Showing posts with label pentecostalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pentecostalism. Show all posts

Friday, April 12, 2013

Conservative Christians and stigma around mental health issues

The famous conservative evangelical pastor Rick Warren's song Matthew committed suicide recently. (Joseph Serna, Rick Warren son 'probably not' owner of gun in suicide, cops say Los Angeles Times 04/10/2013)

This news brought to public light the reality that many conservative Christians retain a sense of deep shame and denial in relation to mental illness and other clinical psychological problems.

This article from a site called A Holy Experience, What Christians Need to Know about Mental Health 04/08/2013, by Ann Voskamp, who identifies herself as "a plain Ann without even the fanciful 'e', wife to The Farmer, mama to six, and honestly, I'm a bit of a mess."

Her article is about a family, presumably her own, in which the mother suffered severe depression in connection with cancer. She starts off with a "Dear Church" introduction saying, "Cancer can be deadly and so can depression. So can the dark and the shame and the crush of a thousand skeletons, a thousand millstones, a thousand internal infernos."

The mother required in-patient treatment for depression. She writes, "My Dad, he had told me that if I told, it'd slit us all." I really did a double-take on that line. I came up with a benign interpretation that it's probably a typo, and that she meant to say her father was warning that if the kids told people Mom was in a psychiatric ward, it would "split" up the family.

She does reflect how such a charge from a parent can feel to a child:

So much for believing the Truth will set you free. So much weight for a wide-eyed nine-year-old.

So I locked lips and heart hard so no one knew about the locked wards and the psychiatric doctors and why my mama was gone and it’s crazy how the stigma around mental health can drive you right insane."
Her post is apparently to tell people it's all right to recognize that people have psychiatric problems that has nothing to do with some spiritual state of sin:

There are some who take communion and anti-depressants and there are those who think both are a crutch.

Come in close — I'd rather walk tall with a crutch than crawl around insisting like a proud and bloody fool that I didn’t need one. [emphasis in original]
But in that formulation and in the rest of the post, what comes through is a remaining heavy sense of stigma. "the dark and the shame" that she speaks of in his introduction.

Are there things going on in religious communities that promote such attitudes above and beyond ordinary fear and lack of medical understanding?

There are a few obvious things. One is that Christian fundamentalists are by definition anti-science in some important sense, although one of the characteristics of fundamentalism is to argue against science in terms that mimic the techniques of science. Another is that fundamentalist Christianity has a mystical core related to the Pietist tradition that assumes that people can have a direct interaction with God that is in theory is not different than material, "real-world" experience. And that mystical union of the believer with God is generally assumed to produce general happiness in the believer's life, making any chronic disturbance of the kind represented by depression or other clinical conditions a sign of inadequate faith or a damaged relationship with God.

Third, there is a belief in faith-healing. The faith-healing services are particularly associated with the Pentecostal tradition, but Catholics also have faith healers and faith-healing services, which depending on the parish can lean more to the superstitious or to the abstract-spiritual side. But non-Pentecostal fundamentalists and even more mainstream of liberals church-goers generally have some sense that praying for the sick at least may result in a more-or-less supernatural recovery.

Finally, there the Pentecostal (or neo-Pentecostal if you prefer) practice of deliverance, i.e, exorcism of demons. Which can be especially potent in promoting denial and shame when it comes to mental illness. This is largely but not exclusively the province of neo-Pentecostals in the Christian world. The Catholic Church has a relatively discrete but active deliverance ministry, although there are Church rules that put formal constraints on how its practiced. (Though it's not particularly relevant here, the encouragement of exorcism is associated with hardline reactionaries in the Catholic Church.)

Stephen Hunt in Managing the demonic: Some aspects of the neo‐Pentecostal deliverance ministry Journal of Contemporary Religion 13:2 (1998) addressed the deliverance ministries as they were practiced at that time, with particular reference to the British context. (You probably need access to a library database for the link to work.) He does a good job of explaining how in some contexts, "deliverance" can be a relatively benign ritual that owes such to the "encounter group therapy" and he notes that "early exponents were influenced by Carl Roger's work." In a well-managed small group therapy of more of a workshop type, "This can be quite cathartic in the sense that deliverance appears to sometimes marry confession with a rigourous self-directing therapy." And he cites one such example:

For instance, on one occasion at a healing centre, I witnessed Paul (not his real name), a young middle-class Anglican charismatic, stand up before some 70 people and admit to pre-marital sex with his wife. He was subsequently delivered of a spirit of 'guilt' and supported by a long period of counselling.
Leaving aside for a moment whether its really healthy to encourage a sense of guilt about boinking your partner before marriage, that does sound benign and kind of sweet. If he had confessed to have been sleeping with her best friend before their marriage, that might have had more upsetting consequences, I'm guessing. He also mentions that in the deliverance ceremonies, "The concern with the previous sexual behaviour of believers by those advancing deliverance reaches almost the point of obsession."

