Showing posts with label karl rosenkranz. Show all posts
Showing posts with label karl rosenkranz. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Karl Rosenkranz on Friedrich Schleiermacher (3 of 3)

Conclusion, continuing from Part 2: Rosenkranz defended Schleiermacher from some of the criticisms directed against him. For instance, in Der christliche Glaube § 170, Schleiermacher writes that the teaching of the Trinity cannot be derived philosophically. Rosenkranz writes that this is not because Schleiermacher rejects the teaching of the Trinity but rather a statement that it cannot be derived from his philosophy. It's notable that in § 170, Schleiermacher accurately argues that the dogma of the Trinity cannot be lifted directly from the Gospel of John. The doctrine of the Trinity developed over time through much controversy, and was first clearly established as Christian orthodox doctrine by the Council of Nicaea of 325 CE.


At the same time, Rosenkranz was not satisfied with Schleiermacher's treatment of the Third Person of the Trinity, the Holy Spirit, as something like a metaphor for the Christian church itself, the church in the sense of the mystical body of Christ. "Der heilige Geist ist nach Schleiermacher die Vereinigung des göttlichen Wesens mit der menschlichen Natur in der Form des das Gesammtleben der Gläubigen beseelenden Gemeingeistes." (The Holy Spirit is, according to Schleiermacher, the unity of the divine essence with human nature in the form of that of the common life of the believers annimated by the spirit of the community.) Rosenkranz argues that with this conception, "hat Schleiermacher auch den Begriff des göttlichen Geistes nicht erreicht." (Schleiermacher also did not reach the concept of the divine Spirit.) Rosenkranz argues that the doctrine of the Trinity requires a more clear designation of the Holy Spirit as a divine Person with an identity distinct from the Church. He argues that Schleiermacher only makes "Analogieen vom Geist eines Volkes und vom Geist der Menschheit." (analogies with the spirit of a people and with the spirit of humanity.)

Rosenkranz describes the period of Schleiermacher's thought represented by Der christliche Glaube as one in which "verwicklete Schleiemacher sich immer bestimmter in den Widerspruch, die Theologie philosophisch begründen und sie nichts desto weniger von der Philosophie unabhängig machen zu wollen." [Scheiermacher became more and more decidedly entangled in the contradiction, that he wanted to ground theology philosophically and nevertheless to make it independent of philosophy.] (emphasis in original)

The criticisms sketched above are the major ones identified by Rosenkranz in his critique of Schleiermacher's theology. Along the way, he deals with numerous other provocative aspects of it. Rosenkranz treats Schleiermacher's work with respect although in places he makes emphatic arguments against it.

For example, Rosenkranz is partially critical and partially supportive of Schleiermacher's approach to the more fantastic aspects of the Christian Scriptures. Schleiermacher argued for the application of reason to Christian religious understanding and contended that the "signs and wonders" of the Bible should be understood as stories conveying important religious truths, not as actual physical events. And Schleiermacher dismisses angels and the Devil as products of the imagination. As Rosenkranz characterizes Schleiermacher's position:

In Bezug auf die beiden Anhänge zum Lehrstücke von der Schöpfung, nämlich von den Engeln und vom Teufel, müssen wir Schleiermacher's [sic] Folgerichtigkeit rühmen. Diese Vorstellungen sind für ihn inhaltslos und können nur als ein durch die Tradition entstandenes Anhängsel des frommen Gefühls genommen werden. Ein so in sich seinem Begriff ruhendes Selbstbewußtsein, wie das seinige, ist gegen solche Imaginationen absolut sicher gestellt.

[In relation to the two attachments of the angels and the Devil to the portions of the teachings on the Creation, we must praise Schleiermacher's consistency. These concepts are for him without content and can only be taken as appendages of pious feeling. A self-consciousness that is so content in its notion as his is absolutely fixed against such imaginary figures.]
Although it wouldn't have been the best translation to put it this way, what Rosenkranz is saying there is that Schleiermacher is confident enough in his basic conception of Christian theology that he has no problem excluding such notion as angels and the Devil which are inconsistent with his conception. And Rosenkranz praises him for his consistency, which would even today would cause discomfort among many of the pious.

