Showing posts with label marshall ganz. Show all posts
Showing posts with label marshall ganz. Show all posts

Sunday, October 23, 2016

Democrats "down-ballot" - cautious optimism may be in order

One hopeful sign for the upcoming years is that President Obama has announced that he plans to promote building the Democratic Party at the state and local levels, an effort with which former Attorney General Eric Holder has also associated himself.

Edward-Isaac Dovere reports in Obama endorses all the way down ballot Politico 10/23/16 on Obama's high-profile presence is some down-ballot races:

President Barack Obama will make a late splash into races for state senate and assembly over the next week, endorsing roughly 150 candidates across 20 states.

He’ll also back a candidate for North Carolina state supreme court.

The endorsements — which will come along with a variety of robocalls, social media, mailers, photos of Obama with the candidates taken as he’s been traveling to campaign in recent weeks, and even a few radio ads — are Obama’s biggest investment in state races ever by far, and come as he gears up to make redistricting reform at the state level the political priority of his post-presidency.

This is the beginning of that effort, an unprecedented engagement all the way down-ballot for any president. [my emphasis]
A caution on that last assertion: "unprecedented" for many reporters and pundits means that they haven't heard such a thing being talked about in Beltway gossip before.

I've seen reporting about what a good get-out-the-vote operation the Clinton campaign has in place. But I don't recall coming across any reporting that evidenced any investigation beyond what they Clinton campaign was telling the press. The nitty-gritty reporting that would be involved in doing detailed investigations across the country, or even in key swing states, is not considered a sexy enough topic to make it into the horserace chatter that is the main interest of TV pundits. Even though the GOTV effort can have a decisive effect on the outcome of the horseraces, i.e., elections.

According to this, the Democratic Party establishment may be finally taking better account of the reality that has been hitting them in the face for a couple of decades or so:

Six years ago, Democrats felt they couldn’t even get Obama interested in House races. But now, after years of the Democratic bench being depleted on his watch, Obama’s looking to build it back. On top of all that: a concern within the Oval Office and through the West Wing with how much policy is being crafted in state capitals, from laws on reproductive health to climate change to voting rights.

“While Congress has been obstructionist and there’s been no substantive legislation moving under Republican control, what you see in the states is very, very different,” Simas said. “This has not been a focus of presidents in the past. But given what’s happening in state legislatures throughout the country, it has to be.”
This is something that progressive Democrats have been complaining about for years, shaking our heads in amazement that the Democrats seemed to be neglecting even though it is something that is important even in the crassest, careerist, opportunist mode for a Democratic Party that is competing against the Republican Party. On some issues - too many, actually - it may really not matter a lot whether a Democrat or a Republican is elected because they agree. But it does matter to the egos and the career opportunities of the candidates and their closest allies.

Part of the reason it's so frustrating is that there have been actual moments in very recent history when the Democrats did take greater account of the need for better state and local mobilization. One was during Howard Dean's chairmanship of the Democratic National Committee in 2005-9 during which he pursued a "50 State Strategy" to build the Party organization in all Congressional districts with the goal of regularly contesting Congressional elections in them all. Including ones conventionally considered "safe" Republican territory. It combined a long-term perspective (create as strong a Democratic presence as possible in politics everywhere) and short-term urgency (be positioned to take advantage of unexpected local developments). At the very least, contesting even "hopeless" elections would pressure Republicans to spend money to defend safe seats instead of channeling those funds to more heavily contested districts.

The 2006 mid-terms elections produced evidence that this was a promising approach. The Wikipedia entry on Howard Dean as of this writing observes:

The success of the strategy became apparent after the 2006 midterm elections, where Democrats took back the House and picked up seats in the Senate from normally Republican states such as Missouri and Montana. In the 2008 presidential election, Barack Obama used the 50 state strategy as the backbone of his candidacy.
It would go too far to say the 50 State Strategy was solely responsible for those results. Five years of war and misrule by the Cheney-Bush Administration, the Iraq War disaster and Hurricane Katrina significantly contributed to both those results. And then there was the financial panic of 2008 that was the hallmark of the Great Recession from which the US economy is still recovering.

The other major example is theorganizing effort headed by Marshall Ganz, a veteran political organizer for the United Farm Workers union, also under the auspices of Dean's DNC. Ganz has discussed the experience of that project in various places, including Organizing Obama: Campaign, Organizing, Movement August 2009. This is a good example of how grassroots activism affected the outcome of the 2006 election. It provided anr indication of the tremendous popular appeal Obama had and the potential he had for mobilizing public opinion for progressive goals.

