This is a PBS Newshour report from 03/29/2011 on the current state of findings on short- and long-term effects of the Chernobyl nuclear accident, Revisiting Chernobyl: A Nuclear Disaster Site of Epic Proportions. At around 8:30, they talk about scientists' findings on the long-term effects of nuclear radiation in the vicinity of Chernobyl.
Tags: nuclear power
Showing posts with label nuclear power. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nuclear power. Show all posts
Tuesday, April 05, 2011
Thursday, March 17, 2011
Is the White House letting yet another crisis go to waste? Nuclear waste, in this instance?
A couple of characteristics have emerged as defining aspects of President Obama's leadership style to date. One is what Marshall Ganz identified in How Obama lost his voice, and how he can get it back Los Angeles Times 11/03/2010.. The times in which Obama became President called for transformational leadership. But what the Obama Administration has provided has been transactional leadership: "The nation was ready for transformation, but the president gave us transaction. And, as is the case with leadership failures, much of the public's anger, disappointment and frustration has been turned on a leader who failed to lead."
The other is a related point about Obama's response to crises, from David Bromwich in The Embarrassments of Empire: Washington Wonders What to Say about Arab Freedom TomDispatch 03/10/2011:
And how is our transactional-minded President responding? Joan Walsh explains (The nuclear credibility gap Salon 03/16/2011):
Joan may overstate her point just a bit in the following. But it's still an excellent point:
Tags: barack obama, joan walsh, marshall ganz, nuclear power, obama administration
The other is a related point about Obama's response to crises, from David Bromwich in The Embarrassments of Empire: Washington Wonders What to Say about Arab Freedom TomDispatch 03/10/2011:
... Obama visibly hates crisis. He is so averse to the very idea of instability that he seems unable to use a crisis to his advantage. Seldom, to judge by the evidence thus far, is he the first, second, or third person in the room to recognize that a state of crisis exists. The hesitation that looked like apathy and the hyper-managerial tone of his response to the BP oil spill offered a vivid illustration of this trait. [The democratic upheaval in ] Egypt brought out the same pattern. [my emphasis]Now the very serious Fukushima crisis in Japan has Obama has a second major environmental moment of opportunity in a year, BP being the other.
And how is our transactional-minded President responding? Joan Walsh explains (The nuclear credibility gap Salon 03/16/2011):
... American leaders are putting their own credibility at risk by being so quick to reiterate the Obama administration's commitment to expanding nuclear power in the U.S. On Wednesday [Secretary of Energy Steven] Chu told Congress that officials planned to look at the "lessons" of the Japan disaster -- but he also told Rep. Joe Barton (R-Energy Industry) that the president continues to support expanding nuclear power in the U.S. at a cost to taxpayers of $36 billion, mainly in loan guarantees for new reactors, and to fund new small, modular reactors. To meet the president's clean energy goals, Chu said, "We believe we will have to have some fraction coming from nuclear." Without knowing the "lessons" of the unforeseen Japanese disaster, I'm not sure why any administration leader is making a full steam ahead commitment to nuclear expansion.As I mentioned in my previous post, nuclear power isn't economically feasible for private industry. They have to rely on major subsidies from governments, even before a Fukushima disaster happens and the government has to spend more piles of cash to deal with the crisis. American and German taxpayers are joining those from Japan in dealing with the results of the epic private enterprise failure at Fukushima.
Chu's statements highlight the Democratic Party's dreary record in developing a compelling safe, sustainable energy vision in the two years since they took control of Congress and the White House (of course they lost the House in November). Democrats blew so many opportunities when they took control in January 2009, it's hard to say what was the most disappointing. Their response to the economic crisis was an inadequate, politically compromised stimulus bill that's left too many Americans unemployed today. They passed financial regulatory reform that still offers plenty of room for the kinds of abuses that led to the 2008 mess. They extended the Bush administration's tax cuts for the super-wealthy, even though a promise to let them lapse had been central to most Democratic leaders' campaigns, including President Obama's, thus failing to reverse the steady upward transfer of wealth that's deformed American society over the last 30 years. [my emphasis]
Joan may overstate her point just a bit in the following. But it's still an excellent point:
Our profound lack of seriousness when it comes to energy policy is at the heart of most of our problems. Our reliance on coal is destroying the planet; our reliance on foreign oil and gas leads us to coddle Middle Eastern tyrants and meddle where we have no national interests except energy, and right now it's threatening our fledgling economic recovery as gas prices continue to spiral. Meanwhile, even as the Japanese nuclear crisis worsens, a Democratic energy secretary is reconfirming his support for nuclear power. [my emphasis]I suppose I should add what's beginning to sound like a ritual disclaimer: a McCain-Palin Administration would have had a worse record on environmental issues. With the Republican Party in full science-denial mode on environmental issues, any Republican Administration in 2013 will be worse. But on energy policy including offshore drilling and nuclear power, "not as horrible as the Republicans" just isn't nearly good enough.
