Showing posts with label wikileaks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wikileaks. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 07, 2017

Wikileaks and the Trump-Russia scandal

A new Wikileaks document drop happened this week. And it provides yet another example of how US news and politics right now is a bizarre mixture of intrigue, espionage and conspiracy theories.

Noting a new set of documents being released by Wikileaks, Josh Marshall posts You Probably Can't Be Both (TPM 03/07/2017), which reads in full, "According to Wikileaks, the new tranche of CIA documents was provided by a government contractor or ex-government operative concerned at the overreach of various CIA hacking capabilities. But Wikileaks role as a de facto arm of Russian cyber-warfare and disruption operations against the United States certainly complicates its role as a purported or former whistleblower organization."

Marcy Wheeler has a less dismissive take on the sourcing in Wikileaks Dumps CIA'S Hacking Tools Emptywheel 03/07/2017:

We will no doubt have further debate about whether Wikileaks was responsible or not with this dump. But consider: various contractors (and to a much lesser degree, the US intelligence community) have been releasing details about Russian hacking for months. That is deemed to be in the common interest, because it permits targets to prevent being hacked by a state actor.

Any hacking CIA does comes on top of the simplified spying the US can do thanks to the presence of most tech companies in the US.

So why should CIA hacking be treated any differently than FSB or GRU hacking, at least by the non-American part of the world?

This leak may well be what Wikileaks claims it to be — a concerned insider exposing the CIA’s excesses. Or perhaps it’s part of a larger Russian op. (Those two things could even both be true.) But as we talk about cybersecurity, we would do well to remember that all nation-state hackers pose a threat to the digital commons.
The Guardian's story on the leaks if by-lined to Ewen MacAskill, Sam Thielman and Philip Oltermann, WikiLeaks publishes 'biggest ever leak of secret CIA documents' 03/07/2017. They address the documents' credibility this way:

The documents appear to be from the CIA’s 200-strong Center for Cyber Intelligence and show in detail how the agency’s digital specialists engage in hacking. ...

The CIA declined to comment on the leaks beyond the agency’s now-stock refusal to verify their contents. “We do not comment on the authenticity or content of purported intelligence documents,” wrote CIA spokesperson Heather Fritz Horniak.

But it is understood the documents are genuine and a hunt is under way for the leakers or hackers responsible for the leak. [my emphasis]
That's an unusually vague reference to sourcing, although the placement suggests that they mean that the CIA understands the docs to be genuine.

A Guardian report by Julian Borger focuses on the intrigue aspect, To security establishment, WikiLeaks' CIA dump is part of US-Russia battle 03/07/2017:

In the Washington security establishment ... the leaks are being viewed more as the latest battle in a struggle between US and Russian intelligence services being played out in the US political arena – a fight in which WikiLeaks is widely seen as sitting firmly in Moscow’s corner.

The latest leaks land amid an ongoing and very public feud between the US president and the country’s intelligence agencies over Kremlin efforts to influence the election in Donald Trump’s favour. In recent months, the president has repeatedly denigrated US intelligence agencies – going as far as comparing them to the Nazi regime – while openly cheering on WikiLeaks activities. He has also alleged, so far without any evidence, that the Obama administration spied on him and his election campaign.

The apparent CIA hacking tools published by WikiLeaks feed directly into that struggle. Some Trump supporters have claimed that the apparent Russian hacking attacks could be a “false-flag” operation, hinting it was carried out by the new president’s domestic foes, and the “Vault 7” documents published on Tuesday give them potential ammunition.
The PBS Newshour reports on the latest Wikileaks revelations here, WikiLeaks publishes purported CIA cyber tools for hacking phones, TVs 03/07/2017:


Thursday, August 23, 2012

Glenn Greenwald on the Assange extradition issue

Glenn Greenwald provides a good summary of the legal and practical issues around the Swedish government's demand for Wikileaks' head Julian Assange's extradition to Sweden in Greenwald's new regular spot in The Guardian, The bizarre, unhealthy, blinding media contempt for Julian Assange 08/22/2012.

Tags: ,

Friday, June 17, 2011

US dependence on Saudi Arabia: oil and security

Courtesy of Wikileaks and McClatchy's Kevin Hall in WikiLeaks cables show worry about Saudi oil security McClatchy Newspapers 06/13/2011, we get a glimpse of US dependence on Saudi Arabian oil and therefore on the House of Saud:

When al Qaida suicide bombers tried on Feb. 24, 2006, to blow up Saudi Arabia's Abqaiq oil processing facility, arguably the world's most important petroleum hub, it was taken as a sign of strength that internal security had foiled the attack.

