Showing posts with label roy moore. Show all posts
Showing posts with label roy moore. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 02, 2018

Roy Moore, the ick factor and the evidence (3 of 3)

This is the last of three posts on the Roy Moore scandal material. My purpose has been to look at what the public knew before the election and what was a reasonable way to process it.

I'm personally was and am "tribally" inclined to think Roy Moore is a scumbag. And I've thought so ever since his Ten Commandments monument sideshow in the early 2000s. But the Washington Post  story that initially reported his alleged molestation of a 14-year-old was well-sourced, with at least two people the complainant/accuser had talked to at the time backing up her story that she had told them she was dating an older man, one of them remembering Roy Moore as his name. And the three women who he dated when they were 16-18 added some kind of a pattern.

It seemed to me that, at a minimum, a man in his thirties who had been a Army officer in combat in Vietnam who sought out 16-year-olds to date was weirdly immature. Although according to the Post story, none of the three reported having sex with him. All four of the women were on the record with their names in making the statements. And Moore's responses weren less than convincing to anyone not drinking the special Breitbart-Limbaugh Kool-Aid concoction. Plus, one of the 14-year-old's later boyfriends said on camera a bit later that she told him about the molestation part of the story when they were together.

But our Pod Pundits couldn't even keep a well-sourced story like this straight. This Morning Joe segment treated the story of the other three women as essentially just like the story of the 14-year-old, The Choice Dems And GOP Must Make On GOP Alabama Senate Nominee Roy Moore MSNBC 11/13/2017:



One of the panel said that all four women had experienced what had to have been "the worst horrific moments of their lives, being fondled and touched by Roy Moore when they were teenaged girls." Another said "these women have been playing this on auto-repeat every day of their lives." When the real story is well-sourced and, for marketing purposes, sensational enough on its own, careless embellishments like that are unnecessary. (Is there a phrase for gilding an ugly lily?) Especially since it won't surprise anybody if more damning stories come out in the next couple of weeks. In fact, AL.com the famous attorney Goria Allred is having a news conference at 2:30 EST with another accuser reporting that Moore "assaulted her when she was a minor."

A few days after the initial report, another accuser came forward on the record in a press conference claiming that Moore had sexually assaulted her when she was 16: Dylan Stableford, New woman accuses Roy Moore of sexual assault when she was a minor Yahoo News 11/13/2017. This case described a very similar scenario to that of the 14-year-old and she showed what she said was something that Roy Moore wrote in her school yearbook.

The same day, Charles Bethea reported on people who remembered Moore's reputation as a mall crawler during that period, Locals Were Troubled by Roy Moore’s Interactions with Teen Girls at the Gadsden Mall New Yorker 11/13/2017.

By November 15, the stories of Roy Moore's fondness for actions toward women and girls that fit consistently with the patterns others had described were coming out faster than revelations about Trump associates with dubious involvements with Russians: Stephanie McCrummen et al, Two more women describe unwanted overtures by Roy Moore at Alabama mall Washington Post 11/15/2017; Anna Claire Vollers, New Roy Moore accuser: 'He didn't pinch it; he grabbed it' AL.com 11/15/2017.

November 16, one week from the original molestation story, it had reached the point where Matt Bai - also tribally inclined to be unsympathetic to Moore - was writing the following which by then had come to seem like the cautious and sensible conventional wisdom on the topic (Roy Moore fights his inner demons. It's not pretty. Yahoo News 11/16/2017):
I’m not a fan of media stampedes, generally. And I suppose it’s possible that the ever-growing list of women who have accused Moore, in highly detailed accounts, of general creepiness and outright assault on teenage girls have all been put up to it by nefarious Democratic operatives.

But I’m guessing the only ones who really believe that now are longtime, willfully blind supporters and Breitbart editors who profit from their insistence that reality is the opposite of whatever the coastal, elite media say it is.

