Showing posts with label benno ohnesorg. Show all posts
Showing posts with label benno ohnesorg. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Neda and images of revolution


The already-legendary death of Neda Agha-Soltan (1983-2009)

John "bomb-bomb-bomb-bomb-bomb Iran" McCain has adopted the late Neda Agha-Soltan as as his mascot for hostility to Iran, as Andrew Malcolm explain in his Los Angeles Times blog, McCain's Iran Neda speech raises domestic political stakes for Obama 06/22/09. Malcolm closely follows the Beltway Village press script, in which McCain, whose judgment in cheering on the Iraq War in 2002-3 couldn't possibly have been worse, is treated as a Very Serious spokesman on foreign policy. And he sounds like the typical McCain fanboy, which means he's a typical reporter:

The obviously angry McCain, Obama's GOP opponent in last year's presidential election, cites the tragic death of an Iran female protester called Neda whose name has suddenly become known globally as she was shot in Tehran and died in the street, bleeding profusely, on a now viral and very graphic video with friends screaming around her.

McCain's outspoken criticism of Iran's government for its violence mirrors his strong denunciations last summer when Russia invaded the democratic country of Georgia.

Obama, who was vacationing in Hawaii at the time, was more measured initially, calling on both sides to stop fighting. He later changed tone more in favor of the invaded democracy.

On the weekend, before taking his daughters out for ice cream, Obama issued a statement, published here on The Ticket, warning the theocratic regime that the world is watching and it should permit peaceful democratic demonstrations. [my emphasis]
The bolded portions make me wonder if Andrew Malcolm isn't aspiring to be a future Maureen Dowd.

Without refighting the Georgia-Russia War of 2008, in both cases Obama showed sensible restraint while McCain mouthed off in ways that could have caused all kinds of problems if his statements has come from a President of the United States. The brilliant Tom Tomorrow captured the cynical frivolity of chronic warmongers like McCain who, if they had had there ways, would have already blown up thousands or tens of thousands of Iranian civilians like Neda in another unnecessary war, now pretending to be such great admirers of the freedom-loving Iranian people. It'a always time to worry when rightwing Republicans like the bold Maverick start talking about how much they care about the human rights of people in some foreign country. It usually means they want to start bombing them.

One similarity I notice is that McCain's appeal in the video has the same kind of maudlin sentimentality and arrogant pretentiousness as his statements on the Georgia-Russian War in which he claimed to speak for the American people. Remember, "today, we are all Georgians"?

Here's a You Tube video of the bold Maverick speaking about Neda:



President Obama had a good response in his news conference on Tuesday, as a McCain-lining reporter asked him to respond to the press' favorite Maverick:

Look, the -- you know, I think John McCain has genuine passion about many of these international issues. And, you know, I think that all of us share a belief that we want justice to prevail.

But only I'm the president of the United States. And I've got responsibilities in making certain that we are continually advancing our national security interests and that we are not used as a tool to be exploited by other countries.

I mean, you guys must have seen the reports. They've got some of the comments that I've made being mistranslated in Iran, suggesting that I'm telling rioters to go out and riot some more. There are reports suggesting that the CIA is behind all this. All of which patently false. But it gives you a sense of the narrative that the Iranian government would love to play into.

So the -- you know, members of Congress, they've got their constitutional duties, and I'm sure they will carry them out in the way that they think is appropriate. I'm president of the United States, and I'll carry out my duties as I think are appropriate. [my emphasis]
See also Obama to GOP: "Iranians can speak for themselves" by Mike Madden Salon 06/23/09.
The image of Neda dying in the street has certainly become a powerful one. Borzou Daragahi in Family, friends mourn 'Neda,' Iranian woman who died on video Los Angeles Times 06/23/09 reports on Neda Agha-Soltan's life, which just ended at 26. With this kind of actual reporting, I see no reason at this point not to think the story of her death is on the level.

Still, the Great Maverick seems to be going a little beyond what is actually known in the public record that Neda was killed by a government sharpshooter. Although it seems to be a reasonable assumption. But the pictures of Neda and their instantly becoming iconic remind me very much of a similar photo of the dying Benno Ohnesorg on June 2, 1967, one of the key iconic images of "the Sixties" in Germany. As I've written here before, new angles of the story are still coming out 42 years later.