But then there's the full-blown holy-roller, Linda Blair-in-The Exorcist type of ceremonies. And those are considerably less benign. Where the encounter group context may use the notion of evil spirits mainly as a kind of metaphor for the frustrations and problems of life, the holy-roller version treats demons as kind of parasitic infections in the body and soul of the victim.

No, this is not what a virus or a mental health problem looks like

It's interesting to note here that while non-Pentecostal fundamentalists tend to regard exorcism as something to stay the hell away from - sorry, I couldn't resist! - the "literalist" reading of Scripture to which they adhere, i.e., reading the Christian Bible as though it were a history and science text, pretty much leaves them stuck believing in the reality of demonic possession in some way. That is, as a literal infection by some kind of foreign body, not as a metaphor.

I'll just mention in passing here that the early Christians came to regard the gods of "pagan" religions as evil spirits. The Greek word "daimon" (demon) in the New Testament derived from a Greek word for "divine"; the transformation is a case of a word taking on an opposite meaning, and probably reflects in part the notion of regarding foreign gods as not just foreign and unfriendly but actively evil. More mainstream Christians don't have much trouble in regarding the demon stories in the New Testament as meant to describe a religious outlook rather than as medical texts.

As Hunt describes, in the Pentecostal or "charismatic" religious world, demons are not only viewed as causing mental illness like some kind of germ. He notes that "in the hands of charismatic" there is an emphasis also on "demons as representing negative emotions." And in the fundamentalist/Pentecostal world, all sorts of emotions, including very normal and healthy responses to real conditions, are stigmatized as sinful

If the belief in literal demons seems superstitious, which it certainly is, it may seem that such a belief in itself is a sign of some clinical problem. But presumably for most people who believe it it, it's something that seems creepy and scary and they would shy away from deliverance ceremonies of the more extreme type. However, the literal belief that demons can cause mental illness almost certainly makes it much easier for such believers to fear mental illness as something uniquely evil and frightening. And if you do hold such beliefs and find yourself having serious emotional/mental problems, you not only have to worry about the clinical problems. You have to worry that your body and soul are being inhabited by a malignant spirit that is trying to drag you down to Hell.

These fearful associations are encouraged by the holy-roller deliverance ceremonies, which Hunt notes "can be extremely violent with a great deal of shaking or involve lying on the floor with limbs thrashing about," and also "a great deal of weeping." The ceremonies may also involve those seeking deliverance "screaming, crying, sobbing, belching, laughing, and screeching." Kind of like an episode of American Horror Story Asylum. Hunt observes dryly, "This is particularly unnerving for the outsider to witness." And it undoubtedly has similar effects even though they assimilate the experience in a different way.

Which brings me to this article by Frank Viola, 3 Christian Responses to Mental Illness; Which One Is Most Biblical? Christian Post 04/11/2013, addressing concerns among conservative Christians raised by Matthew Warren's suicide:

Throughout my years of being involved in various and sundry Christian movements and denominations, it seems that Christians understand mental disorders in one of three chief ways:

1. Mental illness is demonic in origin. So the antidote is to cast out the demons that are causing it.
2. Mental illness is psychobabble. There's no such thing as a "mental disorder." All so-called mental illnesses are just sinful behaviors. So the antidote is for person to repent and get right with God.
3. Mental illness is a physiological disorder. The brain is a physical organ just like the heart, the thyroid, the joints, etc. Thus if someone has panic attacks or bipolar disorder or schizophrenia or chronic depression or ADHD, they have a chemical imbalance in the brain, not dissimilar to a hyperthyroidism or high blood pressure or arthritis.

I cut my teeth on a movement that promoted #1. I've met many people who believed #2. But I believe #3 is often the case.
The tone of his article is telling. Instead of telling his readers, look, people, don't be conned by some exorcist who wants to hear lurid stories about your sex life and who may be looking to get some nookie out it somehow, recognize that it's the 21st century and there are ways to get help for clinical psychological and psychiatric problems. And if your fellow church members thinks there's something shameful about that, then you can forgive them for their stupidity and superstition after you or your family member get treatment for depression, or alcoholism, or drug addiction, or bulimia, or whatever it is. If your local exorcist drives out a common-cold demon, the cold will probably magically go away in a week or two. But you also might want to get some cough drops and be careful not to let it develop into a pneumonia demon while you're waiting.

