Showing posts with label muslim ban. Show all posts
Showing posts with label muslim ban. Show all posts

Saturday, March 11, 2017

The Trump image of immigrants as a terrorist threat

Kate Brannen at Just Security (More Info Needed on Travel Ban’s Claim that 300 Refugees Under Counterterrorism Investigations 03/06/2017) has an update on the demagogic claims that the Trump Family Business Administration is making about "criminal aliens" to justify their mass deportation program that is primarily aimed at Latinos residents in the US.

A key point is that being investigated for something at all terrorism-related is not at all the same as being charged, much less convicted. And as Brannon writes, "It goes without saying that just because there is an investigation, that does not mean terrorist activity has been established."

... Faiza [Patel] notes that it’s important to know whether the word “investigation” is actually referring to an “assessment” or a full investigation. “An assessment is an early stage investigation which does not require suspicion of criminal activity, but rather can be started by an agent with an ‘authorized purpose,'” Faiza says. “The overwhelming majority of assessments do not result in full investigations — not surprising because they are not based on facts.”

This New York Times article from 2011 shows that from December 2008 to March 2009, only 3.7 percent of 11,667 assessments led to full investigations.

The number of investigations leading to successful prosecutions is even smaller. According to Justice Department statistics, there were 580 terrorism and terrorism-related convictions from Sept 11, 2001 through the end 2014. That’s roughly 41 to 42 per year, so about 10 percent of full investigations lead to a conviction (assuming the numbers obtained by the NYT are representative of the rate at which investigations lead to convictions).

Also of note is the fact that terrorism-related suspicions can cover a broad category of offenses, including immigration violations, according to Faiza. “These may have started as terrorism investigations, but we cannot know whether they actually have anything to do with terrorism.”


Andrew Lindsay analyzed the information on immigrants and terrorism last month for the Brennan Center in What the Data Tells Us About Immigration and Terrorism 02/17/2017, reminding us that many of the actual "terrorism" convictions since 2001 have been FBI stings, some of very dubious quality:

For example, Laguerre Payen is one of four convicted in a Newburgh, NY sting operation made infamous by an HBO documentary. An FBI informant recruited James Cromite, a low-level drug dealer and offered him $250,000 to recruit three other Muslims and carry out an attack. The informant recruited Payen, a homeless crack addict and paranoid schizophrenic. When told of a trip to Florida as reward, Payen said he could not go because he had no passport. He hardly posed the type of threat on which the government should expend resources.

Another example is Patrick Abraham, one of five convicted in a Miami sting operation. An FBI informant targeted a group of poor African-American and Haitian men, offering them $50,000 to join a terror plot. Subsequently, the informant recorded Abraham and the other men pledging allegiance to al-Qaeda. The group, dubbed the Liberty City 7, was not even Muslim, but a sect of the Moorish Science Temple that called itself the “Seas of David.” According to Mother Jones, the men were financially strapped misfits who operated out of a warehouse, where they had no weapons save a ceremonial sword. They were clearly misguided in seeking support from a purported member of a terrorist group but not, as the government asserts, domestic al-Qaeda operatives intent on, much less capable of, committing harm to the United States.
"Relying on raw and undifferentiated data," he writes, "serves to obfuscate rather than assist the development of an effective response" to terrorism.

And there's this: Fahgim Abeb and Rod Nordland, Afghans Who Worked for U.S. Are Told Not to Apply for Visas, Advocates Say New York Times 03/10/2017.

Officials at the International Refugee Assistance Project at the Urban Justice Center in New York said they had learned that as of Thursday, Afghans were being told that applications were no longer being accepted, though the suspension had taken place on March 1. “Our worst fears are proving true,” said Betsy Fisher, the group’s policy director.

Mac McEachin, another official at the organization, said the decision could affect the 2,500 soldiers of the Army’s 82nd Airborne Division who might be deployed to Syria. “Now that the world has seen how we turn our backs on our Afghan allies, there is almost no chance that local allies in Syria will be inclined to work with us,” he said.

American military officials are also requesting an increase in troops deployed to Afghanistan.
Does anyone in this Administration know what they're doing except for hustling sweetheart deals for the family business?

Wednesday, March 08, 2017

Fighting the mass deportation

A press release from the National Immigration Law Center describes legal efforts on behalf of Daniela Vargas, the Argentine Dreamer arrested in Jackson MS by ICE in an obvious retaliation for her having spoken out publicly against the Trump Family Business Administration for arrested her father and brother as part of their mass deporation operation (Civil and Immigrants’ Rights Groups Work to Win Release for Dreamer Daniela Vargas and Prevent Deportation 03/07/2017):

Civil and immigrant rights groups have taken legal action to stop the deportation of Daniela Vargas, a DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) recipient who was detained by immigration agents immediately after she spoke at a March 1 press conference protesting recent U.S. Immigration & Customs Enforcement (ICE) raids in Mississippi. Vargas spoke of her hope that she and other Dreamers could remain in and contribute to this country.