That photo of Friederike Dollinger attempting to aid the wounded, dying Benno Ohnesorg became a symbol of the student movement in West Germany. In fact, the student movement there is conventionally dated from the day Ohnesorg was shot, although that's probably a bit simplistic. It only emerged this year that Karl-Heinz Kurras, the West Berlin policeman who shot Ohensorg for no good reason was an active agent of the Stasi, the East German spy agency. There's no evidence that Kurras shot Ohnesorg on orders from the Stasi. But it's one of several mysteries about the killing and the events surrounding it that have yet to be fully explained.

There was even an Iranian connection. The events that led to Benno Ohnesorg's death involved two demonstrations against the Shah of Iran, who was visiting West Berlin. German students, including Iranians living in Germany, were protesting his dictatorial regime.

Friederike Dollinger became part of German history by being there at that moment. She herself, now known by her married name Friederike Hausmann, also practices history, having written several historical books herself, like the one shown here, Die deutschen Anarchisten von Chicago: Oder warum Amerika ken 1.Mai nicht kennt (1998) [The German Anarchists of Chicago: Or, Why America Doesn't Recognize May 1]. The title reference is to the "Haymarket riot" in Chicago in 1886, at which several anarchists were falsely accused of exploding a bomb. That event was the one originally commemorated by International Workers Day on May 1, celebrated as such by social-democratic parties, unions and other left parties all over the world - except in America. President Grover Cleveland, a reactionary Democrat, established Labor Day to discourage the celebration of International Workers Day on May 1 in America.

Getting back to the Iranian situation today, We don't have to know every detail of a story like Neda's killing for an image like that to take on great symbolism. I don't doubt that many Iranians take the image as a symbol for a struggle for democracy, justice and freedom. Juan Cole writes, "Mourning martyrs is central to Shiite Iran's religious sensibilities", so Neda's iconic depiction as a martyr "plays on powerful cultural themes" in Iran. He further explains, "the [Shi'a version of the Islamic] religion is all about resisting the tyrants in history who made the martyrs".

For others like Baby Shah Reza Pahlavi II, it's more likely to be a symbol useful in helping another repressive regime take power so they can do the same thing to dissenters. For people like the bold Maverick or his good buddy Lindsey "Huckleberry" Graham, I can't imagine she's anything but a symbol of their desire to have a war against Iran.

I think Obama continues to strike the right tone of restraint. He clearly has no intention at this point of getting drawn into an unnecessary war with Iran. And what did Iraq War advocates like the bold Maverick think when they were cheering for war back in 2002-3? It was obvious to anyone whose brain wasn't pickled in OxyContin that removing Saddam would boost Iran's relative power in the region. And our allied government in Iraq is a pro-Iranian, Islamist regime. We need Iran's help to be able to meet the 2011 withdrawal deadline that Bush agreed to and that Obama has committed himself to.

Andrew Malcolm's post features the following photo, which he doesn't identify but apparently is from recent street protests in Iran. It strikes me how much images like this one affect the American idea of what revolution means. It's a stereotypical image: a couple of angry guys tossing something at somebody with a fire in the scene behind them.


Or maybe I should say seemingly angry guys who look like they are tossing something.

Dealing with revolutions and revolutionary regimes has been a chronic problem for American foreign policy since, when, the Spanish-American War? I wonder how much images like this contribute to a perception not only among the general public but also among policymakers that revolution means chaos and scary guys starting fires and throwing rocks in the street. I mean, that kind of thing has been going on since the French Revolution, and I'm wondering if the use of those kinds of images isn't related to historical images of the storming of the Bastille and similar kinds of things from 19th democratic revolutionary movements. I suspect that melodramatic images of revolutionary situations - and I'm not convinced that what is going on in Iran is a revolutionary situation yet - don't interfere with people's ability to see such events as a complex political and social process, as opposed to the bad guys getting thrown out and the good guys winning. Or vice versa. I mean, viewing the Islamist warlords and international jihadists fighting the Soviet Union in Afghanistan in the 1980s as brave freedom fighters on Our Side didn't necessarily work out so well over the long run. To take one example.

