Showing posts with label medicaid. Show all posts
Showing posts with label medicaid. Show all posts

Thursday, November 20, 2014

Third Way, "liberal trolls" for the Republicans

If Third Way in the United States was ever anything other than a liberal-troll operation on behalf of Republicans, it is no longer. Sidney Blumenthal was one of early leaders in putting it together, as he describes in his The Clinton Wars (2003). My impression is that his intention was to establish a firmer basis for liberal politics, even if with a corporatist twist.

But now its just another Centrism Fetishist outfit (to adapt a phrase from Joan Walsh) that pushes Democrats to be more like the Republicans. We see the electoral results of that approach in the 2014 midterms. Sam Stein reports in Following 2014 Drubbing, Democrats Fret Things Could Get Worse Huffington Post 11/18/2014:

The president has promised or pursued action on priority items for his base: deferring deportations for groups of undocumented citizens and announcing a climate deal with China. He's also trying to sand down the rough edges of opposition and dissatisfaction in Congress. After a public airing of criticism by Senate Democratic leader Harry Reid's office, staffers for the White House and the majority leader have reached out to each other to calm tensions.

Some in the party want him to go even further, arguing that at least showing good rapport with Republicans would improve the party's standing.

"He should take their veto-bait bills in stride, not overreact to their rhetorical and legislative excesses," said Matt Bennett, co-founder and senior vice president of Third Way, a moderate Democratic think tank. "It is very much in his interest that he be seen as getting the wheels of government moving again. That will help his legacy and the prospects of the next Democratic nominee." [my emphasis]
Probably 99% of what anybody needs to know about Third Way's perspective is this paper that scolds the Democrats for not being more aggressive in attempting to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid ("entitlements" in the Republican propaganda phrase which they use): Entitlement Reform (n/d; accessed 11/20/2014).

Friday, October 18, 2013

Obama and "Obamaism" after the non-negotiating negotiations and budget/debt deal this past week

This is excellent news: Labor puts Dems on notice: Don't touch Medicare and Social Security benefits Washington Post Plum Line by Greg Sargent 10/17/2013.

Robert Reich explains why that timely in What to Expect During the Cease-Fire 10/17/2013:

We know the parameters of the upcoming budget debate because we’ve been there before. The House already has its version — the budget Paul Ryan bequeathed to them. This includes major cuts in Medicare (turning it into a voucher) and Social Security (privatizing much of it), and substantial cuts in domestic programs ranging from education and infrastructure to help for poorer Americans. Republicans also have some bargaining leverage in the sequester, which continues to indiscriminately choke government spending.

The Senate has its own version of a budget, which, by contrast, cuts corporate welfare, reduces defense spending, and raises revenues by closing tax loopholes for the wealthy.

Here, I fear, is where the President is likely to cave.

He’s already put on the table a way to reduce future Social Security payments by altering the way cost-of-living adjustments are made – using the so-called "chained" consumer price index, which assumes that when prices rise people economize by switching to cheaper alternatives. This makes no sense for seniors, who already spend a disproportionate share of their income on prescription drugs, home healthcare, and medical devices – the prices of which have been rising faster than inflation. Besides, Social Security isn’t responsible for our budget deficits. Quite the opposite: For years its surpluses have been used to fund everything else the government does.

The President has also suggested "means-testing" Medicare – that is, providing less of it to higher-income seniors. This might be sensible. The danger is it becomes the start of a slippery slope that eventually turns Medicare into another type of Medicaid, a program perceived to be for the poor and therefore vulnerable to budget cuts. [my emphasis]

President Obama's remarks on Thursday after the debt ceiling crisis had passed for the moment (Remarks by the President on the Reopening of the Government, 10/17/2013) don't give defenders of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid a lot of comfort.

There are a number of disturbing things about the speech.

There's consistency. He gets harsh with the Republicans here: "But probably nothing has done more damage to America's credibility in the world, our standing with other countries, than the spectacle that we've seen these past several weeks. It's encouraged our enemies. It's emboldened our competitors. And it's depressed our friends who look to us for steady leadership."

But a few sentences later, he's saying: "And when we disagree, we don't have to suggest that the other side doesn't love this country or believe in free enterprise, or all the other rhetoric that seems to get worse every single year."

My fingertips would no doubt burst into flames if I were to say anything that sounded like it was even slightly taking the Republicans' side of this. But it is Obama's chronically inconsistent messaging to the Republicans. I actually doubt that the budget debacle "encouraged our enemies." What, the hardcore Islamist militants in Yemen trying to avoid drone-strike assassination have spent the last two weeks charged up over the US debt ceiling?

But if you're going to slap the Republicans with that kind of thing, you don't then need to turn around and say, oh, it's naughty "to suggest that the other side doesn't love this country." It certainly would be reasonable to conclude that the Tea Party Republicans don't have much love for the people of this country, at least the ones that aren't filthy rich white Christians.

He cites a credit-rating agency as an authority that he thinks we should actually pay attention to:

And you don’t have to take my word for it. The agency that put America's credit rating on watch the other day explicitly cited all of this, saying that our economy "remains more dynamic and resilient" than other advanced economies, and that the only thing putting us at risk is -- and I'm quoting here -- "repeated brinksmanship." That's what the credit rating agency said. That wasn't a political statement; that was an analysis of what's hurting our economy by people whose job it is to analyze these things.
First of all, the credit ratings agencies proved that they had, shall we say, quality and accuracy issues in the run-up to the start of the depression in 2007-8. Their ratings would have real-world effects if they downgraded US government bonds to non-investment grade, because it would force pension funds and others who have requirements for maintaining a certain portion of investment-grade securities. Otherwise, why is the President citing one of those organizations as an authority? It just reinforces the non-chronic Democratic habit of apologizing for being a Democrat, i.e., his statement implies that people should believe a solid bitness organization (in this case one of the clueless credit-rating agencies!) over the Democratic President. Just stop it, please!

He repeats the tiresome, abstract complaint about "Washington": "And, of course, we know that the American people's frustration with what goes on in this town has never been higher. That's not a surprise that the American people are completely fed up with Washington."

It was "this town" that caused the problem. Not, you know, the Republicans who wanted to force the world into a new financial crisis. It was "Washington." How did the President and head of the Democratic Party deal with the opposing party that was fully responsible for the recent crisis? Here are his mentions of the word "Republican" in this statement:

Because Democrats and responsible Republicans came together, the first government shutdown in 17 years is now over.
And I want to thank those Democrats and Republicans for getting together and ultimately getting this job done.
First, in the coming days and weeks, we should sit down and pursue a balanced approach to a responsible budget, a budget that grows our economy faster and shrinks our long-term deficits further.

At the beginning of this year, that’s what both Democrats and Republicans committed to doing.
Again, the Senate has already passed a solid bipartisan bill. It's got support from Democrats and Republicans. It's sitting in the House waiting for passage. If House Republicans have ideas that they think would improve the farm bill, let's see them. Let's negotiate. What are we waiting for? Let's get this done.
I understand we will not suddenly agree on everything now that the cloud of crisis has passed. Democrats and Republicans are far apart on a lot of issues. And I recognize there are folks on the other side who think that my policies are misguided -- that's putting it mildly. That's okay. That's democracy. That’s how it works. We can debate those differences vigorously, passionately, in good faith, through the normal democratic process.
The American people's hopes and dreams are what matters, not ours. Our obligations are to them. Our regard for them compels us all, Democrats and Republicans, to cooperate, and compromise, and act in the best interests of our nation –- one nation, under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all.
How many times is he going to rehash his famous 2004 no-red-America-no-blue-America speech? Forever, apparently. In the face of the most blatant attempts to politically sabotage the national government since before the civil war, the Democratic President presents the Republican Party as:

  • A party that deserves equal credit with the Democrats for ending the crisis (Mark Shields on the PBS Newshour 10/18/2103, Shields and Brooks on who will come out ahead after the shutdown 'cease-fire': "John Boehner, after all of this, standing at the precipice, about to plunge over, to send the country into default, only one-third of his entire caucus supported the resolution and the compromise crafted by the Senate.")
  • A party that contains some meaningful faction that deserves the label "responsible"
  • A party with which the Democrats share a commitment to concentrate on reducing budget deficits in the middle of a depression, with a weak recovery already seriously endangered by the drastic cuts made just this year
  • A normal party that can be expected to work in a "bipartisan" basis, at least on farm legislation
  • A party committed to "democracy," to debating differences "in good faith," a party willing to work within "the normal democratic process"

Only one of these even comes close to describing the real existing Republican Party as we've seen it in action this year, the part about an irresponsible joint commitment to focusing on minimizing federal spending during a depression and weak recovery. In other words, the one on which the corporate Democrats have successfully persuaded the People's Party to adopt a Herbert Hoover austerity economics perspective.