But alcoholism or schizophrenia, hey, don't be a fool about it!

Viola doesn't tell his readers that. In fact, he even says explicitly, "Sometimes demons are involved in mental illness, but not always."

No, demons are not involved in mental illness. And you're doing no one but exorcist hucksters any good by promoting that view.

Viola's article is revealing, though, in that he seems to actually be encouraging his readers to recognize that mental health problems are health problems that require medical treatment. Yet he seems to have believed that the conservative Christian audience that the Christian Post serves needed a reassurance that he was down with the fundamentalist belief that demons cause health problems like some kind of virus or germ.

Fundis are always whining that somebody is persecuting them for their Christian beliefs. The truth is in America that people are pretty much free to believe any dang fool thing they want about religion or anything else. But when religious beliefs lead people to neglect real healthy problems out of fear or superstition or shame, that can do real harm. And American Christians who promote such beliefs should expect other Christians to call them on it, both for promoting something dangerous and for giving the religion and bad name in doing so.

Tags: , , ,

Wednesday, September 07, 2011

Dominionist Christians in their context, for better or worse

Christian dominionists like to control their own marketing. And despite supposedly being bold in their witness for Jesus, they don't want to let their little lights shine before the unbelievers (Democrats, non-Christians, Catholics, most Protestants). It's not exactly timidity. They know that can't justify their positions in terms that most Americans and most Christians in the US or anywhere would support. So they mealy-mouth a lot.

Al Bundy - Christian dominionist theologian?
Our stumbling press is willing to facilitate the mealy-mouthing, since that's largely what our star pundits generally do anyway. So there's a discussions going on now in places that actually deal realistically with the Christian Right, like Talk to Action and Religion Dispatches, as to what the correct way to talk about the dominionists is. I understand why serious journalists and scholars like to be careful about their terminology. For scholars in particular, their work involves making careful distinctions.

This piece from Religion Dispatches is an especially good one on the topic, Beyond Alarmism and Denial in the Dominionism Debate by Sarah Posner and Anthea Butler 08/29/2011. They make an essential point in reference to the Christian Right in general and the Pentecostal New Apostolic Reformation (NAR), a group that suddenly came to new (and to them unwelcome) public attention with Rick Perry's big prayer rally:

... theological disagreements among these folks are largely inconsequential from a broad political perspective; the overarching Christian nation ideology, along with opposition to secularism, LGBT rights and abortion rights, and favoring public prayer and Ten Commandments and so forth are unifying.

But the idea that the NAR in particular — as opposed to the broader apparatus and movement the religious right has built over four decades — is somehow, in a vacuum, more powerful, or more authoritarian, or more threatening to democracy is a view that is far too narrow, ahistorical, and uninformed. [my emphasis]
What makes Posner's and Butler's piece especially good is the way they describe the networks of relationships that participants in neo-Pentecostal groups experience and how the influence of the leadership enters into that experience. As Posner puts it, this is a "crucial point here that I think is frequently overlooked by some people who focus too hard on the NAR rhetoric without contextualizing it: how people actually live and experience these movements." Their description doesn't minimize the ugly side of the neo-Pentecostal experience. It puts it in its actual context as lived by its believers.

Butler slips in a kind of disclaimer that I've seen several times lately in similar articles by people who actually know the Christian Right. She says the lack of decent research by mainstream reporters "has also led to a whole cottage industry of those who write about dominionism, the NAR, and other theocratic movements from the opposite perspective: It’s taking over everything." Now, I'm willing to believe there are people exaggerating one aspect or another of this phenomenon. But who is she talking about? I've seen this kind of comment several times lately without those guilty ones supposedly doing this being referenced, linked or specified. Without knowing who they are talking about, this kind of comment isn't helpful. In fact, it sounds suspiciously like knee-jerk rhetoric to reassure the un-assurable that the speaker/writer isn't one of those stereotypical libruls who supposedly hates "people of faith" and their faiths, too.

But, as I said, Butler's and Posner's description of the neo-Pentecostal lived experience is an exceptionally good summary. Butler:

... there are streams of people crossing each other, and what is happening can have a multiplicity of meanings. That is how to think about the NAR, dominionism, all of these movements that people are involved in. In evangelical and Pentecostal churches, most people have a home church they identify with, but you have a favorite pastor or evangelist that you listen to occasionally. Studying scripture means you don't just read the Bible, you read devotional books, and books designed to help your spiritual walk or the church broadly construed. That is the problem with focusing in only on NAR and dominionism. If you don't know the everyday context of how people, churches, and organizations deal with these broad-based movements, it can sound like a vast conspiracy theory.

