Showing posts with label joe biden. Show all posts
Showing posts with label joe biden. Show all posts

Monday, January 22, 2018

Joe Biden is charming but positions himself in an odd way

This video excerpt of Joe Biden provides a good example of how the Democrats too often come off as smug and dismissive of their own base, To millennials who think they have it tough: ‘Give me a break,’ Biden says Los Angeles Times (n/d; video of a 01/10/2018).

The headline is misleading, but that's part of the problem. Biden makes himself too easy to quote out of context. That said, it's not entirely misleading.

The point he's actually making (I think!) is to use the examples of the antiwar, civil rights and women's movements of the Sixties to encourage young people to get engaged with politics and public service and not fall into cynicism, apathy and passive conservatism.

But, gosh, he manages to garble the message:
And we were told drop out, go out to Haight-Ashbury [pronouncing it "Azbury"], get engaged. Y'know, shortly after I graduated '68, Kent State, 17 kids shot dead. And so, the younger generation now tells me how tough things are. Give me a break! No, no, I have no empathy for it. Give me a break!

Because here's the deal, guys, we decided we were gonna change the world. And we did. We did. We finished the civil rights movement to the first stage. The women's movement came into being. So my message is, get involved, there's no place to hide. You can go out and you can make all the money in the world. But you can't build a wall high enough to keep the pollution out. You can't live where your - you can't not be diminished when your sister can't marry the man or woman, or the woman, she loves. You can't, when you have a good friend being profiled, you can't escape this stuff.
Still, even for those of us who find Biden's ditsy-uncle moments kind of lovable, it's still kind of jarring to hear him say, "the younger generation now tells me how tough things are. Give me a break! No, no, I have no empathy for it. Give me a break!"

It sounds pretty seriously out of touch. People who were 21 in 1968 were living in a world where there were still many unionized workers without college degrees who had relatively secure jobs with health insurance and a pension plan that paid enough for a single earner to be able to afford a house and at least one car for a family and send their kids to a good state university.

Today's 21-year-olds are facing an economy of McJobs in which most have no immediate shot at all to "make all the money in the world." The term "precariat" is a good one for those who must rely on precarious employment and multiple jobs and still won't be able to afford to buy a house in the foreseeable future. And pensions? Please.

The pressure is greater than ever to get a college education; neoliberal boosters say you're responsible for building your own personal "portfolio" of skills and experience. But for many, getting that education means taking on a serious load of student debt that will place limitations on their finances and their choices in life for years if not decades. And, thanks to legislation that Biden supported in the Senate, they can't even get it reduced if they go into bankruptcy (David Sirota and Matthew Cunningham, Joe Biden Backed Bills To Make It Harder For Americans To Reduce Their Student Debt IBT 09/15/2015):
As a senator from Delaware -- a corporate tax haven where the financial industry is one of the state’s largest employers -- Biden was one of the key proponents of the 2005 legislation that is now bearing down on students like Ryan. That bill effectively prevents the $150 billion worth of private student debt from being discharged, rescheduled or renegotiated as other debt can be in bankruptcy court.
As a friend of mine noted about this Biden segment, there's nothing there to appeal to people in non-urban areas. And the way he frames this, he is addressing an audience of affluent ("make all the money in the world") and white Anglo (your friend is being profiled, not you) listeners.

To be fair, it was a presentation on his book tour that gives him a chance to promote himself as a Presidential candidate, not a political rally. Book interviews tend to attract a more educated crowd. Also, politicians as experienced as Biden also make judgments about how to present things based on their read of the audience in front of them.

Even allowing for that, he still comes across as saying that us retirement-age baby-boomers have already done all the real work needed in political and social reform, and you young'uns should shut up with your whining.

This also makes me worry that more than the already-chronic complacency may be taking new hold on establishment Democratic leaders. I'm concerned about the 2006 model, in which the Democrats had a striking success in the midterms and then went on to elect Barack Obama as President in 2008, relying on a movement-style mobilization, along with substantial majorities in the Senate and House. And then Obama took office and started talking up bipartisan compromise and worrying about the budget deficit. Obamacare squeaked through, there was significant economic stimulus, and some important consumer protections got enacted. But the Democrats' insistence on framing even their successful policies in Republican terms squandered a major chance to change the political paradigm.

And don't even get me started on Obama's Grand Bargain to cut Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid ...

Sunday, August 27, 2017

Biden on the President and the Radical Right

Joe Biden's essay on opposing the far right is a good one ('We Are Living Through a Battle for the Soul of This Nation' The Atlantic 08/27/2017):

Did we think the charlatans and the con-men and the false prophets who have long dotted our history wouldn’t revisit us, once again prop up the immigrant as the source of all our troubles, and look to prey on the hopelessness and despair that has grown up in the hollowed-out cities and towns of Ohio and Michigan and Pennsylvania and the long-forgotten rural stretches of West Virginia and Kentucky?

We have fought this battle before—but today we have a special challenge.

Today we have an American president who has publicly proclaimed a moral equivalency between neo-Nazis and Klansmen and those who would oppose their venom and hate.

Thursday, July 17, 2014

Biden @ Netroots Nation #NN14

Joe Biden on Thursday became the first sitting Vice President to address a Netroots Nation convention. Dick Cheney never showed up.

Given Biden's current position as a part of the Obama Administration and as a potential 2016 Presidential candidate, it's hard to judge the content of one of his speeches without referring to those two roles.

His speech Thursday was not one to say, Obama's program is great, so get out there and help the Party in the midterm elections ! This was a speech to say: If you want somebody to fight for progressive values, I'm your guy!

In fact, some of the Democratic candidates in Michigan will probably be dismayed that he didn't have more to say about the 2014 elections.

But Biden can give a real Democratic campaign speech when he puts his mind to it.

And he didn't promise Bipartisanship or talk about how important it is to "reach across the aisle".

Tags: ,

Tuesday, October 16, 2012

David Bromwich on Obama's speaking style

David Bromwich is a close observer of Obama's words and how they connect with his policies. Also he sometimes dabbles in pop psychology while doing it, I've found his analyses of Obama particularly insightful.

A couple of years ago in The Fastidious President (London Review of Books 32/22 11/18/2012), Bromwich talked about Obama's two basic speaking styles with particular reference to press conferences:

I recently listened to some of John Kennedy’s press conferences, and was struck, not by his charm and easy control of the press, the usual traits that people bring up, but rather by his quickness and conversational rhythm. Kennedy’s answers are detailed and matter of fact, and though he occasionally speaks of his own views, he treats Congress as an equal partner. He sometimes shows irritation and is none the less cogent for that. He can speak a whole paragraph when a thought comes all at once without a pause. Any observer of Obama realises that, by contrast, he is always slow, always circumspect, and he has two distinct registers of diction: one for talking to very clever but abstracted people, the other for talking to well-meaning people who are very young or very old and certainly need remedial help. In the higher idiom he talks of a ‘critique’ of policy and ‘trend lines’ and the ways to ‘incentivise’ better care and ‘prioritise’ the next steps of government assistance to show that we are ‘doing everything we can to accelerate job creation’. It is the language of a technocrat, the man at the head of the conference table. In the lower idiom, there are lots of ‘folks’, ‘folks who oppose me’, ‘a whole bunch of folks’, interspersed with vaguely regional comfort words like ‘oftentimes’. [my emphasis]
That second kind of diction was very much on display in the first debate with Mitt Romney. The next day, Obama was able to use a speech to ridicule some of Romney's position in a way that he was completely unable to do the evening before.

The second debate is set up in town-hall format, so we can expect Obama to be more in that second, "remedial help" mode there. Not that it's bad. After all, the man won the Presidency in 2008 as the first African-American elected to that office. He was obviously doing something right.

Although it's not entirely clear if Bromwich was including traditional campaign speeches in that two-dictions part, the one-way type speech when Obama addresses a crowd gives him a chance to use soaring but vague rhetoric, e.g., "the fierce urgency of now." Or, "This is our time, America!"

Bromwich has a recent piece in which he observes that Obama is comfortable with those types of speeches, how they are compatible with his seemingly compulsive centrist/postpartisan aspirations, and what it was about Biden's debate performance last week that was particularly effective: Saying It Straight in October Huffington Post 10/13/2012.

What Biden did that Obama failed to do in the first debate was to give people arguments against the Romney-Ryan positions and in favor of the Administration's. Jennifer Granholm on Current TV commented that Biden gave a lot more detail. But my impression watching the debate was Ryan seemed to be rattling of a lot of figures (of dubious reliability), the kind of talk that made him look like the punditocracy's dream of a Serious Conservative Policy Wonk. Biden shot that down by talking about specific policies but doing so with in a conceptual framework that let people view Obama's policies favorably and Romney-Ryan's unfavorably. It wasn't so much the detail as the relevance.