We just do not need any more Democratic Presidents that spend so much time trying to minimize the partisan advantages that the Democratic Party stands to gain from the most irresponsible kind of behavior by the Republicans. We really do not need another one.

I don't recall noticing the phrase "Obamaism" before I saw Rick Perlstein using it recently. "Even if Obamaism works on its own terms," he wrote, "it can't stop Republicans from wrecking the country. Instead, it may end up abetting them." (Why Obama Needs to Change to Win Rolling Stone 02/28/2013)

For me, there are two basic elements of "Obamaism" in the sense Rick uses it. One is his habit of framing issues in Republicans terms. In his Oct. 17 statement, he defended a moderately-conservative deficit policy by invoking the hardcore Reaganite attack on earned-benefits programs, "The challenges we have right now are not short-term deficits; it's the long-term obligations that we have around things like Medicare and Social Security."

Second is his obsession with bipartisanship with the Republican Party as a good thing in itself. Bipartisan agreement on policy is only as good as the policy being agreed upon. And by making holy bipartisanship a key goal of his Presidency, he gives the Republicans a club to beat Democratic policy into the ground with. Because if bipartisanship is an end in itself, he by definition has to have Republican cooperation to achieve it.

The two weaknesses of "Obamaism" come together nicely in his drive to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, known in the Beltway Village and the business press as "entitlement reform," aka, the Grand Bargain. It's a Republican goal, and to achieve it he has to have substantial Republican support. Teaming with the Republicans will anger something like 99% of the Democratic Party's voting base, which is a good thing in Obama's view of holy bipartisanship. He regularly brags about his own voting base being upset with him over something. That is a virtue in the eyes of this particular Democratic President.

We see that kind of Obamaism at work when he said during the run-up to the debt ceiling deadline, "When you hear government not compromising, we're compromising so much we're willing to open the government at funding levels that reflect Republican wishes, that don't at all reflect our wishes." (Obama: We're Willing To Fund Government With Republican Priorities TPM 10/07/2013) Rick posted a Facebook comment about that story the same day saying, "Even our wins are losses."

And, in fact, that what this past week's deal did. It funds the government at sequester levels, with new sequester cuts still scheduled, funds it only until mid-January when another continuing resolution will be needed, and sets up another debt ceiling fight for mid-February.

Obama endorsed the false equivalence the Beltway Villagers love so much: "There's a lot of noise out there, and the pressure from the extremes affect how a lot of members of Congress see the day-to-day work that’s supposed to be done here." It plainly was not "the extremes" that brought on the debt ceiling crisis, it was the "the extreme" otherwise known as today's Republican Party in Congress.

The following is a statement of a key idea of the neoliberalism that is not a distinctive features of Obamaism, it's the ideology that has corrupted large portions of the Democratic Party, as well as center-left parties in Europe:

And we shouldn't approach this process of creating a budget as an ideological exercise -- just cutting for the sake of cutting. The issue is not growth versus fiscal responsibility -- we need both. We need a budget that deals with the issues that most Americans are focused on: creating more good jobs that pay better wages. [my emphasis]
Now, he's right that we should be reducing the federal budget "for the sake of cutting." But the striking thing is his comment that "creating a budget" should be no "ideological exercise." This is the neoliberal idea, the End of Ideology, the End of History. Issues of government become non-ideological, a matter of technical management - because both "left" and right should agreement with Calvin Coolidge's ideal that the bitness of America is bitness, and that what's good for the Koch Brothers and Goldman Sachs is good for America. Everything else is the whining of malcontents who worry about labor rights, jobs, decent pay, women's rights, etc. Unimportant distractions from the Real Business of making gubment the best servant possible to bitness.

In an interview with Jann S. Wenner in the spring of 2012, Obama expressed this hope for the period after his reelection (Ready for the Fight: Rolling Stone Interview with Barack Obama 04/25/2013):

My hope is that if the American people send a message to them that's consistent with the fact that Congress is polling at 13 percent right now, and they suffer some losses in this next election, that there's going to be some self-reflection going on – that it might break the fever. They might say to themselves, "You know what, we've lost our way here. We need to refocus on trying to get things done for the American people."

Frankly, I know that there are good, decent Republicans on Capitol Hill who, in a different environment, would welcome the capacity to work with me. But right now, in an atmosphere in which folks like Rush Limbaugh and Grover Norquist are defining what it means to be a true conservative, they are lying low. My hope is that after this next election, they'll feel a little more liberated to go out and say, "Let's redirect the Republican Party back to those traditions in which a Dwight Eisenhower can build an interstate highway system."
It doesn't seem to me that the post-election Republican Party reflects any of those hopes. Yet there was the President on Thursday, talking about them in much the same vein. Dwight Eisenhower? Interstate highway system? There was no good reason to expect that in 2012 and even less to expect it now.

Kathleen Hennessey wrote of those groundless 2012 hopes recently (Obama's reelection did little to 'break the fever' in Washington Los Angeles Times 09/30/2013), "Whether the president’s thesis misjudged his opponents or was merely wooing supporters with wishful thinking is an open question." Actually, I don't think it's much of an open question. While he put up more resistance to being jacked around over the debt ceiling this time compared to 2011, it's hard to avoid the conclusion that his hopes for Republican rationality are boundless.

She also wrote:

Now, several months into his second term, with Washington on the cusp of the first government shutdown since 1996, the fever of brinkmanship has spiked. ...

Even as Obama campaigned on the notion, few in Washington agreed with the president’s analysis. The 2012 election never looked like a power-shifting election, and it wasn’t. Republicans lost a handful of seats but easily maintained their majority in the House. The Democratic majority in the Senate grew only slightly. The balance of power remained the same, and for the most part so did the politics.

Charlie Pierce (The Reign of Morons: The Presidenting Esquire Politics Blog 10/17/2013) take on the notion of non-ideological federal budgets:

This is, of course, ridiculous. Everything in politics is an ideological exercise. That's the way it's supposed to be. Paul Ryan's objection to social-welfare programs is entirely ideological; he does not believe that things like Medicare and Social Security are legitimate exercises of the power of government. He wants them eliminated. He wants the ideas behind them defeated, forever. His approach is more tactically nuanced than that of Louie Gohmert -- so is a tackhammer -- but the goals are the same. If one side of these negotiations is utterly ideological, and the other side if ideologically fastidious, on which side would you put your money? [emphasis in original]
Obama's neoliberal ideology paired with his obsessive pursuity of sacred bipartisanship would be bad enough if the Republican Party were actually conservative. Since at the moment and for the foreseeable future they are screaming reactionaries with a strong tendency to bouts of collective insanity, Obama's reverence for bipartisanship bears a disturbing mirror-image relationship to the reality-denial rampant on the Republican side.

Sadly, I don't think Obama's concluding words in his post-debt-ceiling-crisis speech were just a rhetorical flourish. I think he's actually expected the Republican Party in Congress to be able and even willing to rise to them:

And those of us who have the privilege to serve this country have an obligation to do our job as best we can. We come from different parties, but we are Americans first. And that’s why disagreement cannot mean dysfunction. It can't degenerate into hatred. The American people’s hopes and dreams are what matters, not ours. Our obligations are to them. Our regard for them compels us all, Democrats and Republicans, to cooperate, and compromise, and act in the best interests of our nation –- one nation, under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all.
Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid are good things. Obama and the Republicans want to cut them. Every month and every year that goes by without that happening is a real victory for the great majority of Americans.

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Thursday, October 03, 2013

The shutdown, the Williamsburg Accord and the President's strategy

So, the Reds have shut down the national government. (Sorry, I couldn't resist. I still think it's hilarious that conventional usage now calls the Republicans the "red" party.)

I haven't posted about the shutdown since it began early Wednesday morning. It's anyone's guess at this point how long it may go on. The analysis that sees this event as this Republican House's version of the Clinton impeachment, a kind of Constitutional coup, makes a lot of sense to me.

