Showing posts with label united nations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label united nations. Show all posts

Thursday, September 25, 2003

The UN and the Iraq War

The initial responses the Bush's appeal to the UN indicate that it was even more of a flop than critics expected. The Washington Post reports:

President Bush ended two days of meetings with foreign leaders today without winning more international troops or funds for Iraq and with a top aide saying it could take months to achieve a new U.N. resolution backing the U.S. occupation.

Bush's failure to win a promise of fresh soldiers in meetings with the leaders of India and Pakistan -- aides said the president did not even ask -- increased the difficulty the United States will have in assembling another division of foreign troops in Iraq, which senior Pentagon officials say is the minimum needed to relieve overstretched U.S. forces.
Pakistan is saying, unless you come up with big bucks to pay for it, no way we're sending troops. Turkey, which has been discussed as one of the most likely to send troops, says they want to see more UN involvement and a faster turnover of control to the Iraqis before they commit troops.

The best news on foreign assistance came from Germany. "Bush aides said Germany might provide police training."

They might provide police training. And this was the good news. The Pentagon is now looking at more reserve call-ups. No quick-and-easy war on this one.

Tags: , ,

Wednesday, September 24, 2003

Bush's UN speech: there was a surprise

Okay, so one thing in Bush's speech to the UN did surprise me (my emphasis):

Events during the past two years have set before us the clearest of divides: between those who seek order and those who spread chaos; between those who work for peaceful change and those who adopt the methods of gangsters; between those who honor the rights of man and those who deliberately take the lives of men and women and children without mercy or shame.
For a domestic Republican audience, that's just boilerplate. But it's surprising he would use it for a world audience very suspicious of his own Administration's commitment to world order and international law. With all the publicity about continuing civilian casualties in Iraq and Afghanistan, and reports of chaotic conditions in Iraq especially, it was certainly an awkward choice of words.

As Glenn Kessler notes in the Washington Post:

But in two speeches that bracketed the president's address, Annan and French President Jacques Chirac suggested that it is the administration's doctrine of "preemption" -- the promise to strike against emerging threats -- that threatens to spread chaos across the globe. Both men bluntly said that the Bush administration is undermining the collective security arrangements that have governed the world since World War II. ...

Annan said that reserving "the right to act unilaterally or in ad hoc coalitions ... represents a fundamental challenge to the principles on which, however imperfectly, world peace and stability have rested for the last 58 years. My concern is that if it were to be adopted, it would set precedents that resulted in a proliferation of the unilateral and lawless use of force with or without justification."
Not one of Bush's more impressive performances.

Tags: , ,

After Bush's UN speech

Bush's speech Tuesday to the UN General Assembly didn't have any surprises for me, good or otherwise. It was pretty much what I expected: We were right on Iraq; you sissy wimp nations were wrong; but if you beg nicely, we'll let you send troops and money to help us out.

As a diplomatic strategy, it strikes me as deeply unserious.

What did surprise me was how strong (in diplomatic terms) the criticism was of the Bush Doctrine of preventive war. All understood that UN Secretary General Kofi Annan was referring to that when he said:
Since this organization was founded, states have generally sought to deal with threats to the peace through containment and deterrence by a system based on collective security and the United Nations Charter.

This may be a moment no less decisive than in 1945 itself, when the United Nations was founded.
French President Jacques Chirac said (emphasis mine):

The United Nations has just weathered one of its most serious trials in its history: respect for the Charter, the use of force, were at the heart of the debate. The war, which was started without the authorization of the Security Council, has shaken the multilateral system.

Having taken stock of this crisis, our organization is now resuming its onward march, for it is primarily within this forum, the crucible of international law, that we must exercise our responsibilities to the world and to future generations.
Americans of both parties will be quick to dismiss Chirac's words especially as some kind of devious Old World cyncism. But both Kofi Annan and Chirac were all but explicitly raising the issue of the legality of the US war on Iraq under international law.

This puts more immediate pressure on Tony Blair than on Bush. The British public, press and Parliament seem to be more aware of issues around international law than those in America. Britain is also a member of the International Criminal Court.

But it seems to me that, in the longer term, that was a much more significant thing than the immediate outcome of the pending Iraq resolution. Like it or not, Americans haven't heard the last of that one.

Tags: , ,

Tuesday, September 23, 2003

Bush and the UN

The only way I've been able to make sense out of Bush's current effort to get additional troops and money for Iraq from the United Nations is to assume it was more for domestic political consumption than a serious attempt to get international help.

But maybe it's a mistake to try to make sense out of it. Maybe they're just floundering. Because with the Iraq War, it Bush and Rummy are looking more and more like the guy in Buck Owens' song who has "got a tiger by the tail." They can't hang on forever this way. But any immediate alternative is very risky.

And the risk calculations have already been bad. Going into Iraq the way they did, with reasons for war that were, well, fake, now appears to have been a "bet the farm" kind of gamble. If the war was quick and easy, the potential payoff was big in terms of domestic political prestige, military clout in the Middle East, access to Iraqi oil and contracts for Halliburton and Bechtel. But now that it's turned out not be be quick or easy, there are huge downsides. (Halliburton and Bechtel seem to be doing okay so far.)

Today's San Francisco Chronicle has a good analysis of the prospects for action on a new Iraq resolution. Barring some big breakthrough, Bush is likely to get a cosmetic Security Council resolution offering some kind of very limited UN participation in the eventual transfer of power. But the US will still maintain full control over the occupation and the transition. And any international military or economic assistance will be limited. The Chronicle's analyst is probably being over-optimistic when he says:

The Bush administration is hoping that a resolution would pave the way for U.S. troops in Iraq to be substituted by 10,000 to 15,000 troops from Pakistan, Turkey, Bangladesh, India and the Arab nations. But Turkey is considered the only sure bet.
I won't count Turkey as a "sure bet" until the troops are on the ground in Iraq. Given the tensions between Turkey and the Kurds in northern Iraq, even then it's still more of a gamble than a "sure bet."

Bush just delivered his speech a few minutes ago. We'll soon see what the response from other countries will be.

Tags: , ,