Tags: barack obama, joan walsh, marshall ganz, nuclear power, obama administration
Wednesday, March 16, 2011
The economics of nuclear power, the industry that survives by sucking on the public tit
They weren't great before the Fukushima disaster. Presumably increased safety awareness will make them even more expensive. Robert Reich in Safety on the Cheap 03/15/2011 talks about why the public and the regulators need to stay aware of the pressure to cut corners on safety that is built into the incentive system for corporations under our current laws:
Chapter 3 of this study from the Strategic Studies Institute (SSI) of the US Army War College, Nuclear Power's Global Expansion: Weighing Its Costs and Risks, Henry Sokolski, ed. 12/31/2010, is on the wonky side but informative. The authors of that chapter write:
In other words, this dangerous, expensive source of energy with sub-standard reliability is surviving not on the magic of the "free market," but on the generosity of taxpayers. Public money would be much better spent developing renewable sources that provide cheaper, cleaner and more reliable power.
Tags: fukushima, nuclear power, robert reich
Don’t get me wrong. No company can be expected to build a nuclear reactor, an oil well, a coal mine, or anything else that’s one hundred percent safe under all circumstances. The costs would be prohibitive. It’s unreasonable to expect corporations to totally guard against small chances of every potential accident.And he adds the important conclusion, "It’s also why the public in every nation is endangered if the political clout of its biggest corporations — BP, Halliburton, Massey, G.E., or TEPCO — grows too large."
Inevitably there’s a tradeoff. Reasonable precaution means spending as much on safety as the probability of a particular disaster occurring, multiplied by its likely harm to human beings and the environment if it does occur.
Here’s the problem. Profit-making corporations have every incentive to underestimate these probabilities and lowball the likely harms.
Chapter 3 of this study from the Strategic Studies Institute (SSI) of the US Army War College, Nuclear Power's Global Expansion: Weighing Its Costs and Risks, Henry Sokolski, ed. 12/31/2010, is on the wonky side but informative. The authors of that chapter write:
The Economist observed in 2001 that "Nuclear power, once claimed to be too cheap to meter, is now too costly to matter—cheap to run but very expensive to build." Since then, it has become even more costly to build, and in a few years, as old fuel contracts expire, it is expected to become more expensive to run. Its total cost now markedly exceeds that of coal- and gas-fired power plants, let alone the cheaper decentralized competitors described below. [my emphasis]"Wind, cogeneration, and end-use efficiency" are among that latter group. They explain that private capital does not consider nuclear power a good investment anywhere in the world, including the United States, and that public subsidies are required to make it economically viable for private companies.
In other words, this dangerous, expensive source of energy with sub-standard reliability is surviving not on the magic of the "free market," but on the generosity of taxpayers. Public money would be much better spent developing renewable sources that provide cheaper, cleaner and more reliable power.
Tags: fukushima, nuclear power, robert reich
Monday, March 14, 2011
The Fukushima "black swan"

Before Black Swan became a household word as a movie with a dark theme and a lesbian kiss, it was already being used as a metaphor for an extremely unlikely risk, popularized by The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable (2007) by Nassim Nicholas Taleb.