It seems that not only the mainstream press but much of Left Blogostan missed the significance of a Republican convocation back in January. Jonathan Chait writes in The House GOP’s Legislative Strike Daily Intelligencer 09/30/2013:

In January, demoralized House Republicans retreated to Williamsburg, Virginia, to plot out their legislative strategy for President Obama’s second term. Conservatives were angry that their leaders had been unable to stop the expiration of the Bush tax cuts on high incomes, and sought assurances from their leaders that no further compromises would be forthcoming. The agreement that followed, which Republicans called "The Williamsburg Accord," received obsessive coverage in the conservative media but scant attention in the mainstream press. (The phrase "Williamsburg Accord" has appeared once in the Washington Post and not at all in the New York Times.)

But the decision House Republicans made in January has set the party on the course it has followed since. If you want to grasp why Republicans are careening toward a potential federal government shutdown, and possibly toward provoking a sovereign debt crisis after that, you need to understand that this is the inevitable product of a conscious party strategy. Just as Republicans responded to their 2008 defeat by moving farther right, they responded to the 2012 defeat by moving right yet again. Since they had begun from a position of total opposition to the entire Obama agenda, the newer rightward lurch took the form of trying to wrest concessions from Obama by provoking a series of crises. [my emphasis]
I certainly don't want to detract from the blame that the Republican Party deserves in the shutdown. It wasn't "the politicians in Washington" who did this week's needless and destructive government shutdown. It was the Republican Party Members of the House of Representatives who shut it down.

Here's a stock both-sides-are-to-blame version from former General Electric CEO Jack Welch: Schmooze or Lose: How the Lost Art of Negotiation Led to a Shutdown Huffington Post 10/02/2013. At this point, such a position is simply a partisan Republican one. The main Republican position of course, is that it's the President's fault. By any rational standard, that's plainly ridiculous.

However, Democrats and the country more generally should expect a strategy from the twice-elected Democratic President that takes full account of the Republicans' behavior. And Obama has been sadly deficient in that regard.

He said on Wednesday, "I have bent over backwards to work with the Republican Party, and have purposely kept my rhetoric down." Gee, maybe it's time for a different approach! (Sam Stein, Obama To Wall Street: You Should Be Scared Huffington Post 10/02/2013)

Obama came into office at a time of acute economic crisis. And he passed enough of a stimulus to stop the slide and allow the economy to eventually limp out of a recession. But the economy is still performing far below capacity, unemployment is high and poverty has risen.

But from the very first, even while pursuing a stimulus package, Obama framed his goals in terms of giving priority to reducing the federal deficit. Even worse, he set his longer-term economic goals as a Grand Bargain, which originally envisioned: adoption of the Bob Dole/Heritage Foundation/Mitt Romney health care plan now known as Obamacare; raising taxes on the wealthiest; and cutting benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. He adopted a basically conservative understanding of economics in which austerity is good and virtuous even during a depression.

He didn't take it to the catastrophic extremes that German Chancellor Angela Merkel did in her management of the eurozone economy. But he relentlessly framed economic problems in terms of the virtues of austerity economics and budget-cutting. An essentially conservative framing that benefits the goals of Republicans far more than it does the goals of the Democratic base, which are generally reflected in the nominal goals of the Democratic Party.

By 2011, his Grand Bargain had come down to cutting benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid with nominal tax increases for the One Percent. That year, he tried to use the negotiations over the debt ceiling as leverage to get a consensus of Republicans and some Democrats big enough to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. It also showed the Republicans that he was willing to negotiate over the debt ceiling and forego obvious options like invoking the 14th Amendment or minting a platinum coin to make the debt ceiling confrontation meaningless.

The failure of that negotiation led to the "fiscal cliff" arrangement of late 2012. Even though re-elected by a healthy margin, he went back to pursuing the Grand Bargain even before his Second Inauguration. When the Republicans, still negotiating in bad faith, wouldn't make any kind of deal with him, the Bush tax cuts on the wealthy were set to expire at the end of 2012. At the last minute, he insisted on an agreement to restore a substantial amount of the tax cuts for the One Percent. If what he wanted was higher taxes on the wealthy, as he claimed, he could have gotten a lot more of it by just doing nothing and letting the Bush tax cuts expire.

It was after that the Republicans agreed on their Williamsburg Accord approach. They would surely have attempted something similar anyway. But his immediate postelection behavior surely served to increase their confidence that he could be rolled.

Robert Reich in Why Obama and the Democrats Shouldn't Negotiate with Extortionists 09/29/2013 recalls those previous negotiations:

Obama and the Democrats must not give in. They shouldn’t even negotiate with extortionists. ...

The President began negotiations with the Republican bullies in 2011 when they first threatened to default on the nation’s debt if they didn't get the spending cuts they wanted. He negotiated again at the end of 2012 when they threatened to go over the fiscal cliff and take the rest of the nation with them if they didn't get the budget they wanted. Now they want to repeal a law they detest. If we give in again, what’s next? A coup d'etat?
Obama is right when he claims, "I have bent over backwards to work with the Republican Party, and have purposely kept my rhetoric down."

But that's not adequate for dealing with an insurgent party intent on wrecking his Presidency. Austerity economics and credulous assumptions about the good faith of the other side aren't the likely to win this fight on any terms that Democrats can consider good.

And it's important to note that the Sequester and now the shutdown achieve the Republicans' goal of reducing government and imposing even more austerity policies than Obama wants. And, as of now, the Republicans are getting what they want.

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Sunday, September 01, 2013

The undead Grand Bargain and the platinum coin option on debt-ceiling negotiations

As a new fight over the debt ceiling approaches, it's worth remembering that President Obama has a straightforward legal power to avoid the whole farce, the ability to mint a platinum coin of any value and use it to finance debt payment obligations. The power is called platinum coin seigniorage (PCS).

So if there is a negotiation in which Obama and the Democrats make concessions to Republicans, it's because Obama has chosen not use the power he has to avoid it. In other words, he wants the confrontation for some purpose, like putting through his Grand Bargain to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid.

Paul Krugman has discussed the platinum coin option in Be Ready To Mint That Coin 01/07/13:

There's a legal loophole allowing the Treasury to mint platinum coins in any denomination the secretary chooses. Yes, it was intended to allow commemorative collector’s items — but that's not what the letter of the law says. And by minting a $1 trillion coin, then depositing it at the Fed, the Treasury could acquire enough cash to sidestep the debt ceiling — while doing no economic harm at all.

So why not?
Yes, it's that straightforward.

Also on the platinum coin option:

Beowulf, FDL Coin Seigniorage and the Irrelevance of the Debt Limit 01/03/2011

Joe Firestone (letsgetitdone), Coin Seigniorage: A Legal Alternative and Maybe the President's Duty Corrente 07/17/2011

Joe Firestone, End the Austerity War Against the People: Mint the Platinum Coin! Corrente 08/05/2011

Joe Firestone, Beyond Debt/Deficit Politics: The $60 Trillion Plan for Ending Federal Borrowing and Paying Off the National Debt Corrente 08/01/2012

Joe Firestone, A Counter Narrative to Peterson's New Economic Perspectives 10/30/2012

Paul Krugman, Rage Against the Coin 01/08/2013

Paul Krugman, Barbarous Relics 01/09/2013

Mike Sandler, Beyond Debt Ceiling, Trillion Dollar Coin Offers New Economic Paradigm Huffington Post 01/10/2013

Joe Weisenthal, COINTASTROPHE: White House Rules Out The Trillion Dollar Coin Option To Break The Debt Ceiling Business Insider 01/12/2013

Mike Konczal, The Game Theory of the Post-Platinum Coin Debt Ceiling Rortybomb 01/14/2013; this should be read in combination with Gene Lyons, Obama Has The GOP Right Where He Wants Them National Memo 01/16/2013.

Ezra Klein, Treasury: We won’t mint a platinum coin to sidestep the debt ceiling Wonkblog 02/12/2013

And as Firestone reminds us in Declaring the Grand Bargain Dead Is Premature FDL 08/31/2013, what Obama would be offering up in such a standoff would be cuts in benefits to Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. This is his Grand Bargain, at this point a painful misnomer. It would only be "grand" for investment banker and insurers who collected fees and bonuses while delivering substitute products for the cut programs that provide inferior service, even for those who can afford it, compared to the current arrangement.

And it this point the only real "bargain" seems to be that both Democrats and Republicans would agree to support cuts to benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. What those would would lose from the cuts would get in the "bargain" is pretty darn vague at this point.