The National Immigration Law Center (NILC), the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC), the law firm of Elmore & Peterson, and the Law Office of William Most filed a habeas petition on Monday in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Louisiana, Alexandria Division.

“Detaining Dany just minutes after she spoke publicly about immigrants’ rights appears to be nothing short of ICE retaliating against somebody who dared assert their First Amendment rights,” said Naomi Tsu, deputy legal director for the SPLC. “Dany, an aspiring math teacher and active community member, is not a threat to her community. Her detention only serves to chill free speech and stoke fear throughout immigrant communities.”
BBC Mundo reports on the 23 countries that ICE describes as uncooperative or outright refusing to take deportees that the US claims are from their countries. (Los 23 países que rechazan recibir a sus nacionales deportados desde Estados Unidos 03/07/2017) Cuba is the only one from Latin America on the list of 23. Canada is also not one of the 23. And Canada is seeing an increase in the number of Mexicans requesting refuge there. Aumenta en Canadá el número de peticionarios mexicanos por refugio

Just Security 03/08/2017 provides A Line-by-Line Comparison Between Trump’s Original Muslim Ban and Today’s 03/08/2017.

Faiza Patel evaluates the new order in A Muslim Ban By Any Other Name Smells Just the Same Brennan Center 03/06/2017: "The revised executive order President Trump signed Monday morning is still a Muslim ban and it is still unconstitutional."

I'm guessing that the Trump Family Business Administration will try to protect at least one business from being much disturbed: the small arms proliferation business, which relies heavily on its own form of undocumented activity, Estados Unidos, principal vendedor de armas a México Proceso TV 03/07/2017:



Tuesday, March 07, 2017

Separating refugee kids from their parents on the southern US border

Mexican Chancellor Luis Vedegaray made an official statement of concern to the US government over the leak and/or trial balloon of a proposal to separate mothers caught crossing the US border without proper papers from any of their children they might be bringing in. (Angélica Mercado y Sivia Arellano, Preocupa a México que EU separe a madres de hijos: Vedgaray Milenio 07.03.2017)

The current government of President Peña Nieto is trying to avoid confrontational postures with the Trump Family Business Administration. But both the immigration and trade policies of the Trump family will make confrontations difficult to avoid.

Amy Goodman on Democracy Now! discusses the latest version of the Muslim ban, This is Still a Muslim Ban: Trump's New Executive Order Decried for Discriminating Based on Religion 03/07/2017



Aljazeera's Empire Files reports on the new Muslim ban, Will Donald Trumps' travel bans serve any purpose? 03/07/2017:



The PBS Newshour presented these two reports on the new ban. Trump administration announces new travel ban 03/06/2017:



This second one features the notorious xenophobe and segregationist Kris Kobach, Is Trump’s revised travel ban constitutional? 03/07/2017:


Saturday, February 11, 2017

Trump's xenophobia Muslim Ban undermines national security

Steve Vladeck describes the statement of several former national security officials, including John Kerry and Janet Napolitano condemning Trump's Executive Order instituting the Muslim ban in Bepartisan Ex-Senior US Officials to Federal Court: Trump's Immigration Order Endangers National Security Just Security 02/06/2017. He quotes this section from their statement:

We all agree that the United States faces real threats from terrorist networks and must take all prudent and effective steps to combat them, including the appropriate vetting of travelers to the United States. We all are nevertheless unaware of any specific threat that would justify the travel ban established by the Executive Order issued on January 27, 2017. We view the Order as one that ultimately undermines the national security of the United States, rather than making us safer. In our professional opinion, this Order cannot be justified on national security or foreign policy grounds. It does not perform its declared task of “protecting the nation from foreign terrorist entry into the United States.” To the contrary, the Order disrupts thousands of lives, including those of refugees and visa holders all previously vetted by standing procedures that the Administration has not shown to be inadequate. It could do long-term damage to our national security and foreign policy interests, endangering U.S. troops in the field and disrupting counterterrorism and national security partnerships. It will aid ISIL’s propaganda effort and serve its recruitment message by feeding into the narrative that the United States is at war with Islam. It will hinder relationships with the very communities that law enforcement professionals need to address the threat. [my emphasis]
Fred Kaplan judges that the Executive Order (EO) shows, "He doesn’t seem to understand the political nature of war or the strategic consequences of politics." (The Commander Stumbles Slate 01/29/2017)

Vladeck also explains:

The statement also assesses that “the Order will endanger intelligence sources in the field,” which is notable since the signatories include John McLaughlin and Michael Morell, who served at different points as Deputy Director and Acting Director of the CIA during the George W. Bush Administration.

