happen.
Bobblehead Charlie offers no proof whatsoever for this latter charge, except "as you just listed" (see below), nor does he describe the "very nefarious means and desires" of those people who he says (against without a shred of evidence) are controlling this now-worldwide protest movement.

Bobbblehead Charlie is just regurgitating John Birch Society boilerplate, of course. I wonder if he knows the Soviet Union doesn't exist any more?

It's hard not to be completely sarcastic about this kind of stuff. Amending the Constitution is anathema to Americans? His ulcers would probably start acting up if he were to here that the very first Congress quickly sent Constitutional Amendments to the states, where they were quickly approved, becoming the Bill of Rights. They include that Second Amendment that our Republicans claim to love so much.

The Constitutional change to which he refers was reported by the anchor starting around 2:45 said that some protest group called the General Assembly of New York City, of whom I've never heard before, suggested some specific demands for the protests to adopt. One is "the imposition of a Robin Hood tax," which he describes as a tax on financial transactions (i.e., a "Tobin tax", from the late Nobel laureate James Tobin who long advocated it). They also called for "re-writing the Constitution", which he presumes is a plan to "put forward a new, progressive US Constitution by the year 2020". The final demand was to "reinstate the Glass-Steagall Act", which as I mentioned above he bungles describing. He didn't mention Communism, socialism and Marxism being part of that group's demands. Nor did such demands appear in the opening minutes during the news report. (I believe I saw a Ché Guevara t-shirt, though. Oh, Miss Mellie, bring the smelling salts, quickly!)

Starting around 3:40, Hannah interviews a Mark Bray, who is identified as a spokesperson for Occupy Wall Street and one of the organizers of the group. Unlike Bobblehead Sam Bowman, he not only looks old enough to have face hair, he actually has a nicely-trimmed beard. Mark says:

Well, fundamentally what we're looking for is economic justice. [Lawdy, lawdy, bring me those smellin' salts!!]

We want to create a society where the needs of the vast majority of the people are prioritized over the profits of a small number of corporations which have an undue influence on the organization of our society.

And, moreover, we're looking for a more democratic structure, where the people can actually hold those officials that make these decisions accountable. Those are the two fundamental things we're looking for.
Even Bobblehead Sam was a little embarrassed by his Bobblehead Brother's rant about Communism conspiracy. But he seems to think it's the Tea Party protesting on Wall Street, worrying about bailouts and gubment regulation.

The Bobblehead Brothers make David Brooks looks like an actually sensible person!

Tags: ,

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

The New Republic's editors show once again why they are smug and clueless Very Serious People

I feel like a rant along the lines of the statement attributed to Robert Frost that liberals are the people who are so open-minded they can't take their own side in an argument. But before I can do that and focus on the proximate target of the rant, I pretty much have to explain some background.

The US term "liberal" can be confusing, and not just because the Republicans and their fellow travelers use it as an insult term. In Europe and Latin America, liberals are advocates of something like "laissez-faire" economics, i.e., for deregulation and against government social programs. Those same liberals may also be serious civil libertarians and advocates against xenophobia and racial discrimination. They come out of the classical liberal tradition identified by the "free markets, free men" slogan, except that present-day version of those liberals can be strong advocates for women's rights, too. The "free markets" part draws from the tradition of classical economists like Adam Smith and David Ricardo and neo-classical ones like Alfred Marshall. The political reform part of that tradition draws from thinkers like John Stuart Mill.

The current usage of "liberal" in the United States goes back to the post-First World War period when pro-labor politicians, thinkers and activists wanted a way to distinguish themselves from the Progressives, which then tended to be middle-class reformers of the "good government" sort, and from the socialists of various stripes. The Socialist Party actually had gained some traditional political clout in some places in the US prior to the Great War. Skipping forward to today, the terms liberal and progressive are sort of merged, although the more pro-labor, anti-Wall Street people tend to refer to themselves as progressives to distinguish themselves from liberals.