Stephen Walt in What Iran means by Foreign Policy Online 06/23/2009 gives us a more sober view of the Iranian situation than what we're likely to hear from the bold Maverick or Huckleberry Graham:

Yet even if the current regime survives the present challenge, the impact of the crisis is likely to be salutary. Iran's appeal as a model of Islamic governance has been tarnished by this episode: instead of being the principled defenders of the Ayatollah Khomeini's revolutionary vision of the "rule of the jurisprudent," his successors now look more like garden-variety authoritarians trying to hang onto privilege and power in the face of widespread popular discontent. And that means Muslims elsewhere will be less inclined to see Tehran as an inspiration, even if they are unhappy with political conditions in their own countries.

The current crisis may also put to rest a lot of the bellicose talk about military action. In recent years, advocates of "kinetic action" (read: preventive war) against Iran have sought to portray it as a nation of wild-eyed revolutionary fanatics, led by Holocaust-denying zealots who openly crave martyrdom and would therefore be willing to fire nuclear weapons at other countries even if it led to their own destruction. That alarmist image was always pretty ludicrous, and it looks increasingly inappropriate today. In the wake of this stolen election (and see here for more evidence of electoral chicanery), Iran's rulers looks less like a group of fanatics and more like a group of grumpy old men. I don't see Osama bin Laden or Che or Qutb or even Khomeini; I see Brezhnev, Andropov, Mussolini, or Ceaucescu. [my emphasis]
See also: Icons of the New Iran by Barbara Crossette The Nation Online 06/23/09;
Regimeopfer Neda Agha-Soltan: Propagandaschlacht um die Heldin des neuen Iran
von Ulrike Putz Der Spiegel Online 23.06.09

Tags: , , ,
,

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Bettina Röhl on Karl-Heinz Kurras and the Stasi revelations


Der Tod des Demonstranten (Death of the Demonstrator)- a memorial to Benno Ohnesorg by Alfred Hrdlicka, 1971: photo in Berlin 1990

I posted earlier about the story that came out in the German press last week about how Karl-Heinz Kurras, the West Berlin policeman who shot and killed Benno Ohnesorg on June 2, 1967, had been an East German spy and an illegal member of the East German Communist Party (SED) since 1967. Ohnesorg’s death is generally understood as having been a decisive event in spreading the militant German student movement throughout West Germany, when it had been primarily a West Berlin phenomenon prior to that. And the movement in response became even more militant and, in part, violent.

In her blog post Tod von Benno Ohnesorg: Staatsmord aus Ostberlin?, journalist Bettina Röhl Die Welt 22.05.2009 gives some quirky interpretations of the history of that event and its aftermath. I’ve laid out my understanding of the Ohnesorg killing and its repercussions in my earlier post, so I won’t do another overall recap here. She argues that the biggest impetus to the spread and increased militance of the student movement after June 2 was due to the resignations of West Berlin's Mayor and Police President, which signalled to the extra-parliamentary opposition (APO), i.e., the militant left opposition, that state authorities were weak. In other words, she argues that insufficient authoritarianism by West German officials let the student movement flourish that otherwise could have been restricted.

In doing so, she makes contradictory arguments about the power of the student movement, which she heavily implies was essentially a creation of East Germany. In one place, she argues that the movement would have developed pretty much the way it did, violence and all, without Ohnesorg’s killing. Yet she also argues that if the public had just known then about Kurras' Stasi (East German Security) ties, that the movement couldn’t have gotten any traction from the killing.

But the West German state hardly showed itself to be weak in dealing with protesters, then or later. On the contrary, their training in crowd control was based on a scenario of crowd actions in support of an act of Soviet/East German military aggression against West Berlin. In the situation of the late 1960s, the overly aggressive police tactics had the effect of polarizing the situation in university cities all over West Germany, including conservative Bavaria. The Ohnesorg killing became a symbol of that, but it became a symbol because police excesses were real.

"Enteignet Springer" (Expropriate Springer) became a popular slogan of the student movement shortly after Benno Ohnesorg's death

Her self-contradicatory argument that the APO would have been undercut by the immediate knowledge that Kurras was a Stasi agent is essentially based on the notion that the APO admired the East German version of socialism, which for the most part wasn’t really the case. APO activists expressed solidarity with protest movements in Poland and Czechoslovakia and were generally critical of East German "Stalinism“. She also ignores the ham-handed pugnacity of Social Democratic Mayor Heinrich Albertz in the immediate wake of the killing, as well as the hysteria of the Springer press. On the latter, she is explicitly in denial, writing that they were "die einzige, die damals einen kühlen Kopf bewahrte" (the only ones who kept a cool head back then). That’s imaginative, for sure, but it‘s astonishing revisionism that could only be defended by defining "cool head“ as something like "recklessly irresponsible“. (Die Welt was then and is now a Springer paper.)