The group’s statement also calls into doubt any deference that might normally be given to executive branch decision-making. “The ‘considered judgment’ of the President in the prior cases where courts have deferred was based upon administrative records showing that the President’s decision rested on cleared views from expert agencies,” their statement reads. “Here, there is little evidence that the Order underwent a thorough interagency legal and policy processes designed to address current terrorist threats [and] we know of no interagency process underway before January 20, 2017 to change current vetting procedures.” [my emphasis]

Also at Just Security, Cristina Rodríguez expands on that point (Trump and the Immigration Bureaucracy: Should We Expect Civil Servants to Dissent? 02/09/2017):

By all accounts,... it appears that the Trump White House failed to enlist the relevant agency heads, much less their knowledgeable civil service personnel, when formulating the order—bypassing inter-agency consultation that could have highlighted operational concerns. The initial chaos at the airports in the days after the order’s release, and the administration’s repeated change of position on whether the EO applied to green card holders, suggest it had no real insight or plan for how to provide implementation guidance. The airport turmoil was only exacerbated by the nature of customs and border officials’ jobs. Officers at ports of entry have considerable discretion when determining whether to allow a non-citizen into the country. They know it, and they operate with that frame of mind every day. The administration’s failure to communicate the meaning of the new order created uneven enforcement. The sweeping reach of the order further amounted to a shock to the system, opening the door to overbearing law enforcement and excessive hardships for families and others.

Amazingly enough, the absence of inter-agency consultation and communication with the bureaucracy might actually become relevant in the litigation, as courts seem willing to question the President’s national security judgment in light of the haphazard formulation and implementation of the order. His disorganization and poor planning is an indication that national security may not have been his motive at all. [my emphasis]
Personal rule of the United States may be turning out to be harder than our new President expected.

But, as Dahlia Lithwick says, "There is no longer any doubt that President Trump is at war with the federal judiciary. The more the courts align against him, crossing virtually all ideological and political divisions to do so, the more he insists they are partisan and “political” and willfully endangering the country." (Why Trump Has Declared War on the Judiciary Slate 02/10/2017)

Thursday, February 09, 2017

Trump not persuading the Morning Joe crew on the Muslim ban

Even Joe Scarbourgh is apparently dismayed by the President's antics over the Muslim ban, as we hear in Joe: 'Presidents Do Not Speak This Way' Morning Joe 02/09/2017:



But Republicans still aren't ready for this:



And this is a bizarre twist in the immigration story:



This, however, is unsurprising news!


Sunday, February 05, 2017

American Football fans too delicate to see the Trump wall? (Updated)

Apparently FOX News thought so: El comercial de Super Bowl censurado por hablar del muro de Trump La Opinión 05.20.2017; Sapna Maheshwari, Challenge for Super Bowl Commercials: Not Taking Sides, Politically New York Times 02/02/2017.

The 84 Lumber company made an add about a Latina mother and her daughter, presumably Mexican, taking the dangerous trip to enter the United States without papers. FOX News required them to take some scenes featuring a border wall out.

This is the shorter version that runs during the Super Bowl, 84 Lumber Super Bowl Commercial - The Journey Begins 02/02/2017



Melissa Wylie writes about how the company is navigating the controversy in How her company leveraged a Super Bowl ad smackdown Bizwomen 02/02/2017

Meanwhile, legal obstacles continue for the Muslim ban immigration restrictions, Trump ban fails again in courts; window opens for travelers to US Middle East Eye 02/05/2017

Update 02/03/2017: The company has now made the full version of video available, including the parts that FOX thought were two intense for their delicate viewers, 84 Lumber Super Bowl Commercial - The Entire Journey:



Friday, February 03, 2017

Friday in Trumpist xenophobia

Aljazeera's UpFront takes a look at how Muslim fundamentalists, and the Islamic State in particular, may use Trump's Muslim ban in propaganda, Is Trump's Muslim ban a gift to ISIL? 02/03/2017:



The latter half of the program has a discussion about Russian and Ukraine.

Deutsche Welle's Spanish channel's Quadriga also discusses the Trumpist immigration policy, Veto migratorio: ¿Fin de una sociedad abierta? 02/03/2017:



An attorney for the government said in court: Over 100,000 visas revoked, government lawyer says in Virginia court CNN 002/03/2017.

The ExxonMobil State Department said the number was less than 60,000. One might think that government attorney making a presentation in court might be more careful to give the correct numbers than the State Department. But with the Trump Family Business Administration, who knows?