Showing posts with label zorro's times. Show all posts
Showing posts with label zorro's times. Show all posts

Friday, September 14, 2007

Zorro's times: Carlos IV and the real-life Reina María Louise

Carlos IV and his family, including Queen María Luisa and the future Fenando VII

Carlos IV followed his father Carlos III as King of Spain, reigning from 1788 to 1808. Like his father, Carlos IV was a despot. Unlike his father, he lacked the "Enlightened" side.

His queen was María Luisa, which was the name of the liberal-minded and popular queen in the Zorro: la espada y la rosa telenovela. So there was a Reina María Luisa around Zorro's time.

But the real one wasn't the popular figure of the telenovela. She persuaded her husband to appoint her lover, Godoy, as first minister. Godoy was more than a bit like el Duque Jacobo in the telenovela in being conniving and tyrannical-minded. His government was unpopular both in the Iberian Peninsula and in the overseas colonies.

The telenovela version of María Luisa, played by Evelin Giro:


Goya's version of the real María Luisa:


Godoy's lover la Reina María Luisa was known as La Parmesana, because she was from Parma. Carlos Fuentes in El Espejo Enterrado (1992) describes La Parmesana as "sexually voracious", although he doesn't elaborate beyond the fact of her affair with Godot. The King himself was neither very bright nor particularly interested in carrying forward the referoms initiated by his father. See also this post on Godoy.

Goya's version of María Luisa's lover and her husband's First Minister, Godoy:


This is a painting by José Aparicio showing Godot, who was bizarrely called the Prince of Peace, presenting peace to Carlos IV:


In 1808, Carlos IV's own son persuaded him to abdicate, and the son took the throne as Fernando VII to popular acclaim. Fernando had been the leader of the anti-Godoy faction during his father's reign.

Tags: , , , , , ,

Friday, September 07, 2007

Zorro's times: Carlos III, the "Enlightened Despot"

Carlos III of Spain

Carlos III (1716-1788), reigned as the Bourbon King of Spain 1759-1788. He practiced what was known as Enlightenment Despotism (Despotismo Ilustrado), and brought administrative reforms such as restructuring the colonial administration in the Nuevo Mundo (New World) along French lines, which meant more direct Spanish administration of what had previously been more loosely governed colonies. He set up twelve "intendancies" to exercise power in the colonies. T. R. Fehrenbach explains:

The intendants, who under Carlos III were career soldier-statesmen, were directly responsible and responsive to the viceregal chair. They assumed almost all of the civil and financial administration. Again, because of social pressure and the office mania of the [colonial] society, few of the older posts were abolished; they remained as useless ceremonial offices. Power, however, flowed around them. In one thing there was no change: the intendants were always peninsulares [Spaniards]. This further angered the criollos [Spaniards born in the colonies who were limpiado, or racially "pure"] who had been allowed to buy offices as alcaldes and corregidores, for the titles they came to hold were meaningless in terms of power.
But, as with England's North American colonies, the increased taxes that came with this new arrangement were annoying. To most everybody, according to Fehrenbach, with specific reference to Mexico (Nueva España/New Spain):

By European standards of the time, this taxation was not devastating - but all of it was money that left New Spain; it was a drain. The Bourbons [including Carlos III] spent much on local defense, but the vast majority of the monies they extracted went to support Spaniards and Spanish administration. Nothing was used for capital investment in Mexico. Therefore, increased revenues hurt rather than helped the economy and the poorer classes, while the criollo establishment, accustomed to a century of successful tax avoidance, was outraged.
One of the key issues for the liberals was limiting the power of the Church, which included not only considerable political influence but large landholdings and the personal wealth they generated. This was an interest that Carlos III's government embraced, moving in various ways to limit the power of the Church. This situation was significantly different that those pertaining in the North American British colonies and even in England itself. As Fehrenbach remarks, "societies which have not experienced clericalism cannot easily understand anticlericalism."

But not all restrictions of Church power were liberal or enlightened in their actual effect. For instance, the powerful Jesuit order, which had been the clerical shock troops of the Papacy in the Counter-Reformation, was expelled from Mexico in 1767 under Carlos III.