People who are in that web don't often recognize differences, or they don’t care about them. They care about their spiritual lives, and that's what keeps these movements going. They can go from one meeting to the next if they have the funds to do so, and the highs are good. Who doesn’t want to go to a meeting that feeds your soul where you meet like-minded people?

All of the groups are enmeshed in a symbiotic web. These evangelists', apostles’, and leaders’ messages are the commodity, and you have to buy the books, conferences, and other materials in order to get the blessings. I know that will seem distasteful and a caricature to some, but these events are well-attended, and at a hundred bucks a person, revenues from book and DVD sales. Conferences and meetings like Lou Engles’ The Call are not just prayer meetings, they are Christian marketplaces, with all sorts of spiritual wares being sold. [my emphasis]
Posner amplifies that description:

... if you’ve ever been to a neo-Pentecostal conference or revival you’ve seen this sort of thing. And as [Carlton] Pearson's biography clearly demonstrates, if you give up that central idea that there is a hell (and hence a Satan), you'll be banished from not only friendships, but the lucrative ministries that Pearson himself helped to create.

All that said, there are different ways that people experience this, or faith healings, or other performances you find in these environments. Not everyone is in lockstep, when you sit down and talk with them. I remember vividly the 2007 event at Gimenez's church in Virginia Beach—this was before John Gimenez passed away—and there was quite a lineup of different preachers (I mean entrepreneurs)! I remember Lou Engle was on what I might, looking back, call a prophecy bender: rocking, as he does, and really doing an extended sequence on some dream he had about Jerusalem. People were wandering out of the sanctuary, as I did, and I was chatting with a woman in the hall. She commented about she hadn't seen him preach in a while. And she seemed pretty unimpressed with this one.

I point this out only to emphasize how these individual players do not necessarily always enrapture the audience; I've seen this at various events. On the other hand, I've seen others, like Rod Parsley and Kenneth Copeland, have the audience eating out of their hands (and also putting money in their hands).

These events are, like I said, performances that are carefully staged and mapped out; there may be a series of speakers who seem like they are reacting spontaneously to what's happening, moved by the holy spirit. But it's carefully orchestrated, along with mesmerizing music, for maximum impact. It's big business.
However, I suspect this ability to understand and empathize with rank-and-file participants may also contribute to the temptation to downplay that nuttiness and cultish aspects of these movements. Posner, for instance, expresses misgivings that some (unnamed) "people have been distracted by focusing too much on bizarre statements Perry’s prayer friends made (the Statue of Liberty is a demonic idol, Oprah is the harlot of Babylon, and so forth)."

But this stuff is also standard fare in the neo-Pentecostal subculture. I just clicked on the website of Charisma, a leading Pentecostal magazine, and found this article on the front page: J. Lee Grady, Unraveling the Power of Witchcraft—One Warlock at a Time 09/07/2011. Ole Jaylee apparently believes literally in the ability of witches and warlocks to magically affect people:

Just a year ago, Victor Hugo Perez Vargas was a leader in Peru’s vast but secretive occult movement. His strange ability to curse people and cause accidents seemed to be increasing. He was being mentored by a well-known satanist master and he attended witchcraft conferences. ...

Victor, who is 36, was drawn into this occultism as a teenager in the city of Moyobamba, where friends convinced him to have sex with dogs in order to receive supernatural power. Witches told him to do this so he could hear better and see in the spiritual realm. After the perverse initiation rites, he began to hear voices—and he discovered his ability to kill people with his words.
I'm sorry. People who can swallow tales about warlocks causing accidents by cursing and initiation rites involving dog-fucking are just superstitious and gullible. If it hurts their feelings to see or read someone saying that, then they just need to grow up. Ole Jaylee has his head stuck in the 19th century:

Victor’s transformation showed me how the Holy Spirit is working in Peru, where occultism has been a tradition ever since ancient Incas sacrificed children on altars to their sun god. Today, occultists from Africa, Europe and the United States attend witchcraft gatherings in Peru because they consider the country a central power center for New Age energy.
He goes on to describe an exorcism allegedly performed on the warlock's girlfriend, a description evidencing less critical thinking ability than the average illiterate backwoods hick can muster.

He goes on to describe his conversion to a brand of Christianity evidently as superstitious as the most dim-witted occultist. "I had a vision of the feet of Jesus," the redeemed and exorcised former warlock says. It reminds me of an episode of the old TV series Married...With Children in which Al Bundy has a vision of God's shoes and starts to manufacture and market them, only to later to discover they were the shoes a deceased fellow shoe salesman had invented and had never been able to sell, either.

