Showing posts with label scott horton. Show all posts
Showing posts with label scott horton. Show all posts

Friday, October 14, 2011

Celebrity politics, the flip side of demagoguery and cynicism

California Gov. Jerry Brown, Inaugural Address 01/03/2011:

Without the trust of the people, politics degenerates into mere spectacle; and democracy declines, leaving demagoguery and cynicism to fill the void.
Human rights attorney Scott Horton 10/06/2011 (A Snapshot from the Age of Distraction No Comment):

We have created an environment in which scrutiny of political candidates is superficial, and in which candidates can get away with knowing only enough about critical issues to fill a three-by-five-inch filing card. Illiteracy about key economic issues is widespread, and vacuous, simplistic formulations are put forth without being challenged or parsed. Bogus claims about history are made without shame or correction. That would be a fair summary of the televised debates, which offer little actual debating and are often packaged to resemble a television game show. Is America going about picking presidential candidates the way viewers choose their favorite contestants on "American Idol"? America today faces the very real prospect of a double-dip recession, and is deeply enmeshed in two land wars in the Middle East (one of which marks its first decade this week) that are unpopular but that our political elites don’t want to discuss. It faces the prospect of a "lost generation" of un- and underemployed youth. But our political culture continues to avoid vital issues. Instead, we are treated to political tragicomedy.
Tags: , ,

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

The US, Pakistan and the Raymond Davis case

Former Special Forces officer and CIA contractor Raymond Davis is scheduled to be arraigned in court in Lahore, Pakistan on Wednesday in a case which has seriously soured relations between the United States and Pakistan. Scott Horton has an informative background piece on the case in Spy Games Foreign Policy 03/11/2011 (updated 03/14/2011). Davis is accused of shooting two Pakistanis execution-syle in the street in Lahore. Horton writes:

The problem is that lately Washington and Islamabad have been less than friendly. "The diplomatic immunity struggle over Davis is a smokescreen for other issues," one senior AfPak analyst told me. "It actually goes to the heart of a dispute over national security issues of the utmost importance to both Pakistan and the United States."

More than a month after Davis's arrest, sources in Washington began to acknowledge what had been reported in the Pakistani media from the outset: Davis was a contractor for the CIA. In short time he was identified as its acting station chief. Shortly thereafter, Pakistani intelligence sources claimed that the motorcyclists Davis had killed, who had previously been portrayed by Davis's defenders as street thugs, had in fact been known to Davis -- as low-level operatives of the ISI, who had been assigned to tail him. Davis had crossed "a red line," Pakistani officials told ABC News.

But what was that "red line"? Neither the ISI nor the CIA is eager to air their disagreements in public. But in the last three months, the friction between them has grown so intense that the flashpoints have become obvious. Some disputes have to do with specific personnel; others have to do with broader questions of policy and specific operations. But the essence is clear: The ISI believes that the CIA can only be given free range to operate on Pakistani soil if it treats the ISI as an equal, sharing with the ISI information about its personnel, the operations on which it is engaged, and the information it secures from those operations. And until the CIA makes meaningful concessions on the ISI's demands, the ISI is prepared to clamp down on the CIA. Indeed, at present no one appreciates that point more intensely than Raymond Davis.
See also his blog post of the same name, Spy Games No Comment 03/14/2011.

Tags: , ,

Monday, January 12, 2009

A legal precedent on chief executives and torture

Scott Horton in Bush’s Torture Confession 01/12/08 at his Harper's blog No Comment points to an important legal precedent in Anglo-Saxon law for when a chief executive of the government directs or knowingly allows prisoners to be tortured.

Horton isn't advocating that the penalty be the same. But he does advocate that it be treated as a criminal matter.


King Charles I of England


Tags: , ,

Sunday, December 09, 2007

A very sad question


US Chief Prosecutor Justice Robert Jackson at the Nuremberg Trials

Scott Horton of the Harper's blog No Comment tells this story in Remembering December 7 12/07/07. For the context of the story, I should point out that Horton is American:

A short time ago, in Germany, I spoke with one of the senior advisors of [Christian Democratic] Chancellor Angela Merkel. I noted that a criminal complaint had been filed against Donald Rumsfeld and a number of others invoking universal jurisdiction for war crimes offenses. How would the chancellor see this, I asked? There was a long pause, and I fully expected to get a brush-off response. But what came was very surprising. "You must remember," said the advisor, "that my chancellor was born and raised in a totalitarian state [Communist East Germany]. She cannot be indifferent to questions of this sort. In fact, she views them as matters of the utmost gravity and they will be treated that way. The Nuremberg process happened in my country. It was painful for us. But we absorbed it. It became a part of our legacy. An important part of our legacy. We will not forget it. But I have to ask you: why has your country forgotten?" (my emphasis)
To answer the question, you would have to look at the evolution of the Republican Party during the last four decades. I've suggested that two key guidelines in doing so would be, "Follow the segregationists" and "Follow Dick Cheney". Tracing those two strands of recent Republican Party history will go a long way toward answering it.