Unfortunately, once in office Obama reverted to the conventional Democratic establishment approach. As Marshall Ganz frames the concepts, the Democratic Party went back to relying more on the marketing approach and less on the organizing emphasis behind OFA and the 50 State Strategy. Obama and the Democratic leadership abandoned the 50 State Strategy, replacing Dean at the DLC with Tim Kaine (yes) 2009-11, Donna Brazile as interim (2011), and Debbie Wasserman Schultz (2011-16), the BFF of the payday loan industry who became one of the chief symbols for the Sanders campaign of everything that is wrong with the Democratic Party. Donna Brazile is now back as interim chair, itself not an encouraging sign for progressive. Did I mention that it was Tim Kaine who succeeded Howard Dean in that position?

The grassroots organizing effort morphed after Obama's first inauguration into Organizing for America (OFA), which operated largely as a more conventional lobbying arm for the President and the Party. It later changed its name to Organizing for Action. If it has any notable continuing distinct influence of progressive politics or the Democratic Party, it has been successful in keeping it well concealed.

In the conclusion to the paper linked above, Ganz notes that adapting the organizing approach in 2008 was an exception in Obama's political career, despite having been a community organizer:

A highly motivated constituency, rooted especially, but not only, in the young, moved by a story of hope that engaged their values and drew them to candidate and campaign was transformed into a very powerful electoral force. To be sure, the financial resources generated to support this effort were extraordinary, but other campaigns have raised lots of money and not used it in this way. This effort was able to combine the enthusiasm, contagion, and motivation of a movement, with the discipline, focus, and organization that it takes to win.

This was not a foregone conclusion. Many have observed that since Obama had served as a community organizer, his campaign would of course feature organizing. However Obama‘s run for the Senate was as conventional a campaign as any. In fact Obama‘s experience of organizing was within an orthodox Alinsky approach of the lone organizer who "agitates" people into awareness of their "real" interests, takes values for granted, focuses on what‘s "winnable" over what‘s urgent, and views social movements as inherently unstable. And as Obama recounts, this experience left him disturbed by the loss of control he experienced, and unsatisfied by the limited aspirations. This is a far cry from the kind of "movement building" organizing that became typical of the campaign and of which Obama, in fact, had no real experience. In fact, Obama wrote of his belief that the way to win a campaign was to "turn it over to the professionals."

Although the inner circle of the campaign included many talented and creative people, skilled political operatives, and people who had run field programs for many years, it did not include anyone with any organizing experience outside the realm of conventional politics – and no one with movement organizing experience. The New Hampshire campaign was allowed to proceed with no organizing at all, relied almost exclusively on full time staff to get the "real" work done, supported by volunteers bussed [sic] in from Boston, not unlike the unsuccessful Bradley primary campaign in which the state director had been involved. Had this approach been utilized everywhere, it is very unlikely the movement [for Obama's 2008 election] could have ever flourished as it did. [my emphasis]
Combining "the enthusiasm, contagion, and motivation of a movement, with the discipline, focus, and organization that it takes to win" sounds like a good way for a party to go.

But while there is nothing inherently progressive or left about this approach, in the real existing Democratic Party the people who get active in politics through such an effort will tend to be those more closely aligned with the New Deal wing of the Democratic Party rather than the corporate wing.

That doesn't fully account for the Democrat's willingness in practice to concede so much political territory at the state and local levels to the Republicans. But it's certainly part of it. Corporate Democrats who drool at the thought of privatizing Social Security don't want a bunch of hippies who support expanding Social Security instead pouring into the Party.

The kind of people who will be paying Obama six figures or more for individual speeches over the next few years will mostly not be among those who would welcome such an influx. Nor will the clients who Eric Holder's Wall Street law firm services.

But good signs are good signs. Democrats need to take those when they come!

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Is the White House letting yet another crisis go to waste? Nuclear waste, in this instance?

A couple of characteristics have emerged as defining aspects of President Obama's leadership style to date. One is what Marshall Ganz identified in How Obama lost his voice, and how he can get it back Los Angeles Times 11/03/2010.. The times in which Obama became President called for transformational leadership. But what the Obama Administration has provided has been transactional leadership: "The nation was ready for transformation, but the president gave us transaction. And, as is the case with leadership failures, much of the public's anger, disappointment and frustration has been turned on a leader who failed to lead."