But in Mexico, the Jesuits not only had the best schools in Nueva España. Their relationship was different in Spain than it was in the New World toward one of the core Enlightenment projects, the promotion of scientific thought and education. Allied with the most conservative feudalists in Spain, the Jesuit order was undoubtedly a competing political and social force to the Enlightenment reformers there, including the King. Carlos III banned them by order to the Spanish Inquisition, an office that still existed at the time:

Prohibido expresamente que nadie pueda escribir, declarar o conmover, con pretexto de estas providencias en pro ni en contra de ellas, antes impongo silencio en esta materia a todos mis vallos y mando que a los contraventores se les castigue como a reos de Lesa Majestad.

[I expressly forbid anyone from writing, speaking or acting with the pretext of these rulings either in favor or against them, before I have effectively established the ban of this material on all my subject and I mandate that violations of this order be punished as if they had were acts of lèse majesté {violation of the sovereignty of the throne, something like treason under absolutist monarchies}.]
(I wanted to quote the language to give a sense of how despotic even an "enlightened" despot could sound. If anyone has suggestions for improving the translation, though, please let me know. Royal decrees of two centuries ago in bureacratic legalese can be tricky to translate into modern terms. The real point, though, is that he imposed a really sweeping and drastic sanction by means of the Inquisition against the Jesuits and anyone who might be inclined to defend them.)

The virrey (viceroy) of Mexico expelled the Jesuits and publicly complied with the royal position against them. Privately, however, he wrote of the expelled order, "Eran dueños absolutes de los corazones y las conciencias de todos los habitantes de este vasto imperio". (They possessed all our hearts and the consciences of all the inhabitants of this vast empire.)

As Fehrenbach writes:

The expulsion of the Jesuits from Mexico in 1767 destroyed the only element in the Mexican Church that was free of medievalism. The Bourbon officials meant to erase a competing institution, but the true effect was the destruction of all educational standards in New Spain.
This role of the Jesuits as bearers of modern ideas and men of the Church beloved by the people does provide some actual historical background for the role played by Padre Tomás and the nuns in the Zorro telenovela.

Padre Tomás (Jorge Cao) from the telenovela Zorro: la espada y la rosa (2007)

Carlos III seemed to have been a genuine visionary in some ways. He supported the development of an agricultural law based on the principles of Jovellanos, the leading Enlightenment intellectual in Spain, though the law was not enacted until 1894. Jovellanos best-known book was Informe en el expediente de la Ley Agraria (1795), explaining the law.

The changes Carlos III instituted in the colonies laid the basis for a more concrete notion of nationalism and national independence in the colonies. As Fehrenbach explains:

In the same way, the new laws that made indios [Indians] citizens and opened the ports of Spanish America to the world at last opened immense opportunities. The commerce of New Spain quadrupled in a few years, though citizenship of indios meant less since the debt peonage laws were retained. The reforms were unsettling for two reasons. They raised expectations, as reforms always do, and they also reminded the criollos and mestizos of the inequities that remained. And, enacted arbitrarily and in an authoritarian manner, they made the colonials acutely aware of the fact of Spanish tyranny over their lives.

Carlos III certainly intended to go farther. Before his death he approved a grand design for an Hispanic Commonwealth, in which the viceroyalties would be ruled as virtually independent countries. This could only have been implemented over violent protests by various interests in Spain, and the idea died with the ablest of the Bourbons.
Here we see the contradictory effects that can emerge from historical developments, sometimes only dimly perceived by the immediate participants. The reforms of Carlos III especially opened up new opportunities for business in the Nuevo Mundo and empowered the criollo and mestizo capitalists and their supporters by providing them new wealth, prominence, prestige and opportunity. But the imposition of such reforms by absolutist-monarchist methods also engendered resentment, including among those in the colonies who most directly benefited from the reforms so imposed.

Statue of Carlos III (Photo: Luis García/Wiki Commons)

Liberal though the regime of Carlos III may have been, it did not look favorably on the Túpac Amaru rebellion of 1780-1781 in Alto Perú and part of Bajo Perú, named for the indigenous leader of the rebellion, who had taken on the name of the last Inca Emperor, decapitated by the Spanish in 1572. The new Túpac Amaru's real name was José Gabriel Condorcanqui (1738-1781); he was a local Indian cacique (local warlord, in today's terms).

Carlos Fuentes writes, "Fue un rebelion inmersa en la violencia y en el simbolismo." (It was a rebellion immersed in violence and in symbolism.) The rebellion was triggered in response to the reforms of Carlos III, such as the administrative separation of Alto Perú and Bajo Perú which disrupted traditional relationships in that region and the intensification of the system of impressed labor that the Spanish maintained there.