(Related: Apparently someone operating on Moore’s behalf has been calling people in Alabama posing as a sleazy Washington Post reporter named “Bernie Bernstein” who is trying to dig up more gossip about Moore. I mean, you can’t do better than that? There are plenty of names that sound more realistic. Like “Philip Roth,” or maybe “Hank Greenberg.” Use some creativity.)
This Velshi & Ruhle segment addresseds how to evaluate claims like the ones being made against Moore, Roy Moore's Friend Mat Staver: “This Is Not The Roy Moore I Know” 11/16/2017:



There was certainly a lot of credibility in the reports against Moore. Maybe not enough to satisfy a court in a legal proceeding, I don't know about that.

Josh Marshall had a good point in this post about accountability on the larger issue of sexual harassment and abuse. (Trump Skates. But It’s Not the Press’s Fault. TPM 11/29/2017) High-profile cases can prompt action by management or employers. But in places like, say, the Republican Party, where neither shame nor fear of losing voters currently seem to be factors when Rep politicians are credibly accused of genuine bad acts, there is no accountability.

In the larger scheme of things, high-profile scandals of the Moore, Harvey Weinstein and Matt Lauer types may not do a lot in themselves to address the much wider problem. Large organizations of all kinds as well as small businesses have a strong incentive for self-protection on these things, and sweeping them under the rug is usually the prescription. That's why non-disclosure agreements on settlements are so popular. I don't know what psychological studies may say about it. But I'm reasonably sure that the Moores and Weinsteins and Lauers aren't going to be deterred from genuinely predatory behavior by obligatory annual HR presentations or by seeing other employees warned or disciplined for telling lewd jokes at work.

The decline of unions, employment-at-will laws, business deregulation generally, the increase of "precarious" jobs with more and more "independent contracting," those all make systemic solutions more challenging. I saw one report recently suggesting that the restaurant business may be the one with the largest number of sexual harassment reports. And despite the large number of chains, that's a notoriously decentralized and high-turnover business. Also in agriculture, construction, and service industries like restaurants, there are large percentages of undocumented workers who don't find it easy to use what recourses are available to citizens and legal residents. E.g., "You tell anybody about me showing you my dick in the back office and I'll call ICE to arrest your children at their school."

One thing that could be mandated legislatively with some reasonable chance of enforcement would be to somehow legally obligate personnel/human resource departments to have a responsibility to defend employees in some meaningful way. Because right now, HR departments in practice think their only job is to defend employers to the extent they can get away with it. That would probably involve some kind of more extensive auditing requirements along the lines of compliance audits in medical facilities. But that's heresy to the gospel of deregulation and "free-market" competition.

Thursday, December 14, 2017

Roy Moore, the ick factor and the evidence (1 of 2)

I'm generally reluctant to post on stories in which the "ick" factor is so high as it is on the Roy Moore alleged molestation story reported out first by Stephanie McCrummen, Beth Reinhard and Alice Crites in , Woman says Roy Moore initiated sexual encounter when she was 14, he was 32 11/09/2017.

The accusation is described in some detail there, and repeated many times since, so I won't repeat it here.

But what I'm trying to do in this post is step back and think of how news consumers can think about these stories when they emerge to come up with a critical judgment based on the facts as they are known. A lot of other material has emerged which is consistent with the accuser's claim since that original story appeared. But I'm focusing here on what was known immediately after that initial story.

As always occurs in political campaigns, an allegation like this tends to be embraced by opponents and rejected or called into doubt by supporters of the candidate being accused. I was surprised to see prominent Alabama Republicans rushing right away to saying "it's no big deal" if it happened, rather than sticking with the much safer, "This is a partisan charge from Democrats and there's no proof of it," maybe adding "it doesn't sound at all like the candidate we know." The latter defense may not be particularly admirable but it seems like it would be the more obvious one.

I'm posting on this only after the election has been completed. Because I've been a detractor of Roy Moore ever since I first heard about him. In fact, he was the subject of one of my very first blog posts, Ten Commandments Monument 08/22/2003. Re-reading it now, I much say it was pretty good.