Her post also carries a tone of what we in America would call "culture war" polemics, i.e., she still wants to discredit the DHF's (darn frigging hippies, in the nice version) of those days while imagining that their malign influence is present all over the place in present-day German culture. She talks, for instance, about the "die 68er-Ideologen und auch das gigantische Millionenheer der Mitläufer von 68" (the Sixties ideologues and also the gigantic army of millions of fellow-travelers of the Sixties) who are supposedly resistent to facts about that period. DFH's, in other words. And historians of the period who don't share her dismissive atitude toward the DFH's are acting as "security guards" to protect some DFH conventional wisdom about the 1960s.

Having fairly recently read a number of accounts of the period - not least of them Röhl's own highly informative book on the subject, which shows a level of care in narrative and analysis that is missing in her blog post - I don't know who she may be talking about there. I've reviewed here two 2008 books on "1968" by leading German historians Norbert Frei and Götz Aly. Neither strikes me as some DFH ideological position paper. On the contrary, most of the analysis I've seen from German writers on that period seem to take a critical view of events, especially on the ideology and practice of violence.

Röhl also paints with a very broad brush in her post when she writes:

Indes war die Propaganda der APO eine ganz durchsichtige Angelegenheit: Die 68er-Bewegung, die damals noch APO-Bewegung hieß, baute auf dem Tod von Ohnesorg ihre Legende auf, dass der Staat derjenige war, der zuerst Gewalt angewendet hätte, auf die die friedliche Massenbewegung nur reagiert habe.

[In this way, [Ohnesorg's shooting] was a very obvious opportunity for the propaganda of the APO. The Sixties Movement, when then was still called the APO Movement, built up on the death of Ohnesorg their legend that it was the state that first introduced violence, to which the peaceful mass movement only reacted.]
Here she seems to be so intent on denigrating the APO that she manages to simultaneously exaggerate and minimize the significance of the Benno Ohnesorg shooting. Sure, his death became an element of the APO's propaganda. Just as the events of that day became an element of the Springer press' hysterical campaign against the student movement - a cool-headed hysterical campaign, according to Röhl. But it became a widespread symbol for the APO because the image and the context resonated strongly with so many young people given how they saw the police acting.

And I'm not sure what it means to say that the APO "built up on the death of Ohnesorg their legend that it was the state that first introduced violence". However emotional a turning point the Ohnesorg may have been for many APO activists, for those among them who advocated some form of political violence, I don't get the impression that "who shot first" was a particularly important question.

A video accompanying the following article addresses some of these issues: Stasi-Fall Kurras: Birthler weist "rätselhafte" Vorwürfe zurück Die Welt 26.05.2009

Other related links:

Dutschke-Sohn fordert neue Suche in den Stasi-Akten von Einar Koch Bild-Zeitung 26.05.2009

Der Fall Benno Ohnesorg: Jetzt spricht die Frau des Todes-Schützen Bild-Zeitung 26.05.2009

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Monday, May 25, 2009

Other links on Benno Ohnesorg's murder by Stasi agent Karl-Heinz Kurras

These are a variety of links with mostly no commentary by me on the Curious Case of Benno Ohnesorg and His Killer Karl-Heinz Kurras, Stasi Agent:

Stasi-Debatte: Vorwürfe gegen die Birthler-Behörde Frankfurter Rundschau 25.05.2009

Given the notorious role the Springer press in general and the Bild-Zeitung in particular played in inciting fear and hatred against young political activists in the 1960s, there something weirdly ironic about citing Bild's articles on the revelations that Benno Ohnesorg's killer, Karl-Heinz Kurras, was a Stasi agent. But here's one link, Der Ex-Innenminister zum Fall Benno Ohnesorg: War es ein Auftragsmord, Herr Schily? 24.05.2009.