Secret U.S. State Department cables obtained by WikiLeaks and shared with McClatchy and other news organizations show otherwise.

Even though 70 percent of Saudi Arabia's oil exports flow through the Abqaiq facility, Saudi security forces were woefully ill prepared to defend it, investigations into the attack found, according to the cables. Efforts to fix the problems were hampered by bickering between the Saudi state oil company and the country's Ministry of the Interior, the cables indicate.
This is an important piece of news, and one that Wikileaks was able to overcome one more piece of secrecy and concealment from the Cheney-Bush Administration, even if it's five years later. With the Obama Administration pursuing even more stringent secrecy policies, it's more important than ever to have news organization like Wikileaks at work.

The precarious security of Saudi oil fields ought to be a central part of the public discussion on US Middle East policy. Partisans of the House of Saud like the Bush family would presumably use it as a reason to pursue an even closer alliance with the repressive, conservative monarachy. But it also should be an argument for aggressive development of renewable energy sources and a reminder of the urgency of drastically reducing US dependency on oil as an energy source.

US oil companies, of course, like to make the argument about reducing US dependence on foreign oil. It's a perpetual pitch of theirs against environmental and other regulatory restrictions.

But, as Hall reports, the Saudi monarchy currently looms very large in the American oil picture:

Saudi Arabia, with 12 percent of the world's oil supply, remains the key to the West's ability to influence oil prices. Last week, when members of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries failed to increase production in a move that Western officials had hoped would help curb rising crude oil prices, Saudi Arabia announced it would unilaterally pump more oil. Crude prices immediately dropped.

A successful terrorist attack on Saudi oil facilities would wreak havoc on the kingdom's ability to take a similar step in the future.
Tags: ,

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

Glenn Greenwald on Julian Assange, Wikileaks and the sad state of the Establishment press

This interview with Glenn Greenwald on Julian Assange and Wikileaks is not only informative on those topics. It also puts on dramatic display the all-too-typical dysfunctions of our US national media, especially television.



Greenwald expands on this interview in The merger of journalists and government officials Salon 12/28/2010.

Our national press has very serious problems. The cynics who dismiss politics altogether are happy to say, oh, of course the press is totally corrupt and useless. And overstating the problem in that way harms our understanding of it rather than furthers it. It's important to see what the press currently delivers that still contributes to democratic government and what its specific problems are. Even a softball interview with a senior government official or leading politician can be revealing, sometimes entirely unintentionally. Just as the video above shows the two alleged journalists from CNN, one of which was the Homeland Security Adviser to George W. Bush as President, taking a straight-up polemical stand in favor of the federal government's case against Wikileaks.

At one level it's superfluous to say, but it's still worth noting sometimes that we're not hearing a lot in defense of freedom of the press and open government around the Wikileaks controversy from the Tea Party activists who profess to love freedom and the Constitution so much.

Greenwald's observation here is very much consistent with the interview:

Over the last month, I've done many television and radio segments about WikiLeaks and what always strikes me is how indistinguishable -- identical -- are the political figures and the journalists. There's just no difference in how they think, what their values and priorities are, how completely they've ingested and how eagerly they recite the same anti-WikiLeaks, "Assange = Saddam" script. So absolute is the WikiLeaks-is-Evil bipartisan orthodoxy among the Beltway political and media class (forever cemented by the joint Biden/McConnell decree that Assange is a "high-tech Terrorist,") that you're viewed as being from another planet if you don't spout it. It's the equivalent of questioning Saddam's WMD stockpile in early 2003.
As Gene Lyons, also writing about the press and democracy in Salon on 12/22/2010 says in a line that also became the article's headline, People, we're in deep trouble.

I find it frustrating to write about this without falling into some meaningless generalization, e.g., "we don't have a real democracy." We don't have a generally understood vocabulary in US politics to talk about degrees of democracy. The Deep South in which Haley Barbour (and others including me) grew up spoke the language of democracy. But the Mississippi of the 1950s and 1960s was qualitatively different in the kind of government it practiced than most of the country. It and several other Deep South states could be said to be democracy for whites only until after the Voting Rights Act of 1965 was passed and enforced.

Similarly, it's nothing new to see newspapers and other media siding with local business interests against labor, or to see corrupt old-style city political machines fix elections.

Even today, despite great and continuing efforts by the Republicans to establish 1950s-Deep-South levels of election manipulation in various parts of the country, the voting procedures in the US right now are generally pretty clean.