So based on the low opinion I've had of Moore for a long time, I wouldn't have wanted to sound like I was defending him. Also, the WaPo story was consistent with what I've known about Roy Moore by the news of him over the years. It's not hard for me to imagine him having been like that in his 30s.

But on the larger matter of reading the news critically, I was initially reserved about taking the story on its face value. Moore's critics focused on the three women who were between 16 and 18 at the time Moore dated them in his thirties as support for the story about the 14-year-old. I'll have to leave it to the psychologists as to whether that is particularly consistent with the more sensational one.

But on the face of it, a man in his thirties dating 16-18 year olds may be creepy. And I would assume that at the minimum it was a sign of serious immaturity on the part of the man. Especially for someone who had served as an officer in the Vietnam War. But it's not a crime. And it's not child molestation. The three in the initial report said they never went to his house. The story included him buying them alcohol, which was a crime at the time.

But, honestly, who would think that just giving a drink to a 16-, 17- or 18-year-old forty years ago says anything significant about who a person is today?

The allegation from the woman who said Moore had molested her was from when she was 14. The Post reporters did find two friends that she had told at the time about dating an older man, one of them recalling he was named Roy Moore. And they found that the woman's story of how she had met Moore was possible, i.e., that her mother had been in court at that time and that Moore's office was just down the hall from the courtroom at the time.

So I found the story credible. And still do. But it was also forty years ago. And at least in the initial story, there was no contemporary report or record of the specifics of what she alleges happened in Moore's house. From the first WaPo story, it sounds like the victim told her friends at the time only that she was dating an older man. And that's a big reason for statutes of limitation. Memories change and become less reliable.

On the other hand, it's not easy to see how the accuser would think she had anything particular to gain from coming forward with the story, and reason to worry that coming forward could hurt her due to retaliation of some kind by Moore and/or the Republican Party.

And as important as it is to recognize the courage of women who come forth with their stories of sexual harassment against prominent and powerful figures like Harvey Weinstein, sometimes people can and do lie about these things. That's why contemporary evidence or evidence from similar cases is so important in proving allegations like this. In Weinstein's case, there were various witnesses with stories describing a similar modus operandi on Weinstein's part. And in at least some of the cases, the victims had reported it at the time to others. If a company has paid large sums to victims over harassment claims against a particular person, as with more than one famous individual at FOX News, that's also pretty strong evidence for the validity of the claims.

Whether we as the public should believe allegations like this about public figures shouldn't depend on standards as strict as civil or criminal law. Mitt Romney tweeted the day after the story broke:



But facts do matter. And like for all other kinds of news, critical scrutiny of stories like this is necessary.

Also, in the real world of politics, Roy Moore even before the WaPo report was seen as a potential political burden on other Republicans. Even Donald Trump opposed him in the Republican primary, and Trump is anything but a man of deep integrity and decency. Now, I think Romney's tweet is a perfectly sensible and fair take on the story as it was known on November 10. But that doesn't mean there isn't some conventional political calculation behind it, as well.

Terminology matters

One other point worth noting in reality-checking stories like this. It has become common in the general American vocabulary to refer to any adult of maybe 25 or older having sexual activity with someone below the age of consent as "pedophilia." Medically, however, pedophilia is defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), generally regarded in the US as medically authoritative, "defines pedophilic disorder as when an individual over 16 experiences 'recurrent, intense sexually arousing fantasies, sexual urges, or behaviors involving sexual activity with a prepubescent child or children (generally age 13 years or younger)'." (Rachel Hope Cleves and Nicholas Syrett, Roy Moore is not a pedophile Washington Post 11/19/2017)

Cleves and Syrett argue:

The outrage against the Republican Senate candidate from Alabama is entirely fitting, but the terminology is not. Moore is not a pedophile. If you believe his accusers, as we do, he is a powerful man who has serially harassed and even assaulted teenage girls.