The other is a related point about Obama's response to crises, from David Bromwich in The Embarrassments of Empire: Washington Wonders What to Say about Arab Freedom TomDispatch 03/10/2011:

... Obama visibly hates crisis. He is so averse to the very idea of instability that he seems unable to use a crisis to his advantage. Seldom, to judge by the evidence thus far, is he the first, second, or third person in the room to recognize that a state of crisis exists. The hesitation that looked like apathy and the hyper-managerial tone of his response to the BP oil spill offered a vivid illustration of this trait. [The democratic upheaval in ] Egypt brought out the same pattern. [my emphasis]
Now the very serious Fukushima crisis in Japan has Obama has a second major environmental moment of opportunity in a year, BP being the other.

And how is our transactional-minded President responding? Joan Walsh explains (The nuclear credibility gap Salon 03/16/2011):

... American leaders are putting their own credibility at risk by being so quick to reiterate the Obama administration's commitment to expanding nuclear power in the U.S. On Wednesday [Secretary of Energy Steven] Chu told Congress that officials planned to look at the "lessons" of the Japan disaster -- but he also told Rep. Joe Barton (R-Energy Industry) that the president continues to support expanding nuclear power in the U.S. at a cost to taxpayers of $36 billion, mainly in loan guarantees for new reactors, and to fund new small, modular reactors. To meet the president's clean energy goals, Chu said, "We believe we will have to have some fraction coming from nuclear." Without knowing the "lessons" of the unforeseen Japanese disaster, I'm not sure why any administration leader is making a full steam ahead commitment to nuclear expansion.

Chu's statements highlight the Democratic Party's dreary record in developing a compelling safe, sustainable energy vision in the two years since they took control of Congress and the White House (of course they lost the House in November). Democrats blew so many opportunities when they took control in January 2009, it's hard to say what was the most disappointing. Their response to the economic crisis was an inadequate, politically compromised stimulus bill that's left too many Americans unemployed today. They passed financial regulatory reform that still offers plenty of room for the kinds of abuses that led to the 2008 mess. They extended the Bush administration's tax cuts for the super-wealthy, even though a promise to let them lapse had been central to most Democratic leaders' campaigns, including President Obama's, thus failing to reverse the steady upward transfer of wealth that's deformed American society over the last 30 years. [my emphasis]
As I mentioned in my previous post, nuclear power isn't economically feasible for private industry. They have to rely on major subsidies from governments, even before a Fukushima disaster happens and the government has to spend more piles of cash to deal with the crisis. American and German taxpayers are joining those from Japan in dealing with the results of the epic private enterprise failure at Fukushima.

Joan may overstate her point just a bit in the following. But it's still an excellent point:

Our profound lack of seriousness when it comes to energy policy is at the heart of most of our problems. Our reliance on coal is destroying the planet; our reliance on foreign oil and gas leads us to coddle Middle Eastern tyrants and meddle where we have no national interests except energy, and right now it's threatening our fledgling economic recovery as gas prices continue to spiral. Meanwhile, even as the Japanese nuclear crisis worsens, a Democratic energy secretary is reconfirming his support for nuclear power. [my emphasis]
I suppose I should add what's beginning to sound like a ritual disclaimer: a McCain-Palin Administration would have had a worse record on environmental issues. With the Republican Party in full science-denial mode on environmental issues, any Republican Administration in 2013 will be worse. But on energy policy including offshore drilling and nuclear power, "not as horrible as the Republicans" just isn't nearly good enough.

Tags: , , , ,

Wednesday, February 09, 2011

Marshall Ganz on the Obama non-movement

Sasha Abramsky has a very interesting article on longtime organizer Marshall Ganz in The Nation, A Conversation With Marshall Ganz 02/03/2011. I worked with Ganz some back when he was organizing director for the United Farm Workers Union (UFW).

He got quite a bit of well-deserved attention late last year with his article, How Obama lost his voice, and how he can get it back Los Angeles Times 11/03/2010, which makes an important point. The times in which Obama became President called for transformational leadership. But what the Obama Administration has provided has been transactional leadership: "The nation was ready for transformation, but the president gave us transaction. And, as is the case with leadership failures, much of the public's anger, disappointment and frustration has been turned on a leader who failed to lead."

Abramsky gives a fascinating biographical sketch of Ganz, who was the leader of the "movement" aspect of Obama 2008 Presidential campaign:

In April 2007 Ganz met with Obama and David Axelrod at Harvard. Intrigued by Ganz's ideas, they invited him to campaign headquarters in Chicago the following month. In June, after a series of meetings, Ganz was charged with the task of setting up a Camp Obama network, intensive community organizing–style training camps in which young people would be taught to tell Obama's story, to spread a message and generate the enthusiasm of a true grassroots movement. Its success was phenomenal, ultimately generating one of the most effective and broad-based presidential campaigns in American history.