But while Rosenkranz makes it clear that he's no fan of the resurgent "mystical obscurantism" of that time which embraces concepts like Satan and angels in a superstitious way, he also expresses concern that a superficial dismissal of those Scriptural notions risks missing important aspects of Christian teaching about good and evil.

Friedrich Schleiermacher
Another notable aspect of Rosenkranz’ evaluation of Schleiermacher’s theology is his observation that Schleiermacher undervalues the Old Testament:

In Bezug auf das alte Testament, §. 132., geht Schleiermacher aber so weit, daß er ihm die normale Dignität und die Eingebung der Neutestamentischen Schriften abspricht und als Grund für seine Aufnahme in unsere Bibel theils nur die Berufung der Neutestamentischen Schriften auf die Alttestamentischen, theils den geschichtlichen Zusammenhang des christlichen Gottesdienstes mit der Jüdischen Synagoge anführt. Sollte aber der Grund, weshalb wir Christen das Alte Testament mit dem Neuen immer zusammengefaßt haben, wirklich nur ein so äußerlicher sein? Sollte nur die anfängliche Beschaffenheit unseres Cultus, sein erster Hervorgang aus dem Jüdischen, und wieterhin das Bedürfniß der historischen Erklärung des Neuen Testamentes das Band dieser Schriften sein. Ist nicht auch ein innerer Zusammenhang derselben da, eine innere gegenseitige Ergänzung, welche auch für uns Christen das regste Interesse an dem Alten Testament aufrecht hält, unabhängig von aller Historie, Philologie und Enrichtung des Cultus?

[But in relation to the Old Testament, § 132, Schleiermacher goes so far as to deny it the normal dignity and the inspiration of the New Testament. And as a basis for its inclusion in our Bible, partially he partially cites the historical connection of the Christian religious services with the Jewish synagogue. But should the reason why we Christians have always combined it with the New really be such a merely superficial one? Should only the early condition of our religious tradition, its original emergence out of the Jewish tradition, and further the need for the historical clarification of New Testament, be the link of these Scriptures {Old and New Testament}? Is not there also an inner connection between the two there, an inner supplementation, which continues to hold the most intense interest even for us Christians, independent from all history, philology and the establishment of the religious tradition?] (italics in original)
Schleiermacher shared with other Romantics the notion of united nature and reason and of the centrality of love to his philosophy of the Christian religion. But his philosophy of religion departed significantly from that of Hegel and an Old Hegelian like Karl Rosenkranz. Hegel himself wrote, in lines that he likely applied to the philosophy of his colleague Schleiermacher in Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Religion, Teil 3: Die vollendete Religion (1924), "Wäre Gott nur in der Empfindung, so ständen die Menschen nicht höher wie die Tiere; er ist zwar auch für das Gefühl, aber nur in der Erscheinung." (If God existed only in feeling, then humans would stand no higher than the animals; he also exists for feeling, but only in the appearance.) Hegel and Rosenkranz believed Schleiermacher relied too exclusively on the subjective view in describing the reality of God, that his philosophy failed to describe the objective aspect of God's reality.

Tags: , ,

Monday, June 20, 2011

Karl Rosenkranz on Friedrich Schleiermacher (2 of 3)

Friedrich Schleiermacher

Continuing from Part 1 yesterday: Rosenkranz describes his more general Hegelian criticism of Schleiermacher's dialectics as follows, saying the deficiency is:

... daß alle Bestimmungen von ihm nur in der Reflexion des Positiven und Negativen genommen werden, ohne weder die Entgegensetzung als wirklichen Widerspruch, noch auch die Aufhebung des Widerspruchs in seiner Grunde zu erkennen, in welchem, als der Einheit der Entgegengesetzten, das bloße Beziehen verschidener Seiten ein Ende hätte. So stehen sich nun Sünde und Gnade, der Mensch und Christus, die menschliche und die göttliche Natur, die Welt und die Kirche, die Gegenwart und die Zukunft der Kirche nur einander gegenüber, statt sich lebendig durch sich selbst als die Unterschiede der Idee zu bewegen.