As Bromwich puts it:

By nature and disposition, Barack Obama is a man who blends and consolidates. The plaintive undertone that you hear sometimes, under his heartiest shout, really says to his listeners "How can anyone reject what I'm saying? This is so reasonable. And we know it already -- it's enough to remember what we know. Now, come along with me and agree that this is what we've always stood for."

But not everyone knows, not everyone agrees, not everyone will call it reasonable unless the arguments and history are laid out in a connected order. In last night's debate, Joe Biden brought a reminder of what it sounds like when a politician offers reasons. He did not vaguely concede and back away as Obama did a few nights earlier when he said he probably agreed with his opponent about Social Security. Biden recalled that Republicans want to privatize Social Security and that, as recently as 2005, they were for entrusting personal holdings to the stock market. How well would that have worked? Beyond the minutiae of Medicare and vouchers, Biden remembered that the Republican Party was unfriendly to Medicare from the start.
And he argues this was effective because, "These weren't extended reasons, and they didn't develop as full arguments, but they were reasons and arguments: the part of persuasion that Obama has always dismissed too lightly."

He uses as an example Obama's referring to "the mess we're in" being the result of previous policies. But Obama doesn't then give a sketch of what those policies were and how they harmed the country. Bromwich recommends that for the second debate and the rest of the campaign generally that Obama should "think twice about calling a time of widespread suffering 'the mess we're in.' It isn't something that someone spilled in the kitchen. The reality has a history, and there are names that can be named."

Tags: , , ,

Friday, October 12, 2012

Biden-Ryan debate: Iran and the Grand Bargain to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid

Joe Biden's performance in Thursday evening's debate against Paul Ryan reminded me of Abe Lincoln's famous comment about General Grant: "He fights."

Bill Press picks up on that aspect of the debate in Bill says Vice President Biden saved the day 10/12/2012:



Since I can't offer a better analysis of what went right for Biden than Charlie Pierce, I'll refer you to his post from the early AM, VP Debate 2012: The Real Paul Ryan Is Bad for America 10/12/2012.

You know what's the difference between Sarah Palin and Paul Ryan?

Lipstick.
There were some substantive problems with what Biden had to say, much as I enjoyed his clobbering the Ayn Rand fanboy. They were points on which the Romney-Ryan ticket is worse than the incumbent President's trajectory. But for those of us who don't look at national policy as purely a binary partisan matter, they're worrisome. (See the transcript for text.)

Biden used the Republicans' bluster against them on the subject of Iran. Biden said, "The last thing we need now is another war." And, "War should always be the absolute last resort." Peace is good politics. He also did a good job of debunking the scare talk about an Iranian nuclear weapon. I like that he said in this connection, "facts matter."

But he also said of the Iran sanctions, "These are the most crippling sanctions in the history of sanctions, period, period." That sounds an awful lot like being only one short step from war. The US policy toward nuclear nonproliferation is dangerously one-sided in the Middle East. Nuclear nonproliferation is extremely important. But it doesn't justify an unprovoked attack on Iran. "Aggressive war", aka, preventive war, is a threat to peace, international law and nuclear nonproliferation. The Obama Administration's Libya policy can also be faulted in that regard. Muammar Ghaddafi's regime had cooperated with the United States on nuclear nonproliferation and gave up their nuclear weapons program. Then the US sided military with rebels against that government.

The other big concern was Biden's weasily-worded comments on Social Security and Medicare. People following the grim negotiations on the "Grand Bargain" to cut benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, what Biden said wasn't entirely reassuring, though he drew sharp and necessary contrasts with Ryan. David Dayen looks at those moments in VP Debate: The Constrained Discussion on Social Insurance FDL News Desk 10/12/2012:

... the myth that Biden didn't confront sprung from the very premise of the question.

"Both Medicare and Social Security are going broke and taking a larger share of the budget in the process," said Martha Raddatz, marring an otherwise good moderating performance. Social Security has nothing to do with the federal budget. It has a dedicated funding stream from the payroll tax, and is fully funded for the next two decades, which is more than you can say about pretty much any other government program. A good portion of Medicare comes from its hospital insurance tax, another dedicated funding stream. That Medicare is taking a larger share of the federal budget is an artifact of higher health spending in the United States generally, and Medicare is the least important driver of that. In fact, the antidote for higher health spending is more Medicare, a single payer program that can bargain down these higher costs. ...

But he didn’t challenge this premise, this idea that these vital programs are “going broke,” and that the role of government is just to hang onto them rather than design them in a more adequate way to increase security for older Americans. We need a Social Security system that increases benefits to those who need it. We need a Medicare program that covers really everyone, but certainly more people, to increase its bargaining power. But Biden, inside the contours of the question, and determined to maintain the wiggle room the President clearly wants, could only say that he opposed a voucher system for Medicare and privatization for Social Security. I agree, but that’s not the only answer.
The Obama Administration created a (still relatively small) exception to the very useful argument that Social Security does not draw on the General Fund budget. He and Congress financed the temporary payroll tax reductions by having the General Fund reimburse the Social Security Trust Fund for the cost. This always bothered me from the standpoint of defending Social Security. If it's supposedly going broke, why would we cut the taxes that pay for it? Well, the answer is that the General Fund is reimbursing Social Security. But that opens the program up for the Republicans to call it a "welfare" program that draws down General Funds. The obvious alternative would have been to provide those subsidies in the form of refunds coming directly to payroll tax payers.

Here's what Biden said:

Look, I was there when we did that with Social Security, in 1983. I was one of eight people sitting in the room that included Tip O'Neill negotiating with President Reagan. We all got together, and everybody said, as long as everybody's in the deal, everybody's in the deal, and everybody is making some sacrifice, we can find a way. We made the system solvent to 2033.

We will not, though, be part of any voucher plan eliminating the voucher says, Mom, when you're when you're 65, go out there, shop for the best insurance you can get; you're out of Medicare. You can buy back in, if you want, with this voucher, which will not keep pace will not keep pace with health care costs, because if it did keep pace with health care costs, there would be no savings. That's why they go the voucher they we will be no part of a voucher program or the privatization of Social Security. ...

Quickly, the bottom line here is that all the studies show that if we went with Social Security proposal made by Mitt Romney, if you're 40 in your 40s now, you will pay $2,600 a year you get $2,600 a year less in Social Security. If you're in your 20s now, you get $4,700 a year less. The idea of changing and change being, in this case, to cut the benefits for people without taking other action you could do to make it work is absolutely the wrong way.

These look, these guys haven't been big on Medicare from the beginning. Their party's not been big on Medicare from the beginning. And they've always been about Social Security as little as you can do. Look, folks, use your common sense. Who do you trust on this? A man who introduced a bill that would raise it $6,400 a year, knowing it and passing it, and Romney saying he'd sign it? Or me and the president? [my emphasis]
This formulation clearly leaves the door open for cuts in benefits to Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid in a post-election Grand Bargain.

The politics on this is kind of twisted. Because the Republicans got away in the Congressional campaigns of 2010 with claiming that projected savings to Medicare that do not reduce benefits to recipients were actually cuts to Medicare, they've recycled it in 2012 with the "$716 billion" meme. Instead of attacking Obama on the cuts he actually proposed in the debt ceiling negotiations last year and clearly intends to propose again in the lame-duck session this year, the Reps are attacking him with a phony claim. Shameless prevaricators that they are, even they don't seem to have found a way to attack him on the Grand Bargain proposals o cuts benefits on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid because they are actually down with that program.

Biden repaired some of the damage Obama did to their campaign in the first debate when he said there were no real differences between him and Romney on Social Security. But there's still a Grand Bargain fight coming after the November election between supporters of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid on one side and Obama and the Republicans on the other.

Finally, Biden's answer on abortion was a strong variation on the standard Democratic politician's position - to say they're personally against it but support choice for women - and it very effectively made the point that the Democrats are pro-choice and the Republicans anti-choice. And that helps the Democrats.

But given the success of the fanatical anti-abortion movement in passing restrictions to access to abortion services, their newly visible front against contraception more generally, and their success in framing the issue to the point that violent and even murderous attacks against abortion clinics and providers aren't even called "terrorism" by politician or the government or the mainstream news media - the I'm-personally-against-it-but-support-a-woman's-right-to-choose really isn't good enough any more. Advocates of choice, including Democratic politicians, need to be making a case on the medical facts central to the Roe v. Wade decision: that a fetus cannot survive outside its mother womb until the third trimester and is therefore medically a part of the woman's body. The mushy, subjective dodge just doesn't work well enough any more. Law needs to be based on medical realities. Because "facts matter."

Tags: , , ,

Thursday, October 11, 2012

Biden-Ryan debate tonight

After last week's Obama-Romney debate, we all got to be theater critics for a few days. This week I've been seeing a lot of analysis and criticism of the theater criticism. This is how we news junkies entertain ourselves.