While media consultant Axelrod was the numbers brain, the wonk behind the campaign’s caucus-and-primary strategy, Ganz was the brains behind the movement-building. No one, including Obama, understood what made the campaign so effective, so good at connecting with young people in particular, so able to fill the vacuum created by the collapse of old loyalties and coalitions, better than Ganz. He understood how to unlock the "prophetic imagination" of youth; the willingness to take the world from where it is to where you want it to be. "The blending of a grassroots organizing capacity with Obama really worked," he argues. "But it wasn't because Obama was telling anybody to do it." [my emphasis]
But, sadly, as she also explains, after the election the Obama team wasn't interested in leading an activist movement:

President Obama, Ganz says ruefully, seems to be "afraid of people getting out of control." He needed the organizing base in 2008, but he and his inner circle were quick to dismantle it after the election. Yes, Ganz concedes, they kept Organizing for America, with its access to the vast volunteer databases, alive; but they made a conscious decision to neuter it, so as to placate legislators who were worried about the independent power base it could give Obama. Following a meeting of key members of the transition team, they placed it under the control of the Democratic National Committee. It became, if you like, something of a house pet. Yes, President Obama proposed, and continues to propose, many good policies; but, the community organizing guru concludes, the fire, the passion and the moral clarity were left out of his postelection rhetoric.

... Ganz surveys what’s left of candidate Obama’s promise to deliver a cleaner, more uplifting style of politics. After winning in November 2008, Obama and his inner circle wanted to control the terms of the debate rather than be pushed from below by a chaotic, empowered, activist community. They wanted to shift Obama's leadership style, Ganz believes, from the transformational aura of his candidacy to something different; they wanted him to be a transactional leader, a maker of deals, a compromiser in chief.

"He’s not a bad man," Ganz says of the president. "His policy intent is not bad. But you don't have the opportunity to change history every day. The Obama campaign excited the whole world. It created an opportunity to build capacity and do real movement-building."

In losing sight of that historic opening, and in tamping down the activist energies the campaign had unleashed, President Obama’s inner circle lost a chance to change the country he leads. And then, intellectual polymath that he is, Ganz quotes the medieval Jewish scholar Maimonides. "Hope is belief in the plausibility of the possible as opposed to the necessity of the probable." [my emphasis]
Tags: , ,

Saturday, January 01, 2011

The Obama Administration: Strategic political problem? Or good enough at putting "points of the board"?

Frank Schaeffer is a recovering Christian Rightist and has some very insightful things to say about his former movement, of which his father was a major founder. And at one level it's refreshing that he isn't the kind of convert who goes from being a shrill rightwinger to being a dogmatic leftwinger.

Having said that, it's still annoying that in defending President Obama and the Democratic Party, he still likes to verbally punch the hippies, as he does in his year-end piece, Obama's Critics Owe Him a New Years (Fact-Based) Apology Huffington Post 12/31/2010. Why should Obama's critics like Paul Krugman apologize? "Why? Because 2011 will see the USA rebounding, the Democratic Party doing well in 2012, the country in boom times by 2013 and the President having a great second term." Okay, maybe he does have some of the convert's starry-eyed optimistic zeal! It's just focused on Obama and the Democratic Party rather than some actual lefty dogma.

Despite what Schaeffer says in his column, Paul Krugman and others like Robert Reich and Joseph Stiglitz have been pretty consistent over the last two years, in their cases specifically on the subject of the stimulus of early 2009 not being large enough to jump-start the economy. Their warnings against fetishizing the balanced budget are well taken. As are their related debunking of various conservative scare stories: the bond vigilantes are after us! We're becoming like Greece! The Federal Reserve is printing lots of money and is going to set off hyperinflation! If the economy booms and unemployment plunges in 2011, not only they but lots of other economists will be taking a new look to see what they missed. But such a turn of events would be near-miraculous.

And if Krugman and his Democratic sympathizers, including the DFHs of the blogosphere, are what Schaeffer means by "the Left", it's hard to imagine how he came up with this: "But the Left is also being shown up because it kept carping no matter what the President did." The latter specifically in relation to the Senate approval of New START, the repeal of Don't Ask Don't Tell, and the health-care compensation for Ground Zero workers. But did Krugman criticize any of those things? Did any of the front-page writers for Daily Kos? Anybody else who would be recognized by other liberals or progressives as liberal or progressive? Not that I saw.