Risk calculations involve not only the likelihood of doing well versus doing poorly, but also assumptions about what those are likely to mean. Consumers make such assumptions, with varying degrees of consciousness and care in evaluation, when buying insurance. A homeowner far from any earthquake zone would likely calculate that the possibility of an earthquake was extremely low, and the likely damage if any to the house would be small. Homeowners living a mile from a major seismic fault will presumably recognize a much higher likelihood of both an earthquake event and potentially large damages from one of them. For the homeowner far from an earthquake zone, an earthquake would be a "black swan" event, i.e., extremely unlikely.
The crisis at the Fukushima power plant in Japan in the wake of last week's earthquake and tsunami has once again dramatized the very real risks in nuclear power. Calculating risks in nuclear power also require some calculation of risk. A big challenge with nuclear power risk calculations is that while the risk of a catastrophic event can be greatly mitigated, the effects of a catastrophic event occurring can be huge. This affects the economics of nuclear power because even unlikely risks impose significant costs in terms of safety features that have to be built into nuclear power plants. That factor is largely responsible for the wildly optimistic expectations in the 1950s worldwide that nuclear energy could provide cheap and abundant power.
Mother Jones' environmental reporter Kate Sheppard explains (Japan's Nuclear Emergency 03/12/2011; 6:22 update) that in the current Japanese crisis, we saw an overlapping of risk events:
Several people have asked me what this incident says about whether nuclear plants are built to withstand earthquakes. Plants are supposed to be able to handle the anticipated quake intensity and likelihood relevant to their location, but it appears that this quake in Japan was far stronger than anticipated. Moreover, the problem here looks to be more of a power supply issue, a secondary effect of the quake and tsunami. It's the combination of events that created the bigger problem here. As Ellen Vancko, the nuclear energy project manager for the Union of Concerned Scientists and a former staffer at the North American Electric Reliability Council told me earlier today, "The one lesson we can draw from Japan is no matter how technologically advanced we are as a society, it's virtually impossible to plan for every curveball Mother Nature is going to throw at us." That said, it's probably not a great idea to put a nuclear power plant on an active fault line. [my emphasis]And, from The Automatic Earth blog via Business Insider, How Black Is The Japanese Nuclear Swan? 03/14/2011. This writer winds up arguing that the risk at Fukushima was foreseeable enough that it should not be characterized as a black swan event:
Proponents argue that the energy returned on energy invested (EROEI) for nuclear power is sufficient to power our societies, that nuclear power can be scaled up quickly enough as fossil fuel supplies decline, that there will be sufficient uranium reserves for a massive expansion of capacity, that nuclear is the only option for reducing carbon dioxide emissions, and that nuclear power can be operated with no safety concerns through probabilistic safety assessment (PSA).Many countries are likely to rely on nuclear energy for decades to come even in the best of circumstances. Oil companies can use an increased public perception of nuclear plant risks to promote the promise of cheap oil via further deregulation of their drilling onshore and offshore. But the risks or real. And the public should demand that regulators take full account of them.
I disagree with all these assertions. Looking at the full life-cycle energy inputs for nuclear power, it seems to be barely above the minimum EROEI for maintaining society, and the costs (in both money and energy terms) are front-loaded.
Scaling up nuclear capacity takes extraordinary amounts of both money and time. While construction can be speeded up, where this has been done (as it was in Russia), the deleterious effect on construction standards was significant. Uranium reserves, especially the high-grade ores, are depleting rapidly. The reduction in carbon dioxide emissions over the full life-cycle do not impress me. In addition, nuclear authorities make risk decisions without informing the public. They have consistently made risk calculations that have grossly underestimated the potential for accidents of the kind that can have generational impacts.
In my view, nuclear power represents an unjustified faith in the power of human societies to control extremely complex technologies over the very long term. Any activity requiring a great deal of complex and cooperative control will do badly in difficult economic times.
Also, no human society has ever lasted for as long as nuclear waste must be looked after. It needs to be held in pools on site for perhaps a hundred years in order to cool down enough for permanent disposal, assuming a form of permanent disposal could be conceived of, approved and developed. During this period, the knowledge as to how this must be done will need to be maintained, and this may be more difficult than is currently supposed.
We need to evaluate the potential for a nuclear future in light of the disaster in Japan. This was not unpredictable, and should have been accounted for in any realistic assessment of nuclear potential. It cannot realistically be described as a black swan event. [my emphasis]
Tags: fukushima, nuclear power
Wednesday, March 25, 2009
Is nuclear power the salvation of the Earth?