The difference matters. Moore’s alleged crime was not a sexual orientation toward children. It was his willingness to exploit the unequal power structures of gender and age to victimize young girls who couldn’t stand up to him. To understand Moore as a monster outside medical or societal norms is to ignore the ways that his position enabled him to take advantage of his alleged victims. Much like the claims of sex addiction offered by other powerful men in recent weeks, accounting for sexual abuse with a diagnosis of pedophilia obscures the way that abusive behavior fits into our everyday sexual system that privileges powerful men to take advantage of the younger, the female and the less powerful.
Understanding mental disorders as well as crimes is important. The common colloquial use of "pedophile" for cases like Roy Moore and the 14-year-old blurs a distinction that mental health professionals regard as important.

Friday, November 17, 2017

Abortion and the Roy Moore scandal

One of the things that has struck me about the discussion of the Roy Moore scandals among self-identified conservative Christians is how their ideological position on abortion seems to trump their sense of disgust at even child molestation when it comes to voting choices.

John Archibald reports on a classmate of one of Moore's accusers who gives background information about Moore's reputation at the time he was hitting on high school girls, Schoolmate of Roy Moore accuser: He was 'creepy and icky' AL.com 11/16/2017. She seems to take the molestation accusations seriously, and she claims she also was molested as a child, though not by Moore:
"I was molested," she said. "It started when I was five years old and it went for several years. I have yet to confront this person. I've had several Christian counselors and psychiatrists and I didn't tell them until just this past year. It's been almost 50 years."

She can only imagine what it's like to see her abuser every day on TV.

"If I had to hear his voice -- whether it be on the radio or TV or see a picture of him and his name in print -- I would find the loudest and largest voice I could find to speak out," she said.

It has happened time and time again since the Roy Moore allegations began. An Arizona woman came forward after more than 60 years to talk about her abuser, and women across Alabama have done the same. Because it is a moment of change in the culture.

"It's not political," she said. "It's our lives."

But it puts her in a tough spot, because she doesn't support Doug Jones or his views on abortion.

So who is she going to vote for?

"I can't imagine voting for either one of them. I don't know. It's a horribly sad state.

"Literally."
Schoolmate of Leigh Corfman talks about avoiding Roy Moore in the mall as a teenager AL.com YouTube 11/16/2017:



Abortion was consciously used as symbolic issue by the Christian Right as it emerged in its present form in the late 1970s. Abortion was not a high priority issue for most conservative Christians until then. Conservative churches generally didn't make much ruckus about the Roe v. Wade decision when it was handed down in 1973. Not that it was an invisible issue. Legalizing abortion was a priority for the women's movement. And the Nixon-Agnew campaign in 1972 used opposition to abortion as one of several signifiers that they were opposed to hippies and lefties.

But it has now become a issue which signifies a whole wide range of morally-charged loyalties for Republicans.

This is especially notable because I've gotten to the point where it's difficult for me to believe that virtually any Republicans actually cares about the issue in the way they claim. I'll consider changing my mind when I see a majority of Republicans in Congress vote against a war on the explicit grounds that it would kill innocent "unborn babies." As all our wars do.

Have you every heard a single Republican politician or voter express concern about the "unborn babies" killed in the wars they cheer on? Me neither.

But even for someone like this woman who describes herself as a victim of childhood sexual molestation and even defends Moore's accusers against the excuse that they didn't "come forward" for 40 years, an excuse which she clearly thinks is ridiculous, cites "abortion" as her reason for (apparently) still considering supporting someone like Moore. She does mention it in the broader context of identifying herself politically as part of the "Christian conservative" tribe.

She ever states, "I am proud to say I voted for Donald Trump. Despite everything. I think it's what our country needed."

Wednesday, November 15, 2017

Electing Roy Moore - and seating him in the Senate?

Infamous theocratic blowhard Roy Moore's chances of winning the open Alabama Senate seat vacated by Jefferson Beauregard Sessions III have probably been diminished by credible accusations from two women that he sexually abused them as minors.

But who knows? It's Alabama. And a non-trivial number of voters there are telling pollsters the accusations makes them more likely to vote for him.

The truth is that the Democratic candidate Doug Jones was always a strong candidate. Even though conventional wisdom assumed - not without reason - that it would be difficult for a Democrat to win the seat.