But when the Supreme Court picks the loser in the Presidential race to place into office, as they did in 2000, that is something new and bad that has happened that reduces the degree of democracy we have. When the national press has travelled the road it has from Whitewater (1992) to Judith Miller and her "weapons-of-mass-destruction" propaganda fraud (2002) to the empty-head-propaganda standard of infotainment passing for journalism that we see in the clip above, something bad has happened that reduces the degree of democracy. When the Supreme Court opens the floodgates of corporate money to influence election outcomes, relying on a legal theory of the corporation as a legal person that was reactionary even in the 19th century, something bad has happened that reduces the degree of democracy.

At the same time, the Internet has created alternative forms of political participation in the last 15 years or so that has been on balance a positive contribution up to now. The political system as a whole doesn't move uniformly in one direction. Progress in one area can come at the same time as retrogression in another.

But the current state of our national press is a danger to democracy in the United States. Not the only one, but certainly one of the most serious. Maybe in the long run, the most serious.

Tags: ,

Monday, December 27, 2010

David Frost and guests on 2010 news events, Part 1

Part 1 of David Frost's 2010 year-end wrap-up, from Aljazeera English:



Tags: ,

Saturday, December 18, 2010

Wikileaks, freedom of the press and the rule of law

Glenn Greenwald has been following the Wikileaks story closely, explaining how it represents a serious threat to press freedom and a continuing breach of the rule of law in the name of the national security state. In Joe Biden v. Joe Biden on WikiLeaks Salon 12/18/2010, he writes:

It's really not an overstatement to say that WikiLeaks and Julian Assange are the new Iraqi WMDs because the government and establishment media are jointly manufacturing and disseminating an endless stream of fear-mongering falsehoods designed to depict them as scary villains threatening the security of The American People and who must therefore be stopped at any cost. So often, the government/media claims made in service of this goal are outright false, which is why I have focused so much on the un-killable, outright lie that WikiLeaks indiscriminately dumped 250,000 diplomatic cables without regard to the consequences (on Thursday, The New York Times, in its article on Assange's release from prison, re-printed the lie by referencing "Mr. Assange's role in the publication of some 250,000 American diplomatic documents" only to delete it without any indication of a correction in the final version of the article, while the always-conventional-wisdom-spouting Dana Milbank in The Washington Post -- in the course of condemning "the absurd secrecy of the Obama administration, in some ways worse than that of George W. Bush" -- today wrote of "Assange's indiscriminate dump of American government secrets over the last several months - with hardly a care for who might be hurt or what public good was served").
Given that after the tax deal passed, it's fashionable even among some writers who should know better to lecture those of us in need of remedial education on the fundamentals of American politics involved Compromise, the two-party system, etc., I should say here that criticizing leading Democrats on the Wikileaks issue does not imply that a Republican Administration would be more Constitutionally responsible on this issue. It's clear from the statements that Republicans have been making that no such assumption is justified. It is true that the Obama Administration has made more sweeping claims for state secrecy than the Cheney-Bush Administration ever formally did, though Cheney's doctrine of the Unitary Executive essentially claimed Presidential authority to be unlimited by the Constitution or by national and international law.

Greenwald cites this Kim Sengupta report, Assange begins mansion arrest, but his 'source' feels the heat The Independent 12/18/2010, on the conditions in which Pvt. Bradley Manning, accused of leaking classified information to Wikileaks, is being held. The Justice Department is looking to build a case that Julian Assange actively assisted Manning in obtaining the material, which would allow them to indict Assange as a co-conspirator. Assange, who is neither an American citizen nor a US government employee, is not bound by the secrecy laws Manning is accused of violating. to make that charge stick, they would need Manning to finger Assange as an accomplice.

Greenwald also discussed Manning's conditions of imprisonment in The inhumane conditions of Bradley Manning's detention Salon 12/15/2010.

Tags:

Wednesday, December 01, 2010

A mild evaluation of the latest Wikileaks dump from Timothy Garton Ash

Our Pod Pundits are no doubt disappointed that the Wikileaks cables aren't brimming with sex and current "horserace" political speculation. So much of our proud [gulp!] American press is bitching and moaning about how that naughty Wikileaks is publishing boring news about war and nuclear proliferation and international laws and stuff. Booo-ooooring. By Beltway Village standards, anyway.