Tags: , , ,

Sunday, November 04, 2007

The torture issue

Here are a couple of worthwhile posts on the torture issue: Tortured Editorials Scott Horton Harper's No Comment blog 11/04/07; Now Why Didn't I Think of That? Washington Post Proposes That Senate Ban Torture! by Marty Lederman, Balkinization blog 11/02/07. Both talk about the specifics of the ways torture is illegal in the US, and how scandalously pitiful the national debate on the subject has been.

Digby also has a well-meaning post on the ugly topic, Too Much Fun Hallabaloo blog 11/03/07. She's right critical of the irresponsibility of CNN reporter Jeanne Moos. But she doesn't question the essentially anecdotal evidence she apparently used as the basis of her report. Staged YouTube videos of water-boarding? Let's get real. People who went through torture survival training that included water-boarding have testified about its effects. Since that particular torture technique has been around since at least the days of the Spanish Inquisition, which was founded in 1488, it's not as though there isn't evidence about what the practice actually does. YouTube videos are her evidence? Our TV media is a train wreck.

Digby also has this to say:

Every time they normalize state sanctioned sadism, from tasering to waterboarding, we are one step closer to fully accepting a police state. That's how they do it. It never happens over night. It happens one taboo at a time.
But I don't this is exactly what's happened on torture. Cheney and Bush used the 9/11 attacks to stoke fear and hatred, and the Geneva Conventions went out the window fairly quickly. Tasering, whatever its merits or lack thereof, is normally used in making arrests. Tasering a prisoner strapped down to a table would be torture, and there's no general acceptance (legal or otherwise) of such a practice.

The leap into the torture practice was sudden, not gradual. If we had a real press corps instead of the corporate Potemkin version with which we are currently blessed, they would have made torture and execution of prisoners-of-war a major news story in late 2001 as soon as such crimes started emerging in the early weeks of the Afghanistan War. What's been gradual is Congress and the media reacting against torture.

Still one of the most remarkable moments of the Cheney-Bush administration to me was back on 12/01/01, when Rummy was being interviewed on TV by Novakula (Robert Novak) about war crimes being committed by the Northern Alliance, the America-backed guerrilla group, which was still recognized by most countries as the legitimate government of Afghanistan. Rummy replied:

The fact that they don't happen to subscribe to some convention that we do or that other countries do is a fact. It is also a fact that we have to stop those terrorists from killing more Americans. And I don't feel even the slightest problem in working with the Northern Alliance to achieve that end.
There was Rummy on national television sneering at the Geneva Conventions as "some convention" for which he had total contempt. Certainly in the European Union, any defense minister who had made such a comment in public would have been required to resign the following day, if not the same day.

But there he was, announcing it to the world. And our "press corps" and Congress snoozed right through it.

Tags: , , , ,

Saturday, October 06, 2007

"Libertarianism" at the airport

Herbert Hoover: he was against the "fascist" New Deal and Roozevelt socialism, too

Continuing my grumbling about "libertarianism" from Friday, there's a good example of how dingy "libertarian" dogma can be at Antiwar Radio (on Antiwar.com). Dated 10/05/07, it's an audio interview by Scott Horton with Becky Akers, who the site describes as follows:

Becky Akers discusses the case of Carol Anne Gotbaum who was killed while being detained by cops at the Phoenix airport, how the government’s control over TSA [Transportation Safety Administration] and countless other entities results in waste and mismanagement, the benefits of free-market security and America’s descent into despotism.
It also identifies her as a regular contributor to the neo-Confederate site LewRockwell.com.

Both interviewers who are currently featured at Antiwar Radio, Charles Goyette and Scott Horton, seem to assume that we already live in a "police state" in the US. Akers is on board with that concept. Now, I'm not familiar with the details of the Carol Anne Gotbaum case, where a woman died after being taken custody by police at the Phoenix airport. But I'm not sure from the interview how familiar Akers is with it either. She mainly uses it to rant about the evils of government.

It's a good example of how "libertarians" come up with surprising arguments which are often unfamiliar to those who are not immersed in Ayn Rand when we first hear them.

Akers complains that the government has anything to do with airport security. And even that the government owns airports. In her utopia, private businesses would own airports and they, working together with the airlines, would provide security. And that security, being sprinkled with the magic of the Private Sector, would be far better than what the TSA currently provides. Because the airlines and the private airports would know their customers wanted security, so they would provide it.