I'll give my own pre-theater criticism of tonight's debate and say that I would expect Joe Biden to come across better than Paul Ryan to most people, unless he has a stroke or something just beforehand and walks out on the stage buck nekkid and babbling incoherently. Biden's old-fashioned political glad-handing style is kind of enduring, though it does produce the occasional hyperbole that our star pundits gleefully treat as one of the "gaffes" they love to chatter about. But he also conveys a seriousness about public service and a sense that he actually enjoys the process of democratic politics.

Paul Ryan, on the other hand, is a pompous stiff. Charlie Pierce's epithet for him, "zombie-eyed granny-starver", catches his general style pretty well.

As I was writing this, I went to the Esquire Politics Blog to pick up the link to a clip of Ryan that Pierce recently used, and I see he already did the same pre-theater criticism I did in the above paragraphs in just the headline alone, The Zombie-Eyed Granny-Starver Takes on the One Man Who Relishes This Mess: Your 2012 VP Debate Preview 10/11/2012. But I'll go ahead and post mine anyway, though any thin claim to originality is clearly shot already. As Exhibit 1 from his post shows:

Joe Biden is not riven with self-doubt. Joe Biden is not exhausted by the hurly-burly of politics. Joe Biden is not burdened by the weight of events and laid low by the constant battle against know-nothing obstructionism. Joe Biden is not going to take the stage tonight and find himself wishing he were anywhere else. I mean, god be good to him, as my gran' used to say, but Joe Biden actually likes all these silly performance pieces in which we insist he be engaged in order to stay vice-president. He revels in them. He would do ten of them a day, if he could. When I consider Joe Biden, and I look at the enthusiasm with which he throws himself into the various cataracts and torrents of hogwash that constitute our politics these days, I find myself looking at him the way I look at people who sky-dive or drive in demolition derbies. I have no idea why they do what they do, and I have absolutely no intention of doing it myself, ever, but, goddamn, do those people look like they're having fun.
I'll go ahead and add to Pierce's observation that Ryan "is as ambitious as Satan," that Ryan is likely to look better to a lot of people after this because it will be the first major exposure a lot of people have to him. At least partisan Republicans are likely to be jazzed by his presentation. Shoot, partisan Republicans were jazzed by Sarah Palin's performance against Biden in 2008. Some audience segements are easy to please.

Here's the BuzzFeed video of Ryan being a prickly jerk, Paul Ryan Gets Testy And Ends Interview 10/08/2012:



Aside from his testiness, it also seems to me in that clip Ryan is struggling to string together several favorite conservative cliches into a coherent whole. He probably wished he hadn't said that not even Obama was proposing new gun laws, because his base believes that Obama is part of a massive UN conspiracy to take away everyone's guns so the federal gubment can force us all into homosexual marriages and unisex bathrooms. Or something like that.

And he also seemed to slip when he blurted out that the answer to crime was to create opportunity in the inner cities, which sounded in the context like he was suggesting that social conditions and economic situations might actually have some meaningful effect on causing crime! It was as if Ramsey Clark had taken over his mouth for a few seconds. But then he proceeded to the Christian-Right-ly Correct position that all those black people in the ghetto inner-city dwellers need to learn Discipline. Culture-of-poverty and all that, you know.

While I'm on the topic of debates, the discussion about whether debates matter in Presidential elections has taken on metaphysical overtones, or at least the after-work-drinks version of metaphysics at the local pub. Political scientists and sociologists and (gulp!) economists can come up with analyses and even models showing that debates have no effect on Presidential elections at all. Because their models need data that can be quantified and correlated, and it's hard if not impossible to isolate quantifiable measures that would isolate perceived debate performance to its effect on the final vote.

Of course the debates matter, because they are in this and the last several Presidential elections, major focuses of the Presidential campaign and voters ultimately make a choice based on a variety of factors. Voting matters, so turnout matters, so get-out-the-vote operations are important. TV is the single most important communication channel for the elections, so ads and ad buys matter.

And what candidates say matters. Even if we have to read their lips very carefully. William Saletan offered a good analysis of Willard Romney's weasel-words on abortion in Romney’s Abortion “Agenda” Slate 10/10/2012. It's worth paying attention to what major Presidential candidates say and how they say it.

Tags: , , ,

Friday, September 07, 2012

Obama and Biden in Charlotte

I thought President Obama made the best case he could for himself during his acceptance speech at the Democratic convention in Charlotte, given the largely self-imposed constraints he's placed on his own campaign: he's more focused on reducing the deficit than in directly creating jobs; he's fixated on bipartisan cooperation on domestic issues, no matter how many times the Republicans slap him down; and because he wants the flexibility to propose actual cuts in benefits for Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, he's not making defense of those programs nearly as prominent as it should be. That said, he got in some good verbal shots against Romney and Ryan last night.

I've only heard the last part of Vice President Joe Biden's speech so far. It was important for the Dems to recognize that there are wars going on and soldiers serving in them. And I normally find Biden's over-the-top rhetorical flourishes endearing.

But when he said that the only sacred duty of the national government was to train soldiers for war and then take care of them when they come home, I wondered if I had tuned in to some local cult of Ares. Then he followed it up by referring to soldiers killed as "fallen angels". Yikes! It's way easier to send "angels" to war than real live soldiers. And even Republicans would have added as sacred govt duties the need to protect "unborn babies" and the second half of the 2nd Amendment. I'm guessing Biden doesn't really think war and its consequences are the only "sacred" duty of democratic government. But that IS what he said.

Idolizing the military and glorifying war are not good things. Whether it's politically helpful or not.

It seems that Friday's jobs figures at least don't suck. There is a recovery under way, not as strong as it would be with major stimulus, but stabilizing the financial system and saving General Motors stopped the economic free-fall in 2009. The biggest drag on the economy right now is all the reductions in public employment by Republican governors - and that means basically teachers, cops and firefighters.

Tags: , ,

Monday, February 15, 2010

Biden vs. Cheney

Vice President Joe Biden was interviewed by David Gregory on Meet the Press Sunday: 'Meet the Press' transcript for February 14, 2010. While I think Biden probably has more consistent liberal instincts than Obama, I continue to be amazed at the way leading Democrats pass up obvious opportunities to shift the narrative frame against Republicans. Biden did make some good criticism of Dick Cheney. But he stepped on his own criticisms by trying to find nice things to say about him. Some examples:

Dick Cheney's a fine fellow.
[Again:] Dick Cheney's a fine fellow ...
No, he's not. He's confessed to being part of the decision-making process supporting torture. He's a war criminal and should be tried as such. No, he's not a "fine fellow" at all. And he's been publicly trashing the current administration's policies both himself and through his family surrogate, his daughter Liz Cheney, for the whole time Obama has been in office.

I, I, I'm not going to guess about his [Cheney's] motive.
Why not? The Republicans have not problem accused your President of the most malicious motives about everything.

And maybe he isn't--literally, I'm not being facetious, maybe he's not fully informed of what's going on. I mean, the progress we have made [in fighting terrorism].
Yes, Dick Cheney knows very well what's going on. And so do Obama and Biden. He's trying to create as much political pressure as possible against prosecuting the torture perpetrators - of which he's publicly admitted to being one - and against prosecuting the various other criminal activities of the Cheney-Bush administration from the Iraq War to military contracting to the outing of Valerie Plame as an undercover CIA officer to malicious and partisan Justice Department prosecutions. To name some of the better known ones.

The success rate [of this administration in fighting Al Qa'ida] exceeds anything that occurred in the last administration. And they did their best. I'm not, I'm not impugning their effort.
And why not? There's plenty to "impugn" about it. Why not take the chance to do it? Cheney is sure "impugning" your own administration's efforts.

Biden did repeat the point several times that Cheney is trying to rewrite history. And that's important. It's important that they fight back against Cheney's criticisms.

But the best way - the right way - to do that is to do a thorough investigation and appropriate prosecutions of the known crimes committed in the previous administration, starting with the torture program.

But since they won't do that, at least for now, we're stuck with hoping things like that we can get the administration to stop stepping on their own messaging against Cheney. It's worse than sad.

Tags: ,

Sunday, July 05, 2009

Biden talking carelessly on Israel and Iran?

Helena Cobban thinks so: Joe Biden's loose lips Just World News 07/05/09. She criticizes the Vice President for seeming to repeatedly declare his indifference to a military strike by Israel on Iran in a weekend interview with George Stephanopoulos. "Whether we agree or not," Biden said. They're entitled to do that. Any sovereign nation is entitled to do that..."