Historian Timothy Garton Ash (US embassy cables: A banquet of secrets Guardian 11/28/2010) discusses some of the ways in which the current batch of documents, which will take even experts a while to sift through, is a boon for people who actually may care about the information and the major topics they touch:

The historian usually has to wait 20 or 30 years to find such treasures. Here, the most recent dispatches are little more than 30 weeks old. And what a trove this is. It contains more than 250,000 documents. Most of those I have seen, on my dives into a vast ocean, are well over 1,000 words long. If my sample is at all representative, there must be a total at least 250m words – and perhaps up to half a billion. As all archival researchers know, there is a special quality of understanding that comes from exposure to a large body of sources, be it a novelist's letters, a ministry's papers or diplomatic traffic – even though much of the material is routine. With prolonged immersion, you get a deep sense of priorities, character, thought patterns.
I'm trying to imagine CNN's Gloria Borger trying to get out a line like that last sentence. I picture her sputtering, mouth hanging open in blank outrage at who-knows-what, saying, "Priorities? Thought patterns? Who cares? 'Character', yeah, that's the stuff. What sort of catty things are in there of people insulting Hillary Clinton?"

Don't get me wrong. There's definite entertainment value in seeing fatuous pundits saying impossibly dumb things and reacting in inexplicable ways to trivia. The problem is that this is what US television passes off as "news".

Garton Ash's short evaluation in that piece is that the most recent batch of leaks shows American diplomats in a generally good light, looking competent and perceptive. He does repeat the stock official arguments about how confidentiality in diplomatic communications is important, etc. But he also makes this important observation:

Most of this material is medium-and high-level political reporting from around the world, plus instructions from Washington. It is important to remember that we do not have the top categories of secrecy here – Nodis (president, secretary of state, head of mission only), Roger, Exdis, Docklamp (between defence attaches and the defense intelligence agency only). What we have is still a royal banquet.
As examples of quality work by US diplomats, he offers the following:

As readers will discover, the man who is now America's top-ranking professional diplomat, William Burns, contributed from Russia a highly entertaining account – almost worthy of Evelyn Waugh – of a wild Dagestani wedding attended by the gangsterish president of Chechnya, who danced clumsily "with his gold-plated automatic stuck down the back of his jeans".

Burns's analyses of Russian politics are astute. So are his colleagues' reports from Berlin, Paris and London. In a 2008 dispatch from Berlin, the then grand coalition government of Christian and Social democrats in Germany is compared to "the proverbial couple that hated each other but stay together for the sake of the children". From Paris, there is a hilarious pen portrait of the antics of Nicolas (and Carla) Sarkozy. And we the British would do well to take a look at our neurotic obsession with our so-called "special relationship" with Washington, as it appears in the unsentimental mirror of confidential dispatches from the US embassy in London. ...

More broadly, what you see in this diplomatic traffic is how security and counter-terrorism concerns have pervaded every aspect of American foreign policy. But you also see how serious the threats are, and how little the west is in control of them. There is devastating stuff here about the Iranian nuclear programme and the extent not merely of Israeli but Arab fears of it ("cut off the head of the snake", a Saudi ambassador reports his king urging the Americans); the vulnerability of Pakistan's nuclear stockpile to rogue Islamists; anarchy and corruption on a massive scale in Afghanistan; al-Qaida in Yemen; and tales of the power of the Russian mafia gangs, that make John le Carré's latest novel look almost understated. [my emphasis]
The predominance of military and terrorism concerns is the immediate legacy of the Cheney-Bush Administration, whose dubious legacy in those areas the Obama Administration is largely continuing. But it's also evidence of the corrosive, militarizing effects of Andrew Bacevich's version of "the Long War", which includes the Cold War and the interim between the fall of the Soviet Union and 9/11, as well as the Global War on Terrorism (GWOT) that continues today though the Obama Administration has retired that particular label and acronym.

Tags:

Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Wikileaks revelations, torture and war crimes

One set of documents from the latest Wikileaks dump concern pressure that the US government brought on Spain to head off what the Cheney-Bush Administration clearly understood was a real danger: that Americans involved in torture or war crimes were vulnerable to prosecution under international law. Spain is well known for prosecutor Baltasar Garzón's willingness to apply universal jurisdiction to bring charges against accused perpetrators of war crimes committed in other countries.

As one example, this cable from the US Embassy in Madrid of 03/23/2007 noted (Cable en el que la Embajada de EE UU ... El País 30/11/2010; the PSOE has been the ruling party in Spain since March 2004):

As reported in reftel, magistrate Baltasar Garzon wrote an op-ed on March 20 that proposed an investigation into "criminal responsibility" for the war. Socialist Party (PSOE) secretary Jose Blanco hopped on the bandwagon in a TV ... interview that evening. The Ambassador immediately contacted National Security Adviser Casajuana to express concern. Casajuana promised to take the message to President Zapatero. [my emphasis]
The article to which the cable refers is this article by Garzón, Aniversario El País 20/03/2007. El País has a special report webpage on this round of Wikileaks.