Lori Montgomery reports in White House, Republican senators give up on budget talks Washington Post 08/29/2013, Obama has been offering up the Grand Bargain in negotiations with Republicans even this past week:

Through multiple meetings with White House Chief of Staff Denis McDonough, Deputy Chief of Staff Rob Nabors and Budget Director Sylvia Mathews Burwell, the group discussed a range of options, including a “grand bargain” that would involve a complete restructuring of Medicare, according to people familiar with the meetings, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe the private talks.

The group also discussed a smaller deal that would replace much of the remaining sequester savings — about $500 billion over the next eight years — with narrower reforms to Medicare, Social Security and other ­mandatory-spending programs, such as farm subsidies.

But the talks never really gelled, in part because Republicans would not consider raising taxes on the wealthy or corporations as part of the smaller deal, arguing that congressional Republicans as a whole would never agree to replace sequester cuts with higher taxes. Nor did they offer a specific strategy for raising taxes as part of the larger deal.
In the current vocabulary of our political elites, certainly including Obama loyalists, "reform" for Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid means "cutting benefits."

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Sunday, April 07, 2013

Today in Obama/Hoover/Brüning economics

There's going to be a lot of repetition in the fight to preserve benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid from the current attacks from President Obama and the Republicans. One that deserves a lot of repeating is one that George Stephanopoulos didn't make on This Week today when he hosted White House "strategist" Dan Pfeiffer. Stephanopoulos asked him about the proposed benefit cuts to Social Security justified by the "chained CPI" scam, which would also apply to veterans benefits and reduce those, as well:

PFEIFFER: Well, a couple of things. One, Senator Sanders is a passionate advocate, and has been a big supporter of the president. This president will -- this -- this chained CPI that's being referred to here, is something the president will only accept on two conditions. It's something Speaker Boehner and -- and Senator McConnell asked for in the context of the original negotiations, and those two conditions are, one, It's part of a balanced package that includes asking -- closing tax loopholes to benefit the wealthiest, and, two, that it has protections for the most -- for the most vulnerable, including the oldest seniors.

STEPHANOPOULOS: So there will be some carve outs there?

PFEIFFER: Absolutely. And look, this is compromise. And compromise means there are going to be some folks on both sides who are not happy. [my emphasis]
The point Stephanopoulos couldn't be bothered to make is that if "chained CPI" really were the more realistic measure of inflation that its advocates falsely claim it is, there wouldn't be any need to have special adjustments for anybody. The argument for the "chained CPI" is seniors won't be hurt by it. But the admission that implementing it may require "protections ... for the most vulnerable, including the oldest seniors," what Stephanopoulos calls "carve outs" is an admission that seniors really will be hurt by this.

Means-testing Social Security benefits is also something to be on the lookout for, and those "carve outs" referred to here are a form of means-testing. Obama and other opponents of Social Security want to introduce elements of "welfare" into Social Security to make cuts to the program more politically acceptable.

Pfeiffer also reminds us that the Herbert Hoover/Heinrich Brüning economics symbolized by "Simpson-Bowles" is still the operative policy of the Obama Administration: "Our budget includes investments in infrastructure, bringing jobs back to America, you know, preschool for our -- for -- for everyone, while still bringing our deficits down to the -- our debts down to levels that are talked about by commissions like Simpson-Bowles." (my emphasis)

STEPHANOPOULOS: But it hasn't seemed to change the dynamic at all, at least so far. Here's what part of what Speaker Boehner said. He said, "If the president believes these modest entitlement savings are needed to help shore up these programs, there's no reason they should be held hostage for more tax hikes. That's no way to lead, and move the country forward." If they're good ideas, he says, why not just do them?

PFEIFFER: Well there's -- there are a couple -- couple things here, George. First is, the House has passed a budget, the Senate has passed a budget. The hope is that those houses can then come together and work to try and find a compromise. The president's focused, in addition to the regular order process that members of Congress say they want, is to try to find a caucus of common-sense. Folks who are willing to compromise, who don't think compromise is a dirty word, and try to get something done. And -- but, if Speaker Boehner's position, as he said in that statement, remains his position, then -- then we will not make progress.
Phrases like "a caucus of common-sense" are weasel-words for cutting benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid.

The tiresome "compromise means there are going to be some folks on both sides who are not happy" is pretty much the Obama Administration's standard excuse to the Democratic voting base for why the White House is kicking them in the face yet again.

From the AFL-CIO, Tell Congress: No Benefit Cuts to Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid 11/08/2012:



Paul Krugman was on the This Week pundit panel to face off with one-time Reagan budget director David Stockman, who has just written a new book pimping Hoover/Brüning economics. Krugman said of the weak job figures that just came out:

I mean, the usual stuff, one month's numbers don't mean much. A lot of noise in the data. It might be revised up and all that. But yeah, I mean, what people forget, is two things. One is that the -- we say we avoided the fiscal cliff. But to larger extent we did not. In fact, payroll taxes went up. We had a pretty big hit to working Americans' incomes starting in January.

And the other thing is sequester is starting to hit and businesses have already been making adjustments in anticipation of that. So, we're actually pursuing a lot of fiscal austerity right now. You look at the CBO numbers on cyclically adjusted budget balance, which is your best measure. And we have had basically a contraction of about 3 percent of GDP since 2011, which is bigger, that's more anti-stimulus than the stimulus ever was. We're doing a lot of contraction on the fiscal side. And, you know, why should we surprised if that shows up in an economic slowdown? [my emphasis]
Krugman and others who haven't forgotten basic macroeconomics have been warning Obama and the Democrats for years now about pulling a "1937", referring to Franklin Roosevelt's spectacularly ill-advised decision to emphasize reducing deficits in 1937 after his re-election which threw the economy back into a new recession before it had fully recovered from the Depression.

Krugman challenged Stockman directly on a central point of his book:

This is actually, this is the core of my problem with David's book. Which is yeah, we have huge debt numbers. But there's a huge misunderstanding of what those numbers mean. People look at the big numbers, debt is 3.6 times GDP and say we're broke, the country has been living beyond its mean. We need to pull it back. But that's not what it means. It's a little known fact that America actually earns more on its investments overseas than it pays to foreigners, right? We're not deeply in hock to the rest of the world.

What has happened is that we've complexified (sic) our financial system. So it used to be that Jimmy Stewart's bank made a mortgage loan and that was it. Now some mortgage originator makes a loan, repackages the loan, borrows money using those mortgage security as collateral, so you can count the same debt twice and sometimes three times.

So we have this overly complex financial system which is why we need financial regulation to bring it back to simplicity. But it has nothing to do with excess. It has nothing to do with zero interest rates.

The big increase in debt took place during the years when the interest rates were reasonably high. So this is a terrible misunderstanding. And again, do you really want to raise interest rates in a deeply depressed economy?
Here Krugman whacks the White House for its Hoover/Brüning economic policies, and Ariana Huffington jumps in with a good point, though it's not quite clear why she thinks it's different that Krugman's perspective:

STOCKMAN: Can I just say Social Security CPI saves $100 billion over 10 years. It's one percent of the problem. The machinery is paralyzed. The Republicans can't own up to the fact that we need major new revenue sources. The Democrats keep saying Social Security isn't busted. It's busted. It is already running a $50 billion deficit a year. There is nothing in the trust fund. It's confetti.

KRUGMAN: I disagree with everything my colleague just said. But let me say, this is not about machinery. This is about people and it's about visions. We have two parties that have fundamentally different visions of what America should be.

We have Democrats who want an expansion of the safety net and have gotten it, mostly in Obama Care but they want it to be, you know, even more. And we have Republicans who want to dismantle a lot of the legacy of both the Great Deal, the Great Society and the New Deal. And of course we have, it's a paralysis because the parties do not agree at all on which direction this country should take.

HUFFINGTON: But Paul that's not true.

KRUGMAN: And the last election was not, unfortunately did not resolve it one way or the other.

(CROSSTALK)

HUFFINGTON: That is not true, that there's a clear distinguished vision at the moment. We have a 64 percent increase in suburban poverty, we have a doubling of people on food stamps and disability payments. We have millions of people's homes underwater.