Helena spells out three problems with that idea:

  1. The hardware the IDF would use to strike Israel would certainly include US-supplied items, all of which are supplied on the basis of explicit agreements that they will be used only for defensive purposes.
  2. As Stephanopoulos was smart enough to point out, the US controls the air-space in Iraq, Saudi, Arabia, and other countries that Israel would need to overfly in any air-launched attack on Iraq.
  3. Finally-- and this for me is the clincher--It is US forces, not Israeli forces, that are "on the front-lines" against Iran. If Israel attacks Iran, the Iranian government can justifiably assume, based in part on points 1 and 2 above, that it did so with at least US collusion, if not active US partnership. On this basis Iran would be entitled to respond to any Israeli attack by counter-attacking against not only Israel but also the many, very vulnerable military assets that the US has very near Iran's borders and coastline-- whether in Iraq, in and around the Gulf, or in Afghanistan.
With our troops in Iraq, the United States is part of the neighborhood. And what happens there that affects our position in Iraq is very definitely an American concern.

Tags: , , ,

Sunday, October 05, 2008

SNL strikes again

One thing this Presidential campaign has done is to raise the profile of Saturday Night Live. And maybe it's just me. But I nearly got woozy from lack of oxygen laughing at points in this one. Their take on Joe Biden was at least as funny as Tina Fey's version of the White Princess.



Tags: ,

Friday, October 03, 2008

Biden-Palin debate

I just watched the Biden-Palin debate. I thought I would try to put down my initial reactions before I listened to or read any punditry on it.

I'm visiting in Austria, so I watched it on a Tivo-ed recording from the German channel ZDF which carried it with a simultaneous German translation.

This was the best performance by Joe Biden I recall seeing. He did the essential thing. I agree with Paul Krugman in thinking and hoping that if the Obama campaign can keep it clear that the Presidential race is between a Democrat and a Republican, the Dems are likely to win. And Biden did an excellent job of keeping that point always in focus.

For our Establishment media, of course, all this boring content stuff is strictly secondary. What matters to them are gaffes, zingers and that all-important body language. I didn't see any that appear of any consequence to me. Palin certainly appears to be an intellectual lightweight. And she has some beauty-pageant mannerisms like winking and tossing in perky-sounding phrases that I personally find annoying. Others no doubt find them enduring. And both politically and substantively they are of no consequence. Biden had a gracious manner, as he normally does, but he showed Palin the respect to go after her claims and positions aggressively.

The best part to me was that Biden made it very clear that he and Obama support a 16-month timeline for withdrawal of US troops from Iraq, while McCain and Palin have no plan that we know of other than continuing the Iraq War indefinitely and prattle about the magic of The Surge. In general, Biden clearly sounded more informed and more credible than Palin on foreign affairs. And he was diligent about not leeting Palin's happy-talk version of McCain's foreign policy positions stand unchallenged.

The scariest part by far was that Palin made it very clear that she supports the Cheney position on the Vice President's role as a special office between the Executive and the Legislative brances, a theory that Biden rightly labelled as a "bizarre notion". Palin's comments on this made it sound to me like she foresees an even larger role for the Vice President.

It certainly appears to me that Palin is an intellectual lightweight in terms of normal expectations about grappling with political ideas. But we shouldn't underestimate the influence she could have as Vice President or the damage she could do even in that office, let alone as President herself. The current administration provides the obvious examples. Bush was and is considered a man of limited intellectual curiousity or analytical ability, though there are some of his critics who doubt that view, the present writer not being one of them. Almost everyone regarded Cheney as a colorless fellow who was likely to play a limited role or would, if anything, be a moderating influence on Bush. Actually, he has been both an enormous influence in the administration and a force for rightwing radicalism. And sadly effective at both within the administration.

Palin could bring neocon and Christianist players into the Cheneyized Office of the Vice President and wind up wielding enormous influence. And between her moralistic, Manichean notions of good and evil in foreign policy and those winks which McCain probably finds charming, she could have a great deal of personal influence with the old guy.

In general, Palin's strategy was to try to blur the differences between McCain and Bush while presenting McCain as the Maverick who would oppose Wall Street greed and Big Oil. And to pass off standrad Republican positions like "drill, drill, drill" as some kind of thoughtful approach to energy and environmental issues. If Biden had been as passive and unassertive as Joe Lieberman was in that long-ago 2000 debate with Dick Cheney, some of those point might have gone down better. As it happened, Palin's use of timeworn Republican clichees over and over probably served to highlight her own continuity with the Cheney-Bush nightmare years.

Biden's strategy was basically the mirror image, to remind everyone that McCain=Bush. And he made the point directly, over and over, and did a good job of shooting down Palin's claims for McCain's and her own "mavrickicity". I thought it was expecially effective when he agreed with one policy of Palin's that arguably was "maverick", which was that she applied an excess-profits tax to oil company profits in Alaska in order to finance a tax rebate to the general public, the pointed out that McCain opposes any such policy.

Biden did a good job of reminding people that McCain has been a huge supporter of deregulation and that he and Obama favored specific measures to help debt-squeeyed homeowners keep their homes in the current crisis. He also made it very clear that Demcorats support a policy to provide health insurance to everyone and the Republicans don't.

And, Lord-a-mercy, Biden even used the phrase "free market" as an accusation against McCain! The time they are 'a changin', so it seems.

My biggest disappointment in the debate was that I didn't hear a single mention of the torture policy.

Biden was good up to a point on defending Constitutional rights and gays and lesbians. But both he and Palin oppose gay marriage. And the two of them, Gwen Ifill, and the live audience present go a good chuckle out the fact that they agree on that point. I found that moment to be an embarassment for all involved, though they obviously thought the notion of gay marriage was worth no more than a good chuckle.

A couple of points gave me raised-eyebrow moments. One was when Palin made it sound like she opposed Iran having even nuclear energy. Though the connection to the nuclear weapons program is major, the practical discussions for a solution to the Iranian nuclear issue all involve so far as I'm aware some way to provide for Iran to have nuclear power plants under adequate international controls, a right which they have under the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty.

Another was Biden's particular wording on Afghanistan. I'm opposed to escalation in Afghanistan, so maybe this was wishful hearing. But it seemed to me that while Biden used the Afghanistan-Pakistan situation to attack McCain's focus on the Iraq War, he was cautious about suggesting any major escalation there. I didn't catch any refernce to the need to escalate the military conflict there. Instead, he talked about providing non-military aid to Pakistan to counter the influence of violent Islamists. I'm hoping for that to be a new sign that a future Obama administration is already giving itself wiggle-room on the Afghanistan-Pakistan conflict.

I also found Biden's notion of a NATO no-fly zone for Darfur a discouraging note. The notion that involving ourselves in a civil war via NATO, airplanes and bombs will somehow be a clean way of intervening is a largely false and generally dangerous one.

And on that issue, Palin referred to Alaska's policy of disinvestment in the Sudan, seemingly agreeing with Biden on the Darfur issue. This was one example in this debate, as were her comments on Iran and Israel, that reminded me that the Republican Party is so thoroughly merged with Christianist factions that we almost need to have an expert in conservative American Protestant sociology to interpret what statements really mean. The Sudan has been an issue for Christitianists because it involves Muslims persecuting Christians. It's a legitimate concern in itself. But legitimate concerns can be instrumentalized for illegitimate purposes. What most viewers probably heard as a possibly moderate-liberal foreign policy position in Palin's statement on the Sudan, Christianists heard as a shout-out to rightwing Islamophobia.

One translating Palin's Christianist phraseology, I highly recommend Sarah Posner's FundamentaList columns of 09/24/08 and 10/01/08 at The American Prospect Online. Her 09/24/08 column touches on the particular cult-like definition of "tolerance" which the Christianists use expecially in relation to gay rights, a world which Palin used repeatedly in her anti-gay-marriage comments in the debate.

Tags: , , , , ,

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

Wednesday's Democratic speeches


Bill Clinton was good, as everyone should have expected. The best part of his speech to me was that he attacked the Republicans directly on the torture policy. As did John Kerry and Gen. Claudia Kennedy in her brief presentation after Kerry's speech. This is a critical issue. It's a major disgrace to the country that it has become a partisan issue. But it is. The Republican Party supports torture with virtual unanimity. The Democratic Party opposes it. We won't hear similar statements in opposition to torture at next week's Republican Party convention. It's a true national disgrace.

My favorite Clinton line was, "People the world over have always been more impressed by the power of our example than by the example of our power." That's heresy to war-loving Republicans. But it's the attitude that normal people who don't have seven houses generally take.

This was also great section of the Big Dog's presentation:

American families by the millions are struggling with soaring health care costs and declining coverage. I will never forget the parents of children with autism and other severe conditions who told me on the campaign trail that they couldn’t afford health care and couldn’t qualify their kids for Medicaid unless they quit work or got a divorce. Are these the family values the Republicans are so proud of? What about the military families pushed to the breaking point by unprecedented multiple deployments? What about the assault on science and the defense of torture? What about the war on unions and the unlimited favors for the well connected? What about Katrina and cronyism?