And Pentecostalists like Jaylee often track in National Inquirer fantasies like this:

Observers say witchcraft is growing in Peru today, and human sacrifice still occurs—although it is rarely reported. (Several weeks ago, a girl’s dismembered body was found in Mayobamba.) Teresa Gomez believes this is all a last-ditch effort by satanic forces.

"These satanists want to take over the nation of Peru," she says. "Witches come here because there was so much blood sacrifice during the Inca times." She also noted that poor families, especially in jungle areas, have been known to sell their children to be sacrificed in occult rituals.
Substitute "Jews" for "poor families" and you've got the bad old medieval (and later) "blood libel" about Jews sacrificing Christian babies. This is a mean, superstitious, and militant ignorant brand of Christianity. I don't see any good reason for other Christians, journalists, scholars, Democratic politicians or anyone else who's not crouching in a corner trembling in fear of flying demons and witches' curses to treat this kind of nonsense as anything other than a sad, degenerate brand of religion that will certainly do most participants more harm than good.

Ole Jaylee is at least not so mired in the 16th century he doesn't have a Twitter account, where you can read confessions like this: "I hope this doesn't disappoint anyone...but I like Easy Listening music. It calms me." I don't know, Jaylee, sounds like you've got one of them thar Guy Lombardo demons or something. You'd better lock yourself in a room and listen to Christian contemporary for 24 hours straight. It may not git rid of yore Easy Listenin' demon, but it will strip you brain badly enough that you're unlikely to be able to hurt anybody. Also not be able to write your silly column.

Tags: , , , ,

Friday, February 27, 2009

Religion and politics: Sympathy for the exorcist

Bobby, why are you doing this to me?

Bobby Jindal got panned by even Republicans and very Republican-friendly media outlets that you would have expected to hype his memorably poor nationally-televised response to Barack Obama special State of the Union address on Tuesday. Then Rush jumped in to express his man-love for Bobby and demand that the Republican dittoheads fall in line.

Max Blumenthal in Bobby Jindal's Secret Past The Daily Beast 02/25/09 writes about an article Jindal did about an exorcism in which he participated as a young man.

During his years at Brown University, Jindal pursued his Catholic faith with unbridled zeal. Jindal became emotionally involved with a classmate named Susan who had overcome skin cancer and struggled to cope with the suicide of a close friend. Jindal reflected in an article for a Catholic magazine (called “Beating a Demon: Physical Dimensions of Spiritual Warfare”) that “sulfuric” scents hovered over Susan everywhere she went. In the middle of a prayer meeting, Jindal claimed that Susan collapsed and began convulsing on the floor. His prayer partners gathered together on the floor, holding hands and shouting, “Satan, I command you to leave this woman!”

While under the supposed control of satanic demons, Susan lashed out at Jindal and his friends. “Whenever I concentrated long enough to begin prayer, I felt some type of physical force distracting me,” Jindal reflected. “It was as if something was pushing down on my chest, making it very hard for me to breathe ... I began to think that the demon would only attack me if I tried to pray or fight back; thus, I resigned myself to leaving it alone in an attempt to find peace for myself.”

Toward the conclusion of what Jindal called “the tremendous battle between the Susan we knew and loved and some strange and evil force,” Jindal and his friends forced Susan to read passages from the Bible. "She choked on certain passages and could not finish the sentence 'Jesus is Lord.' Over and over, she repeated "Jesus is L..L..LL," often ending in profanities," Jindal wrote. Finally, evil gave way to the light. "Just as suddenly as she went into the trance, Susan suddenly reappeared and claimed ‘Jesus is Lord.’ With an almost comical smile, Susan then looked up as if awakening from a deep sleep and asked, ‘Has something happened?’"
(Warning: This is definitely one of what Dave Neiwert calls "long-form" blog posts.)

The article to which Max refers is Beating a Demon: Physical Dimensions of Spiritual Warfare by Bobby Jindal New Oxford Review Dec 1994. The version linked appears to be the full article; the article appears to the same as the original; the first three paragraphs match to the partial text available at the New Oxford Review Web site. For $1.50 and the risk of getting an additional source to spam you, you can get the original online. This following cheesy graphic of what is presumably a demon's head is featured at the magazine's site:

I'll refrain from "demonizing" the political opposition by restraining myself from comparing that graphic to the heart of any recent Vice President.

The indicates that "some of the names ... but none of the details" had been altered by Jindal. I actually dug up the original at the library and that intro is in the original. But the demon's head is missing and they actually have a pretty good graphic there, I mean if you like St. Michael and the Dragon pictures, which I do.