And the administration is ignoring this crisis because they are prioritizing deficit reduction. They have bought into the Republican talking points. And this is not a right/left point, they are ignoring what's happening in Europe. The eurozone has now the highest unemployment rate it has had. All the austerity measures and the deficit reduction measures have not worked in Europe. They are not working here. And yet the administration is not putting forward a coherent vision that prioritizes jobs and growth. [my emphasis]
I'm a little concerned about Democrats/progressives using this argument without taking into account that the White House has adopted its own version of the generational-accounting scam the rightwing is so fond of, arguing that social insurance (Social Security and Medicare) for seniors is undercutting jobs and income for younger people. This is a poisonous Obama/Republicans argument, and supporters of Social Security and Medicare need to shoot it down and avoid feeding into it even indirectly.

AFL-CIO President Richaqrd Trumka approaches it this way: "Millions of Americans remain out of work and the job market is especially devastating for young people. Young people ages 20-24 are facing 13.3% unemployment rates. Without the prospect of good jobs in their early and crucial earning years, these young people will bear the cost of these proposed cuts in Social Security." (Damon Silvers, Bad Policy: President Obama's Budget Cuts Social Security and Medicare 04/06/2013)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Saturday, April 06, 2013

More on the Social Security/Medicare wobble watch

This has been a real "what Digby says" week. Because she has been following Obama's push for a Grand Bargain since before he was first inaugurated. In It's Official Hullabaloo 04/05/2013, she writes:

Mark this day. For the first time in history, a Democratic president has officially proposed to cut the Democratic Party's signature New Deal program, Social Security ...

Meanwhile prepare for a barrage of savvy, world weary commentary from your fellow liberals telling you that this is no big thing and that Democrats will not suffer even a tiny bit if they vote for a common sense proposal like this one. You will be shushed and told to calm down and take a chill pill. In other words, you will be gaslighted by fellow liberals who are embarrassed that you aren't being coolly accepting of something that is completely unacceptable. This is how this works. Tell them to STFU and move out of the way.
In A couple of elite Villagers explain their formula for deciding what's "sensible." 04/06/2013, she quotes from the bipartisan consensus between SocSec/Medicare opponent and "liberal" E.J. Dionne and SocSec/Medicare opponent and conservative David "Bobo" Brooks. She calls attention to their mutual joy at hippie-punching (a phrase which I believe she popularized in Left Blogostan). Here's establishment liberal Dionne: "I'm very glad a lot of Democrats came out against the president's proposal to change the index for Social Security because, if nothing else, this shows that President Obama has really been willing to put some hard stuff on the table."



And our old friend Bobo: "I, too, am glad Democrats came out against because it suggests there's something sensible in what Obama has proposed."

Digby observes:

It's good to know that one thing hasn't changed, even in this era of right wing cranks and Tea Party intransigence: Villagers automatically approve of anything the liberal faction of the Democratic Party is against. I'm a little bit surprised that it still has such salience but I shouldn't be. These people are very uncomfortable with the idea that the salt-o-the-earth Real Americans might be the true radicals while the tired old hippies and their nerdy political heirs are just trying to hold on to a country that doesn't starve old and sick people.

It's a very lazy and convenient way to order the world, but I'm afraid that when it comes to Social Security and medicare [sic] it might not be the best guide to how the people feel about it.
Part of this is a reflection of the extent to which the "culture wars" as they played out in 1968-72 still influence the frameworks used by today's Beltway Villagers. They're still assuming that the Democrats to be successful have to run away from George McGovern. But "liberals" like E.J. Dionne who oppose Social Security and Medicare can go [Cheney] themselves. McGovern himself addressed this issue last year, a few months before his death (George McGovern's Comments on Social Security and Medicare - January 2012):



Digby again:

Oh, and unlike a lot of important issues, these are issues voters understand very well and they vote on them. It's not abstract and theoretical. It will affect every American.

Not that it matters in the Village. To them the world stopped sometime around 1975 and "sensible" policies are defined by opposition to the crazy hippie fringe[.] I guess it makes them feel young again[.]
Here is what SocSec/Medicare opponent Barack Obama had to see in his weekly Saturday address today. He sidestepped any mentioned of cuts in benefits to Social Security, but he does promote the Medicare cuts:



I’ve already signed more than $2.5 trillion in deficit reduction into law, and my budget will reduce our deficits by nearly $2 trillion more, without harming the recovery. That surpasses the goal of $4 trillion in deficit reduction that many economists believe will stabilize our finances.

We’ll make the tough reforms required to strengthen Medicare for the future, without undermining the rock-solid guarantee at its core. And we’ll enact commonsense tax reform that includes closing wasteful tax loopholes for the wealthy and well-connected – loopholes like the ones that can allow a billionaire to pay a lower tax rate than his or her secretary.

This is the compromise I offered the Speaker of the House at the end of last year.
The framework he's building here is, not surprisingly, the same as that of the Republican Party, the Peterson Foundation and its various front groups, and other opponents of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, which is to cast programs that benefit the elderly or the poor as detracting from programs that benefit the young and productive.

This guy was more supportive of Social Security in 2008:



Bobo was also doing his weekly schtick with Sleepy Mark Shields on the PBS Newshour yesterday, Shields and Brooks on the Job Numbers, Obama's Budget Bargaining Prospects 04/05/2013:



Bobo at around 6:00 talks his pet Hernert Hoover nonsense about how unemployment is all structural and the federal gubment can't really do anything about it starting at around 6:00, and does the generational-accounting pitch, also known as the "greedy geezers" line. And he uses the you-do-this construction like a mechanic explaining to someone how to repair a flat tire:

You increase training. You increase infrastructure spending. You get the education system, and mostly you devote less resources, fewer resources to the elderly and consumption on health care for the affluent, and much more to young families and young workers, and shift what's turned into a -- really a redistribution machine at the age scale. [my emphasis]
This was their bridge to talking about Obama's proposed cuts in benefits to Social Security and Medicare. Here's how the liberal lion Sleepy Mark approaches it:

I mean, this is a real body blow to those who have accused President Obama of being a socialist.

This is hardly a socialistic approach.

In addition, I mean, for not taking difficult political stands, he's been bombarded by the liberal part of his own party and many liberal groups. You know, I think, Judy, that he's probably the last best chance we're going have to reach any kind of a big or semi-big agreement is in what the president is going to unveil in his budget next Wednesday.

And I think it's an absolutely legitimate point on his side to say that the Republicans have to come up with revenue if we are going to do this, because this is a blow to the Democrats. It's been the Holy Grail of the Democratic Party platform for the past 70 years, Social Security.

And, you know, I think, in that sense, we will find out whether the commonsense caucus that editorial writers and some of the leading pundits have spoken about, whether it's the Loch Ness Monster of American politics or whether it's a reality. [my emphasis]
If someone had nudged him fully aware, his response might have been a bit more coherent. But last week he sounded like he was on a double-dose of caffeine and was ranting about how the Roe v. Wade decision had been a big mistake and Real Americans oppose gun control, so being back to his normal state of semi-stupor was an improvement, I guess.

But he's clearly hopeful that the cuts to Social Security and Medicare go through, because that's the consensus of "the commonsense caucus that editorial writers and some of the leading pundits have spoken about," i.e., the conventional wisdom among the Villagers. So Sleep Mark's on board.

And so is Bobo:

Well, I think he's taking the right approach.

I mean, we have the Patty Murray, the Senate Democratic budget over here. We have got the Ryan budget over there. He's sort of a little closer to Murray, obviously, but he's sort of in the ballpark of where a deal will be cut.

And so some of the things I think are right and good policies, this chained CPI, which will be adjusting Social Security revenues or benefits. Some of the things, I think, are a little less persuasive. He's got some Medicare things which are not structural reform, but just trying to tamp down reimbursements at the same time as we are just running away from any kind of effort to control Medicare costs.

But if he can take this chained CPI, this Social Security thing, and he can put in a few little more moderate Medicare reforms, structural reforms, like combining Medicare A and B and some other things that I think that has some bipartisan agreement, then I do believe there are a number of Republicans who would be willing to give on revenues.

And then you -- we're not going to have a grand bargain, but then do you see a bargain. You see a functioning government making progress.
As Digby characterized his performance on NPR, Bobo "needs a little bit more in cuts for the elderly and the sick to truly make him happy. And Lord knows, the White House yearns to make David Brooks happy."

This will be a real dividing point in American politics, maybe as much so or more than the Iraq War has been.

Oh, yeah. The idea of cutting benefits on Social Security and Medicare ain't popular: As Sequester Deadline Looms, Little Support for Cutting Most Programs Pew Research Center 02/22/2013. All of 10% of the public supports cutting Social Security benefits, with 6% supporting cutting veterans benefits. "Chained CPI" that the White House says Obama will formally propose in his budget cuts both. Support for cutting Medicare is all the way up at 15%. The disconnect between the public and and the political/media elite on these issues is amazing.