But the unexpected turn of events with the scandalous revelations about Moore is yet another reminder of how damaging the Barack Obama/Debbie Wasserman-Schultz strategy of studied neglect of state parties and less-competitive districts has been to the Democratic Party. Even the most conventional political pundits now realized that the liberal Democrat Doug Jones has a real shot at winning the Senate election in supposedly safely Republican Alabama. If the Democratic National Committee had spent the eight years of the Obama Presidency building the state party in Alabama, they would have been in an ever stronger position to take the Senate seat in December.

It's important to keep in mind that for Obama, having the Democratic Party be non-competitive and weak in many states was an advantage. Obama seemed genuinely obsessed with bipartisanship as an end in itself. And some of his major goals were downright conservative, particularly his repeated attempts at a Grand Bargain to cut Social Security and Medicare benefits. And it's hard to forget how willing he was cave to Congressional Republicans on occasions like the "fiscal cliff" deal at the beginning of 2013. As Paul Krugman wrote at the time, "He kept drawing lines in the sand, then erasing them and retreating to a new position. And his evident desire to have a deal before hitting the essentially innocuous fiscal cliff bodes very badly for the confrontation looming in a few weeks over the debt ceiling." (Perspective on the Deal New York Times 01/01/2017)

For a Democrat like Obama eager to make those kinds of compromises and concessions, it's actually better to have a Republican majority or only a narrow Democratic majority in Congress. If bipartisanship is a goal in itself, not annoying conservative Republicans in a state like Alabama is a feature, not a bug in the approach.

There is presently a lot of speculation about whether the Republicans will replace Moore as the Republican candidate. As I understand it from the news reports, the Alabama Republican Party can withdraw its official endorsement of Moore. It's too late to take him off the ballot for the election now scheduled. But if the state party withdraws its endorsement, since Moore appears on the ballot as the Republican candidate, any votes for him in that category would be invalid. (If voters just wrote in his name, I don't know if those would be counted.) In one version of that scenario, the Republicans could get behind Jefferson Beauregard Sessions III as a write-in candidate. If he wins, he could resign as Attorney General to become Senator, then Trump could appoint a new Attorney General who could fire Robert Mueller and instead open an investigation of a series of Hillary Clinton pseudoscandals.

There has been discussion of the Senate declining to seat Moore if he wins, and much of the commentary I've seen appears to assume that's an obvious possibility. But as William Douglas reports in If elected, Roy Moore will probably take his seat in the Senate McClatchy Newspapers 11/14/2017:

Senate Republicans could try to refuse to seat Moore at all, but that could prove legally difficult thanks to the late Rep. Adam Clayton Powell, a Democrat from New York.

Powell won a Supreme Court case in 1969 after House leaders tried to refuse to seat him following his re-election because he was accused of misappropriating public funds. The justices ruled that Powell had to be seated because he met the Constitution’s age, residency and citizenship requirements to hold office.
Here is the Morning Zoo crowd today discussing the Moore race, including the Sessions option, Alabama Voters Continue Deliberation On Senate Candidate Roy Moore Morning Joe/MSNBC 11/15/2017:



At around 5:00 in the video, there is an Alabama example of what Germans and Austrians call a Stammtisch, a "regular table" where the good ole boys discuss life and politics and wimmin.

further reporting from the Washington Post: Sean Sullivan, National Republican move against Roy Moore grows — but key Alabama Republicans are not joining in 11/14/2017; Write-ins, expulsion: Roy Moore offers no easy answers for Republican Party WaPo/AL.com

Greg Garrison reports that Roy Moore was a topic of discussion at the annual state convention of Alabama Baptists, Alabama Baptists rattled by accusations against Roy Moore AL.com 11/14/2017:
The allegations have rattled pastors attending the Baptist convention.

"If he did it, we need to know that," said State Baptist President John Thweatt, pastor of First Baptist Church of Pell City. "We need to condemn it. If he didn't, then we need to know that too. There are probably some people who will believe him no matter what."