[... that all he takes all analysis only in the positive and negative, without either recognizing the opposition as true contradiction, nor also recognzing the ablation of the contraction, which puts an end to the simple relationship of different sides. So stand sins and grace, human and Christ, the human and divine nature, the world and the church, the present and the future of the church only opposite one another, instead of moving themselves in a living way as the differences of the Idea.]
Rosenkranz is also dissatisfied with Schleiermacher's Christology. How can Jesus of Nazareth have been both fully human and fully God? Schleiermacher's answer is that Jesus was a man who was fully infused with the consciousness of God that he was aware of God in every moment of his life in the same way. He points to several aspects of Schleiermacher's argument that he finds deficient. In Schleiermacher's Christology, "weder der Bruch des Menschen so tief, noch die Einheit Gottes mit Christo so innig ist, als die Kirche lehrt." (neither is the rupture with humanity so deep, nor the unity of God with Christ so intimate, as the Church teaches) (S. 79) He writes that Schleiermacher's Christology is "von einem doketischen Anstrich gefärbt" (tinted with a Docetic color). Docetism is one of the classic Christian heresies, which argued that Jesus' human body was only an illusion, a belief that was incorporated into some forms of Gnosticism.


Rosenkranz notes that Schleiermacher's Christology is heavily rooted in the Gospel of John and its concept of Christ as Logos. But he also contrasts it with the image of Jesus that he sees in that Gospel. And Rosenkranz writes vividly:

Um so populär als möglich hierüber auszusprech, bitten wir den geniegten Leser, erst ein Stück von Schleiermacher's [sic] Christologie und demnächst ein Stück aus dem Evangelium Johannis zu lesen. Dort wird ihnen die Empfindung entstehen, welche uns bei jedem Großen anwandelt, ws zugleich seltsam ist; das Staunen über eine so einzige Persönlichkeit, die Verwunderung über ihr geheimnißvolles Verhalten zu Gott wird sie ergreifen. Sie werden sich angezogen und doch entfernt gehalten fühlen. Hier aber wird, trotz des unleugbar wunderbaren Anstrichs, die innigste Liebe zu Christus in ihnen entbrennen; seine Fremdheit wird sie stören und sie werden fühlen, daß wirklich Gott durch Christus in eigener Person zu ihnen redet; wer ihn siehet, siehet den Vater.

[In order to express this in as accessible a way as possible, we ask the readers who are so inclined to first read a portion of Schleiermacher's Christology and then next a portion from the Gospel of John. There {in the Gospel} the feeling will develop in you, which varies among us toward that Great Man {Jesus}, which is strange at the same time; the amazement over such a unique personality, the wonderment over his mysterious relationship to God will grip you. You will be drawn to him and yet feel yourself held at a distance. But here, despite the undeniably wonderful colors {of the story}, the deepest love for Christ will be aroused within you; his strangeness will disturb you and you will feel that God is really speaking to you through Christ in his own person; whoever sees him, see the Father.]
Schleiermacher's Christology is one illustration of his affinity with the Romantic thinkers like Karl Wilhelm Friedrich von Schlegel (1772-1829) and Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph von Schelling (1775-1854). Schleiermacher argued in discussing the Incarnation of Jesus that if God could take human form, that means that that humanity has the capability of taking on divine attributes. He viewed Jesus as having fully realized that capability.