Inside the Oxycontin haze of the Rush Limbaugh bubble in which the thinking of today's Republican Party resides, "liberal" is synonymous with "socialist" which is synonymous with "bad", or rather "evil". Inside the OxyContin Bubble, they've been regularly telling each other for the past 20 years that liberal are liars, liberals are fools, liberals hate America, liberals hate God. Mad Annie Coulter's latest book-length pamphlet hating on liberals is called Demonic: How the Liberal Mob Is Endangering America. Mad Annie's anorexic, semi-secular variation on the notion isn't really that far from the belief of Rick Perry's close political friends in the New Apostolic Reformation that the Democratic Party is literally controlled by a giant demon named Jezebel.

Of course, if you try to word things in a way that might make sense inside the OxyContin Bubble, you wouldn't be able to say anything meaningful of substance about a policy issue. So while we have to be aware of the looniness that now dominates Republican Party thinking and language, we can't let it stop us from talking in plain language.

Now to the real existing world of real existing liberals. What put me in the rant mood was this editorial from the editors of The New Republic, Protests and Power: Should liberals support Occupy Wall Street? 10/12/2011. The whole thing sounds like some self-satisfied prig sniffing at the amateurishness of anyone who actually cares enough to actually participate in the political process. This kind of sneering is exactly the same kind that has been direct at labor unions since their beginnings in the US in the 1820s or so.

The authors are especially fastidious over associating in any way with anything that might sound a little Commie to anyone:

One of the core differences between liberals and radicals is that liberals are capitalists. They believe in a capitalism that is democratically regulated - that seeks to level an unfair economic playing field so that all citizens have the freedom to make what they want of their lives. But these are not the principles we are hearing from the protesters. Instead, we are hearing calls for the upending of capitalism entirely. American capitalism may be flawed, but it is not, as Slavoj Zizek implied in a speech to the protesters, the equivalent of Chinese suppression. "[In] 2011, the Chinese government prohibited on TV and films and in novels all stories that contain alternate reality or time travel," Zizek declared. "This is a good sign for China. It means that people still dream about alternatives, so you have to prohibit this dream. Here, we don't think of prohibition. Because the ruling system has even oppressed our capacity to dream. Look at the movies that we see all the time. It's easy to imagine the end of the world. An asteroid destroying all life and so on. But you cannot imagine the end of capitalism." This is not a statement of liberal values; moreover, it is a statement that should be deeply offensive to liberals, who do not in any way seek the end of capitalism.

Zizek is not alone. His statement is typical of the anti-capitalist, almost utopian arguments that one hears coming from these protesters.
Slavoj Žižek not only has one of them suspicious foreign-sounding names. He's an academic who admits to being a more-or-less Marxist philosopher! He writes books with spooky-sounding titles like Looking Awry: An Introduction to Jacques Lacan through Popular Culture. Well, it sounds scary if you're a prig afraid of anyone associating you with dirty hippies. Because, you know, that Jacques Lacan is some kind of French intellectual or something. Žižek was even once a member of (gulp!) an actual Communist Party. From his biography page at the European Graduate School website:

Up until October of 1988 Slavoj Žižek was an active member of the Communist Party of Slovenia. He quit during the protest against the JBZ-trial. He was not alone in this protest, he quit along with thirty two other public intellectuals with origins in Slovenia. Slavoj Žižek was involved with the Committee for the Defense of Human Rights a social movement fighting for democracy in Slovenia. In 1990 the first free elections were held in Slovenia. At this time Slavoj Žižek ran for President aligned with the Liberal Democratic Party.
But, hey, this academic suggested that his audience might try to "imagine the end of capitalism." Oh, Miss Mellie, bring me smellin' salts! Lawd have mercy, ah thank ah'm gonna faint dead away!

That, by the way, is the only example the TNR editors give of what they describe as " calls for the upending of capitalism entirely".

But, hey, I hear on CNN that some of these hippies dress up in funny costumes and play bongo drums. No, we can't take them seriously like we can the Very Serious People at The New Republic. The diligent liberal prigs at TNR even found video of an earnest protester saying, "The point of this general assembly is to kick-start a democratic process in which no singular human being is inherently more valuable than any other human being." Why that's just so shocking because it, uh, well, why is that supposed to be shocking?