Bild's Web site has an aggregator page of at least some of its articles on the Ohnesorg case: Alle Infos zum Fall Benno Ohnesorg.

Der Fall Karl-Heinz Kurras: "Soll ich mich deshalb schämen?" von S. Höll Süddeutsche Zeitung 24.05.2009

The current issue of Der Spiegel makes the story its cover feature:


Fall Kurras: Ohnesorgs Todesschütze gesteht SED-Mitgliedschaft Die Zeit 24.05.2009

Ohnesorg-Todesschütze: "Mein Fall ist längst verjährt" Frankfurter Rundschau 24.05.2009

Benno Ohnesorg: Mit einem Schuss in die Geschichte von Uwe Schlicht Die Zeit24.05.2009

Fall Kurras: Neue Details: "Ich komme wegen der Schießabteilung" Süddeutsche Zeitung 23.05.2009

Birthler-Behörde: Stasi-Spitzel erschoss Ohnesorg Die Zeit23.05.2009

Studentenbewegung 1967: Zu Besuch bei Ohnesorgs Todesschützen von Uwe Soukup Die Zeit23.05.2009

Stasi-Spitzel: Schuss mit Fragezeichen von Steffen Hebestreit Frankfurter Rundschau 22.05.2009

Stasi-Vergangenheit: Erneut Strafanzeige gegen Kurras gestellt Die Zeit22.05.2009

Taumeln von einer Lüge zur anderen: Ohnesorg und die DDR von Willi Winkler Süddeutsche Zeitung 22.05.2009

Vielleicht war es nicht die NS-Vergangenheit von Wolfgang Kraushaar Frankfurter Rundschau 22.05.2009

Der Stasi-Kurras: Ohnesorg, die DDR und die 68er von Heribert Prantl Süddeutsche Zeitung 22.05.2009

Oskar Negt über Karl-Heinz Kurras: "Eine gespenstische Wende" Süddeutsche Zeitung 22.05.2009

Karl-Heinz Kurras: Stasi-Agent tötete Ohnesorg Süddeutsche Zeitung 22.05.2009

Karl-Heinz Kurras: Strafanzeige gegen Ohnesorg-Todesschützen Süddeutsche Zeitung 22.05.2009

Benno Ohnesorg: Die Geburt der 68er von Michael König Süddeutsche Zeitung 22.05.2009

Kurras: "Können die uns nicht endlich in Ruhe lassen?" Süddeutsche Zeitung 22.05.2009

Neue Berichte: Ohnesorg von Stasi-Spitzel erschossen" Süddeutsche Zeitung 21.05.2009

Tod Benno Ohnesorgs: "Die Polizisten haben geprügelt wie blöd" Süddeutsche Zeitung 30.05.2007 (Interview mit Friederike Hausmann)

Benno Ohnesorg: Der Tod des Träumers von Willi Winkler Süddeutsche Zeitung 30.05.2007

Der 2. Juni 1967 und Ohnesorgs Tod: "Zynischer ging's nicht" Süddeutsche Zeitung 02.06.2007

Spätes Bedauern in Berlin: Polizeipräsident legt Kranz für Ohnesorg nieder von Oliver Das Gupta Süddeutsche Zeitung 02.06.2007

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Wow! And, wow! New wrinkle on a notorious event in recent German history


Friederike Dollinger (now Friederike Hausmann) with the dying Benno Ohnesorg, who had just been shot in the head by a West Berlin policeman who was secretly a Stasi agent (June 2, 1967)

I'm really surprised at this one. The West Berlin policeman Karl-Heinz Kurras set off a long wave of violence when he murdered a 26-year-old student named Benno Ohnesorg on June 2, 1967. A photo of Ohnesorg bleeding out from his head wound is one of the most famous images of recent German history. It was a crucial turning point in the student movement in West Germany.

Now the 81-year-old Kurras is admitting that he was a secret member of the East German Communist Communist Party (SED) and spied for East Germany!

Der Fall Karl-Heinz Kurras: "Soll ich mich deshalb schämen?" von S. Höll Süddeutsche Zeitung 24.05.2009 reports that Kurras initially denied it last week when documents from the archives of the Stasi (East Germany secret police) were published showing his role. But now he admits it straightforwardly. He denies getting paid for his spying, though. Höll reports that a new charge against Kurras over the shooting of Ohnesorg is unlikely, since he was acquitted in two trials related to the killing already. He also reports that there is no indication that the Ohnesorg shooting was somehow ordered by East Germany.