Many blacks and mulatos joined in the revolt, and the rebels proclaimed emancipation for slaves. To a signficant extent, the Túpac Amaru rebellión represented a revolt of the lower classes. Their famous slogan was, "Viva el rey y muera el mal gobierno!" (Long live the King and death to the bad government!") His Enlightened Majesty was not impressed with the rebels' good wishes, nor were his colonial administrators. I don't want to get all Mel Gibson here, so let's just say the rebel leader was publicly executed in Cuzco by Spanish officials in a gruesome manner. His wife and two of his sons were also put to death by the forces of the Enlightened Despot.

This rebellion, and perhaps even more so a revolt of blacks and Indians in Venzuela in 1795 which openly proclaimed the radical democratic ideas of the French Revolution, pushed the reluctant and conservative crillo elite in the Nuevo Mundo into taking the idea of independence more seriously.

Sources:

T.R. Fehrenbach, Fire and Blood: A History of Mexico (1973)

Carlos Fuentes, El Espejo Enterrado (1992)

Thursday, September 06, 2007

Zorro's times: classes and races in el Nuevo Mundo

Spain's New World was diverse, but not "multicultural"

Working to understand more about the real-life times of the fictional Zorro, I found myself needing to learn about some previously-obscure issues. Like the ones in this post.

A critical concept in Spain was limpieza, literally cleanliness, but which also meant "racial purity". More specifically, it meant descent from Christian Spaniards, i.e., without Jewish or Muslim ancestors.

In the Nuevo Mundo (New World) colonies in Zorro's day (early 19th century), there was an elaborate system of racial categories which also translated to a large degree into class position and social/political power.

Carlos Fuentes describes the following categories, in Spain's New World empire. He estimates about 18 million inhabitants around 1810 who he classifies as follows:

Caucasians; 4 million. This included "limpieza" Spaniards born in Spain, who were known as peninsulares or gachupins. This group also included "limpieza" Spaniards born in the colonies, called criollos (Creoles). Peninsulares had a more privileged and powerful position than criollos. The colonial independence movements were largely led by the criollo elite.

Indígenas, or indios (indigenous Indians); 8 million, and, negros (blacks); 1 million. Blacks and indígenas were the poorest, least powerful and most exploited groups. Some blacks were slaves.

The remaining 5 million were composed of a variety of distinct groups, defined by their parents' race, of which Fuentes gives the following: mestizos (white and Indian); mulato (white and black), a derisive term; tercerón (mulato and white); cuarterón (tercerón and white) tenteneaire (tercerón and mulato); and, saltapatrás (cuarterón and black).

The criollos in Mexico and Central America also referred to the lower classes more generally as "léperos".

Isabel Allende in her Zorro novel gives quite a bit of emphasis to the role of these racially-defined social categories. I'm not sure at what point in the literary development of the Diego/Zorro character that he bacame a mestizo. In Johston McCulley's original story The Curse of Capistrano/The Mark of Zorro (1919), Diego was a criollo.

Allende definitely made much of Diego's indígena heritage from his mother Toypurnia/Regina. She also makes his relationship with the indígena Bernardo one of a lifelong, sibling-type relationship: "hermaos de leche" (like brothers from birth). She has Diego and Bernardo learn about the network of tunnels in their area, which Zorro later used to navigate his way around secretly. In her version, he takes the name Zorro from his meeting his totem animal, a fox (zorro), during a rite-of-passage indígena vision quest.

The 2007 telenovela, Zorro: la espada y la rosa, reatins Diego's mestizo status and uses the same background with Toypurnia as his mother.

The various racial divisions played a big role in the telenovela, as in El Gobernador Fernando's tortured relationship with the indios. They also add the various complications with the gitanos (Gypsies, Romany).

The various geogrpahical/administrative division of Spain's New World Empire can be confusing. As of 1784, the divisions were the virreinatos (vicroyalties), each ruled by a virrey (viceroy). They lay roughly as follows in present-day terms.

Virreinato de Nueva España: Mexico, Texas, California and much of present-day southwest and western United States; sparsely populated territories of Lousiana and Florida were also administratively part of Nueva España.