By the way, for you apocalypse fans, that scene depicts the story in the middle of Revelations, Chapter 12. That chapter is one of my favorite stories in the Bible.

But back to Jindal's story.

David Brody of the Christian News Network also provides most of the text of the article in Bobby Jindal's Story about Demons and Spiritual Warfare 02/24/09. Brody is cautious about characterizing the story. But he seems to be offering an alibi against Jindal being persecuted by that Christian-hatin' librul press:

I’m sure some will read this and afterwards try to label Jindal as someone with strange religious views. But in typical Jindal fashion, he dissects the situation intellectually. He experienced something that clearly had a major impact in his life. Now if he does run for President, this incident will be under the microscope and he’ll be put on the couch by the mainstream media.
I do think it's a legitimate issue for a Presidential candidate to have to address. After all, he wrote the account himself and published it in a religious journal. It's perfectly legitimate for journalists, if there are any real ones left, to quiz him about how he analyzes that same situation now.

I have an alternative explanation of events that, on the one hand, is probably more generous than most Democrats are inclined to be about young Bobby's college experience. On the other hand, my interpretation doesn't say anything very good about Jindal's adult ability to process real-world information.

To begin, I'll say that I find both the Pentecostal and the still-to-be-found style of beliefs in demons and demon-possession not only superstitious but dangerous. In the context of the Catholic Church - and Jindal in the article is speaking from his own Catholic perspective - validating and promoting exorcism and belief in literal demons is considered downright reactionary theologically. The Church still has the rite of exorcism "on the books", i.e., it's still permitted as an official Catholic procedure. But it is also required to be done in the context of medical care and psychological evaluations. Like "alternative medicine" is often understood, it is seem as a kind of comforting supplement to individuals suffering from certain kinds of medical disorders.

Still, even in the milder official form the Catholic Church officially approves, it implies a belief that there are demons floating around that infect people's bodies kind of like germs. There are lots of very practical problems with seeing things that way.

For one, there's no actual evidence of any such thing. Second, it's a silly-ass version of Christian theology to take the Biblical references to demons that way. It encourages a terrible mystification of emotional conflicts. It can lead people to neglect needed medical treatment. It can make the person who's suffering from some kind of physical and/or emotional problem think it's happening because they're a bad person. At the same time, it encourages a childish ethical attitude: it's not me that's having lustful thoughts, it's a demon attacking me. Belief in demon-possession is the kind of thing that cult leaders can and do exploit.

Having said all that, the ritual Jindal describes in that article is really not something that unusual in the context of Protestant Pentecostalism. Check out Matt Taibbi's article Jesus Made Me Puke: Matt Taibbi Undercover with the Christian Right Rolling Stone Online 05/01/08. The article is something you don't see nearly often enough in American journalism these days: an actual investigation.

In this case, what Taibbi was investigating was the church of John Hagee, the warmongering Christian Zionism whose endorsement John McCain finally wound up rejecting during the 2008 Presidential primaries. The culminating moment of the weekend retreat was a exorcism ceremony in which participants were encouraged to physically vomit out their demons. Aside from being a good read, it puts the exorcism ceremony into its Pentecostal ritual context. The version Taibbi describes does not have the safeguards that the Catholic Church officially requires.

The point I'm making here is that even though the ritual may attract crazy people, and even though it can do real harm to participants, in the context of Pentecostal (or "charismatic") Christianity, believing in it or participating in it can't be automatically regard as "crazy".

My alternative take on what Jindal describes of his college friend "Susan" goes like this. It's my suggestion for an alternative framing, assuming that he has related the facts more-or-less accurately.

Bobby and "Susan" (which may or may not have been her real name) were conservative Christian college students. They were friends and attracted to each other. Both of them subscribed to religious beliefs that told them it was a sin to have sex before marriage. Probably even a sin to risk "heavy petting".

But youthful hormones are also persuasive things. He describes Susan's post-exorcism thoughts about her experience:

Susan, who had experienced visions and other related phenomena as a child, thought her intense flirting with guys and straying away from God had led to this punishment. [my emphasis]
He also relates that Susan "had other guys in her life". Let's assume that Susan had preserved her virtue for marriage to her future divinely-selected husband. But, taking into account the Pentecostal language and assumptions, she's pretty much saying explicitly that she felt terrible guilt because of her own sexual desires.

I'll save my rant about the barbaric effects of religious sexual repression for another post.