Thweatt, who has four daughters, said the denomination stands opposed to the abuse of women.

"Baptists have to stand against the abuse of women," he said. "It's not tolerable. There are no exceptions. We have to create a culture that treating women as sexual objects is not acceptable. There's no hesitance to speak against the abuse of women. But we're hesitant to speak out against Roy Moore because we don't know if it's true."

Many of the pastors here have had Moore speak in their churches or attended prayer rallies with him.

"He has denied it and I take him at his word," said the Rev. John Killian, director of the Fayette County Baptist Association, who hosted Moore speaking twice when he was pastor of Maytown Baptist Church. "I believe him. That's not the way he's lived his life for the last 25 years. It's been reputable and respectable. He's a godly man, a brilliant man. I know Roy Moore. He has a great relationship with (his wife) Kayla. That's not the guy that's (being portrayed) out there now. I believe he's a good man. I don't believe the allegations have been proven. When a brother in Christ speaks, you give him the benefit of the doubt."

The Rev. Chad Burdette, pastor of Macedonia Baptist Church in Ranburne, said he attended a prayer rally at which Moore recited Psalm 103 from memory. "Until it's proven, pastors are holding their breath," Burdette said. "If it's not, then maybe they are afraid of having a man that quotes scripture in government. Are they that afraid? Maybe they are scared of this guy who is so full of scripture. We can't cast a stone because we all have sinned. The truth always comes to the surface."
I would say that none of those quoted responses actually qualify as examples of prophetic courage.

Saturday, July 02, 2005

What would a Christian Right America look like?

Okay, so my last post was a bit light on the political content. Well, maybe in a kind of Wilhelm Reich sense it was political.

But here's an article that focuses more on the political aspects of the Christian Right.

One benefit of a group blog is that we have been able to combine our respective research staffs into a large research division. :) Marigolds2 alerted me to this article that one of our experienced researchers came across: The Crusaders by Bob Moser Rolling Stone 04/07/05.

It's a report about a February conference called "Reclaiming America for Christ." But they weren't focused on handing out pamphlets on street corners about how you will go to Hell if you don't get saved. Moser notes that they were meeting at a time in which the political clout of the Christian Right was at an unprecedented level nationwide.

But despite their unprecedented power, fundamentalists still see themselves as a persecuted minority, waging a holy war against the godless forces of secularism. To rouse themselves, they kick off the festivities with "Soldiers of the Cross, Arise," the bloodthirstiest tune in all of Christendom...
On the bloodthirstiest tune front, apparently Moser hasn't experienced "There Is A Fountain Filled With Blood." Which is actually one of my favorite hymns, thanks to Kate Campbell's rock version (!?) on her Wandering Strange album. But Moser shares some of the lyrics of "Soldiers of the Cross, Arise":

Seize your armor, gird it on
Now the battle will be won
Soon, your enemies all slain
Crowns of glory you shall gain.

Yeesh. This was a conference of Christian Dominionists. If you haven't encountered the concept, Moser's article gives an introductory glance. In this passage, he refers to James Kennedy, who I quoted in my previous post about how sex before marriage is "an uprising [sic] against God."

The godfather of the Dominionists is D. James Kennedy, the most influential evangelical you've never heard of. A former Arthur Murray dance instructor, he launched his Florida ministry in 1959, when most evangelicals still followed Billy Graham's gospel of nonpartisan soul-saving. Kennedy built Coral Ridge Ministries into a $37-million-a-year empire, with a TV-and-radio audience of 3 million, by preaching that it was time to save America - not soul by soul but election by election. After helping found the Moral Majority in 1979, Kennedy became a five-star general in the Christian army. Bush sought his blessing before running for president - and continues to consult top Dominionists on matters of federal policy.

"Our job is to reclaim America for Christ, whatever the cost," Kennedy says. "As the vice regents of God, we are to exercise godly dominion and influence over our neighborhoods, our schools, our government, our literature and arts, our sports arenas, our entertainment media, our news media, our scientific endeavors - in short, over every aspect and institution of human society." (my emphasis)
At least he didn't include the blogosphere in his list!