America can do better than that. And Barack Obama will. [my emphasis]
Kerry gave a conventional liberal Democratic speech. What he said was fine by me. But his criticisms of McCain's changing positions was undercut by his using the "for it before he was against it" line that the media and the Reps used against him in 2004. Kerry was wagging his finger at McCain for playing Karl Rove politics. But that's the wrong response. (More thoughts on that below.)

Still, Kerry had good things to say:

Never in modern history has an administration squandered American power so recklessly. Never has strategy been so replaced by ideology. Never has extremism so crowded out common sense and fundamental American values. Never has short-term partisan politics so depleted the strength of America’s bipartisan foreign policy.

George Bush, with John McCain at his side, promised to spread freedom but delivered the wrong war in the wrong place at the wrong time. They misread the threat and misled the country. Instead of freedom, it’s Hamas, Hezbollah, the Taliban and dictators everywhere that are on the march. North Korea has more bombs, and Iran is defiantly chasing one.

Our mission is to restore America’s influence and position in the world. We must use all the weapons in our arsenal, above all, our values. President Obama and Vice President Biden will shut down Guantanamo, respect the Constitution, and make clear once and for all, the United States of America does not torture, not now, not ever.

We must listen and lead by example because even a nation as powerful as the United States needs some friends in this world. We need a leader who understands all our security challenges, not just bombs and guns, but global warming, global terror and global AIDS. And Barack Obama understands there is no way for America to be secure until we create clean energy here at home, not with a little more oil in five, 10 or 20 years, but with an energy revolution starting right now. [my emphasis]
Tammy Duckworth made good points about the Iraq War, too:

In Barack Obama, our troops will have a commander-in-chief who has the judgment to use them wisely, sending them into harm’s way as a last resort, not a first resort; who listens to intelligence, doesn’t exaggerate it; who will bring our troops home from Iraq responsibly, not keep them there indefinitely; who knows that torture is not only morally repugnant, it’s militarily ineffective. It doesn’t work. It puts our troops at risk. It endangers our national security.

In Barack Obama, our military families will have a leader who will ease their burdens, ensure predictable deployments, offer more support to spouses back home and ensure military paychecks keep pace with the private sector. Our veterans will have a president who finally makes veterans’ benefits and health a priority, caring for their body, mind and spirit. [my emphasis]
It was good that they followed Clinton and Kerry up with the Iraq War video.

It's really good. It gives a straightforward account of the real-life situation in Iraq. It focuses on the experiences of US soldiers. And without beating anyone over the head with it, the film says the reality of the Iraq War is very different than the pretty lies McCain tells about it.

The most encouraging thing about Wednesday night's convention for me was that the Dems made an issue of the Cheney-Bush-McCain torture policy and made the Iraq War a central issue. Whatever the political effect, those are vital issues and they need to be addressed right.

Beau Biden's story about his father being sworn in for the Senate at his hospital bedside when he was severely hurt in the car accident that killed his mother and sister was incredibly moving.

He opened by defending the Constitution against Dark Lord Dick Cheney. His personal story was well delivered. The part about his mother sending him back outside to bloody the nose of the bullies was a welcome bit in the context of this Presidential election.

Biden opened his story about how Obama has an all-American personal story by observing, "John McCain doesn't seem to get it" when it comes to understanding the economic needs of ordinary working people.

I'm was getting concerned that I hadn't heard much at the convention so far going at McCain in a way that would jar his "maverick" image. Both Clintons did the ritual nod to McCain's brilliant service. But then he followed it up with vague invocations of how his policies are worse than Obama's. Biden did a version of it. But he followed it up with a long peroration on the theme of, "That's not change, that's more of the same." I thought his best hits on the following points:

John McCain is my friend. We’ve known each other for three decades. We’ve traveled the world together. It’s a friendship that goes beyond politics. And the personal courage and heroism John demonstrated still amaze me.

But I profoundly disagree with the direction that John wants to take the country. For example, John thinks that during the Bush years “we’ve made great progress economically.” I think it’s been abysmal.

And in the Senate, John sided with President Bush 95 percent of the time. Give me a break. When John McCain proposes $200 billion in new tax breaks for corporate America, $1 billion alone for just eight of the largest companies, but no relief for 100 million American families, that’s not change; that’s more of the same.

Even today, as oil companies post the biggest profits in history—a half trillion dollars in the last five years—he wants to give them another $4 billion in tax breaks. But he voted time and again against incentives for renewable energy: solar, wind, biofuels. That’s not change; that’s more of the same.

Millions of jobs have left our shores, yet John continues to support tax breaks for corporations that send them there. That’s not change; that’s more of the same.

He voted 19 times against raising the minimum wage. For people who are struggling just to get to the next day, that’s not change; that’s more of the same.

And when he says he will continue to spend $10 billion a month in Iraq when Iraq is sitting on a surplus of nearly $80 billion, that’s not change; that’s more of the same.

The choice in this election is clear. These times require more than a good soldier; they require a wise leader, a leader who can deliver change—the change everybody knows we need. [my emphasis]
This section expanded more on the national-security theme:

As we gather here tonight, our country is less secure and more isolated than at any time in recent history. The Bush-McCain foreign policy has dug us into a very deep hole with very few friends to help us climb out. For the last seven years, this administration has failed to face the biggest forces shaping this century: the emergence of Russia, China and India as great powers; the spread of lethal weapons; the shortage of secure supplies of energy, food and water; the challenge of climate change; and the resurgence of fundamentalism in Afghanistan and Pakistan, the real central front against terrorism.

In recent days, we’ve once again seen the consequences of this neglect with Russia’s challenge to the free and democratic country of Georgia. Barack Obama and I will end this neglect. We will hold Russia accountable for its actions, and we’ll help the people of Georgia rebuild.

I’ve been on the ground in Georgia, Iraq, Pakistan and Afghanistan, and I can tell you in no uncertain terms: this Administration’s policy has been an abject failure. America cannot afford four more years of this.

Now, despite being complicit in this catastrophic foreign policy, John McCain says Barack Obama isn’t ready to protect our national security. Now, let me ask you: whose judgment should we trust? Should we trust John McCain’s judgment when he said only three years ago, “Afghanistan—we don’t read about it anymore because it’s succeeded”? Or should we trust Barack Obama, who more than a year ago called for sending two additional combat brigades to Afghanistan?

The fact is, al-Qaida and the Taliban—the people who actually attacked us on 9/11—have regrouped in those mountains between Afghanistan and Pakistan and are plotting new attacks. And the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff echoed Barack’s call for more troops.

John McCain was wrong. Barack Obama was right. [my emphasis]
I have big, big reservations about the Obama-Biden policy on escalating in Afghanistan. But for the election, it's the policy the Democrats are stuck with.

And Biden bloodied the bullies' noses tonight.

Still, the campaign needs to hit McCain in ways that not only tie him to Bush and his disastrous policies. But they also need to do it in a way to address more personal and "character" issues. McCain is old and clearly confused on some important things. He's impulsive and hot-headed. Combine that with his eagerness to go to war and it's genuinely scary. He's also so wealthy he's rolling in his wife's money no matter in which of their many houses they happen to be at a given moment.

And those ugly personal characteristics are visible in his policies. He wants to keep the Iraq War going for 100 years or longer. He wants to play chicken with Russia in the Caucuses over countries most Americans would have some trouble naming, much less spelling, when we have vitually no viable military options there. He wants to flush the nuclear anti-proliferation efforts with Russia. And he wants to go war with Iraq. But that together with his impulsiveness, his bad temper, and his stereotypical old-man nostalgia for war and the symbols of military glory and it's a really, really bad picture.

The wealthy old grouch wants to phase out Social Security! He's worse than out of touch. He's perfectly willing to toss the country he professes to love so profoundly right back into the 1920s, when being old meant for all but the very wealthy meant being poor, dependent and sick.

The Democrats need to make those points. And they need to keep the focus they had tonight on the Iraq War.

Texts of Thursday night's speeches are available at the Convention website.

Tags: , , , ,

Monday, August 25, 2008

Biden, Obama and foreign policy

I'm happy with Biden as Obama's Vice Presidential candidate. There's no question in my mind that they will make a much better administration than John McCain and Joe Lieberman (or whoever he picks for VP). But since a McCain administration is all-but-certain to be worse in that regard than Dick Cheney and George Bush, that doesn't necessarily say that much.

Getting the US out of the Iraq War is the most pressing foreign policy issue right now. And Obama is on the right track in demanding a fixed timetable for combat troop withdrawals. The number of mercenaries, military advisers ("trainers") and Embassy protection forces also needs to be minimized. But he's on the right track. If he gets that withdrawal underway immediately, he will open up additional possibilities for a more realistic, pragmatic foreign policy.

