Showing posts with label peter schrag. Show all posts
Showing posts with label peter schrag. Show all posts

Friday, January 07, 2011

Leading columnist/historian of California notices that Jerry Brown was ahead of his time

Gosh, who would have thought that? I mean, aside from anyone who bothered to take a look at what Jerry Brown accomplished and the ideas he advocated during his first Governorship and since.

But I'm not putting down this column, which is by Peter Schrag, Jerry Brown seems better suited to run today's California than in the '80s Sacramento Bee 01/07/2010. He "gets" Jerry's perspective better than 99% of those who write about him. He even managed to notice the influence on Jerry's thinking of the Christian philosopher Ivan Illich (which long-time readers of this blog have heard of more than once):

Brown, who like many of his contemporaries once had at least one hesitant foot in the counterculture of the 1960s, was deeply influenced by the anti-institutional ideas of his friend Ivan Illich. Illich, ordained as a priest, later an influential scholar, challenged all conventional ideas of progress – in institutionalized schooling, in modern health care, in technology – as forces that alienated the individual from his own ability to live a confident, self-reliant life.

In his moving tribute after Illich's death in 2002, Brown talked about how Illich took him back to the "Ignatian indifference to secular values of long life, fame and riches," he had learned as a Jesuit seminarian.

Both in his life and his work, Brown said, Illich "bore witness to the destructive power of modern institutions that 'create needs faster than they can create satisfaction, and in the process of trying to meet the needs they generate, they consume the earth.' "

Brown has always seemed torn between the ambitions of practical politics and his didactic, moralistic impulses. He left the seminary, but the seminary never quite left him.
This is what I always tell people who are puzzled by Brown's perspective. He's a Jesuit who went into politics.

On Brown's being ahead of his time, Shrag writes:

At times during those years [his first Governorship], his talk about an era of limits and the need to lower expectations seemed just a little – well, preachy. Similarly "small is beautiful," the British economist E.F. Schumacher's metaphor for the design of human-scale appropriate technologies that Brown embraced, often seemed almost un-American at a time when "bigger is better" was the rallying cry of national progress.

But limits – whether economic, environmental, political or military – hardly seem so strange now, even if the state, and other states and the nation as a whole, didn't face the monster budgetary crises they now struggle with.
And he recalls that Jerry understood that California needed to be on the leading edge of technological development and environmental business; this orientation wound up generating Jerry's most famous nickname:

Something similar is true about what you could call Brown's futurism. Thirty years ago Brown's fascination with the advanced and at times esoteric ideas of people like the great anthropologist and cybernetician Gregory Bateson, who he would appoint to the University of California regents, seemed too far out for the earthy practicalities of everyday government and public administration. Brown even flirted with the idea of a California space program. Chicago columnist Mike Royko's famously called him Governor Moonbeam.

During his last tenure as governor, Brown created a California Office of Appropriate Technology (which was promptly shut down by George Deukmejian when he succeeded Brown in Sacramento), and pushed hard for many of the model environmental and energy efficiency programs and policies for which the state has since become globally famous.
Tags: , ,

Wednesday, October 29, 2003

California Politics: Closing the $ Gap

The headline writer called it "Mississippification". But Alabama is the only other state Peter Schrag's column mentions.

Alabama, Mississippi, one of those Southern states. Yankees get confused about these things sometimes. :) You have to be patient with them.

But Schrag's column is a good one. He talks about how the recently-defeated tax referendum in Alabama was actively supported by Bob Riley, the conservative Republican Governor. Riley was criticized by Grover Norquist, an antitax zealot who currently has a lot of influence on the national Republican Party. He said, "Every Republican governor who thinks of raising taxes next year will walk past Traitors Gate and see Bob Riley's head on a pike."

Schrag uses Alabama's story as a lead-in to talking about the possible option For Schwarzenegger of using a large bond issue in California to close the current state deficit, coupled with "some sort of tight cap that would allow state spending to increase by no more than population and the rate of inflation."

The fact that such a measure is being seriously discussed is another sign of how common the idea has become in California that we could find some magic formula to put government on auto-pilot and solve the state's problems that way.
Schrag's analysis in part, is that, even with a $20 billion bond issue:

However it's done, it would, in the absence of any significant revenue increase, drive the state's battered public services further toward the bottom. If Schwarzenegger, as promised, were really to protect spending for K-12 education (spending that even now is woefully unequal to the state's own standards) the failure to increase revenues would almost necessarily suck more out of higher education and health programs for the poor, whose budgets have already been severely cut, and, very possibly, support for local governments as well. ...

Which is to say that the possibility of making California's school resources commensurate with the high standards we've set, or increasing access to the state's colleges and universities for the hundreds of thousands of additional students who'll be seeking places, is almost nil.
Tags: , ,

Wednesday, October 22, 2003

California politics: What will Schwarzenegger do?

Schwarzenegger has so far given few signals about how he will proceed when he takes office. One of his campaign issues was to oppose the new law allowing undocumented immigrants to obtain state driver's licenses. This is a bellweather issue for many Latino voters. Since California agribusiness is completely dependent on illegal immigrants, I'd sure feel safer knowing the ones driving met minimal qualifications.

Schwarzenegger may also wind up bringing the structural crisis in state government closer to a head by trying to "go to the people" via referenda. Using referenda as a bludgeon against the Democratic Legislature could provoke the kind of confrontation that would put constitutional reform on the public agenda. Peter Schrag writes:

[T]here's a good chance that if the Legislature drags its feet on Schwarzenegger's reform program, he'll become the ringmaster for a wave of ballot measures all his own: a new measure imposing spending limits on the state budget and one shifting control of the decennial redistricting of Assembly, Senate and congressional seats from the Legislature to some kind of independent commission.

Schwarzenegger has already said that, if necessary, he wouldn't hesitate to go over the heads of the Legislature and directly to the voters. ...

[H]owever charmed some futurists are by the notion of some sort of instant electronic democracy, where people vote constantly on every conceivable question, the world is too complex, the need for expertise, deliberation and compromise too great, for good government to survive such a system.

Democracy may be in danger from domination by money, political venality and systemic dysfunction, but it's in at least as much danger from solutions that quick-fixers have tried to impose. Representative democracy needs restoration, not replacement.
Tags: , , , ,