Will the Bobos and the Dionnes and the Mark Shieldses who are so spectacularly wrong about this be discredited as Very Serious People when it turns out to be a screamingly unpopular idea and derails what's left of Obama's second-term agenda? Were those who were wrong about the Iraq War so discredited? Who knows, miracles can happen. But in any case, we should give all opponents of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid the chance to sympathize with each other that they were neglected prophets on this issue by defeating Obama's proposals to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Friday, April 05, 2013

Social Security/Medicare wobble watch

Now that the Democratic President is endorsing cuts in benefits to Social Security and Medicare in his budget to be formally proposed next week, we're going to see various Democratic partisans, Obama admirers and left-leaning journalists who prefer to stay on the good side of White House finding ways to go wobbly on defending Social Security.

Josh Marshall's Obama’s Dangerous Game TPM 04/05/2013 shows some hints of this. He articulates what he sees as the White House position:

In conversations with the president’s key advisors and the President himself over the last three years one point that has always come out to me very clearly is that the President really believes in the importance of the Grand Bargain. He thinks it's an important goal purely on its own terms. That's something I don't think a lot of his diehard supporters fully grasp. He thinks it's important in longrange fiscal terms (and there's some reality to that). But he always believes it's important for the country and even for the Democratic party to have a big global agreement that settles the big fiscal policy for a generation and let's the country get on to other issues — social and cultural issues, the environment, building the economy etc.
Watch for those phrases like "(and there's some reality to that)."

No, actually, long-term fiscal healthy does not require cuts in benefits for Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and veterans benefits. The long-term problems of growth in health care costs also adversely impact Medicare. But Medicare actually acts as a restraint on health care costs. And some more recent data on health care cost increases project lower growth than what has been assumed in previous years.

There's a good, very practical case for expanding both Medicare and Social Security.

But the conventional assumption is that "entitlements", the propaganda term for Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid preferred by their opponents to make them sound like "welfare", are some dire threat to the country's economic well-being. As conditions change, the justifications for cutting benefits and putting those programs on the road to abolition also shift. But they are based in Herbert Hoover economics. And more specifically in the greed of Wall Street financiers who would love to have retirement and health care fully privatized so they could take huge cuts in fees from the funds that now go to retirees and to health care costs.

At this point, I'm ready to shift by assumption about Obama's understanding of the whole framework of social insurance. I've assumed up until now that his concept of the Grand Bargain was something like Josh describes, "to have a big global agreement that settles the big fiscal policy for a generation and let's the country get on to other issues — social and cultural issues, the environment, building the economy etc." Although I would add that he seems to think this postpartisan heaven would reduce those other issues to more technical issues that reasonable elites could handle in an agreeable fashion without a lot of noisy and annoying interference by voters and ordinary workers who are the most directly affected by them. The "end of ideology," as the dream was called in an earlier incarnation, or "the end of history" in another.

But I imagined that he thought that cutbacks in benefits to Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid would be a one-time thing that would then lead to full acceptance by the Republicans of those programs.

Now I'm starting to think he buys into a more radical privatization framework. His healthy care program, which the Republicans are shrieking is a totalitarian imposition, is famously similar to that on which Bob Dole campaigned when running for President as the Republican nominee in 1994. Obama may well see 401(k)'s and the remnants of the private pension system as an adequate and preferable substitute for Social Security. And Obamacare, with its absence of a public option, as a desirable substitute for Medicare and Medicaid.

That implies even more cynicism on Obama's part than even most of his sharpest Democratic partisan critics have assumed so far. But since his course opens those programs up to even more aggressive political attacks the moment his Grand Bargain deals gets enacted, that's a straightforward possibility. Assuming he hopes for a postpartisan state of "end of ideology" harmony at least allows him a dream of a more harmonious state. But it's delusional. Take your pick.

Rick Perlstein at his Facebook page today quotes from that paragraph of Josh Marshall and gives his own translation:

Yes. Me: "There’s something so arbitrary about it, so cliché: pick the one thing that Republicans are supposed to cherish most (tax cuts!). Pick the one thing Democrats are supposed to cherish most (spending!). If you get both to give up what they cherish, something transcendent has occurred; something mystical; something deep, deep inside America's soul—healing! It’s almost as if, were the Democrats' most cherished nostrum was that the sky is blue; and if the Republicans’ most cherished nostrum were that the sky is red, Obama somehow imagines that if he can somehow get both to agree that the sky is purple, lo and behold, America will finally be a warm and conciliatory place."
Josh claims to be giving context to the proposed cuts:

First, though I think these cuts are a bad idea, they’re are qualitatively different from efforts to dismantled and phase out Social Security through privatization and private accounts.
Yes, I suppose you could say that serious and damaging cuts that make many people's lives visibly harder are qualitatively different that immediately abolishing the programs altogether.

There are also a number of progressive economists and policy analysts that think this might be a positive step in the context of other changes to get the country’s longterm financial house in order.
He doesn't name any. And since supporting cuts in benefits to Social Security and Medicare make someone by definition something other than "progressive" the way I look at it, I have no idea who or what he means here.

But that last point is key: it doesn't make sense if you just do it alone, if Social Security doesn't get anything back as part of the same bargain. Otherwise, when you do finally come to a deal that brings major new revenue in (and it will come) Social Security and other similar programs will be asked to take yet more hits.
Even the sentences don't make sense there. If we raise or eliminate the cap on Social Security taxes, that takes care of any financing problems with Social Security for upteen years and probably until hell freezes over. But he seems to be saying that it only makes sense to cut Social Security benefits unless Social Security also gets more revenue which means benefits have to be cut even more if it does. Which really doesn't make jack for sense to me.

Second, on the politics, President Obama and his advisors have made clear this isn’t what President Obama is actually for. He doesn’t think it’s a good idea.
This is generous way beyond what the facts indicate. Obama has been talking about the Grand Bargain to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid since before his first inauguration. Digby at Hullabaloo has been faithfully tracking it ever since then. Maybe Josh should check out her blog occasionally.

So really this is just the President negotiating with himself, validating the wisdom of big Social Security cuts while Republicans are still saying — and show no signs of not saying — that no more taxes should ever go up ever.

Now, the counter to this is that the optics of going the extra length helps the President with swing voters who want to see he’s trying to compromise. I’m uncertain about that. But that’s certainly part of the calculus.
The whole argument is silly. Polls consistently show that cuts in benefits to Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid are very unpopular: with Democrats, with swing voters, with Republicans. Even if Josh's sources at the White House are claiming that, they have surely seen the polls. Josh is being very credulous to credit them with thinking that. Obama is trying to make a deal by doing something he knows is very unpopular because it very damaging.

Robert Reich explains why the "chained CPI" proposal is such a scam and why the benefit cuts involved in using it the way the Democratic President is now proposing is a really bad idea, Robert Reich on Chained CPI (the proposal to cut Social Security benefits) 04/03/2013:



Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Obama opens another round in the War against Social Security and Medicare

President Obama-Brüning is escalating his efforts to achieve his Grand Bargain to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. Jackie Calmes reports in Obama Budget to Include Cuts to Programs in Hopes of Deal New York Times 04/05/2013:

President Obama next week will take the political risk of formally proposing cuts to Social Security and Medicare in his annual budget in an effort to demonstrate his willingness to compromise with Republicans and revive prospects for a long-term deficit-reduction deal, administration officials say.

In a significant shift in fiscal strategy, Mr. Obama on Wednesday will send a budget plan to Capitol Hill that departs from the usual presidential wish list that Republicans typically declare dead on arrival. Instead it will embody the final compromise offer that he made to Speaker John A. Boehner late last year, before Mr. Boehner abandoned negotiations in opposition to the president’s demand for higher taxes from wealthy individuals and some corporations. [my emphasis]
The article derived from those anonymous "administration officials" that the Social Security benefits cut includes the "chained CPI" scam and that the Medicare cuts will involved means-testing, thus setting up the framing of Medicare as "welfare" instead of social insurance.

And, of course, this becomes that starting point for Obama's famous negotiating with the Republicans in the debates over the budget.

Obama's push for his Grand Bargain to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid is the main reason I regard the Pod Pundit chatter about how the Republicans have to reform their hard-right policies as hot air. The Democratic President is giving retirees and those who aspire to be retirees someday a big reason to not vote for Democrats.