Virreinato de Nueva Grenada: Central America, Colombia, Venezuela, Ecuador

Virreinato de Perú: Peru, part of Brazil

Virreinato de Buenos Aires (aka, Virreinato del Río de la Plata): Argentina, Bolivia, Paraguay, Chile, Uruguay

The Virreinato de Brasil, generally corresponding to present-day Brazil, was ruled by Portugal.

Sources:

T.R. Fehrenbach, Fire and Blood: A History of Mexico (1973)

Carlos Fuentes, El Espejo Enterrado (1992).

Tuesday, September 04, 2007

Zorro's times: Napoleon Bonaparte and militant liberalism

The historical time period of Zorro in the days when Los Angeles was part of the Spanish colony of Nueva España (Mexico) would most likely fall within the period 1800-1823. I've put together several posts on the historical background of that time. This is the first one.

One of the key concepts for the politics of this period is liberalism, which is hard to relate to our current concepts of "liberal" in the United States. There is more of an historical resemblance to the present-day liberalism in the European sense, as advocated by the parties of the Liberal International. (A bit of advice: don't give yourself a headache trying to translate the LI's brand of liberalism to the American political meaning; their Web site lists Ayn Rand and Thomas Sowell as "liberal" thinkers. Yikes!)

But rather than try to summarize two centuries of the concept's evolution, here I'll just briefly describe the version of Zorro's time.

The liberalism of the 18th century was very much identified with the class interests of the rising capitalist class all over Europe, and also with the ideas of the Enlightenment. Liberals sought to abolish or (more often) limit the power of monarchies in favor of elected assemblies. They wanted to establish greater limits on the political power of the Church, especially the Catholic Church but also the Protestant. Free trade and the sanctity of contracts were important goals for the liberals.

So were personal freedoms, such as freedom of speech, religion and conscience, a press free of government censorship, and security of the person against arbitrary arrest: rights like those in the American Constitution and Bill of Rights. These rights were also central to their political goals. Limiting the privileges of the landed aristocracy was a part of the liberal project.

Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin and Adam Smith would be exemplary liberals of that period.

The French Revolution of 1789 was, on the whole, a liberal revolution against the French monarchy and aristocracy, and was initially led by liberals. The French Revolution underwent a radicalization that took it beyond classical liberal goals and methods.

Eventually, the French Republic established by the Revolution became an empire led by Napoleon Bonaparte. Here is where the interactions of the French Revolution with other European powers including Spain gets complex and contradictory.

Napoleon as Emperor certainly wasn't going to stand for election, much less allow himself to be voted out of office. During the Napoleonic Wars, France occupied other European territories like the German Rhineland and Bavaria. Napoleon's occupation imposed many classical liberals institutions and practices on them, such as more democratic local elections, or restrictions on the great power of the feudal Junkers (aristocratic large landholders) in Prussia (then one of the German kingdoms).

From the standpoint of the development of democracy, these produced contradictory results. In the Germans lands, it was Napoleon's introduction of "French" ideas and practices, along with the end of the Holy Roman Empire framework and restrictions on the aristocratic powers like the Junkers, that began concrete political developments toward democracy there. It's no accident that the German Rhineland areas most influenced by France became a leading hotbed of the democratic Revolution of 1848.

At the same time, resistance to French occupation was also an important source of democratic sentiment and also greatly increased national consciousness in Europe. It may not be quite so easy to picture today, but at that time nationalism and democracy were closely related concepts. (And, no, not just in the United States.)

In the German lands including Prussia, the opposition to French occupation was organized by German officials raising regular armies and the struggle is remembered as the Wars of Liberation.

However, the legendary Prussian army of "Old Fritz", aka, Frederick the Great, had been a professional army, a "standing army" of the kind that the American Founders considered an inherent threat to democratic institutions. The armies raised for the Wars of Liberation were popular armies drawn from a much wider cross-section of ordinary people who volunteered to fight against French occupation.

This didn't mean that Prussian Junkers were ready to accept farmers and factory workers as equal citizens. But the experience of participating in a "people's army" (by early 19th century standards) was a major step toward a democratic consciousness. And in Germany as in other countries, the democratic movement was heavily identified with the "national movements".

A similar movement occurred in Spain when Napoleon occupied the country and set up his older brother as Jose I, King of Spain. But that's a story for another post in the series.

Tags: , , , , , ,