But wait, you may be saying, isn't that what happened prior to 9/11? Those airlines used to provide security. And being responsive in the free market to their customers' complaints about the annoyance of the security checks, they tried to minimize the checks. Being subject to the competitive pressures of the free markets, they tried to keep ticket prices for major routes down. And being under the sovereign authority of their stock holders in the free market, they were under tremendous pressure to show rising profits each year and each quarter, which means they needed to cut costs wherever they could.

The result of this lovely free-market process? Inadequate security equipment, inadequate procedures, and very low-paid security personnel, many of whom were in jobs with more than 100% turnover in a year. This also meant that the personnel were often inexperienced, poorly trained, not terribly motivated and often not very friendly. So how is it going to help things if we go back to that system?

Oh, silly you. You obviously don't understand the, uh, depths of libertarian dogma. Because, you see, the airlines are government, too! True, they're technically private companies. But they get subsidies from the federal government! That means they're all just another set of socialistic institutions crushing out our liberty in the police state. (Hey, the hardcore libertarians actually do talk this way.)

In Aker's utopian free-market Eden, the airlines, the airports and all the security people will be privately owned. (A bit of a slip there; I guess it is the security services which will be privately owned, not the security people: but with libertarians, you can't be sure.) They will all be free of government safety and security regulations, they won't have to worry about all those pesky financial reporting standards or about lawsuits from irate customers, and of course they won't have hassle with any of those dang unions!

And what if these companies foolishly cut corners to squeeze out a bit of extra profit or just skim the company funds? Well, you don't need to worry, because we'll all be able to carry the weapons of our choice onto the airplanes with us. Akers was really irritated that people coming into the airports are "disarmed". Shoot, once we can bring our Glocks and Uzis and double-barrelled shotguns onto the plane with us, we won't have to worry about no terrorists. Somebody starts talkin' Arabic or some funny language like that, or if you hear somebody say something that sounds like "Allah", or some dark-skinned guy stands up and looks like he's up to something, the passengers can just gun him down right away. Who needs these socialistic government-paid police?

Akers griped that when she goes to the airport now, she feels helpless because "I don't have my gun, I don't have my knife". This, she says, is destroying civility and even civilization itself.

You get the drift. You can listen to the interview if you want to hear Akers explain how somebody named Leviathan has a giant conspiracy going through the TSA to make middle-class and wealthy white folks think like poor black people. Or something like that. It starts around minute 16. Mr. Leviathan's ultimate goal, she says, is to have police stationed in all our neighborhoods to make us go through scanners before we enter our houses. Scott Horton reminded her that there would be eyeball scans, too. And he gets in his usual plug for the crackpot rightwinger Ron Paul.

Now, this is the sort of thing that you can only take seriously if you grew up doing something like spending your every waking hour by the pool at the country club. If fans of this kind of stuff are antiwar, it's probably because they think war threatens to raise taxes on rich people and risks subjecting nice white youngsters to a military draft. No true AynRandian individualist would want to compromise his soul by having to spend a couple of years in a collectivist institution like the Army. And this idea that the wealthy should have to pay taxes or do anything else to support their country, why that's just another version of fascocommunistislamistdefeatocratism!
Sure, libertarians when you catch them running loose like on that radio interview will say things that don't sound like your standard stodgy Republican, such grouching about the cops or whining about intrusions on privacy.

But, in practice, to the extent that libertarians have any noticeable impact on American politics, it tends to be through advocacy of their free-market, no-regulations-on-business ideas, like through the "libertarian" think-tank, the Cato Institute. As of this writing, the following items are featured on their Web site's homepage:

"The Antitrust Religion", which looks to be a polemic against gubment regulation of business

"Cato Scholar Testifies on Reforming Health Care in Wisconsin" (hint: he's not demanding a broad new government program to plug gaps in health insurance)

"Bush Vetoes SCHIP Expansion", praising Bush's veto of the dangerous socialistic program to provide health care for more children, with links to several articles explaining why such dreadful threats to American liberty have to be blocked

"Supreme Court Begins New Term", bitching about how That Man Roosevelt turned the Supreme Court into stark raving socialists, or something to that effect

Less prominent items on the front page include an article about "what FDR had in common with the other charismatic collectivists of the 1930s". Follow the link and you can read about the "surprising similarities between the programs of Roosevelt, Mussolini, and Hitler". Well, Stalin, too, but it's a review of a book that focuses on the other three.

This is not unusual. While the Antiwar.com site usually presents the antiwar and civil-libertarian side of libertarianism, that's not the main focus of the small libertarian movement. Theoretically, libertarians generally may be concerned with such things. But their main influence is to promote Republican-friendly, "pro-business", anti-regulation, anti-union causes. Their political and philosophical affinities, and those of some of their biggest bankrollers, are much closer to the Republicans than to the Democrats.

In the end, so is their narrowly-nationalistic, isolationist foreign policy perspective. They mostly share the unilateralist outlook of Dick Cheney and George Bush. They just don't approve of their current wars.

Tags: , , , , ,

Friday, October 05, 2007

You want me to read what?

Antiwar.com 10/05/07 promotes the article War With Iran? Who Decides? from a John Birch Society journal

I know the various sayings: politics makes strange bedfellows, the enemy of my enemy is my friend and yadda, yadda.

But the John Birch Society is a crackpot group of rightwing promoters of hate and bigotry.

So I wasn't thrilled to see at Antiwar.com an article highlighted from a Bircher journal, The New American. The "About" Web page for that journal explains:

In addition to political topics, The New American also publishes articles about economics (from a free-enterprise perspective of course!), culture, and history. It is published by American Opinion Publishing, a wholly owned subsidiary of The John Birch Society.
I've posted before about how Antiwar.com is a "libertarian" site with philosophical affinities to the neo-Confederate LewRockwell.com crew.

I've cited articles on numerous occasions from Antiwar.com, and I expect to continue to do so. The same page that featured the Bircher article link also links to a number of current news articles on war-related matters and to articles by Norman Solomon, Ted Rall and Tom Engelhardt, none of whom are close to the Birchers' worldview. The Antiwar Radio feature there has some very impressive guests, including Juan Cole, Wesley Clark, Chalmers Johnson, Gareth Porter, Ray McGovern, Andrew Bacevich and others who are not associated with some crackpot far-right ideology.

So I encourage people to use Antiwar.com for the resources it provides, as I will continue to do.

But front-paging the John Birch Society? This makes me really wish that there was a comparable site run by real liberals or Greens or Catholic antiwar activists that was providing this service. Because Antiwar.com is also a site where articles by rightwingers from LewRockwell.com and now the Birchers are presented favorably to new audiences and have an additional route to mainstreaming their far-right ideas.

Antiwar Radio also features the occasional "libertarian" guest, like the following:

William Norman Grigg, publisher of TheRightSource, and author of the blog Pro-Libertate, discusses America’s descent into an authoritarian fascist state, our current system’s similarity to the way things are in China and Cuba (executions, slave labor, new prisons in waiting, etc.), the Prison-Industrial-Complex, the economics of the corporate warfare/police state, its origins in the Civil and Indian wars, the solution of laissez faire, the militarization of domestic police, the American civic religion of force that makes it all possible and the push for a North American Union. (my emphasis)
The "North American Union" is a popular bugaboo right now for the black-helicopter nativist crowd.

Far-right Congressman Ron Paul is a real favorite at Antiwar.com. Scott Horton at Antiwar Radio can't seem to do an interview with anyone lately without making a plug or two for "Dr. Ron Paul" and his wise thoughts. As Dave Neiwert has pointed out, Ron Paul has been notable over the years for his role in helping to mainstream themes from the far-right gutter to the "respectable" bosom of the Republican Party. Despite his being one of the few overtly antiwar Republicans in Congress, I've always been very suspicious of Paul's Presidential candidacy and even of his antiwar position. One of the reasons he gives for opposing the Iraq War is that he says it was authorized by and is being fought on behalf of the United Nations, a perennial bogeyman of the far right. (That anti-UN sentiment is very much mainstream Republicanism now.)

But the UN did not authorize the invasion of Iraq. In a weird, mirror-image kind of way, he's defending the false claims of Bush and Tony Blair in 2003 that their invasion of Iraq was in defense of UN resolutions.

The Bircher article that Antiwar.com front-paged is also lavish with the Ron Paul quotations. Not surprising: the Birchers like his crackpot economic ideas, too.

I know, "it takes all kinds," and all that. Some isolationist and "libertarian" types do sometimes have decent analyses of some aspect of the Iraq War or US foreign policy. But rightwing isolationism, whether it's the Old Right brand or the paleo-conservative or the neo-Confederate or the clean-shaven-lets-legalize-dope libertarian variety, is based on the same kind of nationalism and nativism that Dick Cheney's unilateralism is. No one should kid themselves about where that perspective leads, even if it agrees with the liberal/left position on the Iraq War or some other particular issue.

Politics make strange bedfellows, true. But that doesn't mean we have to let them take the covers.

And you may want to look twice and three times at articles from Antiwar.com by authors you don't immediately recognize when they talk about anything to do with Israel or Jews. The Birchers don't much like them either.

Tags: , , , , ,