Whether or not those trials were genuinely fair ones from the victim's viewpoint, it's clear that there was no good reason for Kurras to shoot Ohnesorg to death. The incident took place after the second of two demonstrations against the Shah of Iran, who was paying a state visit to Germany. There was a politically active community of pro-democracy Iranian dissidents in West Germany who were highlighting the human rights abuses of the Iranian regime. One of them was a young intellectual named Bahman Nirumand who had fled Iran in 1965 and had published a book in 1967 called Persien: Modell eines Entwicklungslandes oder Die Diktatur der freien Welt [Persia [Iran]: Model of a developing country or the Dictatorship of the Free World]. Nirumand criticized the support of the Western democracies for the Shah's brutal government, and his book was one of the most influential books for the activist German students of the 1960s.

Stasi expert Helmut Müller-Enbergs on discovering the Kurras Stasi files: "Ich bin vom Stuhl gefallen." ("I fell out of my chair.")

The German authorities had made a spectacularly ill-advised decision to allow a group of thugs run by the Iranian secret service, the SAVAK, to act as guards to the Shah. During a peaceful demonstration during the daytime of June 2, the SAVAK thugs had attacked a few hundred anti-Shah demonstrators while the Berlin police looked passively on and let it happen. Then the police moved in themselves against the student demonstrators, arresting some of them but none of the SAVAK attackers.

This raised the emotional temperature for a second demonstration already planned that evening outside the Deutsche Oper, where the Shah and his wife were attending a performance of Mozart's opera, The Magic Flute. The demonstrators were more militant, and a few tomatoes and paint balloons flew, injuring no one but embarassing the Berlin officials. Erich Duensing, the chief police official (president), had directed the police to proceed aggressively against the demonstrators, beating them with clubs (men and women alike) and firing water cannons at them, like in the infamous photos from Birmingham, Alabama, of a few years before. The demonstrators were in full flight when Kurras shot Benno Ohnesorg in the back of the head in a parking garage.

Ohnesorg was a 26-year-old literature student who apparently wasn't taking part in the demonstration at all. Nor was he armed or threatening the police in any way. The reaction was intense. Part of the problem, aside from the bad judgments of the moment by German officials and police, was that the Berlin police weren't really trained to deal with street demonstrations at that time. Their training for emergency situations was predicated opposing street actions coordinated with a Soviet invasion of the city. Which also meant that city officials were also pretty clueless about how to respond to such an event as the Ohnesorg shooting. So the Social Democratic Mayor of West Berlin, Heinrich Albertz, said the demonstrators were to blame for the death, adding, "Die Geduld der Stadt ist am Ende." (The patience of the city is at an end.") Not especially diplomatic in a situation where a cop has just made a very questionable fatal shooting, in a situation that was already tense because of blatant police misconduct.

This video shows the report on the German channel ZDF about the Kurras revelations, including footage of the fatally wounded Benno Ohnesorg with Friederike Hausmann:



The Springer press empire, which included the sensation-oriented Bild-Zeitung, accused the demonstrators of acting like Hitler's SA Brownshirts back in the day. Bild on the day after the Ohnesorg murder declared, "In Berlin gab es bisher Terror nur östlich der Mauer. Gestern haben bösartige und dumme Wirrköpfe zum erstenmal versucht, den Terror in den freien Teil der Stadt zu tragen." ("In Berlin up until now, there was Terror only east of the Wall. Yesterday, malicious and dumb crazies attempted for the first time to bring Terror into the free part of the city.") Again, it was the demonstrators they were accusing of Terror, not the police and the SAVAK thugs. A particularly awkward comparison to place against state terror in Communist East Berlin. And even more ironic in retrospect, knowing now that the killer was an East German agent.

Protests grew against the police and the Springer press, as well. Within a few weeks, the slogan "Enteignet Springer!" (Expropriate Springer!) became popular among left-leaning student demonstrators. It's generally assumed among German historians that the killing of Benno Ohnesorg touched off "1968" or "the Sixties" in West Germany, insofar as that meant a mass political movement among the young (though it was not only young Germans who were outraged by the Ohnesorg shooting). As historian Norbert Frei describes it in 1968: Jugendrevolte und globaler Protest (2008), the fate of Benno Ohnesorg, shot down by a cop because he looked like a student who was in the wrong place at the wrong time, was one in which it was easy for many students to imagine themselves.