Obama's proposal to escalate US troops presence in Afghanistan is a prescription for expanding disaster there. But since both he and McCain are talking about some kind of escalation there, it's unlikely to be a decisive issue in the campaign. The Iraq War is.

Joe Biden's foreign policy positions aren't entirely a smooth fit for Obama's. On Afghanistan, they seem to match up. But on Iraq, it's going to be interesting to see how they handle Biden's long-standing proposal for what amounts to partitioning Iraq into three entities: Arab Shi'a, Arab Sunni and Kurdistan. Biden recognizes that the US needs to get out of there. And a rapid withdrawal of US troops will probably make the partition plan a dead letter. But if they were to incorporate that as part of the withdrawal plan, it would likely make the withdrawal much more difficult and greatly increase the already-large risk of a wider regional war.

On Iran, McCain and Lieberman want to start a new war. Or it's probably more accurate to say they want to consolidate it into a wider war reaching from Iraq's border with Syria to Afghanistan's border with Pakistan, and maybe even into Pakistan. Biden has actually been more restrained in his rhetoric about war with Iran than Obama. Biden's position is a very welcome addition to the Democratic ticket on that issue.

It seems that both Obama and Biden have been cautious on the Georgia-Russia war, limiting themselves to reaffirming the official US position that Georgia should be incorporated into NATO . Whereas McCain and his chief foreign policy adviser, Georgia lobbyist Randy Scheunemann, have gone considerably beyond the official position and reacted to the Georgia-Russia conflict in hot-headed fashion. McCain's conduct as a candidate, including his frequent contacts with the reckless Georgian President who initiated the conflict, seem to indicate that McCain thinks it's the Republican Party that runs US foreign policy, not the US Government. Obama and Biden are both enough in touch with reality to know that NATO cannot as a practical matter incorporate Georgian into a mutual defense treaty with the country having settled borders that can be defined precisely. McCain seems to be living in a militarist/neocon fantasy world where that's not a problem.

A couple of recent article illustrate some of the problems that Biden's foreign policy perspective may bring: Laura Rozen, Biden's Worldview: An Interview with a Former Biden Foreign Policy Staffer Mother Jones Online 08/25/08
http://www.motherjones.com/mojoblog/archives/2008/08/9370_bidens_worldvie.html; and by Bob Dreyfuss, On Iraq, Biden Is Worse than McCain The Nation Online 08/23/08.

Dreyfuss is more alarmed than I am at the possible influence of Biden's partition plan for Iraq. And his criticism is overstated. But Dreyfuss' concerns about the partition plan are well-founded.

Rozen interviews a former Biden staffer who, for some reason, she agreed to quote anonymously, though it's not at all clear to me why such an interview needed to be anonymous. But Anonymous Former Staffer does offer a framework that Biden and Obama can use to unite on a withdrawal plan without partition, though neither of them is likely to word it this way:

The Iraq partition idea fell by the wayside over a year ago as events on the ground in Iraq overtook it. Biden deserves praise for introducing a fresh idea into the Iraq debate, one that went beyond “stay the course” vs. “withdraw the troops.” And, to be fair, it was never about partition. Biden took his experience from the Balkans conflict in the 1990’s, where an imperfect compromise was hammered out to create two semi-autonomous regions inside Bosnia Herzegovina, one for the Muslims and one for the Serbs, yet maintaining Bosnia as a single state. So Biden wanted to do the same in Iraq, where you would have a central government in Baghdad responsible for the national army and foreign policy, but almost all other powers devolved to three autonomous regions in Iraq. There was much to criticize in the plan, most notably the fact that Iraqis wanted nothing of it, but the Biden plan has been incorrectly characterized as advocating the split of Iraq into three separate states – that was not what Biden was calling for. [my emphasis]
Actually, the Kurdish parties are sympathetic to the notion and may yet go to all-out civil war for Kurdish independence. But that's a reasonably dignified explanation for ditching a bad idea.

This comment from Anonymous Former Staffer doesn't surprise me. But it doesn't send a thrill running up my leg, either:

As [a "liberal interventionist"], in an Obama Administration, Biden – and the legion of current and former foreign policy staffers he will bring into the Administration – will provide a healthy counterpoint to those advisors closest to Obama. A number of Democrats are concerned by the fact that his two leading senior foreign policy advisors are Tony Lake and Susan Rice. Lake was a disaster as NSC Advisor and Rice had mixed reviews as the leading Africa policy maker in the Clinton Administration, especially in her role leading the U.S. response to Rwanda. Both individuals don’t seem as comfortable with the use of military force as people in the Biden orbit, which include Richard Holbrooke, Jamie Rubin, and Tony Blinken. ...

Biden unequivocally believes America is a force for good in the world. In this respect, his view dovetails with those liberal interventionists like Paul Berman and George Packer. He carries this belief to the core of his heart. I think Obama also shares this view, but it is less derived from passion and gut and more of an intellectual belief. Obama brings a uniquely multi-cultural perspective, and he has lived in places where America is not seen as the good guys. We’ll see how this plays out in an Obama Administration.
Clinton-style liberal interventionism certainly wasn't as destructive as the Bush Doctrine of preventive war. But the Iraq War showed that the "liberal interventionist" framework can be dangerous and destructive as well. Biden, Paul Berman and George Packer all talked themselves into supporting the Iraq War initially.

Speaking of which, to conclude, I still hope will decide to use the explanation for his October 2002 vote for the war resolution that he and others should have been using all along: that Cheney and Bush violated that resolution when they went to war in March, 2003 in the way that they did. It was still bad judgment to vote for the 2002 resolution. But it's still important to recognize that this administration violated it.

Tags: , , , ,

Sunday, May 18, 2008

Maverick Iraq War policy

Sen. Joe Biden points out that the bold Maverick McCain's talk about winning in Iraq by 2013 is empty talk (McCain Has Zero Plan to Get Us Out of Mess President Bush Has Created Huffington Post 05/15/08):

John McCain revealed today that he has no plan - none - to get us out of the mess the president has created. Senator McCain said that it is important for presidential candidates to "define their objectives and what they plan to achieve not with vague language but with clarity." But especially when it comes to Iraq and Afghanistan, the picture he painted today of where he hopes to be by 2013 is totally divorced from reality and there is zero clarity about how he would get there. It's beyond being vague: John McCain is totally silent about how he would realize his rosy vision for 2013. ...

Exactly how will we have any chance of winning in Afghanistan and defeating al Qaeda if we keep 140,000 troops in Iraq for another three or four years? Senator McCain doesn't say because he can't. ...

Today's speech is further proof that when it comes to Iraq, there is no daylight between John McCain and George W. Bush. They are joined at the hip. When it comes to Iraq, there will be no change with a McCain administration and so there is a real and profound choice for Americans in November. (my emphasis)
That's our Maverick!

Tags: , ,

Monday, April 30, 2007

Joe Biden

We had commute hell in the San Francisco Bay Area this morning, because a freeway melted after a truck full of gasoline crashed and burned on what's called the MacArthur Maze in Oakland. I didn't know it was called that until it collapsed, but what the heck. See The maze meldown: Eyewitness sees driver emerge from inferno by Patrick Hoge, Demian Bulwa, Peter Fimrite San Francisco Chronicle Online 04/30/07; Maze detours make for brave new commute by George Kelly and Malaika Fraley Oakland Tribune Online 04/30/2007. The Chronicle's dramatic photo of the blaze is here. Although a lot of people seem to have adapted by adjusting their schedules, working from home for the days, and so forth, so the actual morning commute wasn't as nightmarish everywhere as it could have been. The return commute in the evening is sure to be more problematic, because its the lanes leading east out of San Francisco that are blocked, not the other way around.

What does all this have to do with Joe Biden? Nothing directly. But remember the terrorists who actually try to attack American targets? They read the news, too: Accident sparks worries about copycat attacks by Ian Hoffman Oakland Tribune 04/30/2007. Now, state officials will try to connect nearly anything to terrorism if there might be extra federal funds attached. But still, instead of spending $100 billion a year on (Biden's number on Sunday) on the Iraq War, I would feel a lot safer if we had been reinforcing obvious vulnerabilities like airplane cargo compartments, port security and freeways that melt. And in many cases, the kind of improvements that would boost security in case of attack would also be good for public safely in non-terrorist accidents like this one. Fortunately, this one took place in the dead of night. If it had happened during rush hour, it's inconceivable that no deaths would have resulted.

Biden was on Meet the Press Sunday for an hour with Tim Russert. (The transcript doesn't seem to be available yet as of this writing.) He mentioned the need for better domestic precautions against terrorist attacks, which has been a standard Democratic talking point for years. But this disaster reminds me that it's a valid priority, even allowing for the inevitable hype and scamming around the still-hot topic of terrorism. This road collapse is likely to mess up the commute in a seriously bad way for months. All large cities and all states need to have workable plans in place that can be implemented quickly for dealing with these kinds of emergencies.