This US Embassy cable (Cable en el que ... "pierde la paciencia" ... El País 03/21/2007) addresses the same concern:

Summary. In a volatile political climate leading up to regional/municipal elections in late May, the ruling Socialist Party (PSOE) and far left political allies have ramped up criticism of the war in Iraq, in part to counteract opposition Popular Party (PP) attacks on the Zapatero Government's controversial policies on the ETA issue. The Madrid Regional PSOE joined the far left "United Left" (IU), unions, and pacifist groups staged mass demonstrations against the war on March 17 - though the turnout was lower than for the anti-ETA march. On March 20, high profile magistrate Baltasar Garzon published an editorial in the left leaning "El Pais" saying that the time had arrived to investigate "criminal responsibility" for the war in Iraq, to include possible charges against former President Aznar, PM Blair, and President Bush (Spaniards frequently refer to the "Picture of the Azores" in 2003 of the three leaders as the moment in which the decision to go to war was made, thus linking Aznar not just with the Spanish troop deployment, but with full responsibility for the war). PSOE Secretary Jose Blanco said in a March 20 television interview that "someone must pay" for the war in Iraq, and that if someone could demonstrate criminal culpability on the part of political leaders, Blanco said he was "all for it." The Ambassador contacted National Security Adviser Carles Casajuana on March 21 to convey his deep concern regarding the direction and tenor of PSOE statements on Iraq, which could only harm bilateral relations. Casajuana discussed the heated political context of the statements and said he expected them to abate soon, but assured the Ambassador that he would convey the Ambassador's concerns to President Zapatero immediately. The DCM is following up with PSOE Secretary Blanco to insist that the PSOE avoid dragging the ... USG [US Government] into its domestic conflict with the PP. End summary.
Things like this are not a surprise. But it is good to see it laid out like this, because Dick Cheney and George Bush were claiming their actions were legal, leaning on the dishonest internal legal opinions they flunkies like John Yoo generated.

This is also an interesting little tidbit to see (Cable en el que se critican las acusaciones a mandos de EE UU El País 30/11/2010):

[President Zapatero] may even take credit, as in the case of adjustments in U.S.-Cuba policy, for shaping USG views. He is not innately ill-disposed to the USG. For him, foreign policy is subordinate to domestic political interests, and the U.S. relationship is just one more element to be viewed XXXXXXXXXXXX.

MADRID 00000614 003.2 OF 004

currently a wave of goodwill for President Obama in Spain, which is the answer to Zapatero's prayers in that it enables him to engage the USG without being dinged by the traditional anti-U.S. sentiment among his socialist base. XXXXXXXXXXXX. Zapatero does not speak English, though we think he may understand it.
I'm surprised that the Embassy wouldn't know something like that about a head of state. I also can't believe that Zapatero doesn't speak some English.

Carlos Yárnoz covers this aspect of the story in EE UU maniobró en la Audiencia Nacional para frenar casos El País 30.11.2010.

On the Wikileaks revelations in general, the Guardian has comments from several figures in US embassy cables: Verdict on the leaks about the Middle East 11/29/2010. One of the them is former British diplomat Craig Murray:

It is seriously argued that ambassadors will not in future give candid advice if there is a chance that that advice might become public. In the past 12 hours I have heard this remarkable proposition put forward on five different television networks, without anybody challenging it. ...

Put it another way and the cracks start to appear. The best advice is advice you would not be prepared to defend in public. Really? Why? In today's globalised world, embassies are not a unique source of expertise. Often, expatriate, academic and commercial organisations are a lot better informed. The best policy advice is not advice that is shielded from peer review.
What the establishment mean is that ambassadors should be free to recommend things that the general public would view with deep opprobrium, without any danger of being found out. But should they really be allowed to do that, in a democracy? [my emphasis]
This 11/29/2010 PBS interview with (How Will New WikiLeaks Revelations Affect Diplomatic Candor?) includes Zbigniew Brzezinski of the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) and former George W. Bush advisor Stephen Hadley discussing Wikileaks. Brzezinski, and hardcore devotee of the Realist foreign policy school has some worthwhile comments. (Hadley, as I said, was a Bush II Administration advisor.)



Tags: , , , ,