Charlie Pierce is understandably disgusted, as he explains in Moochers Incorporated Esquire Politics Blog 04/05/2013:

The entire power of the presidency comes down now to the president's ability to "demonstrate his willingness to compromise" with a bunch of vandals and yahoos ... Exactly what is this supposed to accomplish? What is the purpose of the demonstration? The Democrats are going to go up the wall, and the Republicans are going to ask for more and more "demonstrations" of the president's willingness to compromise until he has shown himself willing to compromise us back to 1922. Who is the demonstration supposed to convince? David Brooks? This is crazy. This is wrong. It is government by Beltway dumbshow. It is awful politics and worse policy. ...

The American people are going to look at a Democratic president's selling out the cornerstones of eighty years of Democratic social policy and blame the Republicans because they won't help him do it? I can write the "Stop Obama's Raid On Social Security" ads for the 2014 midterms in my sleep. In addition, wasn't this also the logic behind the sequester? How's that working out?
Joan McCarter comments in President Obama's budget will include cuts to Social Security, Medicare Daily Kos 04/05/2013:

Now that Obama has fully embraced the cuts, no amount of White House spin is going to be able to permanently pin the chained CPI on Republicans, as the administration official is trying to do. Republicans have been demanding for months that Obama specifically spell out the cuts to social insurance programs he would accept; now he's done so, they will make sure he owns them.

The White House seems to believe that this will show the American public that he is Very Serious about both deficit reduction and working with Republicans, that "he is willing to compromise and do tough things to reduce the deficit,” in the words of a senior administration official. Because of course a willingness to compromise is all that it takes to make the Republicans come around. That and his charm offensive.

Republicans aren't going to come around, and now have a weapon. And what the American people will probably remember is that in 2008 candidate Obama promised that as president, he would not cut Social Security, a promise reiterated by Vice President Biden in 2012. In fact, we're probably not going to be allowed to forget that, once the Republicans get their ads running in congressional districts around the country saying that Barack Obama broke his promise and wants to cut your Social Security.
Yep. The awesome awesomeness of Obama has come down to this. He wants to have as his legacy that he cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid and put those programs on the road to extinction.

Tags: , , , , , ,

Monday, April 01, 2013

Can we stop calling Social Security opponent Barack Obama a liberal now?

President Obama isn't just unenthusiastic about the issues on which he got elected. In the critical cases of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, he's determined to do the work of cutting benefits and putting the programs on the fast track to extinction that the Republicans want him to do. This is not only to the right of his own 2012 platform, it's to the right of what the Romney-Ryan ticket campaigned on.

Joan Walsh writes in Mr. President, you won the election, not them! Salon 04/01/2013 (the title in the mobile version earlier today was "Bad ideas that just won't die"):

White House sources are now telling reporters that the president is “strongly considering” including entitlement cuts in his 2014 budget, to be introduced around April 10. The budget could lay out precise cuts to Social Security and Medicare, as well as Medicaid, that the president has reportedly been offering in futile negotiations with Republicans, but that he’s never officially spelled out.

The Wall Street Journal reported Friday that the budget will likely include the chained CPI for Social Security. “We and all of the groups engaged on this are starting to feel it may well be in the budget,” AARP vice president Nancy LeaMond told the WSJ. The same day the New York Times revealed that Obama and House Republicans are getting close to agreement on a package of Medicare cuts that would restructure Medicare parts A and B – one covers hospitalization, the other doctors’ visits — to raise deductibles for the 80 percent of seniors who see doctors but don’t require hospitalization in any given year. The Times reports that some version of the proposal might also find its way into the 2014 budget.
This can't be explained by some shrewd political calculation. As Joan's piece reminds us, Obama has seen how unpopular such approaches are. It's bad politics and it's bad policy.

But Social Security is the Mississippi River of all cash flows, as Jamie Galbraith once described it. Wall Street wants it, in the form of private insurance and investments of which they can take a substantial cut as profits. And the current Democratic President is happy to help them get it.

The fight to defend benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid is a fight by their supporters against President Obama and the Republicans.

And it's looking like we can kiss off any hope of substantial gains or even holding off losses for the Democrats in Senate and House elections of 2014. The President is giving the Democratic base a big kick in the mouth with his proposals to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. And bragging that he's making his own supporters angry by doing so!

What kind of Democratic Party leader is this?

Tags: , , , , ,

Monday, March 25, 2013

Radical Republicans and fumbling corporate Democrats

Krugman, after analyzing columnist Jonathan Chait for going brain-dead over Matt Yglesias' recent real estate purchase, writes, "The lesson here is never to take right-wing huffiness about the process of politics and political debate seriously. These guys don't actually believe in any rules at all; whatever rule they may lay down in one case, they’ll break in an instant if they think they see an advantage." (Attacking Success 03/23/2013)

"Never," of course is a big word. And, not so long ago, I would have probably qualified a statement like that by saying it applied to hardline, dogmatic rightwingers including a lot of prominent Republican figures like Newt Gingrich. But I would have added that it wasn't so much the case with moderate Republicans like [fill in your favorite example from bygone times].

But now, when "moderate Republican" has become as self-contradictory a term as "lightweight heaviness," I can't really say that any more.

And when I think about it a bit, "not so long ago" in this case basically means 10 years ago, the beginning of the Iraq War. The Republicans were so cynical and so self-righteous in the face they put on their cynicism, and so openly contemptuous of those who disagreed that I lost any real sense from the Republican side of goodwill or serious consideration of the common good in their positions. It was quite a contrast to what Linda Feldmann in 2006 referred to as "the serious, dignified tone of deliberation that preceded the Gulf war, in 1991." (The Iraq war debate reopens in Washington Christian Science Monitor 06/13/2006)

But you have only to look at the full sentence in which that phrase appears to see how much things have changed: "House majority leader John Boehner (R) of Ohio, who has long planned for this week's debate, hopes to match the serious, dignified tone of deliberation that preceded the Gulf war, in 1991." And if you think that there might have been some tiny amount of seriousness in Boehner's expressed intent, you have only to read the immediately following sentence, "Most of his GOP colleagues support the idea."

And it's gotten steadily worse since 2003. As Charlie Pierce chronicles weekly at the Esquire Politics Blog, not only are the Republicans in Congress as happily hardline as ever. But the Republicans in statehouses and state legislatures even after the resounding Democratic win nationwide in 2012 are going full speed ahead on trying to wreck unions, dismantle public education and establish new controls over what women do with their ladyparts.

And in Congress, they are conducting themselves more like a revolutionary party intent on discrediting the entire existing form of government than on anything resembling pragmatic solutions for major national problems. Our Pod Pundits, reciting their Washington Beltway Village lines, chatter about some struggle between moderate and conservative Republicans. But that debate is occurring in their Village imaginations. Yes, there is a Tea Party faction that raves about the insufficient conservatism of the "Republican establishment." But it usually means something like that the "establishment" candidate hates immigrants, but isn't vocal and nasty enough about his hatred. Or that the "establishment" candidate thinks you should only say "some girls rape easy" (Wisconsin State representative Roger Rivard) when there are no microphones around, while the Tea Party zealot thinks it should be obvious that if a woman gets raped, "the bitch was asking for it." OK, I haven't heard any prominent Tea Partier say the latter outright, but it's the obvious meaning of Rivard's comment, Richard Mourdoch's comment that pregnancy resulting from rape "it is something that God intended to happen" and Todd Akin's "legitimate rape" nonsense; see Erin Gloria Ryan, Team Rape Lost Big Last Night Jezebel 11/07/2012. Though all Republicans would take a different attitude if the rapist were black and the victim white.

As Henry Decker reports in 'GOP Autopsy’ Is Dead On Arrival National Memo 03/18/2013, the Republican Party sees no strong motive to change anything but its marketing. "With the exception of a qualified push for immigration reform, the [Republicans National Committee's] Growth and Opportunity Project centers around the idea that the Republican Party’s platform is sound, while the messaging is at fault. That comes as no surprise — it was RNC chairman Reince Priebus, after all, who recently declared "I don’t think our platform is the issue."

But Robert Reich comments on a major reason, maybe the major reason, why the Republican Party feels no obvious pressure to de-crazyfy itself in Selling the Store: Why Democrats Shouldn't Put Social Security and Medicare on the Table 03/21/2013:

Prominent Democrats — including the President and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi — are openly suggesting that Medicare be means-tested and Social Security payments be reduced by applying a lower adjustment for inflation.