And if those preparations wind up being used for accidents and natural disasters more than for responses to terrorism, so what? The OxyContin crowd won't like it. But bitching and moaning and slinging sleaze at the Democrats about everything is just what they do all the time anyway.

I was also thinking as I dragged myself out of bed 45 minutes early and rushed to leave for work an hour and 15 minutes early, that around here a disaster like this makes for a really aggravating commute. If we lived in Baghdad, this kind of accident that would mean new traffic jams would be life-threatening to commuters. Because it would mean more time in traffic jams, and therefore more chances for snipers, car bombers and kidnappers to strike people stuck in traffic. Maybe that sounds like a case of trying to find somebody that's worse off than you, and maybe it is. That's generally pretty easy to do. Unless you live in Baghdad or Anbar province or Darfur.

Biden talked a lot about the Iraq War and foreign policy issues. He had a couple of good things to say. But it was disappointing, on the whole. The best thing he said was a point I've been saying for a while that the Democrats should be making: that the October 2002 war resolution did not authorize the invasion of Iraq that Cheney and Bush launched in March of 2003. Chuck Hagel, the rightwing Nebraska Senator who passes for a "moderate" in today's authoritarian Republican Party, also makes the same point in an interview with Salon ("We cannot stay as an occupying force in the Middle East" 04/30/07):

I wasn't convinced [of WMD] or in any way connected Saddam Hussein with 9/11. Before we even had the vote I said that. Some get the resolution wrong. It wasn't a resolution to go to war ... Ultimately it was giving the president authority to use force if all the diplomatic efforts fail. If there was no other recourse it would allow the president to use force. I believed the president and others who said they would exhaust all diplomatic efforts. Which they did not. They told us they would and they did not. (my emphasis)
Neither Biden nor Hagel mentioned the other official goal of the war specified in that resolution besides dealing with the nonexistent WMDs, which was to deal with the nonexistent operational links between Saddam's regime and Al Qaida and as part of that to specifically to retaliate for Saddam's nonexistent role in the 9/11 attacks.

Biden did okay in terms of style responding to Russert's trademark gotcha questions asking about things he had said before that sound different than what he's saying now. But in terms of substance, Biden is still caught up in the fact that he foolishly took a hawkish position on the war up until last year, so he winds up dissembling to justify a dovish-sounding position now.

When I saw Tom Hayden speak in San Francisco last November, he stressed that politicians are especially good at double-talk, so the antiwar movement will have to keep the pressure on all of them to continue to pull the troops out. That is, once we start pulling troops out rather than sending more in. Biden's MTP interview Sunday reminded me of that.

I've written here before about how I'm concerned by the current Congressional pullout plan because it leaves a wide-open loophole to have troops to keep fighting "Al Qaida" in Iraq, which already seems to be leading the war fans to make Al Qaida sound like it has a huge role in the guerrilla war there. But during the current veto fight over the war, I'm content that the message most voters and people in other countries will get will be, "Bush is in favor of continuing the war, the Democrats want to end it."

But Biden on Sunday used the various qualifications in the Congressional plan to step on the general Democratic antiwar message. None of his comments on the Iraq War were particularly encouraging for war critics; he even managed to smother his observation that Bush's invasion in 2003 violated the Congressional war resolution with confusing talk about how it authorized Bush to go to war but not really stressing the conditional nature of that authorization.

He emphasized that the current Democratic position is not a deadline date for US withdrawal from Iraq, but a target that is "flexible". He is still justifying his vote for the war resolution in 2002. He's claiming that he was voting to give the President authority for war under certain conditions in order to avoid war. That is a disingenious argument. While I've said that it's important to recognize how Bush violated the war resolution, there was also no doubt at the time that the practical effect of passing that resolution was to give Bush effective permission to launch an invasion on his own say-so.

Biden also said that when the UN inspectors left in 1998, they were still saying Iraq had large quantities of material that could be weaponized as WMDs. Now, my entire staff of fact-checkers are still caught in the commute. But I'm pretty sure what they said was that there were certain amounts of materials not accounted for.

On a related whopper, I don't need the fact checkers to know he was repeating a falsehood when he said that Saddam kicked out the inspectors in 1998. The facts are worth remembering since this was one of several lies used to justify going to war and killing and wounding a lot of people including American soldiers for no good reason. Iraq blocked inspectors from their work in 1998 because they discovered that the UN team included members that were passing information to the CIA. The US government later admitted this was the case. Then Scott Ritter who was heading the inspection team at the time decided on his own to remove the inspectors. Yet here's Joe Biden the famous "realist" still repeating this false war-propaganda point.

The rest of Biden's interview also wasn't that encouraging. He sneered at "the French" for criticizing the effects of the economic sanctions on Iraq during the 1990s; in reality, a realistic look at those sanctions should be one of the most important "lessons of Iraq" to examine. He wants to send more American troops to Afghanistan and also to Darfur. I can't say I'm thrilled about either prospect - even if we could pretend that this current administration had the ability to manage either situation competently, which they certainly do not.

He said correctly that Medicare is more of a financial problem than Social Security. But he said more than once, clearly including Social Security, that he wants to "put it all on the table" in looking at solutions. "You have to," he said. No, we don't have to put Social Security "on the table". And the Republicans' phase-out schemes ("privitization") should be permanently off that famous metaphorical table.

Biden also supported the so-called "partial-birth abortion" ban. He said he was alarmed by the Supreme Court's apparent positioning in a case unsuccessfully challenging that law seems to be setting the stage to overturn Roe v. Wade. But defending the right to choose on abortions clearly does not seem to be the higest priority for Biden.

After Biden's gab-fest with Russert, I watched Chris Matthews' 30-minute Sunday show, where Matthews and various pundits kicked around fogettable comments about the Presidential candidates. Clarence Paige, generally one of the more sensible among the Big Pundits, made the remarkable observation that the 2008 election will be the "first big election since 9/11".

Say what? Let's see, there was the 2002 election that handed the Senate back to Republican control, insuring that virtually no Congressional oversight of the Executive Branch would occur during the next four years. There was that little Presidential election in 2004 that retained Dear Leader Bush as President. Last year the Congressional elections turned both Houses of Congress back to the Democrats in a striking protest against the disaster known as the Iraq War.

I can only wonder what counts as a "big election" in the world of our Wise Pundits.

Tags: ,

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

Why Democratic officials need Democrats

The Democratic Party's current position requires the Democrats in the Senate and House to fight for the restoration of Constitutional government to maximize their own partisan itnerests as well as the people's interests.

Whether they will do so will be largely a function of what kind of signals they get from the Demcratic base. Because some of the ideas and practices that have caused the Dems to stagnate in many ways over the years are still on auto-pilot.

For instance, we had Presidential contender Joe Biden trapsing down to South Carolina to try to impress a bunch of Republican white guys by criticizing his own party and also by assuring them he appreciates the traditional values of the Old Confederacy. He later backed off from those comments.

Yes, I'm sad to say that's the Joe Biden who is now the incoming chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. The one we realy on to be conducting extensive hearings and asking tough questions and seriously demanding the White House honor subpeonas and so forth.

Instead, he goes down to South Carolina to tell a bunch of Republicans who won't vote for a Democratic Presidential candidate in a thousand years and tells them, "America needs, and I need, for the Republican Party to get back up. There’s not a single problem out there that cannot be solved without a bipartisan coalition.”

He needs the Republican Party to "get back up"? Since now they only control the Executive Branch, which claims its not obliged to follow the law or the Constitution, and also the federal judiciary? No, what we really need is for Democratic leaders to just shut up with stuff like this and concentrate on their Congressional oversight jobs.

These two articles from the San Francisco Chronicle 12/04/06, Diplomacy seen as essential, but difficult by Matthew Stannard and Bush digs in at pivotal point in Iraq war by Carolyn Lochhead, give a good look of three of the Democratic Party's problems in dealing with the Iraq War over the next two years: political inertia, the authoritarian Republican Party's commitment to the war and a dysfunctional American press corps.

Political inertia

Lochhead quotes Charles Kupchan from the Clinton administration's National Security Council staff, offering a pre-emptive excuse for the Democrats to duck confronting the Iraq War issue:

The bottom line is that the president still holds the cards. Even though the Democrats won the midterms, they're not yet in control of Congress, they're not yet in control of the committees, and even though I expect the discussion next week to be very testy, Democrats can do little more than scream and shout and jump up and down.
This has become much too typical of a lazy Democratic attitude that still has far too much influence. The Dems are taking control of both Houses of Congress after an election in which they Iraq War was the single most important issue. A large majority of the public wants an early exit from Iraq. The Cheney-Bush administration is vulnerable to the revelations from Congressional investigations on so many fronts it's hard to count them.