Now, I'm not trying to suggest any kind of scandal for pure young Bobby. I assume he was preserving his virtue, as well. But he says that both a previous girlfriend and Susan accused him of not being able to love. How might Susan have come to such a conclusion? Well, Jindal describes visiting her in her dorm room to have a talk about her troubled feelings after a bump on her head had been diagnosed (according to her) as skin cancer:

Against my will, I found myself reaching out and holding her hand. I promised to stand by her forever, to be the rock against which she could lean, to accompany her to the doctor's office and the operating room. I never stopped to think of the significance of my valiant pledges; I assumed any good friend would react similarly in the same situation. How could any de­cent person turn away a desperate woman in such need? ...

During Susan's next wave of tears, I found my­self putting my arm around her to provide both physical and emotional support. We were soon sit­ting on the bed next to each other, and I told her a fairy tale. Instead of tackling all of her problems at once, we took each individual concern -- e.g., up­coming finals -- and magically solved it. Her prob­lems began to seem insignificant and our ability to overcome adversity soon assumed heroic propor­tions. We were soon laughing, and despair was defi­nitely vanquished, at least for the night. We were both startled to find my arm around her shoulder, but she asked that I continue to hold her for just a few moments longer. I happily complied and we embraced her problems away; along with my sooth­ing words, the simple gesture of a hug was enough to bring peace to Susan's heart for one night.
Dude! For a devoutly chaste Pentecostal woman, this is aggressive seduction! You're sitting on the bed. In her room. Alone. Hugging. Things are very emotional. If you stayed on the bed for a while longer, you might have gotten around to other things besides just hugging. And if, you know, one thing led to another, then "it just happened". And if you didn't use birth control, that just shows you didn't really intend to sin.

But instead they (apparently) stayed pure. And for a month, Susan didn't want to have much to do with Bobby. She even broke a dinner date and Bobby didn't talk to her for a week. I don't blame her. Here she was putting her immortal soul in peril to get Bobby into the sack and he wouldn't go for it.

I'm really going to have to start working on that post about the barbaric effects of religious sexual repression!

The exorcism took place after they had made up, in a chaste kind of way. It was a prayer meeting to prepare her for the cancer operation for the bump on her head. So she staged a possession scene that looked weird and scary to Bobby. But was familiar to her from seeing Pentecostal exorcisms herself and/or from movies and TV. As described in Max Blumenthal's account quoted above, she suddenly came out of "possessed" situation and professed to remember none of what had gone on during the session. The memory loss is consistent with the ritual, but unlikely.

Jindal related that after the exorcism was over, people in the group seemed particularly concerned about what he thought of the experience. This indicates that in some way, the other participants saw the exorcism as a kind of recruitment/conversion experience by which Bobby would be initiated into accepted of distinctive Pentecostal/charismatic beliefs and rituals.

A final interesting tidbit. Susan claimed after the operation that the doctors found no cancer, though the biopsy had indicated cancer. She took this to mean that along with the exorcism, she was also healed from her cancer. This kind of story is completely routine in the faith-healing racket. According to Occam's Razor - by which the simplest explanation that accounts for all the facts is probably the best - this presents the same less-miraculous possibilities that most such claims do. The diagnosis could have been mistaken. Susan could have been lying about either the diagnosis or the doctor's report back to her. Jindal in the article didn't indicate that he had done further investigation, such as requesting to see the doctor's actual records.

I don't see anything in this account that can't be reasonably explained in terms of the convergence of raging youthful hormones, fear of illness, sexual repression, school stress and normal religious and emotional issues of the transition to adulthood, all filtered through Susan's very religious, Pentecostal understanding of the world. Add in the non-improbable possibility that some of her other boyfriends weren't so chaste as Bobby, maybe a pregnancy that had to be aborted, and the presence of malignant supernatural forces isn't required to understand what he describes.

Jindal was 23 when that article appeared and working for the prestigious McKinsey & Co. consulting firm. It's certainly reasonable to ask if he still takes so credulous a view of that experience. And it's not a matter of general "judgment" or "character", two of the Establishment press' favorite hooks on which to hang any silly story they want to flog. But if he runs for President, we should know how much he supports real science. And, on the other side, to what extent his very conservative political and (apparently) religious view incline him to support anti-birth-control, anti-stem-cell-research and pro-"creationist" pseudoscience.

Tags: , ,

Wednesday, January 18, 2006

2006: A Pentecostal anniversary

This year is the 100th anniversary of the beginning of the modern Pentecostal or "charismatic" movement. Adherents might suggest it began very soon after the Resurrection of Jesus.