Stewart Brand
I heard a presentation last week from Stewart Brand, publisher of the legendary Whole Earth Catalog and who ranks as kind of an ur-hippie because of that. But to my surprise, the main part of his presentation was to hype nuclear power as the the solution to climate problems. I don't buy his argument at all. But it did inspire me to start paying more attention to the latest hype from the nuclear lobby.
The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, which became an online-only publication starting this year, is a great source on the topic. Thomas Cochran in this article argues that Safety and carbon mitigation must be top energy priorities, not advanced nuclear energy projects 02/05/09. He defines the key problems as follows: "proliferation; the risk of another catastrophic nuclear plant accident; spent fuel/high-level waste disposal; and poor economics."
To hear Stewart Brand tell it, none of those are problems worth bothering about. Proliferation? Why, we're dismantling all the nuclear weapons! No proliferation to worry about any more. Waste disposal? Shoot, we've got these super-cool invulnerable storage tanks that will last forever. Poor economics? It's because all these dang environmentalist keep insisting on all these safety regulations and stuff. Chernobyl? Three Mile Island? What kind of superstitious wimps worry about those?
He wasn't quite that crass in expressing it. But close. He's certainly drunk the nuclear lobby's Kool-Aid. And wants the rest of
I got the impression that Brand is impressed by the whiz-bang possibilities of the technology. And maybe if it were all being run by cyborgs like those in the Terminator stories, it would be fine. But then, those cyborgs don't really care about the human race surviving. In fact, they are mostly out to wipe out the human race because their master computer Skynet thinks humans are a threat to the planet. And it kind of has a point, but that's another story.
Terminator cyborg
But until Skynet and the cyborgs take over, those whiz-bang nuclear facilities have to be constructed and operated by human beings. And that's part of the problem. Cochran writes:
The most important factor affecting the safety of existing nuclear power plants isn't their design, but the safety culture at the plant. It's difficult to assess whether any of these nuclear plants is safe enough because the probability of a severe accident depends on many technical and human factors that are difficult to measure. Nevertheless, U.S. nuclear plants on the whole are safer today than they were two decades ago primarily because U.S. nuclear plant safety culture has improved. If another catastrophic nuclear accident occurs, it will likely be in one of several countries with demonstrably poor nuclear safety culture. Also, few, if any, of the states that are planning to construct their first nuclear power plant have adequate nuclear regulatory regimes and in several of these countries there is no evidence that a robust safety culture is in store. Thus, Washington and the nuclear industry should concentrate on improving the regulatory regimes and safety culture in these other countries. [my emphasis]I accept it as an unfortunately fact that there is going to be an increase in the number of nuclear power plants in the developing world. But I don't want to see additional nuclear plants in the United States. And pretending it's going to be the salvation of the planet is fantasy.
And, oh yeah, it's not only failed banks that have their hands out for federal handouts:
The domestic nuclear power industry is confronting two big economic dilemmas. In the United States, new nuclear power plants are uneconomical when compared to other electricity generating technologies and improvements in end-use efficiency; and the unit costs of new nuclear plants are so high that they cannot be privately financed. It appears likely that construction of new plants will remain cost prohibitive until the price of carbon emissions exceeds $50 per ton of carbon dioxide. The nuclear industry, through its congressional boosters, has already received large federal subsidies and loan guarantees to support the construction of a few new nuclear plants. It has received additional subsidies from states and local governments.Tags: global climate change, nuclear power, nuclear proliferation, stewart brand
Now the industry is returning to Congress for more taxpayer largess, claiming that it is needed to mitigate climate change and provide for jobs under the economic stimulus plan. We should reject this "lemon socialism" approach. The economically efficient way to mitigate climate change is to internalize the cost of carbon emissions through a cap-and-trade program or by carbon tax. We shouldn't subsidize the construction of new nuclear power plants, thereby penalizing alternatives that can provide climate-change mitigation quicker, safer, and cheaper. Subsidizing new nuclear plants is one of the least productive means to create jobs or to stimulate the economy in the next year or two, a key criterion of the stimulus package. [my emphasis]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)