And it's Bush that "holds the cards"? Say what?

I have a little more sympathy with serving elected officials, whose normal tendency is to step carefully around issues as controversial and volatile as the Iraq War. There's a terrible tendency to try to kick the can down the road in hopes that you can win points from one side while minimizing controversy from the other. For instance, California's staunchly Democratic Congressman George Miller spelled out the cautious, kick-the-can approach for Lochhead:

"I think we have an obligation to have the hearings so we can ask the questions the Republicans refused to ask, the hearings they wouldn't have, and I think we can do it in a very expeditious fashion," Miller said. "Then we'll have to come to a conclusion, given the evidence that's been presented to date."

Miller said he wants a U.S. troop withdrawal to start in six months.

"Clearly there are people in our caucus who would be shorter or longer," he said. "But hopefully the hearings and the actions in both the House and the Senate will be helpful."

Miller ruled out cutting off funding for the war.

"I don't think you're at that point yet," he said. "I certainly don't think you're at that point before you have an opportunity for the Democrats who are most deeply involved in terms of their committee jurisdiction having a chance to take a look at it under their stewardship."
Not necessarily a bad position the month prior to taking over the Congressional leadership. But after the Democratic-led Congressional Committees have had their "chance to take a look at it under their stewardship", how hard they press for answers and results will depend to a very large degree on pressure from the base.

Because even though I'm willing to give George Miller the benefit of the doubt here in December based on his solid previous record, I really don't see why the Democrats need to tiptoe around the issue of de-funding the war. What, are they afraid the Republicans might now criticize them if they suggest imposing deadlines? The Republican campaign this year was already calling them defeatists, "Defeatocrats" and allies of The Terrorists. Is he worried the Reps might really insult them now?

And this "begin withdrawal in six, four, twelve months" business is nonsense. The Iraq War has long since been doing the United States more harm than good. And the amount of control that the US can exercise of the outcome may not be negligible. But it's not that great either. If anything, the US would have more influence on Iraqi developments after withdrawing than with 140,000+ American troops on the ground there.

We need to start withdrawing now and plan to get all the combat troops preferably within six months. We also need to be aware that the situation is deteriorating so fast that we may not have the option to select the time length of the US withdrawal.

Republican support for Bush's War and the dysfunctional press corps

These are separate but closely related phenemena. The partisan Republican outlets - OxyContin radio, FOX News, the many Republican advocacy groups - spew out new defenses for the war and attacks on war critics nonstop. The Establishment press not only picks up on many of those. They also are operating on so many war-friendly and Republican-friendly scripts that they reinforce the Republican spin on events even without copying the partisan press.

Lochhead gives the Republican-friendly (and lazy-Democratic-friendly) view about the nomination of Robert Gates for Secreatary of Defence:

This week, they'll grill Gates on his plans, hopeful that unlike Rumsfeld, he is not wedded to past mistakes. A CIA director under former President George H.W. Bush, Gates is viewed as a member of the realist Republican school rather than the neoconservatives who backed the invasion of Iraq. He has called for engagement with Syria and Iran, an approach the Iraq Study Group is also expected to recommend even though the Bush administration long has spurned those nations.

Democrats hope Gates will tip the White House balance of power, allying with Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice against Vice President Dick Cheney, who was allied with Rumsfeld.
The guy was also known as someone who is willing to bend intelligence findings for pure propaganda purposes and engaged in at best questionable conduct in the Iran-Contra affair in the 1980s. Democrats, in this spin, are supposed to assume the compliant role of asking a few questions, approving Gates and then putting confidence in the new Republican DefSec as a political and policy ally within the administration.

Meanwhile, who is going to confront the problems of the Iraq War? Why, those responsible moderate Republicans, of course! Lochhead writes:

Ironically, the greatest pressure is expected from Republicans, who just lost control of the House and Senate and, unlike Bush, face another election in 2008.

Republicans have begun cutting their ties to Bush. Nebraska Republican Sen. Chuck Hagel warned the president last week to seize the opportunity offered by the Iraq Study Group, led by Republican former Secretary of State James Baker and Democratic former Rep. Lee Hamilton.

Hagel wrote the war is "not an American divine mission," and called any refusal by Bush to use the Baker commission to build a bipartisan exit strategy a blunder.
Hagel voted for the Cheney-Bush torture policy. That's about all you need to know about his willingness to challenge the administration on issues related to the "global war on terror" (GWOT). Wow, Hagel suggests that Bush seize the opportunity to come with some kind of vague bipartisan exit strategy under which maybe someday probably most of the combat troops would still be there. And, golly, he said the Iraq War is "not an American divine mission"! What a bold statement of independence and courage! Where would we be without those "moderate" Republicans?

This is not to pick on Carolyn Lochhead's reporting in particular. These brain-dead scripts in which the "moderate" Republicans bravely do something bold and responsible about the Iraq War are part of the script on which our dysfunctional press corps operates. But, still, the Republicans in Congress have hardly been showing bold leadership on the Iraq War in the weeks since she wrote that.

Lochhead's version of Democratic timidity is slightly more reality-based, i.e., not complete fantasy, for the reasons I mentioned above. But her report ignores not only the Democrats' political mandate to challenge the administration's Iraq War failures. It also doesn't look at the political dynamics of the situation where all but the most hopeless Democrats (like Joe Lieberman, and I'm really beginning to wonder about Biden) are likely to feel a lot of pressure to aggressively challenge a continuing war in Iraq.

The Stannard article assesses US diplomatic options by quoting five experts: James Dobbins of the conservative-leaning Rand Institute; Charles Hill of the conservative Hoover Institution and "diplomat in residence" (?) at Yale; Abbas Milani, a Stanford professor and co-director of the Iran Democracy Project at the Hoover Institution; Marina Ottaway of the nonpartisan Carnegie Institute for International Peace; and, tenacious war supporter Anthony Cordesman of the conservative-leaning Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) in Washington.

The last two are good authorities on the Iraq War. I quote Anthony Cordesman normally once per week or so. He's one of the few war supporters I could name who didn't get carried away by fantasies of a short easy war and the magical flourishing of democracy in Iraq. He's managed to keep his reputation for integrity intact, which is more than one can say for the neocons who were so in favor of this war.

But Stannard doesn't get around to quoting Cordesman until the very end. The first authority he quotes is Dobbins from a Foreign Affairs article:

"The United States did not invade Afghanistan in order to remake that country as a model for Central Asia, nor did Washington announce an intention to subsequently promote the democratization of all of the states neighboring Afghanistan. Had the United States committed itself to such a program, it would never have secured the support of Iran, Pakistan, Russia, Tajikistan or Uzbekistan for the war," Dobbins wrote. "The United States, however, did invade Iraq with the intention of making that state a model for the Middle East, promising that success in Iraq would be followed by efforts to transform the political systems of Iraq's neighbors. This was not a vision any of those regimes was likely to embrace. Nor have they."
While it's true that some of the neocon true believers expected this democracy effect and the idea played an important role in the administration's push for war, Stannard might have informed his readers that there were two war goals approved by Congress in October 2002: dealing with the Saddam regime's (nonexistent) weapons of mass destruction and ending the regime's (nonexistent) operational ties to Al Qaida. What Dobbins says about this aspect of the Cheney-Bush policy affecting the perceptions of surrounding countries is probably correct. But presented without the proper context it is misleading.

Next cited is the Hoover Institution's Charles Hill peddling straight Republican partisan propaganda:

"Until about a year ago, there were really very important achievements, although in some cases minor first steps, such as actually getting an election ... in Saudi Arabia, or getting Egypt to talk about things that would be more open and democratic that they hadn't talked about before. Getting (Libyan leader Moammar) Khadafy to give up his weapons of mass destruction is one of those." ...

"The most signal achievement was (U.N. Security Council) Resolution 1559, on Lebanon, which said the Syrian army had to get out of Lebanon," he said. "That opened the way for beginning to get Lebanon on the road to regaining its legitimacy internationally."
The timid democratic openings in Saudi Arabia and Egypt were largely cosmetic and mainly showed the popularity of Islamist candidates. The Libyan agreement over their WMD program was negotiated before the Iraq invasion, though the administration didn't formally conclude it until later exactly so they could make such a claim.

I'm actually very hopeful about the next two years. But the Democrats definitely face some problems, especially in challenging Bush war policies. Political inertia. Republican support for the war. Dysfunctional reporting.

Then there's Joe Biden pandering to white Republican Southerners who have fond memories of the Confederacy, Good Lord!

It's like Rummy said about the Army. You fight for the Constitution with the Democratic Party you have, not with the Democratic Party you want or that you might like to have.

It does make me a bit jealous of multi-party parliamentary democracies, though.