Moser makes a distinction between Billy Graham's brand of evangelical Christianity and the Christian Right/Dominionist version. It's an important distinction, although Graham has not always been so "nonpartisan."

As the fight over the Supreme Court takes place over the next three and a half years, this is an image worth remembering:

Activist judges, of course, are precisely what the Dominionists want. Their model is Roy Moore, the former Alabama chief justice who installed a 5,300-pound granite memorial to the Ten Commandments, complete with an open Bible carved in its top, in the state judicial building. At Reclaiming America, Roy's Rock sits out front, fresh off a tour of twenty-one states, perched on the flag-festooned flatbed of a diesel truck, a potent symbol of the "faith-based" justice the Dominionists are bent on imposing. Activists at the conference pose for photographs beside the rock and have circulated a petition urging President Bush to appoint Moore - who once penned an opinion calling for the state to execute "practicing homosexuals" - to the U.S. Supreme Court.
And the following is notable, since it involves the spokesman on social policy of the Southern Baptist Convention, the largest Protestant denomination in the United States:

It helps that Dominionists have a direct line to the White House: The Rev. Richard Land, top lobbyist for the 16-million-member Southern Baptist Convention, enjoys a weekly conference call with top Bush advisers including Karl Rove. "We've got the Holy Spirit's wind at our backs!" Land declares in an arm-waving, red-faced speech. He takes particular aim at the threat posed by John Lennon, denouncing "Imagine" as a "secular anthem" that envisions a future of "clone plantations, child sacrifice, legalized polygamy and hard-core porn."
I think the Rev. Land may be confusing Karl Rove with the Holy Spirit.

David Neiwert is one of the best contemporary writers on radical-right movements in America. And he has written quite a bit in his Orcinus blog about Christian Dominionist thinking and activity. In this post, The undertow of totalism Orcinus blog 05/11/05, he quotes author and former war correspondent (and serious student of religion) Chris Hedges on the Christian Right (my emphasis):

If you look at the ideology that pervades this movement, and the term we use for it is dominionism, it comes from Genesis, where the sort of founders of this movement, Rousas Rushdoony and others, talk about how God gave man - this is a very patriarchal movement - dominion over the land. And dominionists believe that they have been tasked by God to create the Christian society through violence, I would add. Violence, the aesthetic of violence is a very powerful component within this movement. The ideology, when you parse it down and look what it's made up of, is essentially an ideology of exclusion and of hatred. It is a totalitarian ideology. It is not religious in any way. These people quote ... selectively and with gross distortions from the Gospels. You cannot read the four Gospels and walk away and tell me that Jesus was not a pacifist. I'm not a pacifist, but Jesus clearly was. They draw from the Book of Revelations the only time in the Bible, and that's a very questionable book, as Biblical scholars have pointed out for centuries, the only time when you can argue that Jesus endorsed violence and the apocalyptic visions of Paul. And they do this to create an avenging Christ.
At some point here, I hope to talk more about alternatives ways of understanding the Book of Revelations. Which is one of my favorite books of the Bible. (Maybe I shouldn't be naming my favorites like this.) For one thing, it's a great story! It's also a Christian "power vision" that does not have to be understood in terms of warfare in the physical world, as the Christian Right insists on doing.

Speaking of the Christian Right/dominionist vision of the kind of America they want (see Rev. Kennedy's quotation above), Hedges says with particular reference to the "Justice Sunday" hatefest of earlier this year (my emphasis):