The occasion should at least provide some interesting informational pieces on Pentecostalism. Although it's similar in theology to fundamentalism, the two groups tend to define themselves separately. The Pentecostalists tend to have a more emotional style of worship. They practice rituals like speaking in tongues, laying on of hands, exorcism and faith healing that fundamentalists regard as weird.

Also, Pentecostals are known for having much livlier music. Elvis Presley grew up going to a Pentecostal church and absorbing their brand of Gospel music. His long-time backup singers, the Jordanaires, were a Gospel group.

Here are a couple of articles on the anniversary.

The House of the Spirit: Tucked away in a neighborhood near Echo Park, the mostly forgotten birthplace of the Pentecostal movement still attracts the faithful by Mark Kendall Los Angeles Times 01/08/06

Kendall's article reminds us that one of the distinctive features of Pentecostalism at the start was it's inter-racial congregations:

It was at the Bonnie Brae house that believers set off a movement of exuberant worship that has grown from a scoffed-at sect to the world's fastest-growing branch of Christianity, with more than 500 million participants around the globe. And as Pentecostalism explodes in Latin America, Africa and parts of Asia, the fire hasn't gone out on Bonnie Brae Street. ...

"You can feel the presence of God wherever you are," he says, standing in the uncluttered living room, its walls bare white, "but in this place, this is where the Holy Spirit fell."

That was in 1906, shortly after an African American preacher named William Seymour came to Los Angeles from Texas. Raised in a Catholic home, Seymour was drawn as an adult to a fledgling sect that stressed the need for believers to receive "baptism in the Holy Spirit," as described in the Bible's Book of Acts. His notions about speaking in tongues didn't go over well at the storefront church in L.A. that he had been asked to lead as pastor; within days of his arrival, the church kicked him out.

Before long, he was leading Bible studies in the house on Bonnie Brae Street, owned at the time by a husband and wife who were believers. And on April 9, 1906, some in Seymour's group began speaking in tongues. The word traveled fast, and worshipers flocked to the house. One day, so many gathered for a service that they spilled out onto the front porch, which collapsed under their weight.

Seeking larger quarters, Seymour and his congregation moved to a building on Azusa Street in what now is Little Tokyo. Daily services at the Apostolic Faith Mission drew hundreds of ecstatic worshipers inspired by the New Testament story of the Day of Pentecost, when believers gathered in Jerusalem after Christ's ascension to heaven and received the Holy Spirit, descending as "tongues of fire."

The press mocked the Azusa Street crowd; "Weird Babel of Tongues," declared a headline in the April 18, 1906, issue of the Los Angeles Times. "New Sect of Fanatics Is Breaking Loose." Many local Protestant church leaders opposed the new movement, not only for its enthusiastic style but also for its multiracial makeup and African American leader. "Here was this little upstart, racially integrated mission that was making all these outlandish claims about God's power and about miracles," says Cecil M. Robeck Jr., a church history professor at Pasadena's Fuller Theological Seminary, a Pentecostal himself and the author of the upcoming book "The Azusa Street Mission & Revival: The Birth of the Global Pentecostal Movement." The L.A. newspapers were "scandalized by the fact that white folk and black folk are hugging and kissing and praying together." (my emphasis)

This piece in the fundamentalist/evangelical oriented Christian Post delicately avoids specific mention of some of the more controversial Pentecostalist practices:
Pentecostals Prepare for 100th Anniversary of the Azusa Street Revival: More than 100,000 Christians from around the world are expected to gather in Los Angeles in April for a week-long celebration of the 100th anniversary of the Azusa Street revival Christian Post 011/18/06

Prominent theologians consider Azusa Street "the birthplace of the modern Pentecostal movement," that now boasts more than 600 million adherents to the tenets of Pentecostalism. According to a recent Lausanne report, Pentecostals/Charismatics make up 26.3 percent of the population in the United States with 79 million members. In addition, the U.K.-based Christian research institute noted in its January statistic that out of all Christian groups, Charismatic independent churches are growing the fastest, at 2.4 percent per year. [Critical reserve about these figures is probably in order. - Bruce.]

The denominations that follow the Pentecostal tenets include the Church of God in Christ, Assemblies of God and the International Church of the Foursquare Gospel. ...

More than 150 well known Pentecostal leaders from around the world are confirmed to preach or teach [at the April celebration], including Bishop T.D. Jakes of The Potter's House in Dallas, Texas; the Rev. Paula White of the Church Without Walls in Tampa, Fla.; the Rev. Jack Hayford of Living Way Ministries in Van Nuys, Calif.; and Pastor Kenneth Copeland of Kenneth Copeland Ministries in Fort Worth, Texas.