Democratic progressives have generally been concerned about a number of serious and substantive policy issues: the failure to prosecute perpetrators of torture and war crimes from the previous administration; the inadequacy of the stimulus to push the economy into a healthy recovery which thereby risks the danger of a liquidity trap that could produce something like Japan's "lost decade" of the 1990s; the escalation of the Afghanistan War; government secrecy claims literally more extreme than those made by the Cheney-Bush administration; a health care reform bill structured in a way that makes it highly vulnerable to attack by Republicans and to nullification of many of its practical benefits by private insurers - yes, including the critical weakness of not having a public option; a financial reform bill that doesn't restrain the financial derivatives practices that crashed the financial system in 2008; the continuation of Bush's tax subsidies for billionaires coupled with a payroll tax reduction that sets up Social Security for phaseout advocates, which will likely include the President himself.

The Washington Post's E. J. Dionne did a milder version of the same in his Post column, Liberals should accept defeat and get back to their goals 12/30/2010, and in his 12/31/2010 guest appearance on the PBS Newshour (transcript here):



This is Dionne's basic pitch from his column:
For the president's loyalists, of course, this indictment is profoundly unfair. He inherited a mess at home and abroad. The economic downturn began on Bush's watch, but its bitter fruits were harvested after Obama took office. By contrast, Franklin Roosevelt took power after Herbert Hoover had presided over three of the most miserable years in American economic history. Blame was firmly fixed on Hoover by the time FDR showed up with his jaunty smile and contagious optimism. And, yes, there is the small issue of Obama's real achievements, the health-care law, above all. If insuring 32 million more Americans is not an enormous social reform, then nothing can be said to count as change. The now well-rehearsed list of additional accomplishments - from Wall Street and student-loan reform to the end of "don't ask, don't tell" to the simple fact that the economy's catastrophic slide was halted and reversed - would, in the abstract, do any administration proud.
As strange as it may strike Frank Schaeffer and E. J. Dionne, it is possible for Democratic base voters and activists to walk and talk at the same time. We can praise Harry Reid for getting New START and DADT repeal through the Senate, and still point out that the decision to continue the filibuster rule in the 2009-10 Senate was brutally damaging to official Democratic positions and to the Democrats' political standing. I attended the Netroots Nation convention in 2010 where Elizabeth Warren was a guest. And from what I could see, those DFH liberals there regarded her as a heroine. Those same liberals who also cheered for her appointment to head the Consumer Protection agency which she was instrumental in getting enacted can also look at the financial reform bill that contained it and see that it failed to enact adequate regulations to address the known and highly consequential risks associated with financial buccaneering with derivatives.

Unless we regard politics as little more than a sports event, in which putting "points on the board" for Our Side is the only thing that matters - and that is pretty much how our star pundits regard it! - then any adult of reasonable mental competence should be able to see things of which they approve as well as things they don't in this Administration.

It doesn't fit in the points-on-the-board framework that both Schaeffer and Dionne use in these examples. But Marshall Gans' Ganz'op-ed, How Obama lost his voice, and how he can get it back Los Angeles Times 11/03/2010, which I've quoted here before, makes an important point. The times in which Obama became President called for transformational leadership. But what the Obama Administration has provided has been transactional leadership: "The nation was ready for transformation, but the president gave us transaction. And, as is the case with leadership failures, much of the public's anger, disappointment and frustration has been turned on a leader who failed to lead."

This is a valid point, though Obama's popularity ratings have held up well, and it was Congress that was the more direct target of discontent in 2010 for the obvious fact that members of Congress were up for election and Obama wasn't. But the Republican Party does take a longer view in their political strategy, looking toward transformational opportunities. They know that fighting for an issue that can define the Party strategically and losing can be a failure in "putting points on the board" but an important success in the longer run effort to frame the issues in the media and the public discussion.

If the Democratic President in his State of the Union address later this month endorses Social Security Phaseout, that is likely to be a transformational moment. But not in a good way for most people. And not in a good way for the Democrats in either the long term or the point-scoring game. 

And regardless of what position it occupies at the moment on the left-to-right scale as determined by the Beltway Village, the Obama Administration's failure to properly investigate and prosecute known criminal actions by the Cheney-Bush Administration, especially the torture program in which both Bush and Cheney have publicly and explicitly acknowledged being involved in acts that a are unquestionably criminal, is a fundamental failure in its duty to defend the Constitution and the laws of the country. The torture issue isn't going away. But Constitutional government was nullified in significant ways by the previous Administration. And the failure to prosecute all but guarantees that the next Republican Administration will consider itself even less bound by US or international law. 

Tags: , , , ,