The shooting didn't create the student or youth movements, they were already under way. But, referring to the SDS, the leading militant political group among German university students (not to be confused with the American SDS of the same time), Frei writes that at their national conference in Frankfurt a few weeks later, "nobody was talking about tomatoes any more." The Ohnesorg shooting marked a militant and violent turn in the student movement.

Wolfgang Kraushaar writes in Vielleicht war es nicht die NS-Vergangenheit von Frankfurter Rundschau 22.05.2009 that Ohnesorg's death was "the spark that ignited the student revolt". There had been something like a student revolt at the Freie Universität in West Berlin before that, he writes, but the Ohnesorg killing and the general official misconduct around the demonstrations on June 2 created such a shock and outrage among univerisity students and other young people that activism took off among them all over West Germany.

Karl-Heinz Kurras, Stasi agent and killer of Benno Ohnesorg, in 1967

When Karl-Heinz Kurras was acquitted on November 21, 1967 of murder in the Ohnesorg case, the chief judge in the case indicated that he was unhappy with the outcome of the case in words that retroactively take on a new meaning in light of the revelations that Kurras as an East German spy: "Kurras weiss mehr, als er sagt, und er macht den Endruck, als wenn er in vielen Dingen die Unwahrheit sagt." ("Kurras knows more than he's saying, and he gives the impression that he is speaking falsehood in many things.") The judge was more perceptive than he knew.

Despite Kurras' acquital, both police president Erich Duensing and Mayor Heinrich Albertz wound up resigning their posts after the details of the Ohnesorg killing became public.

According to Höll's report, Kurras provided intelligence reports to East Germany on the West German police and the West German Verfassungsschutz, an internal security agency. The Stasi reduced their contacts with him after the Ohnesorg murder. But the files show a Stasi contact as late as 1976. He provided information to the Stasi about East German refugees and planted microphones in offices. He wasn't just passing on office gossip.

I hate to speculate. But who can resist speculating about a spy story? One obvious speculation is that the East Germans could have put him up to shooting somebody at that demonstration to cause trouble. Or, he could have seen himself as a convinced Communist - which he presumably did if he wasn't taking money for his information - a made a similar calculation on his own, although that seems more far-fetched. But there's apparently no evidence of either, so far.

Then it's always possible that the West German authorities somehow greased the skids for Kurras' acquitals on charges related to the Ohnesorg murder because he was working as a double agent, or because they were secretly aware of his spying activities and were using him to feed misinforation to the Stasi. But there is no evidence in the public record of that either, so far as I know.

Still, it is a remarkable coincidence that a policeman whose shooting of student played such a key role in the politics of West Germany in the 1960s turns out to have been a secret Communist and a spy for East Germany!

Kraushaar recalls something I don't recall seeing described before. Benno Ohnesorg's funeral procession of over 100 cars had to pass through East German territory to get from West Berlin to Hannover, where he was buried. Normally, the East German officials required cars to wait for hours to pass. The funeral convoy was waved through. Along the way, young people greeted the convoy along the highway, and East German soldiers along the route even paid honor to the deceased. As Kraushaar says, these unusual occurences looked like an act of state by the East Germans. At a minimum, it meant that East Germany wanted to make the incident as much of a pain as they could for the West German government. Kraushaar cautions that this is not to say that it was some kind of genuine act of solidarity by the East Germans. The leaders of the East German SED regime generally weren't interested in the "anti-authoritarian" goals of the western student movement except as it further their own state goals. Some twenty years later, they were rejecting Michael Gorbachev's brand of reform Communism as way too liberal for their liking.

But he also cautions that there is no evidence of an East German order to Kurras to shoot somebody. And he warns that we may never know. Since Kurras is still alive and apparently lucid, he himself could reveal for the first time what his motive in the killing was. But, as Kraushaar notes, there is no statute of limitations on murder, so by talking openly about his motives, Kurras could open himself to another prosecution on the Kurras killing. So it's unlikely to happen.

Tags: , , , , , , ,