This is even before they've started budget negotiations with Republicans ...

It’s not the first time Democrats have led with a compromise, but these particular pre-concessions are especially unwise. ...

Social Security and Medicare are the most popular programs ever devised by the federal government, which is why Republicans hate them so much. If average Americans have trusted the Democratic Party to do one thing it has been to guard these programs from the depredations of the GOP.
Reich doesn't seem to have recognized, or maybe he doesn't quite believe them yet, the more recent projections that show a slowing in projected health care inflation. But he's dead right in pointing to the absurdity of the position Obama-Brüning and Pelosi are taking. For the Democrats, becoming the lead advocates for cuts in benefits to Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid is just lemming instinct. Although as I've said here before, that's unfair to lemmings, because they plunge over the cliff and drown because they are so determined to get to where they're headed. With the Dems it's become more, "Hey, let's drown ourselves so we'll look moderate!" But they might as well adopt this as the official Party anthem:



And Reich adds this killer question: "Paul Ryan's House Republican budget takes on Medicare, but leaves Social Security alone. Why should Democrats lead the charge on either?"

The good news is that Obama-Brüning and Pelosi are still having to advocate for the cuts because they haven't happened yet. For some reason, this comes to mind when I start thinking about how the Dems got here:



Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Monday, March 11, 2013

Middle Man strikes again!

Tom Tomorrow's weekly cartoon of 03/11/2013 brings us the continuing adventures of Obama Middle Man!


Poor Middle Man. Mean Mr. Orange always seems to get the best of him.

Tags: , , , , ,

Friday, March 08, 2013

The Grand Bargain to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid is just as bad an idea now as in 2009

Digby has been closely following President Obama-Brüning's effort to strike a Grand Bargain to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid (aka, "entitlements") since before his first inauguration in 2009. She's been the best analyst I know of on the whole rotten idea.

In How to succeed as an opposition party without really trying Hullabaloo 03/08/2013, she reminds us again what a bad concept in was for everyone except Republican greedheads like Peter Peterson who have been looking to get their hands on the Social Security cash flow and rake huge investment banking profits off of it:

The original calculation of the Grand Bargain was always daft: deficit reduction in a time of massive unemployment and a moribund economy. And even worse that the Bargain was defined as some sort of amorphous "revenue" from people who won't even feel it in exchange for benefits cuts to some of the neediest people in the country. This is also known as a "balanced approach" (to a problem that doesn't doesn't need fixing.) That we've taken a hatchet to discretionary programs is just frosting on the cake. Well played.

The bottom line is this: I think it would be nice to raise some more "revenue." But it is definitely not worth this price and I doubt very seriously it will last any longer than the Clinton tax hikes lasted --- that is until the Republicans regain the presidency. They are not going to overnight become friendly to the idea of progressive taxation, so whatever tiny little accommodation we get now is it, and it's very temporary. But the people of this country will be suffering for many, many years from the cuts to vital programs that were given up in this Bargain.
In an earlier post, The Village: "very, very privileged people wanting to make sure they cut spending on everybody else?" 03/07/2013, she writes:

... we've had a bipartisan National Security policy for decades, one that has always placed a premium on our continued global military hegemony. There is nothing particularly new about that, as appalling as it is. But a Democratic president leading the way to cutting Social Security and Medicare is something new. There was a time when that would have been unthinkable. I've said it before, but it's more and more obvious to me that if the Democratic Party sells out its constituents on "entitlements" --- which they fought for and defended for over half a century, particularly at a time when their authentic democratic political power is stronger than it's been in over three decades, I'm hard pressed to see what the rationale for their continued existence really is. [my emphasis in bold]
She refers to an article on Social Security by Tom Edsall, who she describes as a "highly respected political reporter Tom Edsall, The War On Entitlements New York Times 03/06/2013.

Whenever referring to Edsall, I feel obligated to include the qualifier that, although he does some solid reporting and has for years, his analysis has an aggravating liberal-concern-troll aspect that has irritated me since I read his Chain Reaction: The Impact of Race, Rights, and Taxes on American Politics (1991). He often analyses in terms that broadly agree with conservative talking points of the moment, thought phrased in a way to imply that he's a liberal who views his results sorrowfully. After having seen his arguments so often tending that way, I'm tempted to read that even into his conclusion in this piece:

Elite anxiety over entitlement-driven budget deficits and accumulating national debt has created a powerful class in the nation’s capital. The agenda of this class is in many respects on a collision course with mounting demands for action by those lower down the ladder to address the threat to government social insurance programs. Intransigent opposition by the better off and their representatives to raising the necessary revenue means that not only Social Security and Medicare face a budgetary ax.

Among the additional likely casualties: WIC, which provides free nutrition for women, infants and children; long-term and emergency unemployment compensation benefits; low-income housing vouchers; vaccines for poor children; schooling for children with disabilities; special education; preschool programs; child care for disadvantaged and vulnerable children; after-school programs; treatment of the mentally ill; and meals for sick and homebound seniors.

This conflict could not have come at a more difficult time: the United States is in the midst of a zero sum struggle requiring politicians to pick losers, not winners. The population of those over 65 is set to multiply, with longevity steadily increasing even as median annual household income for the population at large has shrunk to $51,584 in January 2013 from $54,000 in 2008.

In this kind of conflict over limited goods, one of the most valuable resources that can get lost in the fray is the wisdom of the electorate at large. In this case, the electorate is pointing toward progressive tax increases for those closer to the top far more readily than members of the political class, for whom high-earners are a crucial source of campaign contributions.
But however Edsall himself regards the value of that outcome, he is correct in describing the strong pressures to cut benefits on Social Security and Medicare and other programs that benefit others than only the super-rich. Pressures actively encouraged right now by Medicare opponent Barack Obama.

Digby's comment on the effect of the Democrats supporting cuts in benefits to benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, "I'm hard pressed to see what the rationale for their continued existence really is", really resonates with me. Although it's like what I think of a classic Jesuit comment that first makes me think, "Something's not quite right about that." But then I find myself not being able to think about the issue without taking account of that comment.

I have a hard time envisioning what that might mean in practice for the Democrats to lose "the rationale for their continued existence." There's always the standard third-party slogans to apply: there's not a dime's worth of difference between the two parties, if you vote for the lesser of two evils you'll get what you vote for, etc.

But even in a world in which politicians wouldn't even bother to pretend they were anything but corporate whores - how hard many of them are already to that point might be a matter of some discussion - there would still be competition between individuals to be first in line to collect their fees. And as long as elections are happening, there is always some room for people advocating positions not 100% consistent with a state of corporate whoredom to get a hearing, and even occasionally get elected. Even in the one-party segregated South, there were intense contests, including contests around issues, among candidates in the Democratic Party primaries as they competed for a majority of the white vote, nonwhites not normally having a vote to cast.

But I do think a Democratic Party that joins the Republicans, as Medicare opponent Obama-Brüning wants to do, in opposing the most basic social "safety net" programs like Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, will put us into a fundamentally different political era for the Democratic Party.

I'm confident in saying it will not look like the postpartisan, end-of-ideology state on which Obama-Brüning seems to be so fixed. That happy state in which all "ideological" issues are settled: the requirement that rich people pay taxes to support their country, women grousing about how they should be able to control their own ladyparts, minorities complaining about being discriminated against, aspiring mall shooters griping that libruls are trying to limit their access to guns, workers thinking they have a right to join unions, old people expecting some kind of retirement in minimal dignity and with access to health care, all those will be resolved. All that will be left to discuss in politics will be technocratic issues, like which wars we should start this year, how much public land should be handed over to the extractive industries and at how low a price, and which new job-exporting, antilabor international trade agreements should be approved. The annoying public would happily accede to the advice of their betters in the corporate boardrooms, Wall Street casinos, K Street lobbying firms, the Pentagon and the pundits on TV talk-fests. And they will do their civic duty to show up every couple of years to select which corporate whore they think has greater celebrity appeal.

Shakira doesn't necessarily come first to mind when you think "protest song." But her song "Timor" comes to mind in this context:

It's alright, it's alright
The system never fails
The good guys are in power
And the bad guys are in jail

It's alright, it's alright
Just as long as we can vote
We'll have a democracy
And that's what we promote

Isn't it? Isn't it?
That is on her Oral Fixation Vol. 2 album from 2005, when George W. Bush was using "democracy promotion" as a prominent justification for perpetual war.



Tags: , , , , , , , ,