(Concludes in Part 3)

Tags: , ,

Sunday, June 19, 2011

Karl Rosenkranz on Friedrich Schleiermacher (1 of 3)

Friedrich Daniel Ernst Schleiermacher (1768-1834) was recognized throughout the 19th century as a major Protestant theologian, as one of the most significant and politically democratic Romantic thinkers. Ecumenical Christian theologian Hans Küng considers Schleiermacher the most important Christian theologian of the 19th century and the first Christian theologian who developed a distinctively modern view of Christianity. He was also highly regarded for his philological work translating Plato into German, as a pedagogical reformer, and as an activist mobilizing Prussians to the anti-French resistance during the Wars of Liberation against the Napoleonic occupation.

Friedrich Daniel Ernst Schleiermacher (1768-1834)

Karl Rosenkranz (1805-1879), the Hegelian scholar and leading figure among the Old Hegelians, published his Kritik der Schleiermacherischen Glaubenslehre (Critique of the Schleiermacherian Religious Teaching) in 1836. Most of the content had previously been published in 1830-31 as a series of articles in the Berliner Jahrbücher and focuses on the content of the 2nd edition of Schleiermacher's Der christliche Glaube (The Christian Faith), which appeared in 1830. In the preface to the book, Rosenkranz describes vividly from his own experience in the 1920s Schleiermacher's ability to inspire his listeners and to explain complex and imaginative concepts in a clear way. The Kritik der Schleiermacherischen Glaubenslehre was a philosophical and theological reckoning with Schleiermacher’s Christian theology from Rosenkranz' Hegelian outlook.

Schleiermacher's theology was informed by the philosophies of his time and took full account of the historical-critical Scriptural studies of his day. Going beyond Enlightenment rationalism, he argued that faith must be understood as involving both reason and emotion. Schleiermacher wanted to situate Biblical scholarship and philosophical reason within a Protestant theology with a distinctly mystical element.

The mystical core of Schleiermacher's theology was heavily influenced by his own Pietist background. His father was a Reformed (Calvinist) Protestant minister, and Schleiermacher studied under the Moravian Brethern (Herrnhuter Brüdergemeine). Schleiermacher argued that individuals experienced the reality of God through their own feelings. And this feeling takes the form of an awareness of the individual's utter dependence on God. Rosenkranz found this too exclusively a subjective basis on which to describe God, who also must be understand as an objective essence in and for Himself.

Ronsenkranz' Hegelian understanding of Christian theology required the establishment of a clear distinction and contradiction (in the technical Hegelian dialectical sense) between the finite and the infinite. He argues that Schleiermacher’s theology fails to establish that distinction adequately:

Das Mengelhafte hierin ist, daß Schleiermacher das Endliche und Unedliche als einen abstracten Gegensatz behandelt; jedes ist; das Endliche aber ist abhängig vom Unendliche und hat im Verhältniß [sic] zu ihm den Character eines rein Bestimmunglosen. Es verschwindet im Unendlichen. Und doch ist es.

[The insufficiency in this is that Schleiermacher deals with the finite and the infinite as an abstract contradiction; both exist; but the finite is dependent on the infinite and relative to it has the character of a purely indeterminate thing. It disappears in the infinite. And nevertheless it exists.]
This is a quarrel on Rosenkranz' part with the notion, particularly emphasized by Protestant theology, of the transcendence of God. Kant’s philosophy is known as transcendental philosophy because of its speculative nature, and Kant influenced Schleiermacher's theology in important ways. In Rosenkranz' understanding, the finite and the infinite must be established not only in a subjective but an objective way. And in his view, Schleiermacher's theology is founded so heavily in that subjective experience of the individual's emotional perception of God that it provides no clear way for the individual ego to achieve the knowledge of the infinity of God.


Schleiermacher’s version of dialectics was different from Hegel's. In Hegel's dialectical concept of development, processes contained a positive contradiction in opposition to a negative contradiction, in a dynamic that resolved itself by what Hegel called Aufheben ("ablation" in English), in which the positive and negative contractions were both preserved and cancelled out as they are lifted to a higher level. Rosenkranz argues that Schleiermacher's dialectics failed to achieve the Aufheben/ablation of the contradiction between the finite and the infinite, which for Hegel takes place in the state of Absolute Spirit.

(Continued in Part 2)

Tags: , ,