And this is an America where people like you and me have no place. And you don't have to take my word for it, turn on Christian broadcasting, listen to Christian radio. Listen to what they say about people like us. It's not a matter that we have an opinion they disagree with. It's not a matter of them de-legitimizing us, which they are. It's a matter of them demonizing us, of talking us - describing us as militant secular humanists, moral relativists, both of which terms I would not use to describe myself, as a kind of counter-militant ideology that is anti-Christian and that [is] essentially propelled by Satan that they must destroy. Listen to their own language. You know, when in "Justice Sunday," listen - you know, I urge everyone to go back and look closely at what James Dobson, head of Focus on the Family, said. He talked about Roe v. Wade causing the biggest holocaust in the 20th century. There is a frightening kind of revisionism and a kind of moral equation of a magnitude that, you know, having lived through disintegrating states in Yugoslavia and other places, essentially divides - destroys the center, divides the American public, and creates a very dangerous and frightening culture war. And that's what these people are about.
The Hodges quotations are taken from a 05/05/05 "Democracy Now!" program, The Christian Right and the Rising Power of the Evangelical Political Movement.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, September 03, 2003

Git Thee Behind Me, Vulcan

Vulcan Statue, Alabama State Fairgrounds 1910

Even if Alabama Supreme Court Justice Roy Moore is a cynic, certainly not all of his supporters are. Some of them are sincere about wanting to use the government to cram their brand of Christianity down the throats of the rest of us, including other Christians, who don't understand the affairs of the Almighty in exactly the way they do.

I had occasion last week to read a few issues of the Baptist Record, the newspaper of the Mississippi [Southern] Baptist Convention. (It doesn't seem to be available online.)

A piece in the 08/21/03 issue by Tony Martin is pretty lightweight. He relies on such arguments as suggesting that the statue of Vulcan in Birmingham, Alabama, not be allowed on public land because the ancient Romans once worshipped him as a god.

He doesn't mention it, but maybe Tony is also scandalized by the statue's famously nekkid hiney. John Ashcroft would melt the thing down for that reason alone!

At the risk of giving undeserved credibility to an airhead argument, I'll point out that Vulcan is a god only in a long-dead religion. Now, I realize that somewhere in California or Ashville, NC, there are probably a few Vulcan worshippers. But I doubt that any Church of Vulcan has applied for tax-exempt status in the US.

Government promotion of the dominant religion is a whole different thing.

Okay, maybe there is a Church of Vulcan. I'm thinking from Ashville.

- Posted by Bruce Miller 09/03/03

Tags: , ,

Friday, August 22, 2003

Ten Commandments Monument

Alabama seems to be having quite a time with issues of church and state right now.

Besides the controversy over the Ten Commandments monument, Governor Bob Riley is part of a dispute within his own Republican Party about the correct Christian position on taxes.

On the Ten Commandments front, the print edition of the Mobile Register of 08/24/03 carried a profile of State Supreme Justice Roy Moore, who was recently suspended from his judicial duties for refusing to obey a court order to remove the monument from state property.

The article, by Associated Press writers Jon Krawczynski and Allen Breed, has a couple of items about Moore that especially caught my attention.

He comes off as a rigid person who enjoys confrontations. The article portrays him as the son of a none-too-affluent "itenerant construction worker."

Moore seems to have grown up with a stern conscience of a highly religious cast. But, the authors say, when he was an officer with the Military Policy in the Vietnam War, "Moore's bible seemed to be the Army handbook." He earned the derisive nickname of "Captain America" because he insisted on "regulation haircuts and constant salutes."

They report that he was rigid to the point of almost getting "fragged" [assassinated] by his own men. One of them, Barney Hall, is quoted as saying, "His policies damn near got him killed in Vietnam. He was a strutter."

That latter comment suggest that his men had more serious complaints than a strict haircut policy. If he was considered a "strutter", it probably means his men thought he was taking needless risks without really knowing what he was doing.

The article also notes that he has been unusally outspoken for a judge on political issues.

The picture that emerges is that of a man who takes risks that make him look on the surface like a tough fighter, but without thinking through the damage he may be causing either to others or to himself.

In the same paper, editor Michael Marshall casts doubt on how great a role religious conviction plays for Moore in this show. He claims Moore is casting himself as a persecuted religious zealot. But he contends that Moore "is not a religious zealot." Instead, "He's just another media harlot."

- Posted by Bruce Miller 08/25/03

Tags: ,