The TNR editors also find other dangerous totalitarian tendencies:

When someone speaks, he or she pauses every few words and the crowd repeats what the person has just said in unison. The idea was apparently logistical - to project speeches across a wide area - but the effect when captured on video is genuinely creepy.
Less fastidious guardians of Respectability might have noted that the Wall Street protesters adopted this technique, which they call a human megaphone, because they liberal-minded policy in the financial capital of the Greatest Country in the History of the World ... wouldn't let them use a megaphone. I saw a video of Michael Moore speaking to the protesters who were using the human megaphone technique to transmit his message to the larger crowd. It didn't strike me as creepy. But then I've been in real live protests and even organized a few myself. And I don't aspire to be one of the Very Serious People.

But I'm very relieved to know that the editors of even-the-liberal-New-Republic are Very Serious People. We won't see any of them out there protesting in public against Wall Street abuses where they might see some real live union member or somebody who doesn't think the Obama Presidency is the best of all possible worlds.

Tags: , ,

Sunday, October 09, 2011

Monday, October 03, 2011

Occupy Wall Street video reports

From The Young Turks (Current TV) 09/29/2011, Cavalry Arrives for Occupy Wall Street:



From Countdown with Keith Olbermann (Current TV), Occupy Wall Street: Bernie Sanders calls for real reform 09/30/2011:



Also from Countdown with Keith Olbermann, John Samuelsen: Why TWU is joining the Occupy Wall Street protest 09/30/2011

From ITN News, OCCUPY WALL STREET: Demonstrators and police clash on Brooklyn Bridge 10/02/2011:



From Aljazeera English, Hundreds held in anti-Wall Street protests 10/01/2011:



From Think Progress, AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka Backs Occupy Wall Street 09/30/2011:



Tags:

Sunday, October 02, 2011

Occupy Wall Street: a "democratic moment"?

Years ago I heard Jerry Brown use the phrase "democratic moment" to describe those occasions on which genuine people's power asserts itself to change the course of the normal operations of governmental and political institutions.

Because even the most representative institutions can become blind and corrupted. And the blindness of the ruling elites in Europe and the United States right now is staggering, with their destructive austerity politics in the middle of a depression. A more recent Jerry Brown quote, this one from 2011, is relevant here:

You look back at history and all the elites, the ruling families of Europe in 1914 were feeling pretty good about themselves. And yet, it wasn't just a few months into the summer when they began what was an absolute catastrophe. So blindness is compatible with good breeding, good education and good relationships. Well, we don't even have that now in much of Washington.
It will take "democratic moments" to drive the political systems of the West back onto a more constructive track. In the US, a more fundamental transformation is needed than in Europe. For a genuine democratic renewal in the United States there will have to be a major rollback of the national security state and the foreign policies, wars and police state measures and mentality that are so much an integral part of it.

It may be in part the immensity of the problem that led some liberals to scoff at the scruffy hippies that started the Occupy Wall Street protests. That, plus lazy thinking and foolish illusions about the seriousness of the undemocratic turn of politics in the US and Europe.

The coincidence in time of the Occupy Wall Street protests with the Obama Administration's assassination of American citizens Anwar al-Awlaki and Samir Khan solely on the order of the President without even the pretense of charges, trials or the most minimal Constitutional procedures has affected how I understand both issues. Coincidental as the timing was, the two coming together highlight the increasingly outlaw conduct of the US government and the inability to date of the "democratic moment" which occurred in 2008 with the election of Barack Obama as President to restore the rule of law, progressive economic policies and a greater degree of social justice. And the steps that this Administration has made in that direction are in great danger of being reversed by a Republican President being elected in 2012 thanks to the failures of the Obama Administration, particularly its irresponsible embrace of austerity-based, Herbert Hoover economics.

The Occupy Wall Street protests are now being endorsed and joined by organized labor and have sparked solidarity protests all across the country.

Donna Jablonski reports for the AFL-CIO Now Blog Next Up Summit Supports Occupy Wall Street Protests 10/02/2011. He quotes from a declaration of the AFL-CIO Next Up Young Worker Summit in Minneapolis MN:

The world in which we live isn't working for the vast majority of people. The top 1 percent controls the economy, makes profits at the expense of working people, and dominates the political debate. Wall Street symbolizes this simple truth: a small group of people have the lives and livelihoods of working Americans in their hands.
And he provides a video from the conference:



Sounds good to me!

Current TV has an archive of Occupy Wall Street video reports.

Tags: