Showing posts with label tony blair. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tony blair. Show all posts

Friday, July 08, 2016

The Chilcot report on Britain's involvement in the Iraq War

An official British inquiry into the Iraq War has made its report. Thirteen years after the invasion.

By Steven Erlanger and David Sanger report on it in Chilcot Report on Iraq War Offers Devastating Critique of Tony Blair New York Times 07/06/2016:

The report’s 2.6 million words describe a prime minister who wanted stronger evidence of the need for military action and a more solid plan for occupying Iraq and reconstituting a government there. Beyond its pledge of fealty to Mr. Bush, the July 28, 2002, note warned broadly of the risks of “unintended consequences’’ from an invasion and presciently forecast that other European nations would be reluctant to back the war.

Continue reading the main story
But by the time the invasion was launched, most of Mr. Blair’s warnings and conditions had been swept aside, the report concluded. The chairman of the committee, John Chilcot, said on Wednesday morning that Mr. Blair had been advised by his diplomats and ministers of “the inadequacy of U.S. plans” and their concern “about the inability to exert significant influence on U.S. planning.”

Mr. Blair chose to override their objections.
BBC News provides a bullelt-point summary here, Chilcot report: Findings at-a-glance 07/06/2016.

Paul Pillar contrasts the Chilcot report to the The Iraq War and the American and British Ways of Retrospection The National Interest 07/08/2016:

The release of the Chilcot report ought to be the occasion for Americans to reflect on another asymmetry between the United States and Britain regarding the Iraq War: that it was the U.S. administration, not any British government, that initiated this whole horrible idea. The United Kingdom got involved because Blair was Bush's poodle, who was so concerned about keeping U.S.-U.K. relations harmonious that he wrote to George W. Bush, “I will be with you, whatever.” Americans ought to think about the responsibilities of global leadership, and about how easy it is to abuse a position of power in which even a significant and proud country like the United Kingdom will fall in line that way. Dragging Britain into the Iraq mess was such an abuse of power. It was a betrayal of one of America's most important and staunchest allies. It gives many, including not just in Britain but elsewhere, reason to be less inclined to follow the U.S. lead in the future. [my emphasis]
This is something the Obama Administration could and should have done.

The full report is available online.

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Tony Blair, Syria, Islam and fear itself

Remember Tony Blair and Saddam Hussein's (nonexistent) ready-to-use-in-45-minutes WMD claim?

From BBC News, Timeline: The 45-minute claim 10/13/2004:

24 September 2003

The dossier is published with a foreword from Tony Blair, which says: "The document discloses that his military planning allows for some of the WMD to be ready within 45 minutes of an order to use them."

The prime minister tells MPs the intelligence concludes that Saddam Hussein "has existing and active military plans for the use of chemical and biological weapons, which could be activated within 45 minutes, including against his own Shia population".

London's Evening Standard carries the headline: "45 minutes from attack".
You would think after such an epic FAIL! that Lord Blair would try to refrain from ever again making any kind of claim about WMDs at all. But you would be wrong.

Lord Blair now wants the NATO powers to go to war in Syria. So he writes, "Assad is using chemical weapons on a limited but deadly scale." (The Trouble Within Islam Project Syndicate 06/10/2013)

Why would anyone with any kind of responsible attitude toward war and peace ever again listen to anything the man, who became known as "Bush's Poodle" for his shameless subservience to the Cheney-Bush Administration during the run-up to the invasion of Iraq, has to say about going to war? If you just want to be conned, sure. If you love cheering for war and killing based on lies, Lord Blair's your man. If you think the risks and consequences of real-world war are the same as for video combat games, go right ahead.

Lord Blair's message: Scary Muslims everywhere! Aiieee-eeeeee!!! Let's have more wars now!now!!now!!!

His anti-Muslim message is pretty much indistinguishable from the clean-shaven fundamentalist Christian Right version:

But I am afraid that the problematic strain within Islam is not the province of a few extremists. It has at its heart a view of religion – and of the relationship between religion and politics – that is not compatible with pluralistic, liberal, open-minded societies. At the extreme end of the spectrum are terrorists, but the worldview goes deeper and wider than it is comfortable for us to admit. So, by and large, we don't admit it.

This has two effects. First, those who hold extreme views believe that we are weak, and that gives them strength. Second, those Muslims – and the good news is that there are many – who know the problem exists, and want to do something about it, lose heart.

Throughout the Middle East and beyond, a struggle is playing out. On one side, there are Islamists and their exclusivist and reactionary worldview. They comprise a significant minority, loud and well organized. On the other side are the modern minded, those who hated the old oppression by corrupt dictators and despise the new oppression by religious fanatics. They are potentially the majority; unfortunately, they are badly organized.
In other words, Islam evil! Sharia!! Aiieee-eeeeee!!!

John Steinbeck, 1958: "Now for many years we have suckled on fear and fear alone, and there is no good product of fear. Its children are cruelty and deceit and suspicion germinating in our darkness."

ags: ,

Saturday, June 01, 2013

Being an ex-head of government is profitable

Profil reports today that Alfred Gusenbauer, Social Democratic Chancellor of Austria 2007-8, is under investigation by Austrian federal officials for possibly passing secret parliamentary files to the dictatorial government of Kazakhstan. It's not clear from the report how serious it might be for Gusenbauer.

But I was struck by the information in the report that the Kazakh regime of Nursultan Nazarbayev has several former heads of government working for it as paid consultants, including Britain's Tony Blair, Gusenbauer, Poland's Alexander Kwaśniewski, Italy's Romano Prodi, and Germany's Gerhard Schröder. (Ulla Kramar-Schmid and Michael Nikbakhsh, Causa Aliyev: Alfred Gusenbauer unter Spionageverdacht 01.06.2013)

They write, "Es gilt als offenes Geheimnis, dass Nasarbajew seine Triple-A-Konsulenten jährlich mit siebenstelligen Beträgen entschädigt, wobei Tony Blair mit kolportierten neun Millionen Euro Jahresverdienst ganz oben steht." ("It is taken as an open secret that Nazarbayev compensates his Triple-A consultants with seven-figure amounts, whereby Tony Blair with a supposed nine million euro annual service stays at the very top.") That would be about $12 million at current exchange rates.

That's staggering. They add, "Was man dafür leisten muss?" ("What must they do for that?") A very good question.

Tags: , ,

Tuesday, December 04, 2012

Tony Blair annoys me even more than Bernard-Henri Lévy

Listening to Tony Blair about anything is kind of like watching FOX News to get informed about current events, or consulting Mitt and Ann Romney on how to show the common touch.

But here is Lord Blair, holding forth about Britain and the European Union, The UK should Shape the Future of Europe, not Withdraw from it 12/04/2012 (speech of 11/28/2012). We should remember he that the main thing the pro-Europe Tony Blair did for the EU during his long stint as Prime Minister was to divide its members in a major way by acting as "Bush's poodle" on the Iraq War, joining the conservative governments of Spain and Portugal to be Europe's leading cheerleaders for the invasion to get the non-existent "weapons of mass destruction."

A devout devotee of the neoliberal gospel, Lord Blair illustrates that really bad ideas can and sometimes do spread across the Atlantic, in this case the "Grand Bargain":

So the flagship policy of Europe is listing dangerously. As I have said before, to save it, I believe, requires a kind of 'Grand Bargain' approach rather than incremental steps, in which Germany agrees, effectively, to some form of mutualisation of debt; the debtor countries carry out profound structural reform; and the ECB stands fully behind the bargain. There are some signs this may happen. But even if it does, Europe will suffer for some time to come. ...

So the real issue for us should be: what type of EU? And here there is no doubt that Europe needs fundamental, far reaching reform. Many of those reforms are precisely what the UK has been arguing for, like reform of the social model. It should be pointed out that these reforms are partially being made. Spain's labour costs have declined substantially since the crisis began. Italy has grasped crucially important reforms in areas like pensions. Greece has cut spending by a bigger amount proportionally than any country in Europe since the War.
Like the American version of the much-discussed Grand Bargain to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, this one is aimed at impoverishing the people of countries like Greece, Italy, Ireland, Spain and Portugal for the benefit of (primarily) Germany. This is what "profound structural reform" actually means.

Like the tax side of the American "Grand Bargain" scheme, the revenue side of Lord Blair's is pretty weak. I assume that what he means by "some form of mutualisation of debt" means that the eurzone has to recognize that Greece is never going to be able to pay back the debt load they current have and still have any kind of half-decent economy, so Germany is going to have to eat a bunch of losses. But that's going to happen anyway. His endorsement of Germany Chancellor Angela "Frau Fritz" Merkel's brutal austerity demands is the only real substance to that suggestion.

Lord Blair can earn healthy speaking fees at One Percenter gatherings with blather like the following: "Changes to the labour market, pensions, welfare and the way the State operates are necessary in all Western countries for reasons of demography, technology and external competition. The European social model has to change radically for Europe to prosper." All of which means weaken unions, cut wages, increase unemployment, remove worker protections, cut government services, and let Grandma eat catfood.

Lord Blair realizes that Britain outside the EU is likely to suffer a relative loss in power. But he really offers nothing in terms of the kinds of changes, like creating a full political, budget and transfer union, that would be necessary for a truly vital, well-functioning EU. Britain's foreign policy subservience to the US, of which Blair was fully supportive as Prime Minister, prevents it from being a true EU partner. The US has a foreign policy of global dominance or global hegemony, and part of what flows from that is preventing the rise of a "peer competitor" to the US, which the EU at least once had the potential to be. As long as Britain is nothing but a servant of the US in foreign policy, if a sometimes annoying one, they will continually push to keep the EU a weaker union, one that can't deal with the kind of problems the currency union is now facing.

The Labour Party that Tony Blair headed is officially Britain's social-democratic party. Blair's One Percenter outlook as the former Labour Prime Minister and party head illustrates some of the severe problems its much smaller sister party in Greece, PASOK, is currently having. Already badly battered in the last national election, PASOK now is polling down around the five percent level. John Psaropoulos describes in Socialist Schism Could Weaken Government The New Athenian 12/04/2012 how PASOK is steadily shrinking even before any new elections:

Pasok suffered the loss of six MPs on November 7, who were expelled for voting against a package of painful austerity measures amounting to 13.5bn euros. One more departed later. It is now down to 25 MPs from 33 after the June election. ...

The socialists' fortunes have gone from bad to worse since they ceded power to a technocrat interim prime minister last November. In back-to-back elections last May and June they took 13 percent and 12 percent of the popular vote, respectively, in a steep tumble from 44 percent in 2009.
The European social democrats have proved themselves very ill-prepared to take political advantage of the political conditions of a depression. Even in France, where François Hollande's Socialist government took power campaigning against austerity and demanding to renegotiate Frau Fritz' fiscal suicide pact, then promptly once in office proposed a nasty austerity budget and approved the fiscal suicide pact with any attempt to renegotiate it.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Sunday, November 18, 2007

The latest chapter of "How pathetic is Tony Blair"?


Tony Blair (with his Commander-in-Chief): A man with bad judgment on Iraq, or totally irresponsible?

The Times of London (a Murdoch property) reports on what Tony Blair says about the Iraq War in a new BBC documentary, Tony Blair: ‘I wanted war – it was the right thing to do’ by Philip Webster 11/17/07:

Tony Blair has admitted for the first time that he ignored the pleas of his aides and ministers to deter President Bush from waging war on Iraq because he believed that America was doing the right thing. And he has acknowledged that he turned down a last-ditch offer from Mr Bush to pull Britain out of the conflict. ...

In frank remarks in a BBC documentary, Mr Blair confirmed openly the belief of many of his closest supporters that he never used his position as America’s strongest ally to try to force Mr Bush down the diplomatic rather than the military route.

It was never a "bargaining chip" for him and he was never looking for a way out, he told David Aaronovitch, of The Times, in interviews for The Blair Years. "It was what I believed in, and I still do believe it," he said.
Oddly, the quotation in the article title does not appear in the text of the online version.

I think if I were a British voter, this would tick me off worse than anything else in the article:

The programme also reveals that just before the key Commons vote on war Mr Bush telephoned Mr Blair and offered him a way out. Mr Blair explained why he had declined the offer: "He was always very cognisant of the difficulty I had. He was determined we should not end up with the regime change being in Britain and he was saying to me, 'Look I understand this is very difficult and America can do this militarily on its own and if you want to stick out of it, stick out of it', and I was equally emphatic we should not do that."
That's amazing in more ways than one. First, Blair was reassured by his Commander-in-Chief Bush that Britain's help wasn't needed. At least according to Blair; it does sound odd considering the US position was that any one Bush ordered to participate in the "coalition" was expected to do so. But it could have been a ploy to set up an excuse to cut British oil companies out of the expected postwar bonanza. Which may materialize someday, if we ever get to a "postwar" period.

Secondly, it's stunning that Blair is claiming he was told that Bush didn't expect him to do this, and that "America can do this militarily on its own". And yet Blair insisted on sending British troops to fight in that war, to kill and die in a conflict where Commander-in-Chief Bush said Britain's help was not militarily necessary. Opting out would have saved British lives and avoided the additional enmity toward Britain in the Muslim world they incurred by tagging along with the Americans. It also would have enhanced Blair's image in the European Union, allowing him to show that he was sticking with his European partners on this issues that was not essential to British security.

It's always tempting to assume that when a national and/or world leader makes an historic decision like this, there's some elaborate political or economic or strategic reason for it. It's easy to forget that even exceptionally talented leaders sometimes just do stupid things. (See Citibank and Merrill Lynch on the subprime mortgage fiasco, to name only the two largest companies whose CEO's have so far resigned over the mess.)

Maybe Tony Blair was just a fool about the Iraq War. At the very minimum, he seemed to be so dogmatically attached to what has been the general British policy since the Suez Crisis of 1956 of not getting caught on the other side of the US on a major diplomatic issue, that he saw nothing else he could do.

This also gives us another piece of evidence relevant to the timeline on the war decision suggested by the Downing Street Memo and other material, suggesting that Bush and Blair had decided on war in the first half of 2002 (though it could have been earlier). Nothing in the Times article directly confirms that timeline. But if Blair was so committed to the war and supporting Cheney and Bush that he would even turn down an excellent opportunity to keep Britain out of the direct combat, it certainly lends credence to the notion of any early decision for war.

Tags: , ,

Sunday, June 24, 2007

Robert Fisk on the idea of Tony Blair as special envoy for the Middle East

British journalist Robert Fisk gives his caustic view of President Bush's suggestion that outgoing British premier Tony Blair be appointed the Quartet envoy to work on an Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement: How can Blair possibly be given this job? Independent 06/23/07. Fisk consistently refers to Blair sarcastically as "Lord Blair of Kut al-Amara", referring to a city in eastern Iraq where British forces were defeated and 10,000 British soldiers compelled to surrender to the Ottoman army during the First World War. Blair hasn't actually been knighted yet, though it's customary for former prime ministers to receive knighthood soon after they leave office, so he probably will be knighted in the near future.

I suppose that astonishment is not the word for it. Stupefaction comes to mind. I simply could not believe my ears in Beirut when a phone call told me that Lord Blair of Kut al-Amara was going to create "Palestine". I checked the date - no, it was not 1 April - but I remain overwhelmed that this vain, deceitful man, this proven liar, a trumped-up lawyer who has the blood of thousands of Arab men, women and children on his hands is really contemplating being "our" Middle East envoy.

Can this really be true? I had always assumed that Balfour, Sykes and Picot were the epitome of Middle Eastern hubris. But Blair? That this ex-prime minister, this man who took his country into the sands of Iraq, should actually believe that he has a role in the region - he whose own preposterous envoy, Lord Levy, made so many secret trips there to absolutely no avail - is now going to sully his hands (and, I fear, our lives) in the world's last colonial war is simply overwhelming.
By "the world's last colonial war", Fisk means the Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank and the conflict over them now entering its fifth decade.

The Independent also has an article on three Catholics on Blair's Downing Street staff who left their posts because of their religious objections to the Iraq War: PM's Iraq war 'helped drive Catholics out of Downing Street' by Andrew Grice and Andy McSmith 06/23/07.

Tags: ,

Thursday, May 17, 2007

Various comments on the rolling disaster called the Cheney-Bush foreign policy

It's really phenomenal to think about how Cheney and Bush took the enormous sympathy for the United States all over the world after the 9/11 attack- though notably cooler in Latin America than in the rest of the world - and turned it into widespread hostility.

Relations between Russia and the West, both the US and the EU, are going into the tank. Look! Over there! John Edwards is getting a new haircut! So we can hardly expect our "press corps" to pay excessive attention to trivia like all the progress made in Western relations with Russis since the end of the Cold War being wiped out. How boring for the priests and ministers of High Broderism. Much more pleasant to worry about whethre Barack Obama is sufficiently or excessively black.

Still, the real world moves on, even when David Broder fails to notice it:

Merkel vor schwierigem EU-Russland-Gipfel dpa/Yahoo! Nachrichten 17.05.2007

Hoffen auf das Wunder an der Wolga von Matthias Schepp Spiegel Online 17.05.07

Partnerschaft von Russland und EU wichtig AFP/Yahoo! Nachrichten 17.05.2007

Transatlantische Wirtschaftspartnerschaft Der Stnndard 30.04.07

Polen betont Krise mit Russland AFP/Yahoo! Nachrichten 17.05.2007

Tensions high, expectations low for Russia-EU talks by Louis Charbonneau Reuters/Washington Post 05/16/07.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel is trying to position Germany as the new leading intermediary between the US and Europe: Staunen - dreimal Spiegel Online 01.05.07 von Gabor Steingart. I'm guessing that the German government is really hoping to position itself to work with a more sensible US government beginning in January 2009. Because after all that's happened, it's difficult to believe that Merkel's Grand Coalition government can seriously imagine that "cooperation" means anything to the Cheney-Bush administration other than Dear Leader Bush gives the orders, the "allied" government does what it's total. In any case, obeying orders from the Cheney-Bush government involves a lot of problems: Germany rethinks its Afghan presence by Mariah Blake Christian Science Monitor 03/22/07.

The pathetic Tony Blair apparently intends to leave office in full snivel mode, reaffirming once again his subservience to the Cheney-Bush regime: Blair y Bush reafirman la alianza entre Londres y Washington El País 17.05.2007.

Surely it hasn't escaped the notice of the Merkel government that part of the deal between Blair and Dear Leader Bush was that Blair would support Cheney's war of aggression against Iraq, then Cheney and Bush would push hard for an Israeli-Palestinian settlement. Blair followed orders, and Bush spit in his face on his side of the deal. And we see the results anew just this week: Israel bombardea objetivos de Hamás en Gaza en represalia por los últimos ataques de milicianos palestinos El País 17.05.2007; Kämpfe im Gazastreifen eskalieren Frankfurter Rundschau 17.05.07..

And how is that glorious war of liberation in Iraq going? According to the British Chatham House research institute, the place is on the verge of collapse: Irak vor dem Kollaps Süddeutsche Zeitung 17.05.07; 'Collapse and Fragmentation' for Iraq Spiegel International 17.05.07.

Blair tied himself and his country to Bush's Iraq War, apparently because British leaders decided after the Suez crisis back during the Eisenhower administration that they would not allow themselves to be on a different side than the United States in any major foreign policy issue again and Blair was committed to carrying on that tradition, even to the point of leading one of the most cynical foreign policy moves in the long history of British diplomatic cynicism. But cynicism wasn't enough to conquer Iraq.

Cheney, Bush: Ya'll are doin' a heckuva job!

Tags: , ,

Sunday, February 01, 2004

Dog Bites Poodle? Will Tony Blair Become a Scapegoat for Bush and Rummy? (2)

Blair deserves better from his partners in Washington. No foreign leader has been such an important ally to Bush. And the two were unlikely allies. Blair must be reflecting that it might have been better to emphasize the unlikely part more. Blair had been close to Bill Clinton. And his support was critical during the Kosovo War - not least because Blair made a very persuasive, idealistic case that the American public found appealing. Blair seems to have had a vision of expanding international law and practice to combat human rights abuses.

And he was a critical ally to a shell-shocked Bush in the days following the 9/11 attacks. As Ivo Daalder and James Lindsay describe it in America Unbound: The Bush Revolution in Foreign Policy (2003):

Blair's five-page memo, which he had sent Bush a day after the attacks, outlined his ideas for undertaking a campaign against terrorism. The prime minister argued that it would be critical to shape world opinion by publicly presenting any evidence linking bin Laden to the attcks. He proposed demanding that the Taliban hand over bin Laden and al Qaeda's leaders, shut down training camps, and allow international monitors to enter Afghanistan or face the consequences. If the Taliban resisted, the Northern Alliance would have to be a crucial part of any military campaign, and Pakistan's support would be necessary. Iran was also crucial, given its long border with and involvement in Afghanistan. It would thus be important for Washington to improve relations with Tehran. Britain, finally, would offer whatever was needed in the way of military support for operations in Afghanistan. Blair's ideas - and his steadfast support for the United States - proved useful and heartening as Bush considered how to respond to the attacks.
None of this excuses Blair for going to war in Iraq based on false claims. It was just as wrong for him as it was for Bush, even though it was primarily Bush's and Rummy's war. But he deserves better from Bush than being kicked in the teeth. It's another example of the incredible arrogance with which Bush and his team treat even the best of their foreign allies and genuine friends and admirers of America.

Tags: ,

Thursday, October 16, 2003

The poodle turns?

Tony Blair's critics in Britain and other EU countries have referred to him as "America's poodle" because of his down-the-line support for Bush's Iraq War. Blair may have expected to continue to maintain the British role as a bridge between the US and the European Union that he played effectively during the Clinton Administration.

But he apparently didn't realize how strong an anti-Europe inclination the new Republican Administration had. Now he has badly damaged his standing at home and even more badly damaged his reputation in Europe by his Iraq policy. I've wondered how the Bush team would react if somehow Blair found himself siding with his European partners against the Bush Administration on an important issue.

This report from the London Financial Times indicates that we may soon see. It says that Blair is leaning toward support a European Defense Force independent of NATO, which doesn't make his Republican friends in Washington happy.

The US has received mixed signals from London despite assurances from UK diplomats that Britain would seek to scupper such moves [toward an independent EU force].

Donald Rumsfeld, the US defence secretary, raised the issue in a meeting with Britain's Geoff Hoon at the informal gathering of Nato defence ministers last week in Colorado. Condoleezza Rice, White House national security adviser, has telephoned Sir Nigel Scheinwald, Mr Blair's chief foreign policy aide, to express her concern.

"There is no sense of crisis between London and Washington over this," said a senior Bush administration official. "But there is a sense of real confusion and real concern. For the US, the issue of Nato's primacy in Europe is of real importance to us. We have made that clear."

US officials last week expressed consternation to several European allies that the Franco- German proposal for a separate EU military command and planning structure came in April, months after the signing of the "Berlin Plus" agreement requiring the EU to work within Nato.
After all Blair has done for Bush on the Iraq War, you might think that Bush officials would be more cautious about publicly calling him to heel this way as though he were, well, their poodle.

Tags: ,

Friday, September 19, 2003

Tony Blair's Star Sinks Again

More trouble for Tony Blair, this time a surprising Labour defeat in a special election (they call them by-elections in Britain) in what was thought to be a safe Labour district. A candidate from Britain's third party, the Liberal Democrats, which opposed the Iraq War, won the seat.

A Reuters analysis explains:

On the face of it, a marginal reduction in Blair's huge 165-seat parliamentary majority looks inconsequential.

But timing is all. The political damage to Blair will be heavy at a time when opinion polls show most Britons no longer trust him and his annual Labour Party conference looms, with activists angry about a war they opposed.
Foreign policy is never the only issue in these things. But it played a significant role in this one.

I do feel sorry for Blair, up to a point. I had seen him as a very sympathetic figure, up until he backed the Iraq War and agreed to participate in the invasion without UN approval. And he's paid a heavy price for what he apparently saw - with more faith than judgment - as a moral imperative. His credibility is wrecked. He's lost one of his most key long-time advisers, Alistair Campbell. He runs a real risk of being outsted as Prime Minister by his own Labour Party.

It seems to me that Blair tried to play Britain's traditional role of being a bridge between the US and the other countries of Europe. The problem in this case is that he failed to understand just how drastic Bush and Rummy's foreign policy was breaking from previous Administrations. The European democracies expected to be America's allies. Bush and Rummy expected them to be something more like vassal states. In the end, Blair wound up being derided by critics at home as "America's poodle" and blowing his credibility with Europe, as well.

Blair is joining German Chancellor Schroeder and French President Chirac for a three-way summit this weekend. We'll see if they come up with any meaningful progress on the Iraq mess. With expectations low, they have a good chance of surprising everyone if they accomplish anything at all.

Tags: ,

Sunday, September 07, 2003

More Pre-Iraq War Speech Thoughts

The official spin from the White House, abetted as usual by the compliant press, is that Sunday's Presidential address represents a significant mid-course correction on Iraq. So far, the translation of that into normal English seems to be: We know people are upset about the way things are going and we want to put a better public-relations face on it.

Ivo Daalder of the Brookings Institution, reports the Washington Post, "sees no indication that Bush plans to redress the concerns that have made foreign governments reluctant to contribute money or troops to the occupation."

"This is typical Bush: 'I know what's right; here is what's right; you have to do what I tell you to do,' " Daalder said. "They think they can fix this with a speech instead of doing the hard work of traveling to these countries and convincing them that we're willing to listen to their point of view and figure out what they need for us to do in order for us to do this together."
The American press is also doing a pretty pitiful job of reporting the trouble in which Tony Blair finds himself. Derided by his critics, many of them in his own Labour Party, as "America's poodle" (or "Bush's poodle"), Blair has put his entire political career on the line to support Bush and Rummy's adventure in Iraq.

And as a result, he'll be lucky to survive the year as Prime Minister. The immediate cause of his troubles is an investigation into the suicide of a British weapons expert who was the source of a BBC report on the British government's prewar claims on "weapons of mass destruction." But, any way you cut it, it was Blair's support of the Iraq War that put him into this jam.

Elected leaders in Germany, France and other democracies will have Blair's fate very much in mind as they consider whether they, too, want to stake their careers - and the lives of their soldiers - on supporting Bush and Rummy's Iraq policies.

- Bruce Miller

Hearing: Nanci Griffith, "One Blade Shy of a Sharp Edge"

Tags: , ,